Shemin pathway and peroxidase deficiency in a fully habituated and fully heterotrophic non-organogenic sugarbeet callus: an adaptative strategy or the consequence of modified hormonal balances and sensitivities in these cancerous cells? A review and reassessment

There are many arguments for considering a specific fully habituated (auxin and cytokinin-independent) and fully heterotrophic non-organogenic (HNO) sugarbeet callus cell line as terminating a neoplastic progression, and thus to be made of cancerous cells. The similarities with animal tumour and cancer cells are recalled. All types of habituated tissues examined in the literature share at least three common biochemical characteristics: low apparent peroxidase activity, high content of polyamines (PAs) and low production of ethylene. However, results concerning their auxin and cytokinin levels are not consistent. Peroxidase synthesis in the achlorophyllous HNO callus appears to arise from aminolevulinic acid (ALA) synthesis through the Shemin pathway, commonly used by animals and fungi. This pathway is limited by disturbed nitrogen metabolism that diverts glutamate (directly used for ALA synthesis in green higher plants) from the Kreb's cycle into PA synthesis. There is no argument to suggest that the low ethylene production is caused by a competition with PAs for their common precursor, S-adenosylmethionine. The results we report here indicate modified anabolic and catabolic pathways of auxins and cytokinins but also the possibilities of unusual compounds playing similar roles (dehydrodiconiferyl alcohol glucosides, for instance). A higher turnover of PAs is shown in the HNO callus, which could suggest a role for H2O2 and gamma-aminobutyric acid, products or intermediates in the PA catabolic pathway, as secondary messengers. The habituated cells retain some sensitivity towards exogenous auxins and cytokinins. Their increased sensitivity to PAs and ethylene suggests modified hormonal balances for the control of these actively dividing cells.     

A comparison between ethylene production, ACC and mACC contents, and hydroperoxide level in normal and habituated sugar beet calli

In contrast to normal hormone, requiring sugar beet callus, habituated auxin- and cytokinin-independent callus of the same plant produces very little ethylene, contains less 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid (ACC) and malonyl-ACC (mACC), has a low capacity to convert ACC into ethylene and has lower levels of hydroperoxides. The low ethylene production is apparently controlled by the rate of ACC synthesis and conversion to mACC, as well as by the activity of the ethylene forming enzyme. The interactions between ethylene and polyamine metabolism are discussed, as well as the possible causal relation between the low level of ethylene and the low degree of differentiation of the habituated cells.     

No relation between drought stress and ethylene production in Norway spruce

The relationship between water availability and ethylene production was studied in 24‐year‐old trees of Norway spruce [ Picea abies (L.) Karst.] growing on experimental plots with different water availability. Ethylene and oxygen were collected from the cambial/xylem region and heartwood in the stem using non‐destructive sampling methods. Xylem sap flow was measured in stems using a heat‐balance technique. Pre‐dawn water potential of shoots was used to assess the water status of the trees. Growth was calculated from increments in stem basal area. The highest ethylene concentrations were found in irrigated trees that also, as compared to the other treatments, showed the most rapid flow rate of sap, the highest pre‐dawn water potential, and the most rapid growth. By contrast, the lowest ethylene concentrations were measured in trees to which artificial drought was induced. Such trees also showed the lowest water transport, lowest water potential and relatively slow growth. Thus, no signs of drought‐induced ethylene production were found in this study, contrary to the general contention of a positive relation between drought stress and ethylene production.     

Polyamine metabolism and ethylene biosynthesis in normal and habituated sugar beet callus

The optimal assay conditions and the trend with time in culture (28 days) of arginine decarboxylase (ADE; EC 4.1.1.19), omithine decarboxylase (ODC; EC 4.1.1.17) and diamine oxidase (DAO; EC 1.4.3.6) activities in habituated (H) and normal (N) auxin- and cytokinin-requiring sugar beet callus were compared. Although the response to variations in buffer pH and EDTA and pyridoxal phosphate (PLP) concentrations varied for ADC and ODC activities between the two callus types, pH 8.3, 50 μ M PLP and 5 m M EDTA were generally optimal or near-optimal for both H and N callus. In most cases the addition of ornithine or arginine in the ADC and ODC assays, respectively, given to block the interconversion between the two substrates, resulted in lower ¹⁴CO₂ recovery. DAO activity was very differently affected in H and N callus by the presence of polyvinylpyrrolidone in the extration buffer. However, in both cases, this activity increased with time in culure. ADC activity was always predominant in both cell lines and always higher in N callus. In the latter, ADC activity rose sharply between days 14 and 21 and then leveled off while in H callus it incresed steadily from day 14 onwards. ODC activity was also higher in N callus and peaked sharply on day 21 while in H callus it was not detectable in the second half of the culture period. In both cell lines this activity was low or nil on day 28. 3,4-[¹⁴C]-methionine incorporation into ethylene and polyamines was also compared in N and H callus. In the latter, ethylene synthesis was lower and [¹⁴C]-spermidine formation higher than in N callus. This is in accord with the significantly higher spermidine titres found in H callus.     

Darkness improves growth and delays necrosis in a nonchlorophyllous habituated sugarbeet callus: Biochemical changes

The transfer of light-cultured green normal (N) and white habituated (HNO) sugarbeet callus to darkness reduced the growth of N callus and improved growth and delayed necrosis in the HNO callus. The decrease of dry matter of N callus under darkness was accompanied by a reduced content of carotenoids and by decreased CO₂ fixation, which was compensated by an increased dependency on externally supplied sucrose. The levels of some organic nitrogen compounds such as glutamate, proline, and free polyamines were not affected by transfer to darkness of N or HNO callus. Darkness decreased ethylene emissions in both callus types. In the HNO callus, the sucrose growth dependency and the CO₂ fixation were unaffected by darkness. Chlorophylls were absent both in light and darkness, whereas some carotenoids were accumulated in the HNO callus only in dark conditions. In another connection, a significant increase of peroxidase activity, which did not occur in the N callus, was induced by darkness in the HNO callus. A decreased content of thio-barbituric acid (TBA)-reactive substances was measured in the HNO callus transferred to darkness, whereas an increase was noticed in the N callus placed in the same conditions. These metabolic changes and the reduction of cellular damage in darkness revealed light-induced stress reactions leading to necrosis and to reduced growth of HNO callus. It appeared that darkness allowed the HNO callus to avoid the photooxidation stress. Therefore, the favorable effect of darkness on HNO growth might be explained by the suppression of photooxidative damage due to the absence of carotenoids. The higher peroxidase activity in the HNO callus maintained in darkness raised the problem of heme synthesis in this heterotrophic callus.     

Development of auxin autotrophy in Nicotiana tabacum callus cultures

Changes of auxin and ethylene metabolism of Nicotiana tabacum var. Xanthi callus were investigated in relation to auxin-independent growth. During the habituation process, changes occur progressively in hormone metabolism in auxin-heterotrophic tissues: the potential for the destruction of indoleacetic acid (IAA) increases, the IAA level in the cultures rises slightly, and the auxin sensitivity of the callus becomes modified. Preceding the onset of habituation, ethylene production is enhanced although the tissues retain their ability to undergo regeneration.
Gradual changes in auxin metabolism and ethylene production confirm the epigenetic character of the habituation process.     

Polyamine levels in relation to growth and NaCl concentration in normal and habituated sugarbeet callus cultures

Abstract. The concentrations of putrescine, spermidine and spermine, the only polyamines detectable in normal and habituated calli of Beta vulgaris L. ssp. altissima , were much higher in the habituated callus than the normal callus, irrespective of experimental conditions. These results suggest that, in normal (tolerant to NaCl) and habituated (sensitive to NaCl) calli, there exists a competition for the common precursor of ethylene and polyamine biosynthesis viz. S-adenosylmethionine. A disequilibrium favouring the synthesis of putrescine and spermidine in the habituated callus might be linked to structural deterioration of the cell membrane following extended culture or severe osmotic stress (68 mol m⁻¹ NaCl). The maintenance of membrane integrity by the normal callus coincides with ethylene production at the expense of polyamine synthesis. In contrast to the habituated callus, the salinity tolerance of the normal callus is accompanied by the accumulation of proline under hypersaline conditions (274mol m⁻³). The important osmoregulatory role played by quaternary ammonium compounds in the-aerial parts of Chenopodiaceae, especially the sugarbeet, is not observed in the calli, these compounds being found in very low concentrations in saline conditions.     

Pollination-induced ethylene promotes the early phase of pollen tube growth in Petunia inflata

In Petunia inflata, a species with gametophytic self-incompatibility, pollination triggers two phases of ethylene production by the pistil, the first of which peaks 3 hours after pollination with compatible or incompatible pollen. To investigate the physiological significance of the first phase of ethylene production, pollinated flowers were treated with 2,5-norbornadiene (NBD), an inhibitor of ethylene action. Treatment with NBD reduced pollen tube growth in a dose-dependent manner during the first six hours after pollination; however, pollen tube growth was insensitive to NBD if the treatment was applied 6 hours or more after pollination. Simultaneous application of exogenous ethylene substantially offset the inhibitory effects of NBD in flowers pollinated for 4 hours. Another inhibitor of ethylene action, 1-methylcyclopropene (1-MCP), also produced a strong inhibition of pollen tube growth during the first six hours of pollination. The experiments with 1-MCP pretreatment indicate that pistil tissues are the primary target of the pollination-induced ethylene.     

Habituation of plant cells does not mean insensitivity to plant growth regulators

Summary Fully habituated organogenic and nonorganogenic sugarbeet calluses reacted to application of the synthetic auxin [3-benzo(b) selenienyl] acetic acid by changes in growth and ethylene production. Treatment of fully habituated cells of periwinkle with 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid led to the decrease of free cytokinin contents (isopentenyl adenine, zeatin riboside, and zeatin) during the late exponential phase of growth. The polyamine contents were also modified and the capacity to biotransform secologanin into ajmalicine was decreased. Treatment of the habituated periwinkle cells with zeatin greatly increased the amount of a polypeptide of 16 kDa; this response was more marked than that displayed by the auxin-dependent line. These data show that hormone-independent calluses and cell suspensions can retain some sensitivity to growth hormones. However, differences of responses were observed between the auxin-dependent lines and the habituated lines.     

Cytokinin effects on root growth and possible interactions with ethylene and indole-3-acetic acid

Etiolated pea seedlings ( Pisum sativum L. cv. Weibull's Marma) were used to investigate the effects of exogenous cytokinins on root growth. Benzylaminopurine (BAP) added to the growth solution inhibited the elongation and formation of lateral roots and stimulated swelling of the root tips. Similar effects were obtained with zeatin. The effects were obtained over a wide concentration range down to 0.01 μ M . Growth responses appeared only after treatment for several hours, and the duration of treatment had an important influence on the degree of the effects. BAP caused a moderate increase in ethylene production as measured in excised 10-mm-long root tips. Lowering ethylene production by treatment with cobalt ions counteracted both the inhibition and swelling caused by BAP. Treatment with silver ions also reversed the effect to some extent, indicating that ethylene is involved in the response of the roots to BAP. To further study the involvement of the increased ethylene production in the elongation and swelling response, the effects were compared with those obtained after application of 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid (ACC) in relation to the ethylene produced from this compound. This comparison showed that the increase in ethylene production caused by BAP was too low to explain the response of the roots. However, ACC treatment caused a considerable lowering of the content of indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) in the root tips, whereas BAP did not; instead, BAP increased the amount of IAA per root tip. It is concluded that cytokinins influence growth processes in roots via several mechanisms. A synergistic interaction between endogenous IAA, maintained at a high level by the cytokinin treatment, and the increased ethylene levels appears to explain most of the cytokinin effects during the first day of treatment.     

De novo shoot morphogenesis and plant growth of mustard (Brassica juncea) in vitro in relation to ethylene

Role of ethylene in de novo shoot morphogenesis from explants and plant growth of mustard ( Brassica juncea cv. India Mustard) in vitro was investigated, by culturing explants or plants in the presence of the ethylene inhibitors aminoethoxyvinylglycine (AVG) and AgNO₃. The presence of 20 μ M AgNO₃ or 5 μ M AVG in culture medium containing 5 μ M naphthaleneacetic acid and 10 μ M benzyladenine were equally effective in promoting shoot regeneration from leaf disc and petiole explants. However, AgNO₃ greatly enhanced ethylene production which reached a maximum after 14 days, whereas ethylene levels in the presence of AVG remained low during 3 weeks of culture. The promotive effect of AVG on shoot regeneration was overcome by exogenous application of 25 μ M 2-chloroethylphosphonic acid (CEPA), but AgNO_3-induced regeneration was less affected by CEPA. For whole plant culture, AVG did not affect plant growth, although it decreased ethylene production by 80% and both endogenous levels of 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylate (ACC) synthase and ACC by 70–80%. In contrast, AgNO₃ stimulated all 3 parameters of ethylene synthesis. Both AgNO₃ and CEPA were inhibitory to plant growth, with more severe inhibition occuring in AgNO₃. Leaf discs derived from plants grown with AVG or AgNO₃ were highly regenerative on shoot regeneration medium without ethylene inhibitor, but the presence of AgNO₃ in the medium was inhibitory to regeneration of those derived from plants grown with AgNO₃.     

Fully habituated sugarbeet callus: Under permanent stress?

Summary A fully habituated nonorganogenic (HNO) sugarbeet callus line, compared to a normal (hormone dependent) one originated from the same plant exhibits many characteristics of a vitrified tissue and several traits common to animal cancer cells. Four types of biochemical or metabolic characteristics of HNO callus [deficiency of tetrapyrrole-containing compounds; lipid (per)oxidation and malondialdehyde formation; high activity of enzyme protective systems; proline, glutamate, and polyamine accumulation] may be interpreted as responses to stress. The deficiency of tetrapyrrole-containing compounds can be considered an indirect protection against activated forms of oxygen as well as the higher activity of the antioxidant defense mechanisms. This fits with suggestions in the literature that the autonomy associated with plant cancer tissue is explained on the basis of antioxidants as stimulators of cell division and corresponding inhibitors of cell differentiation. Such changes occurring in HNO cells may in turn be responsible for a greater absorption and sensitivity to ammonium ions. An altered nitrogen metabolism leads to proline, glutamate, and polyamine accumulation. Lipid peroxidation and malondialdehyde accumulation rapidly occur in this very sensitive HNO callus in a prolonged culture cycle, which might be related to the appearance of necrosis bands. Thus there are arguments allowing us to consider HNO cells as mutants adapted to some stresses, but resulting changes in their structure might have rendered them still more sensitive to other factors.     

The role of ethylene in the regeneration of Helianthus annuus (sunflower) plants from callus

Hypocotyl-derived callus from the Helianthus annuus L. inbred line SS415B regenerated significantly more plants if the seedlings were grown in the light. The difference between light- and dark-grown seedlings was not correlated with differences in seedling ethylene production, but seemed to be due to a difference in sensitivity to ethylene at a specific time during seedling growth. Treating 3-day-old dark-grown seedlings with 10 μ M aminoethoxyvinylglycine (AVG) effectively inhibited ethylene production for at least 7 days. Hypocotyl callus derived from AVG-treated seedlings gave the same amount of regeneration as callus from light-grown seedlings. Promotion of regeneration by AVG was not seen unless the 3-day-old seedlings were grown for 4 additional days prior to culturing hypocotyl explants. The effects of AVG could be reversed by treatment with 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid (ACC) during these 4 days. After the 4 days, ACC was no longer effective.     

Ethylene production in habituated and auxin-requiring tobacco callus cultures. Does ethylene play a role in the habituation?

Ethylene production of habituated and auxin-requiring tobacco ( Nicotiana tabacum L. cv. Xanthi) callus cultures were compared. More ethylene was produced by auxinrequiring i.e. auxin-heterotrophic cultures than by habituated ones. Treatment with 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid increased the ethylene evolution of habituated cultures over the range 10⁻⁷ to 10⁻⁴ M , which suggests that the higher ethylene production of auxin-dependent callus is caused by the 2,4-D in the medium. The IAA levels depended on the age of both types of callus cultures.     

Fusicoccin, an inhibitor of brassinosteroid-induced ethylene production

Fusicoccin was evaluated for its effects on brassinosteroid (BR), indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) and BR + IAA-induced ethylene, 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid (ACC) and ACC-synthase production by etiolated mung bean ( Vigna radiata L. Rwilez cv. Berken) hypocotyl segments. Fusicoccin inhibition of ethylene and ACC production induced by 2 μ M BR started at concentrations as low as 0.05 μ M . Maximum inhibition occurred at a 1 μ M concentration with no further inhibition at higher concentrations tested. Fusicoccin (1 μ M ) was effective in the inhibition of BR-induced ethylene, ACC and ACC-synthase production at low and high concentrations of BR.
Fusicoccin at concentrations as high as 2 μ M had no effect on ethylene and ACC production promoted by low concentrations of IAA (1 to 10 μ M ). When higher concentrations (100–1000 μ M ) of IAA were used, fusicoccin (1 μ M ) had an inhibitory effect on ethylene and ACC production. Interestingly, fusicoccin (1 μ M ) had little or no effect on ACC-synthase promoted by high concentrations of IAA (1000 μ M ).
When BR and IAA were used in combination, fusicoccin inhibited ethylene and ACC production at concentrations as low as 0.05 μ M with maximum inhibition occurring at 0.5 μ M . At a 1 μ M concentration, fusicoccin was effective in inhibiting the synergistic stimulation of ACC-synthase promoted by BR and IAA.     

Involvement of abscisic acid and ethylene in the responses of citrus seedlings to salt shock

The responses of salt‐sensitive citrus rootstocks to 200 m M NaCl were periodically determined on seedlings of citrange Carrizo ( Citrus sinensis [L.] Osbeck × Poncirus trifoliata [L.] Raf) during 30 days. The stressed seedlings adjusted osmotically, reduced stomatal conductance, increased proline content and ethylene production, and showed massive leaf abscission (92%). The salt shock also increased abscisic acid (ABA) and aminocyclopropane‐1‐carboxylic acid (ACC) in roots, xylem fluid and leaves, and in addition promoted Cl⁻ accumulation. The pattern of change of ABA, ACC and proline followed a two‐phase response: an initial transient increase (10‐12 days) overlapping with a gradual and continuous accumulation. This biphasic response appears to be compatible with the proposal that the transitory hormonal rises are induced by the osmotic component of salinity, whereas the Cl⁻ increase determines the subsequent accumulations. During the second phase, Cl⁻ levels correlated with abscission in leaves. Production of leaf ethylene was also concomitant with the increase in the abscission rate. Salt‐induced abscission was either reduced with CoCl₂ (52%) or inhibited with silver thiosulphate (14%). The results suggest that in salt‐stressed citrus, leaf abscission is induced by the chloride build‐up through a mechanism that stimulates leaf ACC synthesis and further conversion to ethylene.     

Effects of anaerobiosis on ethylene production, respiration and flowering in iris bulbs

Ethylene production of iris bulbs (Iris hollandica cv. Ideal) was very low. When stored at 30°C, production was 12–20 pmol C₂H₄ (kg fresh weight)^?1 h^?1. Higher temperatures (35°C, 40°C) enhanced the ethylene production; a treatment with 40°C for ca 7 days caused a 3 times higher ethylene production than at 30°. During anaerobic storage (in 100% N₂) ethylene production was equal to that of control bulbs. When after a 7 day period of anaerobiosis the N₂ was replaced by air, a burstlike ethylene production was observed. Twenty-four h after the replacement, ethylene production was equal to control values again. The effects of this production of ethylene on mitochondrial respiration and flowering were investigated. When mitochondria were isolated immediately after the anaerobic treatment (before the enhanced ethylene production) alternative pathway capacity was not detectable, a situation also occurring in control bulbs. When mitochondria were isolated 24 h after the end of the anaerobiosis (after the ethylene burst) uninhibited respiration did not change significantly, but a capacity of the alternative pathway was observed. The increase in alternative pathway capacity after anaerobiosis was partly inhibited by 2,5-norbornadiene (NBD), an ethylene antagonist. Fermentation occurred during anaerobiosis: ethanol concentrations increased during the treatment and decreased when air was supplied. When bulbs were exposed to ethanol vapour the alternative pathway was induced but only when very high ethanol levels in the bulbs were reached. The amount of ethanol accumulated in the bulbs during a 7 day anaerobic treatment was far too low to explain the observed induction of alternative pathway capacity. Flowering percentages were enhanced after a 24 h treatment with ethylene and after a 7 day anaerobic treatment. NBD significantly inhibited the effect of exogenous ethylene and of anaerobiosis on flowering. Ethanol was not able to induce flowering. The burst-like production of ethylene after anaerobiosis probably is responsible for the effects on respiration and flowering.     

Comparative study of respiratory metabolism in three types of sugarbeet calli,a normal and two habituated ones (organogenic and non-organogenic)

The respiratory metabolism was studied in three types of sugarbeet (Beta vulgaris L. var. altissima) calli: a normal callus (N) and two fully habituated (auxin- and cytokinin-independent) calli, organogenic (HO) and non-organogenic (HNO). Except for the HO callus at day 14, the oxygen consumption rates of the habituated calli were always higher than that of the normal callus throughout the cycle of culture. The maximum activity of the cyanide-resistant pathway (alternative pathway) was much higher in the two habituated calli than in the normal one. By contrast, important differences were found in HNO and HO calli concerning the activity of the cytochrome pathway. In HNO cells, the high activity of this pathway was correlated with a high ATP level while the inverse situation was observed in HO cells. The physiological significance of these results is discussed.     

Response of maize seedling roots to changing ethylene concentrations

Maize roots (Zea mays, cv. DK 626) growing in aerated solutions showed striking variations in the amount of ethylene produced during different stages of development. As endogenous ethylene increases, root elongation decreases. Exogenous 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid (ACC) supplied to these roots also inhibited their elongation and increased both the fresh weight of the apex and the ethylene produced. The inhibitor of ethylene biosynthesis, 2-aminoethoxyvinyl glycine (AVG), and the inhibitor of ethylene action, silver thiosulfate (STS), also reduced growth and increased swelling. As growth diminishes at reduced ethylene concentrations or with impeded ethylene action, these results support the view that ethylene is necessary for root growth. As ACC treatment also inhibited root elongation, it appears that ethylene was inhibitory at both low and high concentrations. Whereas ACC stimulated ethylene production 4 h after the beginning of treatment, inhibition of root elongation and promotion of fresh weight advanced slowly and needed 24 h to be established. At that time, root elongation reached a maximum response of 60% inhibition and 50% increase in weight. At 48 h, higher doses of ACC were required to provoke the same response as at 24 h. This suggests that the root growth progressively accomodates to higher ethylene concentrations. Published in Russian in Fiziologiya Rastenii, 2009, Vol. 56, No. 4, pp. 539–545. This text was submitted by the authors in English.