The Effect of Adaptive Mutagenesis on Genetic Variation at a Linked, Neutral Locus

Based on recent studies in single-celled organisms, it has been argued that a fitness benefit associated with a mutation will increase the probability of that mutation occurring. This increase is independent of mutation rates at other loci and is called adaptive mutagenesis. We modeled the effect of adaptive mutagenesis on populations of haploid organisms with adaptive mutation rates ranging from 0 to 1 X 10(-5). Allele frequencies at the selected locus and a neutral linked locus were tracked. We also observed the amount of linkage disequilibrium during the selective sweep and the final heterozygosity after the sweep. The presence of adaptive mutagenesis increases the number of genetic backgrounds carrying the new fitter allele, making the outcomes more representative of the population before the selection. Therefore, more neutral genetic variation is preserved in simulations with adaptive mutagenesis than in those without it due to hitchhiking. Since adaptive mutagenesis is time-dependent, it can generate mutants when other mechanisms of mutation cannot. In addition, adaptive mutagenesis has the potential to confound both phylogeny construction and the detection of natural selection from patterns of nucleotide variation.     

环境胁迫诱导的细胞适应性突变

细胞具有普遍的突变和进化能力, 如病原菌的抗药性、工业菌株的适应性和人体细胞的癌变等, 但是细胞的适应性突变是如何产生的呢？通过非致死性突变分析模型的建立与应用, 产生了新的适应性进化观点, 即环境胁迫诱导细胞适应性突变。这种环境诱导的细胞突变过程涉及多方面的生理调控, 包括细胞内毒性物质(如氧活性物质)积累并造成DNA损伤、DNA错配修复的活性受到抑制、胞内RpoS反应和SOS反应被激活等。这些反应使胞内高保真的DNA复制状态转变为低保真的DNA修复状态, 提高胞内突变率和重组活性。此外, 基因转录影响基因组的不稳定, 容易产生DNA损伤, 并造成局部的高突变率, 即形成了转录偶联的DNA修复与突变为基础的适应性突变观点。文章围绕环境胁迫诱导细胞突变率增加和转录偶联的DNA修复与突变这两种适应性突变分子机制, 阐述其相关的研究进展, 以期更好地理解环境条件诱导细胞发生适应性突变的过程。     

Adaptive response and enhancement of N-methyl-N'-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine mutagenesis by chloramphenicol in Streptomyces fradiae.

Streptomyces fradiae expressed an adaptive response to treatment with small doses of N-methyl-N'-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine (MNNG) that caused a reduction in mutagenesis by treatment with larger doses of MNNG. Treatment of S. fradiae with high levels of MNNG in the presence of chloramphenicol caused enhancement of mutagenesis, independent of the adaptive response.     

Persistence and adaptive mutagenesis in biofilms

The mechanisms of formation of persisting cells in planktonic and structured microbial populations are considered. The relations between persistence and adaptive mutagenesis are discussed. Persisting cells are suggested to be among the major objects of adaptive mutagenesis and act as an instrument of the microevolution processes in microbial biofilms.     

Modulation of allele leakiness and adaptive mutability inEscherichia coli

It is shown that partial phenotypic suppression of two ochre mutations (argE3 andlacZU118) and an amber mutation (inargE) by sublethal concentrations of streptomycin in anrpsL ⁺ (streptomycin-sensitive) derivative of theEscherichia coli strain AB1157 greatly enhances their adaptive mutability under selection. Streptomycin also increases adaptive mutability brought about by theppm mutation described earlier. Inactivation ofrecA affects neither phenotypic suppression by streptomycin nor replication-associated mutagenesis but abolishes adaptive mutagenesis. These results indicate a causal relationship between allele leakiness and adaptive mutability.     

Yeasts acquire resistance secondary to antifungal drug treatment by adaptive mutagenesis

Acquisition of resistance secondary to treatment both by microorganisms and by tumor cells is a major public health concern. Several species of bacteria acquire resistance to various antibiotics through stress-induced responses that have an adaptive mutagenesis effect. So far, adaptive mutagenesis in yeast has only been described when the stress is nutrient deprivation. Here, we hypothesized that adaptive mutagenesis in yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae and Candida albicans as model organisms) would also take place in response to antifungal agents (5-fluorocytosine or flucytosine, 5-FC, and caspofungin, CSP), giving rise to resistance secondary to treatment with these agents. We have developed a clinically relevant model where both yeasts acquire resistance when exposed to these agents. Stressful lifestyle associated mutation (SLAM) experiments show that the adaptive mutation frequencies are 20 (S. cerevisiae -5-FC), 600 (C. albicans -5-FC) or 1000 (S. cerevisiae - CSP) fold higher than the spontaneous mutation frequency, the experimental data for C. albicans -5-FC being in agreement with the clinical data of acquisition of resistance secondary to treatment. The spectrum of mutations in the S. cerevisiae -5-FC model differs between spontaneous and acquired, indicating that the molecular mechanisms that generate them are different. Remarkably, in the acquired mutations, an ectopic intrachromosomal recombination with an 87% homologous gene takes place with a high frequency. In conclusion, we present here a clinically relevant adaptive mutation model that fulfils the conditions reported previously.     

Inhibitory effect of theophylline on repair of potentially lethal MMS-induced damages to DNA in V79 cells

Vanillin and its isomer o-vanillin have an effect on the adaptive and SOS responses, as well as mutagenesis, induced in Escherichia coli by N-methyl-N-nitrosourea (MNU) and UV irradiation, potentiating in some cases and suppressing in others. o-Vanillin markedly inhibited the MNU-induced adaptive response, while both vanillins potentiated the UV-induced SOS response. These phenomena appear to be responsible for the comutagenic or antimutagenic role of these chemicals in MNU and UV mutagenesis.     

Pathways of mutagenesis and repair in Escherichia coli exposed to low levels of simple alkylating agents.

Mutagenesis by simple alkylating agents is thought to occur by either a lexA+-dependent process called error-prone repair or a lex-independent process often attributed to mispairing during replication. We show here that error-prone repair is responsible for the majority of mutants formed after a large dose of alkylating agent, but it is unlikely that it contributes significantly to mutagenesis during exposure to low concentrations of these chemicals. The mutagenicity of these low doses of alkylating agent is reduced by a repair system constitutively present in lexA+ cells but absent in lexA mutants. This system reduces mutagenesis until a second error-free system, called the adaptive responses, can be induced [P. Jeggo, M. Defais, L. Samson, and P. Schendel, Mol. Gen. Genet, 157:1-9, 1977; L. Samson and J. Cairns, Nature (London) 267:281-283, 1977]. The adaptive response is capable of dealing with a much larger amount of alkylation damage than the constitutive system and, when induced, appears to be able to reduce mutagenesis by both decreasing the number of sites available for mutagenesis and delaying the induction of error-prone repair enzymes. Finally, we discuss a model of chemically induced mutagenesis based on these findings which maintains that the observed mutation frequency is dependent on a "race" between these two error-free systems and the two mutagenic pathways.     

Alkylating Agents Induce Uvm, a Reca-Independent Inducible Mutagenic Phenomenon in Escherichia Coli

Noninstructive DNA damage in Escherichia coli induces SOS functions hypothesized to be required for mutagenesis and translesion DNA synthesis at noncoding DNA lesions. We have recently demonstrated that in E. coli cells incapable of SOS induction, prior UV-irradiation nevertheless strongly enhances mutagenesis at a noninstructive lesion borne on M13 DNA. Here, we address the question whether this effect, named UVM for UV modulation of mutagenesis, can be induced by other DNA damaging agents. Exponentially growing δrecA cells were pretreated with alkylating agents before transfection with M13 single-stranded DNA bearing a site-specific ethenocytosine residue. Effect of cell pretreatment on survival of the transfected DNA was determined as transfection efficiency. Mutagenesis at the ethenocytosine site in pretreated or untreated cells was analyzed by multiplex DNA sequencing, a phenotype-independent technology. Our data show that 1-methyl-3-nitro-1-nitrosoguanidine, N-nitroso-N-methylurea and dimethylsulfate, but not methyl iodide, are potent inducers of UVM. Because alkylating agents induce the adaptive response to defend against DNA alkylation, we asked if the genes constituting the adaptive response are required for UVM. Our data show that MNNG induction of UVM is independent of ada, alkA and alkB genes and define UVM as an inducible mutagenic phenomenon distinct from the E. coli adaptive and SOS responses.     

Appearance and properties of L-sorbose-utilizing mutants of Candida albicans obtained on a selective plate.

This is the first report that adaptive mutagenesis can arise by chromosomal nondisjunction, a phenomenon previously associated exclusively with DNA alterations. We previously uncovered a novel regulatory mechanism in Candida albicans in which the assimilation of an alternative sugar, l-sorbose, was determined by copy number of chromosome 5, such that monosomic strains utilized l-sorbose, whereas disomic strains did not. We present evidence that this formation of monosomy of chromosome 5, which is apparently a result of nondisjunction, appeared with increased frequencies after a selective condition was applied, i.e., by adaptive mutagenesis. The rate of formation of l-sorbose-utilizing mutants per viable cell per day ranged from 10(-6) at the initial time of detection to 10(-2) after 4 days of incubation on the selective plate.     

Adaptive,or stationary-phase,mutagenesis, a component of bacterial differentiation in Bacillus subtilis

Adaptive (stationary-phase) mutagenesis occurs in the gram-positive bacterium Bacillus subtilis. Furthermore, taking advantage of B. subtilis as a paradigm for the study of prokaryotic differentiation and development, we have shown that this type of mutagenesis is subject to regulation involving at least two of the genes that are involved in the regulation of post-exponential phase prokaryotic differentiation, i.e., comA and comK. On the other hand, a functional RecA protein was not required for this type of mutagenesis. The results seem to suggest that a small subpopulation(s) of the culture is involved in adaptive mutagenesis and that this subpopulation(s) is hypermutable. The existence of such a hypermutable subpopulation(s) raises important considerations with respect to evolution, the development of specific mutations, the nature of bacterial populations, and the level of communication among bacteria in an ecological niche.     

Effects of vanillin and o-vanillin on induction of DNA-repair networks: modulation of mutagenesis in Escherichia coli

Vanillin and its isomer o-vanillin have an effect on the adaptive and SOS responses, as well as mutagenesis, induced in Escherichia coli by N-methyl-N-nitrosourea (MNU) and UV irradiation, potentiating in some cases and suppressing in others. o-Vanillin markedly inhibited the MNU-induced adaptive response, while both vanillins potentiated the UV-induced SOS response. These phenomena appear to be responsible for the comutagenic or antimutagenic role of these chemicals in MNU and UV mutagenesis.     

An Escherichia coli mutant refractory to nitrosoguanidine mutagenesis

Summary A newly-isolated Escherichia coli mutant suffers only about 10% as many mutations as normal strains on exposure to nitrosoguanidine¹. The responsible mutation, inm-1, maps at approximately minute 79 in the current E. coli genetic map. The mutant is normal for overall growth, nitrosoguanidine lethality, spontaneous mutagenesis, ultraviolet light lethality and mutagenesis, ethyl methanesulfonate lethality and mutagenesis, and the adaptive repair induced by alkylating agents. The existence of this mutation proves that nitrosoguanidine mutagenesis is not merely the result of reactions between the chemical and DNA, but requires specific cellular function(s), and underscores the peculiarity of nitrosoguanidine as a mutagen.     

Activation of the bgl operon by adaptive mutation

In growing Escherichia coli K12 cells, the cryptic bgl operon is activated 98% of the time by insertions of IS1 or IS5 into the control region, designated bglR. The activated bgl operon permits utilization of the beta-glucoside sugar arbutin as a sole carbon and energy source. The bgl operon is also activated by late-occurring mutations during prolonged selection on arbutin. The late-occurring mutations that occurred during prolonged carbon starvation in the presence of arbutin were "adaptive mutations" because they were specific to the presence of arbutin, and they did not occur during prolonged starvation in the absence of arbutin. The spectrum of late-arising mutations differed from that of early-arising, growth-dependent mutations in that 20% of the late-arising mutants resulted from mutations at the hns locus. This provides the first direct evidence for adaptive mutagenesis mediated by the insertion of IS elements. Because no special genetic background is required to select Bgl+ mutants, this affords the opportunity to study IS-element-mediated adaptive mutagenesis in a variety of genetic backgrounds, including the backgrounds of natural isolates of E. coli.      

Evaluation of drug candidates in a battery of short-term genetic toxicology assays: overview

2-Hydroxy-3-methoxybenzaldehyde (omicron-vanillin), the antimutagenic effect of which has been reported on mutagenesis induced by 4-nitroquinoline 1-oxide (4NQO) in Escherichia coli WP2s, enhanced N-methyl-N'-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine (MNNG)-induced mutagenesis in the same strain. A remarkable enhancement of mutagenesis provoked by N-methyl-N-nitrosourea (MNU) was also observed by the addition of omicron-vanillin. No enhancing effect was observed on mutagenesis induced by other mutagens such as methyl methanesulfonate (MMS), dimethylsulfate, N-ethyl-N'-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine (ENNG), N-ethyl-N-nitrosourea (ENU), ethyl methanesulfonate, diethylsulfate, 4NQO and furylfuramide (AF-2). On the contrary, omicron-vanillin greatly suppressed AF-2- and 4NQO-induced mutagenesis and showed a slight suppressing effect against mutagenesis induced by MMS, ENNG and ENU. One possible explanation for the enhancing effect of omicron-vanillin on the mutagenesis induced by MNNG or MNU in E. coli WP2s may be inhibition of an inducible adaptive response. Among 7 derivatives of omicron-vanillin, 2-hydroxy-3-ethoxy-benzaldehyde, omicron-hydroxybenzaldehyde and m-methoxybenzaldehyde showed an enhancing effect on MNNG-induced mutagenesis.     

Contribution of the mismatch DNA repair system to the generation of stationary-phase-induced mutants of Bacillus subtilis

A reversion assay system previously implemented to demonstrate the existence of adaptive or stationary-phase-induced mutagenesis in Bacillus subtilis was utilized in this report to study the influence of the mismatch DNA repair (MMR) system on this type of mutagenesis. Results revealed that a strain deficient in MutSL showed a significant propensity to generate increased numbers of stationary-phase-induced revertants. These results suggest that absence or depression of MMR is an important factor in the mutagenesis of nongrowing B. subtilis cells because of the role of MMR in repairing DNA damage. In agreement with this suggestion, a significant decrease in the number of adaptive revertant colonies, for the three markers tested, occurred in B. subtilis cells which overexpressed a component of the MMR system. Interestingly, the single overexpression of mutS, but not of mutL, was sufficient to decrease the level of adaptive mutants in the reversion assay system of B. subtilis. The results presented in this work, as well as in our previous studies, appear to suggest that an MMR deficiency, putatively attributable to inactivation or saturation with DNA damage of MutS, may occur in a subset of B. subtilis cells that differentiate into the hypermutable state.     

Evidence that N-methyl-N'-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine induces adaptive response in Bacillus thuringiensis

Bacillus thuringiensis is shown to have an inducible error-free repair system for alkylation damage as found in Escherichia coli and Bacillus subtilis. Growth of cells in the presence of low concentrations of N-methyl-N'-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine (MNNG) induces an adaptive response which is characterized by an increase in resistance to killing and mutagenesis by challenge with higher concentrations of MNNG. In addition, we have noted with interest that adaptive low doses seem to produce lesions at a rate sufficient to induce an increase of mutation frequency, and inhibition of cell division. The possibility of an interaction between SOS and adaptive responses with these low doses of MNNG is discussed.