Appropriate initiation of the strand exchange reaction promoted by RecA protein requires ATP hydrolysis

The DNA-dependent ATPase activity of the Escherichia coli RecA protein has been recognized for more than two decades. Yet, the role of ATP hydrolysis in the RecA-promoted strand exchange reaction remains unclear. Here, we demonstrate that ATP hydrolysis is required as part of a proofreading process during homology recognition. It enables the RecA-ssDNA complex, after determining that the strand-exchanged duplex is mismatched, to dissociate from the synaptic complex, which allows it to re-initiate the search for a "true" homologous region. Furthermore, the results suggest that when non-homologous sequences are present at the proximal end, ATP hydrolysis is required to allow ssDNA-RecA to reinitiate the strand exchange from an internal homologous region.     

Force and ATP hydrolysis dependent regulation of RecA nucleoprotein filament by single-stranded DNA binding protein

In Escherichia coli, the filament of RecA formed on single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) is essential for recombinational DNA repair. Although ssDNA-binding protein (SSB) plays a complicated role in RecA reactions in vivo, much of our understanding of the mechanism is based on RecA binding directly to ssDNA. Here we investigate the role of SSB in the regulation of RecA polymerization on ssDNA, based on the differential force responses of a single 576-nucleotide-long ssDNA associated with RecA and SSB. We find that SSB outcompetes higher concentrations of RecA, resulting in inhibition of RecA nucleation. In addition, we find that pre-formed RecA filaments de-polymerize at low force in an ATP hydrolysis- and SSB-dependent manner. At higher forces, re-polymerization takes place, which displaces SSB from ssDNA. These findings provide a physical picture of the competition between RecA and SSB under tension on the scale of the entire nucleoprotein SSB array, which have broad biological implications particularly with regard to competitive molecular binding.     

Formin is a processive motor that requires profilin to accelerate actin assembly and associated ATP hydrolysis

Motile and morphogenetic cellular processes are driven by site-directed assembly of actin filaments. Formins, proteins characterized by formin homology domains FH1 and FH2, are initiators of actin assembly. How formins simply bind to filament barbed ends in rapid equilibrium or find free energy to become a processive motor of filament assembly remains enigmatic. Here we demonstrate that the FH1-FH2 domain accelerates hydrolysis of ATP coupled to profilin-actin polymerization and uses the derived free energy for processive polymerization, increasing 15-fold the rate constant for profilin-actin association to barbed ends. Profilin is required for and takes part in the processive function. Single filaments grow at least 10 microm long from formin bound beads without detaching. Transitory formin-associated processes are generated by poisoning of the processive cycle by barbed-end capping proteins. We successfully reconstitute formin-induced motility in vitro, demonstrating that this mechanism accounts for the puzzlingly rapid formin-induced actin processes observed in vivo.     

On the role of ATP hydrolysis in RecA protein-mediated DNA strand exchange. II. Four-strand exchanges.

RecA protein promotes a substantial DNA strand exchange reaction in the presence of adenosine 5'-O-3-(thio)triphosphate (ATP gamma S) (Menetski et al., 1990), calling into question the role of ATP hydrolysis in this reaction. We demonstrate here that the ATP gamma S-mediated process is restricted to homologous strand exchange reactions involving three strands. In four-strand exchanges between a gapped duplex circle and a second linear duplex, joint molecules are formed in the gap but are not extended into the four-strand region when ATP gamma S is present. This result provides evidence that one function of ATP hydrolysis in the recA system is to facilitate reciprocal DNA strand exchange involving four strands. Implications with respect to the role of four-stranded pairing intermediates and the mechanistic relationship between three- and four-strand exchange reactions are discussed.     

On the role of ATP hydrolysis in RecA protein-mediated DNA strand exchange. I. Bypassing a short heterologous insert in one DNA substrate.

RecA protein promotes a substantial DNA strand exchange reaction in the presence of adenosine 5'-O-3-(thio)triphosphate (ATP gamma S) (Menetski, J.P., Bear, D.G., and Kowalczykowski, S.C. (1990) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 87, 21-25), calling into question the role of ATP hydrolysis in the strand exchange reaction. Here, we demonstrate that the ATP gamma S-mediated reaction can go to completion when the duplex DNA substrate is only 1.3 kilobase pairs in length. The ATP gamma S-mediated reaction, however, is completely blocked by a 52-base pair heterologous insertion in either DNA substrate. This same barrier is readily bypassed when ATP replaces ATP gamma S. This indicates that at least one function of recA-mediated ATP hydrolysis is to bypass structural barriers in one or both DNA substrates during strand exchange. This suggests that ATP hydrolysis is directly coupled to the branch migration phase of strand exchange, not to promote strand exchange between homologous DNA substrates during recombination, but instead to facilitate the bypass of structural barriers likely to be encountered during recombinational DNA repair.     

The homologous pairing domain of RecA also mediates the allosteric regulation of DNA binding and ATP hydrolysis: a remarkable concentration of functional residues

Switching between the active (ATP and DNA bound) and inactive conformations of the homologous recombination RecA protein is regulated by ATP hydrolysis. First, we use the homologous pairing domain of RecA derived from its mobile loop L2 to show that the interaction of this random coil peptide with the gamma-phosphate of ATP results in a peptide beta-conformation similar to that previously shown to be induced by DNA binding. Next, we show that in the whole RecA protein two residues in this L2 domain, Gln194 and Arg196, are catalytic amino acid residues for ATP hydrolysis and functionally resemble the corresponding residues engaged in GTP hydrolysis by two distinct classes of G proteins. Finally, we show that the role of DNA and high salt in the stimulation of the ATPase of RecA is to stabilize this highly mobile region involved in hydrolysis. This is a role similar to that described for RGSs in the activation of the GTPase of heterotrimeric G proteins. Therefore, (i) a prototypical DNA-dependent ATPase and ATP-stimulated DNA-binding protein, RecA, and eukaryotic signaling proteins share common stereochemical regulatory mechanisms; and (ii) in a remarkable example of parsimony, loop L2 is a molecular switch that controls both ATP promoted DNA binding and pairing reactions and DNA stimulated ATP hydrolysis.     

Modulation of MutS ATP hydrolysis by DNA cofactors

Escherichia coli MutS protein, which is required for mismatch repair, has a slow ATPase activity that obeys Michalelis-Menten kinetics. At 37 degrees C, the steady-state turnover rate for ATP hydrolysis is 1.0 +/- 0.3 min(-1) per monomer equivalent with a K(m) of 33 +/- 6 microM. Hydrolysis is competitively inhibited by the ATP analogues AMPPNP and ATPgammaS, with K(i) values of 4 microM in both cases, and by ADP with a K(i) of 40 microM. The rate of ATP hydrolysis is stimulated 2-5-fold by short hetero- and homoduplex DNAs. The concentration of DNA cofactor that yields half-maximal stimulation is lowest for oligodeoxynucleotide duplexes that contain a mismatched base pair. Pre-steady-state chemical quench analysis has demonstrated a substoichiometric initial burst of ADP formation by free MutS that is governed by a rate constant of 78 min(-1), indicating that the rate-limiting step for the steady-state reaction occurs after hydrolysis. Prebinding of MutS to homoduplex DNA does not alter the burst kinetics or amplitude but only increases the steady-state rate. In contrast, binding of the protein to heteroduplex DNA abolishes the burst of ADP formation, indicating that the rate-limiting step now occurs before hydrolysis. Gel filtration analysis indicates that the MutS dimer assembles into higher order oligomers in a concentration-dependent manner, and that ATP binding shifts this equilibrium to favor assembly. These results, together with kinetic findings, indicate nonequivalence of subunits within a MutS oligomer with respect to ATP hydrolysis and DNA binding.     

Vanadate-induced trapping of nucleotides by purified maltose transport complex requires ATP hydrolysis

The maltose transport system in Escherichia coli is a member of the ATP-binding cassette superfamily of transporters that is defined by the presence of two nucleotide-binding domains or subunits and two transmembrane regions. The bacterial import systems are unique in that they require a periplasmic substrate-binding protein to stimulate the ATPase activity of the transport complex and initiate the transport process. Upon stimulation by maltose-binding protein, the intact MalFGK(2) transport complex hydrolyzes ATP with positive cooperativity, suggesting that the two nucleotide-binding MalK subunits interact to couple ATP hydrolysis to transport. The ATPase activity of the intact transport complex is inhibited by vanadate. In this study, we investigated the mechanism of inhibition by vanadate and found that incubation of the transport complex with MgATP and vanadate results in the formation of a stably inhibited species containing tightly bound ADP that persists after free vanadate and nucleotide are removed from the solution. The inhibited species does not form in the absence of MgCl(2) or of maltose-binding protein, and ADP or another nonhydrolyzable analogue does not substitute for ATP. Taken together, these data conclusively show that ATP hydrolysis must precede the formation of the vanadate-inhibited species in this system and implicate a role for a high-energy, ADP-bound intermediate in the transport cycle. Transport complexes containing a mutation in a single MalK subunit are still inhibited by vanadate during steady-state hydrolysis; however, a stably inhibited species does not form. ATP hydrolysis is therefore necessary, but not sufficient, for vanadate-induced nucleotide trapping.     

Secretory protein translocation in a yeast cell-free system can occur posttranslationally and requires ATP hydrolysis

We describe an in vitro system with all components derived from the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae that can translocate a yeast secretory protein across microsomal membranes. In vitro transcribed prepro-alpha-factor mRNA served to program a membrane-depleted yeast translation system. Translocation and core glycosylation of prepro-alpha-factor were observed when yeast microsomal membranes were added during or after translation. A membrane potential is not required for translocation. However, ATP is required for translocation and nonhydrolyzable analogues of ATP cannot serve as a substitute. These findings suggest that ATP hydrolysis may supply the energy required for translocation of proteins across the endoplasmic reticulum.     

Protease Ti from Escherichia coli requires ATP hydrolysis for protein breakdown but not for hydrolysis of small peptides

Protease Ti, a new ATP-dependent protease in Escherichia coli, degrades proteins and ATP in a linked process, but these two hydrolytic functions are catalyzed by distinct components of the enzyme. To clarify the enzyme's specificity and the role of ATP, a variety of fluorogenic peptides were tested as possible substrates for protease Ti or its two components. Protease Ti rapidly hydrolyzed N-succinyl(Suc)-Leu-Tyr-amidomethylcoumarin (AMC) (Km = 1.3 mM) which is not degraded by protease La, the other ATP-dependent protease in E. coli. Protease Ti also hydrolyzed, but slowly, Suc-Ala-Ala-Phe-AMC and Suc-Leu-Leu-Val-Tyr-AMC. However, it showed little or no activity against basic or other hydrophobic peptides, including ones degraded rapidly by protease La. Component P, which contains the serine-active site, by itself rapidly degrades the same peptides as the intact enzyme. Addition of component A, which contains the ATP-hydrolyzing site and is necessary for protein degradation, had little or no effect on peptide hydrolysis. N-Ethylmaleimide, which inactivates the ATPase, did not inhibit peptide hydrolysis. In addition, this peptide did not stimulate the ATPase activity of component A (unlike protein substrates). Thus, although the serine-active site on component P is unable to degrade proteins, it is fully functional against small peptides in the absence of ATP. At high concentrations, Suc-Leu-Tyr-AMC caused a complete inhibition of casein breakdown, and diisopropylfluorophosphate blocked similarly the hydrolysis of both protein and peptide substrates. Thus, both substrates seem to be hydrolyzed at the same active site on component P, and ATP hydrolysis by component A either unmasks or enlarges this proteolytic site such that large proteins can gain access to it.     

Complementation of one RecA protein point mutation by another. Evidence for trans catalysis of ATP hydrolysis

The RecA residues Lys248 and Glu96 are closely opposed across the RecA subunit-subunit interface in some recent models of the RecA nucleoprotein filament. The K248R and E96D single mutant proteins of the Escherichia coli RecA protein each bind to DNA and form nucleoprotein filaments but do not hydrolyze ATP or dATP. A mixture of K248R and E96D single mutant proteins restores dATP hydrolysis to 25% of the wild type rate, with maximum restoration seen when the proteins are present in a 1:1 ratio. The K248R/E96D double mutant RecA protein also hydrolyzes ATP and dATP at rates up to 10-fold higher than either single mutant, although at a reduced rate compared with the wild type protein. Thus, the K248R mutation partially complements the inactive E96D mutation and vice versa. The complementation is not sufficient to allow DNA strand exchange. The K248R and E96D mutations originate from opposite sides of the subunit-subunit interface. The functional complementation suggests that Lys248 plays a significant role in ATP hydrolysis in trans across the subunit-subunit interface in the RecA nucleoprotein filament. This could be part of a mechanism for the long range coordination of hydrolytic cycles between subunits within the RecA filament.     

Division of labor--sequential ATP hydrolysis drives assembly of a DNA polymerase sliding clamp around DNA.

The beta sliding clamp encircles DNA and enables processive replication of the Escherichia coli genome by DNA polymerase III holoenzyme. The clamp loader, gamma complex, assembles beta around DNA in an ATP-fueled reaction. Previous studies have shown that gamma complex opens the beta ring and also interacts with DNA on binding ATP. Here, a rapid kinetic analysis demonstrates that gamma complex hydrolyzes two ATP molecules sequentially when placing beta around DNA. The first ATP is hydrolyzed fast, at 25-30 s(-1), while the second ATP hydrolysis is limited to the steady-state rate of 2 s(-1). This step-wise reaction depends on both primed DNA and beta. DNA alone promotes rapid hydrolysis of two ATP molecules, while beta alone permits hydrolysis of only one ATP. These results suggest that beta inserts a slow step between the two ATP hydrolysis events in clamp assembly, during which the clamp loader may perform work on the clamp. Moreover, one ATP hydrolysis is sufficient for release of beta from the gamma complex. This implies that DNA-dependent hydrolysis of the other ATP is coupled to a separate function, perhaps involving work on DNA. A model is presented in which sequential ATP hydrolysis drives distinct events in the clamp-assembly pathway. We also discuss underlying principles of this step-wise mechanism that may apply to the workings of other ATP-fueled biological machines.     

In vitro packaging of bacteriophage T7 DNA requires ATP.

Removal of nucleoside triphosphates from extracts prepared from bacteriophage T7-infected Escherichia coli results in a stringent requirement for added ATP to form infective phage particles by in vitro packaging of bacteriophage T7 DNA. Optimal packaging efficiency was achieved at a concentration of about 1.25 mM. Other nucleoside triphosphates could be substituted for ATP, but none of the common nucleoside triphosphates was as effective as ATP in promoting in vitro encapsulation.     

Relationship between the functional regions of the RecA protein and ATP hydrolysis in UV-irradiated Escherichia coli cells.

The time course of the intracellular ATP concentration in several UV-irradiated RecA protease constitutive (Cptc) mutants of E. coli has been studied. All Cptc mutants harboring a mutation in region 3 of the RecA protein (including amino acid residues 298-301) increased ATP after UV damage but without any subsequent decrease. Nevertheless, these mutants induced the SOS response after UV irradiation. Likewise, truncated RecA proteins lacking region 3 are also unable to carry out massive ATP hydrolysis in UV-irradiated cells. On the other hand, mutants in region 1 (including amino acids 25-39) or 2 (amino acids 157-184) of the RecA protein showed an increase in ATP concentration during the first 20 min following UV irradiation, which dropped afterwards to the basal level. All these data indicate that region 3 of the RecA protein must be involved in the ATP hydrolysis process. Furthermore, a relationship between the quantity of the UV-mediated ATP produced and the strength of the different RecA Cptc mutants has also been found. Accordingly, both lexA71::Tn5 and null lexA mutants of E. coli only show a cellular ATP increase after UV irradiation when containing a multicopy plasmid carrying either a wild-type lexA or a lexA (Ind-) gene.     

TGF-beta1 inhibits BRCA1 expression through a pathway that requires pRb

TGF-beta1 inhibits BRCA1 expression, which contradicts the model that TGF-beta1 prevents carcinogenesis by activating tumor suppressor genes. To resolve this apparent contradiction, we examined BRCA1 expression in Mv1Lu cells, a well-established model system for studying the TGF-beta1 tumor suppressor pathway. We found that inactivation of pRb by the papillomavirus type 16 E7 protein increased BRCA1 expression and abolished the ability of TGF-beta1 to inhibit BRCA1 expression. We conclude that TGF-beta1 inhibits BRCA1 expression through a pathway that requires pRb. We propose a model to explain the inhibition of BRCA1 as a target in the TGF-beta1 tumor suppressor signaling pathway. Our results suggest that the tumor suppressor functions of BRCA1 are initiated by the inactivation of pRb, and therefore that the activation of pRb by TGF-beta1 might alleviate the requirement for BRCA1 function.     

Closing the folding chamber of the eukaryotic chaperonin requires the transition state of ATP hydrolysis

Chaperonins use ATPase cycling to promote conformational changes leading to protein folding. The prokaryotic chaperonin GroEL requires a cofactor, GroES, which serves as a "lid" enclosing substrates in the central cavity and confers an asymmetry on GroEL required for cooperative transitions driving the reaction. The eukaryotic chaperonin TRiC/CCT does not have such a cofactor but appears to have a "built-in" lid. Whether this seemingly symmetric chaperonin also operates through an asymmetric cycle is unclear. We show that unlike GroEL, TRiC does not close its lid upon nucleotide binding, but instead responds to the trigonal-bipyramidal transition state of ATP hydrolysis. Further, nucleotide analogs inducing this transition state confer an asymmetric conformation on TRiC. Similar to GroEL, lid closure in TRiC confines the substrates in the cavity and is essential for folding. Understanding the distinct mechanisms governing eukaryotic and bacterial chaperonin function may reveal how TRiC has evolved to fold specific eukaryotic proteins.     

Extent of duplex DNA underwinding induced by RecA protein binding in the presence of ATP

A method is described for the accurate determination of the superhelical density (omega) of highly underwound circular DNA molecules. Using this method, duplex DNA bound by RecA protein in the presence of ATP at pH 7.5 is found to be underwound by 39.6% (omega = -0.396), corresponding to a helical periodicity of 17.4 base-pairs per turn. The underwinding is increased to 41% (17.9 base-pairs per turn) in the presence of low levels of ATP gamma S, in good agreement with the 18.6 base-pairs per turn reported previously. In spite of the extensive underwinding, the distribution of DNA topoisomers produced by RecA protein binding is small. This indicates a high degree of structural uniformity among RecA-double-stranded DNA complexes in the presence of ATP.     

The Discovery of Error-prone DNA Polymerase V and Its Unique Regulation by RecA and ATP

My career pathway has taken a circuitous route, beginning with a Ph.D. degree in electrical engineering from The Johns Hopkins University, followed by five postdoctoral years in biology at Hopkins and culminating in a faculty position in biological sciences at the University of Southern California. My startup package in 1973 consisted of $2,500, not to be spent all at once, plus an ancient Packard scintillation counter that had a series of rapidly flashing light bulbs to indicate a radioactive readout in counts/minute. My research pathway has been similarly circuitous. The discovery of Escherichia coli DNA polymerase V (pol V) began with an attempt to identify the mutagenic DNA polymerase responsible for copying damaged DNA as part of the well known SOS regulon. Although we succeeded in identifying a DNA polymerase, one that was induced as part of the SOS response, we actually rediscovered DNA polymerase II, albeit in a new role. A decade later, we discovered a new polymerase, pol V, whose activity turned out to be regulated by bound molecules of RecA protein and ATP. This Reflections article describes our research trajectory, includes a review of key features of DNA damage-induced SOS mutagenesis leading us to pol V, and reflects on some of the principal researchers who have made indispensable contributions to our efforts.     

ATP hydrolysis and the displaced strand are two factors that determine the polarity of RecA-promoted DNA strand exchange.

When the recA protein (RecA) of Escherichia coli promotes strand exchange between single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) circles and linear double-stranded DNAs (dsDNA) with complementary 5' or 3' ends a polarity is observed. This property of RecA depends on ATP hydrolysis and the ssDNA that is displaced in the reaction since no polarity is observed in the presence of the non-hydrolyzable ATP analog, ATP gamma S, or in the presence of single-strand specific exonucleases. Based on these results a model is presented in which both the 5' and 3' complementary ends of the linear dsDNA initiate pairing with the ssDNA circle but only one end remains stably paired. According to this model, the association/dissociation of RecA in the 5' to 3' direction on the displaced strand determines the polarity of strand exchange by favoring or blocking its reinvasion into the newly formed dsDNA. Reinvasion is favored when the displaced strand is coated with RecA whereas it is blocked when it lacks RecA, remains covered by single-stranded DNA binding protein or is removed by a single-strand specific exonuclease. The requirement for ATP hydrolysis is explained if the binding of RecA to the displaced strand occurs via the dissociation and/or transfer of RecA, two functions that depend on ATP hydrolysis. The energy for strand exchange derives from the higher binding constant of RecA for the newly formed dsDNA as compared with that for ssDNA and not from ATP hydrolysis.     

DNA pairing and strand exchange by the Escherichia coli RecA and yeast Rad51 proteins without ATP hydrolysis: on the importance of not getting stuck

The bacterial RecA protein and the homologous Rad51 protein in eukaryotes both bind to single-stranded DNA (ssDNA), align it with a homologous duplex, and promote an extensive strand exchange between them. Both reactions have properties, including a tolerance of base analog substitutions that tend to eliminate major groove hydrogen bonding potential, that suggest a common molecular process underlies the DNA strand exchange promoted by RecA and Rad51. However, optimal conditions for the DNA pairing and DNA strand exchange reactions promoted by the RecA and Rad51 proteins in vitro are substantially different. When conditions are optimized independently for both proteins, RecA promotes DNA pairing reactions with short oligonucleotides at a faster rate than Rad51. For both proteins, conditions that improve DNA pairing can inhibit extensive DNA strand exchange reactions in the absence of ATP hydrolysis. Extensive strand exchange requires a spooling of duplex DNA into a recombinase-ssDNA complex, a process that can be halted by any interaction elsewhere on the same duplex that restricts free rotation of the duplex and/or complex, I.e. the reaction can get stuck. Optimization of an extensive DNA strand exchange without ATP hydrolysis requires conditions that decrease nonproductive interactions of recombinase-ssDNA complexes with the duplex DNA substrate.