The effectiveness of mate guarding by male black-throated blue warblers

In many socially monogamous birds, males maintain close proximityto their mates during the fertile period. This is often consideredan effort on the male's part to prevent other males from copulatingwith his mate, but other functions have been suggested andthe effectiveness of males in preventing extrapair fertilizationshas come into question. Moreover, it is unclear whether mateguarding conflicts with other male activities, particularlythe pursuit of extrapair fertilizations. We examined mate guardingby male black-throated blue warblers (Dendroica caerulescens).Behavioral observations showed that males that guarded theirmates more closely were less likely to have extrapair youngin their nests. Moreover, the experimental detention of a malefor 1 h during the fertility risk period increased the probabilitythat a brood would contain extrapair young. Thus, male mate guarding was effective in reducing the risk of extrapair fertilization.Males with many opportunities for extrapair copulations appearedto guard their mates less and consequently had more extrapairyoung in their broods than males with few such opportunities.This suggests that mate guarding may conflict with the pursuitof extrapair fertilizations.     

Extrapair paternity, migration, and breeding synchrony in birds

To understand interspecific patterns in the strength of sexualselection, variation in the costs and benefits of exercisingmate choice needs to be evaluated. One manifestation of sexualselection in birds is the occurrence of greatly variable levelsof extrapair paternity (EPP). A proposed general explanationfor this variation is that the benefits to females in seekingextrapair copulations vary in a predictable manner accordingto the degree of breeding synchrony because females are betterable to assess potential extrapair partners when males are simultaneouslyin breeding condition. This hypothesis predicts a latitudinaltrend in EPP because birds tend to breed more synchronouslyaway from the equator. Expanding on previous geographicallyand taxonomically restricted tropical/temperate comparisons,we used phylogenetically independent standardized linear contraststo show that this positive relationship persists when all birdspecies for which EPP estimates currently exist are considered.However, if a third factor covaries with latitude in the sameway as breeding synchrony and EPP, this relationship need notbe causal. Migration could also account for latitudinal variationin the benefits to females of pursuing EPP, if migration isassociated with (1) hasty or (2) inaccurate mate choice, (3)facilitated assessment of male quality through the condition-dependenceof arrival time, or (4) increased genetic variance in male quality.We show that migration distance is positively related to theproportion of EPP and that migration can statistically explainthe latitudinal trend in EPP, even when confounding factorsare simultaneously controlled. Hence, alternative explanationsfor latitudinal variation in EPP may be feasible, and carefulintraspecific tests are needed to assess their relative importanceand their implications for geographical variation in life-historyevolution.     

Extrapair paternity and mate choice in a chickadee hybrid zone

The dynamics of hybrid zones are likely to be influenced greatlyby patterns of mate choice, including cryptic choice mediatedthrough extrapair copulations. To understand changes in hybridzones over time and space, a detailed examination of matingpatterns and correlates is needed. We studied the role of extrapairfertilizations (EPFs) in the breeding biology of hybridizingblack-capped and Carolina chickadees in southeastern Pennsylvaniaover 4 years, using microsatellite DNA markers. We detectedextrapair offspring (EPO) in 56% of 90 broods examined; theseaccounted for at least 26% of 477 offspring. Chickadees do notappear to use EPFs to reduce costs of heterospecific pairing:EPFs were no more likely to occur in genetically dissimilar(heterospecific) social pairs than in pairs where social mateswere genetically similar. However, females paired with black-capped–likemales were more likely to have EPO. Females that acquired EPFsdid not obtain these from males genetically similar to themselves;instead, all females, regardless of their genotype or that oftheir social mate, tended to prefer Carolina-like males as extrapairpartners. There was no relationship between the presence ofEPO and hatching or fledging success. High rates of extrapairpaternity and apparent female preference for Carolina-like malessuggest that mate choice is an important influence in ongoingnorthward movement of this hybrid zone.     

Tests of the mate-guarding hypothesis for social monogamy: male snapping shrimp prefer to associate with high-value females

Social monogamy without biparental care has evolved in manytaxa, and a number of hypotheses have been developed to explainthis phenomenon. Several authors have suggested the importanceof male mate-guarding behavior in the evolution of social monogamy,although empirical support for this hypothesis is lacking. Inthe caridean shrimp genus Alpheus, social monogamy may resultfrom selection on males for long-term guarding of females becausemating is temporally restricted to a short time after the female'smolt. I used Alpheus angulatus to test two predictions of theextended mate-guarding hypothesis: Males should (1) be physiologicallycapable of predicting the timing of female sexual receptivity,and (2) prefer to associate with (guard) females that are closerto sexual receptivity. Data from a Y-maze experiment testingfor distance chemical communication showed that males of A.angulatus were attracted to water treated by exposure to premoltfemales, repulsed by water treated by exposure to intermoltmales and females, and did not appear to respond in either directionto water treated by exposure to premolt males. In mate choiceexperiments, significantly more males paired with premolt femalesthan with postmolt females. These data suggest that males ofA. angulatus engage in precopulatory mate-guarding behavior.Other factors (population density, sex ratio) may have playeda role in the temporal extension of mate guarding to socialmonogamy.     

Manipulation of male quality in wild tits: effects on paternity loss

Extrapair paternity (EPP) has proved to be widespread and highlyvariable among birds and other taxa, including socially monogamousspecies. A multitude of hypotheses have been put forward toexplain this variation, but its occurrence is not fully understood.Male age, social dominance rank, song and breeding density orsynchrony have been among the suggested correlates of EPP, butresults so far are inconclusive. We interspecifically cross-fosteredblue tits (Parus caeruleus) and great tits (Parus major) inthe wild, thus manipulating males to exhibit reduced socialdominance rank, sing aberrant songs, and consequently be perceivedas low-quality males as compared to controls. This allowed usto test if male quality had an influence on loss of paternity.We found no statistically significant differences between cross-fosteredand control males of either species, neither with respect tolevels of cuckoldry nor proportions of extrapair young (EPY)in the broods. Paternity levels were comparable to other studieson the same species. No effect of density could be detectedon levels of EPP either, while an age effect seemed to be presentat least in the blue tit, EPY being almost absent in broodsof older blue tit males. We conclude that the effects of malequality on paternity loss are minor, if any, in these populations.     

Constrained mate choice in social monogamy and the stress of having an unattractive partner

In socially monogamous animals, mate choice is constrained by the availability of unpaired individuals in the local population. Here, we experimentally investigate the physiological stress endured by a female (the choosy sex) when pairing with a non-preferred social partner. In two experimental contexts, female Gouldian finches (Erythrura gouldiae) socially paired with poor-quality mates had levels of circulating corticosterone that were three to four times higher than those observed in females that were paired with preferred mates. The elevated level of this stress hormone in response to partner quality was observed within 12 h of the experimental introduction and maintained over a period of several weeks. Our findings demonstrate the extent of intra-individual conflict that occurs when individuals are forced to make mate-choice decisions that are not perfectly aligned with mate-choice preferences. The elevated level of corticosterone also suggests a mechanistic route through which females might adaptively manage their responses to intersexual conflict over reproductive investment.     

High fidelity on islands: a comparative study of extrapair paternity in passerine birds

It is commonly assumed that the intensity of sexual selectionis lower in island populations. Extrapair paternity (EPP) iswidespread within passerine birds and is indicative of sexualselection. A conservative analysis of the levels of EPP inisland and equivalent mainland populations of passerines revealsthat insular populations are indeed characterized by low levelsof EPP. This supports the idea that the intensity of sexualselection is lower on islands. This relationship has previouslybeen predicted, based on the assumption of low levels of geneticvariation for fitness in such populations. The evidence fromthis analysis suggests that this is just one of several nonmutuallyexclusive hypotheses that may explain the high fidelity ofisland-living females.     

Extrapair paternity in chestnut-sided warblers is correlated with consistent vocal performance

The elaborateness of many bird songs is commonly presumed tohave evolved under the influence of sexual selection by femalemate choice. Thus, aspects of acoustic diversity, such as songrepertoire size, are seen as likely targets of female choice.In many songbird species with song repertoires, however, therepertoires are small. In such species, female choice mightbe based on song features other than, or in addition to, songdiversity. To investigate this conjecture, I assessed singingand paternity in a population of chestnut-sided warblers (Dendroicapensylvanica), a species in which song repertoires are of modestsize. Twenty-two song traits were evaluated to determine whichones best predicted male extrapair reproductive success. Thecandidate traits encompassed measures of song diversity (e.g.,song repertoire size), gross-scale song performance (e.g., singingrate), and fine-scale song performance (e.g., variability amongsongs in a bout). Regression analysis revealed that the bestpredictor of extrapair success was singing with little variability.In particular, the most successful males sang with consistentpitch and timing, as well as high pitch. The greater extrapairsuccess of males with more consistent vocal performance maybe due to female preference for such performance, which couldbe an indicator of male quality.     

Do male paternity guards ensure female fidelity in a duetting fairy-wren?

Most socially monogamous bird species engage in extra-pair mating,and consequently males may adopt various behavioral strategiesto guard paternity. However, the relationship between mate guardingand extra-pair paternity is unclear: low levels of extra-pairpaternity can be associated either with no mate guarding orwith intense mate guarding. We investigate paternity guardsin the purple-crowned fairy-wren (Malurus coronatus), a duettingspecies where extra-pair paternity is rare. This species isunusual in a genus known for extremely high levels of extra-pairmating. We examine the behavioral interactions between the sexesunderlying these low rates of extra-pair paternity and showthat male purple-crowned fairy-wrens do not use frequent copulationor courtship feeding to assure paternity or guard females acousticallyby duetting. Males maintain close proximity to females bothwhen they are fertile and when they are not breeding and donot invest in courtship displays to extra-pair females. Consistentwith predictions of theoretical models, low extra-pair paternityin this species may be related to female fidelity rather thanmale paternity assurance strategies, but short-term removalof males would be necessary to test this experimentally.     

Sexual conflict and cooperation under naturally occurring male enforced monogamy

An evolutionary conflict often exists between the sexes in regard to female mating patterns. Females can benefit from polyandry, whereas males mating with polyandrous females lose reproductive opportunities because of sperm competition. Where this conflict occurs, the evolution of mechanisms whereby males can control female remating, often at a fitness cost to the female, are expected to evolve. The fitness cost to the female will be increased in systems where a few high status males monopolise mating opportunities and thus have limited sperm supplies. Here we show that in the cockroach Nauphoeta cinerea, a species where males enforce female monogamy in the first reproductive cycle, males that have become sperm depleted continue to be able to manipulate female remating behaviour. Although the manipulation severely decreases fecundity in females mated to sperm-depleted males, males benefit, increasing their relative fitness by preventing other males from reproducing. Our results suggest that there is selection on maintaining the mechanism of manipulation rather than maintaining sperm numbers. Taken with previous research on sexual conflict in N. cinerea, this study suggests that the causes and consequences of sexual conflict are complex and can change across the life history of an individual.     

Mate sampling and the sexual conflict over mating in seaweed flies

The order in which females encounter, or sample, males in apopulation may have important consequences for mate choice,with the information gathered about males influencing boththe preference function and degree of choosiness of females.Sexual selection may be affected as a result. Sampling of particularsubsets of males may be a crucial component of individual variation in mate preferences within populations. However, the sequencein which males are sampled may also be important in specieswithout traditional, active mate choice, such as when sexualselection involves sexual conflict over mating. This wouldoccur if the likelihood of a female mating with a male of acertain phenotype changes as a result of previous encounters.We examined the effects of encountering males differing inbody size, a sexually selected phenotype, in the seaweed flyCoelopa frigida. Sexual selection occurs in this species asa result of a sexual conflict over mating. We show that theoutcome of the sexual conflict is independent of the orderin which males are encountered by female seaweed flies, withthe overall mating advantage to large males being unaffected.In addition, we explored female preference functions and evaluatethe heterogeneity in female willingness to mate. We suggestthat consideration of mate sampling theory is valuable whenexamining mate choice in species in which sexual selectionis driven by sexual conflict.     

Sex-specific chemical cues from immatures facilitate the evolution of mate guarding in Heliconius butterflies

Competition for mates has substantial effects on sensory systems and often leads to the evolution of extraordinary mating behaviours in nature. The ability of males to find sexually immature females and associate with them until mating is a remarkable example. Although several aspects of such pre-copulatory mate guarding have been investigated, little is known about the mechanisms used by males to locate immature females and assess their maturity. These are not only key components of the origin and maintenance of this mating strategy, but are also necessary for inferring the level to which females cooperate and thus the incidence of sexual conflict. We investigated the cues involved in recognition of immature females in Heliconius charithonia, a butterfly that exhibits mate guarding by perching on pupae. We found that males recognized female pupae using sex-specific volatile monoterpenes produced by them towards the end of pupal development. Considering the presumed biosynthetic pathways of such compounds and the reproductive biology of Heliconius, we propose that these monoterpenes are coevolved signals and not just sex-specific cues exploited by males. Their maintenance, despite lack of female mate choice, may be explained by variation in cost that females pay with this male behaviour under heterogeneous ecological conditions.     

Extrapair paternity and the evolution of bird song

Bird song is usually considered to have evolved in the contextof sexual selection. Because extrapair paternity is a majorcomponent of sexual selection, mating advantages at the sociallevel for males that produce songs of high quality may be transformedinto higher success in extrapair paternity. Therefore, maleswith longer and more complex songs should suffer less from extrapairpaternity intraspecifically, whereas species with high ratesof extrapair paternity, reflecting intense sperm competition,should produce more elaborate songs. Although some intraspecificstudies demonstrated a negative link between features of songsand extrapair paternity in own nest, others failed to detectsuch a relationship. Contrary to expectation, a meta-analysisof all studies revealed no significant intraspecific evidencefor songs being associated with extrapair paternity. In addition,in comparative analyses based on generalized least squares (GLS)models, we found that no measures of song complexity and temporaloutput were significantly related to extrapair paternity interspecifically,even when potentially confounding factors such as social matingsystem, life history, migration, habitat, or sexual dichromatismwere held constant. Only plumage dichromatism was significantlyrelated to extrapair paternity. The absence of both intra- andinterspecific relationships between measures of song variabilityand extrapair paternity suggests that factors other than postmatingsexual selection have been the important evolutionary forcesshaping differences in song.     

Parallel divergence in mate guarding behaviour following colonization of a novel habitat

Ecological factors can have profound effects on mating system and mating behaviour. We investigated the effect of altered ecological conditions, following colonization of a novel habitat, on precopulatory mate guarding in a freshwater isopod (Asellus aquaticus). This isopod occurs in two different ecotypes, which coexist within several different lakes in Sweden but which utilize different habitats. These ecotypes have rapidly (ca. 40 generations) diverged in parallel among lakes in several phenotypic characters, presumably as a response to different predatory pressures. Here, we demonstrate that also mate guarding characteristics have diverged in parallel between the ecotypes in different lakes. This is one of the few studies reporting parallel evolution of mating behaviour. Furthermore, our results also indicate a potential sexual conflict, as the length of mate guarding appears to lower components of female fitness. We discuss how novel environments might have strong and rapid effects on mate guarding dynamics and mating behaviour.     

The unexpected but understandable dynamics of mating,paternity and paternal care in the ocellated wrasse

Although theory generally predicts that males should reduce paternal care in response to cues that predict increased sperm competition and decreased paternity, empirical patterns are equivocal. Some studies have found the predicted decrease in male care with increased sperm competition, while even more studies report no effect of paternity or sperm competition on male care. Here, we report the first example, to our knowledge, of paternal care increasing with the risk and intensity of sperm competition, in the ocellated wrasse (Symphodus ocellatus). Theory also predicts that if paternal care varies and is important to female fitness, female choice among males and male indicators traits of expected paternal care should evolve. Despite a non-random distribution of mating success among nests, we found no evidence for female choice among parental males. Finally, we document the highest published levels of extra-pair paternity for a species with exclusive and obligate male care: genetic paternity analyses revealed cuckoldry at 100 per cent of nests and 28 per cent of all offspring were not sired by the male caring for them. While not predicted by any existing theory, these unexpected reproductive patterns become understandable if we consider how male and female mating and parental care interact simultaneously in this and probably many other species.     

Female extrapair mate choice in a cooperative breeder: trading sex for help and increasing offspring heterozygosity

Sexual conflict between males and females over mating is common. Females that copulate with extrapair mates outside the pair-bond may gain (i) direct benefits such as resources or increased paternal care, (ii) indirect genetic benefits for their offspring, or (iii) insurance against infertility in their own social mate. Few studies have been able to demonstrate the different contexts in which females receive varying types of benefits from extrapair mates. Here, I examined sexual conflict, female extrapair mate choice, and patterns of extrapair paternity in the cooperatively breeding superb starling Lamprotornis superbus using microsatellite markers. Although extrapair paternity was lower than many other avian cooperative breeders (14% of offspring and 25% of nests), females exhibited two distinct mating patterns: half of the extrapair fertilizations were with males from inside the group, whereas half were with males from outside the group. Females with few potential helpers copulated with extrapair mates from within their group and thereby gained direct benefits in the form of additional helpers at the nest, whereas females paired to mates that were relatively less heterozygous than themselves copulated with extrapair mates from outside the group and thereby gained indirect genetic benefits in the form of increased offspring heterozygosity. Females did not appear to gain fertility insurance from copulating with extrapair mates. This is the first study to show that individuals from the same population mate with extrapair males and gain both direct and indirect benefits, but that they do so in different contexts.     

Extrapair paternity and the opportunity for sexual selection in a socially monogamous passerine

Effects of alternate mating strategies on the opportunity forsexual selection are widely debated, and recent studies haveconcluded that the effects of extrapair (EP) paternity on theopportunity for sexual selection may have been overstated dueto 1) methodological limitations of empirical studies and 2)the potential for males to gain from additional within-pair(WP) reproductive opportunities. We therefore examined the impactof EP paternity on the opportunity for sexual selection in thesocially monogamous and single-brooded eastern kingbird (Tyrannustyrannus). EP paternity was common in all 3 years of our study(61% of 89 broods, 47% of nestlings) and realized reproductivesuccess (EP + WP young) ranged from 0 to 9 young/male/year.A total of 31% of males lost all WP paternity (24% sired neitherWP nor EP young, whereas 7% sired EP but not WP young), andvariance in male realized reproductive success was more than9 times greater than that of apparent reproductive success.Nearly half of EP mates were not nearest neighbors, and manywere separated by 3 or more territories (>1000 m). EP successwas independent of nest defense behavior, but early singingmales and males with high song rates were most successful atboth a population level and when cuckolders and cuckoldees werecompared. EP paternity contributed significantly to the opportunityfor sexual selection in kingbirds, and we suggest that thisis probably due to the low potential for WP variation in reproductivesuccess, apparent long-distance movements of one or both sexes,and consequent absence of reciprocal cuckoldry.