Maize centromeres: where sequence meets epigenetics

The centromere is a highly organized structure mainly composed of repeat sequences, which make this region extremely difficult for sequencing and other analyses. It plays a conserved role in equal division of chromosomes into daughter cells in both mitosis and meiosis. However, centromere sequences show notable plasticity. In a dicentric chromosome, one of the centromeres can become inactivated with the underlying DNA unchanged. Furthermore, formerly inactive centromeres can regain activity under certain conditions. In addition, neocentromeres without centromeric repeats have been found in a wide spectrum of species. This evidence indicates that epigenetic mechanisms together with centromeric sequences are associated with centromere specification.     

Formation of novel CENP-A domains on tandem repetitive DNA and across chromosome breakpoints on human chromosome 8q21 neocentromeres

Endogenous human centromeres form on megabase-sized arrays of tandemly repeated alpha satellite DNA. Human neocentromeres form epigenetically at ectopic sites devoid of alpha satellite DNA and permit analysis of centromeric DNA and chromatin organization. In this study, we present molecular cytogenetic and CENP-A chromatin immunoprecipitation (ChIP) on CHIP analyses of two neocentromeres that have formed in chromosome band 8q21 each with a unique DNA and CENP-A chromatin configuration. The first neocentromere was found on a neodicentric chromosome 8 with an inactivated endogenous centromere, where the centromeric activity and CENP-A domain were repositioned to band 8q21 on a large tandemly repeated DNA. This is the first example of a neocentromere forming on repetitive DNA, as all other mapped neocentromeres have formed on single copy DNA. Quantitative fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) analysis showed a 60% reduction in the alpha satellite array size at the inactive centromere compared to the active centromere on the normal chromosome 8. This neodicentric chromosome may provide insight into centromere inactivation and the role of tandem DNA in centromere structure. The second neocentromere was found on a neocentric ring chromosome that contained the 8q21 tandemly repeated DNA, although the neocentromere was localized to a different genomic region. Interestingly, this neocentromere is composed of two distinct CENP-A domains in bands 8q21 and 8q24, which are brought into closer proximity on the ring chromosome. This neocentromere suggests that chromosomal rearrangement and DNA breakage may be involved in neocentromere formation. These novel examples provide insight into the formation and structure of human neocentromeres.     

Four distinct alpha satellite subfamilies shared by human chromosomes 13, 14 and 21.

We describe the characterisation of four alpha satellite sequences which are found on a subset of the human acrocentric chromosomes. Direct sequence study, and analysis of somatic cell hybrids carrying specific human chromosomes indicate a unique 'higher-order structure' for each of the four sequences, suggesting that they belong to different subfamilies of alpha DNA. Under very high stringency of Southern hybridisation conditions, all four subfamilies were detected on chromosomes 13, 14 and 21, with 13 and 21 showing a slightly greater sequence homology in comparison to chromosome 14. None of these subfamilies were detected on chromosomes 15 and 22. In addition, we report preliminary evidence for a new alphoid subfamily that is specific for human chromosome 14. These results, together with those of earlier published work, indicate that the centromeres of the five acrocentric chromosomes are characterised by a number of clearly defined alphoid subfamilies or microdomains (with at least 5, 7, 3, 5 and 2 different ones on chromosomes 13, 14, 15, 21 and 22, respectively). These microdomains must impose a relatively stringent subregional pairing of the centromeres of two homologous chromosomes. The different alphoid subfamilies reported should serve as useful markers to allow further 'dissection' of the structure of the human centromere as well as the investigation of how the different nonhomologous chromosomes may interact in the aetiology of aberrations involving these chromosomes.     

Structure of the major block of alphoid satellite DNA on the human Y chromosome

Alphoid DNA is a family of tandemly repeated simple sequences found mainly at the centromeres of the chromosomes of many primates. This paper describes the structure of the alphoid DNA at the centromere of the human Y chromosome. We have used pulsedfield gradient gel electrophoresis, cosmid cloning and DNA sequencing to determine the organization of the alphoid DNA on each of the Y chromosomes present in two somatic cell hybrids. In each case there is a single major block of alphoid DNA. This is approximately 470,000 bases (475 kb) long on one chromosome and approximately 575 kb long on the other. Apart from the size difference, the structures of the two blocks and the surrounding sequences are very similar. However, one restriction enzyme, AvaII, detects two clusters of sites within one block but does not cleave the other. The alphoid DNA within each block is organized into tandemly repeating units, most of which are about 5.7 kb long. A few variant units present on one chromosome are about 6.0 kb long. These variants, like the AvaII site variants, are clustered. The 5.7 kb and 6.0 kb units themselves consist of tandemly repeating 170 base-pair subunits. The 6.0 kb unit has two more of these subunits than the 5.7 kb unit. Our results provide a basis for further structural analysis of the human Y chromosome centromeric region, and suggest that long-range structural polymorphisms of tandemly repeated sequence families may be frequent.     

Centromeric inactivation in a dicentric human Y;21 translocation chromosome

A de novo dicentric Y;21 (q11.23;p11) translocation chromosome with one of its two centromeres inactive has provided the opportunity to study the relationship between centromeric inactivation, the organization of alphoid satellite DNA and the distribution of CENP-C. The proband, a male with minor features of Down’s syndrome, had a major cell line with 45 chromosomes including a single copy of the translocation chromosome, and a minor one with 46 chromosomes including two copies of the translocation chromosome and hence effectively trisomic for the long arm of chromosome 21. Centromeric activity as defined by the primary constriction was variable: in most cells with a single copy of the Y;21 chromosome, the Y centromere was inactive. In the cells with two copies, one copy had an active Y centromere (chromosome 21 centromere inactive) and the other had an inactive Y centromere (chromosome 21 centromere active). Three different partial deletions of the Y alphoid array were found in skin fibroblasts and one of these was also present in blood. Clones of single cell origin from fibroblast cultures were analysed both for their primary constriction and to characterise their alphoid array. The results indicate that (1) each clone showed a fixed pattern of centromeric activity; (2) the alphoid array size was stable within a clone; and (3) inactivation of the Y centromere was associated with both full-sized and deleted alphoid arrays. Selected clones were analysed with antibodies to CENP-C, and staining was undetectable at both intact and deleted arrays of the inactive Y centromeres. Thus centromeric inactivation appears to be largely an epigenetic event. Received: 30 January 1997; in revised form: 3 April 1997 / Accepted: 8 May 1997     

Evolutionary relationships of multiple alpha satellite subfamilies in the centromeres of human chromosomes 13, 14, and 21

Summary Using Southern and in situ hybridization analyses, we have earlier defined four different subfamilies of alpha satellite DNA (designated pTRA-1, -2, -4, and -7), each of which has a unique higher order structure represented almost identically on human chromosomes 13, 14, and 21. Here we present the complete sequence of single isolates of these four subfamilies, representing approximately 12 kb of sequence information. Sequences of the individual 171-bp monomers that constitute these four subfamilies (and a fifth subfamily, Alpha-R1, that is known to be present on chromosomes 13 and 21) were compared both within and between the different clones. The results indicate that, at the level of their primary sequence, the five alpha subfamilies are characterized by structures that are as unrelated to each other as the different alpha subfamilies from other chromosomes. However, sequence comparisons between monomers of these clones indicate the possibility that pTRA-2, -4, and-1 may have arisen, at least in part, from a common ancestral alphoid sequence. We also provide evidence that exchange of pTRA-1 between nonhomologous centromeres and its homogenization throughout the population, perhaps by unequal exchange mechanisms, could have occurred after the divergence of humans and chimpanzees. The evolution of multiple alphoid subfamilies within a single centromere suggests that unequal exchange mechanisms may be restricted to specific domains. This may in turn contribute to some requirement for subregional pairing of sequences along the length of the centromeres of these chromosomes. Offprint requests to: K.H.A. Choo     

Repeatless and Repeat-Based Centromeres in Potato: Implications for Centromere Evolution

Centromeres in most higher eukaryotes are composed of long arrays of satellite repeats. By contrast, most newly formed centromeres (neocentromeres) do not contain satellite repeats and instead include DNA sequences representative of the genome. An unknown question in centromere evolution is how satellite repeat-based centromeres evolve from neocentromeres. We conducted a genome-wide characterization of sequences associated with CENH3 nucleosomes in potato (Solanum tuberosum). Five potato centromeres (Cen4, Cen6, Cen10, Cen11, and Cen12) consisted primarily of single- or low-copy DNA sequences. No satellite repeats were identified in these five centromeres. At least one transcribed gene was associated with CENH3 nucleosomes. Thus, these five centromeres structurally resemble neocentromeres. By contrast, six potato centromeres (Cen1, Cen2, Cen3, Cen5, Cen7, and Cen8) contained megabase-sized satellite repeat arrays that are unique to individual centromeres. The satellite repeat arrays likely span the entire functional cores of these six centromeres. At least four of the centromeric repeats were amplified from retrotransposon-related sequences and were not detected in Solanum species closely related to potato. The presence of two distinct types of centromeres, coupled with the boom-and-bust cycles of centromeric satellite repeats in Solanum species, suggests that repeat-based centromeres can rapidly evolve from neocentromeres by de novo amplification and insertion of satellite repeats in the CENH3 domains.     

CENP-G: a new centromeric protein that is associated with the α-1 satellite DNA subfamily

A new constitutive centromere-specific protein (CENP) has been identified as a result of its recognition as an autoantigen by serum from a patient with gastric antral vascular ectasia disease. Conventional immunoblotting and two-dimensional double blotting with both this antiserum and a known anti-centromere antiserum showed that this antiserum predominantly recognized a M _r 95,000 protein that is different from all known CENPs. We have named this new protein CENP-G. This protein was detected at the centromeric region throughout the cell cycle. In mitosis, it was restricted to the kinetochore inner plate as shown by immunogold labeling and electron microscopy. The centromeres of some human chromosomes are known to contain two subfamilies of α-satellite DNA. Using immunofluorescence combined with fluorescent in situ hybridization with subfamily-specific DNA probes, we revealed that CENP-G was specifically associated with one of the subfamilies, which we have named α-1, but not the other. The localization and the α-1-specific association suggested that CENP-G may play a role in kinetochore organization and function. Like CENP-B and C, but unlike CENP-A, this protein remained with the nuclear matrix after intensive extraction. While CENP-B is absent from the human Y chromosome, the existence of CENP-G on the Y chromosome has been proven by immunofluorescence and whole chromosome painting. CENP-G was also detected in CHO, Indian muntjac and Chinese muntjac cells, suggesting that it is conserved in evolution. Received: 23 March 1998 / Accepted: 2 April 1998     

Chromosome-specific subfamilies within human alphoid repetitive DNA

Nucleotide sequence data of about 20 X 10(3) base-pairs of the human tandemly repeated alphoid DNA are presented. The DNA sequences were determined from 45 clones containing EcoRI fragments of alphoid DNA isolated from total genomic DNA. Thirty of the clones contained a complete 340 base-pair dimer unit of the repeat. The remaining clones contained alphoid DNA with fragment lengths of 311, 296, 232, 170 and 108 base-pairs. The sequences obtained were compared with an average alphoid DNA sequence determined by Wu & Manuelidis (1980). The divergences ranged from 0.6 to 24.6% nucleotide changes for the first monomer and from 0 to 17.8% for the second monomer of the repeat. On the basis of identical nucleotide changes at corresponding positions, the individual repeat units could be shown to belong to one of several distinct subfamilies. The number of nucleotide changes defining a subfamily generally constitutes the majority of nucleotide changes found in a member of that subfamily. From an evaluation of the proportion of the total amount of alphoid DNA, which is represented by the clones studied, it is estimated that the number of subfamilies of this repeat may be equal to or exceed the number of chromosomes. The expected presence of only one or a few distinct subfamilies on individual chromosomes is supported by the study, also presented, of the nucleotide sequence of 17 cloned fragments of alphoid repetitive DNA from chromosome 7. These chromosome-specific repeats all contain the characteristic pattern of 36 common nucleotide changes that defines one of the subfamilies described. A unique restriction endonuclease (NlaIII) cleavage site present in this subfamily may be useful as a genetic marker of this chromosome. A family member of the interspersed Alu repetitive DNA was also isolated and sequenced. This Alu repeat has been inserted into the human alphoid repetitive DNA, in the same way as the insertion of an Alu repeat into the African green monkey alphoid DNA.     

CENP-B box is required for de novo centromere chromatin assembly on human alphoid DNA

Centromere protein (CENP) B boxes, recognition sequences of CENP-B, appear at regular intervals in human centromeric alpha-satellite DNA (alphoid DNA). In this study, to determine whether information carried by the primary sequence of alphoid DNA is involved in assembly of functional human centromeres, we created four kinds of synthetic repetitive sequences: modified alphoid DNA with point mutations in all CENP-B boxes, resulting in loss of all CENP-B binding activity; unmodified alphoid DNA containing functional CENP-B boxes; and nonalphoid repetitive DNA sequences with or without functional CENP-B boxes. These four synthetic repetitive DNAs were introduced into cultured human cells (HT1080), and de novo centromere assembly was assessed using the mammalian artificial chromosome (MAC) formation assay. We found that both the CENP-B box and the alphoid DNA sequence are required for de novo MAC formation and assembly of functional centromere components such as CENP-A, CENP-C, and CENP-E. Using the chromatin immunoprecipitation assay, we found that direct assembly of CENP-A and CENP-B in cells with synthetic alphoid DNA required functional CENP-B boxes. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first reported evidence of a functional molecular link between a centromere-specific DNA sequence and centromeric chromatin assembly in humans.     

Centromeres: long intergenic spaces with adaptive features

Centromeres are composed of inner kinetochore proteins, which are largely conserved across species, and repetitive DNA, which shows comparatively little sequence conservation. Due to this fundamental paradox the formation and maintenance of centromeres remains largely a mystery. However, it has become increasingly clear that a long-standing balance between epigenetic and genetic control governs the interactions of centromeric DNA and inner kinetochore proteins. The comparison of classical neocentromeres in plants, which are entirely genetic in their mode of operation, and clinical neocentromeres, which are sequence-independent, illustrates the conflict between genetics and epigenetics in regions that control their own transmission to progeny. Tandem repeat arrays present in centromeres may have an origin in meiotic drive or other selfish patterns of evolution, as is the case for the CENP-B box and CENP-B protein in human. In grasses retrotransposons have invaded centromeres to the point of complete domination, consequently breaking genetic regulation at these centromeres. The accumulation of tandem repeats and transposons causes centromeres to expand in size, effectively pushing genes to the sides and opening the centromere to ever fewer constraints on the DNA sequence. On genetic maps centromeres appear as long intergenic spaces that evolve rapidly and apparently without regard to host fitness.     

Definition of a second dimeric subfamily of human alpha satellite DNA

We describe a new human subfamily of alpha satellite DNA. The restriction endonuclease XbaI cleaves this subfamily into a collection of fragments which are heterogeneous with respect to size. We compared the sequences of 6 clones from four different XbaI size classes. Clones from a single size class were not necessarily more related than clones from different classes. Clones from different size classes were found to produce almost identical hybridization patterns with XbaI-digested human genomic DNA. All clones were found to share a common dimeric repeat organization, with dimers exhibiting about 84% sequence identities, indicating that the clones evolved from a common progenitor alphoid dimer. We show that this subfamily, and the EcoRI dimer subfamily originally described by Wu and Manuelidis, evolved from different progenitor alphoid dimers, and therefore represent distinct human alphoid subfamilies.     

Concerted evolution of alpha satellite DNA: Evidence for species specificity and a general lack of sequence conservation among alphoid sequences of higher primates

We investigated relationships among alpha satellite DNA families in the human, gorilla, chimpanzee, and orangutan genomes by filter hybridization with cloned probes which correspond to chromosome-specific alpha satellite DNAs from at least 12 different human chromosomes. These include representatives of both the dimer-based and pentamer-based subfamilies, the two major subfamilies of human alpha satellite. In addition, we evaluated several high-copy dimer-based probes isolated from gorilla genomic DNA. Under low stringency conditions, all human probes tested hybridized extensively with gorilla and chimpanzee alpha satellite sequences. However, only pentameric and other non-dimeric human alphoid probes hybridized with orangutan alpha satellite sequences; probes belonging to the dimer subfamily did not cross-hybridize detectably with orangutan DNA. Moreover, under high stringency conditions, each of the human probes hybridized extensively only with human genomic DNA; none of the probes cross-hybridized effectively with other primate DNAs. Dimer-based gorilla alpha satellite probes hybridized with human and chimpanzee, but not orangutan, sequences under low stringency hybridization conditions, yet were specific for gorilla DNA under high stringency conditions. These results indicate that the alpha satellite DNA family has evolved in a concerted manner, such that considerable sequence divergence is now evident among the alphoid sequences of closely related primate species.     

Different subfamilies of alphoid repetitive DNA are present on the human and chimpanzee homologous chromosomes 21 and 22.

The alphoid repeat DNA on chimpanzee chromosome 22 was compared with alphoid repeat DNA on its human homologue, chromosome 21. Hybridization of different alphoid probes under various conditions of stringency show that the alphoid repeats of chimpanzee chromosome 22 are not closely related to those of human chromosome 21. Sequence analysis of cloned dimer and tetramer EcoRI fragments from chimpanzee chromosome 22 confirm the low overall level of homology, but reveal the presence of several nucleotide changes which are exclusive to the chromosome 21 subfamily of human alphoid DNA. Southern blot analysis of alphoid repeat DNA on the chimpanzee X chromosome suggests this subfamily has been strongly conserved during and since the separation of chimpanzee and man although the two subfamilies can be distinguished on the basis of Taq I restriction fragments.     

Study of alpha-satellite DNA in cosmid libraries, specific for chromosomes 13, 21, and 22, using fluorescence in situ hybridization

Fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) was employed in mapping the alpha-satellite DNA that was revealed in the cosmid libraries specific for human chromosomes 13, 21, and 22. In total, 131 clones were revealed. They contained various elements of centromeric alphoid DNA sequences of acrocentric chromosomes, including those located close to SINEs, LINEs, and classical satellite sequences. The heterochromatin of acrocentric chromosomes was shown to contain two different groups of alphoid sequences: (1) those immediately adjacent to the centromeric regions (alpha 13-1, alpha 21-1, and alpha 22-1 loci) and (2) those located in the short arm of acrocentric chromosomes (alpha 13-2, alpha 21-2, and alpha 22-2 loci). Alphoid DNA sequences from the alpha 13-2, alpha 21-2, and alpha 22-2 loci are apparently not involved in the formation of centromeres and are absent from mitotically stable marker chromosomes with a deleted short arm. Robertsonian translocations t(13q; 21q) and t(14q; 22q), and chromosome 21p-. The heterochromatic regions of chromosomes 13, 21, and 22 were also shown to contain relatively chromosome-specific repetitive sequences of various alphoid DNA families, whose numerous copies occur in other chromosomes. Pools of centromeric alphoid cosmids can be of use in further studies of the structural and functional properties of heterochromatic DNA and the identification of centromeric sequences. Moreover, these clones can be employed in high-resolution mapping and in sequencing the heterochromatic regions of the human genome. The detailed FISH analysis of numerous alphoid cosmid clones allowed the identification of several new, highly specific DNA probes of molecular cytogenetic studies--in particular, the interphase and metaphase analyses of chromosomes 2, 9, 11, 14, 15, 16, 18, 20, 21-13, 22-14, and X.     

CENP-B interacts with CENP-C domains containing Mif2 regions responsible for centromere localization

Recently, human artificial chromosomes featuring functional centromeres have been generated efficiently from naked synthetic alphoid DNA containing CENP-B boxes as a de novo mechanism in a human cultured cell line, but not from the synthetic alphoid DNA only containing mutations within CENP-B boxes, indicating that CENP-B has some functions in assembling centromere/kinetochore components on alphoid DNA. To investigate whether any interactions exist between CENP-B and the other centromere proteins, we screened a cDNA library by yeast two-hybrid analysis. An interaction between CENP-B and CENP-C was detected, and the CENP-C domains required were determined to overlap with three Mif2 homologous regions, which were also revealed to be involved in the CENP-C assembly of centromeres by expression of truncated polypeptides in cultured cells. Overproduction of truncated CENP-B containing no CENP-C interaction domains caused abnormal duplication of CENP-C domains at G2 and cell cycle delay at metaphase. These results suggest that the interaction between CENP-B and CENP-C may be involved in the correct assembly of CENP-C on alphoid DNA. In other words, a possible molecular linkage may exist between one of the kinetochore components and human centromere DNA through CENP-B/CENP-B box interaction.     

Evidence for an ancestral alphoid domain on the long arm of human chromosome 2

Summary In situ hybridization, under low stringency conditions with two alphoid DNA probes (pY1 and p82H) labeled with digoxigenin-dUTP, decorated all the centromeres of the human karyotype. However, signals were also detected on the long arm of chromosome 2 at approximately q21.3–q22.1. Since it is supposed that human chromosome 2 originated by the telomeric fusion of two ancestral primate chromosomes, these findings indicate that not only the telomeric sequences, but also the ancestral centromere (or at least its alphoid sequences), have been conserved.     

Molecular cytogenetic analysis of eight inversion duplications of human chromosome 13q that each contain a neocentromere

Neocentromeres are fully functional centromeres that have arisen in previously noncentromeric chromosomal locations on rearranged chromosomes. The formation of neocentromeres results in the mitotic stability of chromosomal fragments that do not contain endogenous centromeres and that would normally be lost. Here we describe a unique collection of eight independent patient-derived cell lines, each of which contains a neocentromere on a supernumerary inversion duplication of a portion of human chromosome 13q. Findings in these patients reveal insight into the clinical manifestations associated with polysomy for portions of chromosome 13q. The results of FISH and immunofluorescent analysis of the neocentromeres in these chromosomes confirm the lack of alpha-satellite DNA and the presence of CENtromere proteins (CENP)-C, -E, and hMAD2. The positions of the inversion breakpoints in these chromosomes have been placed onto the physical map of chromosome 13, by means of FISH mapping with cosmid probes. These cell lines define, within chromosome 13q, at least three distinct locations where neocentromeres have formed, with five independent neocentromeres in band 13q32, two in band 13q21, and one in band 13q31. The results of examination of the set of 40 neocentromere-containing chromosomes that have thus far been described, including the 8 neocentromere-containing chromosomes from chromosome 13q that are described in the present study, suggest that chromosome 13q has an increased propensity for neocentromere formation, relative to some other human chromosomes. These neocentromeres will provide the means for testing hypotheses about sequence requirements for human centromere formation.     

Cloning of human centromeres by transformation-associated recombination in yeast and generation of functional human artificial chromosomes

Human centromeres remain poorly characterized regions of the human genome despite their importance for the maintenance of chromosomes. In part this is due to the difficulty of cloning of highly repetitive DNA fragments and distinguishing chromosome-specific clones in a genomic library. In this work we report the highly selective isolation of human centromeric DNA using transformation-associated recombination (TAR) cloning. A TAR vector with alphoid DNA monomers as targeting sequences was used to isolate large centromeric regions of human chromosomes 2, 5, 8, 11, 15, 19, 21 and 22 from human cells as well as monochromosomal hybrid cells. The alphoid DNA array was also isolated from the 12 Mb human mini-chromosome ΔYq74 that contained the minimum amount of alphoid DNA required for proper chromosome segregation. Preliminary results of the structural analyses of different centromeres are reported in this paper. The ability of the cloned human centromeric regions to support human artificial chromosome (HAC) formation was assessed by transfection into human HT1080 cells. Centromeric clones from ΔYq74 did not support the formation of HACs, indicating that the requirements for the existence of a functional centromere on an endogenous chromosome and those for forming a de novo centromere may be distinct. A construct with an alphoid DNA array from chromosome 22 with no detectable CENP-B motifs formed mitotically stable HACs in the absence of drug selection without detectable acquisition of host DNAs. In summary, our results demonstrated that TAR cloning is a useful tool for investigating human centromere organization and the structural requirements for formation of HAC vectors that might have a potential for therapeutic applications.