Sickle hemoglobin instability: a mechanism for malarial protection

Abstract

Heterozygosity for the mutant sickle hemoglobin confers protection from severe Plasmodium falciparum malaria. It is here proposed that this protection derives from the instability of sickle hemoglobin, which clusters red cell membrane protein band 3 and triggers accelerated removal by phagocytic cells. This explanation requires that sickle trait cells manifest greater hemoglobin instability than normal red cells, something that could derive from their content of sickle hemoglobin. The mechanism also implicates splenic function as a determinant of the protective effect.     

The structural organization of skeletal proteins influences lipid translocation across erythrocyte membrane

In order to define the influence of skeletal protein organization on transmembrane phospholipid movement in erythrocyte membranes, we measured the translocation rate of lysophosphatidylcholine in pathologic red cells. A simple method based on the differential extraction of lysophosphatidylcholine from the red cell membrane by saline and albumin solutions was used to quantitate the translocation rate. Two groups of pathologic red cells were chosen for these studies: red cells with quantitative deficiencies of the skeletal proteins, spectrin and protein 4.1, and sickle erythrocytes in which controlled reorganization of the membrane was induced by hemoglobin polymerization. Marked increase in lipid translocation rate was seen in red cells having quantitative deficiencies of spectrin and protein 4.1. The magnitude of the increase in translocation rate in spectrin-deficient red cells was related to the magnitude of protein deficiency. Translocation rate in sickle erythrocyte membranes increased by 50% upon deoxygenation as a result of sickle hemoglobin polymerization. No increase in translocation rate was seen in normal cells upon deoxygenation. By manipulating the extent of membrane reorganization that occurred following deoxygenation of sickle cells, we have been able to show that skeletal reorganization induced by hemoglobin polymerization and not hemoglobin polymerization per se is responsible for the increase in translocation rate. Together, these findings imply that the structural organization of membrane skeletal proteins plays an important role in regulating the rate of transbilayer movement of lipids across the erythrocyte membrane.     

Effect of sickling on dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine-induced vesiculation in sickle red blood cells

To study the effect of sickling on dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine (DMPC)-induced vesiculation, sickle (SS) red blood cells were incubated with sonicated suspensions of DMPC under either room air or nitrogen. Like normal red cells, when sickle cells were incubated with DMPC under oxygenated conditions, incorporation of DMPC into the erythrocyte membrane occurred, followed by echinocytic shape transformation and subsequent release of membrane vesicles. On the other hand, when SS cells were induced to sickle by deoxygenation, DMPC-induced vesiculation of these cells was dramatically reduced. However, upon reoxygenation, release of vesicles from these sickle erythrocytes occurred immediately. When SS cells were incubated under hypertonic (500 mosM) and deoxygenated conditions (where hemoglobin polymerization occurs but red cells do not show the typical sickle morphology), a similar decrease in the extent of vesiculation was observed. Experiments with radiolabelled lipid vesicles indicated that incorporation of DMPC into erythrocyte membranes occurred in all cases and therefore was not the limiting factor in the reduction of vesiculation in deoxygenated SS cells. Taken together, these results indicate that cellular viscosity and membrane rigidity, both of which are influenced by hemoglobin polymerization, are two important factors in process of vesicle release from sickle erythrocytes.     

The binding of hemoglobin to membranes of normal and sickle erythrocytes.

The binding of hemoglobins A, S, and A2 to red cell membranes prepared by hypotonic lysis from normal blood and blood from persons with sickle cell anemia was quantified under a variety of conditions using hemoglobin labelled by alkylation with 14C-labelled Nitrogen Mustard. Membrane morphology was examined by electron microscopy. Normal membranes were found capable of binding native hemoglobin A and hemoglobin S in similar amounts when incubated at low hemoglobin: membrane ratios, but at high ratios hemoglobin saturation levels of the membranes increased progressively for hemoglobin A, hemoglobin S and hemoglobin A2, respectively, in order of increasing electropositivity. Binding was unaffected by variations in temperature (4-22 degrees C) and altered little by the presence of sulfhydryl reagents, but was inhibited at pH levels above 7.35; disrupted at high ionic strength; and dependent on the ionic composition of the media. These findings suggest that electrostatic, but not hydrophobic or sulfhydryl bonds are important in membrane binding of the hemoglobin under the conditions studied. An increased retention of hemoglobin in preparations of membranes from red cells of patients with sickle cell anemia (homozygote S) was attributable to the dense fraction of homozygote S red cells rich in irreversibly sickled cells, and the latter membranes had a smaller residual binding capacity for new hemoglobin. This suggests that in homozygote S cells which have become irreversibly sickled cells in vivo, there are membrane changes which involve alteration and/or blockade of hemoglobin binding sites. These findings support the notion that hemoglobin participates in the dynamic structure of the red cell membrane in a manner which differs in normal and pathological states.     

The effects of erythrocyte membranes on the nucleation of sickle hemoglobin

Pathology in sickle cell disease begins with nucleation-dependent polymerization of deoxyhemoglobin S into stiff, rodlike fibers that deform and rigidify red cells. We have measured the effect of erythrocyte membranes on the rate of homogeneous nucleation in sickle hemoglobin, using preparations of open ghosts (OGs) with intact cytoskeletons from sickle (SS) and normal adult (AA) red cells. Nucleation rates were measured by inducing polymerization by laser photolysis of carboxy sickle hemoglobin and observing stochastic variation of replicate experiments of the time for the scattering signals to reach 10% of their respective maxima. By optical imaging of membrane fragments added to a hemoglobin solution we contrast the rate of nucleation immediately adjacent to membrane fragments with nucleation in a region of the same solution but devoid of membranes. From analysis of 29,272 kinetic curves obtained, we conclude that the effect of AA OGs is negligible (10% enhancement of nucleation rates +/-20%), whereas SS OGs caused 80% enhancement (+/-20%). In red cells, where more membrane surface is available to Hb, this implies enhancement of nucleation by a factor of 6. These experiments represent a 10-fold improvement in precision over previous approaches and are the first direct, quantitative measure of the impact of erythrocyte membranes on the homogeneous nucleation process that is responsible for polymer initiation in sickle cell disease.     

Reduced water exchange in sickle cell anemia red cells: a membrane abnormality

We have measured the diffusional water permeability of sickle cell anemia red blood cells under isotonic conditions using pulsed nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) techniques. We have found that the equilibrium diffusional permeability for sickle cells is about 1.61.10(-3) cm/s, or about 60% of the value measured for normal cells. This abnormality is not related to the heterogeneity generally found in cell populations in sickle red cells with different mean corpuscular hemoglobin concentrations. We speculate that the abnormality of water exchange under isotonic conditions in sickle cells reflects an alteration of membrane proteins responsible for water exchange, possibly caused by oxidation of Band 3 proteins.     

Co-localization of the immunoreactivities of corticotropin-releasing factor and arginine vasotocin in the brain and pituitary system of the teleost Catostomus commersoni

Summary Using the label-fracture technique, an ultrastructural comparison was made of the number and distribution of wheat germ agglutinin (WGA)-binding sites between human normal and sickle red blood cells. The WGA was adsorbed to colloidal gold, and quantitative analysis of the electron micrographs revealed that more binding sites were present on the sickle erythrocytes than on the normal erythrocytes. Moreover, the sites were more clustered on the sickle red cells than on the normal red cells. Use of another lectin, Bandieraea simplicifolia-II, revealed that it did not bind to normal or sickle red cells. Because of the affinity of the WGA for sialic acid residues, it is probable that the WGA is binding to a transmembrane sialoglycoprotein, glycophorin A. The conformation and/or distribution of the glycophorin A molecules may be altered by the sickle hemoglobin that binds to the red cell membrane. Hence, as detected by WGA, new surface receptors, which could play a role in the adhesion of sickle cells to endothelium may be exposed.     

Kinetics of water transport in sickle cells

This paper reports the results of stopped-flow studies on differences in the kinetics of osmotic water transport of sickle and normal erythrocytes. The kinetics of inward osmotic water permeability are similar in sickle and normal red blood cells. In contrast, the kinetics of outward water flux are significantly (approx. 38%) decreased in sickle cells. Deoxygenation does not modify the water influx kinetics in either type of cells, but accelerates considerably the rate of water efflux in sickle cells. No significant variation of water transport kinetics was observed in density-separated cell fractions of either type. The results suggest that membrane-associated hemoglobin may decrease the outward water permeability and that in deoxygenated sickle cells the fraction of hemoglobin S near the lipid bilayer is lower than in oxygenated conditions.     

The binding of hemoglobin to membranes of normal and sickle erythrocytes

The binding of hemoglobins A, S, and A₂ to red cell membranes prepared by hypotonic lysis from normal blood and blood from persons with sickle cell anemia was quantified under a variety of conditions using hemoglobin labelled by alkylation with ¹⁴C-labelled Nitrogen Mustard. Membrane morphology was examined by electron microscopy. Normal membranes were found capable of binding native hemoglobin A and hemoglobin S in similar amounts when incubated at low hemoglobin: membrane ratios, but at high ratios hemoglobin saturation levels of the membranes increased progressively for hemoglobin A, hemoglobin S and hemoglobin A₂, respectively, in order of increasing electropositivity. Binding was unaffected by variations in temperature (4–22 °C) and altered little by the presence of sulfhydryl reagents, but was inhibited at pH levels above 7.35; disrupted at high ionic strength; and dependent on the ionic composition of the media. These findings suggest that electrostatic, but not hydrophobic or sulfhydryl bonds are important in membrane binding of the hemoglobin under the conditions studied.An increased retention of hemoglobin in preparations of membranes from red cells of patients with sickle cell anemia (homozygote S) was attributable to the dense fraction of homozygote S red cells rich in irreversibly sickled cells, and the latter membranes had a smaller residual binding capacity for new hemoglobin. This suggests that in homozygote S cells which have become irreversibly sickled cells in vivo, there are membrane changes which involve alteration and/or blockade of hemoglobin binding sites.These findings support the notion that hemoglobin participates in the dynamic structure of the red cell membrane in a manner which differs in normal and pathological states.     

Anion transport in normal erythrocytes,sickle red cells,and ghosts in relation to hemoglobins and magnesium

"Band 3," an integral membrane protein of red blood cells, plays a relevant role in anionic transport. The C- and N-terminal portions of band 3 are cytoplasmatics, and the last is the link site for different glycolitic enzymes, such as glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase, aldolase, phosphofructokinase, and hemoglobin. All or some of these interactions on the CDB3 protein could allow a subtle modulation of anion flux. The interaction among HbA, Mg(2+), and membrane proteins has been sufficiently investigated, but not the effect of Mg(2+) on pathological hemoglobin in relation to the influx of the SO(4)(2-). The aim of this study was to evaluate the involvement of hemoglobin S in sulfate transport. This has been measured with native and increased concentrations of Mg(2+), using normal erythrocytes containing HbA, sickle red cells containing HbS, or ghosts obtained from both erythrocytes and normal erythrocytes ghosts with HbS added. The magnitude of the SO(4)(2-) rate constant measured in normal red blood cells increased markedly when measured in the presence of varied Mg(2+) concentrations. The results show that a low increase of intracellular Mg(2+) concentrations exercises a different HbA modulation on band 3 protein and consequently higher anion transport activity. The same experiments carried out in sickle red cells showed that the SO(4)(2-) rate constant measured in the presence of native concentrations of Mg(2+) was normal, compared to normal red cells, and was not affected by any increase of intracellular Mg(2+). Our suppositions with regard to the importance exercised by the hemoglobin and the Mg(2+) on the SO(4)(2-) influx were confirmed by comparison of the data obtained through measuring SO(4)(2-) influx with native and increased concentrations of Mg(2+) in both normal and sickle red cell ghosts. Both revealed the same sensitivity to Mg(2+) due to withdrawal of hemoglobins. The incorporation of HbS in normal as well as in sickle red cell ghosts reduced the Mg(2+) response to sulfate influx in both the reconstituted ghosts. Our research demonstrated that the different effects exercised on the rate constants of SO(4)(2-) influx in normal (HbA) and sickle red cells (HbS) by the increased intracellular Mg(2+) could be ascribed to the physical-chemical influence exercised either on the hemoglobins or on the intracellular contents of erythrocytes.     

Sickle cell trait human erythrocytes are significantly stiffer than normal

Atomic force microscopy (AFM) allows for high-resolution topography studies of biological cells and measurement of their mechanical properties in physiological conditions. In this work, AFM was employed to measure the stiffness of abnormal human red blood cells from human subjects with the genotype for sickle cell trait. The determined Young's modulus was compared with that obtained from measurements of erythrocytes from healthy subjects. The results showed that Young's modulus of pathological erythrocytes was approximately three times higher than in normal cells. Observed differences indicate the effect of the polymerization of sickle hemoglobin as well as possible changes in the organization of the cell cytoskeleton associated with the sickle cell trait.     

Dynamics of oxygen unloading from sickle erythrocytes.

The objective of this work is to theoretically model oxygen unloading in sickle red cells. This has been done by combining into a single model diffusive transport mechanisms, which have been well-studied for normal red cells, and the hemoglobin polymerization process, which has been previously been studied for deoxyhemoglobin-S solutions and sickle cells in near-equilibrium situations. The resulting model equations allow us to study the important processes of oxygen delivery and polymerization simultaneously. The equations have been solved numerically by a finite-difference technique. The oxygen unloading curve for sickle erythrocytes is biphasic in nature. The rate of unloading depends in a complicated way on (a) the kinetics of hemoglobin S polymerization, (b) the kinetics of hemoglobin deoxygenation, and (c) the diffusive transport of both free oxygen and oxy-hemoglobin. These processes interact. For example, the hemoglobin S polymer interferes with the transport of both free oxygen and unpolymerized oxy-hemoglobin, and this is accounted for in the model by diffusivities which depend on the polymer and solution hemoglobin concentration. Other parameters which influence the interaction of these processes are the concentration of 2,3-diphosphoglycerate and total hemoglobin concentration. By comparing our model predictions for oxygen unloading with simpler predictions based on equilibrium oxygen affinities, we conclude that the relative rate of oxygen unloading of cells with different physical properties cannot be correctly predicted from the equilibrium affinities. To describe the unloading process, a kinetic calculation of the sort we give here is required.     

Heme induces significant neutrophil adhesion in vitro via an NFκB and reactive oxygen species-dependent pathway

Molecular and Cellular Biochemistry - Intravascular hemolysis, a major manifestation of sickle cell disease (SCD) and other diseases, incurs the release of hemoglobin and heme from red blood cells,...     

Metastable polymerization of sickle hemoglobin in droplets

Sickle cell disease arises from a genetic mutation of one amino acid in each of the two hemoglobin beta chains, leading to the polymerization of hemoglobin in the red cell upon deoxygenation, and is characterized by vascular crises and tissue damage due to the obstruction of small vessels by sickled cells. It has been an untested assumption that, in red cells that sickle, the growing polymer mass would consume monomers until the thermodynamically well-described monomer solubility was reached. By photolysing droplets of sickle hemoglobin suspended in oil we find that polymerization does not exhaust the available store of monomers, but stops prematurely, leaving the solutions in a supersaturated, metastable state typically 20% above solubility at 37 degrees C, though the particular values depend on the details of the experiment. We propose that polymer growth stops because the growing ends reach the droplet edge, whereas new polymer formation is thwarted by long nucleation times, since the concentration of hemoglobin is lowered by depletion of monomers into the polymers that have formed. This finding suggests a new aspect to the pathophysiology of sickle cell disease; namely, that cells deoxygenated in the microcirculation are not merely undeformable, but will actively wedge themselves tightly against the walls of the microvasculature by a ratchet-like mechanism driven by the supersaturated solution.     

Water proton magnetic resonance studies of normal and sickle erythrocytes. Temperature and volume dependence.

The temperature and cell volume dependence of the NMR water proton line-width, spin-lattice, and spin-spin relaxation times have been studied for normal and sickle erythrocytes as well as hemoglobin A and hemoglobin S solutions. Upon deoxygenation, the spin-spin relaxation time (T2) decreases by a factor of 2 for sickle cells and hemoglobin S solutions but remains relatively constant for normal cells and hemoglobin A solutions. The spin-lattice relaxation time (T1) shows no significant change upon deoxygenation for normal or sickle packed red cells. Studies of the change in the NMR linewidth, T1 and T2 as the cell hydration is changed indicate that these parameters are affected only slightly by a 10-20% cell dehydration. This result suggests that the reported 10% cell dehydration observed with sickling is not important in the altered NMR properties. Low temperature studies of the linewidth and T1 for oxy and deoxy hemoglobin A and hemoglobin S solutions suggest that the "bound" water possesses similar properties for all four species. The low temperature linewidth ranges from about 250 Hz at -15 degrees C to 500 Hz at -36 degrees C and analysis of the NMR curves yield hydration values near 0.4 g water/g hemoglobin for all four species. The low temperature T1 data go through a minimum at -35 degrees C for measurements at 44.4 MHz and -50 degrees C for measurements at 17.1 MHz and are similar for oxy and deoxy hemoglobin A and hemoglobin S. These similarities in the low temperature NMR data for oxy and deoxy hemoglobin A and hemoglobin S suggest a hydrophobically driven sickling mechanism. The room temperature and low temperature relaxation time data for normal and sickle cells are interpreted in terms of a three-state model for intracellular water. In the context of this model the relaxation time data imply that type III, or irrotationally bound water, is altered during the sickling process.     

Influence of sickle hemoglobin polymerization and membrane properties on deformability of sickle erythrocytes in the microcirculation.

The rheological properties of normal erythrocytes appear to be largely determined by those of the red cell membrane. In sickle cell disease, the intracellular polymerization of sickle hemoglobin upon deoxygenation leads to a marked increase in intracellular viscosity and elastic stiffness as well as having indirect effects on the cell membrane. To estimate the components of abnormal cell rheology due to the polymerization process and that due to the membrane abnormalities, we have developed a simple mathematical model of whole cell deformability in narrow vessels. This model uses hydrodynamic lubrication theory to describe the pulsatile flow in the gap between a cell and the vessel wall. The interior of the cell is modeled as a Voigt viscoelastic solid with parameters for the viscous and elastic moduli, while the membrane is assigned an elastic shear modulus. In response to an oscillatory fluid shear stress, the cell--modeled as a cylinder of constant volume and surface area--undergoes a conical deformation which may be calculated. We use published values of normal and sickle cell membrane elastic modulus and of sickle hemoglobin viscous and elastic moduli as a function of oxygen saturation, to estimate normalized tip displacement, d/ho, and relative hydrodynamic resistance, Rr, as a function of polymer fraction of hemoglobin for sickle erythrocytes. These results show the transition from membrane to internal polymer dominance of deformability as oxygen saturation is lowered. More detailed experimental data, including those at other oscillatory frequencies and for cells with higher concentrations of hemoglobin S, are needed to apply fully this approach to understanding the deformability of sickle erythrocytes in the microcirculation. The model should be useful for reconciling the vast and disparate sets of data available on the abnormal properties of sickle cell hemoglobin and sickle erythrocyte membranes, the two main factors that lead to pathology in patients with this disease.     

Sickle cell disease and nitric oxide: a paradigm shift?

Traditionally the pathophysiology of sickle cell disease is thought to result from the polymerization of hemoglobin S in red cells, under hypoxic conditions, resulting in the occlusion of blood vessels. Adhesion of cells to the venular endothelium also appears to play a role. Recent studies have also suggested that in addition to the polymerization of hemoglobin S in the red blood cell, a deficiency of the endogenous vasodilator, nitric oxide may be involved. Hemoglobin released as a result of hemolysis rapidly consumes nitric oxide resulting in a whole program of events that inhibit blood flow. Therapies directed at decreasing the destruction of nitric oxide, increasing the production of nitric oxide, or amplifying the nitric oxide response may prove beneficial.     

Kinetics of increased deformability of deoxygenated sickle cells upon oxygenation

We have examined the kinetics of changes in the deformability of deoxygenated sickle red blood cells when they are exposed to oxygen (O(2)) or carbon monoxide. A flow-channel laser diffraction technique, similar to ektacytometry, was used to assess sickle cell deformability after mixing deoxygenated cells with buffer that was partially or fully saturated with either O(2) or carbon monoxide. We found that the deformability of deoxygenated sickle cells did not regain its optimal value for several seconds after mixing. Among density-fractionated cells, the deformability of the densest fraction was poor and didn't change as a function of O(2) pressure. The deformability of cells from the light and middle fraction increased when exposed to O(2) but only reached maximum deformability when equilibrated with supraphysiological O(2) concentrations. Cells from the middle and lightest fraction took several seconds to regain maximum deformability. These data imply that persistence of sickle cell hemoglobin polymers during circulation in vivo is likely, due to slow and incomplete polymer melting, contributing to the pathophysiology of sickle cell disease.     

Effect of dehydration on the viscoelastic behavior of red cells.

Dehydration of red cells alters their rheological behavior and may contribute to the pathology of disorders such as sickle cell disease. We have measured the viscoelastic properties of individual human HbAA red cells after graded dehydration induced by incubation with valinomycin at different external K levels. With dehydration, the cells underwent progressive reduction in their rate of extensional shape recovery (i.e., after elongation by micropipette manipulation). Their rigidity remained unaffected until the mean cell hemoglobin concentration (MCHC) rose above 50 g/dl, but then increased about 100% as judged from the response of membrane tongues drawn into micropipettes. There was also a marked reduction in the shape recovery rate at this level of dehydration, and the cells no longer behaved elastically but rather showed unrecoverable residual deformation. Additionally, the cytoplasm took on solid-like properties. Changes in cell rigidity and shape recovery rate have been previously demonstrated for dense sickle cells; our results indicate that normal red cells can be induced to behave similarly, but that a greater degree of dehydration is required.     

Increased membrane-associated phorbol-12,13 dibutyrate (PDBu) receptor function in sickle red cells

A four-fold increase in the binding of 3H-PDBu by red cell membrane ghosts isolated from sickle red cells compared to that from normal controls is presented. Phosphorylation studies with gamma-32P-ATP indicate a similar (two to three-fold) increase in the radiolabelling of the acid-precipitable membrane proteins in sickle red cells. When red cells were loaded with Ca2+ using Ionophore A23187, both normal and sickle red cells enhanced their phosphorylation and sickle red cells to a greater extent than normal red cells. Polyacrylamide slab gel electrophoretic separation of the phosphoproteins and autoradiography also reveal phosphorylation, predominantly of protein bands 3, 4.1 and 4.9 which are known in the red cells as specific substrates for the PDBu receptor, protein kinase C. These results indicate that membrane association of protein kinase C in sickle red cells is increased, possibly as a consequence of the pathological change in their ability to accumulate intracellular calcium.