Peptide inhibitors of protein kinases-discovery, characterisation and use

Protein kinases are now the second largest group of drug targets, and most protein kinase inhibitors in clinical development are directed towards the ATP-binding site. However, these inhibitors must compete with high intracellular ATP concentrations and they must discriminate between the ATP-binding sites of all protein kinases as well the other proteins that also utilise ATP. It would therefore be beneficial to target sites on protein kinases other than the ATP-binding site. This review describes the discovery, characterisation and use of peptide inhibitors of protein kinases. In many cases, the development of these peptides has resulted from an understanding of the specific protein-binding partners for a particular protein kinase. In addition, novel peptide sequences have been discovered in library screening approaches and have provided new leads in the discovery and/or design of peptide inhibitors of protein kinases. These approaches are therefore providing exciting new opportunities in the development of ATP non-competitive inhibitors of protein kinases.     

Design principles underpinning the regulatory diversity of protein kinases

Protein phosphorylation in eukaryotes is carried out by a large and diverse family of protein kinases, which display remarkable diversity and complexity in their modes of regulation. The complex modes of regulation have evolved as a consequence of natural selection operating on protein kinase sequences for billions of years. Here we describe how quantitative comparisons of protein kinase sequences from diverse organisms, in particular prokaryotes, have contributed to our understanding of the structural organization and evolution of allosteric regulation in the protein kinase domain. An emerging view from these studies is that regulatory diversity and complexity in the protein kinase domain evolved in a 'modular' fashion through elaboration of an ancient core component, which existed before the emergence of eukaryotes. The core component provided the conformational flexibility required for ATP binding and phosphoryl transfer in prokaryotic kinases, but evolved into a highly regulatable domain in eukaryotes through the addition of exaggerated structural features that facilitated tight allosteric control. Family and group-specific features are built upon the core component in eukaryotes to provide additional layers of control. We propose that 'modularity' and 'conformational flexibility' are key evolvable traits of the protein kinase domain that contributed to its extensive regulatory diversity and complexity.     

A liquid chromatography/mass spectrometry-based method for the selection of ATP competitive kinase inhibitors

The currently approved kinase inhibitors for therapeutic uses and a number of kinase inhibitors that are undergoing clinical trials are directed toward the adenosine triphosphate (ATP) binding site of protein kinases. The 5'-fluorosulfonylbenzoyl 5'-adenosine (FSBA) is an ATP-affinity reagent that covalently modifies a conserved lysine present in the nucleotide-binding site of most kinases. The authors have developed a liquid chromatography/mass spectrometry-based method to monitor binding of ATP competitive protein kinase inhibitors using FSBA as a nonselective activity-based probe for protein kinases. Their method provides a general, rapid, and reproducible means to screen and validate selective ATP competitive inhibitors of protein kinases.     

ATP analog specificity of cAMP-dependent protein kinase, cGMP-dependent protein kinase, and phosphorylase kinase

The ATP analog specificities of the homogeneous cGMP-dependent protein kinase and the catalytic subunit of cAMP-dependent protein kinase have been compared by the ability of 27 analogs to compete with ATP in the protein kinase reaction. Although the data suggest general similarities between the ATP sites of the two homologous cyclic-nucleotide-dependent protein kinases, specific differences especially in the adenine binding pocket are indicated. These differences in affinity suggest potentially useful ATP analog inhibitors of each kinase. For example, apparent autophosphorylation of the purified regulatory subunit of the cAMP-dependent protein kinase is blocked by nebularin triphosphate, suggesting that the phosphorylation is catalyzed by trace contamination of cGMP-dependent protein kinase. Some of the ATP analogs have also been tested using phosphorylase b kinase in order to compare this enzyme with the cyclic-nucleotide-dependent enzymes. All three protein kinases have high specificity for the purine moiety of ATP, and lower specificity for the ribose or triphosphate. The similarity between the ATP site of phosphorylase b kinase to that of the cyclic-nucleotide-dependent protein kinases suggests that it is related to them. The ATP analog specificities of enzymes examined in this study are different from those reported for several unrelated ATP-utilizing enzymes.     

Evolutionary variation and adaptation in a conserved protein kinase allosteric network: Implications for inhibitor design

The activation of protein kinases involves conformational changes in key functional regions of the kinase domain, a detailed understanding of which is essential for the design of selective protein kinase inhibitors. Through statistical analysis of protein kinase sequences and crystal structures from diverse organisms, we recently proposed that the activation of protein kinases involves a hidden strain switch in the catalytic loop. Specifically, we demonstrated that the backbone torsion-angles of residues in the catalytic loop switch from a “relaxed” to “strained” conformation upon kinase activation and the strained geometry results in a network of hydrogen bonds involving conserved non-catalytic residues in the ATP and substrate binding lobes. Here, we further explore this activation mechanism by analyzing families that lack the canonical hydrogen bonding interactions with the strained backbone. We find that alternative mechanisms have evolved to maintain catalytic loop strain. In PIM kinase, for example, two water molecules account for the lack of a conserved aspartate in the substrate binding by hydrogen bonds to the strained backbone. We discuss the relevance of these findings in the design of family-specific allosteric inhibitors, and in predicting the structural and functional impact of cancer mutations that alter the strain associated hydrogen bonding network. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Inhibitors of Protein Kinases (2012).     

The unusual mechanism of inhibition of the p90 ribosomal S6 kinase (RSK) by flavonol rhamnosides

All known protein kinases share a bilobal kinase domain with well conserved structural elements. Because of significant structural similarities of nucleotide binding pocket, the development of highly selective kinase inhibitors is a very challenging task. Flavonols, naturally occurring plant metabolites, have long been known to inhibit kinases by mimicking the adenine moiety. Interestingly, recent data show that some flavonol glycosides are more selective, although underlying mechanisms were unknown. Crystallographic data from our laboratory revealed that the N-terminal kinase domain of p90 ribosomal S6 kinase, isoform 2, binds three different flavonol rhamnosides in a highly unusual manner, distinct from other kinase inhibitor interactions. The kinase domain undergoes a reorganization of several structural elements in response to the binding of the inhibitors. Specifically, the main β-sheet of the N-lobe undergoes a twisting rotation by ~ 56° around an axis passing through the N- and C-lobes, leading to the restructuring of the canonical ATP-binding pocket into pockets sterically adapted to the inhibitor shape. The flavonol rhamnosides appear to adopt compact, but strained conformations with the rhamnose moiety swept under the B-ring of flavonol, unlike the structure of the free counterparts in solution. These data suggest that the flavonol glycoside scaffold could be used as a template for new inhibitors selective for the RSK family. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Inhibitors of Protein Kinases (2012).     

Quantitative methods for the analysis of protein phosphorylation in drug development

Most signal transduction and cell signaling pathways are mediated by protein kinases. Protein kinases have emerged as important cellular regulatory proteins in many aspects of neoplasia. Protein kinase inhibitors offer the opportunity to target diseases such as cancer with chemotherapeutic agents specific for the causative molecular defect. In order to identify possible targets and assess kinase inhibitors, quantitative methods for analyzing protein phosphorylation have been developed. This review examines some of the current formats used for quantifying kinase function for drug development.     

Quantitative methods for the analysis of protein phosphorylation in drug development

Most signal transduction and cell signaling pathways are mediated by protein kinases. Protein kinases have emerged as important cellular regulatory proteins in many aspects of neoplasia. Protein kinase inhibitors offer the opportunity to target diseases such as cancer with chemotherapeutic agents specific for the causative molecular defect. In order to identify possible targets and assess kinase inhibitors, quantitative methods for analyzing protein phosphorylation have been developed. This review examines some of the current formats used for quantifying kinase function for drug development.     

A novel mode of protein kinase inhibition exploiting hydrophobic motifs of autoinhibited kinases: discovery of ATP-independent inhibitors of fibroblast growth factor receptor

Protein kinase inhibitors with enhanced selectivity can be designed by optimizing binding interactions with less conserved inactive conformations because such inhibitors will be less likely to compete with ATP for binding and therefore may be less impacted by high intracellular concentrations of ATP. Analysis of the ATP-binding cleft in a number of inactive protein kinases, particularly in the autoinhibited conformation, led to the identification of a previously undisclosed non-polar region in this cleft. This ATP-incompatible hydrophobic region is distinct from the previously characterized hydrophobic allosteric back pocket, as well as the main pocket. Generalized hypothetical models of inactive kinases were constructed and, for the work described here, we selected the fibroblast growth factor receptor (FGFR) tyrosine kinase family as a case study. Initial optimization of a FGFR2 inhibitor identified from a library of commercial compounds was guided using structural information from the model. We describe the inhibitory characteristics of this compound in biophysical, biochemical, and cell-based assays, and have characterized the binding mode using x-ray crystallographic studies. The results demonstrate, as expected, that these inhibitors prevent activation of the autoinhibited conformation, retain full inhibitory potency in the presence of physiological concentrations of ATP, and have favorable inhibitory activity in cancer cells. Given the widespread regulation of kinases by autoinhibitory mechanisms, the approach described herein provides a new paradigm for the discovery of inhibitors by targeting inactive conformations of protein kinases.     

Unique MAP Kinase binding sites

Map kinases are drug targets for autoimmune disease, cancer, and apoptosis-related diseases. Drug discovery efforts have developed MAP kinase inhibitors directed toward the ATP binding site and neighboring "DFG-out" site, both of which are targets for inhibitors of other protein kinases. On the other hand, MAP kinases have unique substrate and small molecule binding sites that could serve as inhibition sites. The substrate and processing enzyme D-motif binding site is present in all MAP kinases, and has many features of a good small molecule binding site. Further, the MAP kinase p38alpha has a binding site near its C-terminus discovered in crystallographic studies. Finally, the MAP kinases ERK2 and p38alpha have a second substrate binding site, the FXFP binding site that is exposed in active ERK2 and the D-motif peptide induced conformation of MAP kinases. Crystallographic evidence of these latter two binding sites is presented.     

Comparative surface geometry of the protein kinase family

Identifying conserved pockets on the surfaces of a family of proteins can provide insight into conserved geometric features and sites of protein–protein interaction. Here we describe mapping and comparison of the surfaces of aligned crystallographic structures, using the protein kinase family as a model. Pockets are rapidly computed using two computer programs, FADE and Crevasse. FADE uses gradients of atomic density to locate grooves and pockets on the molecular surface. Crevasse, a new piece of software, splits the FADE output into distinct pockets. The computation was run on 10 kinase catalytic cores aligned on the αF‐helix, and the resulting pockets spatially clustered. The active site cleft appears as a large, contiguous site that can be subdivided into nucleotide and substrate docking sites. Substrate specificity determinants in the active site cleft between serine/threonine and tyrosine kinases are visible and distinct. The active site clefts cluster tightly, showing a conserved spatial relationship between the active site and αF‐helix in the C‐lobe. When the αC‐helix is examined, there are multiple mechanisms for anchoring the helix using spatially conserved docking sites. A novel site at the top of the N‐lobe is present in all the kinases, and there is a large conserved pocket over the hinge and the αC‐β4 loop. Other pockets on the kinase core are strongly conserved but have not yet been mapped to a protein–protein interaction. Sites identified by this algorithm have revealed structural and spatially conserved features of the kinase family and potential conserved intermolecular and intramolecular binding sites.     

Inhibition of protein kinase CK2 by anthraquinone-related compounds. A structural insight

Protein kinases play key roles in signal transduction and therefore are among the most attractive targets for drug design. The pharmacological aptitude of protein kinase inhibitors is highlighted by the observation that various diseases with special reference to cancer are because of the abnormal expression/activity of individual kinases. The resolution of the three-dimensional structure of the target kinase in complex with inhibitors is often the starting point for the rational design of this kind of drugs, some of which are already in advanced clinical trial or even in clinical practice. Here we present and discuss three new crystal structures of ATP site-directed inhibitors in complex with "casein kinase-2" (CK2), a constitutively active protein kinase implicated in a variety of cellular functions and misfunctions. With the help of theoretical calculations, we disclose some key features underlying the inhibitory efficiency of anthraquinone derivatives, outlining three different binding modes into the active site. In particular, we show that a nitro group in a hydroxyanthraquinone scaffold decreases the inhibitory constants K(i) because of electron-withdrawing and resonance effects that enhance the polarization of hydroxylic substituents in paraposition.     

Phosphorylation of protein phosphatase type-1 inhibitory proteins by integrin-linked kinase and cyclic nucleotide-dependent protein kinases

Protein phosphatases play key roles in cellular regulation and are subjected to control by protein inhibitors whose activity is in turn regulated by phosphorylation. Here we investigated the possible regulation of phosphorylation-dependent type-1 protein phosphatase (PP1) inhibitors, CPI-17, PHI-1, and KEPI, by various kinases. Protein kinases A (PKA) and G (PKG) phosphorylated CPI-17 at the inhibitory site (T38), but not PHI-1 (T57). Phosphorylated CPI-17 inhibited the activity of both the PP1 catalytic subunit (PP1c) and the myosin phosphatase holoenzyme (MPH) with IC(50) values of 1-8 nM. PKA predominantly phosphorylated a site distinct from the inhibitory T73 in KEPI, whereas PKG was ineffective. Integrin-linked kinase phosphorylated KEPI (T73) and this dramatically increased inhibition of PP1c (IC(50)=0.1 nM) and MPH (IC(50)=8 nM). These results suggest that the regulatory phosphorylation of CPI-17 and KEPI may involve distinct kinases and signaling pathways.     

Allosteric regulation of PKCθ: understanding multistep phosphorylation and priming by ligands in AGC kinases

Protein kinases play critical roles in cellular activation and differentiation, and are involved in numerous pathophysiological processes. As a critical component of the regulatory circuitry of the cell, the kinase domain has the ability to integrate multiple signals, yielding a predetermined output. In PKC and other protein kinases of the AGC family, several phosphorylation sites control the activity, but these are in turn influenced by the presence of ligands in the binding pocket, which promotes phosphorylation. Here, we take PKC-theta as a prototypical member of the family and use molecular dynamics simulations to investigate the cross-talk that exists between regulatory and functional sites. We first show how the apo-unphosphorylated form of the kinase is populating a conformational space in which access to the ATP binding site and to the activation loop (AL) are simultaneously hindered. This could explain why the inactive state is not only catalytically incompetent but also resistant to activation. AL phosphorylation induces ATP binding site opening, which can then readily accept the cofactor. But the signal transmission mechanism works both ways, and if ligand binding to the unphosphorylated form occurs first, the AL is de-protected and becomes exposed to phosphorylation, thus providing an explanation for the paradoxical activation of PKCs by their inhibitors.     

Vicinity analysis: a methodology for the identification of similar protein active sites

Vicinity analysis (VA) is a new methodology developed to identify similarities between protein binding sites based on their three-dimensional structure and the chemical similarity of matching residues. The major objective is to enable searching of the Protein Data Bank (PDB) for similar sub-pockets, especially in proteins from different structural and biochemical series. Inspection of the ligands bound in these pockets should allow ligand functionality to be identified, thus suggesting novel monomers for use in library synthesis. VA has been developed initially using the ATP binding site in kinases, an important class of protein targets involved in cell signalling and growth regulation. This paper defines the VA procedure and describes matches to the phosphate binding sub-pocket of cyclin-dependent protein kinase 2 that were found by searching a small test database that has also been used to parameterise the methodology.     

Protein kinase biochemistry and drug discovery

Protein kinases are fascinating biological catalysts with a rapidly expanding knowledge base, a growing appreciation in cell regulatory control, and an ascendant role in successful therapeutic intervention. To better understand protein kinases, the molecular underpinnings of phosphoryl group transfer, protein phosphorylation, and inhibitor interactions are examined. This analysis begins with a survey of phosphate group and phosphoprotein properties which provide context to the evolutionary selection of phosphorylation as a central mechanism for biological regulation of most cellular processes. Next, the kinetic and catalytic mechanisms of protein kinases are examined with respect to model aqueous systems to define the elements of catalysis. A brief structural biology overview further delves into the molecular basis of catalysis and regulation of catalytic activity. Concomitant with a prominent role in normal physiology, protein kinases have important roles in the disease state. To facilitate effective kinase drug discovery, classic and emerging approaches for characterizing kinase inhibitors are evaluated including biochemical assay design, inhibitor mechanism of action analysis, and proper kinetic treatment of irreversible inhibitors. As the resulting protein kinase inhibitors can modulate intended and unintended targets, profiling methods are discussed which can illuminate a more complete range of an inhibitor's biological activities to enable more meaningful cellular studies and more effective clinical studies. Taken as a whole, a wealth of protein kinase biochemistry knowledge is available, yet it is clear that a substantial extent of our understanding in this field remains to be discovered which should yield many new opportunities for therapeutic intervention.     

Synthesis and characterization of 5'-p-fluorosulfonylbenzoyl-2' (or 3')-(biotinyl)adenosine as an activity-based probe for protein kinases

Most of the kinase inhibitors that are approved for therapeutic uses or that are undergoing clinical trials are directed toward the adenosine triphosphate (ATP) binding site of protein kinases. 5'-Fluorosulfonylbenzoyl 5'-adenosine (FSBA) is an activitybased probe (ABP) that covalently modifies a conserved lysine present in the nucleotide binding site of most kinases. Here the authors describe synthesis of FSBA derivatives, 2'-biotinyl-FSBA and 3'-biotinyl-FSBA as kinase ABPs, and delineate a Western blot method to screen and validate ATP competitive protein kinase inhibitors using biotinyl-FSBA as a nonselective activity-based probe for protein kinases.     

Deciphering the Arginine-binding preferences at the substrate-binding groove of Ser/Thr kinases by computational surface mapping

Protein kinases are key signaling enzymes that catalyze the transfer of γ-phosphate from an ATP molecule to a phospho-accepting residue in the substrate. Unraveling the molecular features that govern the preference of kinases for particular residues flanking the phosphoacceptor is important for understanding kinase specificities toward their substrates and for designing substrate-like peptidic inhibitors. We applied ANCHORSmap, a new fragment-based computational approach for mapping amino acid side chains on protein surfaces, to predict and characterize the preference of kinases toward Arginine binding. We focus on positions P-2 and P-5, commonly occupied by Arginine (Arg) in substrates of basophilic Ser/Thr kinases. The method accurately identified all the P-2/P-5 Arg binding sites previously determined by X-ray crystallography and produced Arg preferences that corresponded to those experimentally found by peptide arrays. The predicted Arg-binding positions and their associated pockets were analyzed in terms of shape, physicochemical properties, amino acid composition, and in-silico mutagenesis, providing structural rationalization for previously unexplained trends in kinase preferences toward Arg moieties. This methodology sheds light on several kinases that were described in the literature as having non-trivial preferences for Arg, and provides some surprising departures from the prevailing views regarding residues that determine kinase specificity toward Arg. In particular, we found that the preference for a P-5 Arg is not necessarily governed by the 170/230 acidic pair, as was previously assumed, but by several different pairs of acidic residues, selected from positions 133, 169, and 230 (PKA numbering). The acidic residue at position 230 serves as a pivotal element in recognizing Arg from both the P-2 and P-5 positions.     

The structure of CYP101D2 unveils a potential path for substrate entry into the active site

We describe in the present paper mutations of the catalytic subunit α of PKA (protein kinase A) that introduce amino acid side chains into the ATP-binding site and progressively transform the pocket to mimic that of Aurora protein kinases. The resultant PKA variants are enzymatically active and exhibit high affinity for ATP site inhibitors that are specific for Aurora kinases. These features make the Aurora-chimaeric PKA a valuable tool for structure-based drug discovery tasks. Analysis of crystal structures of the chimaera reveal the roles for individual amino acid residues in the binding of a variety of inhibitors, offering key insights into selectivity mechanisms. Furthermore, the high affinity for Aurora kinase-specific inhibitors, combined with the favourable crystallizability properties of PKA, allow rapid determination of inhibitor complex structures at an atomic resolution. We demonstrate the utility of the Aurora-chimaeric PKA by measuring binding kinetics for three Aurora kinase-specific inhibitors, and present the X-ray structures of the chimaeric enzyme in complex with VX-680 (MK-0457) and JNJ-7706621 [Aurora kinase/CDK (cyclin-dependent kinase) inhibitor].     

Rational design of inhibitors that bind to inactive kinase conformations

The majority of kinase inhibitors that have been developed so far--known as type I inhibitors--target the ATP binding site of the kinase in its active conformation, in which the activation loop is phosphorylated. Recently, crystal structures of inhibitors such as imatinib (STI571), BIRB796 and sorafenib (BAY43-9006)--known as type II inhibitors--have revealed a new binding mode that exploits an additional binding site immediately adjacent to the region occupied by ATP. This pocket is made accessible by an activation-loop rearrangement that is characteristic of kinases in an inactive conformation. Here, we present a structural analysis of binding modes of known human type II inhibitors and demonstrate that they conform to a pharmacophore model that is currently being used to design a new generation of kinase inhibitors.