Left-handed Z-DNA Helices in Polymers,Restriction Fragments,and Recombinant Plasmids

Abstract

Studies on DNA polymers, restriction fragments, and recombinant plasmids have revealed the following: A) A family of left-handed DNA conformations exists for (dC-dG)_n·(dC-dG)_n. The observation of a particular conformation is dependent on the salt, the salt concentration and dehydrating agent. B) In sodium acetate solutions, (dC-dG)_n·(dC-dG)_n forms left-handed, ψ(+)-condensed structures as detected by Raman spectroscopy and circular dichroism. C) (dT-dG)_n·(dC-dA)_n undergoes a right-to-left-handed transition only when reacted with AAF and at high salt concentrations. D) Transitions observed for polymer DNAs also are observed for restriction fragments containing both (dC-dG)·(dC-dG) and (dT-dG)·(dC-dA) sequences, but the transitions in the fragments generally require higher salt concentrations than observed for the polymers. E) Studies with recombinant plasmids containing (dC-dG) sequences from 10 to 58 bp in length demonstrate that left-handed Z-DNA segments can exist contiguous to B-DNA segments. F) Negative supercoil density (σ≤ ?0.072) is sufficient to convert the (dC-dG) regions in those plasmids into left-handed structures under physiological ionic conditions (200 mM NaCl). G) The favorable free energy contribution of methyla- tion in stabilizing the Z form in fragments and plasmids is approximately offset by the unfavorable free energy contributions of the B/Z junctions. H) S₁ and BAL 31 nucleases recognize aberrant structural features at the confluence of the B and Z regions. I) Detailed mapping of S₁ nuclease cleavage on supercoiled plasmids shows that the nuclease sensitive regions extend over at least five to ten bp. J) Even though the (dT-dG)_n·(dC-dA)_n polymer requires base modification and high salt conditions to undergo the R?L transition, supercoiling (σ ?0.07) can supply enough energy to allow a plasmid containing the intervening sequence of a human fetal globin gene with (dT-dG)·(dC-dA) sequences to undergo a R?L transition.     

S1 nuclease recognizes DNA conformational junctions between left-handed helical (dT-dG n. dC-dA)n and contiguous right-handed sequences

The ability of negative supercoiling to induce a left-handed helix in the recombinant plasmid pRW777, which contains a tract of 64 base pairs of almost perfect (dT-dG) . (dC-dA) from the mouse kappa immunoglobin gene, was studied. S1 nuclease recognizes and cleaves within the junction region which must exist adjacent to the (dT-dG)n . (dC-dA)n tract when in a left-handed state. The cleavage pattern indicates conformational flexibility and structural differences between the two existing junctions. The 64-base pair alternating copolymer undergoes the supercoil-induced formation of a left-handed state over the superhelical density range of -0.04 to -0.06, indicating that (dT-dG)n . (dC-dA) sequences form a left-handed helix less readily than (dC-dG)n . (dC-dG)n sequences of equivalent length. However, these supercoil densities are within the range found in vivo. Supercoil relaxation and antibody binding studies confirmed that the (dT-dG)n . (dC-dA)n tract in supercoiled pRW777 was in a left-handed helix.     

B-Z DNA junctions contain few, if any, nonpaired bases at physiological superhelical densities

The reactions of bromoacetaldehyde (BAA) with recombinant plasmids that contain sequences which can adopt left-handed Z structures or, at other locations, cruciforms were studied as a function of supercoil density. The sequence in pRW756 that undergoes a supercoil induced transition from a right to left-handed helix was (dC-dG)16 and regions near the replication origin of the pBR322 vector were converted from linearforms to cruciforms. The locations of the most nonpaired structural features were mapped by S1 nuclease cleavage of the "wedged open" duplexes after linearization of the DNAs. Three cruciforms in the pBR322 portions of the plasmids were specifically detected by BAA reaction at physiological supercoil densities (sigma = -0.067). However, the B-Z junctions did not react with BAA under these conditions although the junctions were present since the (dC-dG)16 was shown to be left-handed. Thus, the B-Z junctions have less single-stranded character than the pBR322 cruciforms (3-6 nonpaired bases) and may be fully paired. At much higher superhelical densities (sigma = -0.11-0.12), the B-Z junctions as well as the cruciforms react with BAA indicating a change in the nature of the junctions. Studies were also performed with pRW777 which harbors the mouse kappa immunoglobin sequence (dT-dG)32 . (dC-dA)32 that adopts a left-handed helix under appropriate conditions; the results were similar to those found with pRW756.     

Thermodynamic parameters are sequence-dependent for the supercoil-induced B to Z transition in recombinant plasmids

The entropy and enthalpy changes which contribute to the thermodynamics of the B to Z transition were determined for three recombinant plasmids containing a (dC-dG)16 tract and for a plasmid containing a pair of (dT-dG)20 regions. For each base pair which adopts a left-handed conformation in the plasmids with (dC-dG)16 sequences, the delta HBZ and delta SBZ are -2.1 kcal/mol bp and -8.8 cal/K-mol bp, respectively. In the plasmid containing the (dT-dG)20 tracts, however, the delta HBZ and delta SBZ values are 0.58 kcal/mol bp and -0.76 cal/K-mol bp, respectively. Also, these determinations show that for each B-Z junction that forms in the plasmids containing the (dC-dG), the enthalpy and entropy changes are 24 kcal/mol junction and 65 cal/K-mol junction, whereas for the (dT-dG) plasmid, the enthalpy and entropy changes are -1.8 kcal/mol junction and -22 cal/K-mol junction, respectively. Those values for the enthalpy and entropy changes for the formation of a BZ junction in (dC-dG) and (dT-dG) plasmids suggest that the properties and possibly the structures of the junctions are different. Calculations using the enthalpy and entropy changes determined in this study reveal that the B to Z transition in plasmids containing (dC-dG) blocks are more temperature-dependent than the transitions in plasmids with (dT-dG) blocks. Surprisingly, at temperatures above 60 degrees C, calculations indicate that the B to Z transitions in (dT-dG) plasmids should be energetically favored over that transition in (dC-dG) plasmids.     

Chromatin structure of the potential Z-forming sequence (dT-dG)n X (dC-dA)n. Evidence for an "alternating-B" conformation

The sequence (dT-dG)n X (dC-dA)n is the most abundant purine-pyrimidine dinucleotide repeat in eukaryotic genomes. This sequence and certain others that contain alternating purine-pyrimidine residues have been shown to adopt the left-handed, Z-DNA conformation in vitro when subjected to negative torsional stress or elevated ionic strengths. We have asked whether (dT-dG)n X (dC-dA)n tracts exist in topologically constrained Z-form structures in vivo by examining the chromatin organization of these sequences in cultured mouse cell nuclei. We find that these elements are quantitatively packaged into typical core particles which are embedded in canonical polynucleosomal arrays. In addition, these sequences neither flank nor reside within regions of chromatin that are preferentially sensitive to S1 nuclease. These characteristics suggest that these tracts do not exist predominantly in the Z-form in vivo. Furthermore, employing techniques that permit prominent hybridization to DNA fragments as short as 18 bases, we provide evidence that in vivo, most (dT-dG)n X (dC-dA)n elements instead adopt an "alternating-B" conformation on the nucleosomal surface.     

Effects of 5 cytosine methylation on the B-Z transition in DNA restriction fragments and recombinant plasmids

Alternating (dC-dG)n regions in DNA restriction fragments and recombinant plasmids were methylated at the 5 position of the cytosine residues by the HhaI methylase. Methylation lowers the concentration of NaCl or MgCl2 necessary to cause the B-Z conformational transition in these sequences. Ionic strengths higher than physiological conditions are required to form the Z conformation when the methylated (dC-dG)n tract is contiguous with regions that do not form Z structures, in contrast to the results with the DNA polymer poly(m5dC-dG) . poly(m5dC-dG). In supercoiled plasmids containing (dC-dG)n sequences, methylation reduces the number of negative supercoils necessary to stabilize the Z conformation. Calculations of the observed free energy contributions of the B-Z junction and cytosine methylation suggest that two junctions offset the favorable effect of methylation on the Z conformation in (dC-dG)n sequences (about 29 base-pairs in length). Studies with individual methylated topoisomers demonstrate that increasing Na+ concentration up to approximately 0.2 M inhibits the formation of the Z conformation in the (m5dC-dG)n region of supercoiled plasmids. The results suggest that methylation may serve as a triggering mechanism for Z DNA formation in supercoiled DNAs.     

The ubiquitous potential Z-forming sequence of eucaryotes, (dT-dG)n . (dC-dA)n, is not detectable in the genomes of eubacteria, archaebacteria, or mitochondria.

The potential Z-forming sequence (dT-dG)n . (dC-dA)n is an abundant, interspersed repeat element that is ubiquitous in eucaryotic nuclear genomes. We report that in contrast to eucaryotic nuclear DNA, the genomes of eubacteria, archaebacteria, and mitochondria lack this sequence, since even a single tract of greater than or equal to 14 base pairs in length is not detectable through either hybridization or sequence analysis. Interestingly, the phylogenetic distribution of the (dT-dG)n . (dC-dA)n repeat exhibits a striking parallel to that of (dT-dC)n . (dG-dA)n, but not to other homocopolymeric sequences such as (dC-dG)n . (dC-dG)n or (dT-dA)n . (dT-dA)n.     

Spectroscopic studies on acetylaminofluorene-modified (dT-dG)n . (dC-dA)n suggest a left-handed conformation

CD spectroscopy on the double-stranded strictly alternating dinucleotide polymer (dT-dG)n . (dC-dA)n partially modified by N-acetoxy-N-acetyl-2-aminofluorene suggests a left-handed conformation in concentrated NaCl solutions. Modification of the (dT-dG)n . (dC-dA)n polymer with acetylaminofluorene is required to promote formation of the left-handed helix since high salt concentrations and several other ionic conditions, which cause a similar transition for (dG-dC)n . (dG-dC)n, are ineffective. Furthermore, substitution of dC with 5-methyl dC in (dT-dG)n . (dC-dA)n does not facilitate formation of a left-handed helix, also in contrast to results found for (dG-dC)n . (dG-dC)n. A 62-base pair tract of almost perfectly alternating (dT-dG)n . (dC-dA)n from the 3'-side of the mouse kappa immunoglobulin gene modified with acetylaminofluorene undergoes the salt-induced transition to a left-handed helix when studied within a 140-base pair restriction fragment. High NaCl concentrations alone will not cause the transition for this 62-base pair tract in this fragment nor in the recombinant plasmid pRW777, which contains this fragment.     

Energetic and structural inter-relationship between DNA supercoiling and the right- to left-handed Z helix transitions in recombinant plasmids

We have evaluated the B to Z conformational transitions in supercoiled recombinant plasmids containing different lengths of (dC-dG) described in the preceding paper. The sodium chloride-induced right- to left-handed transition in a small segment of the plasmids caused a relaxation of (-) supercoils which was monitored by electrophoretic mobility changes of individual topoisomers on agarose gels containing NaCl at concentrations up to 5.0 M. The number of supercoils relaxed was proportional to the length of the (dC-dG) segment in the plasmid in good agreement with theoretical values. A short B/Z junction region (less than 5 base pairs) was inferred. The stability of the Z conformation in (dC-dG) segments of the plasmids had a strong length dependency; shorter lengths were less stable. Ten base pairs of (dC-dG) was insufficient to allow a Z conformation under the conditions studied. Supercoiling imparts a substantial favorable free energy to the Z conformation, reducing the NaCl concentration necessary to cause the transition. The relationship of supercoiling with the NaCl concentration necessary to cause a B leads to Z transition suggests that supercoiling alone is sufficient to stabilize the Z conformation at physiological salt concentrations. These results support the notion that left-handed DNA has an important biological role.     

Methylation of cytosine in the 5-position alters the structural and energetic properties of the supercoil-induced Z-helix and of B-Z junctions

The structural and energetic consequences of cytosine methylation in the 5-position on the supercoil-dependent B-Z equilibrium in alternating dC-dG sequences cloned into recombinant plasmids were investigated. The helical parameters determined with the band shift method for right-handed [10.7 base pairs (bp)/turn] and left-handed (12.8 bp/turn) 5MedC-dG inserts were different from the helical repeat values for unmethylated dC-dG inserts (10.5 bp/turn in the right-handed and 11.5 bp/turn in the left-handed form). We analyzed the thermodynamic parameters delta GBZ (free energy difference per base pair between right-handed and left-handed helix structure), delta Gjx (free energy for formation of one B-Z junction), and b (helix unwinding at a junction region) for varying lengths of dC-dG inserts by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis and application of a statistical mechanics model. A comparison of plasmids fully methylated in vitro with HhaI methylase and their unmethylated counterparts revealed that delta Gjx is not significantly changed by cytosine methylation. However, this base modification results in an approximate 3-fold decrease of delta GBZ and an approximate 2-fold decrease of the unwinding b at B-Z junction regions. Analysis of a pair of related plasmids, each containing two dC-dG blocks, revealed qualitatively different transition behaviors. When the two dC-dG blocks were separated by 95 bp of a mixed sequence, they underwent independent B to Z transitions with separate nucleation events and junction formations. When the two blocks were separated by only a 4 bp GATC sequence, only one nucleation event was necessary, and the Z-helix spread across the nonalternating GATC region.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

BAL 31 nuclease as a probe in concentrated salt for the B-Z DNA junction

The BAL 31 nuclease, an extracellular nuclease from A. espejiana, specifically recognizes and cleaves the salt induced conformational junction between B and Z-DNA. Short segments of (dC-dG) left-handed Z-helix, comprising approximately 1% of the total DNA, are specifically detected within two different recombinant plasmids. The BAL 31 enzyme is highly resistant to inactivation by the presence of high concentrations of a variety of electrolytes that stabilize left-handed helices, is active at physiological pH, and can be used to probe both linear and circular DNAs. Additionally, the nuclease cleaves left-handed (dC-dG)n only very poorly, if at all. Thus, the BAL 31 nuclease can be utilized as a probe for helical junctions and consequently for segments of left-handed DNA that might exist within predominantly right-handed naturally occurring genomes.     

Characterization of genomic poly(dT-dG).poly(dC-dA) sequences: structure, organization, and conformation.

Hybridization studies suggest the abundant presence of poly(dT-dG).poly(dC-dA) (TG-element), a potential Z-DNA sequence, in eucaryotic genomes. We have isolated and characterized TG-elements from different locations in the human genome: from randomly isolated clones, associated with the actin gene family, and linked to another repeated element. The results indicate that the following features are typical of these TG-elements: the elements consist of 20 to 60 base pairs of (dT-dG)n.(dC-dA)n, the sequences characterized in our study were not flanked by direct or inverted repeats, the sequences are interspersed rather than in satellite blocks, the elements are not usually associated with other repeated elements, and some of the elements are found near coding sequences or in introns. Studies on the conformation of a genomic TG-element in a supercoiled plasmid indicate several distinct properties of the TG-element: it is in the Z-form only at low ionic strength, S1 nuclease recognizes its Z-form with a marked preference for one of the B-Z junctions, and the sensitive region extends for 20 base pairs near the B-Z junction. In contrast to the result with the supercoiled plasmid, S1 nuclease failed to recognize the TG-element in minichromosomes.     

Isolation and characterization of Z-DNA binding proteins from wheat germ

The preparation of a heterogeneous non-histone protein extract from wheat germ utilizing Br-poly(dG-dC).poly(dG-dC) (Z-DNA) affinity chromatography is described. The binding characteristics of antibodies against Z-DNA are used as a model system to define important criteria that the DNA binding behavior of a Z-DNA binding protein should display. We show that the wheat germ extract contains DNA binding proteins specific for left-handed Z-DNA by these criteria. The affinity of the proteins measured by competition experiments was approximately 10(5) greater for Br-poly(dG-dC).poly(dG-dC) (Z-DNA) than for poly(dG-dC).poly(dG-dC) (B-DNA). The affinity of the proteins for plasmid DNA increases with increasing negative superhelicity which is known to stabilize Z-DNA. The proteins are shown to compete with Z-DNA antibodies for binding to supercoiled plasmids. Finally, the affinity for two plasmids at a given superhelical density is greater for the plasmid containing an insert known to form Z-DNA than for a plasmid without the insert. The proteins exhibit a 2-3-fold greater affinity for stretches of (dC-dA)n.(dT-dG)n over stretches of (dG-dC)n.(dG-dC)n when both sequences are induced to form Z-DNA by supercoiling.     

Characteristics of Z-DNA helices formed by imperfect (purine-pyrimidine) sequences in plasmids

The capacities of three synthetic sequences to adopt left-handed helices were evaluated in recombinant plasmids. The sequences consisted of very short runs of (CG)n (n = 2-4) interspersed with runs of alternating A.T base pairs and/or with regions of non-alternating base pairs. The plasmids were studied by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis to determine the natures of the conformational transitions and their free energies of formation. These results coupled with analyses with chemical (diethyl pyrocarbonate, osmium tetroxide, and bromoacetaldehyde) and enzymatic (S1 nuclease, T7 gene 3 product, and MHhaI) probes indicated that the entire sequence was adopting a left-handed helix in each case. In one of these sequences, Z-DNA formation necessitated the retention of the anti conformation of one of the guanines in a region of non-alternation. In a sequence which contains out-of-phase regions of alternation, our results indicate the formation of a separate left-handed helix in the central (CG)2 region, thus forming two Z-Z junctions. In summary, we conclude that only very short regions of alternating CG are necessary to effect the B to Z transition and that this conformational change can be transmitted through non-alternating regions. A set of empirical rules governing the characteristics of the B to Z transition and the types of left-handed helices in supercoiled plasmids was derived from studies on a systematic series of 17 plasmids.     

Site-specific chemical modification of B-Z junctions in supercoiled DNA as detected by nuclease S1 digestion, inhibition of restriction cleavage and nucleotide sequencing

Structural distortions on the boundary between right-handed and left-handed segments in the superhelical plasmid pPK2 (a derivative of pUC19 containing (dC-dG)n segments cloned into polylinker) were studied by means of chemical probes. Strong osmium tetroxide, pyridine (Os,py) modification of DNA at native superhelical density (sigma) was found in four thymines surrounding the (dC-dG)13 segment. These results correlated with restriction cleavage inhibition (due to modification): BamHI cleavage was strongly inhibited, unlike the neighbouring XbaI and SalI (weak or no inhibition). In the (dC-dG)8 segment considerably weaker modification of the B-Z junctions was observed, accompanied by weak inhibition of BamHI cleavage, while the neighbouring SmaI and KpnI were not affected. Os,py modification of DNA at native sigma was not detected by nuclease S1 cleavage at and (dC-dG)n segment. However, this enzyme recognized and cleaved at the B-Z junction, osmium modified at more negative sigma. The results obtained with the glyoxal and diethyl pyrocarbonate modification support the idea of very narrow B-Z junctions at native sigma.     

Recognition of the structural distortions at the junctions between B and Z segments in negatively supercoiled DNA by osmium tetroxide

It has been shown for the first time that conformational junction between contiguous right-handed B and left-handed Z segments can be recognized by a chemical probe. Plasmid pRW751 containing (dC-dG)13 and (dC-dG)16 blocks was treated with osmium tetroxide, pyridine (a reagent known to be single-strand selective) at physiological ionic conditions (0.1 and 0.2 M NaCl) and neutral pH. Mapping of the osmium binding sites by restriction enzyme digestion followed by nuclease S1 cleavage has revealed selective binding of osmium at, or near to, the end of the (dC-dG)n segments proximal to the 95 bp lac sequence. The junction of the shorter (dC-dG)13 segment was modified to a substantially greater extent than that of the longer segment. Partial inhibition of DNA cleavage by BamHI was observed at the restriction sites neighbouring to the both (dC-dG)n segments as a result of DNA modification by osmium tetroxide. The site-selective modification occurred only in supercoiled and not in relaxed molecules. Differences in the sensitivity of the B/Z junctions in pRW751 to the osmium tetroxide were explained by different structural features of these junctions.     

Analysis of Z-DNA in fixed polytene chromosomes with monoclonal antibodies that show base sequence-dependent selectivity in reactions with supercoiled plasmids and polynucleotides

Five monoclonal anti-Z-DNA antibodies were characterized with respect to their binding of synthetic nucleic acid polymers and of supercoiled circular plasmid DNA. All of the antibodies reacted only with DNA in the Z-conformation; however, they fell into two classes on the basis of sequence specificity. One class, with broad specificity, reacted well with all sequences in the Z-form, including poly(dG-dC), poly(dG-dm5C), and poly (dG-dBr5C) in linear polymers and poly(dG-dC)n and poly[(dC-dA)n.(dT-dG)n] sequences in supercoiled plasmids. The other class bound only Z-DNA formed by poly(dG-dC). Binding of the monoclonal antibodies specifically to inserts of Z-DNA-forming sequences in plasmids was mapped directly by cross-linking of antibody to the DNA, digestion with restriction nuclease, and electrophoretic analysis of both the unbound fragments and the bound fragments recovered from immune complexes. The monoclonal antibodies were used for indirect immunofluorescence staining of Drosophila polytene chromosomes fixed by two procedures. One procedure yielded chromosomes with Z-specific antibody binding in many interbands, a few specific bands, and parts of some puffs. On chromosomes fixed by the second procedure, antibody staining appeared to follow the DNA concentration, staining all bands brightly. For each fixation procedure, chromosomes showed the same staining pattern with each of the broad specificity monoclonal antibodies that had been seen with polyclonal antibodies. The antibodies that reacted only with poly(dG-dC) and poly (dG-dC)n plasmid inserts did not stain chromosomes fixed by either protocol. We conclude that stretches of poly(dG-dC)n sequences do not contribute significantly to the presence of Z-DNA in fixed polytene chromosomes of Drosophila melanogaster.