Saponins as cytotoxic agents: a review

Saponins are natural glycosides which possess a wide range of pharmacological properties including cytotoxic activity. In this review, the recent studies (2005–2009) concerning the cytotoxic activity of saponins have been summarized. The correlations between the structure and the cytotoxicity of both steroid and triterpenoid saponins have been described as well as the most common mechanisms of action.     

Anti-tumor agents 255: novel glycyrrhetinic acid-dehydrozingerone conjugates as cytotoxic agents

Esterification of glycyrrhetinic acid (GA) with dehydrozingerone (DZ) resulted in a novel cytotoxic GA-DZ conjugate. Based on this exciting finding, we conjugated eleven different DZ analogs with GA or other triterpenoids, including oleanoic acid (OA) or ursolic acid (UA). In an in vitro anti-cancer assay using nine different human tumor cell lines, most of the GA-DZ conjugates showed significant potency. Particularly, compounds 5, 29, and 30 showed significant cytotoxic effects against LN-Cap, 1A9, and KB cells with ED(50) values of 0.6, 0.8, and 0.9 microM, respectively. Similar conjugates between DZ and OA or UA were inactive suggesting that the GA component is critical for activity. Notably, although GA-DZ conjugates showed potent cytotoxic activity, the individual components (GA and DZ analogs) were inactive. Thus, GA-DZ conjugates are new chemical entities and represent interesting hits for anti-cancer drug discovery and development.     

Discovery of novel andrographolide derivatives as cytotoxic agents

The natural diterpenoid andrographolide (1) exhibits various biological activities. Seventeen derivatives of 1 were prepared via esterification and etherification of 14-dehydroxy-11,12-didehydroandrographolide (2). Most derivatives demonstrated significant inhibition against tumor cell growth. The most active compounds, 3b and 3c, had GI₅₀ values of 1.46–9.19 μM against A549, DU145, KB and KB-Vin tumor cells. In an immunocytochemical study, treatment with compound 3c disrupted microtubule dynamics in PC-3 cells, but caused no accumulation of metaphase cells, which is a phenotype dissimilar from that of 1. This difference suggests that structural modification of 1 resulted in a shift in the underlying molecular mechanism.     

Synthesis of unsymmetrical biphenyls as potent cytotoxic agents

Twenty-six unsymmetrical biphenyls were synthesized and evaluated for cytotoxic activity against DU145, A549, KB and KB-Vin tumor cell lines. Three compounds 27, 35 and 40 showed very potent activity against the HTCL panel with an IC(50) value range of 0.04-3.23 microM. In addition, fourteen active compounds were all more potent against the drug-resistant KB-Vin cell line than the parental KB cell line. Preliminary SAR analysis indicated that two bulky substituents on the 2,2'-positions of unsymmetrical biphenyl skeleton are necessary and crucial for in vitro anticancer activity, thus providing a good starting point to develop unsymmetrical biphenyls as novel anticancer agents.     

ZnCl2 catalyzed new coumarinyl-chalcones as cytotoxic agents

A new series of coumarin-yl-chalcone derivatives (3a-m) had been designed and synthesized through different reactions such as aromatic addition, cyclization and Claisen-Schmidt reactions in good yields (54–78%). 5-acetyl-4-(2-hydroxyphenyl) -6-methyl-3, 4-dihydropyrimidin-2(1H) -one (1) has been synthesized by multi-component one pot reaction of salicylaldehyde, methyl acetoacetate and urea, which was further reacted with malonic acid employing ZnCl₂ catalyst to yield 5-acetyl-4-(4-hydroxy-2-oxo-2H-chromen-8-yl) -6-methyl-3, 4-dihydropyrimidin-2(1H) -one (2). The title compounds (3a-m) were synthesised by reacting 5-acetyl-4-(4-hydroxy-2-oxo-2H-chromen-8-yl) -6-methyl-3, 4-dihydropyrimidin-2(1H)-one (2) with different aromatic aldehydes in the presence of potassium hydroxide. In silico studies, a preliminary screening method for predicting the anti-cancer activity was performed for the synthesized compounds (3a-m) against Src, Alb tyrosine kinase and homology model protein (PDB ID: 4csv). The derivatives 3h and 3m showed moderate binding energies. The in vitro cytotoxic activity was evaluated for the compounds 3h and 3m by using human cancer cell-line morphology and MTT assay against three human cell-lines A549 (Lung), Jurkat (Leukemia) and MCF-7 (Breast). The results indicate that the derivatives 3h and 3m display significant anti-cancer activity, however it was found to be less cytotoxic when compared to the standard used i.e. Imatinib.     

Antitumor agents. Part 209: Pheophorbide-a derivatives as photo-Independent cytotoxic agents

A methanolic crude extract of the plant Garuga pinnata Roxb. (Burseraceae) showed promising cytotoxic activity against a panel of human tumor cell lines in vitro, including KB and its drug-resistant sublines (Ferguson et al. Cancer Res. 1988, 48, 5956). Pheophorbide-a and-b methyl esters (3,4) were isolated as active principles with broad photo-dependent cytotoxic activities in the micromolar range. These findings prompted SAR studies of known and novel pheophorbide-a derivatives as photo-dependent and photo-independent cytotoxic agents. The results showed that zinc-protoporphyrin IX (10), zinc 13(R)-hydroxypheophorbide-a methyl ester (22), and zinc chlorin-e6 trimethyl ester (13) possessed photo-independent cytotoxic activity. Compounds 13 and 22 were the most active cytotoxic agents of the series (mean ED(50) 4.6 +/- 1.0 microM and 5.7 +/- 0.7 microM, respectively) against KB cells incubated in the dark.     

Substituted 4-hydroxyproline di- and tri-peptides as cytotoxic agents

Summary 4-Hydroxyproline di- and tri-peptides and N-cbz-hydroxypropylglycinamides were observed to be potent cytotoxic agents against the growth of suspended single cells, L-1210, Tmolt₃, and HeLa-S³. The agents were not as potent against the growth of cultured solid tumor cells. Selected derivatives were investigated for their mode of action in Tmolt₃ leukemia cells. The compounds selectively inhibited DNA synthesis at 50 and 100smM. The target site of action of the agents appeared to be the purinede novo pathway with marked inhibition of the activities of the two regulatory enzymes of the pathway, i.e. PRPP amido-transferase and IMP dehydrogenase. d[NTP] pools were reduced by the agents consistent with their overall reduction of DNA synthesis. Other marginally inhibited targets of the agents were r-RNA polymerase and TMP-kinase activities. The DNA molecule itself did not appear to be a target of these agents.     

Atovaquone derivatives as potent cytotoxic and apoptosis inducing agents

2-Piperazinyl naphthoquinones (2) and 2-piperidinyl naphthoquinones (3) were designed and synthesized as new cytotoxic and apoptosis inducing agents by utilizing the anti-parasite drug atovaquone as lead compound. Several compounds displayed significantly improved cytotoxic activities against a panel of cancer cell lines than that of atovaquone. These compounds also induced apoptosis through activating pro-apoptotic caspases 9 and 3.     

Carboplatin-containing porphyrin-platinum complexes as cytotoxic and phototoxic antitumor agents

Tetraarylporphyrins of the Ar:Ar′ = 3:1-type were synthesized from pyrrole, 4-hydroxybenzaldehyde and benzaldehydes substituted with ethyleneglycol, hydroxy and quaternary ammonium substituents for solubilization in DMF and, in particular, in water. After etherification with the tosylate of diethyl cyclobutanedicarboxylate and subsequent ester hydrolysis, the resulting carboxylic acid groups were used to bind platinum fragments bearing two ammonia and (RR/SS)-trans-1,2-diaminocyclohexane ligands, respectively, as non-leaving groups. In comparison to hematoporphyrin-platinum complexes, the title compounds show a 30 nm bathochromic shift of their absorption bands increasing the penetration depth of the red light used for irradiation in photodynamic tumor therapy. The antiproliferative activity of 24 new platinum complexes differing in the porphyrin ligands and the platinum fragments were studied in tests with J82 bladder cancer cells. The compounds showed the cytotoxic effect of the platinum moiety and after irradiation the phototoxic effect of the porphyrin system.     

New ursolic and betulinic derivatives as potential cytotoxic agents

Fifteen new ursolic and betulinic triterpenoids, bearing various functionalities at C-3 and C-28 were synthesized as potential cytotoxic agents. All compounds were obtained by a hemisynthetic route via ursolic and betulinic acids. Preliminary screening of these compounds on human HT 29 colon cancer cells revealed inhibitory activity for three of them. Beta-D-Glucopyranosyl-3beta-hydroxyurs-12(13)-en-28-oate 1c, 3beta-3-(3-pyridyl)-prop-2-enoyloxyurs-12(13)-en-28-oic acid 1i and the potassium salt of 3beta-cinnamoyloxylup-20(29)-en-28-oic acid 2d demonstrated cytotoxic activity in the micromolar range: 8.0, 45.0 and 8.0 microM, respectively.     

Design and synthesis of 1,2,3-triazolo-phenanthrene hybrids as cytotoxic agents

A series of new 1,2,3-triazolo-phenanthrene hybrids has been synthesized by employing Cu(I)-catalyzed azide-alkyne cycloaddition (CuAAC) reaction. These compounds were evaluated for their in vitro cytotoxic potential against various human cancer cell lines viz. lung (A549), prostate (PC-3 and DU145), gastric (HGC-27), cervical (HeLa), triple negative breast (MDA-MB-231, MDA-MB-453) and breast (BT-549, 4T1) cells. Among the tested compounds, 7d displayed highest cytotoxicity against DU145 cells with IC₅₀ value of 1.5 ± 0.09 µM. Further, the cell cycle analysis shown that it blocks G0/G1 phase of the cell cycle in a dose dependent manner. In order to determine the effect of compound on cell viability, phase contrast microscopy, AO/EB, DAPI, DCFDA and JC-1 staining studies were performed. These studies clearly indicated that the compound 7d inhibited the cell proliferation of DU145 cells. Relative viscosity measurements and molecular docking studies indicated that these compounds bind to DNA by intercalation.     

Novel 5-azaindolocarbazoles as cytotoxic agents and Chk1 inhibitors

We describe here an efficient synthesis of new 5-azaindolocarbazoles designed for cytotoxic and Chk1 inhibiting properties. The synthesis of ‘symmetrical’ and ‘dissymmetrical’ structures is discussed. Concerning the dissymmetrical 5-azaindolocarbazoles derivatives, with both an indole moiety and a 5-azaindole moiety, the synthesis was achieved using two very efficient key steps. The first one is a Stille reaction with a 3-trimethylstannyl-5-azaindole derivative and the second one a photochemical step leading to the proposed polycyclic structure. Various pharmacomodulations were performed to investigate the structure–activity relationships (SAR). Several substituents such as OBn, OH, and methylenedioxy groups were successfully introduced on the indole moiety of the 5-azaindolocarbazole. Compounds with or without substituents on the nitrogen atom of the maleimide were prepared, as well as derivatives with glucopyranosyl substituent on the nitrogen atom of the indole moiety. The cytotoxicity of these new compounds was evaluated on two cell lines (L1210, HT29). Several compounds showed cytotoxicity in the sub-micromolar range. Among the most cytototoxic was the 1,3-dioxolo[4,5-b]-6-(2-dimethylaminoethyl)-1H-pyrido[3′,4′:4,5]pyrrolo[3,2-i]pyrrolo[3,4-g]carbazole-5,7(6H,12H)-dione (35, IC₅₀ = 195 nM on L1210). The compounds were also investigated for their Chk1 inhibiting activity. Compounds without any substitution on the maleimide moiety were the most potent. This is the case of compounds 45–47 with IC₅₀ of, respectively, 72, 27, and 14 nM toward Chk1. Compound 46, which exhibits moderate cytotoxicity, appears to be a good candidate for development in a multi-drug anticancer therapy.     

Synthesis and preliminary evaluation of curcumin analogues as cytotoxic agents

A series of curcumin analogues with different substituents at the 4-position of the phenyl group were synthesized and screened for in vitro cytotoxicity against a panel of human cancer cell lines. Several novel curcumin analogues, especially 32 and 34, exhibited selective and potent cytotoxic activity against human epidermoid carcinoma cell line A-431 and human glioblastoma cell line U-251, implying their specific potential in the chemoprevention and chemotherapy of skin cancer and glioma. The preliminary SAR information extracted from the results suggested that introduction of appropriate substituents to the 4′-positions could be a promising approach for the development of new cytotoxic curcumin analogues with special selectivity for A-431 and U-251 cell lines.     

Novel bis(indolyl)hydrazide-hydrazones as potent cytotoxic agents

A series of bis(indolyl) hydrazide-hydrazones 5a-n were synthesized and evaluated for their cytotoxicity against selected human cancer cell lines. The reaction of indole-3-carboxaldehyde 2 with indole-3-carbohydrazide 4 in presence of catalytic amount of acetic acid afforded 5a-n in good yields. Among the synthesized bis(indolyl)hydrazide-hydrazones, the compound 5b with N-(p-chlorobenzyl) and bromo substituents was found to be the most potent against multiple cancer cell lines (IC(50)=1.0 μM, MDA-MB-231). The compound 5k exhibited selective cytotoxicity against breast cancer cell line MCF7 (IC(50)=3.1 μM).     

Antitumor agents 216. Synthesis and evaluation of paclitaxel-camptothecin conjugates as novel cytotoxic agents

Five conjugates (16-20) composed of a paclitaxel and a camptothecin derivative joined by an imine linkage were synthesized and evaluated as cytotoxic agents and as inhibitors of DNA topoisomerase I. All of the conjugates were potent inhibitors of tumor cell replication with improved activity relative to camptothecin. Significantly, compounds 16-18 were more active than paclitaxel and camptothecin against HCT-8 (colon adenocarcinoma) cell replication, and the spectrum of activity was different from a simple mixture of paclitaxel and camptothecin. All of the conjugates were significantly less potent than camptothecin as inhibitors of human topoisomerase I in vitro with 16, 18, and 19 showing only marginal activity at 50 microM. Based on activity against drug-resistant cell line replication, one could conclude that the conjugates are simply acting as 'weak taxanes', but the spectrum of activity, particularly against MCF-7 and HCT-8, strongly suggests that a novel mechanism of action has been achieved through conjugation.     

Glycosidation of lupane-type triterpenoids as potent in vitro cytotoxic agents

The weak hydrosolubility of betulinic acid (3) hampers the clinical development of this natural anticancer agent. In order to circumvent this problem and to enhance the pharmacological properties of betulinic acid (3) and the lupane-type triterpenes lupeol (1), betulin (2), and methyl betulinate (7), glycosides (beta-D-glucosides, alpha-L-rhamnosides, and alpha-D-arabinosides) were synthesized and in vitro tested for cytotoxicity against three cancerous (A-549, DLD-1, and B16-F1) and one healthy (WS1) cell lines. The addition of a sugar moiety at the C-3 or C-28 position of betulin (2) resulted in a loss of cytotoxicity. In contrast, the 3-O-beta-D-glucosidation of lupeol (1) improved the activity by 7- to 12-fold (IC50 14-15.0 microM). Moreover, the results showed that cancer cell lines are 8- to 12-fold more sensitive to the 3-O-alpha-L-rhamnopyranoside derivative of betulinic acid (IC50 2.6-3.9 microM, 22) than the healthy cells (IC50 31 microM). Thus, this study indicates that 3-O-glycosides of lupane-type triterpenoids represent an interesting class of potent in vitro cytotoxic agents.     

Antitumor agents 210. Synthesis and evaluation of taxoid-epipodophyllotoxin conjugates as novel cytotoxic agents

Five compounds composed of a taxoid (paclitaxel or cephalomannine) and a 4'-O-demethyl epipodophyllotoxin derivative joined by an imine linkage were prepared and evaluated as cytotoxic agents and inhibitors of mammalian DNA topoisomerase II. Compounds 12 and 14-16 exhibited comparable or better activity than the unconjugated epipodophyllotoxin derivatives in most tumor cell lines, and 12, 15, and 16 also showed enhanced activity against paclitaxel-resistant cells. Compound 13, which contains an epipodophyllotoxin moiety at both the taxoid 2' and 7 positions, did not stimulate protein-DNA breaks, but was 2-fold more potent than 12 and 15 and comparable to GL-331 in the topo II inhibitory assay.     

Antitumor agents. Part 214: synthesis and evaluation of curcumin analogues as cytotoxic agents

Fifty-eight curcumin analogues were prepared and evaluated for in vitro cytotoxicity against a panel of human tumor cell lines. Compound was the most potent analogue against several cell lines, including HOS (bone cancer) and 1A9 (breast cancer), with ED50 values of 0.97 and <0.63 microg/mL, respectively.     

2H-1,2,3-Triazole-chalcones as novel cytotoxic agents against prostate cancer

Prostate cancer is an important cause of death in the male population and for which there is no satisfactory chemotherapy. Herein a new series of chalcone hybrids containing 2H-1,2,3-triazole core as the ring B has been synthesized and evaluated in vitro against PC-3 prostate cancer cell line. Compounds 4a, 4c and 4e significantly reduced cell viability and showed IC₅₀ of 28.55, 15.64 and 25.56 µM, respectively. The structure-activity relationship supported by computational chemistry points that the polarity of the molecular surface area should have some relevance to the efficiency of the compounds, in particular the ratio of the partial positive charge sites and the total molecular surface area exposed to the cell environment.     

Design and synthesis of diarylamines and diarylethers as cytotoxic antitumor agents

Based on a shared structural core of diarylamine in several known anticancer drugs as well as a new cytotoxic hit 6-chloro-2-(4-cyanophenyl)amino-3-nitropyridine (7), 30 diarylamines and diarylethers were designed, synthesized, and evaluated for cytotoxic activity against A549, KB, KB-vin, and DU145 human tumor cell lines (HTCL). Four new leads 11e, 12, 13a, and 13b were discovered with GI(50) values ranging from 0.33 to 3.45μM. Preliminary SAR results revealed that a diarylamine or diarylether could serve as an active structural core, meta-chloro and ortho-nitro groups on the A-ring (either pyridine or phenyl ring) were necessary and crucial for cytotoxic activity, and the para-substituents on the other phenyl ring (B-ring) were related to inhibitory selectivity for different tumor cells. In an investigation of potential biological targets of the new leads, high thoughput kinase screening discovered that new leads 11e, 12 and 13b especially inhibit Mer tyrosine kinase, a proto-oncogene associated with munerous tumor types, with IC(50) values of 2.2-3.0μM. Therefore, these findings provide a good starting point to optimize a new class of compounds as potential anticancer agents, particularly targeting Mer tyrosine kinase.