Inhibition of an allospecific T cell hybridoma by soluble class I proteins and peptides: estimation of the affinity of a T cell receptor for MHC

To investigate the molecular basis of the interaction between the T cell receptor and the MHC class I antigen in an allogeneic response, a soluble counterpart of the murine class I molecule, H-2Kb, was genetically engineered. Cells secreting this soluble molecule, H-2Kb/Q10b, inhibited stimulation of an H-2Kb-reactive T cell hybridoma by cells transfected with H-2Kbm10, a weak stimulus, but not by H-2Kb- or H-2Kbm6-transfected cells. Soluble purified H-2Kb/Q10b protein also blocked T cell stimulation. In addition, a peptide from the wild-type H-2Kb molecule spanning the region of the bm10 mutation specifically inhibited activation of the T cell hybridoma by H-2Kbm10 cells, thus suggesting that amino acid residues 163-174 of H-2Kb define a region important for T cell receptor binding. An estimate for the Kd of the T cell receptor for soluble H-2Kb/Q10b was 10(-7) M, while the Kd for soluble peptide 163-174 was 10(-4) M.     

Cytotoxic T lymphocyte response to minor H-43a alloantigen in H-43b mice. Privileged H-2Kb restriction to the response is not due to immunodominance or epistatic effect but due to Ir gene function of H-2Kb itself

Previous study demonstrated that anti-H-43a cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) response of H-43b CWB (H-2b) stain carrying non-major histocompatability complex (MHC) genes of C3H and F1 strains raised by crossing CWB with various H-43b strains was restricted exclusively by self H-2Kb (Kb). In the present study, newly produced C3W strain (H-2k, H-43b), which is H-43-congenic to C3H/HeN (H-2k, H-43a), was used as H-43b mice, and possibility of immunodominance of Kb was examined. No anti-H-43a CTL response could be induced in C3W strain and F1 strains raised by crossing C3W with other H-43b strains not carrying Kb. Thus, the possibility of immunodominance of Kb over the other MHC class I alleles could not be supported. We also examined possibility of epistatic effect of I region genes and non-MHC genes on the Kb restriction. (C3W x C57BL/6)F1(I-Ak/b) and (C3W x B6.CH-2bm12)F1(I-Ak/bm12)mice showed equally anti-H-43a CTL response restricted exclusively by self Kb, and (C3W x B10.MBR)F1(Ik/k) mice also showed anti-H-43a CTL response restricted solely by self Kb. Cold target competition experiments demonstrated that H-43b C57BL/10 or A.BY mice, which do not have non-MHC genes of C3H mounted anti-H-43a CTL response restricted solely by self Kb. Thus, no relation of I region genes or non-MHC genes to the Kb restriction was shown. All the results indicate that H-43b mouse strains, including F1, can not achieve anti-H-43a CTL response unless they carry Kb allele. Notably, (C3W x C57BL/6)F1 mice mounted self Kb-restricted anti-H-43a CTL response, whereas (C3W x B6.CH-2bm1)F1 mice carrying mutated Kb could not mount anti-H-43a CTL response at all. These findings indicate strongly that Kb itself is classical Ir gene of anti-H-43a CTL response and directs self Kb restriction of the response.     

The DNA sequence of the H-2kb gene: evidence for gene conversion as a mechanism for the generation of polymorphism in histocompatibilty antigens

We have determined the DNA sequence of the H-2Kb gene of the C57B1/10 mouse. Comparison of this sequence with that of the allelic H-2Kd shows surprisingly that the exons have accumulated more mutations than their introns. Moreover, many of these changes in the exons are clustered in short regions or hot spots. Additional comparison of these sequences with the H-2Ld and H-2Db sequences shows that, in several cases, the altered sequence generated at the hot spot is identical to the corresponding region of a non-allelic H-2 gene. The clustered changes are responsible for 60% of the amino acid differences between the H-2Kb and H-2Kd genes and suggest that micro-gene conversion events occurring within the exons and involving only tens of nucleotides are an important mechanism for the generation of polymorphic differences between natural H-2 alleles.     

Tumor rejection mediated by transfection with allogeneic class I histocompatibility gene

Non-self class I histocompatibility Ag can act as strong alloantigens and be recognized as distinct targets by CTL. To study the possibility of using allograft rejection to generate tumor-specific immunity, we have introduced an allogeneic class I histocompatibility gene, the H-2Kb gene, into a k haplotype tumor, K36.16, by DNA-mediated gene transfer. The K36.16 tumor grows readily and does not confer protective immunity in AKR mice. A total of 37 H-2Kb-transfected K36.16 clones (Kb/K36.16) was isolated and studied individually. The Kb/K36.16 clones were found to differ significantly in the amount of the exogenous H-2Kb antigens expressed on their cell surface. Moreover, as a result of the transfection, the level of expression of the endogenous H-2Dk Ag was also altered when compared to that of the parental K36.16 tumor cells. All the Kb/K36.16 clones that were positive for the H-2Kb Ag were rejected by the semisyngeneic AKR mice. Moreover, some of these Kb/K36.16 clones were also rejected by syngeneic (AKR x C57BL/10)F1 mice. In consequence of immunization with the Kb/K36.16 clones, the AKR and F1 mice were able to survive a subsequent challenge of the wild-type, unmodified, parental K36.16 tumor cells. More importantly, some of these Kb/K36.16 clones demonstrated an active and specific immunotherapeutic effect, and they were able to eradicate the growth of the parental K36.16 tumor cells in AKR mice. This observation therefore reinforces the feasibility of using DNA-mediated gene transfer as a molecular approach to abrogate tumor growth.     

Analysis of somatic cell H-2 variants to define the structural requirements for class I antigen expression

We have taken the approach of producing somatic cell variants with altered H-2 products to study the structural requirements for cell surface expression of class I histocompatibility molecules. H-2 antigen variants generated by chemical mutagenesis of a cell line expressing the H-2b haplotype were first selected with alloantisera for their loss of H-2Kb expression, and then were analyzed by radioimmunoassay for the appearance of intracellular Kb antigen. For one such variant (69.9.15), whereas the H-2Kb antigen was absent from the cell surface as assayed by antibody-mediated complement-dependent cytotoxicity, an H-2Kb molecule was detected within the cell lysate as confirmed by direct immune precipitation with Kb-specific monoclonal antibodies. The product had an altered antigenic phenotype, since it reacted with only two anti-Kb monoclonal antibodies (Y-3 and EH-144) and not with a third (5F1.2). Analysis by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis identified the beta 2 microglobulin-associated, intracellular H-2Kb heavy chain to be slightly smaller in Mr than the H-2Kb of the parental cell line. Hybridization analysis revealed the Kb gene from the variant to be without gross alterations, and furthermore, identified a Kb mRNA species that was identical in size to wild-type Kb mRNA. Because complementation was not observed after somatic cell fusion of variant cells with BALB/c splenocytes, it appeared that the alteration in Kb expression was due to a cis-acting defect. In addition, DNA-mediated gene transfer of the wild-type Kb gene into the variant cell line resulted in expression of the Kb antigen on the cell surface, thus confirming that the defect in expression of the mutant Kb product was not due to other factors in the 69.9.15 cell line. Such findings are consistent with the conclusion that stable H-2Kb surface-negative somatic variants can arise due to limited alterations in the Kb gene, resulting in the synthesis of a class I molecule that is expressed only as an intracellular product.     

A nonpolymorphic class I gene in the murine major histocompatibility complex

DNA sequence analysis of a class I gene (Q10), which maps to the Qa2,3 locus in the C57BL/10 (H-2b haplotype) mouse, reveals that it is almost identical to a cDNA clone (pH16) isolated from a SWR/J (H-2q haplotype) mouse liver cDNA library. Exon 5, in particular, has an unusual structure such that a polypeptide product is unlikely to be anchored in the cell membrane. Our findings suggest that the two sequences are derived from allelic class I genes, which are nonpolymorphic, in contrast to H-2K allelic sequences from the same mice, and they may encode liver-specific polypeptides of unknown function. Our previous studies indicate that the Q10 gene is a potential donor gene for the generation of mutations at the H-2K locus by inter-gene transfer of genetic information. Thus the lack of polymorphism in class I genes at the Q10 locus implies either that they are not recipients for such exchanges or that selective pressure prevents the accumulation of mutations in genes at this locus.     

Increased sensitivity to MHC-nonrestricted lysis of BL6 melanoma cells by transfection with class I H-2Kb gene

An H-2Kb- negative clone of BL6 melanoma (BL6-8) was transfected with neor, H-2Kb, or H-2IAk genes. In an 18-h cytotoxicity assay clones with high levels of H-2Kb Ag expression were found more sensitive to lysis by spleen cells of syngenic and allogeneic mice than H-2Kb low clones. NK cells were involved in the lysis of H-2Kb+ BL6 melanoma clones, with spleen cell cytotoxicity of mice increased after poly I:C stimulation or decreased after pretreatment with anti-asialo GM1 serum or NK1.1 mAb. Anti-TNF Ab were also able to reduce the cytotoxicity of normal spleen cells and completely abolished the cytotoxicity of the NK-depleted spleen cells suggesting involvement of NC cells in lysis of H-2Kb+ BL6 melanoma clones. Increase in sensitivity of H-2Kb+ BL6 cells to natural cell-mediated cytotoxicity was associated with the appearance of NK recognizable determinants as assessed by the cold target inhibition assay. All BL6 clones, irrespective of sensitivity to natural cell-mediated cytotoxicity, showed high sensitivity to lysis by LGL-derived granules. In contrast, all H-2Kb low BL6 clones were resistant and all H-2Kb highly positive clones were sensitive to lysis by TNF-alpha. When an H-2Kb highly positive clone was selected in vitro for resistance to TNF, it concomitantly showed increased resistance to cytotoxicity by spleen cells, confirming the importance of TNF in spleen cell cytotoxicity against H-2Kb+ melanoma cells. Taken together, the data indicate that class I H-2Kb but not class II H-2IAk gene product could increase the sensitivity of BL6 cells to lysis by NK and natural cytotoxic cells as well as TNF. We hypothesize that these effects could be due to pleiotropic effects of H-2Kb gene products on various biologic properties of BL6 melanoma cells some of which may be more directly involved in regulation of tumor cell sensitivity to lysis by NK and/or natural cytotoxic cells.     

Cytotoxic T lymphocytes from mice with soluble class I Q10 molecules in their serum are not tolerant to membrane-bound Q10

Q10 is a class I Qa-2 region-encoded molecule that is secreted by the liver and present in serum at high concentrations (about 10 to 60 micrograms/ml) in most strains of mice. The amino terminal portion of this molecule can also be expressed as an integral membrane protein by splicing the 5' end of the Q10 gene to the 3' end of H-2Ld and transfecting the hybrid gene into murine L cells. Because CTL primarily recognize polymorphic determinants controlled by the alpha 1 and alpha 2 domains of class I molecules and because the Q10d/Ld product expressed by transfected L cells includes the alpha 1 and alpha 2 domains of Q10d, we could address whether mice bearing serum Q10 were tolerant to this molecule at the CTL level. The results of these experiments demonstrate that Q10+ mice are able to generate H-2-unrestricted CTL activity against Q10d expressed on transfected L cells, and this response was not inhibitable by the addition of Q10-containing normal mouse serum. It is unlikely that this CTL activity is due to possible polymorphic differences in Q10 alleles, since semisyngeneic BALB/c (H-2d) mice, from which the Q10d hybrid gene construct was derived, are able to generate anti-Q10d effector cells. The Q10d molecule was shown to cross-react with H-2Ld, lending support to the concept that Qa genes can serve as donors for polymorphic sequences found in H-2K, -D, and -L. That mice can generate anti-Q10 CTL activity suggests that this soluble class I protein does not act as a toleragen for these cells. The implications of these findings for an understanding of self-tolerance are discussed.     

Interaction between Kb and Q4 gene sequences generates the Kbm6 mutation.

Genetic interaction as a mechanism for the generation of mutations is suggested by recurrent, multiple nucleotide substitutions that are identical to nucleotide sequences elsewhere in the genome. We have sequenced the mutant K gene from the bm6 mouse, which is one of a series of eight closely related, yet independently occurring mutants known collectively as the "bg series." Two changes from the Kb gene are found, positioned 15 nucleotides apart: an A-to-T change and a T-to-C change in the codons corresponding to amino acids 116 and 121, resulting in Tyr-to-Phe and Cys-to-Arg substitutions, respectively. Hybridization analysis with an oligonucleotide specific for the altered Kbm6 sequence identifies one donor gene, Q4, located in the Qa region of the H-2 complex. The two altered nucleotides that differentiate Kbm6 and Kb are present in Q4 in a region where Kb and Q4 are otherwise identical for 95 nucleotides, delineating the maximum genetic transfer between the two genes. Because the Kbm6 mutation arose in an homozygous mouse these data indicate that the Q4 gene contains the only donor sequence and demonstrates that Q-region gene sequences can interact with the Kb gene to generate variant K molecules.     

Thymocyte antigens do not induce tolerance in the CD4+ T cell compartment.

Thymocytes fail to tolerize the developing T cell repertoire to self MHC class I (MHC I) Ags because transgenic (CD2Kb) mice expressing H-2Kb solely in lymphoid cell lineages reject skin grafts mismatched only for H-2Kb. In this study, we examined why thymocytes fail to tolerize the T cell repertoire to self MHC I Ags. The ability of CD2Kb mice to reject H-2Kb skin grafts was age dependent because CD2Kb mice older than 20 wk accepted skin grafts. T cells from younger CD2Kb mice proliferated, but did not develop cytotoxic functions in vitro in response to H-2Kb. Proliferative responses were dominated by H-2Kb-specific, CD4+ T cells rather than CD8+ T cells. Representative CD4+ T cell clones from CD2Kb mice were MHC II restricted and recognized processed H-2Kb. TCR transgenic mice were generated from one CD4+ T cell clone (361) to monitor development of H-2Kb-specific immature thymocytes when all thymic cells or lymphoid cell lineages only expressed H-2Kb. Thymocyte precursors were not eliminated and mice were not tolerant to H-2Kb when Tg361 TCR transgenic mice were intercrossed with CD2Kb mice. In contrast, all thymocyte precursors were eliminated efficiently in thymic microenvironments in which all cells expressed H-2Kb. We conclude that self MHC I Ags expressed exclusively in thymocytes do not induce T cell tolerance because presentation of processed self MHC I Ags on self MHC II molecules fails to induce negative selection of CD4+ T cell precursors. This suggests that some self Ags are effectively compartmentalized and cannot induce self-tolerance in the T cell repertoire.     

H-2 Effects on cell-cell interactions in the response to single non-H-2 alloantigens

Mice expressing mutant H-2Kb alleles were tested for their ability to generate cytotoxic effector T-cells specific for the non-H-2 histocompatibility alloantigen H-4.2. Cytotoxic effectors specific for H-4.2 are preferentially restricted by the Kb allele. Mutant Kb alleles were observed to differentially regulate the magnitude of the H-4.2-specific cytotoxic effector response. Mice expressing the Kbm5, Kbm6, Kbm7, and Kbm9 alleles generated cytotoxic T-cells to the same level as mice expressing the wild-type Kb allele. Kbm8 and Kbm11 responders generated intermediate levels of effectors, whereas Kbm1, Kbm3, and Kbm10 responders did not generate detectable levels of cytotoxic effectors. Kbm4 responders produced high levels of H-4.2-specific cytotoxic effectors that were variably reactive with wild-type Kb antigens with no H-4.2. The ability to generate H-4.2-specific effectors generally correlated with (1) the ability of mutant Kb molecules to present H-4.2 to wild-type Kb-restricted effectors, and (2) the position of the respective amino acid interchanges on the Kb molecule. Mutations that altered the amino acid sequence in the vicinity of the disulfide bond in the C1 domain had the greatest deleterious effects on Kb-controlled responsiveness to H-4.2. The only exception was the Kbm11 intermediate responder, which differs from Kbm3 in both responsiveness and in a single amino acid interchange. Therefore, the amino acid sequence in the vicinity of the disulfide bond in the C1 domain plays a prominent role in determining the H-4.2-specific immune response potential. These observations are the first to clearly demonstrate association between particular MHC gene product, amino acid sequences and immune responsiveness.     

Microrecombinations generate sequence diversity in the murine major histocompatibility complex: analysis of the Kbm3, Kbm4, Kbm10, and Kbm11 mutants.

The mechanism that generates spontaneous mutants of the Kb histocompatibility gene was analyzed. Nucleotide sequence analysis of four mutant genes (Kbm3, Kbm4, Kbm10, and Kbm11) revealed that each mutant K gene contains clustered, multiple nucleotide substitutions. Hybridization analyses of parental B6 genomic DNA and cloned class I genes with mutant-specific oligonucleotide probes, followed by sequence analyses, have identified major histocompatibility complex class I genes in the K, D, and Tla regions (K1, Db, and T5, respectively) that contain the exact sequences as substituted into mutant Kb genes. These data provide evidence for the hypothesis that the mutant Kb genes are generated by a microrecombination (gene conversion) mechanism that results in the transfer of small DNA segments from class I genes of all four regions of the major histocompatibility complex (K, D, Qa, and Tla) to Kb. Many of the nucleotides substituted into the mutant Kb genes were identical to those found in other naturally occurring K alleles such as Kd. Thus, we propose that the accumulation of microrecombination products within the K genes of a mouse population is responsible for the high sequence diversity among H-2 alleles.     

In vitro mutagenesis of a mouse MHC class I gene for the examination of structure-function relationships

Oligonucleotide-directed, site-specific mutagenesis has been employed to elucidate the role of individual amino acids on the expression and function of a MHC class I antigen. Two oligonucleotides were synthesized to introduce single amino acid substitutions in the murine H-2Ld gene. The highly conserved glycosylation site at amino acid position 86 was changed from asparagine to lysine to remove the carbohydrate moiety from the first external domain of the H-2 molecule, and the phenylalanine at position 116 was changed to tyrosine, replacing the Ld residue with the Kb type amino acid analogous to Kb mutants: bm5 and bm16 mutants derived from the Kb antigen have the Ld-type residue at this position. The mutant genes were constructed by annealing the mutagenic oligomers to the single stranded H-2Ld gene, followed by chain elongation reaction. The expected mutations were confirmed by DNA sequence determination. The mutant genes were introduced into mouse L cells by DNA-mediated gene transfer. Both mutant genes expressed the antigens on the cell surface, as detected by antibody binding; these antigens were reactive with the cytotoxic T cells specific for the H-2Ld antigen. Detailed examination with 16 monoclonal anti-H-2Ld antibodies revealed that the binding of some antibodies was significantly reduced in the glycosylation mutant, implying a certain contribution of the carbohydrates to the antigenic activity of some determinants. No detectable changes have been observed in the mutant of the substitution at position 116 by the parameters we tested.     

Constitutive and IL 1-regulated murine complement gene expression is strain and tissue specific

To study the molecular mechanisms accounting for strain- and tissue-specific variations in the production of complement proteins, complementary DNA probes were used to assess qualitative and quantitative differences in specific mRNA content of complement proteins C2, factor B, and C3 in extracts of tissues (liver, lung, spleen, kidney, and peritoneal macrophages) isolated from various mouse strains. Northern blot analysis of total hepatic RNA revealed differences in C2, factor B, and C3 mRNA levels in strains that share B10 background but differ in the H-2 region (e.g., H-2k, H-2u, H-2d, H-2f). In each instance, hepatic mRNA specific for the individual gene product corresponded in amount to the serum levels. By contrast, specific mRNA content of C2 and factor B in macrophages differed significantly from those observed in liver for each strain. Modulation of C2, factor B, and C3 expression was studied after in vivo administration of recombinant IL 1 or endotoxin to H-2k (B10.AKM) or H-2u (B10.PL) strain mice. As assessed by Northern blot analysis, neither endotoxin nor IL 1 affected liver C2-specific mRNA but increased specific C2 mRNA levels in kidney and lung. For both strains, IL 1 increased specific factor B mRNA in all tissues examined except for the H-2u strain liver factor B mRNA content, which was not affected by IL 1, whereas that of H-2k mice was increased. The lack of factor B modulation by IL 1 in the H-2u lines was specific to that gene and not a reflection of a generalized IL 1 unresponsiveness. Differences in tissue and strain specific constitutive and IL 1-regulated expression of the C3 gene were also observed in the H-2u and H-2k strains.