Paradoxical bilateral asymmetry in bone size and bone mass in the hand

Among 227 chronic renal disease patients, micrometer caliper radiogrammetric measurements of the second metacarpal at midshaft showed the right metacarpal to be larger (with greater bone area) and with a greater cortical area than the left second metacarpal, both in 208 right-handed individuals and in 19 left-handed individuals. This direction of asymmetry was individually characteristic of the majority of individuals, whether right-handed, left-handed or ambidextrous.     

Hand dominance and bilateral asymmetry in the structure of the second metacarpal

Bilateral asymmetry in the structure of the second metacarpal was examined in relation to functional hand dominance in a large, clinically nonselected, healthy population sample from the Baltimore Longitudinal Study of Aging. Bilateral bone measurements were made from anteroposterior hand radiographs of a total of 992 individuals, 609 males and 383 females, with an age range of 19–94 years. Hand dominance was determined on the basis of personal impression. Total width and medullary width at the midshaft of the second metacarpal were measured to 0.05 mm using a Helios caliper. These two measurements were used to derive cortical thickness, cortical bone area, periosteal (total) area, medullary area, percent cortical area, and the second moment of area in the mediolateral plane. In both right and left-handed individuals, statistically significant side differences were found in the calculated bone areas and the second moment of area, with the dominant hand being larger. Cortical thickness did not show significant side-related differences for either handedness. These results show that functional handedness leads to periosteal and endosteal expansion of the second metacarpal cortex on the dominant side, increasing bone strength without increasing cortical thickness. This is the first time this pattern of asymmetry has been reported in left-handers as well as right-handers. Our results argue for the primacy of environmental (mechanical) effects in determining bilateral asymmetry of limb bone structural properties. © 1994 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Size, structure and gender: lessons about fracture risk

The differences in age-related fracture risks among men and women must reflect gender differences in the relevant variables. We are concerned here with gender differences in structural variables that relate to the size and shape of bones. As children grow, their bones grow in diameter through periosteal modeling. Studies show that radial growth is driven by mechanical forces and is not just "genetically programmed". Moving bone mass farther from the center of the diaphysis makes it more effective in resisting bending and twisting forces, and disproportionately so in comparison to changes in bone mass. Gender differences in long bone structure appear to arise because the bone cells of males and females function in different hormonal environments which affect their responses to mechanical loading. In girls, bone formation on the metacarpal periosteal surface essentially stops at puberty, and is replaced by formation on the endosteal surface, reducing endosteal diameter until about age 20. Bone strength is 60% greater in male metacarpals than in those of females because bone is added periosteally in boys and endosteally in girls. At menopause endosteal resorption resumes, accompanied by slow periosteal apposition, weakening cortical structure. Similar phenomena occur in such critical regions as the femoral neck. Another fundamental gender difference in skeletal development is that whole body bone mineral content increases in linear proportion to lean body mass throughout skeletal maturation in boys, but in girls there is a distinct increase in the slope of this relationship at puberty, when estrogen rises. Frost's hypothesis is that this reflects an effect of estrogen on bone's mechanostat set point, and this is increasingly supported by data showing that estrogen and mechanical strain act through a common pathway in osteoblast-like cells. If Frost's hypothesis is correct, the mechanostat is set for maximal effect of mechanical loading on bone gain during the 2-3 years preceding menarche. During the childbearing years, the set point is at an intermediate level, and at menopause, it shifts again to place the skeleton into the metabolic equivalent of a disuse state. The most direct approach to resolving this problem would be to simulate the putative effect of estrogen on the set point itself.     

Skeletal allometry and interlimb scaling patterns in mustelid carnivorans

To address the effects of an evolutionary increase in body size on long bone skeletal allometry, scaling patterns relating body mass, bone length, limb length, midshaft diameters, and cross-sectional properties of the humerus and femur were analyzed for four species of scansorial mustelids. Humeral and, to a lesser extent, femoral allometry is consistent with expectations of elastic similarity: bone and limb length scale with negative allometry on body mass while bone robusticity (cross-sectional parameters against bone length) scales with strong positive allometry. Differences between fore- and hindlimb scaling patterns, however, are observed, with size-dependent increases in forelimb length and humeral strength and robusticity exceeding those of the hindlimb and femur. It is hypothesized that this greater fore- than hindlimb lengthening results in postural modifications that serve to straighten the hindlimb of larger bodied scansorial mustelids relative to smaller mustelids. Straightening of hindlimb joints would more precisely align the long axis of the femur with peak (vertical) ground reaction forces, thereby accounting for the reduction in relative bending stresses acting on the femur compared to the humerus. J. Morphol. 235:121–134, 1998. © 1998 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Aging in the musculoskeletal system of rhesus monkeys: III. Bone loss

It is well established that aging of the human skeleton includes the loss of bone mass or density, but little comparative information on age-related osteopenia in other primates is available. In order to determine whether bone loss occurs in normally locomoting nonhuman primates, radiographs of 139 rhesus monkey skeletons from the Cayo Santiago collection were examined, and measures of percent cortical bone (PCT) at the midshaft of second metacarpals, humeri, and femora were calculated. An age-related osteopenia was observed in the metacarpal of adult female macaques, although much individual variation was present. This variability could not be explained by reproductive history (number of offspring), matrilineal affiliation, or degree of osteoarthrosis. However, in a subsample of 15 animals, females who had given birth in the three months prior to death showed lower PCTs than those who had not conceived in the previous mating season. In adult males, PCT did not vary significantly with age, but males that weighed less and those with no/little osteoarthrosis showed lower PCTs than heavier or more arthritic animals, respectively. The multifactorial nature of the variation in PCT observed here suggests that similar processes of bone behavior are involved in the skeletal aging of both humans and rhesus monkeys.     

Behavioral and morphological asymmetries in chukar Alectoris chukar copulation

Birds often exhibit greater reproductive tract development on the left side than right side. Behavioral evidence from the three species for which data has been published indicates that these species copulate more frequently on the left side of females than on the right side. Missing from the literature are studies that compare asymmetry in copulation behavior to asymmetry in reproductive tract morphology of the same individuals of both sexes within a single species. To better understand the potential for cryptic sexual selection to influence avian copulation, we measured asymmetries in chukar Alectoris chukar copulation using 24 male and 29 female chukar brought into captivity from the wild. Chukar copulated (n=37) more from the left side (n=30) of females than the right side (n=7). The left testis of males was consistently greater in size, mass and volume than the right testis. The left ovary and oviduct of females was consistently functional with no observable development of the right ovary or oviduct. Left-side bias in direction of copulation, larger left testes, and functional left vaginal openings may act in concert to deliver spermatozoa to the oviduct, promoting fertilization.     

Morphometric dimensions of metacarpal bones in the population structure analysis (island of Krk, Croatia)

The population structure analysis by means of the osteometric dimensions of metacarpal bones in the population groups of the northern Adriatic island of Krk, Croatia was performed. The sample consisted of randomly sampled adult islanders (94 males and 79 females) aged from 18 to 85 years from six villages of the island of Krk. "Biological distances" were estimated by the Mahalanobis D2 analysis for bone length (L), total diaphysis width (T) and medullary canal width (M) dimensions of the second left metacarpal bone. Analysis of the osteometric dimensions of metacarpal bones as a measure of biological distance between population groups of the island of Krk indicated bio-cultural and socio-cultural events, rather than geographical distances, to be the primary determinants of anthropogenetic structure of today's population groups of the island.     

Confirmation of the sex difference in continuing subperiosteal apposition

A major sex difference in the rate of continuing bone expansion was confirmed for 5660 adult subjects of European ancestry. The five-decade gain in metacarpal midshaft area amounted to 8.4% in 3455 females and 2.8% in 2205 males. There was no systematic age effect on the length of the second metacarpal. Accordingly, both bone expansion and the marked sex difference in its magnitude may be attributed to sex-specific aspects of ageing much like the sex difference in endosteal surface loss.     

掌骨X线测量推断身高的研究

随机选取在校健康大学生186人(男90人, 女96人, 年龄18—27岁), 拍摄双手后前位372侧X线片, 测量身高和掌骨的长与宽。通过掌骨和身高的测量, 分析掌骨各参数与身高的关系, 为人类学和法医学的身高推断积累研究资料。掌骨长与身高的相关性明显高于掌骨宽, 其中男性第2掌骨长与身高相关性最高, 其线性回归方程为Ym=1097.320+9.337X; 女性第3掌骨长与身高的相关性最高, 其线性回归方程为Yf=1016.752+9.878X。男性第2掌骨长和女性第3掌骨长与身高的相关性最高, 可分别作为推断身高的依据。     

On the track of the bog people

The amount of radiographically detectable cortical bone, as determined by measurements of the second metacarpal, was evaluated in 42 male and 45 female Guamanian Chamorros and compared with the degree of bony demineralization in U.S. Caucasians participating in the Baltimore Longitudinal Study on Aging of the Gerontology Research Center. All Chamorros were individually matched to the Caucasian participants for age, sex, and menopause status. Chamorros of both sexes showed bilateral asymmetry in bone measurements and in the amount of cortical bone. Both Chamorro and Caucasian males had longer second metacarpals and more cortical bone than females. Caucasian males, however, had longer and larger second metacarpals than Chamorro males. Despite differences in the length and total width, Chamorro and Caucasian participants generally showed no significant differences in the amount of cortical bone or percent cortical area in the second metacarpal, suggesting that larger bones may not always indicate greater cortical mass. Although cross-sectional data suggested apparent age differences in the onset and rate of bone loss between Chamorros and Caucasians, the numbers of participants were too small to allow meaningful age-by-age statistical comparisons.     

Some geometric properties of the third metacarpal bone: a comparison between the thoroughbred and standardbred racehorse

Geometric properties of the third metacarpal bone were compared between the young and adult Standardbred and Thoroughbred racehorse. The change in shape during growth and superimposed training was dramatic in both breeds but the Thoroughbred showed the greatest difference in the minimum moment of inertia as the animal matured. Males had larger moments of inertia throughout the length of the diaphysis than did females. The differences in geometric properties of the third metacarpal bone between the Thoroughbred and Standardbred were related to the incidence of fatigue fractures which are common in the racing Thoroughbred but uncommon in the Standardbred racehorse.     

辽宁建平古人类肱骨形态结构分析

1957年,在辽宁省建平县发现了一根古人类肱骨化石,编号PA103。通过同一批龙骨中筛选的哺乳动物化石,吴汝康推断PA103应该为更新世晚期古人类,并对该化石进行了表面形态特征观察和描述。为了对PA103化石的内外结构进行更全面的了解,除了线性测量数据的对比,本文还通过计算机断层扫描技术,结合生物力学和形态示量图分析对建平古人类右侧肱骨化石PA103进行了分析。通过本研究发现,PA103骨干横断面的生物力学粗壮度和力学形状指数明显小于尼安德特人,而与同时期欧亚大陆古人类不利手侧最为接近,这说明建平人右侧肱骨可能不是惯用手,同时,建平人的行为活动应该与同时期同地区的古人类处于同一水平,而小于尼安德特人。整体来看,PA103骨干骨密质厚度和截面惯性矩与近现代人的分布模式较为接近,除局部数值增大外,其整体数值小于近现代人的平均水平,这可能与遗传或行为活动有关,由于缺少古人类化石对比数据,更详细的了解还需后期开展更多相关的研究。     

Hand osteoarthritis and bone loss: Is there an inverse relationship?

An inverse relationship between osteoarthritis (OA) and bone loss has been supported in clinical research, but there has been little research on bioarchaeological skeletal remains. The current study examines 115 adults from a prehistoric hunter–gatherer population to aid in determining whether hand OA and bone loss are negatively correlated. OA lipping is scored on a four-point scale on left and right trapezia, MC1s, and MC2s and then analyzed with regard to their relationships with sex, age, right MC2 cortical index, and left and right MC1 robusticity, midshaft circumference, and midshaft diameter values. With sexes and ages combined, higher OA scores are found in individuals with greater midshaft diameters. However, lower cortical indices were found in individuals with higher right MC2 OA scores. The data presented tenuously support that bone loss is lower in individuals with more severe osteoarthritis, but age-related changes in bone deposition may make cortical index and other external shaft dimensions an unsuitable variable to examine this relationship.     

Articular constraint, handedness, and directional asymmetry in the human second metacarpal

The hypothesis that functional adaptation of joint surfaces to mechanical loading occurs primarily through change in mass, density, and structure of subarticular trabeculae (the "articular constraint" model) is investigated through an analysis of directional asymmetry among three separate bone compartments in the human second metacarpal. Measures of midshaft cross-sectional geometry, osteometry of the distal epiphysis, and subarticular trabecular microarchitecture of the distal epiphysis (assessed by high-resolution microcomputed tomography) were determined for 29 paired male and female metacarpals from a well-preserved nineteenth-century Euro-Canadian historic cemetery sample. For each measure, asymmetry was quantified using both mean-difference and confidence-interval methods. Both methods found a significant right-hand bias for measures of structural strength in midshaft geometry, as has been previously noted for this sample. Articular size, however, exhibits a right-hand bias only with regard to mediolateral, and not dorsopalmar, dimensions, a result that may reflect directional asymmetry in hand breadth at the distal palmar arch. The most striking asymmetries occur for subarticular trabecular microarchitecture. The right metacarpal head exhibits greater bone volume fraction, bone surface density, trabecular number, connectivity, and a more platelike rather than rodlike structure. These outcomes confer greater resistance to both axial compressive and shear strains for the metacarpal head at the metacarpophalangeal arthrosis. In all, these results confirm and extend previous research documenting structural asymmetries and limb dominance and are consistent with the concept of articular constraint. They also suggest a morphological signal through which functional asymmetry associated with handedness in fossil hominins may be investigated.     

Bone mass increase in puberty: what makes it happen?

It is now thought that the critical property of bone is strength rather than weight, and that control of bone strength is mainly exercised through the effect of the mechanical loads brought to bear on bone. Muscle contraction places the greatest physiological load on bone, and so the strength of bone must be adapted to muscle strength (the functional muscle-bone unit). The Utah paradigm of skeletal physiology [J Hum Biol 1998;10:599-605] provides a model of bone development that describes how bone structure is regulated by local mechanical effects that can be adjusted by the effects of hormones. The DONALD (Dortmund Nutritional and Anthropometric Longitudinally Designed) study analysed the interaction between the muscle and bone systems in males and females before and during puberty. This study found that differences between the genders in bone adaptation during puberty are at least partly driven by the influence of oestrogen in females. Testosterone seems to have no direct relevant effect on bone during puberty, but may be implicated in the greater amount of muscle mass achieved in boys compared with girls.     

The Incidence of Double Hypoglossal Canal in Japanese: Evaluation with Multislice Computed Tomography

ResultsDouble hypoglossal canal was identified in 16.9% of the patients, and was bilateral in 2.2%. Double hypoglossal canal was significantly more frequent on the left side than right (P = 0.004, odds ratio = 1.79) and in males than females (P = 0.011, odds ratio = 1.67). A larger left or right-sided canal was found in 31.6% and 12.2% of the patients, respectively, following the same side preference as that of double hypoglossal canal. Almost perfect agreement was achieved between the two readers (k = 0.975).ConclusionsIn this Japanese population, the prevalence of a double hypoglossal canal was 16.9%, of which 2.2% were bilateral. Double hypoglossal canal was more frequent in males than females, and on the left side than right.     

A three‐dimensional analysis of bilateral directional asymmetry in the human clavicle

This study presents a novel three‐dimensional analysis using statistical atlases and automated measurements to assess diaphyseal morphology of the clavicle and its relationship to muscle asymmetry. A sample of 505 individuals (285 males, 220 females) from the William McCormick Clavicle Collection was CT scanned, segmented, and added to a statistical bone atlas that captures correspondence between homologous points on the bone surfaces. Muscle attachment sites were localized on the atlas and then propagated across the entire population. Cross‐sectional contours were extracted at 5% increments along the entire bone, as well as at muscle attachment sites and the clavicle waist; maximum and minimum dimensions of each cross‐sectional contour were calculated. In addition, the entire three‐dimensional surface was examined for asymmetry by analyzing the magnitude and directional differences between homologous points across all bone surfaces in the dataset. The results confirm the existing studies on clavicle asymmetry, namely that the left clavicle is longer than the right, but the right is more robust than the left. However, the patterns of asymmetry are sexually dimorphic. Males are significantly asymmetric in all dimensions and at muscle and ligament attachment sites (P < 0.05), whereas female asymmetry is more variable. We hypothesize that this is related to absolute and relative differences in male muscle strength compared to females. However, an area with no muscle attachments on the posterior midshaft was significantly asymmetric in both sexes. We suggest that this is a curvature difference caused by opposing muscle actions at the medial and lateral ends of the bone. Am J Phys Anthropol 2012. © 2012 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Three-point bending and acoustic emission study of adult rat femora after immobilization and free remobilization

The experiment concerned effects of immobilization and remobilization on mechanical properties of femoral shaft. Twenty-four weeks old male rats were used: two groups (I3 and I3R4) with the right hindlimb immobilized for 3 weeks by taping, and one control (C). In I3R4 immobilization was followed by 4 weeks of free remobilization. Mechanical properties in three-point bending, mass, geometry, and mineralization of bone tissue were measured post mortem in both femora in I3 and I3R4 and in right femora in control. Acoustic emission signals (AE) were recorded during the bending test. The right femora in I3, I3R4 and C did not differ significantly in size, mass and mineralization (ANOVA). The differences were significant considering mechanical parameters and AE signals. In I3 yield bending moment and stiffness were lower (p=0.013 and 0.025) and deflection was larger (p=0.030) than in C. In I3R4 maximum bending moment, yield moment, stiffness and work to failure were lower than in C (p=0.013, 0.009, 0.032, and 0.005). Paired t-test showed that remobilization resulted in worsening of properties of right femora. Side-to-side differences in I3R4 were more pronounced than in I3. Moreover, AE signals from the right femora were more numerous and burst type than from the left. The results demonstrate that strength of bone decreases during the first period of free remobilization. The decrease is accompanied by a significant decrease of bone toughness. The AE data support the hypothesis that immobilization-related degradation of bone mechanical properties is associated with increasing brittleness of cortical bone tissue.     

Bone mass in Guamanian patients with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis and parkinsonism-dementia

Bone mass, as assessed by measurements of total subperiosteal diameter and medullary width of the second metacarpal bone on hand-wrist radiographs, was evaluated for 31 Guamanian patients (15 males, 16 females) with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS), 67 patients (39 males, 28 females) with parkinsonism-dementia (PD), and 66 (34 males, 32 females) nonaffected Guamanian controls. Comparisons between the two disease groups and between each disease group and the nonaffected controls were made taking into account the sex, age, and disability status of each participant. At all ages, ALS patients of both sexes had significantly lower percent cortical areas (PCA) than did nonaffected controls. The ALS males also had significantly lower PCA than PD males, although no significant differences were observed between female ALS and PD patients. The PD patients of either sex had a lower PCA when compared to controls, but the differences were not statistically significant. The observed differences in PCA were due solely to increased medullary width, suggesting that the diminished cortical bone thickness resulted from greater bone resorption rather than differential bone growth. Longitudinal studies support the cross-sectional findings of accelerated bone loss among ALS patients. It is not possible to determine from the present data whether the observed differences in PCA of the second metacarpal of the ALS patients are due to atrophy of the first interosseous muscle, to a generalized resorption process inherently associated with the development and progression of ALS, or to factors not accounted for by the present analysis.