Exploring blocking assays using Octet,ProteOn, and Biacore biosensors

We demonstrate the use of label-free real-time optical biosensors in competitive binding assays by epitope binning a panel of antibodies. We describe three assay orientations that we term in tandem, premix, and classical sandwich blocking, and we perform each of them on three platforms: ForteBio’s Octet QK, Bio-Rad’s ProteOn XPR36, and GE Healthcare’s Biacore 3000. By testing whether antibodies block one another’s binding to their antigen in a pairwise fashion, we establish a blocking profile for each antibody relative to the others in the panel. The blocking information is then used to create “bins” of antibodies with similar epitopes. The advantages and disadvantages of each biosensor, factors to consider when deciding on the most appropriate blocking assay orientation for a particular interaction system, and tips for dealing with ambiguous data are discussed. The data from our different assay orientations and biosensors agree very well, establishing these machines as valuable tools for characterizing antibody epitopes and multiprotein complexes of biological significance.     

Comparison of biosensor platforms in the evaluation of high affinity antibody-antigen binding kinetics

The acquisition of reliable kinetic parameters for the characterization of biomolecular interactions is an important component of the drug discovery and development process. While several benchmark studies have explored the variability of kinetic rate constants obtained from multiple laboratories and biosensors, a direct comparison of these instruments' performance has not been undertaken, and systematic factors contributing to data variability from these systems have not been discussed. To address these questions, a panel of ten high-affinity monoclonal antibodies was simultaneously evaluated for their binding kinetics against the same antigen on four biosensor platforms: GE Healthcare's Biacore T100, Bio-Rad's ProteOn XPR36, ForteBio's Octet RED384, and Wasatch Microfluidics's IBIS MX96. We compared the strengths and weaknesses of these systems and found that despite certain inherent systematic limitations in instrumentation, the rank orders of both the association and dissociation rate constants were highly correlated between these instruments. Our results also revealed a trade-off between data reliability and sample throughput. Biacore T100, followed by ProteOn XPR36, exhibited excellent data quality and consistency, whereas Octet RED384 and IBIS MX96 demonstrated high flexibility and throughput with compromises in data accuracy and reproducibility. Our results support the need for a “fit-for-purpose” approach in instrument selection for biosensor studies.     

Expanding the ProteOn XPR36 biosensor into a 36-ligand array expedites protein interaction analysis

Here we demonstrate methods to expand the throughput of the ProteOn XPR36 biosensor allowing for the simultaneous kinetic characterization of several multiplexed formats, such as 36 disparate antibodies targeting the same antigen, and facilitating detailed epitope binning and mapping studies. The kinetic rate constants determined by these methods correlated with those obtained on Biacore 2000 and the absolute parameter values obtained on the ProteOn’s alginate-based GLC chip agreed closer with those from Biacore’s flat C1 chip than Biacore’s dextran-based CM4 chip. Pairwise epitope binning data from the ProteOn 36-ligand array format and those generated on an orthogonal array-based biosensor, the Octet QK384, gave similar results. In an epitope mapping study using biotinylated peptides, all three biosensor platforms were similar in their ability to identify antibodies that bound to linear epitopes. We apply alternative formats of the ProteOn array that enable a significantly higher number of assays to be conducted simultaneously than previously anticipated on this platform.     

Exploring "one-shot" kinetics and small molecule analysis using the ProteOn XPR36 array biosensor

A ProteOn XPR36 parallel array biosensor was used to characterize the binding kinetics of a set of small molecule/enzyme interactions. Using one injection with the ProteOn's crisscrossing flow path system, we collected response data for six different concentrations of each analyte over six different target protein surfaces. This "one-shot" approach to kinetic analysis significantly improves throughput while generating high-quality data even for low-molecular-mass analytes. We found that the affinities determined for nine sulfonamide-based inhibitors of the enzyme carbonic anhydrase II were highly correlated with the values determined using isothermal titration calorimetry. We also measured the temperature dependence (from 15 to 35 degrees C) of the kinetics for four of the inhibitor/enzyme interactions. Our results illustrate the potential of this new parallel-processing biosensor to increase the speed of kinetic analysis in drug discovery and expand the applications of real-time protein interaction arrays.     

Probing the binding mechanism and affinity of tanezumab, a recombinant humanized anti-NGF monoclonal antibody, using a repertoire of biosensors

We describe the use of four complementary biosensors (Biacore 3000, Octet QK, ProteOn XPR36, and KinExA 3000) in characterizing the kinetics of human nerve growth factor (NGF) binding to a humanized NGF-neutralizing monoclonal antibody (tanezumab, formerly known as RN624). Tanezumab is a clinical candidate as a therapy for chronic pain. Our measurements were consistent with the NGF/tanezumab binding affinity being tighter than 10 pM due to the formation of an extremely stable complex that had an estimated half-life exceeding 100 h, which was beyond the resolution of any of our methods. The system was particularly challenging to study because NGF is an obligate homodimer, and we describe various assay orientations and immobilization methods that were used to minimize avidity in our experiments while keeping NGF in as native a state as possible. We also explored the interactions of NGF with its natural receptors, TrkA and P75, and how tanezumab blocks them. The Biacore blocking assay that we designed was used to quantify the potency of tanezumab and is more precise and reproducible than the currently available cell-based functional assays.     

Multi-analyte surface plasmon resonance biosensing

Surface plasmon resonance (SPR) biosensors are affinity sensing devices exploiting a special mode of electromagnetic field-surface plasmon-polariton-to detect the binding of analyte molecules from a liquid sample to biomolecular recognition elements immobilized on the surface of the sensor. In this paper, we review advances of SPR biosensor technology towards detection systems for the simultaneous detection of multiple analytes (multi-analyte detection). In addition, we report application of a recently developed multichannel SPR sensor based on spectroscopy of surface plasmons and wavelength division multiplexing of sensing channels to multi-analyte detection.     

Direct detection of acetylcholinesterase inhibitor binding with an enzyme-based surface plasmon resonance sensor

Acetylcholinesterase (AChE) inhibitors are potentially lethal but also have applications as therapeutic drugs for neurodegenerative diseases such as Alzheimer’s. Enzyme inhibitor binding are difficult to be detected directly by surface plasmon resonance (SPR) due to their small molecular weight. In this article, we describe the detection of AChE inhibitor binding by SPR without the use of competitive binding or antibodies. AChE was immobilized on the gold surface of an SPR sensor through covalent attachment to a self-assembled monolayer (SAM) of a COOH-terminated alkanethiol. The activity of the immobilized protein and the surface density were determined by using a standard photometric assay. Binding of two reversible inhibitors, which are used as therapeutic drugs, was detectable by SPR without the need to further modify the surface or the use of other reagents. The binding affinities (K_A) obtained from the fits were 3.8 × 10³ M⁻¹ for neostigmine and 1.7 × 10³ M⁻¹ for eserine, showing a higher affinity of the sensor for neostigmine. We believe that the SPR sensor’s ability to detect these inhibitors is due to conformational changes of the enzyme structure on inhibitor binding.     

A portable surface plasmon resonance sensor system for real-time monitoring of small to large analytes

Many environmental applications exist for biosensors capable of providing real-time analyses. One pressing current need is monitoring for agents of chemical- and bio-terrorism. These applications require systems that can rapidly detect small organics including nerve agents, toxic proteins, viruses, spores and whole microbes. A second area of application is monitoring for environmental pollutants. Processing of grab samples through chemical laboratories requires significant time delays in the analyses, preventing the rapid mapping and cleanup of chemical spills. The current state of development of miniaturized, integrated surface plasmon resonance (SPR) sensor elements has allowed for the development of inexpensive, portable biosensor systems capable of the simultaneous analysis of multiple analytes. Most of the detection protocols make use of antibodies immobilized on the sensor surface. The Spreeta 2000 SPR biosensor elements manufactured by Texas Instruments provide three channels for each sensor element in the system. A temperature-controlled two-element system that monitors for six analytes is currently in use, and development of an eight element sensor system capable of monitoring up to 24 different analytes will be completed in the near future. Protein toxins can be directly detected and quantified in the low picomolar range. Elimination of false positives and increased sensitivity is provided by secondary antibodies with specificity for different target epitopes, and by sensor element redundancy. Inclusion of more than a single amplification step can push the sensitivity of toxic protein detection to femtomolar levels. The same types of direct detection and amplification protocols are used to monitor for viruses and whole bacteria or spores. Special protocols are required for the detection of small molecules. Either a competition type assay where the presence of analyte inhibits the binding of antibodies to surface-immobilized analyte, or a displacement assay, where antibodies bound to analyte on the sensor surface are displaced by free analyte, can be used. The small molecule detection assays vary in sensitivity from the low micromolar range to the high picomolar.

     

Analyzing a kinetic titration series using affinity biosensors

The classical method of measuring binding constants with affinity-based biosensors involves testing several analyte concentrations over the same ligand surface and regenerating the surface between binding cycles. Here we describe an alternative approach to collecting kinetic binding data, which we call "kinetic titration." This method involves sequentially injecting an analyte concentration series without any regeneration steps. Through a combination of simulation and experimentation, we show that this method can be as robust as the classical method of analysis. In addition, kinetic titrations can be more efficient than the conventional data collection method and allow us to fully characterize analyte binding to ligand surfaces that are difficult to regenerate.     

A protein detection technique by using surface plasmon resonance (SPR) with rolling circle amplification (RCA) and nanogold-modified tags

Surface plasmon resonance (SPR) can detect molecules bound to a surface by subtle changes in the SPR angle. By immobilizing probes onto the surface and passing analyte solution through the surface, changes in SPR angle indicate the binding between analyte and probes. Detection of analyte from solution can be achieved easily. By using rolling circle amplification (RCA) and nanogold-modified tags, the signals of analyte binding are greatly amplified, and the sensitivity of this technique is significantly improved. Furthermore, this technique has potentials for ultra-sensitive detection and microarray analysis. In this paper, this detection technique is introduced and shown to have great amplification capability. Using 5 nm nanogold with 30 min of RCA development time, this proposed protein detection technique shows over 60 times amplification of the original signal.     

A portable surface plasmon resonance sensor system for real-time monitoring of small to large analytes

Many environmental applications exist for biosensors capable of providing real-time analyses. One pressing current need is monitoring for agents of chemical- and bio-terrorism. These applications require systems that can rapidly detect small organics including nerve agents, toxic proteins, viruses, spores and whole microbes. A second area of application is monitoring for environmental pollutants. Processing of grab samples through chemical laboratories requires significant time delays in the analyses, preventing the rapid mapping and cleanup of chemical spills. The current state of development of miniaturized, integrated surface plasmon resonance (SPR) sensor elements has allowed for the development of inexpensive, portable biosensor systems capable of the simultaneous analysis of multiple analytes. Most of the detection protocols make use of antibodies immobilized on the sensor surface. The Spreeta 2000 SPR biosensor elements manufactured by Texas Instruments provide three channels for each sensor element in the system. A temperature-controlled two-element system that monitors for six analytes is currently in use, and development of an eight element sensor system capable of monitoring up to 24 different analytes will be completed in the near future. Protein toxins can be directly detected and quantified in the low picomolar range. Elimination of false positives and increased sensitivity is provided by secondary antibodies with specificity for different target epitopes, and by sensor element redundancy. Inclusion of more than a single amplification step can push the sensitivity of toxic protein detection to femtomolar levels. The same types of direct detection and amplification protocols are used to monitor for viruses and whole bacteria or spores. Special protocols are required for the detection of small molecules. Either a competition type assay where the presence of analyte inhibits the binding of antibodies to surface-immobilized analyte, or a displacement assay, where antibodies bound to analyte on the sensor surface are displaced by free analyte, can be used. The small molecule detection assays vary in sensitivity from the low micromolar range to the high picomolar.     

Sensitivity enhancement of spectral surface plasmon resonance biosensors for the analysis of protein arrays

A novel method for sensitivity enhancement of spectral surface plasmon resonance (SPR) biosensors was presented by reducing the refractive index of the sensing prism in the analysis of protein arrays. Sensitivity of spectral SPR biosensors with two different prisms (BK-7, fused silica) was analyzed by net shifts of resonance wavelength for specific interactions of GST–GTPase binding domain of p21-activated kinase-1 and anti-GST on a mixed thiol surface. Sensitivity was modulated by the refractive index of the sensing prism of the spectral SPR biosensors with the same incidence angle. The sensitivity of a spectral SPR biosensor with a fused silica prism was 1.6 times higher than that with a BK-7 prism at the same incidence angle of 46.2°. This result was interpreted by increment of the penetration depth correlated with evanescent field intensity at the metal/dielectric interface. Therefore, it is suggested that sensitivity enhancement is readily achieved by reducing the refractive index of the sensing prism of spectral SPR biosensors to be operated at long wavelength ranges for the analysis of protein arrays.     

High-resolution and high-throughput protocols for measuring drug/human serum albumin interactions using BIACORE

Characterizing how chemical compounds bind to human serum albumin (HSA) is essential in evaluating drug candidates. Using warfarin as a test system, we validate the application of BIACORE SPR biosensors to reliably determine binding constants for drug/HSA interactions. The binding responses for warfarin over HSA surfaces were extremely reproducible even though warfarin is small compared to the size of the immobilized protein. At high concentrations, warfarin bound at more than one site on HSA, which is consistent with its known binding properties. The affinity we determined for the high-affinity site (K(25 degrees C)(d) = 3.7 +/- 1.2 microM), as well as the dissociation rate constant (k(25 degrees C)(d) = 1.2 s(-1)), are also consistent with binding constants determined previously. These results validate the biosensor technology and illustrate how BIACORE can be used to study drug/HSA interactions in a high-resolution mode. Using a set of 10 test compounds, we present a protocol for determining equilibrium dissociation constants for HSA in a high-throughput mode. Our method involves working at low compound concentrations and fitting the equilibrium data for all compounds simultaneously. We show that the % bound values determined by SPR correlate with the values determined by solution-based methods. The ability to examine directly the binding of small molecules (130-800 Da), coupled with minimal sample requirements and automated instrumentation, makes BIACORE technology applicable for evaluating drug/HSA interactions.     

Whole cell-based surface plasmon resonance measurement to assess binding of anti-TNF agents to transmembrane target

We developed a technique for the measurement of surface plasmon resonance (SPR) to detect interactions of anti-tumor necrosis factor (TNF) agents with transmembrane TNF-α (mTNF-α) on living whole cells. The injection of a suspension of mTNF-α expressing Jurkat cells, used as an analyte, gave a clear binding response to anti-TNF agents, such as etanercept, infliximab and adalimumab, immobilized on sensorchip. The binding response of the analyte cells increased in a concentration-dependent manner and was competitively reduced by adding soluble TNF receptors to the analyte cell suspension. Treatment of analyte cells with free anti-TNF agent before injection reduced the binding response between the analyte cells and immobilized-etanercept on sensorchip, and the inhibitory effect of free anti-TNF agent was concordant with the affinity of anti-TNF agent for soluble TNF-α. These findings indicate that the SPR response arises from specific binding between anti-TNF agent and its target on cell membrane.     

Bi-Epitope SPR Surfaces: A Solution to Develop Robust Immunoassays

Surface plasmon resonance (SPR)-based immunoassays have numerous applications and require high affinity reagents for sensitive and reliable measurements. We describe a quick approach to turn low affinity antibodies into appropriate capture reagents. We used antibodies recognizing human ephrin type A receptor 2 (EphA2) and a ProteOn XPR36 as a model system. We generated so-called ‘bi-epitope’ sensor surfaces by immobilizing various pairs of anti-EphA2 antibodies using standard amine coupling. The apparent binding affinities to EphA2 and EphA2 detection sensitivities of the bi-epitope and ‘single-epitope’ surfaces were then compared. For all antibody pairs tested, bi-epitope surfaces exhibited an ∼10–100-fold improvement in apparent binding affinities when compared with single-epitope ones. When pairing 2 antibodies of low intrinsic binding affinities (∼10⁻⁸ M) and fast dissociation rates (∼10⁻² s⁻¹), the apparent binding affinity and dissociation rate of the bi-epitope surface was improved up to ∼10^–10 M and 10⁻⁴ s⁻¹, respectively. This led to an ∼100–200-fold enhancement in EphA2 limit of detection in crude cell supernatants. Our results show that the use of antibody mixtures in SPR applications constitutes a powerful approach to develop sensitive immunoassays, as previously shown for non-SPR formats. As SPR-based assays have significantly expanded their reach in the last decade, such an approach promises to further accelerate their development.     

Surface plasmon resonance based biosensor technique: A review

Optical Surface plasmon resonance (SPR) biosensors represent the most advanced and developed optical label‐free biosensor technology. Optical SPR biosensors are a powerful detection and analysis tool that has vast applications in environmental protection, biotechnology, medical diagnostics, drug screening, food safety and security. This article reviews the recent development of SPR biosensor techniques, including bulk SPR and localized SPR (LSPR) biosensors, for detecting interactions between an analyte of interest in solution and a biomolecular recognition. The concepts of bulk and localized SPs and the working principles of both sensing techniques are introduced. Major sensing advances on biorecognition elements, measurement formats, and sensing platforms are presented. Finally, the discussions on both biosensor techniques as well as comparison of both SPR sensing techniques are made. (© 2012 WILEY‐VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim)     

Analysis of native proteins from biological fluids by biomolecular interaction analysis mass spectrometry (BIA/MS): exploring the limit of detection, identification of non-specific binding and detection of multi-protein complexes

Biomolecular interaction analysis mass spectrometry (BIA/MS) is a two-dimensional analytical technique that quantitatively and qualitatively detects analytes of interests. In the first dimension, surface plasmon resonance (SPR) is utilized for detection of biomolecules in their native environment. Because SPR detection is non-destructive, analyte(s) retained on the SPR-active sensor surface can be analyzed in a second dimension using matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight (MALDI-TOF) mass spectrometry. The qualitative nature of the MALDI-TOF MS analysis complements the quantitative character of SPR sensing and overcomes the shortcomings of the SPR detection stemming from the inability to differentiate and characterize multi-protein complexes and non-specific binding. In this work, the benefit of performing MS analysis following SPR sensing is established. Retrieval and detection of four markers present in biological fluids (cystatin C, beta-2-microglobulin, urinary protein 1 and retinol binding protein) was explored to demonstrate the effectiveness of BIA/MS in simultaneous detection of clinically related biomarkers and delineation of non-specific binding. Furthermore, the BIA/MS limit of detection at very low SPR responses was investigated. Finally, detection of in-vivo assembled protein complexes was achieved for the first time using BIA/MS.     

Direct detection of glucose by surface plasmon resonance with bacterial glucose/galactose-binding protein

The monitoring and management of blood glucose levels are key components for maintaining the health of people with diabetes. Traditionally, glucose monitoring has been based on indirect detection using electrochemistry and enzymes such as glucose oxidase or glucose dehydrogenase. Here, we demonstrate direct detection of glucose using a surface plasmon resonance (SPR) biosensor. By site-specifically and covalently attaching a known receptor for glucose, the glucose/galactose-binding protein (GGBP), to the SPR surface, we were able to detect glucose binding and determine equilibrium binding constants. The site-specific coupling was accomplished by mutation of single amino acids on GGBP to cysteine and subsequent thiol conjugation. The resulting SPR surfaces had glucose-specific binding properties consistent with known properties of GGBP. Further modifications were introduced to weaken GGBP-binding affinity to more closely match physiologically relevant glucose concentrations (1-30 mM). One protein with a response close to this glucose range was identified, the GGBP triple mutant E149C, A213S, L238S with an equilibrium dissociation constant of 0.5mM. These results suggest that biosensors for direct glucose detection based on SPR or similar refractive detection methods, if miniaturized, have the potential for development as continuous glucose monitoring devices.     

Characterization of a new maleimido functionalization of gold for surface plasmon resonance spectroscopy

Para‐maleimidophenyl (p‐MP) modified gold surfaces have been prepared by one‐step electrochemical deposition and used in surface plasmon resonance (SPR) studies. Therefore, a FITC mimotope peptide (MP1, 12 aa), a human mucin 1 epitope peptide (MUC, 9 aa) and a protein with their specific antibodies were used as model systems. The peptides were modified with an N‐terminal cysteine for covalent and directed coupling to the maleimido functionalized surface by means of Michael addition. The coupling yield of the peptide, the binding characteristics of antibody and the unspecific adsorption of the analytes were investigated. The results expand the spectrum of biosensors usable with p‐MP by widely used SPR and support its potential to be versatile for several electrochemical and optical biosensors. This allows the combination of an electrochemical and optical read‐out for a broad variety of biomolecular interactions on the same chip. Copyright © 2014 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.