Pyruvate kinase and creatine phosphokinase during development of the chicken with muscular dystrophy

Pyruvate kinase and creatine phosphokinase activities in breast muscle extracts and in serum, and protein content of the muscle extracts were determined during the first eight weeks of development of control and dystrophic chickens. In the dystrophic chicken serum enzyme levels were significantly greater than, and muscle protein content and enzyme activities on a gram wet weight basis were significantly less than control values, by the second week after hatching and thereafter. For both muscle and serum the relative differences between control and dystrophic groups was greater for pyruvate kinase than crearine phosphokinase. On a specific activity basis only pyruvate kinase levels in dystrophic muscle were significantly less than control values in 2–8-week-old chickens.     

The rapid disappearance of muscle AMP aminohydrolase from blood plasma of normal and dystrophic chickens

The levels of creatine kinase and pyruvate kinase are increased 22 and 9.3 fold respectively in the blood plasma of dystrophic chickens as compared to normal controls. AMP aminohydrolase levels are not increased despite their abundance in muscle tissue. When AMP aminohydrolase was injected into a blood vessel, its rate of disappearance from the plasma was rapid with 97% of the enzyme disappearing with a half-life of 3.3 minutes. In contrast, the rate of disappearance of pyruvate kinase from the blood plasma is relatively slow, following a biphasic exponential decay with half-lives of 113 min and 710 min. These data suggest that the rates of disappearance of enzymes from the blood plasma is an important factor in determining whether increased plasma levels of these enzymes are observed in muscular dystrophy.     

Decreased mitochondrial creatine kinase activity in dystrophic chicken breast muscle alters creatine-linked respiratory coupling

Dystrophic chicken breast muscle mitochondria contain significantly less mitochondrial creatine kinase than normal breast muscle mitochondria. Breast muscle mitochondria from normal 16- to 40-day-old chickens contain approximately 80 units of mitochondrial creatine kinase per unit of succinate:INT (p-iodonitrotetrazolium violet) reductase, a mitochondrial marker, while dystrophic chicken breast muscle mitochondria contain 36-44 units. Normal chicken heart muscle mitochondria contain about 10% of the mitochondrial creatine kinase per unit of succinate:INT reductase as normal breast muscle mitochondria. The levels in heart muscle mitochondria from dystrophic chickens are not affected significantly. Evidence is presented which shows that the reduced level of mitochondrial creatine kinase in dystrophic breast muscle mitochondria is responsible for an altered creatine linked respiration. First, both normal and dystrophic breast muscle mitochondria respire with the same state 3 and state 4 respiration. Second, the post-ADP state 4 rate of respiration of normal breast muscle mitochondria in the presence of 20 mM creatine continues at the state 3 rate. However, the state 4 rate of dystrophic breast muscle mitochondria and mitochondria from other muscle types with a low level of mitochondrial creatine kinase, such as heart muscle and 5-day-old chicken breast muscle, is slower than the state 3 rate. Third, dystrophic breast mitochondria synthesize ATP at the same rate as normal breast muscle mitochondria but rates of creatine phosphate synthesis in 20-50 mM Pi are reduced significantly. Finally, increasing concentrations of Pi displace mitochondrial creatine kinase from mitoplasts of normal and dystrophic breast muscle mitochondria with the same apparent KD, indicating that the outer surface of the inner mitochondrial membrane and the mitochondrial creatine kinase from dystrophic muscle are not altered.     

The amino acid sequence of the peptide containing the thiol group of creatine kinase from normal and dystrophic chicken breast muscle. Comparison of some of the immunological properties of the antibodies developed in rabbits against these enzymes

The major (14)C-labelled peptides from creatine kinase from normal and dystrophic chicken muscle obtained by carboxymethylating the reactive thiol groups with iodo[2-(14)C]acetic acid and digestion with trypsin were purified by ion-exchange chromatography on Dowex-50 (X2) and by paper electrophoresis. The chromatographic characteristics of the (14)C-labelled peptides, their electrophoretic mobilities at pH6.5, and their amino acid compositions were identical for the two enzymes. The sequence of amino acids around the essential thiol groups of creatine kinase from normal and dystrophic chicken muscle was shown to be Ile-Leu-Thr-CmCys-Pro-Ser-Asn-Leu-Gly-Thr-Gly-Leu-Arg (CmCys, carboxymethylcysteine). This sequence is almost identical with that for the creatine kinases in human and ox muscle and bovine brain and is very similar to that of arginine kinase from lobster muscle. Antibodies to the enzymes were raised in rabbits and their reaction with the creatine kinase from normal and dystrophic muscles in interfacial, immunodiffusion and immunoelectrophoretic experiments was studied. The cross-reaction between normal muscle creatine kinase and antisera against the dystrophic muscle enzyme (or vice versa) observed by immunodiffusion and by immunoelectrophoretic experiments further suggests that the enzymes from normal and dystrophic chicken muscle are similar in structure. The results of the present study, the identical amino acid sequence of the peptides containing the reactive thiol group from both the normal and dystrophic chicken muscle enzymes and the immunological similarities of the two enzymes are in accord with the similarity of the two enzymes observed by Roy et al. (1970).     

Content and synthesis of glycolytic enzymes and creatine kinase in skeletal muscles and normal and dystrophic chickens

A number of workers have reported that avian muscular dystrophy causes alterations in the levels of certain enzyme activities in "fast-twitch" muscle fibers but has little effect on enzyme activities in "slow-twitch" muscle fibers. In the present work, the effects of this disease on the content and relative rates of synthesis of a number of glycolytic enzymes and the skeletal muscle-specific MM isoenzyme of creatine kinase in chicken muscles was investigated. It was shown that (i) the approximate 50% reductions in steady-state concentrations of three glycolytic enzymes (aldolase, enolase, and glyceraldehyde-3-P dehydrogenase) in dystrophic breast (fast-twitch) muscle result predominantly from decreases in relative rates of synthesis, rather than accelerations in relative rates of degradation, of these proteins in the diseased tissue; (ii) in contrast to the situation with the glycolytic enzymes, muscular dystrophy has only minor effects (25% or less) on the content and relative rate of synthesis of MM creatine kinase in breast muscle fibers; (iii) the muscular dystrophy-associated alterations in content and synthesis of the glycolytic enzymes in breast muscle fibers become apparent only during postembryonic maturation of this tissue; and (iv) as expected, muscular dystrophy has no significant effect on the content or relative rates of synthesis of glycolytic enzymes in slow-twitch lateral adductor muscles of the chicken. These results are discussed in terms of the apparent similarities between the effects of muscular dystrophy and surgical denervation on the protein synthetic programs expressed by mature fast-twitch muscle fibers.     

Immunoassay of muscle-specific creatine kinase with a monoclonal antibody and application to myogenesis and muscular dystrophy.

A competition e.l.i.s.a. (enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay) is described that enables direct measurement of the muscle-specific polypeptide of chick creatine kinase (M-CK) in extracts of differentiating muscle-cell cultures and in blood plasma samples, even in the presence of embryonic, or brain-type, creatine kinase. The characteristics of the assay can be considerably improved by the use of a monoclonal antibody, CK-ART, instead of rabbit antisera, and we offer an explanation for this in terms of heterogeneity of antibody affinities in polyclonal antisera. In addition to native enzyme, the assay will measure creatine kinase unfolded and inactivated by 8 M-urea treatment. During chick muscle differentiation in vitro, M-CK increased from 7.5% of the total creatine kinase at 24h to 76.0% at 143h, in good agreement with isoenzyme separation data. As a percentage of the total cell protein, M-CK increased by 156-340-fold over the same period and constituted 0.38-0.56% of the total protein in late cultures. E.l.i.s.a. measurements on 17-20-day embryonic thigh-muscle extracts, which contain almost exclusively M-CK, agree well with enzyme activity and radioimmunoassay. M-CK constituted 0.7-1.6% of the total protein in 17-19-day embryonic thigh muscle. Plasma M-CK concentrations in normal 2-8-week-old chickens were found to be in the range 0.5-0.9 micrograms/ml. Plasma concentrations of 32-56 micrograms/ml were found in 8-week-old dystrophic chickens by both e.l.i.s.a. and enzyme-activity measurements. The results suggest that inactive or unfolded forms of M-CK do not normally exist, in any significant amounts, in cell and tissue extracts or in freshly prepared samples of plasma.     

Preparation and properties of creatine kinase from the breast muscle of normal and dystrophic chicken (Gallus domesticus)

1. The purification of creatine kinase from normal and genetically dystrophic chicken breast muscle is described. Enzyme recovery was significantly lower from dystrophic muscle. 2. Both enzymes had the same number of reactive and total thiol groups and had similar specific activities and similar amino acid compositions. 3. No significant differences were observed in sedimentation, electrophoretic or kinetic properties. 4. Peptide ;maps' showed no significant differences, and electrophoresis of partial acid hydrolysates of the labelled enzymes suggested that corresponding amino acid sequences around all the thiol groups were very similar. 5. The enzymes showed identical temperature stabilities. 6. No significant differences between the enzymes from normal and dystrophic muscle were observed.     

Dissociation of creatine kinase activity from hydrolytic enzyme activities in muscle of dystrophic mice

Time course studies were done to reexamine the age-dependency of intramuscular enzymatic changes in dystrophic mice. Most of the activities of hydrolytic enzymes in dystrophic mice were elevated in comparison to the controls throughout the span of 8 weeks which was examined. In contrast, the activity of creatine kinase remained depressed throughout the same period. This tendency was similarly seen in the muscles of forelimb and hindlimb but not in heart muscle. The observations are compatible with the notion that the increased activities of hydrolytic enzymes are causally related to the destruction of muscular tissue, leading to the malfunction of contractile machinery in the dystrophic muscles.     

Comparative enzymology of AMP deaminase,adenylate kinase,and creatine kinase in vertebrate heart and skeletal muscle: the characteristic AMP deaminase levels of skeletal versus cardiac muscle are reversed in the North American toad

The specific activity of three characteristic enzymes, adenylate deaminase, adenylate kinase, and creatine kinase, in the skeletal muscles and heart of a variety of vertebrate land animals, including the human, are surveyed. Data from this study and available studies in the literature suggest that adenosine monophosphate deaminase in land vertebrates is quite high in white skeletal muscle, usually somewhat lower in red muscle, and 15-to 500-fold lower in cardiac muscle. Adenosine monophosphate deaminase is active primarily under ischemic or hypoxic conditions which occur frequently in white muscle, only occasionally in red muscle, and ought never occur in heart muscle, and this may therefore account for observed enzyme levels. The common North American toad, Bufo americanus, provides a striking exception to the rule with cardiac adenosine monophosphate deaminase as high as in mammalian skeletal muscle, whereas its skeletal muscle level of adenosine monophosphate deaminase is several times lower. The exceptional levels in the toad are not due to a change in substrate binding and are not accompanied by comparable change in the level of adenylate or creatine kinase. Nor do they signal any major change in isozyme composition, since a human muscle adenosine monophosphate deaminase-specific antiserum reacts with toad muscle adenosine monophosphate deaminase, but not with toad heart adenosine monophosphate deaminase. They do not represent any general anuran evolutionary strategy, since the bullfrog (Rana catesbeiana) and the giant tropic toad (Bufo marinus) have the usual vertebrate pattern of adenosine monophosphate deaminase distribution. Lower skeletal muscle activities in anurans may simply represent the contribution of tonic muscle fiber bundles containing low levels of adenosine monophosphate deaminase, but the explanation for the extremely high adenosine monophosphate deaminase levels in heart ventricular muscle is not apparent.Abbreviations AK adenylate kinase - AMP adenosine monophosphate - AMPD, AMP deaminase - CPK creatine (phospho)kinase - EHNA erythro-9-(2-hydroxy-3-nonyl)-adenine-HCl     

Muscle adenylate kinase in Duchenne muscular dystrophy

On the basis of electrophoretic and enzyme inhibition studies it was postulated that an aberrant adenylate kinase occurs in muscle and serum of patients with Duchenne muscular dystrophy (Schirmer, R.H. and Thuma, E. (1972) Biochim. Biophys. Acta 268, 92-97; Hamada, M. et al. (1981) Biochim. Biophys. Acta 660, 227-237; Hamada et al. (1985) J. Biol. Chem. 260, 11595-11602). On the basis of the following results we conclude that Duchenne muscular dystrophy patients do not possess an unusual adenylate kinase isoenzyme. In muscle biopsies from five Duchenne patients, the electrophoretic mobility of adenylate kinase and the inhibition of the enzyme by P1, P5-di(adenosine-5')pentaphosphate (Ap5A) was normal. Because of the high SH-group content of the extracts from Duchenne muscle, high concentrations of Ellman's reagent were needed to inhibit adenylate kinase activity in these samples. In Duchenne plasma the adenylate kinase activity was elevated. Like in muscle specimens, the DTNB inhibition curves were shifted to higher reagent concentrations; this was due to a high SH-group content of Duchenne plasma when compared with normal plasma. With respect to inhibition by Ap5A and electrophoretic mobility, Duchenne adenylate kinase in Duchenne plasma behaved like normal muscle adenylate kinase in normal plasma. It was noted that normal muscle adenylate kinase changes its electrophoretic behaviour when mixed with normal or Duchenne plasma. This finding had been considered previously as evidence for the presence of an aberrant adenylate kinase in Duchenne plasma.     

Myofibrillar creatine kinase in Duchenne and avian muscular dystrophy

The presence and activity of the fraction of creatine kinase (CK) which was associated with myofibrils and located in the M line of the sarcomeres was determined in normal and dystrophic avian muscle and in normal and dystrophic (Duchenne) human muscle. Myofibrils were isolated from homogenates of muscle and washed nine times so as to remove nonmyofibrillar CK. In myofibrils from dystrophic muscle the enzyme CK was localized to the M line using immunofluorescent techniques and was enzymatically active. These results suggest that in both avian and Duchenne muscular dystrophy, there is not a myofibrillar disorder of the phosphocreatine shuttle.     

Interaction of creatine kinase and adenylate kinase systems in muscle cells

Elsewhere in this book the important role of creatine kinase and its metabolites in high energy phosphate metabolism and transport in muscle cells has been reviewed. The emphasis of this review article is mainly on the compartmentalized catalytic activity of adenylate kinase in relation to creatine kinase isoenzymes, and other enzymes of energy production and utilization processes in muscle cells. At present the role of adenylate kinase is considered simply to equilibrate the stores of adenine nucleotides. Recent studies by us and others, however, suggest an entirely new view of the metabolic importance of adenylate kinase in muscle function. This view offers a closer interaction between adenylate kinase and creatine kinase, in the process of energy production (at mitochondrial and glycolytic sites), and energy utilization (at myofibrillar sites and perhaps other sites such as sarcoplasmic reticular, sarcolemmal membrane, etc.), thus being an integral part of the high energy phosphate transport system.This review article opens up the opportunity to further examine the metabolism of adenine nucleotides and their fluxes through the adenylate kinase system in intact muscle cells. Using an intact system, having a preserved integrity of their compartmentalized enzymes and substrates, is essential in clarifying the exact role of adenylate kinase in high energy phosphate metabolism in muscle cells.     

Enzymological studies on hereditary avian muscular dystrophy.

White and red muscles of normal and genetically dystrophic chickens were compared with regards to activity levels of three soluble enzymes, glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase, creatine phosphokinase, and acetyl phosphatase. In dystrophic white muscle (pectoral), activity of the two sulfhydryl enzymes, glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase and creatine phosphokinase, was preferentially lost from the sarcoplasm resulting in decreased specific activities. By contrast, acetyl phosphatase was preferentially retained and showed increased specific activity. Dystrophic white muscle had decreased sulfhydryl content in the soluble proteins, severe reduction in muscle mass, fatty infiltration, and fragmentation of fibers. Red dystrophic muscles (thigh) were minimally involved in accordance with the known sparing of red fibers. Enzyme activities were correlated with histological observations. The results suggested that the disease process in dystrophic white muscle may be related to alterations in the sulfhydryl groups of proteins. The data are correlated with the beneficial effects of our treatment of hereditary avian dystrophy with the sulfhydryl compound, penicillamine (Chou, T.H., Hill, E.J., Bartle, E., Woolley, K., LeQuire, V., Olson, W., Roelofs, R., and Park, J.H. (1975) J. Clin. Invest. 56, 842-849).     

Changes in the Levels and Forms of Cholinesterases in the Blood Plasma of Normal and Dystrophic Chickens

Abstract: Acetylcholinesterase (AChE) and pseudocholinesterase (°ChE) were analysed in the blood plasma of developing chickens, both normal and those with inherited muscular dystrophy. The amounts and the molecular forms of each were examined. °ChE concentration rises in the plasma of normal and dystrophic chicks at the end of embryonic development and is maintained after hatching at a constant, relatively high level, accounting for 90-95% of total cholinesterase activity in normal plasma. This level is maintained in normal and dystrophic chickens. In embryonic plasma of both normal and dystrophic chicks, on the other hand, the levels of AChE are higher than those of °ChE. Immediately after hatching the AChE level decreases rapidly in normal plasma, reaching a very low level by 2-3 weeks ex ovo. The AChE level in plasma from dystrophic birds, although less than normal from day 19 in ovo to 2 weeks ex ovo, subsequently increases to peak around 4 months at levels 15-20-fold of those in normal birds. There is virtually no enzyme of either type in the erythrocytes of normal or dystrophic chickens. The changes of AChE in plasma were correlated with the alterations of AChE in dystrophic fast-twitch muscles, suggesting that the latter pool is a precursor of the plasma AChE. Both the AChE and the °ChE in plasma exist in multiple molecular forms, which are similar to certain of those found previously in the muscles of these birds. The major form (60-80%) of both enzymes in the plasma is the M form (sedimentation coefficient ≥11 S) in all cases, but it is accompanied by certain other forms. In no case is there any of the heaviest form (H₂, 19-20 S) of AChE or of °ChE found in normal and dystrophic muscle, which is attached at the synapses in normal muscle. The pattern of forms of plasma °ChE is constant at all ages, and in normal and dystrophic chickens. The pattern of forms of AChE in the plasma, in contrast, varies with age and with dystrophy in a characteristic manner. The sedimentation coefficients and the amounts of the enzymes in fast-twitch muscle of dystrophic animals are compared with those of the plasma forms, and an interpretation is given of the characteristic patterns of AChE and of χE in their blood.     

Cytosolic adenylate kinase catalyzes the synthesis of thiamin triphosphate from thiamin diphosphate

An attempt was made to purify a porcine skeletal muscle enzyme catalyzing the formation of thiamin triphosphate (TTP) from thiamin diphosphate (TDP), requiring ATP, Mg2+ and a cofactor (creatine). As the purification proceeded, the reaction requirements for ATP and creatine were lost and then a requirement for ADP was manifested. The activity responsible for TTP synthesis from TDP, ADP, and Mg2+ was found to be copurified with adenylate kinase [EC 2.7.4.3] activity, and was finally purified to a single band on SDS-PAGE. Antiserum obtained against the purified enzyme preparation inhibited both adenylate kinase activity and the TTP-synthesizing activity to exactly the same extent. These results indicate that adenylate kinase catalyzes TTP formation from TDP in vitro.     

Adenosine 5′-triphosphate–creatine phosphotransferase from dystrophic mouse skeletal muscle. A genetic lesion associated with the catalytic-site thiol group

1. A column procedure for the purification of creatine kinase from normal and dystrophic mouse muscle is described. 2. The native enzymes are indistinguishable by various physical criteria and have mol.wt. about 80000. 3. The purified enzyme from dystrophic muscle is only half as active as the normal, contains only one thiol group readily alkylated by iodoacetamide instead of two and has one less free thiol group/mol. 4. Michaelis constants for MgATP and creatine are the same for both preparations. 5. The inhibitor constant for ADP at pH9·0 is different in the two enzymes and this may account for the different degrees of inhibition observed in vitro with the drug Laevadosin. 6. The enzyme from dystrophic muscle is protected by an equilibrium mixture of substrates against inhibition by iodoacetamide to a greater extent than the normal enzyme. 7. `Fingerprinting' suggests one peptide difference between creatine kinases from normal and dystrophic muscle. 8. The possibility that this finding represents the primary lesion in dystrophy is discussed.     

Occurrence of creatine kinase activity in human erythrocyte membrane

Some evidences for creatine kinase activity in normal human erythrocyte membrane were presented. The creatine kinase was indicated to be a constituent of the integral proteins of erythrocyte membrane or to be tightly bound to the membrane, and was contrasted to the results obtained with adenylate kinase. Isoenzyme distribution of the erythrocyte creatine kinase by electrophoresis was identical to MM-creatine kinase from rabbit muscle.     

Purification and properties of squid mantle adenylate kinase. Role of NADH in control of the enzyme.

Adenylate kinase (ATP:AMP phosphotransferase, EC 2.7.4.3) from the mantle muscle of the squid, Loligo pealeii, was purified over 170-fold to homogeneity as judged by polyacrylamide and starch gel electrophoresis. The tissue contains a single isozyme of adenylate kinase, the enzyme from cytoplasmic and mitochondrial compartments (90 and 10% of total activity, respectively) being identical in physical and kinetic properties. Molecular weight was found to be 27,000 +/- 400. The enzyme shows a pH optimum of 8.2 in the forward (APD utilizing) and 7.4 in the reverse direction. Michaelis constants for ADP, ATP, and AMP are 0.70, 0.13, and 0.15 mM, respectively, with optimal Mg2+:adenylate ratios being 1:2 for ADP and 1:1 for ATP. A comparison of mass action ratios with the equilibrium constant indicated that squid adenylate kinase is held out of equilibrium in resting, but not active, muscle. A search for metabolic modulators of adenylate kinase revealed that NADH (Ki of 0.1 mM) was the only modulator which exerted a significant effect within its in vivo concentration range. The data presented indicate that NADH inhibition is the factor maintaining adenylate kinase in a nonequilibrium state in resting muscle and that release of this inhibition can serve to integrate adenylate kinase into the known scheme of intermediary metabolism in this tissue. A sharp drop in NADH levels at the onset on muscular work co-ordinates that activation of aerobic metabolism in this tissue and allows adenylate kinase to return to equilibrium function. At equilibrium, the enzyme can function to ampligy the concentration of AMP, a potent activator and deinhibitor of key glycolytic and Krebs cycle enzymes. The effect of modulators of adenylate kinase in preventing denaturation by heat or proteolysis revealed that NADH and substrates induced conformational changes in the enzyme which rendered it less susceptible to denaturation. The conformation state induced by NADH differed from that induced by substrate.     

Quantification of creative kinase isoenzymes by a radioimmunoassay

Summary It is not known whether loss of enzyme activity from the circulation is due to denaturation, inactivation or removal of intact enzyme molecules. This is in part due to the lack of an assay to measure enzyme protein concentration since available assays measure only enzyme activity. Radioimmunoassays for plasma enzymes and isoenzymes have not been possible because of oxidation in radioactive labelling by conventional methods and the problem of subunit dissociation. In the present study, antibodies specific to the B and M subunits of creatine kinase isoenzymes were obtained by immunization of rabbits with canine BB and MM creatine kinase. Anitgens (MM and BB) were radioactively labelled with ¹²⁵I by acylation, avoiding the problem of oxidation and subunit stabilized by mercaptoethanol (0.020 m) and Trisbuffer (1.6 m). A radioimmunoassay capable of detecting picogram amounts of CK isoenzymes was developed which measures the concentration of enzyme protein rather than activity. The method was shown to provide a sensitive quantitative method for analysis of plasma CK isoenzymes in dogs after myocardial infarction produced by coronary occlusion. This technique may provide a prototype for the development of radioimmunoassays for other plasma isoenzymes and should help to elucidate the nature of the disappearance of isoenzymes from the circulation.Work from the authors' laboratory was supported in part by the National Institutes of Health Grant HL 17646, SCOR in Ischemic Heart Disease     

Thyroidal involvement in the expression of avian muscular dystrophy

We showed previously that propylthiouracil (PTU), a thyroid inhibitor, could alleviate several major signs of hereditary muscular dystrophy in chickens. The goals of the present investigation were to: (1) determine whether a nearly athyroid condition (achieved within two days after hatching by surgical thyroidectomy plus PTU) during an 11-day period beneficially affects the dystrophic condition when followed by triiodothyronine (T3) replacement to 33 days of age; (2) determine the beneficial effects on the expression of avian dystrophy when the thyroidectomized-PTU-treated chickens received a wide range of moderate to low T3 replacement doses beginning by two days after thyroidectomy; and (3) examine the thyroid hormone receptor system in dystrophic muscle for a possible abnormality. Thyroid deprivation increased muscle function (righting ability) and reduced plasma creatine kinase activity in dystrophic chickens. The major thyroid-related abnormality in dystrophic pectoralis muscles was an increased maximum binding capacity of solubilized nuclear T3 receptors.