Single domain camel antibodies: current status

The antigen-binding capacity of the paired variable domains of an antibody is well established. The observation that the isolated heavy chains of anti-hapten antibodies retain some antigen-binding capacity in the absence of light chains led to attempts to obtain an even smaller antigen-binding unit in a VH format. Unfortunately, the poor solubility, the reduced affinity for the antigen and the irreproducible outcome showed that additional protein engineering would be required to successfully generate single-domain antibody fragments. By serendipity, it was discovered that this engineering is already performed continuously in nature. Part of the humoral immune response of camels and llamas is based largely on heavy-chain antibodies where the light chain is totally absent. These unique antibody isotypes interact with the antigen by virtue of only one single variable domain, referred to as VHH. Despite the absence of the VH-VL combinatorial diversity, these heavy-chain antibodies exhibit a broad antigen-binding repertoire by enlarging their hypervariable regions. Methods are described to tap the VHH repertoire of an immunised dromedary or llama. These VHH libraries contain a high titre of intact antigen-specific binders that were matured in vivo. Synthetic libraries of a 'camelised' human VH, a mouse VH or a camelid VHH scaffold with a randomised CDR3 could constitute a valid alternative to immune libraries to retrieve useful single-domain antigen binders. The recombinant VHH that are selected from such libraries are well expressed, highly soluble in aqueous environments and very robust. Some in vivo matured VHH were also shown to be potent enzyme inhibitors, and the low complexity of the antigen-binding site is an asset in the design of peptide mimetics. Because of their smaller size and the above properties, the VHH clearly offer added-value over conventional antibody fragments. They are expected to open perspectives as enzyme inhibitors and intrabodies, as modular building units for multivalent or multifunctional constructs, or as immuno-adsorbents and detection units in biosensors.     

Single domain camel antibodies: current status

The antigen-binding capacity of the paired variable domains of an antibody is well established. The observation that the isolated heavy chains of anti-hapten antibodies retain some antigen-binding capacity in the absence of light chains led to attempts to obtain an even smaller antigen-binding unit in a VH format. Unfortunately, the poor solubility, the reduced affinity for the antigen and the irreproducible outcome showed that additional protein engineering would be required to successfully generate single-domain antibody fragments. By serendipity, it was discovered that this engineering is already performed continuously in nature. Part of the humoral immune response of camels and llamas is based largely on heavy-chain antibodies where the light chain is totally absent. These unique antibody isotypes interact with the antigen by virtue of only one single variable domain, referred to as VHH. Despite the absence of the VH–VL combinatorial diversity, these heavy-chain antibodies exhibit a broad antigen-binding repertoire by enlarging their hypervariable regions. Methods are described to tap the VHH repertoire of an immunised dromedary or llama. These VHH libraries contain a high titre of intact antigen-specific binders that were matured in vivo. Synthetic libraries of a ‘camelised’ human VH, a mouse VH or a camelid VHH scaffold with a randomised CDR3 could constitute a valid alternative to immune libraries to retrieve useful single-domain antigen binders. The recombinant VHH that are selected from such libraries are well expressed, highly soluble in aqueous environments and very robust. Some in vivo matured VHH were also shown to be potent enzyme inhibitors, and the low complexity of the antigen-binding site is an asset in the design of peptide mimetics. Because of their smaller size and the above properties, the VHH clearly offer added-value over conventional antibody fragments. They are expected to open perspectives as enzyme inhibitors and intrabodies, as modular building units for multivalent or multifunctional constructs, or as immuno-adsorbents and detection units in biosensors.     

Recognition of antigens by single-domain antibody fragments: the superfluous luxury of paired domains

The antigen-binding site of antibodies from vertebrates is formed by combining the variable domains of a heavy chain (VH) and a light chain (VL). However, antibodies from camels and llamas are an important exception to this in that their sera contain, in addition, a unique kind of antibody that is formed by heavy chains only. The antigen-binding site of these antibodies consists of one single domain, referred to as VHH. This article reviews the mutations and structural adaptations that have taken place to reshape a VH of a VH-VL pair into a single-domain VHH with retention of a sufficient variability. The VHH has a potent antigen-binding capacity and provides the advantage of interacting with novel epitopes that are inaccessible to conventional VH-VL pairs.     

Characterization of antigen-binding receptors in vitro. II. Antigen-binding capacity and affinity of lymphoid receptors after immunization.

We examined the kinetics and affinity of antigen binding in lymphoid populations in mice after immunization. There is increased binding capacity in lymphoid cells from animals that have undergone primary immunization. This increase would seem to be related to increased numbers of antigen-binding cells (rosette-forming cells). The serum antibody titers rise after the increasing binding capacity and numbers of BSA rosette-forming cells have increased. There is an increased amount of antigen bound per antigen-binding cell at certain times after immunization with two peaks in this capacity being demonstrable--one occurring at 4 days after immunization and the second occurring approximately 12 days after immunization and persisting for prolonged periods after that. With time, after immunization two separable peaks of increased antigen-binding cells become apparent, one very early (before Day 4) and one later (after Day 20 to 30). The affinity constants for antigen-binding cells have been measured and found to be high, and to increase with time after immunization. It appears that the heterogeneity of the affinity constants for antigen-binding cells is high early in immunity and becomes more homogeneous with time after immunization.     

The intrinsic contributions of tyrosine, serine, glycine and arginine to the affinity and specificity of antibodies

Synthetic antibody libraries with restricted chemical diversity were used to explore the intrinsic contributions of four amino acids (Tyr, Ser, Gly and Arg) to the affinity and specificity of antigen recognition. There was no correlation between nonspecific binding and the content of Tyr, Ser or Gly in the antigen-binding site, and in fact, the most specific antibodies were those with the highest Tyr content. In contrast, Arg content was clearly correlated with increased nonspecific binding. We combined Tyr, Ser and Gly to generate highly specific synthetic antibodies with affinities in the subnanomolar range, showing that the high abundance of Tyr, Ser and Gly in natural antibody germ line sequences reflects the intrinsic capacity of these residues to work together to mediate antigen recognition. Despite being a major functional contributor to co-evolved protein-protein interfaces, we find that Arg does not contribute generally to the affinity of naïve antigen-binding sites and is detrimental to specificity. Again, this is consistent with studies of natural antibodies, which have shown that nonspecific, self-reactive antibodies are rich in Arg and other positively charged residues. Our findings suggest that the principles governing naïve molecular recognition differ from those governing co-evolved interactions. Analogous studies can be designed to explore the roles of the other amino acids in molecular recognition. Results of such studies should illuminate the basic principles underlying natural protein-protein interactions and should aid the design of synthetic binding proteins with functions beyond the scope of natural proteins.     

Fab is the most efficient format to express functional antibodies by yeast surface display

Multiple formats are available for engineering of monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) by yeast surface display, but they do not all lead to efficient expression of functional molecules. We therefore expressed four anti-tumor necrosis factor and two anti-IpaD mAbs as single-chain variable fragment (scFv), antigen-binding fragment (Fab) or single-chain Fabs and compared their expression levels and antigen-binding efficiency. Although the scFv and scFab formats are widely used in the literature, 2 of 6 antibodies were either not or weakly expressed. In contrast, all 6 antibodies expressed as Fab revealed strong binding and high affinity, comparable to that of the soluble form. We also demonstrated that the variations in expression did not affect Fab functionality and were due to variations in light chain display and not to misfolded dimers. Our results suggest that Fab is the most versatile format for the engineering of mAbs.     

Serologic aspects of IgG4 antibodies. I. Prolonged immunization results in an IgG4-restricted response

Labeled antigen-binding tests were used to determine quantitatively the contribution of IgG4 antibodies to the total IgG antibody response in humans. In agreement with literature, we found no IgG4-restricted antibody responses with tetanus toxoid or streptococcal carbohydrate. In the serum of individuals immunized for several years with phospholipase (PLA) from honey bee venom, grass pollen allergen, or house dust mite allergen, we often found that more than 50% of the total antigen-binding capacity was due to IgG4 antibodies. In the case of beekeepers, it could clearly be shown that during prolonged immunization a shift in the IgG4:IgG1 antibody ratio occurs that finally results in an IgG4-dominated antibody response. Evidence is provided that antigen-binding assays may even underestimate the contribution of IgG4 antibodies, because in contrast to IgG1 antibodies, IgG4 antibodies act as monovalent antibodies in being unable to cross-link immunosorbent-bound antigen and radiolabeled antigen.     

High affinity antigen recognition of the dual specific variants of herceptin is entropy-driven in spite of structural plasticity

The antigen-binding site of Herceptin, an anti-human Epidermal Growth Factor Receptor 2 (HER2) antibody, was engineered to add a second specificity toward Vascular Endothelial Growth Factor (VEGF) to create a high affinity two-in-one antibody bH1. Crystal structures of bH1 in complex with either antigen showed that, in comparison to Herceptin, this antibody exhibited greater conformational variability, also called "structural plasticity". Here, we analyzed the biophysical and thermodynamic properties of the dual specific variants of Herceptin to understand how a single antibody binds two unrelated protein antigens. We showed that while bH1 and the affinity-improved bH1-44, in particular, maintained many properties of Herceptin including binding affinity, kinetics and the use of residues for antigen recognition, they differed in the binding thermodynamics. The interactions of bH1 and its variants with both antigens were characterized by large favorable entropy changes whereas the Herceptin/HER2 interaction involved a large favorable enthalpy change. By dissecting the total entropy change and the energy barrier for dual interaction, we determined that the significant structural plasticity of the bH1 antibodies demanded by the dual specificity did not translate into the expected increase of entropic penalty relative to Herceptin. Clearly, dual antigen recognition of the Herceptin variants involves divergent antibody conformations of nearly equivalent energetic states. Hence, increasing the structural plasticity of an antigen-binding site without increasing the entropic cost may play a role for antibodies to evolve multi-specificity. Our report represents the first comprehensive biophysical analysis of a high affinity dual specific antibody binding two unrelated protein antigens, furthering our understanding of the thermodynamics that drive the vast antigen recognition capacity of the antibody repertoire.     

Affinity maturation of an anti-hepatitis B virus PreS1 humanized antibody by phage display

In a previous study we generated an anti-Hepatitis B Virus (HBV) preS1 humanized antibody (HzKR127) that showed in vivo HBV-neutralizing activity in chimpanzees. However, the antigen-binding affinity of the humanized antibody may not be sufficient for clinical use and thus affinity maturation is required for better therapeutic efficacy. In this study, phage display technique was employed to increase the affinity of HzKR127. All six amino acid residues (Glu95-Tyr96-Asp97-Glu98-Ala99-Tyr100) in the heavy (H) chain complementarydetermining region 3 (HCDR3) of HzKR127 were randomized and phage-displayed single chain Fv (scFv) library was constructed. After three rounds of panning, 12 different clones exhibiting higher antigen-binding activity than the wild type ScFv were selected and their antigen-binding specificity for the preS1 confirmed. Subsequently, five ScFv clones were converted to whole IgG and subjected to affinity determination. The results showed that two clones (B3 and A19) exhibited an approximately 6 fold higher affinities than that of HzKR127. The affinity-matured humanized antibodies may be useful in anti-HBV immunotherapy.     

Tunable modulation of antibody-antigen interaction by protease cleavage of protein M

While immunoglobulins find ubiquitous use in biotechnology as static binders, recent developments have created proantibodies that enable orthogonal switch-like behavior to antibody function. Previously, peptides with low binding affinity have been genetically fused to antibodies, to proteolytically control binding function by blocking the antigen-binding site. However, development of these artificial blockers requires panning for peptide sequences that reversibly affect antigen affinity for each antibody. Instead, a more general strategy to achieve dynamic control over antibody affinity may be feasible using protein M (ProtM) from Mycoplasma genitalium, a newly identified polyspecific immunity evasion protein that is capable of blocking antigen binding for a wide range of antibodies. Using C-terminus truncation to identify ProtM variants that are still capable of binding to antibodies without the ability to block antigens, we developed a novel and universal biological switch for antibodies. Using a site-specifically placed thrombin cut site, antibody affinity can be modulated by cleavage of the two distinct antibody-binding and antigen-blocking domains of ProtM. Because of the high affinity of ProtM toward a large variety of IgG subtypes, this strategy may be used as a universal approach to create proantibodies that are conditionally activated by disease-specific proteases such as matrix metalloproteinases.     

Passive enhancement of mouse skin allografts by alloantibodies is Fc dependent.

The capacity of F(ab')2 fragments of alloantibodies to enhance mouse allografts was studied in B6AF1 recipients of B10.D2 skin grafts. F(ab')2 obtained by digestion of B6AF1 anti-B10.D2 antibodies was purified by means of affinity chromatography, with anti-subclass antisera and protein A. The degree of contaminating IgG was less than 0.02%. Administration of F(ab')2 with an antigen-binding capacity similar to the IgG from which it originated, inhibited acute antibody-mediated graft rejection but was unable to induce enhancement. Even a dose that was 130 times the molar amount of the minimal enhancing dose of undigested IgG2 was ineffective. We conclude, therefore, that passive enhancement of mouse skin allografts by alloantibodies requires the Fc part.     

Affinity maturation and characterization of the ofatumumab monoclonal antibody

CD20 molecule, a phosphoprotein with 297 amino acids and four transmembrane domains, is a member of MS4A protein family. Anti-CD20 antibodies such as ofatumumab, which have been developed for cancer treatment and has demonstrated efficacy in relapsed/refractory chronic lymphocytic leukemia, are among the most successful therapies to date. Rational engineering methods can be applied with reasonable success to improve functional characteristics of antibodies. Considering the importance of this issue, we have used in silico modeling approach for the improvement of ofatumumab monoclonal antibody. Four mutated variants of ofatumumab were developed and expressed in Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells along with the unmodified antibody. Analysis of affinity of the purified antibodies with CD20 showed significant improvement in antigen-binding characteristics of one of the variants compared with the control antibody. This study represents the first step toward development of the second generation ofatumumab antibody with improved affinity.     

An effective and rapid method for functional characterization of immunoadsorbents using POROS beads and flow cytometry

To facilitate the construction, functional characterization, and use of immunoadsorbents, we have developed a flow cytometry method that allows rapid assessment of large numbers of particle-bound antibodies. Protein G derivitized POROS beads were used to bind affinity-purified antibodies specific for synthetic peptides designed from human plasma proteins. The antibodies were covalently coupled to the beads and used to capture and release synthetic peptides that had been labeled at the C-terminus with the fluorochrome Alexa Fluor 488. Antibody coupling and specificity of antigen binding and release were measured by analysis of the POROS affinity beads by flow cytometry. The affinity-capture matrixes were also used through several antigen-binding and release cycles without loss of peptide binding efficiency. The ability to produce and characterize extremely small amounts of POROS affinity matrices will facilitate their use in protein microchemical procedures such as protein chip technology, monoclonal antibody screening and mass spectrometry, applications where analytes are limiting or present in low abundance in complex mixtures.     

Site-specific antibodies to human erythropoietin: immunoaffinity purification of urinary and recombinant hormone

The 19-amino acid domain Ala111----Pro129 of human erythropoietin was identified as an accessible surface antigen based on the binding of radio-iodinated and of unmodified hormone to antibodies prepared against a synthetic peptide of homologous sequence. The specificity and affinity of this binding was sufficient to provide for the use of anti-peptide antibodies in the preparation of an immunosorbent for the purification of urinary, and of recombinant human erythropoietin. Immobilization of anti-peptide antibodies using agarose activated either with CNBr or with N-hydroxysuccinimido groups largely inactivated binding sites for erythropoietin. In contrast, antibodies crosslinked to N-acetyl-DL-homocysteine agarose through the hetero-bifunctional reagent succinimidyl 4-(N-maleimidomethyl)cyclohexane-1-carboxylate retained their antigen-binding capacity virtually completely and provided a superior immunosorbent for hormone. Urinary erythropoietin with a specific bioactivity of 100 U/A280 was prepared initially by chromatography on phenyl-Sepharose. Subsequent immunoaffinity chromatography resulted in a 350-fold purification with 46.2% recovery yielding erythropoietin with a specific bioactivity of 35,200 U/A280 (44,300 U/mg). Radioiodination of this purified protein and subsequent SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis indicated that this preparation contained a single major component (Mr 30,000) which co-migrated in gels with unmodified biologically active hormone. Recombinant erythropoietin, which was prepared by the cloning of the human erythropoietin gene and its expression in COS cells using the SV40-derived vector pSV2, was purified by the same scheme. Chromatography on phenyl-Sepharose of medium derived from transfected cells (400 U/ml, 170 U/A280) provided for a 3.6-fold purification of recombinant hormone with an apparent recovery of 122%. This erythropoietin bound to the anti-peptide antibody gel and was purified to a specific bioactivity of 10,370 U/A280 with 55% recovery. The procedure described here for attaching antibodies to a solid support maximizes their antigen-binding capacity and is generally applicable. The development of an anti-peptide immunosorbant for human erythropoietin provides a valuable means for isolating hormone for use in studies of its receptor and its presently unresolved mechanism of action.     

Structural consequences of mutations in interfacial Tyr residues of a protein antigen-antibody complex. The case of HyHEL-10-HEL

Tyrosine is an important amino acid in protein-protein interaction hot spots. In particular, many Tyr residues are located in the antigen-binding sites of antibodies and endow high affinity and high specificity to these antibodies. To investigate the role of interfacial Tyr residues in protein-protein interactions, we performed crystallographic studies and thermodynamic analyses of the interaction between hen egg lysozyme (HEL) and the anti-HEL antibody HyHEL-10 Fv fragment. HyHEL-10 has six Tyr residues in its antigen-binding site, which were systematically mutated to Phe and Ala using site-directed mutagenesis. The crystal structures revealed several critical roles for these Tyr residues in the interaction between HEL and HyHEL-10 as follows: 1) the aromatic ring of Tyr-50 in the light chain (LTyr-50) was important for the correct ternary structure of variable regions of the immunoglobulin light chain and heavy chain and of HEL; 2) deletion of the hydroxyl group of Tyr-50 in the heavy chain (HTyr-50) resulted in structural changes in the antigen-antibody interface; and 3) the side chains of HTyr-33 and HTyr-53 may help induce fitting of the antibody to the antigen. Hot spot Tyr residues may contribute to the high affinity and high specificity of the antigen-antibody interaction through a diverse set of structural and thermodynamic interactions.     

The role of interface framework residues in determining antibody V(H)/V(L) interaction strength and antigen-binding affinity

While many antibodies with strong antigen-binding affinity have stable variable regions with a strong antibody heavy chain variable region fragment (V(H))/antibody light chain variable region fragment (V(L)) interaction, the anti-lysozyme IgG HyHEL-10 has a fairly strong affinity, yet a very weak V(H)/V(L) interaction strength, in the absence of antigen. To investigate the possible relationship between antigen-binding affinity and V(H)/V(L) interaction strength, a novel phage display system that can switch two display modes was employed. We focused on the two framework region 2 regions of the HyHEL-10 V(H) and V(L), facing each other at the domain interface, and a combinatorial library was made in which each framework region 2 residue was mixed with that of D1.3, which has a far stronger V(H)/V(L) interaction. The phagemid library, encoding V(H) gene 7 and V(L) amber codon gene 9, was used to transform TG-1 (sup+), and the phages displaying functional variable regions were selected. The selected phages were then used to infect a nonsuppressing strain, and the culture supernatant containing V(H)-displaying phages and soluble V(L) fragment was used to evaluate the V(H)/V(L) interaction strength. The results clearly showed the existence of a key framework region 2 residue (H39) that strongly affects V(H)/V(L) interaction strength, and a marked positive correlation between the antigen-binding affinity and the V(H)/V(L) interaction, especially in the presence of a set of particular V(L) residues. The effect of the H39 mutation on the wild-type variable region was also confirmed by a SPR biosensor as a several-fold increase in antigen-binding affinity owing to an increased association rate, while a slight decrease was observed for the single-chain variable region.     

Crystal structure of Fab198, an efficient protector of the acetylcholine receptor against myasthenogenic antibodies.

The crystal structure of the Fab fragment of the rat monoclonal antibody 198, with protective activity for the main immunogenic region of the human muscle acetylcholine receptor against the destructive action of myasthenic antibodies, has been determined and refined to 2.8 A resolution by X-ray crystallographic methods. The mouse anti-lysozyme Fab D1.3 was used as a search model in molecular replacement with the AMORE software. The complementarity determining regions (CDR)-L2, CDR-H1 and CDR-H2 belong to canonical groups. Loops CDR-L3, CDR-H2 and CDR-H3, which seem to make a major contribution to binding, were analyzed and residues of potential importance for antigen-binding are examined. The antigen-binding site was found to be a long crescent-shaped crevice. The structure should serve as a model in the rational design of very high affinity humanized mutants of Fab198, appropriate for therapeutic approaches in the model autoimmune disease myasthenia gravis.     

Domain antibodies: proteins for therapy

Occurring naturally in "heavy chain" immunoglobulins from camels, and now produced in fully human form, domain antibodies (dAbs) are the smallest known antigen-binding fragments of antibodies, ranging from 11 kDa to 15 kDa. dAbs are the robust variable regions of the heavy and light chains of immunoglobulins (VH and VL respectively). They are highly expressed in microbial cell culture, show favourable biophysical properties including solubility and temperature stability, and are well suited to selection and affinity maturation by in vitro selection systems such as phage display. dAbs are bioactive as monomers and, owing to their small size and inherent stability, can be formatted into larger molecules to create drugs with prolonged serum half-lives or other pharmacological activities.     

Monoclonal antibodies for carcinoembryonic antigen and related antigens as a model system: determination of affinities and specificities of monoclonal antibodies by using biotin-labeled antibodies and avidin as precipitating agent in a solution phase immunoassay

A general method is described for the determination of affinity constants and antigen cross-reactivities of monoclonal antibodies. The method employs biotin-labeled antibody, radiolabeled antigen, and avidin as a precipitating agent in a homogeneous phase, competitive radioimmunoassay. This method eliminates incomplete or variable precipitation of antigen-antibody complexes often encountered in immunoassays in which monoclonal antibodies are employed. Using this assay system, we were able to rapidly determine the affinity constants for a number of monoclonal antibodies elicited to carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA). In the preceding paper it was shown that five of the monoclonal antibodies recognized distinct epitopes on CEA. In antigen-binding experiments with these five monoclonal antibodies, the percent of radiolabeled CEA bound in antibody excess ranged from 30 to 92%. The CEA cross-reacting antigens, normal cross-reacting antigen (NCA), and tumor-extracted, CEA-related antigen (TEX) were significantly bound by one, and to a lesser degree, by two of the five antibodies. Two antibodies did not bind significant amounts of NCA or TEX. In inhibition studies, the amount of unlabeled CEA leading to 50% inhibition of 125I-labeled CEA-binding was in the range of 3.7 to 760 ng per tube. The amount of TEX showing the same degree of inhibition was 23-fold greater than the amount of CEA for two antibodies and 351-fold greater than the amount of CEA for a third antibody. The affinity constants for CEA were in the range of 1.0 x 10(8) to 5.1 x 10(10) M-1. The affinity constants for NCA and TEX, determined for one of the antibodies, were three orders of magnitude lower in comparison to CEA. The heterogeneity of radiolabeled CEA as indicated by the low fraction bound by one of the monoclonal antibodies is shown to be most probably an artifact resulting from radioiodination damage. The application of the approach described in this report should eliminate the problems most commonly encountered in the determination of affinity constants for monoclonal antibodies or the use of monoclonal antibodies in competitive, homogeneous-phase immunoassays.