Immune response to Moloney murine leukemia virus nonviral, tumor-associated antigens fails to provide in vivo tumor protection.

Two distinct populations of CTL have previously been shown to be generated in lymphocyte cultures derived from the spleens of C57BL/6 mice that have rejected Moloney murine leukemia virus:Moloney sarcoma virus (MoMuLV:MSV)-induced tumors. One population is specific for MoMuLV viral Ag whereas the other appears to be directed against a nonviral, tumor-associated Ag (TAA). Using a virus-negative variant of the MoMuLV-induced lymphoma MBL-2 that has retained the expression of the MuLV:TAA, we attempted to further characterize the MuLV:TAA-specific CTL population. First, this same pattern of CTL reactivity was observed using a variety of immunization protocols indicating that the TAA-specific CTL population was not an artifact of the original immunization protocol but was a reproducible component of the MoMuLV CTL response. Moreover, CTL precursor frequency analysis indicates that the MuLV:TAA-specific CTL represent approximately 60% of the CTL detected in in vitro cytotoxicity assays. However, when the role of MuLV:TAA CTL in the in vivo rejection of MoMuLV-induced tumors was examined, no role for the MuLV:TAA-specific CTL response could be determined. Immunization protocols that had been shown to give rise to both CTL populations were capable of protecting mice from tumor development after a challenge with the parental MBL-2 tumor cell line but not the virus-negative variant MBLv cell line. In addition, immunization with the variant, shown to give rise to only MuLV:TAA-specific CTL capable of lysing both MBL-2 and MBLv in vitro, failed to protect mice from a tumor challenge of either cell type.     

Identification of a novel tumor-specific CTL epitope presented by RMA, EL-4, and MBL-2 lymphomas reveals their common origin

C57BL/6 mice generate a vigorous H-2Db-restricted CTL response against murine leukemia virus (MuLV)-induced tumors. For many years it has been suggested that this response is directed to an MuLV-encoded peptide as well as to a nonviral tumor-associated peptide. Recently, a peptide from the leader sequence of gag was demonstrated to be the MuLV-derived epitope. Here we describe the molecular identification of the tumor-associated epitope. Furthermore, we show that the CTL response against this epitope can restrict the outgrowth of MuLV-induced tumors in vivo. The epitope is selectively presented by the MuLV-induced T cell tumors RBL-5, RMA, and MBL-2 as well as by the chemically induced T cell lymphoma EL-4. Intriguingly, these tumors share expression of the newly identified epitope because they represent variants of the same clonal tumor cell line, as evident from sequencing of the TCR alpha- and beta-chains, which proved to be identical. Our research shows that all sources of RBL-5, RMA, RMA-S, MBL-2, and EL-4 tumors are derived from a single tumor line, most likely EL-4.     

Identification of a gag-encoded cytotoxic T-lymphocyte epitope from FBL-3 leukemia shared by Friend, Moloney, and Rauscher murine leukemia virus-induced tumors.

FBL-3 is a highly immunogenic murine leukemia of C57BL/6 origin induced by Friend murine leukemia virus (MuLV). Immunization of C57BL/6 mice with FBL-3 readily elicits CD8+ cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) capable of lysing FBL-3 as well as syngeneic leukemias induced by Moloney and Rauscher MuLV. The aim of this current study was to identify the immunogenic epitope(s) recognized by the FBL-3-specific CD8+ CTL. A series of FBL-3-specific CD8+ CTL clones were generated from C57BL/6 mice immunized to FBL-3. The majority of CTL clones (32 of 38) were specific for F-MuLV gag-encoded antigen. By using a series of recombinant vaccinia viruses expressing full-length and truncated F-MuLV gag genes, the antigenic epitope recognized by the FBL-3 gag-specific CTL clones, as well as by bulk-cultured CTL from spleens of mice immune to FBL-3, was localized to the leader sequence of gPr80gag protein. The precise amino acid sequence of the CTL epitope in the leader sequence was identified as CCLCLTVFL (positions 85-93) by examining lysis of targets incubated with a series of synthetic leader sequence peptides. No evidence of other CTL epitopes in the gPr80gag or Pr65gag core virion structural polyproteins was found. The identity of CCLCLTVFL as the target peptide was validated by showing that immunization with the peptide elicited CTL that lysed FBL-3. The CTL elicited by the Gag peptide also specifically lysed syngeneic leukemia cells induced by Moloney and Rauscher MuLV (MBL-2 and RBL-5). The transmembrane peptide was shown to be the major gag-encoded antigenic epitope recognized by bulk-cultured CTL derived from C57BL/6 mice immunized to MBL-2 or RBL-5. Thus, the CTL epitope of FBL-3 is localized to the transmembrane anchor domain of the nonstructural Gag polyprotein and is shared by leukemia/lymphoma cell lines induced by Friend, Moloney, and Rauscher MuLV.     

High-avidity CTL exploit two complementary mechanisms to provide better protection against viral infection than low-avidity CTL

Previously, we observed that high-avidity CTL are much more effective in vivo than low-avidity CTL in elimination of infected cells, but the mechanisms behind their superior activity remained unclear. In this study, we identify two complementary mechanisms: 1) high-avidity CTL lyse infected cells earlier in the course of a viral infection by recognizing lower Ag densities than those distinguished by low-avidity CTL and 2) they initiate lysis of target cells more rapidly at any given Ag density. Alternative mechanisms were excluded, including: 1) the possibility that low-avidity CTL might control virus given more time (virus levels remained as high at 6 days following transfer as at 3 days) and 2) that differences in efficacy might be correlated with homing ability. Furthermore, adoptive transfer of high- and low-avidity CTL into SCID mice demonstrated that transfer of a 10-fold greater amount of low-avidity CTL could only partially compensate for their decreased ability to eliminate infected cells. Thus, we conclude that high-avidity CTL exploit two complementary mechanisms that combine to prevent the spread of virus within the animal: earlier recognition of infected cells when little viral protein has been made and more rapid lysis of infected cells.     

Tumor progression despite efficient tumor antigen cross-presentation and effective "arming" of tumor antigen-specific CTL

To determine whether APC function or "arming" of CTL for lytic function are the points at which Ags from a nonimmunogenic tumor fail to induce an effective immune response, we established a murine tumor model that expressed intracellular OVA and selected a clone (cOVA-9) that remained susceptible to lysis by specific CD8(+) T cells throughout tumor growth. Viable cOVA-9 tumor cells grew in normal mice at a rate similar to the parental tumor, and vaccination with irradiated cOVA-9 cells did not induce protection against itself or the parental line, confirming its nonimmunogenic status. In vivo evaluation during tumor growth demonstrated persisting tumor Ag cross-presentation accompanied by the generation of potent, specific CTL which were detectable when tumors were barely palpable. Despite the presence of highly active CTL in the tumor-draining lymph nodes, there was no apparent lysis of tumor-associated APC. These data show that tumor-draining APC are not dysfunctional with regard to two crucial processes, in vivo tumor Ag cross-presentation and specific CTL arming, and that failure to prevent tumor growth is not in the induction phase, but in the effector phase and occurs within the tumor itself before the tumor matrix is established.     

Generation of anti-AKR/gross murine leukemia virus cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL). An analysis of precursor CTL frequencies in the AKR.H-2b and C57BL/6 mouse strains.

C57BL/6 mice, after immunization and secondary in vitro restimulation with AKR/Gross murine leukemia virus (MuLV)-induced tumors, generate AKR/Gross MuLV-specific CTL. After similar immunization protocols, AKR-H-2b mice fail to generate CTL specific for AKR/Gross MuLV. The basis for nonresponsiveness in AKR.H-2b mice is unknown, however, unlike C57BL/6 mice, AKR.H-2b mice carry endogenous proviruses and express N-ecotropic viral Ag. Thus, clonal deletion of pCTL populations due to the expression of AKR/Gross MuLV-like Ag is a likely mechanism for the nonresponsiveness. To determine if nonresponsiveness is due to clonal deletion, limiting dilution cultures were performed to assess the presence of pCTL specific for AKR/Gross MuLV. Our study demonstrates that the frequencies of pCTL specific for AKR/Gross MuLV are similar in both the responder C57BL/6 and nonresponder AKR.H-2b strains. The observation that normal levels of AKR/Gross MuLV-specific pCTL exist in AKR.H-2b mice, suggests that clonal deletion of pCTL is not responsible for the inability of AKR.H-2b mice to generate anti-AKR/Gross virus-specific CTL.     

H-2-restricted cytolysis of L cells doubly transformed with a cloned H-2Kb gene and cloned retroviral DNA

We report the construction of target cells by the double transformation of mouse L cells with a cloned H-2Kb gene and molecular clones of Akv or Gross murine leukemia virus (MuLV) or the cloned gag gene of Akv MuLV. Cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) generated in BALB.B mice specific for Gross MuLV (closely related to Akv MuLV) kill these doubly transformed cells. This is a direct indication that a CTL subpopulation recognizes H-2Kb antigen in association with a viral antigen encoded by the gag gene of Gross MuLV.     

The immune response to Moloney murine leukemia virus-induced tumors: induction of cytolytic T lymphocytes specific for both viral and tumor-associated antigens

The specificity of CTL generated against tumors induced by murine leukemia viruses (MuLV) has been reported to parallel the expression of two serologically defined tumor cell surface antigens--the cross-reactive FMR antigen expressed on the surface of tumors induced by Friend, Moloney, and Rauscher MuLV, and the Gross cell surface antigen (GCSA) expressed on tumors induced by AKV/Gross MuLV. We examined the specificity of CTL generated against MuLV-induced tumors and identified two distinct patterns of reactivity. The first follows the traditional pattern of FMR vs GCSA reactivity as assessed on a panel of established MuLV-induced lymphomas. However, CTL exhibiting this pattern of reactivity are incapable of lysing MuLV-infected fibroblasts. CTL exhibiting the second pattern of reactivity are capable of lysing MuLV-induced lymphomas as well as MuLV-infected fibroblasts. In addition, these CTL exhibit extensive cross-reactivity between lymphomas and fibroblasts infected by both groups of MuLV. Our results suggest that CTL exhibiting the traditional FMR vs GCSA pattern of reactivity are directed against a tumor-associated antigen and not against virus-encoded antigens, and that CTL directed against MuLV-encoded antigens demonstrate extensive cross-reactivity, including the ability to lyse AKV-infected cells.     

Inhibitory effect of herpes simplex virus infection to target cells on recognition of minor histocompatibility antigens by cytotoxic T lymphocytes

Target cell lysis by CTL specific for minor histocompatibility Ag (minor HA), which were generated in (C3H/He x BALB/c)F1 mice immunized with A/J mouse spleen cells, was dramatically reduced by infection of HSV to Neuro-2a (A/J mouse origin) cells as target. The reduction was apparent at 5 h after infection of HSV to target cells, when many viral proteins were produced in the cells. Conversely, MHC-restricted HSV-specific CTL-mediated cell lysis increased time dependently. Using an RNA virus, vesicular stomatitis virus, significant reduction of minor specific CTL-mediated target cell lysis was also found. During the time when this reduction of target cell lysis by HSV occurred, the surface expression of class I H-2Dd molecules was maintained, and anti-H-2a allo-MHC-specific CTL lysed HSV-infected Neuro-2a cells as strongly as uninfected Neuro-2a cells. When HSV-infected or uninfected Neuro-2a cells were treated with Brefeldin A that selectively blocks transportation of newly synthesized proteins out of endoplasmic reticulum, both HSV- and minor HA-specific CTL-mediated cell lyses were blocked. These observations demonstrated that minor HA are continuously synthesized and associated with class I molecules at pre-Golgi and transported via trans Golgi system with quick turnover, and that newly synthesized HSV Ag, which are also associated with class I molecules and transported via the same system, should take the place of intrinsic minor HA and be presented on the surface of the cells to be recognized by MHC-restricted CTL.     

Cytolytic T lymphocytes from the BALB/c-H-2dm2 mouse recognize the vesicular stomatitis virus glycoprotein and are restricted by class II MHC antigens.

BALB/c-H-2dm2 mice (H-2KdI-AdI-EdDd), a congenic strain of BALB/c mice, have a deletion of the class I MHC Ag, H-2Ld. This gene encodes the exclusive class I MHC-restricting gene product for vesicular stomatitis virus-specific cytolytic T lymphocytes. When dm2 mice were immunized with infectious vesicular stomatitis virus, a specific CTL response was generated. These CTL lysed VSV-infected targets that expressed Iad gene products, but not VSV-infected Iad- targets. The CTL were used initially as long term cytolytic lines; 13 CTL clones were derived by limit dilution. All of the clones expressed the phenotype CD3+, CD4+, CD8-; some clones expressed TCR that are members of the V beta 8 family, others did not. The clones were restricted by class II MHC Ag, both I-Ad and I-Ed serving as restricting elements for individual clones of the panel. All of the clones derived from dm2 mice were specific for the immunizing serotype, Indiana, of VSV and did not lyse syngeneic cells infected with VSV of the New Jersey serotype. Studies using defective interfering virus particles, UV light-inactivated virus, and purified micelles of the viral glycoprotein indicated that infectious virus was not required for sensitization of target cells for immune recognition by the class II MHC-restricted CTL clones. Additional studies using recombinant vaccinia virus vectors to sensitize targets confirmed the specificity of the clones for the viral glycoprotein. These studies also demonstrated a cryptic population of class II-restricted CTL in BALB/c lines specific for VSV G. Naturally occurring variant viruses and mutant viruses, selected for escape from neutralization by mAb, were used in an effort to map the determinant(s) recognized; on the basis of patterns of target cell lysis, three groups of epitopes recognized by the clones were defined. Therefore, in the absence of the class I MHC Ag required for a CTL response to VSV, dm2 mice generated CTL with the CD4+ phenotype that recognized different epitopes on the viral glycoprotein, and lysed cells in a class II-MHC restricted, Ag-specific manner.     

Use of hybridoma-resistant variant cell lines to study H-2D b/FMR-specific cytotoxic T cells

An H-2D ^b b heterozygous tumor cell line and a variant subclone bearing a mutant gene product were used to analyze the H-2D^b specificity of cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) generated during a Moloney murine sarcoma virus (MSV) infection. When the mutant cells were used as targets for MSV-specific CTL, the amount of cell lysis, compared with that seen with the nonmutant parental cells, was drastically decreased. However, cells of the mutant clones remained susceptible to allogeneic CTL specific for the nonmutant H-2D^b molecule. The mutant cells also did not differ from the parent cells in their level of viral antigen expression. Biochemically the parental and mutant molecules were similar but not identical. The data indicate that minor alterations of the H-2 antigens caused by somatic mutation may prevent virus-infected cells from being recognized as targets by CTL.     

Mouse anti-adenovirus cytotoxic T lymphocytes. Inhibition of lysis by E3 gp19K but not E3 14.7K

Early region E3 of adenovirus (Ad) appears to encode proteins involved in the interaction of the virus with the host immune system. The E3 region 19-kDa glycoprotein (gp19K) binds to class I MHC Ag in the endoplasmic reticulum and inhibits their transport to the cell surface; it has been proposed that this protects virus infected cells from lysis by CTL. We have found that the E3 14.7-kDa protein (14.7K) inhibits lysis of infected cells by TNF, and here we show that it also protects cells from lysis by lymphotoxin, which has been implicated as a mediator of CTL lysis. We have developed a method for producing CTL specific for human Ad2 and Ad5 in mice, in order to test directly which of the genes in the E3 region protect infected cells from lysis by virus specific CTL. The presence of the E3 region inhibits both the induction of Ad-specific CTL in culture and the lysis of infected target cells by these CTL. The inhibition varies between different mouse strains, with almost complete inhibition in C57BL/10 (H-2b) mice, partial inhibition with BALB/c (H-2d) and little or no inhibition with C3H (H-2k); results were similar for Ad2 and Ad5. By using a panel of E3 deletion mutants, inhibition of target cell lysis by Ad5 specific CTL was mapped exclusively to the gp19K gene. The 14.7K gene had no effect on CTL lysis despite its ability to protect cells against lysis by lymphotoxin. gp19K was synthesized abundantly in mouse cells by mutants retaining the gp19K gene; some mutant forms of the protein were synthesized but were nonfunctional. These data support the hypothesis that gp19K can protect Ad infected cells against lysis by virus specific CTL.     

Differential susceptibility of cells expressing allogeneic MHC or viral antigen to killing by antigen-specific CTL

CD8(+) cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) generated by immunization with allogeneic cells or viral infection are able to lyse allogeneic or virally infected in vitro cells (e.g., lymphoma and mastocytoma). In contrast, it is reported that CD8(+) T cells are not essential for allograft rejection (e.g., heart and skin), and that clearance of influenza or the Sendai virus from virus-infected respiratory epithelium is normal or only slightly delayed after a primary viral challenge of CD8-knockout mice. To address this controversy, we generated H-2(d)-specific CD8(+) CTLs by a mixed lymphocyte culture and examined the susceptibility of a panel of H-2(d) cells to CTL lysis. KLN205 squamous cell carcinoma, Meth A fibrosarcoma, and BALB/c skin components were found to be resistant to CTL-mediated lysis. This resistance did not appear to be related to a reduced expression of MHC class I molecules, and all these cells could block the recognition of H-2(d) targets by CTLs in cold target inhibition assays. We extended our observation by persistently infecting the same panel of cell lines with defective-interfering Sendai virus particles. The Meth A and KLN205 lines infected with a variant Sendai virus were resistant to lysis by Sendai virus-specific CTLs. The Sendai virus-infected Meth A and KLN205 lines were able to block the lysis of Sendai virus-infected targets by CTLs in cold target inhibition assays. Taken together, these results suggest that not all in vivo tissues may be sensitive to CTL lysis.     

Abrogation of CTL epitope processing by single amino acid substitution flanking the C-terminal proteasome cleavage site

CTL directed against the Moloney murine leukemia virus (MuLV) epitope SSWDFITV recognize Moloney MuLV-induced tumor cells, but do not recognize cells transformed by the closely related Friend MuLV. The potential Friend MuLV epitope has strong sequence homology with Moloney MuLV and only differs in one amino acid within the CTL epitope and one amino acid just outside the epitope. We now show that failure to recognize Friend MuLV-transformed tumor cells is based on a defect in proteasome-mediated processing of the Friend epitope which is due to a single amino acid substitution (N-->D) immediately flanking the C-terminal anchor residue of the epitope. Proteasome-mediated digestion analysis of a synthetic 26-mer peptide derived from the Friend sequence shows that cleavage takes place predominantly C-terminal of D, instead of V as is the case for the Moloney MuLV sequence. Therefore, the C terminus of the epitope is not properly generated. Epitope-containing peptide fragments extended with an additional C-terminal D are not efficiently translocated by TAP and do not show significant binding affinity to MHC class I-Kb molecules. Thus, a potential CTL epitope present in the Friend virus sequence is not properly processed and presented because of a natural flanking aspartic acid that obliterates the correct C-terminal cleavage site. This constitutes a novel way to subvert proteasome-mediated generation of proper antigenic peptide fragments.     

Expression of retrovirus-related, cytotoxic T lymphocyte- and transplantation-defined antigens in NIH/3T3 transfectants after a single passage in nude mice

Transfection of T24c-Ha-ras oncogene into NIH/3T3 fibroblasts resulted in the establishment of a transformed cell line (pT) that was tumorigenic when injected s.c. both into Swiss outbred nude mice and normal NIH inbred mice. The passage into nude mice, however, led to the development of a tumor variant (pT-nude) able to subsequently grow into sublethally x-irradiated but not into immunocompetent NIH mice. NIH mice immunized with this tumor variant developed a strong specific CTL response against the immunizing cell line, whereas the parental transformed pT cell line was not lysed. Clones were derived by limiting dilution from anti-pT-nude bulk population and were tested on a panel of transformed NIH/3T3 lines before and after their growth as tumor into nude mice. All of these lines were lysed by the Lyt-2+ CTL clones as a sole consequence of one in vivo passage into nude mice. The cross-reactive Ag were shown to be related to endogenous retroviral products as assessed by 1) immunoprecipitations of gp70, p15E, and p30 viral proteins in the nude variants but not in parental lines, and 2) by the ability of retroviruses from irradiated pT-nude cells to infect NIH/3T3 or pT lines making them susceptible to lysis by anti-pT-nude CTL clones. These results show that a single passage in nude mice can induce retrovirus-related, cell-surface Ag in transplanted neoplastic cells.     

CD4+ T cell-induced differentiation of EBV-transformed lymphoblastoid cells is associated with diminished recognition by EBV-specific CD8+ cytotoxic T cells

EBV transformation of human B cells in vitro results in establishment of immortalized cell lines (lymphoblastoid cell lines (LCL)) that express viral transformation-associated latent genes and exhibit a fixed, lymphoblastoid phenotype. In this report, we show that CD4(+) T cells can modify the differentiation state of EBV-transformed LCL. Coculture of LCL with EBV-specific CD4(+) T cells resulted in an altered phenotype, characterized by elevated CD38 expression and decreased proliferation rate. Relative to control LCL, the cocultured LCL were markedly less susceptible to lysis by EBV-specific CD8(+) CTL. In contrast, CD4(+) T cell-induced differentiation of LCL did not diminish sensitivity of LCL to lysis by CD8(+) CTL specific for an exogenously loaded peptide Ag or lysis by alloreactive CD8(+) CTL, suggesting that differentiation is not associated with intrinsic resistance to CD8(+) T cell cytotoxicity and that evasion of lysis is confined to EBV-specific CTL responses. CD4(+) T cell-induced differentiation of LCL and concomitant resistance of LCL to lysis by EBV-specific CD8(+) CTL were associated with reduced expression of viral latent genes. Finally, transwell cocultures, in which direct LCL-CD4(+) T cell contact was prevented, indicated a major role for CD4(+) T cell cytokines in the differentiation of LCL.     

Resistance to cell-mediated cytotoxicity is correlated with reduction of H-2K gene products in AKR leukemia

AKR leukemia cell lines differing in the amount of H-2K and H-2D antigens expressed on the cell surface were used to assess cell-mediated immune responses in syngeneic mice against Gross/AKR murine leukemia virus (MuLV)-induced tumors. Leukemic cells with reduced expression of H-2K^k antigens were inactive as inducers of Gross-MuLV/H-2^k-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) and resistant to lysis by CTL raised against H-2K^k positive AKR leukemia cells. H-2K^k positive leukemias induced cytotoxic effectors, which upon restimulation in vitro, lysed the stimulating and other H-2K^k positive leukemia cells. In antibody inhibition experiments, T-cell-mediated cytotoxicity to these leukemias could only be inhibited by antisera and monoclonal antibodies specific for the H-2K^k antigens. Due to this specific role of H-2K^k antigens in T-cell cytotoxicity to Gross/AKR MuLV-induced tumors, reduced expression of H-2K^k antigens on spontaneous AKR leukemic cells could have important implications for surveillance of these neoplastic cells.Abbreviations used in this paper CTL cytotoxic T lymphocytes - MuLV murine leukemia virus     

Consequences of self-presentation of peptide antigen by cytolytic T lymphocytes

We have used H-2Db-restricted CTL clones specific for peptide 365 to 380 of the influenza nucleoprotein to seek evidence for interaction between the TCR and peptide Ag. Preincubation of these CTL with peptide 365 to 380 resulted in inhibition of target cell lysis. In addition, CTL lysed allogeneic targets in the presence of soluble peptide Ag. Investigation of the basis of these two phenomena revealed a requirement for expression of H-2Db molecules by the effector cells. Either preincubation with anti-Db mAb or the use of chimera-derived H-2d CTL specific for Db plus peptide ablated both peptide-dependent inhibition and lysis of allogeneic cells, suggesting these activities are a consequence of self-presentation of peptide Ag by CTL. Lysis of allogeneic cells appears to represent bystander lysis by CTL in response to recognition of peptide on other effector cells. Lysis inhibition is attributable to a highly potent form of cold target inhibition in which CTL serve as their own cold targets.     

Coordinated function of murine cytomegalovirus genes completely inhibits CTL lysis

Murine CMV (MCMV) encodes three viral genes that interfere with Ag presentation (VIPRs) to CD8 T cells, m04, m06, and m152. Because the functional impact of these genes during normal infection of C57BL/6 mice is surprisingly modest, we wanted to determine whether the VIPRs are equally effective against the entire spectrum of H-2(b)-restricted CD8 T cell epitopes. We also wanted to understand how the VIPRs interact at a functional level. To address these questions, we used a panel of MCMV mutants lacking each VIPR in all possible combinations, and CTL specific for 15 H-2(b)-restricted MCMV epitopes. Only expression of all three MCMV VIPRs completely inhibited killing by CTL specific for all 15 epitopes, but removal of any one VIPR enabled lysis by at least some CTL. The dominant interaction between the VIPRs was cooperation: m06 increased the inhibition of lysis achieved by either m152 or m04. However, for 1 of 15 epitopes m04 functionally antagonized m152. There was little differential impact of any of the VIPRs on K(b) vs D(b), but a surprising degree of differential impact of the three VIPRs for different epitopes. These epitope-specific differences did not correlate with functional avidity, or with timing of VIPR expression in relation to Ag expression in the virus replication cycle. Although questions remain about the molecular mechanism and in vivo role of these genes, we conclude that the coordinated function of MCMV's three VIPRs results in a powerful inhibition of lysis of infected cells by CD8 T cells.