Fault bars and fluctuating asymmetry in birds: are the two measures correlated?

ABSTRACT.   As bio-indicators, bilateral asymmetry and fault bar formation have been found to be correlated with environmental quality, body condition, and individual fitness. Although commonly used as indices of the same parameters, it is not clear whether asymmetry and fault bars are equivalent measures of developmental history. We tested the possible relationship between these two metrics by measuring the degree of asymmetry and the number of fault bars in the wing and tail feathers of migrating White-throated Sparrows ( Zonotrichia albicollis ) at Long Point Bird Observatory on Lake Erie, Ontario, during October 2004. Within individuals, we found no relationship between the occurrence of fault bars and degree of bilateral asymmetry. In addition, individuals with higher fat scores had more symmetrical wings than individuals with lower scores, but did not have fewer fault bars. Together, these results suggest that fluctuating asymmetry and fault bar occurrence should not be used interchangeably as bio-indicators.     

Patterns of fluctuating asymmetry in flowers: Implications for sexual selection in plants

Characters in animals used in signalling and subjected to strong directional selection often demonstrate (i) an elevated level of fluctuating asymmetry (small random deviations from bilateral symmetry) and (ii) a negative relationship between the degree of individual fluctuating asymmetry and the size of a given character. We tested these two predictions in plants since flowers are subjected to strong directional selection and are involved in signalling to pollinators, whereas leaves are supposed not to be directly involved in signalling. The overall level of fluctuating asymmetry in a number of plant species with bilaterally or radially symmetric flowers was not generally higher in floral traits than in leaves. The level of fluctuating asymmetry in plants was sometimes significantly consistent within individuals. The absolute degree of individual fluctuating asymmetry in floral traits was generally negatively related to the size of the trait, while there was a positive relationship for leaves. The degree of individual fluctuating asymmetry in floral traits was marginally negatively related to the degree of individual fluctuating asymmetry in leaf traits. These patterns of fluctuating asymmetry in plants suggest that (i) the degree of asymmetry in flowers signals different aspects of quality than does the degree of asymmetry in leaves, and that (ii) fluctuating asymmetry in flowers often reflects the phenotypic quality of individual plants.     

Developmental stability in yellow dung flies (Scathophaga stercoraria): fluctuating asymmetry,heterozygosity and environmental stress

The genetic basis for developmental stability, the ability of an organism to withstand genetic and environmental disturbance of development, is poorly understood. Fluctuating asymmetry (FA: small random deviations from symmetry in paired, bilateral traits) is the most widely used measure of developmental stability, and evidence suggests FA is weakly and negatively associated with genome‐wide heterozygosity. We investigated the genetic basis of developmental stability in the yellow dung fly. Fly lines were inbred for 16 generations at which time they were homozygous at the phosphoglucomutase (PGM) loci and PGM appears to influence FA in at least one other taxon. After 16 generations of inbreeding, lines homozygous for different PGM alleles were crossed and levels of FA for four metric traits were compared in the inbred and crossed flies. We also compared FA levels in these flies with previously gathered data on wild‐type (second generation outcrossed) flies, and additionally looked at the effects of two environmental stresses (larval food limitation and increased temperature) on FA. There were no significant differences in any measure of FA, nor in mean FA, in any trait when inbred and crossed flies were compared. Comparison of FA in these and wild flies also revealed no significant differences. Food limitation had no influence on FA, whereas heat stress increased FA of naturally, but not sexually, selected traits. Our results do not show a negative relationship between heterozygosity and FA, but support the notion that FA levels are stress, trait and taxon specific.     

No relationship between fluctuating asymmetry and fitness in Lychnis viscaria

Several earlier studies have indicated a negative relationship between fluctuating asymmetry (FA) and fitness. We tested this assumption by investigating the association between petal asymmetry and several fitness-related characters among natural and common garden populations of Lychnis viscaria. Neither seed set, germination percentage nor the growth rate of seedlings were related to the level of flower asymmetry either among natural populations or in common garden conditions. The only significant association found was a positive connection between petal asymmetry and seed mass measured from natural populations. Thus, in contrary to many earlier published reports, we did not find any evidence for a negative relationship between FA and fitness even if we controlled for measurement error, we had adequate sample size and we measured these characters in two environments. This suggests that FA is not consistently related to individual quality and fitness.     

Does fluctuating asymmetry of wing traits capture relative environmental stress in a lepidopteran?

1. Fluctuating asymmetry (FA) is hypothesized to be a useful predictor of population canalization, especially for organisms at risk from environmental change.
2. Identification of traits that meet statistical criteria as FA measures remains a challenge.
3. Here, a laboratory experiment subjected immature butterflies (Vanessa cardui) to diet and temperature conditions of varying stress levels. Variation in dietary macronutrient ratio (protein: carbohydrate) and rearing temperature (optimal: 25°C; elevated: 32°C) was introduced as stressors. Temperature and nutrition are key variables influencing ectotherm growth and fitness and so are likely to be important stressors that influence FA.
4. Individuals subjected to stressful conditions were predicted to show elevated FA of three wing size traits, as well as increased mortality and decreased adult body size.
5. Trait FA did not vary across treatments. Instead, treatment levels impacted viability: The combined incidence of pupal death and expression of significant wing malformations increased in treatment levels designated as stressful. Variation in adult dry mass also reflected predicted stress levels. Results suggest that individuals predicted to display increased FA either died or displayed gross developmental aberrations.
6. This experiment illustrates important constraints on the investigation of FA, including selection of appropriate traits and identification of appropriate levels of stressors to avoid elevated mortality. The latter concern brings into question the utility of FA as an indicator of stress in vulnerable, natural populations, where stress levels cannot be controlled, and mortality and fitness effects are often not quantifiable.

     

Mixture analysis of asymmetry: modelling directional asymmetry, antisymmetry and heterogeneity in fluctuating asymmetry

The occurrence of different forms of asymmetry complicates the analysis and interpretation of patterns in asymmetry. Furthermore, between-individual heterogeneity in developmental stability (DS) and thus fluctuating asymmetry (FA), is required to find relationships between DS and other factors. Separating directional asymmetry (DA) and antisymmetry (AS) from real FA and understanding between-individual heterogeneity in FA is therefore crucial in the analysis and interpretation of patterns in asymmetry. In this paper we introduce and explore mixture analysis to (i) identify FA, DA and AS from the distribution of the signed asymmetry, and (ii) to model and quantify between-individual heterogeneity in developmental stability and FA. In addition, we expand mixtures to the estimation of the proportion of variation in the unsigned FA that can be attributed to between-individual heterogeneity in the presumed underlying developmental stability (the so-called hypothetical repeatability). Finally, we construct weighted normal probability plots to investigate the assumption of underlying normality of the different components. We specifically show that (i) model selection based on the likelihood ratio test has the potential to yield models that incorporate nearly all heterogeneity in FA; (ii) mixtures appear to be a powerful and sensitive statistical technique to identify the different forms of asymmetry; (iii) restricted measurement accuracy and the occurrence of many zero observations results in an overestimation of the hypothetical repeatability on the basis of the model parameters; and (iv) as judged from the high correlation coefficients of the normal probability plots, the underlying normality assumption appears to hold for the empirical data we analysed. In conclusion, mixtures provide a useful statistical tool to study patterns in asymmetry.     

Ethoxyresorufin O-deethylase (EROD) activity and fluctuating asymmetry (FA) in Zosterisessor ophiocephalus (Teleostei, Gobiidae) as indicators of environmental stress in the Venice lagoon

The impact of environmental stress on the grassgoby, Zosterisessor ophiocephalus, wasstudied at both biochemical and morphologicallevels, by comparing three sites in the Venicelagoon (the Northern, Central and Southernbasins) which differ in terms of the degree ofanthropogenic disturbance, in particular withregard to organic sediment contamination. At abiochemical level, the hepatic ethoxyresorufinO-deethylase (EROD) enzyme activity wasmeasured as a biomarker of the degree oforganic pollution (in particular regardingcontamination by PCBs and Dioxins). At amorphological level, the amount of fluctuatingasymmetry (FA) with regard to four bilateraltraits (postorbital length; otolith area;minimum otolith diameter; maximum and minimumotolith radii) was measured as a long termindicator of developmental stress. The ERODactivity was higher in grass gobies from theCentral basin, whereas the amount of FA washigher in the gobies collected from theNorthern basin. Both measurements indicatedthat the Southern basin was affected by lowlevels of environmental stress (low ERODinduction and a lower amount of FA). Theresults were discussed in the light of both theenvironmental differences among the threebasins and the different levels of biologicalorganisation at which the two indicators act.     

Fluctuating asymmetry inMacaca fascicularis: A study of the etiology of developmental noise

Fluctuating asymmetry was determined for six cranial measurements in an age-diverse sample of 138 individuals ofMacaca fascicularis. These data were used to choose among four hypotheses concerning the etiology of developmental noise. The hypotheses considered are (1) that developmental noise represents asymmetry in the causal history of a developing organism's interaction with the environment, (2) that it represents stochasticity in the mechanics of growth and induction, (3) that it reflects variation in the initial conditions of a developmental process, and (4) that it represents the random accumulation of noise at a level below that of morphogenetic mechanism. These hypotheses were tested against predictions concerning the intraspecific patterning of fluctuating asymmetry against age and size and the covariation of asymmetry values. Only the predictions of the fourth hypothesis were confirmed by results of this study. These results provide evidence for the view that developmental noise, as reflected by fluctuating asymmetry, is an intrinsic property of developmental systems, and not merely produced by the complexity of the organism's interaction with the environment.     

Evolution of faster development does not lead to greater fluctuating asymmetry of sternopleural bristle number inDrosophila

Both strong directional selection and faster development are thought to destabilize development, giving rise to greater fluctuating asymmetry (FA), although there is no strong empirical evidence supporting this assertion. We compared FA in sternopleural bristle number in four populations ofDrosophila melanogaster successfully selected for faster development from egg to adult, and in four control populations. The fraction of perfectly symmetric individuals was higher in the selected populations, whereas the FA levels did not differ significantly between selected and control populations, clearly indicating that directional selection for faster development has not led to increased FA in sternopleural bristle number in these populations. This may be because: (i) development time and FA are uncorrelated, (ii) faster development does result in FA, but selection has favoured developmentally stable individuals that can develop fast and still be symmetrical, or (iii) the increased fraction of symmetric individuals in the selected populations is an artifact of reduced body size. Although we cannot discriminate among these explanations, our results suggest that the relationship between development time, FA and fitness may be far more subtle than often thought.     

Parasites and the blackcap's tail: implications for the evolution of feather ornaments

Although parasites may impair the expression of tail ornaments in birds, the importance of parasitism in driving the evolution of the initial stages of tail ornamentation is not well understood. Parasites could have negatively affected the expression of nonexaggerated, functional traits before these evolved ornaments, or they could have played a relevant role only after tails became ornamental and hence too costly to produce. To shed light on this issue, we studied the correlation between the abundance of feather mites (Acari, Proctophyllodidae) and the size, quality, growth rate and symmetry of tail feathers of blackcaps ( Sylvia atricapilla ), a non-ornamented passerine. Tail length was not correlated with mite load, yet blackcaps holding many mites at the moment of feather growth (fledglings) had lighter and more asymmetric feathers that grew at relatively lower rates. In blackcaps whose mite load was measured one year after feather growth (adults), only the negative correlation between mite intensity and feather symmetry remained significant. Changes in mite load since the moult season could have erased the correlation between condition-dependent feather traits and current parasite load in adults. Our results support the idea that different traits of non-ornamental feathers can signal parasite resistance. Therefore, parasitism could have played a central role in the evolution of tail ornamentation ever since its initial stages.  © 2002 The Linnean Society of London. Biological Journal of the Linnean Society , 2002, 76 , 481–492.     

Developmental instability in Brassica campestris (Cruciferae): fluctuating asymmetry of foliar and floral traits

The degree of fluctuating asymmetry of bilateral traits provides a measure of developmental instability, which can be influenced by genetic as well as environmental stress. We studied genetic variation between and within two populations of the mustard Brassica campestris for asymmetry of foliar (cotyledon width) and floral (petal length and width) traits as well as for phenological (germination and flowering) and performance (biomass and flowering) traits. The two populations differed in mean expression of most traits, including asymmetry. However, within-population estimates of genetic variability tended to be lower for asymmetry than other traits. Asymmetry was greater in the population that had lower biomass accumulation and flower production, which supports the idea that population-level asymmetry may be indicative of population-level performance. However, within each population, evidence that performance was negatively correlated with asymmetry was equivocal. Within populations there was little or no concordance among estimates of asymmetry based on different structures, i.e., plants that had highly asymmetrical cotyledons did not tend to have highly asymmetrical petals. The lack of a general buffering capacity at the individual level may be explained by developmental processes (e.g., action of different genes or morphogens) as well as evolutionary processes (e.g., selection on asymmetry of different traits).     

Trait variability and stress: canalization, developmental stability and the need for a broad approach

Trait variability (particularly fluctuating asymmetry) may provide a general measure of environmental stress applicable across taxa but consistent empirical support is lacking. Historically, stress effects were considered to act independently on trait canalization, developmental noise and trait size. However, in trait comparisons these processes are often assumed to be associated. Here we reconsider this issue and implications for detecting stress effects using trait variability. Published studies that consider multiple environments report little association between the effects of environmental variation on trait canalization and on developmental noise measured as fluctuating asymmetry, sug-gesting that environmental effects often act independently on these processes. To further test the usefulness of trait variability as an indicator of stress, comparisons across environ-ments should take a broad approach and report on several measures of trait variability, rather than focusing on only one index of fluctuating asymmetry as is commonly done.     

Fluctuating asymmetry for specific bristle characters in Notch mutants of Drosophila melanogaster

Asymmetry has been used as a measure of developmental stability for bilaterally symmetrical organisms. Most studies have failed to partition the genetic and environmental contributions to the asymmetry phenotype due to the limitations of the systems used or the shortcomings in experimental design. The Notch mutants of Drosophila melanogaster were used to study the genetic contribution to asymmetry for six different bristle characters. Asymmetry response was character specific for the mutants examined. For N ^spl, N ^Co, N ^264–47, Ax ^71d, Ax ^9B2, Ax ^E2, l(1)N ^B and nd ² significant asymmetry responses, relative to wildtype Canton‐S, were observed for some characters. N ^60g11 and nd ¹ did not exhibit significant asymmetry for any of the characters examined. All of the mutants except N ^60g11 and nd ¹ showed thoracic bristle asymmetry. However, when asymmetry scores were pooled over the five bristle characters which individually exhibited fluctuating asymmetry, no significant differences were found between any genotypes. Therefore pooling asymmetry values across characters obscures the significant character specific asymmetry values observed. Thus caution is necessary when using the asymmetry phenotype of specific characters to draw organism wide conclusions about developmental stability. This revised version was published online in July 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Effect of directional selection for body size on fluctuating asymmetry in certain morphological traits in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Drosophila ananassae</Emphasis>

Variation in the subtle differences between the right and left sides of bilateral characters or fluctuating asymmetry (FA) has been considered as an indicator of an organism’s ability to cope with genetic and environmental stresses during development. However, due to inconsistency in the results of empirical studies, the relationship between FA and stress has been the subject of intense debate. In this study, we investigated whether stress caused by artificial bidirectional selection for body size has any effect on the levels of FA of different morphological traits in Drosophila ananassae. The realised heritability (h²) was higher in low-line females and high-line males, which suggests an asymmetrical response to selection for body size. Further, the levels of FA were compared across 10 generations of selection in different selection lines in both sexes for sternopleural bristle number, wing length, wing-to-thorax ratio, sex comb-tooth number and ovariole number. The levels of FA differed significantly among generations and selection lines but did not change markedly with directional selection. However, the levels of FA were higher in the G10 generation (at the end of selection) than G0 (at the start of selection) but lower than the G5 generation in different selection lines, suggesting that the levels of FA are not affected by the inbreeding generated during the course of selection. Also, the levels of FA in the hybrids of high and low lines were significantly lower than the parental selection lines, suggesting that FA is influenced by hybridisation. These results are discussed in the framework of the literature available on FA and its relationship with stress.     

The effect of avermectin B1 on developmental stability in the bush fly, Musca vetustissima, as measured by fluctuating asymmetry

Fluctuating asymmetry is used as an indicator of developmental stability to assess the effect of exposure to Avermectin B₁ on normal developmental processes in the bush fly, Musca vetustissima Walker (Diptera: Muscidae). Flies breeding in dung from cattle treated with Avermectin B₁ were found to be significantly more asymmetric for two morphometric characters (wing vein lengths), than those breeding in dung from either untreated cattle or cattle treated with Levamisole-HCl at times when fly survival was not affected by the treatments. Fluctuating asymmetry is shown to be a valuable means of defining developmental stress in situations where conventional estimates such as survival show no response.

---

Résumé La fluctuation de l'asymétrie a été utilisée comme indice de la stabilité du développement pour mettre en évidence l'effet de l'exposition à l'avermectine B₁ au cours du développement de M. vetustissima. Les mouches élevées sur bouses de vaches traitées à l'avermectine B₁ sont devenues significativement plus asymétriques pour 2 caractères morphométriques (longueurs des veines de l'aile) que celles élevées sur bouses de vaches témoins ou de vaches traitées au Levamisole-HCl, même quand la survie des mouches n'était pas affectée par le traitement. La fluctuation de l'asymétrie s'est avérée un bon critère pour définir des stress pendant le développement, alors que des critères conventionnels comme la survie ne permettent pas de déceler quoi que ce soit.

     

Exploration of the utility of fluctuating asymmetry as an indicator of river condition using larvae of the caddisfly Hydropsyche morosa (Trichoptera: Hydropsychidae)

Organisms are subject to three types of morphological asymmetry: Directional Asymmetry, Antiasymmetry and Fluctuating Asymmetry, but only the latter (FA) is related to the environmental stress acting upon individuals during their development. Larvae of Hydropsyche morosa from five rivers in Ontario, Canada, each exhibiting different degrees of human impact, were examined for FA. Specimens were obtained from collections in the Royal Ontario Museum dating back to 1951, and from fresh collections to 1999. Twelve morphological characters were assessed on both the left and right sides of 297 larvae, and eight of them demonstrated FA. There was a tendency to increase the levels of FA over time. Levels of nitrogen, conductivity and chloride in the river water, used as an index of pollution, were significantly and positively correlated with increasing incidence of FA in four of the characters, the remainder were independent of pollution.