Gradients of lipid storage, photosynthesis and plastid differentiation in developing soybean seeds

This study establishes a topographical framework for functional investigations on the regulation of lipid biosynthesis and its interaction with embryo photosynthesis in developing soybean seed. Structural observations, combined with molecular and functional parameters, revealed the gradual transformation of chloroplasts into storage organelles, starting from inner regions going outwards. This is evidenced by electron microscopy, confocal laser scanning microscopy, in situ hybridization and histochemical/biochemical data. As a consequence of plastid differentiation, photosynthesis becomes distributed along a gradient within the developing embryo. Electron transport rate, effective quantum yield and O2 production rate are maximal in the embryo periphery, as documented by imaging pulse-amplitude-modulated fluorescence and O2 release via microsensors. The gradual loss of photosynthetic capacity was accompanied by a similarly gradual accumulation of starch and lipids. Noninvasive nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy of mature seeds revealed steep gradients in lipid deposition, with the highest concentrations in inner regions. The inverse relationship between photosynthesis and lipid biosynthesis argues against a direct metabolic involvement of photosynthesis in lipid biosynthesis during the late storage stage, but points to a role for photosynthetic oxygen release. This hypothesis is verified in a companion paper.     

Energy state and its control on seed development: starch accumulation is associated with high ATP and steep oxygen gradients within barley grains

The role of oxygen and energy state in development and storage activity of cereal grains is an important issue, but has remained largely uninvestigated due to the lack of appropriate analytical methods. Metabolic profiling, bioluminescence-based in situ imaging of ATP, and oxygen-sensitive microsensors were combined here to investigate barley seed development. For the first time temporal and spatial maps of O2 and ATP distribution in cereal grains were determined and related to the differentiation pattern. Steep O2 gradients were demonstrated and strongly hypoxic regions were detected within the caryopsis (<0.1% of atmospheric saturation). Growing lateral and peripheral regions of endosperm remained well-supplied with O2 due to pericarp photosynthesis. ATP distribution in the developing grain was coupled to endosperm differentiation. High ATP concentrations were associated with the local onset of starch storage within endosperm, while low ATP overlapped with the hypoxic regions. Temporally, the building of steep gradients in ATP coincided with overall elevating metabolite levels, specific changes in the metabolite profiles (glycolysis and citrate cycle), and channelling of metabolic fluxes towards storage (increase of starch accumulation rate). These findings implicate an inhomogenous spatial arrangement of metabolic activity within the caryopsis. It is suggested that the local onset of starch storage is coupled with the accumulation of ATP and elevated metabolic activity. Thus, the ATP level reflects the metabolic state of storage tissue. On the basis of these findings, a hypothetical model for the regulation of starch storage in barley seeds is proposed.     

Positional cues for the starch/lipid balance in maize kernels and resource partitioning to the embryo

This study tests the hypotheses that in vivo oxygen levels inside developing maize grains locally affect assimilate partitioning and ATP distribution within the kernel. These questions were addressed through combined topographical analysis (O2- and ATP-mapping), metabolite profiling, and isotope flux analysis. Internal and external oxygen levels were also experimentally altered. Under ambient conditions, mean O2 concentration immediately inside starchy endosperm dropped to only 1.4% of atmospheric saturation (approximately 3.8 microm), but was 10-fold higher in the oil-storing embryo. Increasing the O2 supply to intact kernels stimulated their O2 demand, shifted ATP localization within the kernel, and elevated their ATP/ADP ratio. Enhanced O2 availability also increased steady-state levels of glycolytic intermediates and those of the citric acid cycle, as well as some related pools of free amino acids. Subsequent analyses indicated that starch formation within endosperm, but not lipid biosynthesis within embryo, was adapted to the endogenous low oxygen. Increasing the O2 supply did not change ADP-glucose levels, activity of ADP-glucose pyrophosphorylase, 13C-labeling of ADP-glucose, or flux of 14C-sucrose into starch. In contrast, enhanced O2 availability increased 14C-label uptake into the embryo, 13C-labeling of acetyl-coenzyme A, and finally 14C-incorporation into lipids. Lipid accumulation in embryo appeared highest in regions with higher ATP. Consistent with labeling data, a decrease in O2 supply most strongly affected the embryo, whereas rising O2 levels expanded ATP-rich zones toward the starch-storing endosperm and the scutellar part of embryo. The latter might be responsible for higher 14C-label uptake into the embryo and flux toward lipid. Collectively, data indicate that the in vivo oxygen distribution in maize kernels markedly affects ATP gradients, metabolite levels, and favors assimilate partitioning toward starch within the O2-depleted endosperm. Clear advantages are thus evident for peripheral localization of the protein and lipid storing structures in maize kernels.     

Energy status and its control on embryogenesis of legumes: ATP distribution within Vicia faba embryos is developmentally regulated and correlated with photosynthetic capacity

To analyse the energy status of Vicia faba embryos in relation to differentiation processes, we measured ATP concentrations directly in cryosections using a quantitative bioluminescence-based imaging technique. This method provides a quantitative picture of the ATP distribution close to the in vivo situation. ATP concentrations were always highest within the axis. In pre-storage cotyledons, the level was low, but it increased strongly in the course of further development, starting from the abaxial region of cotyledons and moving towards the interior. Greening pattern, chlorophyll distribution and photosynthetic O2 production within embryos temporally and spatially corresponded to the ATP distribution, implicating that the overall increase of the energy state is associated to the greening process. ATP patterns were associated to the photosynthetic capacity of the embryo. The general distribution pattern as well as the steady state levels of ATP were developmentally regulated and did not change upon dark/light conditions. The major storage protein legumin started to accumulate in abaxial regions with high ATP, whereas starch localized in regions with relatively lower ATP levels. This suggests a role of the energy state in the partitioning of assimilates into the different storage-product classes. Highest biosynthetic rates occurred when cotyledons became fully green and contained high ATP levels, implicating that a photoheterotrophic state was required to ensure high fluxes. Based on these data, we propose a model for the role of embryonic photosynthesis to improve the energy status of the embryo.     

Seed Architecture Shapes Embryo Metabolism in Oilseed Rape

Constrained to develop within the seed, the plant embryo must adapt its shape and size to fit the space available. Here, we demonstrate how this adjustment shapes metabolism of photosynthetic embryo. Noninvasive NMR-based imaging of the developing oilseed rape (Brassica napus) seed illustrates that, following embryo bending, gradients in lipid concentration became established. These were correlated with the local photosynthetic electron transport rate and the accumulation of storage products. Experimentally induced changes in embryo morphology and/or light supply altered these gradients and were accompanied by alterations in both proteome and metabolome. Tissue-specific metabolic models predicted that the outer cotyledon and hypocotyl/radicle generate the bulk of plastidic reductant/ATP via photosynthesis, while the inner cotyledon, being enclosed by the outer cotyledon, is forced to grow essentially heterotrophically. Under field-relevant high-light conditions, major contribution of the ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase–bypass to seed storage metabolism is predicted for the outer cotyledon and the hypocotyl/radicle only. Differences between in vitro– versus in planta–grown embryos suggest that metabolic heterogeneity of embryo is not observable by in vitro approaches. We conclude that in vivo metabolic fluxes are locally regulated and connected to seed architecture, driving the embryo toward an efficient use of available light and space.     

Energy status and its control on embryogenesis of legumes. Embryo photosynthesis contributes to oxygen supply and is coupled to biosynthetic fluxes

Legume seeds are heterotrophic and dependent on mitochondrial respiration. Due to the limited diffusional gas exchange, embryos grow in an environment of low oxygen. O(2) levels within embryo tissues were measured using microsensors and are lowest in early stages and during night, up to 0.4% of atmospheric O(2) concentration (1.1 micro M). Embryo respiration was more strongly inhibited by low O(2) during earlier than later stages. ATP content and adenylate energy charge were lowest in young embryos, whereas ethanol emission and alcohol dehydrogenase activity were high, indicating restricted ATP synthesis and fermentative metabolism. In vitro and in vivo experiments further revealed that embryo metabolism is O(2) limited. During maturation, ATP levels increased and fermentative metabolism disappeared. This indicates that embryos become adapted to the low O(2) and can adjust its energy state on a higher level. Embryos become green and photosynthetically active during differentiation. Photosynthetic O(2) production elevated the internal level up to approximately 50% of atmospheric O(2) concentration (135 micro M). Upon light conditions, embryos partitioned approximately 3-fold more [(14)C]sucrose into starch. The light-dependent increase of starch synthesis was developmentally regulated. However, steady-state levels of nucleotides, free amino acids, sugars, and glycolytic intermediates did not change upon light or dark conditions. Maturing embryos responded to low O(2) supply by adjusting metabolic fluxes rather than the steady-state levels of metabolites. We conclude that embryogenic photosynthesis increases biosynthetic fluxes probably by providing O(2) and energy that is readily used for biosynthesis and respiration.     

Influence of Temperature, Oxygen, and pH on a Metalimnetic Population of Oscillatoria rubescens

Planktonic Oscillatoria spp. often inhabit depths of thermally stratified lakes in which gradients of physical and chemical factors occur. Measurements of photosynthetic rate or photosynthetic carbon metabolism were used to evaluate the importance of vertical gradients of temperature, oxygen, and pH upon Oscillatoria rubescens in Crooked Lake, Ind. At the low light intensities experienced in situ, neither photosynthetic rate nor relative incorporation of carbon dioxide into low-molecular-weight compounds, polysaccharide, or protein was affected by temperature. At a 10-fold-higher light intensity, the photosynthetic rate increased as temperature increased; most of the additional carbon accumulated as polysaccharide. Polysaccharide which was synthesized at high light intensity and temperature was respired when the organisms were placed in the dark, but was not used for protein biosynthesis. When O. rubescens was shifted from high light to low light, a fraction of the polysaccharide was metabolized into protein. Adaptation to growth at lower temperatures by O. rubescens cultures resulted in a decrease in the maximum photosynthetic rate. Oxygen inhibited photosynthesis by only 10 to 15% at concentrations typically found in the lake. The photosynthetic rates at pH values which occurred in Crooked Lake were all near the maximum. Thus, gradients of temperature, oxygen, or pH are not likely to significantly affect the distribution of O. rubescens in Crooked Lake, given the low light intensity at which O. rubescens grows and the range of values for those factors in the lake.     

Function of mitochondria during the transition of barley protoplasts from low light to high light

Mitochondrial contribution to photosynthetic metabolism during the transition from low light (25–100 μmol quanta m⁻² s⁻¹, limiting photosynthesis) to high light (500 μmol quanta m⁻² s⁻¹, saturating photosynthesis) was investigated in protoplasts from barley (Hordeum vulgare) leaves. After the light shift, photosynthetic oxygen evolution rate increased rapidly during the first 30–40 s and then declined up to 60–70 s after which the rate increased to a new steady-state after 80–110 s. Rapid fractionation of protoplasts was used to follow changes in sub-cellular distribution of key metabolites during the light shift and the activation state of chloroplastic NADP-dependent malate dehydrogenase (EC 1.1.1.82) was measured. Although oligomycin (an inhibitor of the mitochondrial ATP synthase) affected the metabolite content of protoplasts following the light shift, the first oxygen burst was not affected. However, the transition to the new steady-state was delayed. Rotenone (an inhibitor of mitochondrial complex I) had similar, but less pronounced effect as oligomycin. From the analysis of metabolite content and sub-cellular distribution we suggest that the decrease in oxygen evolution following the first oxygen burst is due to phosphate limitation in the chloroplast stroma. For the recovery the control protoplasts can utilize ATP supplied by mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation to quickly overcome the limitation in stromal phosphate and to increase the content of Calvin cycle metabolites. The oligomycin-treated protoplasts were deficient in cytosolic ATP and thereby unable to support Calvin cycle operation. This resulted in a delayed capacity to adjust to a sudden increase in light intensity.     

Effects of low temperature acclimation upon photosynthetic induction in barley primary leaves

Oxygen evolution and chlorophyll fluorescence were measured in cold-hardened and unhardened leaves of barley ( Hordeum vulgare L. cv. Asa) during the induction period of photosynthesis. The lag phase of light-saturated photosynthesis was increased and steady-state rates of photosynthesis were higher in cold-hardened than in unhardened barley leaves. Fluorescence was quenched more rapidly during the first minutes of induction in hardened than unhardened leaves, largely because of greater energy-dependent quenching (q_E). Also, slow fluorescence transients through the M peak were delayed and less pronounced in cold-hardened than in unhardened leaves. Based upon the combined fluorescence and oxygen evolution data it was concluded that cold-hardening delayed light activation of the energy consuming carbon reduction cycle, thereby delaying the use of ATP and NADPH formed in the light reaction. Measurements of oxygen evolution and fluorescence kinetics during photosynthetic induction under oxygenic and anoxygenic conditions suggest that oxygen photoreduction is important for additional ATP generation during both the onset of photosynthetic carbon assimilation and during steady-state photosynthesis.     

Excited chlorophyll and related problems

A historical outline is presented of the primary light energy conversion in photosynthesis studied by our research group. We found that photoexcited chlorophylls, pheophytins and porphyrins are capable of reversible and irreversible oxido-reduction. The mechanism of the photosensitized electron transfer from donor to acceptor molecule is based on the reversible photochemical oxido-reduction of the pigment-sensitizer. This property of the excited pigments is realized in the reaction centres of photosynthetic cells when photooxidation of bacteriochlorophyll(s) or chlorophyll of Photosystem II is coupled to pheophytin reduction leading to the final charge separation.The studies of the state and function of pigments in the course of chlorophyll biosynthesis in cellular and non-cellular systems revealed different monomeric and aggregated forms of pigments and the phenomenon of self-assembly of various forms of chlorophylls, bacteriochlorophylls and protochlorophylls. The discovery of protochlorophyll photoreduction in non-cellular system allowed the study of the molecular mechanisms of this reaction.In order to construct models of photosynthetic charge separation, we used inorganic photocatalysts-semiconductors, mainly titanium dioxide, and pigments incorporated into detergent micelles or lipid vesicles. To prevent back reactions we used heterogeneous systems where primary unstable products were spatially separated; coupling of solubilized chlorophylls or semiconductor particles with bacterial hydrogenase led to molecular hydrogen photoproduction. Light excitation of some coenzymes, mainly NADH and NADPH, was considered from the point of view of early events of chemical evolution.Now we are interested in the creation of photobiochemical systems using principles of photosynthesis for the conversion and storage of solar energy.Written at the invitation of Govindjee.     

18O and mass spectrometry in chlorophyll research: Derivation and loss of oxygen atoms at the periphery of the chlorophyll macrocycle during biosynthesis,degradation and adaptation

Chlorophylls, magnesium-containing tetrapyrrolic pigments of photosynthesis, are widely-distributed in Nature and participate in both light harvesting and in the transduction of light energy to chemical energy for the photosynthetic fixation of carbon dioxide. We briefly discuss the extensive role of various isotopic labelling techniques in elucidating the pathway of tetrapyrrole-pigment biosynthesis and we acknowledge the classic and meticulous research of David Shemin who, approximately 50 years ago, introduced isotopic tracer techniques with ¹⁵N and ¹⁴C isotopes to study the biosynthesis of the carbon/nitrogen macrocycle of haem, an iron tetrapyrrole. The main focus of this review is the application of mass spectrometry and ¹⁸O labelling to the study of the incorporation of oxygen atoms from molecular oxygen or water into the periphery of the chlorophyll macrocycle during biosynthesis and their loss during degradation and light acclimation. In particular, we review the mechanism of formation of the isocyclic ring of chlorophylls, in higher plants, green algae and various photosynthetic bacteria, which concomitantly incurs formation of the 13¹-oxo group that is present in all photosynthetically-active chlorophylls. In addition we discuss the formation of the ubiquitous 13³- and 17³-carboxyl groups and also the formation of the 7-formyl group of chlorophyll b and the 3-acetyl group of bacteriochlorophyll a. This revised version was published online in June 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Relating Cerebral Ischemia and Hypoxia to Insult Intensity

The contributions of five variables believed to influence the brain's metabolism of O2 during hypoxia [duration, PaO2, delta CMRO2 (the difference between normal and experimental oxygen uptake), O2 availability (blood O2 content.CBF), and O2 deficit (delta CMRO2.duration)] were assessed by stepwise and multiple linear regression. Levels of brain tissue carbohydrates (lactate, glucose, and glycogen) and energy metabolites [ATP, AMP, and creatine phosphate (CrP)] were significantly influenced by O2 deficit during hypoxia, as was final CMRO2. After 60 min of reoxygenation, levels of tissue lactate, glucose, ATP, and AMP were related statistically to the O2 deficit during hypoxia; however, CMRO2 changes were always associated more significantly with O2 availability during hypoxia. Creatine (Cr) and CrP levels in the brain following reoxygenation were correlated more to delta CMRO2 during hypoxia. Changes in some brain carbohydrate (lactate and glucose), energy metabolite (ATP and AMP) levels, and [H+]i induced by complete ischemia were also influenced by O2 deficit. After 60 min of postischemic reoxygenation, brain carbohydrate (lactate, glucose, and glycogen) and energy metabolite (ATP, AMP, CrP, and Cr) correlated with O2 deficit during ischemia. We conclude that "O2 deficit" is an excellent gauge of insult intensity which is related to observed changes in nearly two-thirds of the brain metabolites we studied during and following hypoxia and ischemia.     

State transitions, cyclic and linear electron transport and photophosphorylation in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii.

The relationship between state transitions and the kinetic properties of the electron transfer chain has been studied in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. The same turnover rate of cytochrome f was found in state 1 and 2. However, while DBMIB was inhibitory in both states, DCMU was effective only in state 1. These observations suggest that linear electron transport was active only in state 1, while a cyclic pathway around photosystem (PS) I operated in state 2. The reversible shift from linear to cyclic electron transport was modulated by changes of PSII antenna size, which inactivated the linear pathway, and by oxygen, which inhibited the cyclic one. Attainment of state 2, under anaerobiosis in the dark, was associated with the decline of the ATP/ADP ratio in the cells and the dark reduction of the intersystem carriers. Upon illumination of the cells, the ATP/ADP ratio increased in a few seconds to the aerobic level. Then, several minutes later, the F(m) returned to the state 1 level, and O(2) evolution was reactivated. This suggests that ATP, though required for photosynthesis, is not the rate-limiting factor in the reactivation of photosynthetic O(2) evolution, which is rather controlled by the redox state of the electron carriers.     

Distinct roles of the cytochrome pathway and alternative oxidase in leaf photosynthesis

In illuminated leaves, mitochondria are thought to play roles in optimizing photosynthesis. However, the roles of the cytochrome pathway (CP) and alternative oxidase (AOX) in photosynthesis, in particular in the redox state of the photosynthetic electron transport chain, are not separately characterized. We examined the effects of specific inhibition of two respiratory pathways, CP and AOX, on photosynthetic oxygen evolution and the redox state of the photosynthetic electron transport chain in broad bean (Vicia faba L.) leaves under various light intensities. Under saturating photosynthetic photon flux density (PPFD; 700 micromol photon m(-2) s(-1)), inhibition of either pathway caused a decrease in the steady-state levels of the photosynthetic O(2) evolution rate and the PSII operating efficiency, Phi(II). Because these inhibitors, at the concentrations applied to the leaves, had little effect on photosynthesis in the intact chloroplasts, two respiratory pathways are essential for maintenance of high photosynthetic rates at saturating PPFD. CP or AOX inhibition affected to Chl fluorescence parameters (e.g. photochemical quenching and non-photochemical quenching) differently, suggesting that CP and AOX contribute to photosynthesis in different ways. At low PPFD (100 micromol photon m(-2) s(-1)), only the inhibition of AOX, not CP, lowered the photosynthetic rate and Phi(II). AOX inhibition also decreased the Phi(II)/Phi(I) ratio even at low PPFD levels. These data suggest that AOX inhibition caused the over-reduction of the photosynthetic electron transport chain and induced the cyclic electron flow around PSI (CEF-PSI) even at the low PPFD. Based on these results, we discuss possible roles for CP and AOX in the light.     

Light Stress and Oxidative Cell Damage in Photoautotrophic Cell Suspension of Euphorbia characias L

A photoautotrophic cell-suspension culture of Euphorbia characias L. grown at 70 [mu]mol photons m-2 s-1 was very sensitive to light stress: the gross photosynthesis measured by using a mass spectrometric 16O2/18O2 isotope technique showed a fast decrease at a rather low light intensity of 100 [mu]mol photons m-2 s-1, far below the photosynthetic saturation level. The contribution of activated oxygen species on photosystem II photoinhibition was examined for a given light intensity. A protective effect on gross photosynthesis was observed with 1% oxygen. When light stress was applied to a methyl viologen-adapted cell suspension, photoinhibition was reduced. When 50 [mu]mol L-1 methyl viologen was added, photoinhibition was slightly enhanced. These responses suggested an involvement of superoxide radicals in the photoinhibition process of E. characias photoautotrophic cells. The long-term (16 h) effects of photoinhibition were then studied. Aldehyde (malondialdehyde and 4-hydroxyalcenals) production resulting from lipid peroxidation was stimulated in long-term stressed cells. When 50 [mu]mol L-1 methyl viologen were added, increased aldehyde production was measured. Under 1% oxygen, the aldehyde production was comparable to that of nonstressed cells. The relationship among lipid peroxidation, light intensity, and net photosynthesis suggests that aldehyde production may result from cell death provoked by a prolonged energy deficit due to the inhibition of photosynthesis.     

Comparative analysis of ultrastructure,antioxidant enzyme activities,and photosynthetic performance in rice mutant 812HS prone to photooxidation

Under optimal conditions, most of the light energy is used to drive electron transport. However, when the light energy exceeds the capacity of photosynthesis, the overall photosynthetic efficiency drops down. The present study investigated the effects of high light on rice photooxidation-prone mutant 812HS, characterized by a mutation of leaf photooxidation 1 gene, and its wild type 812S under field conditions. Our results showed no significant difference between 812HS and 812S before exposure to high sunlight. However, during exposure to high light, shoot tips of 812HS turned yellow and their chlorophyll (Chl) content decreased. Transmission electron microscopy showed that photooxidation resulted in significant damage of chloroplast ultrastructure. It was confirmed also by inhibited photophosphorylation and reduced ATP content. The decreased coupling factor of ATP, Ca²⁺-ATPase and Mg²⁺-ATPase activities also verified these results. Further, significantly enhanced activities of antioxidative enzymes were observed during photooxidation. Malondialdehyde, hydrogen peroxide, and the superoxide generation rates also increased. Chl a fluorescence analysis found that the performance index and maximum quantum yield of PSII declined on August 4, 20 days after high-light treatment. Net photosynthetic rate also decreased and substomatal CO₂ concentration increased in 812HS at the same time. In conclusion, our findings indicated that excessive energy triggered the production of toxic reactive oxygen species and promoted lipid peroxidation in 812HS plants, causing severe damage to cell membranes, degradation of photosynthetic pigments and proteins, and ultimately inhibition of photosynthesis.     

Effect of oxygen concentration on photosynthesis and respiration in two hypersaline microbial mats

The effects of oxygen concentration on photosynthesis and respiration in two hypersaline cyanobacterial mats were investigated. Experiments were carried out on mats from Eilat, Israel, with moderate photosynthetic activity, and mats from Mallorca, Spain, with high photosynthetic activity. The oxygen concentration in the overlying water above the mats was increased stepwise from 0% to 100% O2. Subsequent changes in oxygen concentration, gross photosynthetic rates, and pH values inside the mats were measured with microelectrodes. According to published reports on the regulation of ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (Rubisco), the key enzyme in the CO2-fixation pathway of phototrophs, we expected photosynthetic activity to decrease with increasing oxygen concentration. Gross photosynthetic and total respiration rates in both mats were highest when the O2 concentration was at 0% in the overlying water. Net oxygen production rates under these conditions were the same as under air saturation (21% O2), while gross photosynthetic and respiration rates were lowest at air saturation. In both mats, gross photosynthetic and respiration rates increased upon gradually increasing the oxygen concentration in the overlying water from 21% to 100%. These results contradict the expectation that photosynthesis decreases with increasing oxygen concentration. Increased photosynthetic rates at oxygen concentrations above 21% were probably caused by enhanced oxidation of organic matter and concomitant CO2 production due to the increased oxygen availability. The cause of the high respiration rates at 0% O2 in the overlying water was presumably the enhanced excretion of photosynthetic products during increased photosynthesis. We conclude that the effect of the O2/CO2 concentration ratio on the activity of Rubisco as demonstrated in vitro on enzyme extracts cannot be extrapolated to the situation in intact microbial mats, because the close coupling of the activity of primary producers and heterotrophic bacteria plays a major role in this ecosystem.