Replication regulation of Vibrio cholerae chromosome II involves initiator binding to the origin both as monomer and as dimer

The origin region of Vibrio cholerae chromosome II (chrII) resembles plasmid origins that have repeated initiator-binding sites (iterons). Iterons are essential for initiation as well as preventing over-initiation of plasmid replication. In chrII, iterons are also essential for initiation but over-initiation is prevented by sites called 39-mers. Both iterons and 39-mers are binding sites of the chrII specific initiator, RctB. Here, we have isolated RctB mutants that permit over-initiation in the presence of 39-mers. Characterization of two of the mutants showed that both are defective in 39-mer binding, which helps to explain their over-initiation phenotype. In vitro, RctB bound to 39-mers as monomers, and to iterons as both monomers and dimers. Monomer binding to iterons increased in both the mutants, suggesting that monomers are likely to be the initiators. We suggest that dimers might be competitive inhibitors of monomer binding to iterons and thus help control replication negatively. ChrII replication was found to be dependent on chaperones DnaJ and DnaK in vivo. The chaperones preferentially improved dimer binding in vitro, further suggesting the importance of dimer binding in the control of chrII replication.     

Initiator protein dimerization plays a key role in replication control of Vibrio cholerae chromosome 2

RctB, the initiator of replication of Vibrio cholerae chromosome 2 (chr2), binds to the origin of replication to specific 12-mer sites both as a monomer and a dimer. Binding to 12-mers is essential for initiation. The monomers also bind to a second kind of site, 39-mers, which inhibits initiation. Mutations in rctB that reduce dimer binding increase monomer binding to 12-mers but decrease monomer binding to 39-mers. The mechanism of this paradoxical binding behavior has been unclear. Using deletion and alanine substitution mutants of RctB, we have now localized to a 71 amino acid region residues important for binding to the two kinds of DNA sites and for RctB dimerization. We find that the dimerization domain overlaps with both the DNA binding domains, explaining how changes in the dimerization domain can alter both kinds of DNA binding. Moreover, dimerization-defective mutants could be initiation-defective without apparent DNA binding defect. These results suggest that dimerization might be important for initiation beyond its role in controlling DNA binding. The finding that determinants of crucial initiator functions reside in a small region makes the region an attractive target for anti-V. cholerae drugs.     

Chromosome I Controls Chromosome II Replication in Vibrio cholerae

Control of chromosome replication involves a common set of regulators in eukaryotes, whereas bacteria with divided genomes use chromosome-specific regulators. How bacterial chromosomes might communicate for replication is not known. In Vibrio cholerae, which has two chromosomes (chrI and chrII), replication initiation is controlled by DnaA in chrI and by RctB in chrII. DnaA has binding sites at the chrI origin of replication as well as outside the origin. RctB likewise binds at the chrII origin and, as shown here, to external sites. The binding to the external sites in chrII inhibits chrII replication. A new kind of site was found in chrI that enhances chrII replication. Consistent with its enhancing activity, the chrI site increased RctB binding to those chrII origin sites that stimulate replication and decreased binding to other sites that inhibit replication. The differential effect on binding suggests that the new site remodels RctB. The chaperone-like activity of the site is supported by the finding that it could relieve the dependence of chrII replication on chaperone proteins DnaJ and DnaK. The presence of a site in chrI that specifically controls chrII replication suggests a mechanism for communication between the two chromosomes for replication.     

Regulatory cross-talk links Vibrio cholerae chromosome II replication and segregation

There is little knowledge of factors and mechanisms for coordinating bacterial chromosome replication and segregation. Previous studies have revealed that genes (and their products) that surround the origin of replication (oriCII) of Vibrio cholerae chromosome II (chrII) are critical for controlling the replication and segregation of this chromosome. rctB, which flanks one side of oriCII, encodes a protein that initiates chrII replication; rctA, which flanks the other side of oriCII, inhibits rctB activity. The chrII parAB2 operon, which is essential for chrII partitioning, is located immediately downstream of rctA. Here, we explored how rctA exerts negative control over chrII replication. Our observations suggest that RctB has at least two DNA binding domains--one for binding to oriCII and initiating replication and the other for binding to rctA and thereby inhibiting RctB's ability to initiate replication. Notably, the inhibitory effect of rctA could be alleviated by binding of ParB2 to a centromere-like parS site within rctA. Furthermore, by binding to rctA, ParB2 and RctB inversely regulate expression of the parAB2 genes. Together, our findings suggest that fluctuations in binding of the partitioning protein ParB2 and the chrII initiator RctB to rctA underlie a regulatory network controlling both oriCII firing and the production of the essential chrII partitioning proteins. Thus, by binding both RctB and ParB2, rctA serves as a nexus for regulatory cross-talk coordinating chrII replication and segregation.     

Opposed actions of regulatory proteins, DnaA and IciA, in opening the replication origin of Escherichia coli.

The opening of the three tandem 13-mers (iterons) in the replication origin (oriC) of Escherichia coli by DnaA protein, assisted by protein HU or IHF (Hwang, D. S., and Kornberg, A. (1992) J. Biol. Chem. 267, 23083-23086), represents an essential early stage in the initiation of chromosomal replication (Bramhill, D., and Kornberg, A. (1988) Cell 54, 915-918). We now show by mutational alterations of the 13-mer region that oriC function, both in vitro and in vivo, requires AT-richness in the left 13-mer and sequence specificity in the middle and right 13-mers. Interactions of DnaA protein with the middle and right 13-mers are crucial for the opening of the region. Binding of the protein to the top strand of the 13-mers appeared to maintain single-strandedness in the bottom strand. IciA protein, the inhibitor of initiation, binds the three 13-mers and blocks the opening of the region. The degrees of inhibition by IciA protein of 13-mer opening and of oriC plasmid replication observed with mutant forms of the 13-mers could be correlated with the binding affinity of IciA protein. Whereas the binding of IciA protein to the 13-mers did not affect the binding of DnaA protein to its four 9-mers boxes, interaction of DnaA protein with the 13-mers was blocked. The selective interactions of DnaA and IciA proteins with the 13-mer region appear to be components of the on/off switch that controls initiation of E. coli chromosomal replication.     

Evidence for Two Different Regulatory Mechanisms Linking Replication and Segregation of Vibrio cholerae Chromosome II

Understanding the mechanisms that coordinate replication initiation with subsequent segregation of chromosomes is an important biological problem. Here we report two replication-control mechanisms mediated by a chromosome segregation protein, ParB2, encoded by chromosome II of the model multichromosome bacterium, Vibrio cholerae. We find by the ChIP-chip assay that ParB2, a centromere binding protein, spreads beyond the centromere and covers a replication inhibitory site (a 39-mer). Unexpectedly, without nucleation at the centromere, ParB2 could also bind directly to a related 39-mer. The 39-mers are the strongest inhibitors of chromosome II replication and they mediate inhibition by binding the replication initiator protein. ParB2 thus appears to promote replication by out-competing initiator binding to the 39-mers using two mechanisms: spreading into one and direct binding to the other. We suggest that both these are novel mechanisms to coordinate replication initiation with segregation of chromosomes.     

Interaction of SeqA and Dam methylase on the hemimethylated origin of Escherichia coli chromosomal DNA replication

Preferential binding of SeqA protein to hemimethylated oriC, the origin of Escherichia coli chromosomal replication, delays methylation by Dam methylase. Because the SeqA-oriC interaction appears to be essential in timing of chromosomal replication initiation, the biochemical functions of SeqA protein and Dam methylase at the 13-mer L, M, and R region containing 4 GATC sequences at the left end of oriC were examined. We found that SeqA protein preferentially bound hemimethylated 13-mers but not fully nor unmethylated 13-mers. Regardless of strand methylation, the binding of SeqA protein to the hemimethylated GATC sequence of 13-mer L was followed by additional binding to other hemimethylated GATC sequences of 13-mer M and R. On the other hand, Dam methylase did not discriminate binding of 13-mers in different methylation patterns and was not specific to GATC sequences. The binding specificity and higher affinity of SeqA protein over Dam methylase to the hemimethylated 13-mers along with the reported cellular abundance of this protein explains the dominant action of SeqA protein over Dam methylase to the newly replicated oriC for the sequestration of chromosomal replication. Furthermore, SeqA protein bound to hemimethylated 13-mers was not dissociated by Dam methylase, and most SeqA protein spontaneously dissociated 10 min after binding. Also, SeqA protein delayed the in vitro methylation of hemimethylated 13-mers by Dam methylase. These in vitro results suggest that the intrinsic binding instability of SeqA protein results in release of sequestrated hemimethylated oriC.     

The coordinated replication of Vibrio cholerae’s two chromosomes required the acquisition of a unique domain by the RctB initiator

Vibrio cholerae, the pathogenic bacterium that causes cholera, has two chromosomes (Chr1, Chr2) that replicate in a well-orchestrated sequence. Chr2 initiation is triggered only after the replication of the crtS site on Chr1. The initiator of Chr2 replication, RctB, displays activities corresponding with its different binding sites: initiator at the iteron sites, repressor at the 39m sites, and trigger at the crtS site. The mechanism by which RctB relays the signal to initiate Chr2 replication from crtS is not well-understood. In this study, we provide new insights into how Chr2 replication initiation is regulated by crtS via RctB. We show that crtS (on Chr1) acts as an anti-inhibitory site by preventing 39m sites (on Chr2) from repressing initiation. The competition between these two sites for RctB binding is explained by the fact that RctB interacts with crtS and 39m via the same DNA-binding surface. We further show that the extreme C-terminal tail of RctB, essential for RctB self-interaction, is crucial for the control exerted by crtS. This subregion of RctB is conserved in all Vibrio, but absent in other Rep-like initiators. Hence, the coordinated replication of both chromosomes likely results from the acquisition of this unique domain by RctB.     

Positioning and the specific sequence of each 13-mer motif are critical for activity of the plasmid RK2 replication origin

The minimal replication origin of the broad-host-range plasmid RK2, oriV, contains five iterons which are binding sites for the plasmid-encoded replication initiation protein TrfA, four DnaA boxes, which bind the host DnaA protein, and an AT-rich region containing four 13-mer sequences. In this study, 26 mutants with altered sequence and/or spacing of 13-mer motifs have been constructed and analysed for replication activity in vivo and in vitro. The data show that the replacement of oriV 13-mers by similar but not identical 13-mer sequences from Escherichia coli oriC inactivates the origin. In addition, interchanging the positions of the oriV 13-mers results in greatly reduced activity. Mutants with T/A substitutions are also inactive. Furthermore, introduction of single-nucleotide substitutions demonstrates very restricted sequence requirements depending on the 13-mer position. Only two of the mutants are host specific, functional in Pseudomonas aeruginosa but not in E. coli. Our experiments demonstrate considerable complexity in the plasmid AT-rich region architecture required for functionality. It is evident that low internal stability of this region is not the only feature contributing to origin activity. Our studies suggest a requirement for sequence-specific protein interactions within the 13-mers during assembly of replication complexes at the plasmid origin.     

Cooperative binding mode of the inhibitors of R6K replication, pi dimers

The replication initiator protein, π, plays an essential role in the initiation of plasmid R6K replication. Both monomers and dimers of π bind to iterons in the γ origin of plasmid R6K, yet monomers facilitate open complex formation, while dimers, the predominant form in the cell, do not. Consequently, π monomers activate replication, while π dimers inhibit replication. Recently, it was shown that the monomeric form of π binds multiple tandem iterons in a strongly cooperative fashion, which might explain how monomers outcompete dimers for replication initiation when plasmid copy number and π supply are low. Here, we examine cooperative binding of π dimers and explore the role that these interactions may have in the inactivation of γ origin. To examine π dimer/iteron interactions in the absence of competing π monomer/iteron interactions using wild-type π, constructs were made with key base changes to each iteron that eliminate π monomer binding yet have no impact on π dimer binding. Our results indicate that, in the absence of π monomers, π dimers bind with greater cooperativity to alternate iterons than to adjacent iterons, thus preferentially leaving intervening iterons unbound and the origin unsaturated. We discuss new insights into plasmid replication control by π dimers.     

The dimerization interface of initiator RctB governs chaperone and enhancer dependence of Vibrio cholerae chromosome 2 replication

Protein function often requires remodeling of protein structure. In the well-studied iteron-containing plasmids, the initiator of replication has a dimerization interface that undergoes chaperone-mediated remodeling. This remodeling reduces dimerization and promotes DNA replication, since only monomers bind origin DNA. A structurally homologs interface exists in RctB, the replication initiator of Vibrio cholerae chromosome 2 (Chr2). Chaperones also promote Chr2 replication, although both monomers and dimers of RctB bind to origin, and chaperones increase the binding of both. Here we report how five changes in the dimerization interface of RctB affect the protein. The mutants are variously defective in dimerization, more active as initiator, and except in one case, unresponsive to chaperone (DnaJ). The results indicate that chaperones also reduce RctB dimerization and support the proposal that the paradoxical chaperone-promoted dimer binding likely represents sequential binding of monomers on DNA. RctB is also activated for replication initiation upon binding to a DNA site, crtS, and three of the mutants are also unresponsive to crtS. This suggests that crtS, like chaperones, reduces dimerization, but additional evidence suggests that the remodelling activities function independently. Involvement of two remodelers in reducing dimerization signifies the importance of dimerization in limiting Chr2 replication.     

A novel protein binds a key origin sequence to block replication of an E. coli minichromosome

A sequence of three tandem repeats of a 13-mer in the replication origin (oriC) of E. coli is the highly conserved site of opening of the duplex for initiation of DNA synthesis. A protein that binds this sequence has been discovered in E. coli and purified to homogeneity. This novel 33 kd polypeptide behaves as a dimer. Binding to the 13-mers is specific and limited to this region. At a ratio of 10-20 monomers per oriC plasmid, the binding blocks initiation by preventing the opening of the 13-mer region by dnaA protein. Once the 13-mers are opened by dnaA protein action, the 33 kd protein is without effect on the subsequent stages of replication. The specificity of binding and profound inhibitory effect suggest a regulatory role for this protein at an early stage of chromosome initiation.     

The dnaA initiator protein binds separate domains in the replication origin of Escherichia coli

After binding to its four 9-mer boxes in the 245-base pair Escherichia coli replication origin (oriC), dnaA protein effects the formation of an "open complex" in an adjacent region made up of three 13-mers (Bramhill, D., and Kornberg, A. (1988) Cell 52, 743-755). This open complex formation requires the ATP form of dnaA protein assisted by HU protein (Sekimizu, K., Bramhill, D., and Kornberg, A. (1987) Cell 50, 259-265). We now provide direct evidence that dnaA protein binds the 13-mers, sequences that bear no resemblance to the 9-mer box. The evidence is (i) displacement of dnaA protein from the open complex by oriC or by a synthetic oligonucleotide containing the 13-mers, but not by a mutant of oriC lacking the 13-mers; (ii) filter binding of the synthetic (13-mer) oligonucleotide by dnaA protein; and (iii) requirement for the ATP form of dnaA protein assisted by HU protein for temperature-dependent binding to the 13-mer region. Controlled proteolysis of dnaA protein results in a prompt loss of oriC binding; an NH2-terminal 30-kDa peptide contains the domain that binds ATP and phospholipids known to destabilize the tightly bound ATP.     

The localized melting of mini-F origin by the combined action of the mini-F initiator protein (RepE) and HU and DnaA of Escherichia coli

Replication of mini-F plasmids requires the initiator protein RepE, which binds specifically to four iterons within the origin (ori2), as well as some host factors that are involved in chromosomal DNA replication. To understand the role of host factors and RepE in the early steps of mini-F DNA replication, we examined the effects of RepE and the Escherichia coli proteins DnaA and HU on the localized melting of ori2 DNA in a purified in vitro system. We found that the binding of RepE to an iteron causes a 50^° bend at or around the site of binding. RepE and HU exhibited synergistic effects on the localized melting within the ori2 region, as detected by sensitivity to the single-strand specific P1 endonuclease. This opening of duplex DNA occurred around the 13mer of ori2, whose sequence closely resembles the set of 13mers found in the chromosomal origin oriC. Further addition of DnaA to the reaction mixture increased the efficiency of melting and appeared to extend melting to the adjacent AT-rich region. Moreover, DNA melting with appreciably higher efficiencies was observed with mutant forms of RepE that were previously shown to be hyperactive both in DNA binding in vitro and in initiator activity in vivo. We propose that the binding of RepE to four iterons of ori2 causes bending at the sites of RepE binding and, with the assistance of HU, induces a localized melting in the 13mer region. The addition of DnaA extends melting to the AT-rich region, which could then serve as the entry site for the DnaB-DnaC complex, much as has been documented for oriC- dependent replication.     

rctB mutations that increase copy number of Vibrio cholerae oriCII in Escherichia coli

RctB serves as the initiator protein for replication from oriCII, the origin of replication of Vibrio cholerae chromosome II. RctB is conserved between members of Vibrionaceae but shows no homology to known replication initiator proteins and has no recognizable sequence motifs. We used an oriCII based minichromosome to isolate copy-up mutants in Escherichia coli. Three point mutations rctB(R269H), rctB(L439H) and rctB(Y381N) and one IS10 insertion in the 3'-end of the rctB gene were obtained. We determined the maximal C-terminal deletion that still gave rise to a functional RctB protein to be 165 amino acids. All rctB mutations led to decreased RctB-RctB interaction indicating that the monomer is the active form of the initiator protein. All mutations also showed various defects in rctB autoregulation. Loss of the C-terminal part of RctB led to overinitiation by reducing binding of RctB to both rctA and inc regions that normally serve to limit initiation from oriCII. Overproduction of RctB(R269H) and RctB(L439H) led to a rapid increase in oriCII copy number. This suggests that the initiator function of the two mutant proteins is increased relative to the wild-type.     

The interaction of RepC initiator with iterons in the replication of the broad host-range plasmid RSF1010.

The replication origin of the broad host-range plasmid RSF1010 contains 3.5 copies of a 20mer iteron sequence that bind specifically to the plasmid-encoded initiator, RepC. Here we demonstrated that even a single iteron was bent upon binding of RepC. Moreover, the bending angle seems to become larger along with the increment of the number of iterons. In a mutational analysis of the iteron sequence, we isolated seven kinds of base-substitution mutants of iterons, and estimated the replication activity of these mutants in vivo. We found that each of the subsections in the 20mer iteron sequence made a distinct contribution to the initiation of RSF1010 DNA replication. With the binding assay of RepC and mutated iterons in vitro, we found that the formation of a productive RepC-iteron complex was required for the initiation of plasmid DNA replication.     

DnaA protein binding to individual DnaA boxes in the Escherichia coli replication origin, oriC.

The formation of nucleoprotein complexes between the Escherichia coli initiator protein DnaA and the replication origin oriC was analysed in vitro by band-shift assays and electron microscopy. DnaA protein binds equally well to linear and supercoiled oriC substrates as revealed by analysis of the binding preference to individual DnaA boxes (9-mer repeats) in oriC, and by a competition band-shift assay. DnaA box R4 (oriC positions 260-268) binds DnaA preferentially and in the oriC context with higher affinity than expected from its binding constant. This effect depends on oriC positions 249 to 274, is enhanced by the wild-type sequence in the DnaA box R3 region, but is not dependent on Dam methylation or the curved DNA segment to the right of oriC. DnaA binds randomly to the DnaA boxes R1, M, R2 and R3 in oriC with no apparent cooperativity: the binding preference of DnaA to these sites was not altered for templates with mutated DnaA box R4. In the oriC context, DnaA box R1 binds DnaA with lower affinity than expected from its binding constant, i.e. the affinity is reduced to approximately that of DnaA box R2. Higher protein concentrations were required to observe binding to DnaA box M, making this low-affinity site a novel candidate for a regulatory dnaA box.     

The localized melting of mini-F origin by the combined action of the mini-F initiator protein (RepE) and HU and DnaA of Escherichia coli

 Replication of mini-F plasmids requires the initiator protein RepE, which binds specifically to four iterons within the origin (ori2), as well as some host factors that are involved in chromosomal DNA replication. To understand the role of host factors and RepE in the early steps of mini-F DNA replication, we examined the effects of RepE and the Escherichia coli proteins DnaA and HU on the localized melting of ori2 DNA in a purified in vitro system. We found that the binding of RepE to an iteron causes a 50^° bend at or around the site of binding. RepE and HU exhibited synergistic effects on the localized melting within the ori2 region, as detected by sensitivity to the single-strand specific P1 endonuclease. This opening of duplex DNA occurred around the 13mer of ori2, whose sequence closely resembles the set of 13mers found in the chromosomal origin oriC. Further addition of DnaA to the reaction mixture increased the efficiency of melting and appeared to extend melting to the adjacent AT-rich region. Moreover, DNA melting with appreciably higher efficiencies was observed with mutant forms of RepE that were previously shown to be hyperactive both in DNA binding in vitro and in initiator activity in vivo. We propose that the binding of RepE to four iterons of ori2 causes bending at the sites of RepE binding and, with the assistance of HU, induces a localized melting in the 13mer region. The addition of DnaA extends melting to the AT-rich region, which could then serve as the entry site for the DnaB-DnaC complex, much as has been documented for oriC- dependent replication. Received: 15 May 1996/Accepted: 11 July 1996     

Independent control of replication initiation of the two Vibrio cholerae chromosomes by DnaA and RctB

Although the two Vibrio cholerae chromosomes initiate replication in a coordinated fashion, we show here that each chromosome appears to have a specific replication initiator. DnaA overproduction promoted overinitiation of chromosome I and not chromosome II. In contrast, overproduction of RctB, a protein that binds to the origin of replication of chromosome II, promoted overinitiation of chromosome II and not chromosome I.