Immunotherapy of hepatocellular carcinoma: strategies for combinatorial intervention

Hepatocellular carcinoma(HCC) is the most frequent primary liver cancer, leading to 74.6 thousand deaths annually. The prognosis of HCC over the last few decades has remained unsatisfactory, and over half of patients with early-stage HCC develop recurrence by the time of follow-up. Immunotherapeutic intervention has emerged as a novel, effective treatment to delay the progression of aggressive tumors and suppress tumor recurrence and metastasis. However, few clinical immunotherapy trials have been conducted in HCC patients, and there is an unmet need for novel therapeutic strategies. The combination of conventional treatments with specific immunotherapeutic approaches may dramatically improve the efficacy of HCC treatment and the clinical outcome of HCC patients. In this review, we briefly summarize immunotherapy strategies and discuss new advances in combined immunotherapeutic approaches for the treatment of patients with liver cancer.     

肝细胞癌循环肿瘤细胞标志物及检测方法研究进展

肝细胞癌(hepatocellular carcinoma, HCC)在中国是一种高发病率和高死亡率的恶性肿瘤。肿瘤切除、肝移植是治疗该病最有效的手段,但术后的高复发率和高转移率是影响患者预后的重要因素。外周血循环肿瘤细胞(circulating tumor cells, CTCs)是导致肝细胞癌术后复发和转移的必要因子。综述了CTCs的标记物——磷脂酰肌醇蛋白聚糖-3、转铁蛋白受体、甲胎蛋白、α-L岩藻糖苷酶、上皮细胞粘附因子、高尔基蛋白73和异常凝血酶原等,以及利用这些标记物检测CTCs的特异性和灵敏度,以期为肝细胞癌转移的早期检测、术后的复发、预后评估和选择治疗方案等提供依据。     

Prognostic evaluation of NANOG and OCT4 expression for posttransplantation hepatocellular carcinoma recurrence

Postoperative hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) recurrence and metastasis throw great threaten to its overall survival (OS). This paper focus on exploring the prognostic significance of NANOG and OCT4 expression in HCC recurrence and OS after liver transplantation. Eighty-six patients who meet University of California San Francisco (UCSF) criteria and underwent liver transplantation in Tianjin First Central Hospital between August 2010 and August 2013 were included. Expression of NANOG and OCT4 was determined by immunohistochemistry. The relationships between NANOG and OCT4 expression with tumor recurrence, tumor count, histology stage, lymph node metastasis (LNM) and microvascular invasion (MVI) were explored through the χ² test and Cox regression analysis. We found that 19/26 and 20/24 patients with positive expression of NANOG and OCT4 relapsed. Combination of NANOG and OCT4 expression was indicated as valuable prognostic signature for HCC recurrence prediction (P < 0.0011). Besides, we identified other key factors with significant correlations with recurrence, such as LNM (P = 0.011) and MVI (P = 0.024). Strikingly, recurrence sites could significantly affect recurrence time (P = 0.0062) and patients with recurrence in transplanted liver have longer recurrence time. In conclusions, we analyzed the relationships between NANOG/OCT4 expression, clinicopathology features, HCC recurrence, and OS after liver transplantation for the first time. Combination of NANOG, OCT4, LNM, histopathological stage, and MVI may be predictor for HCC recurrence posttransplantation. Comprehensive of histopathological stage grade and LNM were considered as prognosis factor for OS after liver transplantation. This should be helpful for treatment method selection for HCC patients after liver transplantation.     

Monocytic MDSC mobilization promotes tumor recurrence after liver transplantation via CXCL10/TLR4/MMP14 signaling

Tumor recurrence is the major obstacle for pushing the envelope of liver transplantation for hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) patients. The inflammatory cascades activated by acute liver graft injury promote tumor recurrence. We aimed to explore the role and mechanism of myeloid-derived suppressor cell (MDSC) mobilization induced by liver graft injury on tumor recurrence. By analyzing 331 HCC patients who received liver transplantation, the patients with graft weight ratio (GWR, the weight of liver graft divided by the estimated standard liver weight of recipient) <60% had higher tumor recurrence than GWR ≥60% ones. MDSCs and CXCL10/TLR4 levels were significantly increased in patients with GWR <60% or tumor recurrence. These findings were further validated in our rat orthotopic liver transplantation model. In CXCL10^−/− and TLR4^−/− mice of hepatic ischemia/reperfusion injury plus major hepatectomy (IRH) model, monocytic MDSCs, instead of granulocytic MDSCs, were significantly decreased. Importantly, CXCL10 deficiency reduced the accumulation of TLR4⁺ monocytic MDSCs, and CXCL10 increased MDSC mobilization in the presence of TLR4. Moreover, MMP14 was identified as the key molecule bridging CXCL10/TLR4 signaling and MDSC mobilization. Knockout or inhibition of CXCL10/TLR4 signaling significantly reduced the tumor growth with decreased monocytic MDSCs and MMP14 in the mouse tumor recurrent model. Our data indicated that monocytic MDSCs were mobilized and recruited to liver graft during acute phase injury, and to promote HCC recurrence after transplantation. Targeting MDSC mobilization via CXCL10/TLR4/MMP14 signaling may represent the therapeutic potential in decreasing post-transplant liver tumor recurrence.Subject terms: Liver cancer, Experimental models of disease     

MMP-2、MMP-9及P53的表达在肝移植后肿瘤复发与转移预测中的价值研究

目的：探讨MMP-2、MMP-9及P53的表达在预测肝癌行肝移植后肿瘤复发与转移中的价值。方法：选择肝癌行全肝移植患者85例,应用免疫组化方法检测其切除的肝癌组织中MMP-2、MMP-9及P53的表达,并对患者进行移植术后随访,观察术后肝癌复发与转移情况。分析MMP-2、MMP-9及P53的表达与移植后肝癌复发与转移之间的关系和意义。结果：肝癌组织中MMP-2、MMP-9及P53阳性表达率均明显高于癌旁组织（P〈0.01）。MMP-2表达与肝癌肿瘤直径、TNM分期、病理分级及门静脉癌栓显著相关性（P〈0.05）,MMP-9表达与肝癌肿瘤直径、TNM分期、门静脉癌栓及肿瘤包膜显著相关性（P〈0.05）,P53表达与肝癌肿瘤直径、门静脉癌栓及肿瘤包膜显著相关性（P〈0.05）。MMP-2、MMP-9在未复发和转移组中的表达明显低于复发和转移组（P〈0.05）,而P53在两组间的表达差异无显著性（P〉0.05）。肝癌组织中MMP-2、MMP-9高阳性表达均是预测肝癌患者肝移植后肿瘤复发和转移的独立预见因子,而P53未显示其具有预测意义。结论：MMP-2、MMP-9及P53在肝癌组织中呈高表达,MMP-2、MMP-9的表达水平可以有效预测肝癌患者肝移植后肿瘤复发和转移。     

MMP-2、MMP-9 及P53 的表达在肝移植后肿瘤复发与转移预测中 的价值研究

目的:探讨MMP-2、MMP-9及P53的表达在预测肝癌行肝移植后肿瘤复发与转移中的价值。方法:选择肝癌行全肝移植患者85例,应用免疫组化方法检测其切除的肝癌组织中MMP-2、MMP-9及P53的表达,并对患者进行移植术后随访,观察术后肝癌复发与转移情况。分析MMP-2、MMP-9及P53的表达与移植后肝癌复发与转移之间的关系和意义。结果:肝癌组织中MMP-2、MMP-9及P53阳性表达率均明显高于癌旁组织(P<0.01)。MMP-2表达与肝癌肿瘤直径、TNM分期、病理分级及门静脉癌栓显著相关性(P<0.05),MMP-9表达与肝癌肿瘤直径、TNM分期、门静脉癌栓及肿瘤包膜显著相关性(P<0.05),P53表达与肝癌肿瘤直径、门静脉癌栓及肿瘤包膜显著相关性(P<0.05)。MMP-2、MMP-9在未复发和转移组中的表达明显低于复发和转移组(P<0.05),而P53在两组间的表达差异无显著性(P>0.05)。肝癌组织中MMP-2、MMP-9高阳性表达均是预测肝癌患者肝移植后肿瘤复发和转移的独立预见因子,而P53未显示其具有预测意义。结论:MMP-2、MMP-9及P53在肝癌组织中呈高表达,MMP-2、MMP-9的表达水平可以有效预测肝癌患者肝移植后肿瘤复发和转移。     

Salvage liver transplantation for patients with recurrent hepatocellular carcinoma after curative resection

Objective

To summarize the experience with salvage liver transplantation (SLT) for patients with recurrent hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) after primary hepatic resection in a single center.

Methods

A total of 376 adult patients with HCC underwent orthotopic liver transplantation (OLT) at Organ Transplantation Center, the First Affiliated Hospital of Sun Yat-sen University, between 2004 and 2008. Among these patients, 36 underwent SLT after primary liver curative resection due to intrahepatic recurrence. During the same period, one hundred and forty-seven patients with HCC within Milan criteria underwent primary OLT (PLTW group), the intra-operative and post-operative parameters were compared between these two groups. Furthermore, we compared tumor recurrence and patient survival of patients with SLT to 156 patients with HCC beyond Milan criteria (PLTB group). Cox Hazard regression was made to identify the risk factors for tumor recurrence.

Results

The median interval between initial liver resection and SLT was 35 months (1–63 months). The intraoperative blood loss (P<0.05) and transfusion volume (P<0.05) were larger in the SLT group than in the PLTW group. The operation time was longer in the SLT group (P<0.05). The post-operative complications incidence, tumor recurrence rate, patients'' survival rate, and tumor-free survival rate were comparable between these two groups (all P>0.05). When compared to those patients with HCC beyond Milan criteria undergoing primary OLT, patients undergoing SLT achieved a better survival and a lower tumor recurrence. Cox Proportional Hazards model showed that vascular invasion, including macrovascular and microvascular invasion, as well as AFP level >400 IU/L were risk factors for tumor recurrence after LT.

Conclusions

In comparison with primary OLT, although SLT is associated with increased operation difficulties, it provides a good option for patients with HCC recurrence after curative resection.     

肝癌免疫治疗的研究进展

肝细胞肝癌是全球发病率和死亡率最高的恶性肿瘤之一,发病率和死亡率呈逐年上升趋势。我国是肝癌大国,每年肝癌的死亡病例数位居全球第一。免疫治疗是继手术、化疗和放疗之后新兴的癌症治疗手段,其通过解除肿瘤微环境对免疫细胞的抑制作用并激活机体免疫功能,实现控制和杀伤肿瘤细胞。常用的免疫治疗的方法有免疫检查点治疗、过继免疫治疗和肿瘤疫苗治疗等。与传统治疗手段相比,免疫治疗因具有增强机体免疫功能、延缓肿瘤进展、延长患者生存时间等优点,逐渐成为基础和临床研究的热点。文中就免疫治疗在肝癌领域的研究进展作一综述。     

A scoring model based on neutrophil to lymphocyte ratio predicts recurrence of HBV-associated hepatocellular carcinoma after liver transplantation

Background

Neutrophil to lymphocyte ratio (NLR) has been proposed to predict prognosis of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC). However, the cut-off values are empirical. We determined the optimal cut-off value to predict HCC recurrence after liver transplantation (LT) and further established a scoring model based on NLR.

Methodology/Principal Findings

We analyzed the outcome of 101 HBV-associated HCC patients undergoing LT. Preoperative risk factors for tumor recurrence were evaluated by univariate analysis. By using ROC analysis, NLR≥3 was considered elevated. The disease-free survival (DFS) and overall survival (OS) for patients with high NLR was significantly worse than that for patients with normal NLR (the 5-year DFS and OS of 28.5% and 19.5% vs. 64.9% and 61.8%, respectively; P<0.001). Univariate analysis revealed that tumor size >5 cm, tumor number >3, macrovascular invasion, AFP≥400 µg/L, NLR≥3, and HBV-DNA level >5 log10 copies/mL were preoperative predictors of DFS. Cox regression analysis showed macrovascular invasion, tumor number, and high NLR were independent prognostic factors. We then established a preoperative prognostic score based on multivariate analysis. Each factor was given a score of 1. Area under the ROC curve of the score was 0.781. All nine patients with score 3 developed recurrence within 6 months after LT. Of 71 patients without vascular invasion, three patients with both tumor number >3 and NLR≥3 developed recurrence within 14 months after LT while the 5-year DFS and OS for patients with a score of 0 or 1 were 68.1% and 62.8%, respectively.

Conclusions/Significance

Preoperative elevated NLR significantly increases the risk of recurrence in patients underwent LT for HCC. Patients with both NLR≥3 and tumor number >3 are not a good indication for LT. Our score model may aid in the selection of patients that would most benefit from transplantation for HCC.     

The Landscape Of Alpha Fetoprotein In Hepatocellular Carcinoma: Where Are We?

Hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) is the most common primary liver cancer and has been acknowledged as a leading cause of death among cirrhosis patients. Difficulties in early diagnosis and heterogeneity are obstacles to effective treatment, especially for advanced HCC. Liver transplantation (LT) is considered the best therapy for HCC. Although many biomarkers are being proposed, alpha-fetoprotein (AFP), which was identified over 60 years ago, remains the most utilized. Recently, much hope has been placed in the immunogenicity of AFP to develop novel therapies, such as AFP vaccines and AFP-specific adoptive T-cell transfer (ACT). This review summarizes the performance of AFP as a biomarker for HCC diagnosis and prognosis, as well as its correlation with molecular classes. In addition, the role of AFP in LT is also described. Finally, we highlight the mechanism and application prospects of two immune therapies (AFP vaccine and ACT) for HCC. In general, our review points out the prevalence of AFP in HCC, accompanied by some controversies and novel directions for future research.     

ZIP4, a Novel Determinant of Tumor Invasion in Hepatocellular Carcinoma,Contributes to Tumor Recurrence after Liver Transplantation

Background and purpose: Recently, evidence that Zinc transporter ZRT/IRT-like protein 4 (ZIP4) is involved in invasiveness and apoptosis has emerged in pancreatic cancer and prostate cancer. Our aim was to assess the role of ZIP4 in invasiveness, migration and apoptosis of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC). The prognostic value of ZIP4 in HCC after liver transplantation was evaluated.Methods: The role of ZIP4 in HCC was investigated by overexpressing ZIP4 in BEL7402 and HepG2 cells and inhibiting ZIP4 in HuH-7 and HepG2 cells, using overexpression and shRNA plasmids in vitro studies. Immunohistochemical analysis was used to evaluate ZIP4 expression in HCC tissues from 60 patients undergoing liver transplantation, 36 cirrhotic tissue samples, and 6 normal tissue samples. Prognostic significance was assessed using the Kaplan-Meier method and the log-rank test.Results: Specific suppression of ZIP4 reduced cell migration and invasiveness, whereas ZIP4 overexpression caused increases in cell migration and invasiveness. Furthermore, overexpression of ZIP4 resulted in increased expression of pro-metastatic genes (MMP-2, MMP-9) and decreased expression of pro-apoptotic genes (caspase-3, caspase-9, Bax). In contrast, suppression of ZIP4 resulted in an opposite effect. ZIP4 was more highly expressed in tumor tissues than non-tumor tissues (P < 0.0001). ZIP4 expression was significantly associated with tumor recurrence (P = 0.002), tumor node metastasis stage (P = 0.044), Child-Turcotte-Pugh score (P = 0.042), and tumor size (P = 0.022). Univariate analysis showed that ZIP4 expression was significantly associated with overall survival (P = 0.020) and tumor-free survival (P = 0.049). Multivariate analysis revealed that ZIP4 was an independent predictor of overall survival (P = 0.037) after liver transplantation.Conclusions: ZIP4 could promote migration, invasiveness, and suppress apoptosis in hepatocellular carcinoma, and represent a novel predictor of poor prognosis and therapeutic target for patients with HCC who undergo liver transplantation.     

Increase in CD14+HLA-DR−/low myeloid-derived suppressor cells in hepatocellular carcinoma patients and its impact on prognosis

Myeloid-derived suppressor cells (MDSCs) are known as key immune regulators in various human malignancies, and it is reported that CD14⁺HLA-DR^?/low MDSCs are increased in hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) patients. However, the host factors that regulate the frequency and the effect on the prognosis of HCC patients are still unclear. We investigated these issues and clarified the relationships between a feature of MDSCs and host factors in HCC patients. We examined the frequency of MDSCs in 123 HCC patients, 30 chronic liver disease patients without HCC, and 13 healthy controls by flow cytometric analysis. The relationships between the clinical features and the frequency of MDSCs were analyzed. In 33 patients who received curative radiofrequency ablation (RFA) therapy, we examined the impact of MDSCs on HCC recurrence. The frequency of MDSCs in HCC patients was significantly increased. It was correlated with tumor progression, but not with the degree of liver fibrosis and inflammation. In terms of serum cytokines, the concentrations of IL-10, IL-13, and vascular endothelial growth factor were significantly correlated with the frequency of MDSCs. In HCC patients who received curative RFA therapy, the frequency of MDSCs after treatment showed various changes and was inversely correlated with recurrence-free survival time. The frequency of MDSCs is correlated with tumor progression, and this frequency after RFA is inversely correlated with the prognosis of HCC patients. Patients with a high frequency of MDSCs after RFA should be closely followed and the inhibition of MDSCs may improve the prognosis of patients.     

Role of alpha-fetoprotein in selection of patients with hepatocellular carcinoma waiting for liver transplantation: must we reconsider it?

Background: Milan criteria (MC) represent the most commonly adopted criteria for the selection of patients with hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) waiting for liver transplantation (LT). However, MC are exclusively based on morphological aspects. The aim of the present study was to evaluate pre-LT-detectable biological parameters, to compare them with morphological ones in terms of tumor recurrence prediction and patient survival. Methods: A cohort of 153 consecutive adult patients who underwent LT for HCC on cirrhosis from January 1999 to March 2009 was retrospectively analyzed. Results: HCC recurrence was observed in 12 patients (7.8%). At multivariate logistic regression analysis, serum alpha-fetoprotein (AFP) was the unique independent negative risk factor for the development of HCC recurrence (odds ratio 2.0, p=0.03). Adopting a cutoff value of 210 ng/mL, patients who presented serum AFP =210 ng/mL showed a 5-year survival rate of 23.3% versus 76.2% observed in patients with pre-LT serum AFP <210 ng/mL (log-rank test: <0.0001). Conclusions: In our experience, AFP was the strongest predictor of HCC recurrence, stronger than tumor morphology. AFP could ameliorate the selection of LT candidates. Further studies to evaluate the combination of morphological and biological criteria are needed.     

Unmasking of alpha-fetoprotein-specific CD4(+) T cell responses in hepatocellular carcinoma patients undergoing embolization

Necrosis of tumor cells can activate both innate and adaptive antitumor immunity. However, there is little information on the effects of necrosis-inducing cancer treatments on tumor-specific T cell immune responses in humans. We studied the effects of a necrosis-inducing treatment (embolization) on anti-alpha-fetoprotein (AFP)-specific CD4(+) T cell responses in hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) patients and controls using an array of AFP-derived peptides. In this study, we show that AFP-specific CD4(+) T cell responses to three immunodominant epitopes in HCC patients were significantly expanded during (p < 0.0001) and after embolization (p < 0.002). The development of higher frequencies of AFP-specific CD4(+) T cells after treatment were significantly associated with the induction of >50% necrosis of tumor and an improved clinical outcome (p < 0.007). In addition, we identified two novel HLA-DR-restricted AFP-derived CD4(+) T cell epitopes (AFP(137-145) and AFP(249-258)) and showed that the CD4(+) T cells recognizing these epitopes produce Th1 (IFN-gamma and TNF-alpha) but not Th2 (IL-5)-type cytokines. AFP(137-145)-, AFP(249-258)-, and AFP(364-373)-specific CD4(+) T cells were detected in HCC patients but not in patients with chronic liver diseases or healthy donors. In conclusion; our study shows that induction of tumor necrosis by a conventional cancer treatment can unmask tumor rejection Ag cell-mediated immunity and provides a rationale for combining embolization with immunotherapy in HCC patients.     

肝细胞肝癌E-Cadherin蛋白的表达及其对判断肝癌肝移植疗效的意义

目的：探讨E-Cadherin蛋白在肝细胞肝癌组织中的表达及其对判断肝癌肝移植患者预后的价值。方法：选择肝细胞肝癌行全肝移植患者68例,应用免疫组化方法检测其切除的肝癌组织和癌旁正常肝组织中E-Cadherin蛋白的表达情况,并对患者进行移植术后随访,分析E-Cadherin蛋白表达与肝癌肝移植患者预后的关系。结果：肝癌组织中E-Cadherin蛋白阳性表达率明显低于癌旁组织（P〈0.01）。经Logrank检验分析显示,E-Cadherin蛋白低表达组移植后的无瘤生存率明显低于E-Cadherin蛋白高表达组（P〈0.01）。多因素Cox回归分析显示,E-Cadherin蛋白表达是影响肝细胞肝癌患者肝移植术后肝癌复发的独立预后因素之一。结论：E-Cadherin蛋白表达是一个预测肝细胞肝癌患者肝移植预后的重要因子。     

Differentially expressed genes between early and advanced hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) as a potential tool for selecting liver transplant recipients

Hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) is the fifth most common cancer in the world. Liver transplantation (LT) represents a curative treatment for "small" HCC. Preoperative staging is critical in selecting optimal candidates for LT to optimize the use of this scarce resource. From December 1997 to February 2004, 148 patients diagnosed with cirrhosis and HCC were evaluated at our center. After staging, the patients were listed for LT according to United Network for Organ Sharing (UNOS) criteria. When pretransplant liver MRIs were compared with the findings of the explanted livers, 8 of 35 patients (22.8%) were understaged. Three of the 8 patients (37.5%) had recurrence post-LT. A retrospective gene expression profiling study was done using microarray technology for tumor samples in the pretransplant hepatitis C virus (HCV)-HCC understaged patients and in a contemporaneous group of HCV-HCC patients that were accurately staged. Two sample t tests comparing the early versus advanced HCV-HCCs with respect to gene expression showed an important set of genes differentially expressed among the samples. Hierarchical clustering analysis of the gene expression profiling classified 93.8% of the total tumor samples and 85.7% of the understaged samples in concordance with the explanted pathological staging. We found a distinctive pattern of gene expression between early and advanced HCV-HCCs. These results suggest that gene expression profiling could improve the pre-LT HCC staging to more closely mimic the explant pathology. Whether gene expression profiling of HCC will be refined to the point of predicting potential metastatic biologic behavior to predict post-LT recurrence will require longitudinal prospective study of this gene array technology.     

Association of mortalin (HSPA9) with liver cancer metastasis and prediction for early tumor recurrence

Hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) is well known for poor prognosis and short survival because of high recurrence rate even after curative surgery. Today there is no available biomarker or biochemical test to indicate HCC recurrence, and this study aims to identify protein markers that can discriminate postoperative patients with early recurrence (ER), i.e. disease relapsed within the first year. In this study, 103 hepatitis B-related HCC patients were recruited, and 68 of them were used for ER-related biomarker discovery study. Proteomic expression patterns of matched tumor and adjacent non-tumor tissues from these patients plus 16 normal liver tissues were delineated by the two-dimensional gel electrophoresis differential profiling method. Significant protein spots were evaluated by hierarchical clustering analysis. SSP4612 that yielded the highest receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve value for the ER subgroup of HCC was subsequently identified by tandem mass spectrometry, and the corresponding expression patterns were further confirmed by quantitative PCR, Western blot, and immunohistochemistry. Correlation analysis with clinicopathological data was also examined. Proteomic profiling analysis revealed overexpression of mortalin (gene HSPA9) in HCC when compared with the non-tumor and normal liver tissues (area under the curve (AUC) = 0.821). Furthermore, elevated mortalin level was also detected in the ER subgroup of HCC versus the recurrence-free state (where no cancer recurs for >1 year) (AUC = 0.833, sensitivity = 90.9%, specificity = 71.4%). Metastatic HCC cell lines also exhibited higher levels of mortalin and HSPA9 mRNA. Clinically, mortalin overexpression in HCC was closely associated with advanced tumor stages and venous infiltration, having implications for increased malignancy and aggressive behavior. Mortalin (HSPA9) is associated with HCC metastasis and thus suggested as a tumor marker for predicting early recurrence, which may have immediate clinical applications for cancer surveillance after curative surgery.     

Intrahepatic Tissue Implantation Represents a Favorable Approach for Establishing Orthotopic Transplantation Hepatocellular Carcinoma Mouse Models

Mouse models are commonly used for studying hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) biology and exploring new therapeutic interventions. Currently three main modalities of HCC mouse models have been extensively employed in pre-clinical studies including chemically induced, transgenic and transplantation models. Among them, transplantation models are preferred for evaluating in vivo drug efficacy in pre-clinical settings given the short latency, uniformity in size and close resemblance to tumors in patients. However methods used for establishing orthotopic HCC transplantation mouse models are diverse and fragmentized without a comprehensive comparison. Here, we systemically evaluate four different approaches commonly used to establish HCC mice in preclinical studies, including intravenous, intrasplenic, intrahepatic inoculation of tumor cells and intrahepatic tissue implantation. Four parameters—the latency period, take rates, pathological features and metastatic rates—were evaluated side-by-side. 100% take rates were achieved in liver with intrahepatic, intrasplenic inoculation of tumor cells and intrahepatic tissue implantation. In contrast, no tumor in liver was observed with intravenous injection of tumor cells. Intrahepatic tissue implantation resulted in the shortest latency with 0.5cm (longitudinal diameter) tumors found in liver two weeks after implantation, compared to 0.1cm for intrahepatic inoculation of tumor cells. Approximately 0.1cm tumors were only visible at 4 weeks after intrasplenic inoculation. Uniform, focal and solitary tumors were formed with intrahepatic tissue implantation whereas multinodular, dispersed and non-uniform tumors produced with intrahepatic and intrasplenic inoculation of tumor cells. Notably, metastasis became visible in liver, peritoneum and mesenterium at 3 weeks post-implantation, and lung metastasis was visible after 7 weeks. T cell infiltration was evident in tumors, resembling the situation in HCC patients. Our study demonstrated that orthotopic HCC mouse models established via intrahepatic tissue implantation authentically reflect clinical manifestations in HCC patients pathologically and immunologically, suggesting intrahepatic tissue implantation is a preferable approach for establishing orthotopic HCC mouse models.