Structural studies of bacteriophage alpha3 assembly

Bacteriophage alpha3 is a member of the Microviridae, a family of small, single-stranded, icosahedral phages that include phiX174. These viruses have an ssDNA genome associated with approximately 12 copies of an H pilot protein and 60 copies of a small J DNA-binding protein. The surrounding capsid consists of 60 F coat proteins decorated with 12 pentameric spikes of G protein. Assembly proceeds via a 108S empty procapsid that requires the external D and internal B scaffolding proteins for its formation.The alpha3 "open" procapsid structural intermediate was determined to 15A resolution by cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM). Unlike the phiX174 "closed" procapsid and the infectious virion, the alpha3 open procapsid has 30A wide pores at the 3-fold vertices and 20A wide gaps between F pentamers as a result of the disordering of two helices in the F capsid protein. The large pores are probably used for DNA entry and internal scaffolding protein exit during DNA packaging. Portions of the B scaffolding protein are located at the 5-fold axes under the spike and in the hydrophobic pocket on the inner surface of the capsid. Protein B appears to have autoproteolytic activity that cleaves at an Arg-Phe motif and probably facilitates the removal of the protein through the 30A wide pores.The structure of the alpha3 mature virion was solved to 3.5A resolution by X-ray crystallography and was used to interpret the open procapsid cryo-EM structure. The main differences between the alpha3 and phiX174 virion structures are in the spike and the DNA-binding proteins. The alpha3 pentameric spikes have a rotation of 3.5 degrees compared to those of phiX174. The alpha3 DNA-binding protein, which is shorter by 13 amino acid residues at its amino end when compared to the phiX174 J protein, retains its carboxy-terminal-binding site on the internal surface of the capsid protein. The icosahedrally ordered structural component of the ssDNA appears to be substantially increased in alpha3 compared to phiX174, allowing the building of about 10% of the ribose-phosphate backbone.     

The Prohead-I structure of bacteriophage HK97: implications for scaffold-mediated control of particle assembly and maturation

Virus capsid assembly requires recruiting and organizing multiple copies of protein subunits to form a closed shell for genome packaging that leads to infectivity. Many viruses encode scaffolding proteins to shift the equilibrium toward particle formation by promoting intersubunit interactions and stabilizing assembly intermediates. Bacteriophage HK97 lacks an explicit scaffolding protein, but the capsid protein (gp5) contains a scaffold-like N-terminal segment termed the delta domain. When gp5 is expressed in Escherichia coli, the delta domain guides 420 copies of the subunit into a procapsid with T = 7 laevo icosahedral symmetry named Prohead-I. Prohead-I can be disassembled and reassembled under mild conditions and it cannot mature further. When the virally encoded protease (gp4) is coexpressed with gp5, it is incorporated into the capsid and digests the delta domain followed by autoproteolysis to produce the metastable Prohead-II. Prohead-I^+P was isolated by coexpressing gp5 and an inactive mutant of gp4. Prohead-I and Prohead-I^+P were compared by biochemical methods, revealing that the inactive protease stabilized the capsid against disassembly by chemical or physical stress. The crystal structure of Prohead-I^+P was determined at 5.2 Å resolution, and distortions were observed in the subunit tertiary structures similar to those observed previously in Prohead-II. Prohead-I^+P differed from Prohead-II due to the presence of the delta domain and the resulting repositioning of the N-arms, explaining why Prohead-I can be reversibly dissociated and cannot mature. Low-resolution X-ray data enhanced the density of the relatively dynamic delta domains, revealing their quaternary arrangement and suggesting how they drive proper assembly.     

In VITRO ASSEMBLY of the øX174 procapsid from external scaffolding protein oligomers and early pentameric assembly intermediates

Bacteriophage øX174 morphogenesis requires two scaffolding proteins: an internal species, similar to those employed in other viral systems, and an external species, which is more typically associated with satellite viruses. The current model of øX174 assembly is based on structural and in vivo data. During morphogenesis, 240 copies of the external scaffolding protein mediate the association of 12 pentameric particles into procapsids. The hypothesized pentameric intermediate, the 12S? particle, contains 16 proteins: 5 copies each of the coat, spike and internal scaffolding proteins and 1 copy of the DNA pilot protein. Assembly naïve 12S? particles and external scaffolding oligomers, most likely tetramers, formed procapsid-like particles in vitro, suggesting that the 12S? particle is a bona fide assembly intermediate and validating the current model of procapsid morphogenesis. The in vitro system required a crowding agent, was influenced by the ratio of the reactants and was most likely driven by hydrophobic forces. While the system reported here shared some characteristics with other in vitro internal scaffolding protein-mediated systems, it displayed unique features. These features most likely reflect external scaffolding protein-mediated morphogenesis and the øX174 procapsid structure, in which external scaffolding-scaffolding protein interactions, as opposed to coat-coat protein interactions between pentamers, constitute the primary lattice-forming contacts.     

Using cryoEM Reconstruction and Phase Extension to Determine Crystal Structure of Bacteriophage ϕ6 Major Capsid Protein

Bacteriophage ?6 is a double-stranded RNA virus that has been extensively studied as a model organism. Here we describe structure determination of ?6 major capsid protein P1. The protein crystallized in base centered orthorhombic space group C222₁. Matthews’s coefficient indicated that the crystals contain from four to seven P1 subunits in the crystallographic asymmetric unit. The self-rotation function had shown presence of fivefold axes of non-crystallographic symmetry in the crystals. Thus, electron density map corresponding to a P1 pentamer was excised from a previously determined cryoEM reconstruction of the ?6 procapsid at 7 Å resolution and used as a model for molecular replacement. The phases for reflections at higher than 7 Å resolution were obtained by phase extension employing the fivefold non-crystallographic symmetry present in the crystal. The averaged 3.6 Å-resolution electron density map was of sufficient quality to allow model building.     

Nucleotide sequence of the J gene and surrounding untranslated regions of phage G4 DNA: Comparison with phage φX174

A 290 nucleotide long region of the bacteriophage G4 genome including the end of the overlapping genes D and E, the entire gene J and the untranslated region between genes J and F has been sequenced and compared with the same region in bacteriophage φX174. Deletions, insertions, duplications and single base changes in G4 relative to φX174 have resulted in the following changes: the loss of the φX174 overlapping gene D termination and gene J initiation codons, resulting in their separation by 32 untranslated nucleotides; the deletion of one third of the gene J coding region, so that the G4 J protein is only 24 amino acids long compared with 37 amino acids in φX174; and the establishment of a longer untranslated region between G4 genes J and F, which despite many nucleotide changes retains the ability to form a stable hairpin loop in the same place and with the same geometry as in φX174. The G4 overlapping gene E is longer than in φX174 and extends beyond gene D. Sixteen nucleotides at the end of genes D and E in φX174 are duplicated in G4 before gene J.     

Physical measurements on the lipid-containing bacteriophage φ6

Bacteriophage φ6 has been studied by small-angle X-ray scattering, intensity-fluctuation spectroscopy, analytical ultracentrifugation, and spectroscopy. The sedimentation coefficient (s₂₀⁰, w) is 375 S, the diffusion coefficient (D₂₀⁰, w) is 2.66 · 10^?8 cm²/s. Using the Svedberg equation and an estimate of the partial specific volume, the M_r is 1.49 ± 0.32 · 10⁸.A simple model which describes φ6, is a central sphere consisting of RNA and protein of radius 330 Å and an outer shell of low electron density 40 Å thick. The RNA may form five concentric shells in the region $\text{r = 140?290}\text{A}\text{?}$     

Evolution of the three overlapping gene systems in G4 and phi X174.

Bacteriophage G4 has the same $\text{A}\text{B}$ and $\text{D}\text{E}$ overlapping gene systems as φX174 and together with the A and $\text{C}\text{K}$ overlapping gene system (Shaw et al., 1978), 7 of the 11 G4 and φX174 genes are involved in overlaps. The nucleotide differences between G4 and φX174 in the overlapping portions of the A, C and D genes are 23%, 27% and 21%, respectively, compared with 32%, 36% and 34% in the non-overlapping portions of the same genes. The amino acid differences between the G4 and φX174 overlapping B, K and E proteins, are 44%, 39% and 44%, respectively, compared with 28%, 26% and 16% in the regions of genes A, A and C, and D which contain genes B, K and E. These results suggest that the nucleotide sequences of overlapping genes evolve at almost the same rate as in non-overlapping genes, and that this is made possible by a lower amino acid sequence stringency of one of the pairs of proteins. The overlapping $\text{D}\text{E}$ and A and $\text{C}\text{K}$ gene systems may have originated by taking advantage of a high incidence of T nucleotides in the second codon position to produce a hydrophobic protein and the $\text{A}\text{B}$ gene system may have evolved by read-through of the A gene into the B gene. From the nucleotide sequences, other overlapping genes appear to be possible in these bacteriophages.     

The role of scaffolding proteins in the assembly of the small, single-stranded DNA virus phiX174.

An empty precursor particle called the procapsid is formed during assembly of the single-stranded DNA bacteriophage phiX174. Assembly of the phiX174 procapsid requires the presence of the two scaffolding proteins, D and B, which are structural components of the procapsid, but are not found in the mature virion. The X-ray crystallographic structure of a "closed" procapsid particle has been determined to 3.5 A resolution. This structure has an external scaffold made from 240 copies of protein D, 60 copies of the internally located B protein, and contains 60 copies of each of the viral structural proteins F and G, which comprise the shell and the 5-fold spikes, respectively. The F capsid protein has a similar conformation to that seen in the mature virion, and differs from the previously determined 25 A resolution electron microscopic reconstruction of the "open" procapsid, in which the F protein has a different conformation. The D scaffolding protein has a predominantly alpha-helical fold and displays remarkable conformational variability. We report here an improved and refined structure of the closed procapsid and describe in some detail the differences between the four independent D scaffolding proteins per icosahedral asymmetric unit, as well as their interaction with the F capsid protein. We re-analyze and correct the comparison of the closed procapsid with the previously determined cryo-electron microscopic image reconstruction of the open procapsid and discuss the major structural rearrangements that must occur during assembly. A model is proposed in which the D proteins direct the assembly process by sequential binding and conformational switching.     

Construction of viable and lethal mutations in the origin of bacteriophage 'phi' X174 using synthetic oligodeoxyribonucleotides

Six different synthetic deoxyhexadecamers complementary to the origin of bacteriophage φX174, corresponding to nucleotides 4299 to 4314, except for one preselected nucleotide change were used as primers for DNA synthesis on wild-type φX² DNA as a template. DNA synthesis was performed with Escherichia coli DNA polymerase I (Klenow fragment) in the presence of DNA ligase. Heteroduplex RFIV DNA was isolated and, after limited digestion with DNAase I, complementary strands containing the mutant primers were isolated. The biological activity of these complementary strands was assayed in spheroplasts. Spheroplasts were made from E. coli K58 ung^? (uracil N-glycosylase) to prevent degradation of the complementary strands caused by uracil incorporation (Baas et al., 1980a).Using (5′-³²P) end-labeled primers, it was shown that all tested DNA polymerase preparations, including phage T4 DNA polymerase, contained variable amounts of 5′ → 3′ exonuclease activity. This nick translation activity may result in removal of the mutation in the primers, and therefore in isolation of wild-type complementary DNA instead of mutant complementary DNA.Restriction enzyme analysis of completed RFIV DNA showed that the primers can initiate DNA synthesis at more than one place on the φX174 genome. These complications result in a mixed population of complementary strand DNAs synthesized in vitro. Nevertheless, the desired mutants were picked up with high frequency using a selection test that is based on the difference in ultraviolet light sensitivity of homoduplex and heteroduplex φX174 RF DNA. Heteroduplex φX174 RF DNA is two to three times more sensitive to ultraviolet light irradiation than is homoduplex φX174 RF DNA (Baas &; Jansz, 1971,1972). Phage DNA derived from single plaque lysates of two of the six mutant complementary strand DNA preparations yielded, after annealing with wild-type complementary strand DNA, heteroduplex DNA with high frequency. DNA sequence analysis in the origin region of RF DNA obtained from these two phage preparations revealed the presence of the expected mutation. RFI DNA of these two origin mutants was nicked by φX174 gene A protein in the same way as wild-type φX174 RFI DNA.Phage DNA derived from single plaque lysates of the other four mutant complementary strand DNA preparations yielded exclusively homoduplex DNA after annealing with wild-type complementary strand DNA. It is concluded that priming with these deoxyhexadecamers resulted in the synthesis of complementary φX174 DNA with lethal mutations. The implications of these results, the construction of two silent, viable φX174 origin mutants and the failure to detect four others, for the initiation mechanism of φX174 RF DNA replication are discussed.     

Identification of an interacting coat-external scaffolding protein domain required for both the initiation of phiX174 procapsid morphogenesis and the completion of DNA packaging

The phiX174 external scaffolding protein D mediates the assembly of coat protein pentamers into procapsids. There are four external scaffolding subunits per coat protein. Organized as pairs of asymmetric dimers, the arrangement is unrelated to quasi-equivalence. The external scaffolding protein contains seven alpha-helices. The protein's core, alpha-helices 2 to 6, mediates the vast majority of intra- and interdimer contacts and is strongly conserved in all Microviridae (canonical members are phiX174, G4, and alpha3) external scaffolding proteins. On the other hand, the primary sequences of the first alpha-helices have diverged. The results of previous studies with alpha3/phiX174 chimeric external scaffolding proteins suggest that alpha-helix 1 may act as a substrate specificity domain, mediating the initial coat scaffolding protein recognition in a species-specific manner. However, the low sequence conservation between the two phages impeded genetic analyses. In an effort to elucidate a more mechanistic model, chimeric external scaffolding proteins were constructed between the more closely related phages G4 and phiX174. The results of biochemical analyses indicate that the chimeric external scaffolding protein inhibits two morphogenetic steps: the initiation of procapsid formation and DNA packaging. phiX174 mutants that can efficiently utilize the chimeric protein were isolated and characterized. The substitutions appear to suppress both morphogenetic defects and are located in threefold-related coat protein sequences that most likely form the pores in the viral procapsid. These results identify coat-external scaffolding domains needed to initiate procapsid formation and provide more evidence, albeit indirect, that the pores are the site of DNA entry during the packaging reaction.     

The phiX174 protein J mediates DNA packaging and viral attachment to host cells

Packaging of viral genomes into their respective capsids requires partial neutralization of the highly negatively charged RNA or DNA. Many viruses, including the Microviridae bacteriophages phiX174, G4, and alpha3, have solved this problem by coding for a highly positively charged nucleic acid-binding protein that is packaged along with the genome. The phiX174 DNA-binding protein, J, is 13 amino acid residues longer than the alpha3 and G4 J proteins by virtue of an additional nucleic acid-binding domain at the amino terminus. Chimeric phiX174 particles containing the smaller DNA-binding protein cannot be generated due to procapsid instability during DNA packaging. However, chimeric alpha3 and G4 phages, containing the phiX174 DNA-binding protein in place of the endogenous J protein, assemble and are infectious, but are less dense than the respective wild-type species. In addition, host cell attachment and native gel migration assays indicate surface variations of these viruses that are controlled by the nature of the J protein. The structure of alpha3 packaged with phiX174 J protein was determined to 3.5A resolution and compared with the previously determined structures of phiX174 and alpha3. The structures of the capsid and spike proteins in the chimeric particle remain unchanged within experimental error when compared to the wild-type alpha3 virion proteins. The amino-terminal region of the phiX174 J protein, which is missing from wild-type alpha3 virions, is mostly disordered in the alpha3 chimera. The differences observed between solution properties of wild-type phiX174, wild-type alpha3, and alpha3 chimera, including their ability to attach to host cells, correlates with the degree of order in the amino-terminal domain of the J protein. When ordered, this domain binds to the interior of the viral capsid and, thus, might control the flexibility of the capsid. In addition, the properties of the phiX174 J protein in the chimera and the results of mutational analyses suggest that an evolutionary correlation may exist between the size of the J protein and the stoichiometry of the DNA pilot protein H, required in the initial stages of infection. Hence, the function of the J protein is to facilitate DNA packaging, as well as to mediate surface properties such as cell attachment and infection.     

A role for single-strand breaks in bacteriophage phi-X174 genetic recombination

Formation of genetic recombinants in bacteriophage φX174 is stimulated up to 50-fold in host cells carrying the recA⁺ allele by subjecting the virus particles to ultraviolet irradiation before infection, or by starving the host cell for thymine during infection; in recA host strains no such increases are observed.φX174 replicative form DNA molecules formed in vivo from ultraviolet-irradiated bacteriophage consist of an intact, circular full-length viral (+) strand and a partially complete complementary (?) strand extending from the point of origin of complementary strand DNA synthesis to an ultraviolet lesion. φX174 replicative form DNA molecules formed in thymine-deficient host strains during thymine starvation have nearly complete circular viral (+) and complementary (?) strands, which contain random single-strand nicks or gaps.Correlation of these structures with the observed increases in recombination suggests that single-strand “breaks” are aggressive intermediate structures in the formation of φX174 genetic recombinants mediated by the host recA⁺ gene product.     

Foreign and chimeric external scaffolding proteins as inhibitors of Microviridae morphogenesis

Viral assembly is an ideal system in which to investigate the transient recognition and interplay between proteins. During morphogenesis, scaffolding proteins temporarily associate with structural proteins, stimulating conformational changes that promote assembly and inhibit off-pathway reactions. Microviridae morphogenesis is dependent on two scaffolding proteins, an internal and an external species. The external scaffolding protein is the most conserved protein within the Microviridae, whose canonical members are phiX174, G4, and alpha3. However, despite 70% homology on the amino acid level, overexpression of a foreign Microviridae external scaffolding protein is a potent cross-species inhibitor of morphogenesis. Mutants that are resistant to the expression of a foreign scaffolding protein cannot be obtained via one mutational step. To define the requirements for and constraints on scaffolding protein interactions, chimeric external scaffolding proteins have been constructed and analyzed for effects on in vivo assembly. The results of these experiments suggest that at least two cross-species inhibitory domains exist within these proteins; one domain most likely blocks procapsid formation, and the other allows procapsid assembly but blocks DNA packaging. A mutation conferring resistance to the expression of a chimeric protein (chiD(r)) that inhibits DNA packaging was isolated. The mutation maps to gene A, which encodes a protein essential for packaging. The chiD(r) mutation confers resistance only to a chimeric D protein; the mutant is still inhibited by the expression of foreign D proteins. The results presented here demonstrate how closely related proteins could be developed into antiviral agents that specifically target virion morphogenesis.     

Activation and Inhibition of d-Arabinose Isomerase of Klebsiella aerogenes by l-Histidine

The spike G protein of bacteriophage φX174 was prepared as a hexa histidine-tagged G protein (HisG). In the enzyme-linked plate assay, HisG bound specifically to lipopolysaccharides (LPSs) of the φX174-sensitive strains, and did not bind to LPSs of the φX174-insensitive strains. The truncated G protein obtained after trypsin digestion of HisG had the similar affinity to the LPSs to HisG, indicating that eight amino acid residues from the N-terminus are not essential to the binding with the LPSs.     

Structures of the Procapsid and Mature Virion of Enterovirus 71 Strain 1095

Enterovirus 71 (EV71) is an important emerging human pathogen with a global distribution and presents a disease pattern resembling poliomyelitis with seasonal epidemics that include cases of severe neurological complications, such as acute flaccid paralysis. EV71 is a member of the Picornaviridae family, which consists of icosahedral, nonenveloped, single-stranded RNA viruses. Here we report structures derived from X-ray crystallography and cryoelectron microscopy (cryo-EM) for the 1095 strain of EV71, including a putative precursor in virus assembly, the procapsid, and the mature virus capsid. The cryo-EM map of the procapsid provides new structural information on portions of the capsid proteins VP0 and VP1 that are disordered in the higher-resolution crystal structures. Our structures solved from virus particles in solution are largely in agreement with those from prior X-ray crystallographic studies; however, we observe small but significant structural differences for the 1095 procapsid compared to a structure solved in a previous study (X. Wang, W. Peng, J. Ren, Z. Hu, J. Xu, Z. Lou, X. Li, W. Yin, X. Shen, C. Porta, T. S. Walter, G. Evans, D. Axford, R. Owen, D. J. Rowlands, J. Wang, D. I. Stuart, E. E. Fry, and Z. Rao, Nat. Struct. Mol. Biol. 19:424–429, 2012) for a different strain of EV71. For both EV71 strains, the procapsid is significantly larger in diameter than the mature capsid, unlike in any other picornavirus. Nonetheless, our results demonstrate that picornavirus capsid expansion is possible without RNA encapsidation and that picornavirus assembly may involve an inward radial collapse of the procapsid to yield the native virion.     

The Structure of Bacteriophage φCb5 Reveals a Role of the RNA Genome and Metal Ions in Particle Stability and Assembly

The structure of the Leviviridae bacteriophage φCb5 virus-like particle has been determined at 2.9 Å resolution and the structure of the native bacteriophage φCb5 at 3.6 Å. The structures of the coat protein shell appear to be identical, while differences are found in the organization of the density corresponding to the RNA. The capsid is built of coat protein dimers and in shape corresponds to a truncated icosahedron with T = 3 quasi-symmetry. The capsid is stabilized by four calcium ions per icosahedral asymmetric unit. One is located at the symmetry axis relating the quasi-3-fold related subunits and is part of an elaborate network of hydrogen bonds stabilizing the interface. The remaining calcium ions stabilize the contacts within the coat protein dimer. The stability of the φCb5 particles decreases when calcium ions are chelated with EDTA. In contrast to other leviviruses, φCb5 particles are destabilized in solution with elevated salt concentration. The model of the φCb5 capsid provides an explanation of the salt-induced destabilization of φCb5, since hydrogen bonds, salt bridges and calcium ions have important roles in the intersubunit interactions.Electron density of three putative RNA nucleotides per icosahedral asymmetric unit has been observed in the φCb5 structure. The nucleotides mediate contacts between the two subunits forming a dimer and a third subunit in another dimer. We suggest a model for φCb5 capsid assembly in which addition of coat protein dimers to the forming capsid is facilitated by interaction with the RNA genome. The φCb5 structure is the first example in the levivirus family that provides insight into the mechanism by which the genome-coat protein interaction may accelerate the capsid assembly and increase capsid stability.     

Electron microscopic determination of the preferential binding sites of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase to phi X174 replicative form DNA

Binding of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase to φX174 DNA replicative form (RF) has been studied by electron microscopy. Samples of the binary complexes were spread for observation upon polylysine-coated carbon films. Binding was obtained with both RFI and RFIII forms of the DNA; complexes formed with the former were treated with restriction enzyme PstI before spreading. A histogram constructed from the positions of 558 polymerase molecules bound to 181 DNA strands exhibited three prominent, sharp peaks at 3.3 × 10² nucleotides, 39.7 × 10² nucleotides and 49.0 × 10² nucleotides from the PstI cleavage point. These positions correspond closely to those of the D, A and B promoter sequences, as derived from φX174 DNA sequence data by Sanger et al. (1977).     

Bacteriophage P22 capsids with a subgenome length of packaged DNA

Bacteriophage P22 assembles a DNA-free procapsid that subsequently packages P22 DNA. To study the packaging of bacteriophage P22 DNA, attempts were made to isolate P22 capsids with a subgenome length of packaged DNA. With the use of cesium chloride buoyant density sedimentation and agarose gel electrophoresis, the following capsids with a subgenome length of packaged DNA were isolated and characterized: (i) a capsid with the solid-support-free electrophoretic mobility and radius of the DNA-free P22 procapsid; (ii) a capsid with the solid-support-free electrophoretic mobility and radius of the mature P22 bacteriophage; and (iii) a capsid with a solid-support-free electrophoretic mobility and possibly a radius intermediate to those of the procapsid and bacteriophage.