共查询到20条相似文献,搜索用时 359 毫秒
1.
The ecological drivers of macrophyte development in a lowland agricultural area were tested based on a 2008 survey on the Wkra River catchment. Our survey was carried out in the rivers of an agricultural area with relatively high concentrations of both nitrates and phosphates in the water. By using the Polish macrophyte method, we were able to calculate several botanical metrics. Canonical ordination analyses used to relate biological data to environmental variables such as physical and chemical parameters of water, surface water velocity or river width, were carried out using CANOCO for Windows. Redundancy analysis (RDA) showed that pH and alkalinity were the parameters best correlated with the distribution of macrophytes and values of macrophyte indices. The recorded values of the Macrophyte Index for River in the Wkra River and its tributaries reflected their good and moderate ecological status (the Water Framework Directive scale). Despite the fact that nutrient concentrations in the water were relatively high and that most of the sites represented eutrophic conditions, the results of this survey showed that non-nutrient parameters may play an important role in explaining aquatic plant occurrence in rivers that have been subjected to eutrophication. 相似文献
2.
Anne Lyche Solheim Seppo Rekolainen S. Jannicke Moe Laurence Carvalho Geoff Phillips Robert Ptacnik W. Ellis Penning Laszlo G. Toth Constance O’Toole Ann-Kristin L. Schartau Trygve Hesthagen 《Aquatic Ecology》2008,42(2):317-334
The objective of this synthesis is to present the key messages and draw the main conclusions from the work on lakes in the
REBECCA project, pointing out their links to theoretical ecology and their applicability for the WFD implementation. Type-specific
results were obtained from analyses of large pan-European datasets for phytoplankton, macrophytes, macroinvertebrates and
fish, and indicators and relationships showing the impact of eutrophication or acidification on these biological elements
were constructed. The thresholds identified in many of the response curves are well suited for setting ecological status class
boundaries and can be applied in the intercalibration of classification systems. Good indicators for phytoplankton (chrysophytes,
cyanobacteria) and macrophytes (isoetids and charaphytes) responses to eutrophication were identified, and the level of eutrophication
pressure needed to reach the thresholds for these indicators was quantified. Several existing metrics developed for macrophytes
had low comparability and need further harmonisation to be useful for intercalibration of classification systems. For macroinvertebrates,
a number of metrics developed for rivers turned out to be less useful to describe lake responses to eutrophication and acidification,
whereas other species based indicators were more promising. All the biological elements showed different responses in different
lake types according to alkalinity and humic substances, and also partly according to depth. Better harmonisation of monitoring
methods is needed to achieve better precision in the dose–response curves. Future research should include impacts of hydromorphological
pressures and climate change, as well as predictions of timelags involved in responses to reduction of pressures. 相似文献
3.
Estimating confidence of European WFD ecological status class and WISER Bioassessment Uncertainty Guidance Software (WISERBUGS) 总被引:1,自引:0,他引:1
Ralph T. Clarke 《Hydrobiologia》2013,704(1):39-56
The Water Framework Directive (WFD) requires estimates of the confidence and precision associated with any scheme for assessing and monitoring the ecological status class of any European rivers, lakes, transitional or coastal waters. This is a complex important issue, especially for waterbody assessments based on multiple metrics and/or two or more taxonomic groups. This paper aims to contribute towards improving understanding and providing practical approaches to assessing confidence of class by (i) discussing the various sources and causes of uncertainty, (ii) using UK rivers macroinvertebrate datasets to illustrate the estimation of replicate, temporal and spatial variance components and the implications for water body metric precision, confidence of class and optimal sampling design, (iii) introducing new freely available general software WISER Bioassessment Uncertainty Guidance Software (WISERBUGS) which uses prior sampling uncertainty estimates with user-specified metrics, class limits and metric combination rules to simulate the joint sampling uncertainty in metric EQR values and provide estimates of confidence of class based on individual metrics, (optionally weighted) multi-metric indices and/or multi-metric classification rules (worst case, mean or median class) based on one or more WFD biological quality elements. 相似文献
4.
European river plant communities: the importance of organic pollution and the usefulness of existing macrophyte metrics 总被引:4,自引:4,他引:0
Krzysztof Szoszkiewicz Teresa Ferreira Thomas Korte Annette Baattrup-Pedersen John Davy-Bowker Mattie O’Hare 《Hydrobiologia》2006,566(1):211-234
The macrophyte surveys undertaken as part of the EU-funded STAR project are a unique resource allowing aquatic plant communities
to be studied at a Pan-European scale (211 stream sites with macrophytes in 14 countries). Using this dataset, we examined
the influence of organic pollution in relation to other environmental correlates of river plant community variation across
Europe. We examined the relationships between several existing macrophyte metrics and nutrient enrichment, and we also explored
the possibility of developing a pan-European macrophyte-based assessment system. We showed that trophic (nutrient) status
is an important driver of aquatic plant communities in European rivers. We found that while most existing macrophyte metrics
are useful, none can be applied at a pan-European scale in their current form. Our attempt to redesign the Mean Trophic Rank
(MTR) index by the addition of further species, and the re-scoring of existing species, resulted in a considerable improvement
in the relationship between MTR scores and nutrient variables. We conclude that an enlarged core group of macrophyte species
can form part of an improved pan-European macrophyte-based bioassessment system, although regional modifications may be required
to adequately describe the nutrient status of certain stream types.
Electronic supplementary material Electronic supplementary material is available for this article at
and accessible for authorised users. 相似文献
5.
An application of canonical correspondence analysis for developing ecological quality assessment metrics for river macrophytes 总被引:5,自引:0,他引:5
1. Aquatic macrophyte composition and abundance is required by the European Union's Water Framework Directive for determining ecological status. Five metrics were produced that can be combined to determine the deviation of aquatic macrophytes from reference conditions in Northern Ireland's rivers. 2. Species optima and niche breadths along silt, nitrate, pH, conductivity and dissolved oxygen gradients were generated from aquatic macrophyte and water quality surveys conducted at 273 sites throughout Northern Ireland using Canonical Correspondence Analysis (CCA). Five metric scores based on these environmental gradients were determined at new monitoring sites using the mean optima of the species occurring at the site, weighted by percentage cover and niche breadth of each species. 3. A preliminary reference network of 32 sites of high physico‐chemical and hydromorphological quality, and representative of the range of river types in Northern Ireland, enabled reference metric scores to be produced for each river type. Five unimpacted and twenty impacted sites were used for testing the performance of the metrics. By subtracting reference metric scores from metric scores at a monitoring site measures of ecological impact could be determined along five different impact gradients. Metrics were also combined to give a measure of total ecological change. 4. The metrics system distinguished unimpacted from impacted sites and correctly identified 77% of the known impacts. The metrics distinguished different types of impact, e.g. silt and nitrate. 5. Aquatic macrophyte occurrence and abundance has high natural variability at a site, both temporally and spatially. This method was designed to be sensitive to ecological change whilst reducing noise caused by natural variation. 相似文献
6.
Spatial processes are increasingly associated with species distributions in freshwaters. However, these processes are usually neglected in bioassessment techniques, which may introduce uncontrolled variation in ecological indicators used to express human disturbance. We used partial linear regression to quantify the relative importance of natural variables, human disturbance and spatial variables in structuring variation in boreal lake status indicators based on six biological indicator groups (phytoplankton, macrophytes, diatoms, littoral and profundal macroinvertebrates and fish). We found that, of the pure fractions, human disturbance explained most variation (7–32%) of the ecological quality ratios (EQRs) for all groups, with the exception of littoral macroinvertebrate metric, which was most controlled by natural and spatial variables (15% and 16%, respectively). In addition, pure fractions of natural and spatial variables and joint fractions of different explanatory variable groups structured all biological metrics to various degrees. Phytoplankton, diatom and profundal macroinvertebrate EQRs responded purest to human disturbance but only weakly to pure natural or spatial variation. Our work demonstrates that spatial processes and spatial structuring of the environment can bias bioassessment techniques and hinder the detection of human impact. Thus, it is important to acknowledge spatial autocorrelation, context of metacommunity dynamics, species dispersal traits and variable spatial extent when defining reference conditions and bioassessment techniques for different biological groups. More research is needed to better understand the relative role of spatial processes on ecological metrics originated from different freshwater ecosystems. To this end, our work provides an example of how sources of variation can be identified to increase accuracy in freshwater bioassessment. 相似文献
7.
Despite the widespread application of periphytic diatoms to water quality assessment at a regional level, there is no standard
European sampling protocol or associated assessment metrics. Furthermore, relatively little is known about the uncertainty
in the results of such assessments. One of the objectives of the European project for the Standardisation of River Classifications
(STAR) is to improve and standardise diatom assessment methods. An extensive diatom ring test, together with an audit of the
project results, provided a better understanding and quantification of the uncertainty in quality assessment of running waters
using diatoms. The variation in multimetric analysis shows that the choice of site and substrate for sampling, the inter-operator
differences in diatom taxonomy and the counting techniques are the primary sources of uncertainty. To some extent, this variation
also reveals the robustness of specific metrics in relation to the sources of uncertainty. Of the three most common substrate
types tested (stone, macrophyte and sediment), macrophytes emerge as the most preferred substrate for diatom sampling when
performing multimetric water quality assessment. 相似文献
8.
《Ecological Indicators》2008,8(4):373-388
The implementation of the Water Framework Directive requires the classification of the ecological quality status of benthic macroinvertebrates in costal and transitional waters. The uncertainty and complexity of this task have lead to the creation of specific Geographical Intercalibration Groups (GIGs) for the different ecoregions and types of water bodies established. In this framework, several metrics are under study in the United Kingdom, Spain and Denmark for North East Atlantic coastal waters (NEA-GIG). All of them include in their formulations the AMBI index. Nevertheless, few advances have been made in relation to transitional waters. This paper aims to test the suitability of those methodological procedures for their application in Northern Spanish estuaries. The results show evident divergences in classification of ecological status among methods, although the correlations of corresponding ecological quality ratios (EQRs) are good. Thus, we think that it may be necessary to modify the boundaries between each ecological status category and adjust the reference conditions for the variety of community-types existing in estuarine water bodies. However, some problems arise in the assessment of some naturally stressed communities. In this situation, we found an overall dominance of species tolerant to organic enrichment in all status categories and low range of variation of AMBI index. This aspect introduces some uncertainty in relation to the ability of this index to detect a deleterious effect in these estuarine communities naturally stressed. On the other hand, we found some sites that achieve good status according to the metrics used, even though the number of opportunistic species was high. The use of combined approaches that incorporate physicochemical condition of sediments would be a straightforward approach to reduce the risk of failing in the assignation of ecological status category. 相似文献
9.
The aim of the study was to verify botanical and ecological traits of river typology based on macrophytes. We compared diversities of macrophyte communities in different river types and their relationship to water quality. The 240 surveyed rivers were situated in the central-west of Poland in a lowland area. Species compositional similarities were analysed using the Jaccard index. The macrophyte matrix was classified into four groups: Large rivers (LR), Sandy rivers (SaR), Stony rivers (StR) and Organic rivers (OR). The highest level of homogeneity was found for LR, followed by OR, StR and SaR. The greatest differences in species composition were found between LR and StR. Variabilities of indices (species richness, Shannon, Simpson and Pielou indices, and total cover) confirmed the specific diversity patterns in the four types of rivers. All metrics based on relative abundance were strongly correlated with each other, and they were never correlated with water quality. The total covers of LR and OR as well as species richness of LR show some correlation with water quality. The total cover was correlated with water quality in OR and LR. The communities with the highest species richness were related with OR. 相似文献
10.
A multimetric diatom index to assess the ecological status of coastal Galician rivers (NW Spain) 总被引:1,自引:0,他引:1
There are many rivers in northwest Spain as a consequence of the mountainous landscape and the granitic geology subjected
to Atlantic influences. Water and epilithic diatoms samples were collected at 72 sites in Galicia flowing into the Atlantic
Ocean and Cantabrian Sea in summer 2002–2003 and spring 2004. These sites included minimally disturbed sites, defined as reference
sites, and impacted sites which were influenced by different human pressures. We used the diatom assemblages to calculate
diatom indices using the Omnidia software, but we also developed new metrics based on the similarity of species composition
in reference sites. The response of the metrics was tested in relation to physicochemical variables. We developed a diatom
multimetric index (MDIAT) as a combination of metric values. The sensitivity of the MDIAT to organic and nutrient stressors
supports the use of this index to classify the ecological status of Galician rivers. The MDIAT showed higher correlations
with some variables and nutrients than the individual metrics. According to the MDIAT, 69% of the sites sampled in Galician
coastal rivers achieve good ecological status. The MDIAT has been developed specifically for Galician granitic rivers (NW
Spain), and has been intercalibrated at the European level in the Central Baltic Rivers GIG. Our study validates the application
of this multimetric index to evaluate the water quality in coastal Galician rivers. 相似文献
11.
Sensitive biological measures of river ecosystem quality are needed to assess, maintain or restore ecological conditions of water bodies. Since our understanding of these complex systems is imperfect, decision-making requires recognizing uncertainty. In this study, a new predictive multi-metric index based on fish functional traits was developed to assess French rivers. Information on fish assemblage structure, local environment and human-induced disturbances of 1654 French river sites was compiled. A Bayesian framework was used to predict theoretical metric values in absence of human pressure and to estimate the uncertainty associated with these predictions. The uncertainty associated with the index score gives the confidence associated with the evaluation of site ecological conditions.Among the 228 potential metrics tested, only 11 were retained for the index computation. The final index is independent from natural variability and sensitive to human-induced disturbances. In particular, it is affected by the accumulation of different degradations and specific degradations including hydrological perturbations. Predictive uncertainty is globally lower for IPR+ than for underlying metrics.This new methodology seems appropriate to develop bio-indication tools accounting for uncertainty related to reference condition definition and could be extended to other biological groups and areas. Our results support the use of multi-metric indexes to assess rivers and strengthen the idea that examination of uncertainty could contribute greatly to the improvement of the assessment power of bio-indicators. 相似文献
12.
The bioassessment and monitoring of the ecological status of rivers using macrophytes has gained new momentum since macrophytes were recognised as biological quality elements for the implementation of the European Water Framework Directive (WFD; EU/2000/60).Our objectives were to test the suitability of two predictive modelling approaches to macrophyte communities as a tool for water quality assessment, and to compare their performance with other more common approaches—the use of macrophytes as indicators of the trophic status of rivers and multimetric indices. We used floristic and environmental data that were collected in the spring of 2004 and 2005 from around 400 sites on rivers across mainland Portugal, western Iberia.We build two predictive models: MACPACS (MACrophyte Prediction And Classification System) and MAC (Macrophyte Assessment and Classification) based on RIVPACS and the BEAST methods, respectively. Whereas MACPACS is derived from taxa occurrence data, MAC uses a quantitative measure of taxa abundance. Both models showed good performance in predicting reference sites to the correct group and low rate of misclassification errors. However, they performed differently. MAC depicts a reliable response to the overall human-mediated degradation of fluvial systems, as does the multimetric index (RVI, Riparian Vegetation Index), but MACPACS presented only a poor correlation with the Global Human Disturbance Index and with the nutrients input. The incorporation of abundance data in vegetation predictive models appears to be particularly important to the detection of high levels of degradation. The values for correlations with physical–chemical pressure variables were lower than expected for MTR (Mean Trophic Rank) due to an insufficient number of scoring species found in Portuguese fluvial systems. Our results suggest that the most effective methods for bioassessment in Mediterranean-type rivers are either the RVI or the MAC predictive model. 相似文献
13.
Gábor Várbíró Gábor Borics Béla Csányi Gizella Fehér István Grigorszky Keve Tihamér Kiss Adrienne Tóth Éva Ács 《Hydrobiologia》2012,695(1):125-135
Results of an ecological quality ratio-based qualification system, developed on the basis of the analysis of 1,161 benthic diatom dataset of the Hungarian national database, are presented herein. Using Kohonen’s Self Organising Map technique, the 25 Hungarian physiographic river types were pooled into six larger distinct categories (diatom river groups). Diatom metrics were tested for their sensitivity to the targeted stressors (nutrients, COD hydromorphological alteration) in each group. The strongest relationships were found in the case of the IPS, SI and TI indices; therefore the average of these metrics (IPSITI) was proposed as a national multimetric index for Hungarian streams. Based on IPSITI values, the ratio of moderate to worse quality water was the highest in those groups containing small rivers. In the case of large, lowland and mid-altitude rivers with fine sediment, the good and moderate ecological status was more characteristic. Applicability of the IPSITI seems to be very useful in case of small- and medium-sized rivers. For these rivers, the index showed a significant relationship with nutrients and organic pollutants. In the case of very large rivers, the stressor–index relationships were not significant because of the insufficient number of samples and the small range of stressors. 相似文献
14.
Carlos Carroll David R. Roberts Julia L. Michalak Joshua J. Lawler Scott E. Nielsen Diana Stralberg Andreas Hamann Brad H. Mcrae Tongli Wang 《Global Change Biology》2017,23(11):4508-4520
As most regions of the earth transition to altered climatic conditions, new methods are needed to identify refugia and other areas whose conservation would facilitate persistence of biodiversity under climate change. We compared several common approaches to conservation planning focused on climate resilience over a broad range of ecological settings across North America and evaluated how commonalities in the priority areas identified by different methods varied with regional context and spatial scale. Our results indicate that priority areas based on different environmental diversity metrics differed substantially from each other and from priorities based on spatiotemporal metrics such as climatic velocity. Refugia identified by diversity or velocity metrics were not strongly associated with the current protected area system, suggesting the need for additional conservation measures including protection of refugia. Despite the inherent uncertainties in predicting future climate, we found that variation among climatic velocities derived from different general circulation models and emissions pathways was less than the variation among the suite of environmental diversity metrics. To address uncertainty created by this variation, planners can combine priorities identified by alternative metrics at a single resolution and downweight areas of high variation between metrics. Alternately, coarse‐resolution velocity metrics can be combined with fine‐resolution diversity metrics in order to leverage the respective strengths of the two groups of metrics as tools for identification of potential macro‐ and microrefugia that in combination maximize both transient and long‐term resilience to climate change. Planners should compare and integrate approaches that span a range of model complexity and spatial scale to match the range of ecological and physical processes influencing persistence of biodiversity and identify a conservation network resilient to threats operating at multiple scales. 相似文献
15.
Bernard Dudley Michael Dunbar Ellis Penning Agnieszka Kolada Seppo Hellsten Alessandro Oggioni Vincent Bertrin Frauke Ecke Martin Søndergaard 《Hydrobiologia》2013,704(1):179-191
Uncertainty is an important factor in ecological assessment, and has important implications for the ecological classification and management of lakes. However, our knowledge of the effects of uncertainty in the assessment of different ecological indicators is limited. Here, we used data from a standardized campaign of aquatic plant surveys, in 28 lakes from 10 European countries, to assess variation in macrophyte metrics across a set of nested spatial scales: countries, lakes, sampling stations, replicate transects, and replicate samples at two depth-zones. Metrics investigated in each transect included taxa richness, maximum depth of colonisation and two indicators of trophic status: Ellenberg’s N and a metric based on phosphorus trophic status. Metrics were found to have a slightly stronger relationship to pressures when they were calculated on abundance data compared to presence/absence data. Eutrophication metrics based on helophytes were found not to be useful in assessing the effects of nutrient pressure. These metrics were also found to vary with the depth of sampling, with shallower taxa representing higher trophic status. This study demonstrates the complex spatial variability in macrophyte communities, the effect of this variability on the metrics, and the implications to water managers, especially in relation to survey design. 相似文献
16.
María C. Alvarez Anita Franco Rafael Pérez-Domínguez Mike Elliott 《Hydrobiologia》2013,704(1):347-362
Fish-based multi-metric indices are an integral tool in implementing effective water policy initiatives for transitional waters. This study analysed the behaviour of three fish indices (TFCI in the UK, ELFI in France and EFAI in Portugal) developed for monitoring in line with the European Water Framework Directive, by applying a supervised multi-way sensitivity analysis with national monitoring data. The relative variation in the index outcome was analysed under different simulation scenarios by setting metric values at various levels and accounting for the co-variation between metrics. Subsets of key metrics were identified based on their higher influence in determining the index output. Index results under manipulations of metric scores clearly indicated that metric type, number of metrics used and correlations between metrics are important in determining their behaviour. This has implications for implementing management/conservation plans, for example, by prioritising restoration and/or conservation of metrics influencing more the ecological status. Indices including uncorrelated metrics (e.g. EFAI) or metrics with a skewed distribution (e.g. TFCI) are less affected by extreme metric changes, reducing the effectiveness of management actions aimed at improving the ecological status of a water body and thus adjustments may be needed to increase their sensitivity to changes in their metrics. 相似文献
17.
Fuelled by the generalized degradation of freshwater ecosystems, the development of tools to assess their ecological status has been the focus of intensive research in the last decades. Although fish are one of the key biological quality elements used to describe the ecological status of rivers, fish metrics that accurately respond to disturbances in Mediterranean trout type streams are still lacking. In these systems, multimetric indices are not optimal indicators because of their low species richness and abundances, thus alternative approaches are needed. Since carrying capacity defines the potential maximum abundance of fish that can be sustained by a river, its relationship with actual density (D/K ratio) could be an accurate indicator of population conservation status and consequently of the ecological status of the river. Based on this rationale, we modeled carrying capacity dynamics for 37 brown trout populations during a 12-year study period. We analyzed the response of the D/K ratio to a gradient of increasing environmental harshness and degradation in order to assess its suitability to accurately measure brown trout conservation status. Our results showed that the D/K ratio was highly sensitive to temporal and spatial variations in environmental conditions and the levels of human-induced environmental degradation. Variations in the environmental and human degradation factors included in the best explaining regression models developed for the whole population and by age classes accounted for between 58 and 81% of the variation in the D/K ratio. Likewise, the D/K ratio was sensitive to both general and life stage specific disturbance factors. Further analyses helped identify the factors limiting population abundance. Therefore, the D/K ratio could be an interesting indicator to consider when defining objective management plans and corrective actions in degraded rivers and streams subject to Mediterranean climatic conditions. 相似文献
18.
Biological quality metrics: their variability and appropriate scale for assessing streams 总被引:4,自引:4,他引:0
The concept of spatial scale is at the research frontier in ecology, and although focus has been placed on trying to determine
the role of spatial scale in structuring communities, there still is a further need to standardize which organism groups are
to be used at which scale and under which circumstances in environmental assessment. This paper contributes to the understanding
of the variability at different spatial scales (reach, stream, river basin) of metrics characterizing communities of different
biological quality elements (macrophytes, fishes, macroinvertebrates and benthic diatoms) as defined by the Water Framework
Directive. For this purpose, high-quality reaches from medium-sized lowland streams of Latvia, Ecoregion 15 (Baltic) were
sampled using a nested hierarchical sampling design: (river basin → stream → reach). The variability of metrics within the
different groups of biological quality elements confirmed that large-bodied organisms (macrophytes and fish) were less variable
than small-bodied organisms (macroinvertebrates and benthic diatoms) at reach, stream and river basin scales. Single metrics
of biological quality elements had the largest variation at the reach scale compared with stream and basin scales. There were
no significant correlations between biodiversity indices of the different organism groups. The correlation between diversity
indices (Shannon’s and Simpson’s) of the biological quality elements (macrophytes, fish, benthic macroinvertebrates and benthic
diatoms) and a number of measured environmental variables varied among the different organism groups. Relationships between
diversity indices and environmental factors were established for all groups of biological quality elements. Our results showed
that metrics of macrophytes and fish could be used for assessing ecological quality at the river basin scale, whereas metrics
of macroinvertebrates and benthic diatoms were most appropriate at a smaller scale. 相似文献
19.
20.
The Water Framework Directive (WFD) requires EU Member States to classify the ecological status of surface waters by using multiple biological quality elements (BQEs). According to the WFD Classification Guidance, a ‘one-out-all-out’ (OOAO) rule should be applied when integrating multiple BQEs into an overall biological status of a waterbody, i.e. classification is determined by the lowest status BQE. Using both simulated and monitoring datasets, we analyzed the effects of different combination rules in classification outcome and classification reliability. The OOAO represented the strictest combination rule in terms of increased probabilities of waterbodies being in moderate or worse status in comparison to other rules. The OOAO approach gave acceptable results when different BQEs were complementary, showing the effects of different pressures, and when level of uncertainty in the metrics used in the assessment was not high. Increasing the number of BQEs used in the assessment affected the classification outcome when using the OOAO approach; this was especially problematic if all BQEs address the same pressure. Our study showed that grouping of metrics and metrics uncertainty has a large influence on classification outcomes and that this should be carefully considered to ensure that final classification adequately reflects ecological status. 相似文献