Nerve growth factor: Cellular localization and regulation of synthesis

1. The role of nerve growth factor (NGF) as a retrograde messenger between peripheral target tissues and innervating sympathetic and neural crest-derived sensory neurons is supported by the observations that (a) the interruption of retrograde axonal transport has the same effects as the neutralization of endogenous NGF by anti-NGF antibodies and (b) the close correlation between the density of innervation by fibers of NGF-responsive neurons and the levels of NGF and mRNANGF in their target organs. 2. In situ hybridization experiments have demonstrated that a great variety of cells in the projection field or NGF-responsive neurons is synthesizing NGF, among them epithelial cells, smooth muscle cells, fibroblasts, and Schwann cells. 3. The temporal correlation between the growth of trigeminal sensory fibers into the whisker pad of the mouse and the commencement of NGF synthesis initially suggested a causal relationship between these two events. However, in chick embryos rendered aneural by prior removal of the neural tube or the neural crest, it was shown that the onset of NGF synthesis in the periphery is independent of neurons, and is controlled by an endogenous "clock" whose regulatory mechanism remains to be established. 4. A comparison between NGF synthesis in the nonneuronal cells of the newborn rat sciatic nerve and that in the adult sciatic nerve after lesion provided evidence for the important regulatory role played by a secretory product of activated macrophages. The identity of this product is currently under investigation.     

Placodal sensory neurons in culture: nodose ganglion neurons are unresponsive to NGF, lack NGF receptors but are supported by a liver-derived neurotrophic factor

Explant and dissociated neuron-enriched cultures of nodose ganglia (inferior or distal sensory ganglion of the Xth cranial nerve) were established from chick embryos taken between embryonic Day 4 (E4) and Day 16 (E16). The response of each type of culture to nerve growth factor (NGF) was examined over this developmental range. At the earliest ages taken (E4-E6), NGF elicited modest neurite outgrowth from ganglion explants cultured in collagen gel for 24 hr, although the effect of NGF on ganglia taken from E4 chicks was only marginally greater than spontaneous neurite extension from control ganglia of the same developmental age. The response of nodose explants to NGF was maximal at E6-E7, but declined to a negligible level in ganglia taken from E9-E10 or older chick embryos. In dissociated neuron-enriched cultures, nodose ganglion neurons were unresponsive to NGF throughtout the entire developmental age range between E5 and E12. In contrast to the lack of effect of NGF, up to 50% of nodose ganglion neurons survived and produced extensive neurites in dissociated cultures, on either collagen- or polylysine-coated substrates, in the presence of extracts of late embryonic or early posthatched chick liver (E18-P7). Antiserum to mouse NGF did not block the neurotrophic activity of chick (or rat or bovine) liver extracts. Whether cultured with chick liver extract alone or with chick liver extract plus NGF, nodose ganglion neurons taken from E6-E12 chick embryos and maintained in culture for 2 days were devoid of NGF receptors, as assessed by autoradiography of cultures incubated with 125I-NGF. Under similar conditions 70-95% of spinal sensory neurons (dorsal root ganglion--DRG) were heavily labeled. 2+     

A serological assay for the detection of cell surface receptors of nerve growth factor

When single-cell suspensions prepared from embroyonic day 8 (E8) chick sensory ganglia are incubated with nerve growth factor (NGF), anti-NGF antiserum, and complement, an NGF-dependent cytotoxic kill of 20 (±3)% of the ganglia cells is observed. This percentage is increased by a factor of two when only the neuronal cells are tested. No kill is observed on the nonneuronal cell population representing 50% of the ganglia dissociate. When E8 sensory ganglia cells are cultured in the presence of NGF following cytotoxic kill, the large, phase-bright NGF-reponsive neurons are missing from the culture. These results indicate that the cells recognized in the cytotoxicity assay have to carry NGF-binding sites of type I, which is the one with the higher affinity of the two types of NGF-binding sites (I and II) present on sensory ganglia cells. This conclusion is further supported by the following data: (a) half maximal cytotoxicity is reached already at a concentration of NGF which is below the K_D of binding site I; (b) a washing step which removes all NGF bound to type II receptors while leaving a high percentage of type I receptors occupied has no effect on the percentage of ganglia cells killed. Using the cytotoxicity assay the presence of high-affinity binding sites of type I can be demonstrated on sensory ganglia cells from E8 chick embryos but not from E4 embryos and not on liver and heart cells from E8 embryos. Further, type I receptor-bearing cells were detectable in the brain using this assay. At E8, NGF receptors could be detected on cells of the forebrain and the tectum but not on brain stem cells. Cytotoxic kill of forebrain cells was found to be especially high at E8 and E9, and decreased by E10.     

Molecular cloning of bovine and chick nerve growth factor (NGF): delineation of conserved and unconserved domains and their relationship to the biological activity and antigenicity of NGF.

Previous experiments with purified mouse and bovine nerve growth factor (NGF) have shown that the biological activities of these two NGFs are identical, whereas the immunological cross-reactivity of antibodies produced against the two NGF molecules is very limited. This observation, together with the fact that antibodies to mouse NGF do not affect the development of sympathetic and sensory neurons in chick embryos, suggests that the domain of the NGF molecules responsible for the biological action has been highly conserved during evolution, whereas other domains determining the immunological properties were under less rigorous evolutionary constraint. The nucleotide sequences of bovine and chick NGF were determined from a cDNA clone prepared from mRNA of bovine seminal vesicles and from cloned chick genomic DNA, and the amino acid sequences deduced therefrom were compared with the available sequences of mouse and human NGF. All six cysteine residues were conserved in agreement with the previous finding that the biological activity of NGF is conformation-dependent requiring intact disulfide bridges. Amino acid changes are mainly confined to hydrophilic regions expected to be potential antigenic determinants, thus providing an explanation for the poor immunological cross-reactivities between the different NGFs. One single hydrophilic region is conserved in all NGFs and this region could be involved in the biological activity. The carboxy termini of bovine and chick NGF differ from that of mouse NGF, the changes in the amino acid sequences suggest that chick and bovine NGF are probably not processed by the gamma-subunit and that no 7S complex can be formed as in the mouse submandibular gland.     

Antibodies against mouse nerve growth factor interfere in vivo with the development of avian sensory and sympathetic neurones

The monoclonal antibody 27/21 directed against mouse nerve growth factor (NGF) interferes in vivo with the survival of sensory dorsal root ganglion (DRG) neurones during the development of the quail embryo: the number of DRG neurones at embryonic day 11 (E11) was reduced by about 30% in embryos treated with the antibody between E3 and E11. Neurone numbers in the nodose ganglion were not affected. The effect of NGF antibodies on sympathetic neurones was assessed by determining the levels of the adrenergic marker enzyme tyrosine hydroxylase. Both total tyrosine hydroxylase activity and protein levels in sympathetic chains were reduced by about 30% in embryos treated with 27/21 antibody but not in embryos treated with a control antibody. The 27/21 antibody cross-reacts with chick NGF-like activity as shown in vitro by the ability of the antibody to partially block the survival activity of chick-embryo-fibroblast-conditioned medium for E9 chick DRG neurones.     

The survival of early chick sympathetic neurons in vitro is dependent on a suitable substrate but independent of NGF

The neuronal cell population of lumbosacral sympathetic ganglia from 7-day-old chick embryos is characterized by a high proportion of cells with the ability to proliferate in culture (Rohrer and Thoenen, 1987). It is now demonstrated that neither proliferation nor survival of these neurons depend on the presence of nerve growth factor (NGF). However, neuronal survival did depend on the culture substrate used: on laminin, E7 neurons survived and their number increased due to proliferation, whereas on fibronectin (FN) or a substrate of molecules from heart cell-conditioned medium (HCM) a significant number of the cells died during early culture periods. Less than 70 and 50% of the number of neurons surviving on a laminin substrate were found on FN and HCM, respectively, after 3 days in culture. Although NGF did not affect neuronal survival, a small increase in neurite extension on these substrates was observed in the presence of NGF. Furthermore, although NGF did not prevent neuronal death after extended culture periods, this could be prevented by elevated extracellular potassium concentrations. Sympathetic neurons of E8 chick embryos however showed a strikingly different response to NGF compared with those of E7: whereas neuronal survival on laminin was not influenced by NGF, a significant effect of NGF on survival and on neurite extension was observed for E8 neurons on a HCM substrate. In contrast to cells from E7 and E8 embryos, the majority of neurons from E11 chick embryos required NGF for survival even on a laminin substrate as described previously (D. Edgar, R. Timpl, and H. Thoenen, 1984, EMBO J. 3, 1463-1468). These results demonstrate that while sympathetic neurons from E7 chick embryos do not depend on the soluble neurotrophic factor NGF for survival in vitro, they are dependent on molecules of the extracellular matrix. With increasing age, the survival requirements demonstrated in vitro change toward the classical pattern of NGF dependency. Low amounts of laminin-like immunoreactivity were shown to be present in sympathetic ganglia of E7 chick embryos which were then shown to increase as development proceeded. These data indicate that laminin may play a role in the survival and development of chick sympathetic neurons not only in vitro, but also in vivo.     

Skin homeostasis during inflammation: a role for nerve growth factor

The skin is a neuroendocrine immune organ in which many different molecules operate in autocrine-paracrine manner to guarantee tissue homeostatsis in physiological and pathophysiological conditions. In this paper we examined NGF and p75 receptor expression in the skin, during CFA induced inflammation, in a time-course study. We also examined cutaneus innervation and proliferation, by means of immunohistochemistry and quantitative image analysis, RT-PCR and Western blot. Spontaneous and evoked pain-behavior was also measured in experimental rats. The main results can be summarized as follows: 1). a peripheral sensory neuropathy develops in this condition, as indicated by thermal hyperalgesia, thus leading to a sensory denervation of the hind-paw skin as indicated by disappearance of CGRP and PGP9.5-IR fibers; 2). NGF and p75 expression (mRNA and protein) increases in the skin (keratinocytes) in the acute phase of CFA inflammation; 3). at this stage, a higher proliferative activity is observed in the skin, as defined by the expression of cell cycle-associated protein Ki67; 4). in the long-lasting chronic phase there is a further up-regulation of NFG and p75 expression in the skin; 5). trkA mRNA expression inversely correlates with p75 and NGF mRNA expression. These results suggest that CFA chronic inflammation evolves from inflammation to a small fibers sensory neuropathy and NGF seems to play a role in both events.     

Nerve growth factor induces neural differentiation in undifferentiated cell of early chick embryos

Nerve growth factor (NGF) induced differentiation in postnodal pieces (PNPs) of stage 4 chick embryos. This induction was highly selective for neural tissue; no other structures developed in the NGF-treated PNPs. Furthermore, the number of PNPs showing neural differentiation was dependent on the concentration of NGF, but there was no correlation between the concentration of NGF (5-100 ng/ml) and extent of neuralization. The neural inducing capacity of NGF could be abolished by anti-NGF antibody. NGF-induced neural differentiation was accompanied by elevated intracellular levels of cyclic AMP. Exogenous cyclic AMP (175 micrograms/ml) was able to stimulate neural differentiation but, unlike NGF, induced other structures (e.g., notochord and pulsatile tissue). Overall results suggest that cells from chick embryos at developmental stages much earlier than previously thought are responsive to NGF and NGF or a a closely related substance may serve as a neural inducer in the chick embryo.     

Formation of cartilage in organ-cultured leg buds of chick embryo

When the leg buds from chick embryos at stages 17-23 were cultured as organ cultures in F12 medium, which contained chick serum and an extract of chick embryos, leg cartilage structures developed that included pelvic girdle, femur, tibiofibula, and tarsometatarsus. The proportion of explants with definite distal elements increased when the leg buds from later embryos were used. Supplementation with chick serum was essential. These results suggest that the pattern of formation of limbs in chick embryos can be studied in organ culture.     

The ontogeny of specific retrograde transport of nerve growth factor by motoneurons of the brainstem and spinal cord.

Radiolabeled Nerve Growth Factor (NGF) was injected into either the mandibular process of the first visceral arch or the limb bud of chick embryos at Days 3.5-14 or Days 4-13 of incubation, respectively. Control embryos received injections of labeled cytochrome-C or labeled NGF plus an excess of unlabeled NGF. The tissues were then processed for autoradiography. The 125I-NGF was retrogradely transported by motoneurons of the trigeminal (V) motor nucleus on Days 3.5-8 of incubation, but not at later stages. Similar transport was seen in motoneurons of the spinal cord lateral motor column from Days 4-10 of incubation, but not at later stages. Sensory neurons of the V ganglion and of the dorsal root ganglia transported NGF at all injection ages. In no instance was the 125I-cytochrome-C transported by sensory or motor neurons. The injection of an excess of cold NGF along with labeled NGF resulted in no evidence of retrograde transport of the labeled NGF indicating that the transport was saturable. The time of transport by these brainstem and spinal cord motoneurons corresponds closely to the points during development at which they have been found to exhibit specific NGF binding. The present results, then, provide further evidence for a possible biological role for NGF during early developmental stages of these motoneuron populations.     

Quantitative in vitro studies on the nerve growth factor (NGF) requirement of neurons. II. Sensory neurons

Studies were carried out in dissociated cell cultures on the nerve growth factor (NGF) requirement of chick embryo dorsal root ganglionic (DRG) neurons. Findings were: (i) The minimum level of 2.5 S NGF required to sustain the survival of maximal numbers of process-bearing cells derived from 8-day (E8) embryonic DRGs is 0.5 ng/ml (～2 × 10^?11M). (ii) Cultures derived from chick embryos of increasing ages (E8 to E18) showed a progressive increase in the proportion of process-bearing cells which survived in the absence of NGF. While few process-bearing cells survived in cultures of E8 ganglia in the absence of NGF, survival of neurons in cultures derived from E17 and E18 ganglia was not affected by the absence of the factor. Comparable results were obtained with cultures in which the number of non-neuronal cells was greatly reduced. (iii) Neurons derived from E8 ganglia lost their NGF requirement in culture at a conceptual age similar to that which they appear to do so in vivo. These results are discussed with respect to the role of NGF in development of sensory neurons.     

Innervation and acetylcholine sensitivity of skeletal muscle cells differentiated in vitro from chick embryo

Trypsin-dissociated myoblasts from leg muscle of 12-day chick embryos have been cultured in monolayers. After four days the muscle cultures have been confronted with fragments of the spinal cord of six-day chick embryos. Electrophysiological and morphological analysis demonstrate that characteristic neuromuscular transmission can develop in these cultures. Electrical stimulation of the cord fragment evokes contractions of innervated muscle fibers, from which end plate potentials and miniature end plate potentials with average frequency around one per second or more can be recorded. D-tubocurarine (1 μg/ml) suppresses reversibly these synaptic potentials. Non-innervated muscle fibers are sensitive to acetylcholine over all their surface, while innervated muscle fibers are sensitive at the regions where structures suggestive of motor end plate (“bulb-type”) are found. We can conclude that neuromuscular connections developed in vitro in our experiments are functional in respect of transmission of impulses but also in respect of neurotrophic influences for restriction of chemosensitivity.     

Expression of the NGF receptor gene in sensory neurons and their cutaneous targets prior to and during innervation

We have studied the expression of NGF receptor (NGFR) mRNA in the mouse trigeminal system at closely staged intervals throughout development. The level of NGFR mRNA per neuron is at a constant low level before the earliest axons reach the target field and increases 5-fold to plateau shortly after the arrival of the last axons. NGFR mRNA expression in developing target skin is restricted to mesenchyme, precedes the arrival of the earliest axons, and increases throughout the phase of target field innervation. These findings suggest that NGFR expression on sensory neurons occurs at a low level prior to target field innervation and is up-regulated with this event, and they raise the possibility that NGFRs on mesenchymal cells restrict the distribution of NGF in the target field.     

Myoglobin synthesis in cell cultures of red and white muscle

Myoglobin synthesis was compared in cell cultures of leg (red) and breast (white) muscle of chick embryos. In leg muscle cultures a rapidly increasing amino acid incorporation into myoglobin begins two days after muscle cell fusion; in breast muscle cultures no comparable increase was observed. This qualitative difference in cultures of the two muscle cell types provides possibilities for the further study of the mechanism of myoglobin synthesis.     

Retinoic acid induces NGF-dependent survival response and high-affinity NGF receptors in immature chick sympathetic neurons.

An important step in the development of peripheral sensory and sympathetic neurons is the onset of the survival response and dependence on the presence of nerve growth factor (NGF) or other neurotrophic factors. We have recently observed that immature sympathetic neurons from 7-day-old chick embryos are unable to become NGF-responsive in vitro and we have now used these cells to identify molecules that induce NGF-dependent neuronal survival. We found that retinoic acid (RA) induces the ability of these cells to survive in the presence of NGF. At RA concentrations of 10(-9)-10(-8)M virtually all neurons survived in the presence of NGF. RA was found to also induce the biologically active, high-affinity NGF receptor: high-affinity receptors were undetectable on dissociated E7 sympathetic neurons and were observed in vitro only in RA-treated neurons. These findings suggest that the induction of high-affinity NGF receptors may be sufficient to activate the survival response in sympathetic neurons and imply an important role for RA during neuron differentiation in the peripheral nervous system.     

Temporal regulation of neuropilin‐1 expression and sensitivity to semaphorin 3A in NGF‐ and NT3‐responsive chick sensory neurons

The extracellular molecule semaphorin 3A (Sema3A) is proposed to be a negative guidance cue that participates in patterning DRG sensory axons in the developing chick spinal cord. During development Sema3A is first expressed throughout the spinal cord gray matter, but Sema3A expression later disappears from the dorsal horn, where small‐caliber cutaneous afferents terminate. Sema3A expression remains in the ventral horn, where large‐muscle proprioceptive afferents terminate. It has been proposed that temporal changes in the sensitivity of different classes of sensory afferents to Sema3A contribute to the different pathfinding of these sensory afferents. This study compared the expression of the semaphorin 3A receptor subunit, neuropilin‐1, and the collapse response of growth cones to semaphorin 3A for NGF (cutaneous)‐ and NT3 (proprioceptive)‐dependent sensory axons extended from E6‐E10 chick embryos. Growth cones extended from E6 DRGs in NT3‐containing medium expressed neuropilin‐1 and collapsed in response to Sema3A. From E7 until E10 NT3‐responsive growth cones expressed progressively lower levels of neuropilin‐1, and were less sensitive to Sema3A. On the other hand, growth cones extended from DRGs in NGF‐containing medium expressed progressively higher levels of neuropilin‐1 and higher levels of collapse response to Sema3A over the period from E6–E10. Thus, developmental patterning of sensory terminals in the chick spinal cord may arise from changes in both Sema3A expression in the developing spinal cord and accompanying changes in neuronal expression of the Sema3A receptor subunit, neuropilin‐1. © 2002 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Neurobiol 51: 43–53, 2002     

Developmental changes in collagen glycosyltransferase activities in chick embryos

The developmental pattern of collagen galactosyltransferase and collagen glucosyltransferase activities was determined in chick embryos between the 4th and 21st day of growth. Both enzyme activities increased up to the 16th day and decreased thereafter in whole chick embryos and in most tissues studied. The highest collagen glycosyltransferase activities were found in the leg tendons of the 16-day-old embryos, and the activities found in cartilage were higher than those noted in either skin or skull, indicating that the the activities of the collagen glycosyltransferases may play a part in the regulation of the carbohydrate content of the collagen synthesized by a given tissue. The changes observed in the collagen glycosyltransferase activities agree with previous data on the development of prolyl and lysyl hydroxylase activities and also with findings on collagen turnover in the developing chick embryo.     

Enhanced extrinsic innervation of nasal and oral chemosensory mucosae in keratin 14-NGF transgenic mice

The role of nerve growth factor (NGF) in neurotrophic support for the extrinsic innervation of the nasal and oral mucosae was investigated in keratin 14 (K14)-NGF transgenic mice in which NGF was over-expressed in K14-synthesizing cells. K14 immunoreactivity was localized in the epithelial basal cells of the whisker pad skin, the hard palate, the floor of the ventral meatus, and the anterior tongue that are stratified squamous epithelia, and also in basal cells of the vomeronasal, olfactory, and respiratory epithelia that are non-stratified epithelia. In transgenic mice, NGF expression was identified and confined primarily to the basal cells of stratified epithelia. The nasal mucosae including the vomeronasal, olfactory, and respiratory mucosae, and the glands associated with the vomeronasal organ received a greater innervation of protein gene product 9.5-immunoreactive extrinsic fibers in transgenic animals than nontransgenic controls. An increased density of calcitonin gene-related peptide-immunoreactive extrinsic fibers was observed in the nonsensory epithelia of the vomeronasal organ, the olfactory sensory and respiratory epithelia in transgenic animals. Our results indicated that the hyperinnervation of the nasal and oral mucosae by extrinsic neurons is due at least partially to target-derived NGF synthesis and release by K14-expressing basal cells.This work was supported by NIH grants NIDCD-00159 (T.V.G.), NIDCO-01715 (M.L.G.), and NINDS-31826 (K.M.A.).     

Placode and neural crest-derived sensory neurons are responsive at early developmental stages to brain-derived neurotrophic factor

The response of embryonic chick nodose ganglion (neural placode-derived) and dorsal root ganglion (neural crest-derived) sensory neurons to the survival and neurite-promoting activity of brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) was studied in culture. In dissociated, neuron-enriched cultures established from chick embryos between Day 6 (E6) and Day 12 (E12) of development, both nodose ganglion (NG) and dorsal root ganglion (DRG) neurons were responsive on laminin-coated culture dishes to BDNF. In the case of NG, BDNF elicited neurite outgrowth from 40 to 50% of the neurons plated at three embryonic ages; E6, E9, and E12. At the same ages, nerve growth factor (NGF) alone or in combination with BDNF, had little or no effect upon neurite outgrowth from NG neurons. The response of NG neurons to BDNF was dose dependent and was sustainable for at least 7 days in culture. Surprisingly, in view of a previous study carried out using polyornithine as a substrate for neuronal cell attachment, on laminin-coated dishes BDNF also sustained survival and neurite outgrowth from a high percentage (60-70%) of DRG neurons taken from E6 embryos. In marked contrast to NG neurons, the combined effect of saturating levels of BDNF and NGF activity on DRG neurons was greater than the effect of either agent alone at all embryonic ages studied. Under similar culture conditions, BDNF did not elicit survival and neurite outgrowth from paravertebral chain sympathetic neurons or parasympathetic ciliary ganglion neurons. We propose that primary sensory neurons, regardless of their embryological origin, are responsive to a "central-target" (CNS) derived neurotrophic factor--BDNF, while they are differentially responsive to "peripheral-target"-derived growth factors, such as NGF, depending on whether the neurons are of neural crest or placodal origin.     

Survival of Chick Embryonic Sensory Neurons in Culture Is Supported by Phorbol Esters

Sensory neurons of the chick embryo are supported in culture by several neurotrophic factors, including the phorbol esters. Because phorbol esters are known to activate one of the second messengers, namely, protein kinase C, it was of interest to see if the neurotrophic action of phorbol 12,13-dibutyrate (PDB) was related to the activation of protein kinase C in sensory neurons. Sensory neurons were obtained from dorsal root ganglia of 10-day-old chick embryos and maintained in a serum-free medium for several days to quantify survival and analyze protein kinase C activity. PDB (30 nM) supported the survival of approximately 50% of the total number of neurons plated. This value was comparable to that supported by nerve growth factor (NGF; 40 ng/ml). If PDB and NGF were added together, there was no additive effect on the survival. The protein kinase C activity of the particulate and cytosolic fractions of sensory neurons supported by NGF for 3 days was 1.26 +/- 0.1 and 2.9 +/- 0.32 pmol/min/mg of protein, respectively. In contrast, neurons supported by PDB showed an approximately 500% increase in enzyme activity in their particulate fraction. The enzyme activity of the cytosolic fraction was decreased by approximately 40%. If NGF-supported neurons were treated with PDB (30 nM) for 15 min, protein kinase C activity increased greater than 400% in the particulate fraction, whereas an approximately 50% decrease was observed in the cytosolic fraction. The protein kinase C value, expressed as a ratio of the activities in the particulate to cytosol fractions, showed large increases after phorbol treatment.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)