Inversion of the balance between hydrophobic and hydrogen bonding interactions in protein folding and aggregation

Identifying the forces that drive proteins to misfold and aggregate, rather than to fold into their functional states, is fundamental to our understanding of living systems and to our ability to combat protein deposition disorders such as Alzheimer's disease and the spongiform encephalopathies. We report here the finding that the balance between hydrophobic and hydrogen bonding interactions is different for proteins in the processes of folding to their native states and misfolding to the alternative amyloid structures. We find that the minima of the protein free energy landscape for folding and misfolding tend to be respectively dominated by hydrophobic and by hydrogen bonding interactions. These results characterise the nature of the interactions that determine the competition between folding and misfolding of proteins by revealing that the stability of native proteins is primarily determined by hydrophobic interactions between side-chains, while the stability of amyloid fibrils depends more on backbone intermolecular hydrogen bonding interactions.     

Improved Gō-like models demonstrate the robustness of protein folding mechanisms towards non-native interactions

The use of simple theoretical models has provided a considerable contribution to our present understanding of the means by which proteins adopt their native fold from the plethora of available unfolded states. A common assumption in building computationally tractable models has been the neglect of stabilizing non-native interactions in the class of models described as "Gō-like." The focus of this study is the characterization of the folding of a number of proteins via a Gō-like model, which aims to map a maximal amount of information reflecting the protein sequence onto a "minimalist" skeleton. This model is shown to contain sufficient information to reproduce the folding transition states of a number of proteins, including topologically analogous proteins that fold via different transition states. Remarkably, these models also demonstrate consistency with the general features of folding transition states thought to be stabilized by non-native interactions. This suggests that native interactions are the primary determinant of most protein folding transition states, and that non-native interactions lead only to local structural perturbations. A prediction is also included for an asymmetrical folding transition state of bacteriophage lambda protein W, which has yet to be subjected to experimental characterization.     

Lattice simulations of cotranslational folding of single domain proteins

We use lattice protein models and Monte Carlo simulations to study cotranslational folding of small single domain proteins. We show that the assembly of native structure begins during late extrusion stages, but final formation of native state occurs during de novo folding, when all residues are extruded. There are three main results in our study. First, for the sequences displaying two-state refolding mechanism de novo cotranslational folding pathway differs from that sampled in in vitro refolding. The change in folding pathways is due to partial assembly of native interactions during extrusion that results in different starting conditions for in vitro refolding and for de novo cotranslational folding. For small single domain proteins cotranslational folding is slower than in vitro refolding, but is generally fast enough to be completed before the release from a ribosome. Second, we found that until final stages of biosynthesis cotranslational folding is essentially equilibrium. This observation is explained by low stability of structured states for partially extruded chains. Finally, our data suggest that the proteins, which refold in vitro slowly via intermediates, complete their de novo folding after the release from a ribosome. Comparison of our lattice cotranslational simulations with recent experimental and computational studies is discussed.     

Protein folding and the organization of the protein topology universe

The mechanism by which proteins fold to their native states has been the focus of intense research in recent years. The rate-limiting event in the folding reaction is the formation of a conformation in a set known as the transition-state ensemble. The structural features present within such ensembles have now been analysed for a series of proteins using data from a combination of biochemical and biophysical experiments together with computer-simulation methods. These studies show that the topology of the transition state is determined by a set of interactions involving a small number of key residues and, in addition, that the topology of the transition state is closer to that of the native state than to that of any other fold in the protein universe. Here, we review the evidence for these conclusions and suggest a molecular mechanism that rationalizes these findings by presenting a view of protein folds that is based on the topological features of the polypeptide backbone, rather than the conventional view that depends on the arrangement of different types of secondary-structure elements. By linking the folding process to the organization of the protein structure universe, we propose an explanation for the overwhelming importance of topology in the transition states for protein folding.     

Understanding how small helical proteins fold: conformational dynamics of Im proteins relevant to their folding landscapes

Understanding the mechanism of folding of small proteins requires characterization of their starting unfolded states and any partially unfolded states populated during folding. Here, we review what is known from NMR about these states of Im7, a 4-helix bundle protein that folds via an on-pathway intermediate, and show that there is an alignment of non-native structure in urea-unfolded Im7 with the helices of native Im7 that is a consequence of hydrophobic helix-promoting residues also promoting cluster-formation in the unfolded protein. We suggest that this kind of alignment is present in other proteins and is relevant to how native state topology determines folding rates.     

The Limited Role of Nonnative Contacts in the Folding Pathways of a Lattice Protein

Models of protein energetics that neglect interactions between amino acids that are not adjacent in the native state, such as the Gō model, encode or underlie many influential ideas on protein folding. Implicit in this simplification is a crucial assumption that has never been critically evaluated in a broad context: Detailed mechanisms of protein folding are not biased by nonnative contacts, typically argued to be a consequence of sequence design and/or topology. Here we present, using computer simulations of a well-studied lattice heteropolymer model, the first systematic test of this oft-assumed correspondence over the statistically significant range of hundreds of thousands of amino acid sequences that fold to the same native structure. Contrary to previous conjectures, we find a multiplicity of folding mechanisms, suggesting that Gō-like models cannot be justified by considerations of topology alone. Instead, we find that the crucial factor in discriminating among topological pathways is the heterogeneity of native contact energies: The order in which native contacts accumulate is profoundly insensitive to omission of nonnative interactions, provided that native contact heterogeneity is retained. This robustness holds over a surprisingly wide range of folding rates for our designed sequences. Mirroring predictions based on the principle of minimum frustration, fast-folding sequences match their Gō-like counterparts in both topological mechanism and transit times. Less optimized sequences dwell much longer in the unfolded state and/or off-pathway intermediates than do Gō-like models. For dynamics that bridge unfolded and unfolded states, however, even slow folders exhibit topological mechanisms and transit times nearly identical with those of their Gō-like counterparts. Our results do not imply a direct correspondence between folding trajectories of Gō-like models and those of real proteins, but they do help to clarify key topological and energetic assumptions that are commonly used to justify such caricatures.     

Force Field Bias in Protein Folding Simulations

Long timescale (>1 μs) molecular dynamics simulations of protein folding offer a powerful tool for understanding the atomic-scale interactions that determine a protein's folding pathway and stabilize its native state. Unfortunately, when the simulated protein fails to fold, it is often unclear whether the failure is due to a deficiency in the underlying force fields or simply a lack of sufficient simulation time. We examine one such case, the human Pin1 WW domain, using the recently developed deactivated morphing method to calculate free energy differences between misfolded and folded states. We find that the force field we used favors the misfolded states, explaining the failure of the folding simulations. Possible further applications of deactivated morphing and implications for force field development are discussed.     

Partially formed native tertiary interactions in the A-state of cytochrome c.

Considerable insight into protein structure, stability, and folding has been obtained from studies of non-native states. We have studied the extent of native tertiary contacts in one such molecule, the A-state of yeast iso-1-ferricytochrome c. Previously, we showed that the interface between the N and C-terminal helices is completely formed in the A-state. Here, we focus on interactions essential for forming the heme pocket of eukaryotic cytochromes c. To determine the extent of these interactions, we used saturation mutagenesis at the evolutionarily invariant residue leucine 68, and measured the free energy of denaturation for the native states and the A-states of functional variants. We show that, unlike the interaction between the terminal helices, the native interactions between the 60s helix and the rest of the protein are not completely formed in the A-state.     

Interpretation of protein folding psi values

The structural characterization of transition states is essential for understanding the mechanism of protein folding. Analyzing the effect of mutations on protein stability and folding kinetics in phi-value analysis is commonly used to gain information about the presence of side-chain interactions in transition states. Recently, specific binding of ligands to engineered binding sites was applied to monitor the formation of local structures in transition states (psi analysis). A surprising result from psi analysis was the presence of parallel folding pathways in all reported studies and a major discrepancy between phi and psi values measured in the same protein. Here, we show that psi values cannot be analyzed in the same way as other rate-equilibrium free energy relationships due to the involvement of bimolecular reactions that may have different dissociation constants for the native, unfolded and transition state. As a consequence, psi values reflect the relative binding energy (kappa) of the transition state only for the extreme values of kappa=0 or kappa=1. In all other cases, non-linear rate-equilibrium free-energy relationships (Leffler plots) are observed. This apparently indicates the presence of parallel folding pathways even if folding occurs over a single homogeneous transition state. Consequently, the results from Leffler plots do not yield information about the structural properties of the transition state. This explains the lack of agreement between results from psi analysis and other methods used to characterize protein folding transition states. We further show that the same considerations apply for the analysis of the effect of pH on protein folding.     

Synonymous mutations and ribosome stalling can lead to altered folding pathways and distinct minima

How can we understand a case in which a given amino acid sequence folds into structurally and functionally distinct molecules? Synonymous single-nucleotide polymorphisms in the MDR1 (multidrug resistance 1 or ABCB1) gene involving frequent-to-rare codon substitutions lead to identical protein sequences. Remarkably, these alternative sequences give a protein product with similar but different structures and functions. Here, we propose that long-enough ribosomal pause time scales may lead to alternate folding pathways and distinct minima on the folding free energy surface. While the conformational and functional differences between the native and alternate states may be minor, the MDR1 case illustrates that the barriers may nevertheless constitute sufficiently high hurdles in physiological time scales, leading to kinetically trapped states with altered structures and functions. Different folding pathways leading to conformationally similar trapped states may be due to swapping of (fairly symmetric) segments. Domain swapping is more likely in the no-pause case in which the chain elongates and folds simultaneously; on the other hand, sufficiently long pause times between such segments may be expected to lessen the chances of swapping events. Here, we review the literature in this light.     

Is protein folding hierarchic? II. Folding intermediates and transition states

The folding reactions of some small proteins show clear evidence of a hierarchic process, whereas others, lacking detectable intermediates, do not. Evidence from folding intermediates and transition states suggests that folding begins locally, and that the formation of native secondary structure precedes the formation of tertiary interactions, not the reverse. Some notable examples in the literature have been interpreted to the contrary. For these examples, we have simulated the local structures that form when folding begins by using the LINUS program with nonlocal interactions turned off. Our results support a hierarchic model of protein folding.     

The effect of increasing the stability of non-native interactions on the folding landscape of the bacterial immunity protein Im9

How stabilising non-native interactions influence protein folding energy landscapes is currently not well understood: such interactions could speed folding by reducing the conformational search to the native state, or could slow folding by increasing ruggedness. Here, we examine the influence of non-native interactions in the folding process of the bacterial immunity protein Im9, by exploiting our ability to manipulate the stability of the intermediate and rate-limiting transition state (TS) in the folding of this protein by minor alteration of its sequence or changes in solvent conditions. By analysing the properties of these species using Phi-value analysis, and exploration of the structural properties of the TS ensemble using molecular dynamics simulations, we demonstrate the importance of non-native interactions in immunity protein folding and demonstrate that the rate-limiting step involves partial reorganisation of these interactions as the TS ensemble is traversed. Moreover, we show that increasing the contribution to stability made by non-native interactions results in an increase in Phi-values of the TS ensemble without altering its structural properties or solvent-accessible surface area. The data suggest that the immunity proteins fold on multiple, but closely related, micropathways, resulting in a heterogeneous TS ensemble that responds subtly to mutation or changes in the solvent conditions. Thus, altering the relative strength of native and non-native interactions influences the search to the native state by restricting the pathways through the folding energy landscape.     

Specific non-native hydrophobic interactions in a hidden folding intermediate: implications for protein folding

Structures of intermediates and transition states in protein folding are usually characterized by amide hydrogen exchange and protein engineering methods and interpreted on the basis of the assumption that they have native-like conformations. We were able to stabilize and determine the high-resolution structure of a partially unfolded intermediate that exists after the rate-limiting step of a four-helix bundle protein, Rd-apocyt b(562), by multidimensional NMR methods. The intermediate has partial native-like secondary structure and backbone topology, consistent with our earlier native state hydrogen exchange results. However, non-native hydrophobic interactions exist throughout the structure. These and other results in the literature suggest that non-native hydrophobic interactions may occur generally in partially folded states. This can alter the interpretation of mutational protein engineering results in terms of native-like side chain interactions. In addition, since the intermediate exists after the rate-limiting step and Rd-apocyt b(562) folds very rapidly (k(f) approximately 10(4) s(-1)), these results suggest that non-native hydrophobic interactions, in the absence of topological misfolding, are repaired too rapidly to slow folding and cause the accumulation of folding intermediates. More generally, these results illustrate an approach for determining the high-resolution structure of folding intermediates.     

Local interactions and the optimization of protein folding

The role of local interactions in protein folding has recently been the subject of some controversy. Here we investigate an extension of Zwanzig's simple and general model of folding in which local and nonlocal interactions are represented by functions of single and multiple conformational degrees of freedom, respectively. The kinetics and thermodynamics of folding are studied for a series of energy functions in which the energy of the native structure is fixed, but the relative contributions of local and nonlocal interactions to this energy are varied over a broad range. For funnel shaped energy landscapes, we find that 1) the rate of folding increases, but the stability of the folded state decreases, as the contribution of local interactions to the energy of the native structure increases, and 2) the amount of native structure in the unfolded state and the transition state vary considerably with the local interaction strength. Simple exponential kinetics and a well-defined free energy barrier separating folded and unfolded states are observed when nonlocal interactions make an appreciable contribution to the energy of the native structure; in such cases a transition state theory type approximation yields reasonably accurate estimates of the folding rate. Bumps in the folding funnel near the native state, which could result from desolvation effects, side chain freezing, or the breaking of nonnative contacts, significantly alter the dependence of the folding rate on the local interaction strength: the rate of folding decreases when the local interaction strength is increased beyond a certain point. A survey of the distribution of strong contacts in the protein structure database suggests that evolutionary optimization has involved both kinetics and thermodynamics: strong contacts are enriched at both very short and very long sequence separations. Proteins 29:282–291, 1997. © 1997 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Selective stabilization of a partially unfolded protein by a metabolite

When proteins fold in vivo, the intermediates that exist transiently on their folding pathways are exposed to the potential interactions with a plethora of metabolites within the cell. However, these potential interactions are commonly ignored. Here, we report a case in which a ubiquitous metabolite interacts selectively with a nonnative conformation of a protein and facilitates protein folding and unfolding process. From our previous proteomics study, we have discovered that Escherichia coli glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase (GAPDH), which is not known to bind ATP under native conditions, is apparently destabilized in the presence of a physiological concentration of ATP. To decipher the origin of this surprising effect, we investigated the thermodynamics and kinetics of folding and unfolding of GAPDH in the presence of ATP. Equilibrium unfolding of the protein in urea showed that a partially unfolded equilibrium intermediate accumulates in the presence of ATP. This intermediate has a quaternary structure distinct from the native protein. Also, ATP significantly accelerates the unfolding of GAPDH by selectively stabilizing a transition state that is distinct from the native state of the protein. Moreover, ATP also significantly accelerates the folding of GAPDH. These results demonstrate that ATP interacts specifically with a partially unfolded form of GAPDH and affects the kinetics of folding and unfolding of this protein. This unusual effect of ATP on the folding of GAPDH implies that endogenous metabolites may facilitate protein folding in vivo by interacting with partially unfolded intermediates.     

How random is a highly denatured protein?

There has been renewed interest in determining the physicochemical properties of denatured states of proteins. In many denatured states there is evidence for the existence of nonrandom configurational distributions. Here we examine the small-angle neutron scattering profile of yeast phosphoglycerate kinase in the native state and in highly denaturing conditions. We show that the denatured protein scattering profile can be interpreted using a model developed for synthetic polymers in which the chain behaves as a random coil in a good solvent, i.e. with excluded volume interactions. The implications of this result for our appreciation of the protein folding process are discussed.     

Electrostatic interactions in the denatured state and in the transition state for protein folding: effects of denatured state interactions on the analysis of transition state structure

The development of electrostatic interactions during the folding of the N-terminal domain of the ribosomal protein L9 (NTL9) is investigated by pH-dependent rate equilibrium free energy relationships. We show that Asp8, among six acidic residues, is involved in non-native, electrostatic interactions with K12 in the transition state for folding as well as in the denatured state. The perturbed native state pK(a) of D8 (pK(a) = 3.0) appears to be maintained through non-native interactions in both the transition state and the denatured state. Mutational effects on the stability of the transition state for protein (un)folding are often analyzed in respect to change in ground states. Thus, the interpretation of transition state analysis critically depends on an understanding of mutational effects on both the native and denatured state. Increasing evidence for structurally biased denatured states under physiological conditions raises concerns about possible denatured state effects on folding studies. We show that the structural interpretation of transition state analysis can be altered dramatically by denatured state effects.     

Im7 folding mechanism: misfolding on a path to the native state

Many proteins populate collapsed intermediate states during folding. In order to elucidate the nature and importance of these species, we have mapped the structure of the on-pathway intermediate of the four-helix protein, Im7, together with the conformational changes it undergoes as it folds to the native state. Kinetic data for 29 Im7 point mutants show that the intermediate contains three of the four helices found in the native structure, packed around a specific hydrophobic core. However, the intermediate contains many non-native interactions; as a result, hydrophobic interactions become disrupted in the rate-limiting transition state before the final helix docks onto the developing structure. The results of this study support a hierarchical mechanism of protein folding and explain why the misfolding of Im7 occurs. The data also demonstrate that non-native interactions can play a significant role in folding, even for small proteins with simple topologies.