Molecular mechanisms of sister-chromatid exchange

Sister-chromatid exchange (SCE) is the process whereby, during DNA replication, two sister chromatids break and rejoin with one another, physically exchanging regions of the parental strands in the duplicated chromosomes. This process is considered to be conservative and error-free, since no information is generally altered during reciprocal interchange by homologous recombination. Upon the advent of non-radiolabel detection methods for SCE, such events were used as genetic indicators for potential genotoxins/mutagens in laboratory toxicology tests, since, as we now know, most forms of DNA damage induce chromatid exchange upon replication fork collapse. Much of our present understanding of the mechanisms of SCE stems from studies involving nonhuman vertebrate cell lines that are defective in processes of DNA repair and/or recombination. In this article, we present a historical perspective of studies spearheaded by Dr. Anthony V. Carrano and colleagues focusing on SCE as a genetic outcome, and the role of the single-strand break DNA repair protein XRCC1 in suppressing SCE. A more general overview of the cellular processes and key protein "effectors" that regulate the manifestation of SCE is also presented.     

Bimodal distribution of sensitivity to SCE induction by diepoxybutane in human lymphocytes. II. Relationship to baseline SCE frequency

Environmental and genetic factors have been implicated as important sources of individual variation in baseline sister-chromatid exchange (SCE) frequency in humans. The current study was designed to test whether the frequency of baseline SCEs in 58 normal blood donors is associated with previously observed variations in SCE frequencies induced by diepoxybutane (DEB). Because 12 subjects were current cigarette smokers and smoking is known to be an in vivo inducer of baseline SCE frequencies, we specifically tested whether higher baseline SCE frequencies in smokers would be associated with in vitro sensitivity to SCE induction by DEB. Analysis of variance showed that DEB-induced SCE frequencies were significantly associated with baseline SCE frequencies; those who were sensitive to SCE induction by DEB were more likely to have higher baseline SCE frequencies. This effect, however, was independent of in vivo induction of SCE by smoking. Chromosomal sensitivity to the induction of SCE by DEB explained approx. 15-20% of the variation in baseline SCE. This was similar in magnitude to the effect of cigarette smoking. Because increased sensitivity to DEB-induced SCEs is common in normal blood donors (approx. 24%) and is associated with an increase in baseline SCEs, it should be investigated as a source of bias and/or a potential marker of sensitivity to environmental mutagens in future cytogenetic studies.     

Aphidicolin-Resistant Mutants of Mouse Lymphoma L5178y Cells with a High Incidence of Spontaneous Sister Chromatid Exchanges

Two aphidicolin-resistant cell mutants (AC 12 and AC 41) with a fourfold increase in spontaneous frequency of sister chromatid exchanges (SCEs) were obtained out of over 400 aphidicolin-resistant mutants isolated from mouse lymphoma L5178Y cells. They also exhibited three- to fourfold increases in spontaneous frequency of chromosome aberrations (CAs). To determine whether the high level of SCE frequency in AC 12 is caused by 5-bromodeoxyuridine (BrdUrd) used for visualizing SCEs, the effect of BrdUrd incorporated into DNA on SCE induction was analyzed. The SCE frequencies in AC 12 remained constant at BrdUrd incorporation levels corresponding to 2-90% substitution for thymidine in DNA. In addition, the small amount of BrdUrd incorporated into both daughter and parenteral DNA strands in AC 12 had minimal effect on SCE induction. Furthermore, AC 12 and AC 41 were slightly resistant to BrdUrd with respect to the induction of CAs, the inhibition of cell-cycle progression and the decrease in mitotic activity. These findings suggest that the high incidence of SCEs in AC 12 and AC 41 is formed by their intrinsic defects, not by the effects of BrdUrd used. The analysis of SCE frequencies in hybrid cells between these mutants and the parental L5178Y revealed that the genetic defects in AC 12 and AC 41 appear to be recessive, and that these two mutants belong to the same complementation group. Furthermore, AC 12 belonged to a different complementation group from ES 4, which was isolated previously from L5178Y as an SCE mutant with a twofold higher frequency of spontaneous SCEs. This finding indicates that at least two different genetic defects participate in the formation of the high incidence of spontaneous SCEs in mouse cells. These SCE mutants would provide valuable cell materials for studying the molecular mechanism of SCE formation.     

Increased rates of sister chromatid exchanges induced by the herbicide 2,4-D

The potential for genetic damage from widely used hormonic herbicides, such as 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D), continues to be of serious concern. The mutagenic effect as reflected by the rates of sister chromatid exchanges (SCE) was determined in cultured human lymphocytes. Data were based on the analysis of 50 cells for the control and each of the three treatments. A 50 micrograms/ml dosage caused a highly significant increase in SCE. Dosages of 100 and 250 micrograms/ml elevated the rate of SCE, but not significantly. Since 2,4-D biodegrades rapidly in soil and water, its continued use is not in serious question until safer compounds are available. However, the results of this study suggest that the danger of genetic damage from direct exposure to commercial samples of 2,4-D should not be ignored.     

Cyclophosphamide-Induced IN VIVO Sister Chromatid Exchanges (Sce) in MUS MUSCULUS. III. Quantitative Genetic Analysis

In vivo cyclophosphamide (CP)-induced sister chromatid exchanges (SCEs) were evaluated in females from five genetic strains of mice (C57BL/6J, C3H/S, 129/ReJ, BALB/c and DBA/2) and their F₁ hybrids. Baseline (noninduced) SCE values differ significantly among strains, 129/ReJ having the lowest and DBA/2 having the highest mean SCE per cell values. In general, the baseline SCE of a given F₁ is within the range of its corresponding parental strains or near the lower parental value. Furthermore, there is a genotype-dependent increase in mean SCEs per cell with CP dose. Strain differences in SCE induction are noted particularly at the two higher CP doses (4.50 and 45.0 mg/kg). In general, F₁ hybrids involving a strain with high induced SCEs and a strain with low induced SCEs exhibit mean SCE values that are closer to the value of the lower strain. F₁ s involving two strains with high SCEs or two strains with low SCEs yield SCEs not different from parental strains. The method of diallel cross analysis showed the order of dominance of these strains in SCE induction to be 129/ReJ BALB/c C3H/S DBA/2 C57BL/6J. These results support the involvement of predominantly nonadditive genetic factors as major gene(s) in SCE induction. In addition, involvement of random and independent events in SCE induction is suggested by the distribution of SCEs which follows a Poisson distribution.     

Sister chromatid exchange and proliferation pattern after ultrasound exposure in vivo.

The sister chromatid exchange (SCE) frequency and cell-cycle specific metaphase patterns were investigated in PHA-stimulated lymphocytes in vitro after in vivo exposure of 15 patients to diagnostic ultrasound. No significant differences were found in SCE rates before and after ultrasound exposure. The evaluation of cell-cycle specific metaphase patterns, differentiating cells which passed one, two, or more cell cycles, gave no evidence for a cell-growth inhibitory effect. Since SCE is regarded as a highly sensitive method for the detection of mutagenic effects, our data confirm previous reports on the genetic safety of diagnostic ultrasound.     

Sister chromatid exchanges in cultured peripheral lymphocytes from twins

Summary Sister chromatid exchange points (SCE points) on individual chromosomes were studied in cultured lymphocytes from 11 monozygotic (MZ) and nine dizygotic (DZ) same-sexed pairs by means of sequential Q-banding and BUdR-Giemsa techniques. No statistically significant variation between unrelated individuals with respect to SCE points on specific chromosomes was found. Intrapair differences in the number of SCE points on specific chromosomes were not significantly smaller between MZ twin partners as compared with DZ partners. The results suggest that genetic factors do not play any major role in the frequency and distribution of SCE in normal subjects.     

Genotoxicity studies on the antimicrobial drug sulfamethoxazole in cultured human lymphocytes

The genotoxicity of the antimicrobial drug sulfamethoxazole was evaluated in cultured human peripheral blood lymphocytes. The frequencies of sister-chromatid exchange (SCE) and micronuclei (MN) were scored as genetic endpoints. Both tests cover a wide range of induced genetic damage such as primary DNA damage, clastogenicity and aneugenicity. Cultures were set up with blood samples from two healthy donors and the treatment was done with different sulfamethoxazole concentrations ranging from 10 to 500 microg/ml. From the results obtained it appears that this drug is able to induce weak genotoxic effects, as revealed by the slight increase in the SCE and MN frequencies, at least at one of the two highest concentrations tested. However, the results of the SCE assay should be interpreted with caution because the increase is just significant. In addition, cyotoxic/cytostatic effects of sulfamethoxazole were revealed by a decrease in the proliferative rate index (PRI) and in the cytokinesis block proliferation index (CBPI).     

Differential enhancement of sister-chromatid exchange frequencies by alpha-naphthoflavone in cultured lymphocytes from smokers and non-smokers

The sister-chromatid exchange (SCE) frequency was assessed in peripheral lymphocytes from 4 smokers and 8 non-smokers in the absence or presence of alpha-naphthoflavone (ANF) in the culture media. ANF produced a concentration-dependent increase in the frequency of SCEs in smoking individuals. At an ANF concentration of 11 micrograms/ml, average SCE levels were 54% and 13% above the baseline levels in smokers and non-smokers, respectively. The ANF-enhanced increase in the SCE frequency ranged from 3.12 to 5.72 among smokers, and from 0 to 1.96 among the non-smokers. No significant difference in the mean SCE baseline levels between smokers and non-smokers was detected. The mechanism responsible for the enhanced frequency of SCEs in smokers following in vitro exposure to ANF is not clear, but may reflect changes in metabolic activation/deactivation or increased sensitivity to genetic effects of ANF.     

Sister Chromatid Exchanges Are Mediated by Homologous Recombination in Vertebrate Cells

Sister chromatid exchange (SCE) frequency is a commonly used index of chromosomal stability in response to environmental or genetic mutagens. However, the mechanism generating cytologically detectable SCEs and, therefore, their prognostic value for chromosomal stability in mitotic cells remain unclear. We examined the role of the highly conserved homologous recombination (HR) pathway in SCE by measuring SCE levels in HR-defective vertebrate cells. Spontaneous and mitomycin C-induced SCE levels were significantly reduced for chicken DT40 B cells lacking the key HR genes RAD51 and RAD54 but not for nonhomologous DNA end-joining (NHEJ)-defective KU70(-/-) cells. As measured by targeted integration efficiency, reconstitution of HR activity by expression of a human RAD51 transgene restored SCE levels to normal, confirming that HR is the mechanism responsible for SCE. Our findings show that HR uses the nascent sister chromatid to repair potentially lethal DNA lesions accompanying replication, which might explain the lethality or tumorigenic potential associated with defects in HR or HR-associated proteins.     

Baseline and phosphoramide mustard-induced sister-chromatid exchanges in pharmacists handling anti-cancer drugs.

Determinations of baseline and mutagen-induced sister-chromatid exchanges (SCE) have been used as indicators of previous mutagen exposure in several human populations. Mutagen-induced SCE is based on the premise that a genetic outcome may depend not only on a present exposure, but also on a cell's "memory" of previous exposure. The genotoxicity of some anti-cancer drugs including cyclophosphamide (CP) has been studied by determining baseline and mutagen-induced SCE in peripheral blood lymphocytes in treated cancer patients. This study examined the in vivo genotoxic effects of occupational exposure to anti-cancer drug handling by relating baseline and phosphoramide mustard (PM) -induced SCE levels with duration of anti-cancer drug handling as a surrogate for anti-cancer drug exposure dose. The mean baseline SCE for the population was 5.19 +/- 0.17 and was not correlated with duration of drug handling. However, a strong correlation was demonstrated between inducible SCE values and life-time duration of drug handling with r = 0.63 (p less than 0.0001 for low-dose PM challenge (0.1 mg/ml PM) and r = 0.67 (p less than 0.0001) for high-dose PM challenge (0.25 mg/ml PM). A similar relationship was seen for PM-induced SCE and duration of anti-cancer drug handling for the workers' present job with correlations obtained being r = 0.63 (p less than 0.0001) for low-dose PM and r = 0.59 (p less than 0.0001) for high dose PM. The short-lived nature of the baseline SCE lesion is discussed as a limitation in population surveillance studies, as it reflects primarily recent mutagen exposure and persists only for days to weeks after exposure. The induced SCE measure is postulated to provide an integrating dosimeter of remote previous exposure, improving upon the current limitation of the baseline SCE measure and allowing the "unmasking" of previous exposure in a provocative framework.     

Induction of sister chromatid exchanges in human cells by fluorescent light.

The Brd-U differential staining technique was utilized to examine the induction of sister-chromatid exchanges (SCE) by fluorescent ligt in human fetal lung fibroblasts (IMR-90). Exposure of these cells in media to fluorescent light resulted in an increase in SCE frequencies from a background level of 8.5 SCE/cell to 20.5 SCE/cell. Cellular replication kinetics were also inhibited by fluorescent light exposure. Exposure of cells to fluorescent light in phosphate buffered saline (PBS) resulted in a two-fold increase in SCE levels and incresed inhibition of cell replication, indicating that culture media may have a protective effect. Determinations of SCE frequencies with blocking filters indicated that the fluorescent light wavelengths responsible for SCE induction were in the near-ultraviolet spectrum between 300 and 390 nm. Culturing cell sin media that had been exposed to fluorescent light resulted in a significant increase in SCE levels, 14.5 ± 1.5 vs. 7.5 ± 0.65, demonstrating the contribution of media photoproducts to SCE induction. The role of media photoproducts was further reinforced by finding a significant decline in fluorescent light induced SCE in cells cultured in medium deficient in three known photosensitizers (phenol red, tetracycline and riboflavin) for 2–3 weeks prior to exposure.Since SCE have been shown to be a sensitive indicator of DNA damage, these results indicate that fluorescent light can induce genetic damage in human cells. These findings are also of importance to investigators culturing cells in laboratories with fluorescent illumination.     

Increased sister chromatid exchange in human lymphocyte cultures infected with mycoplasma

The effects of fermenting, poorly arginine-utilizing Mycoplasma fermentans and arginine-utilizing Mycoplasma salivarium on the frequency of sister chromatid exchange (SCE) in cultured human lymphocytes were examined. M. fermentans caused no apparent mitosis inhibition of lymphocytes and the increase in SCE frequency was dependent on the inoculum size of the mycoplasma. An evident increase in SCE frequency was observed in lymphocytes infected with smaller inoculum sizes of M. salivarium whereas there was mitosis inhibition of lymphocytes infected with larger inoculum sizes of the mycoplasma. In lymphocyte cultures infected with M. salivarium, the addition of arginine to the culture medium reduced mitosis inhibition but did not diminish the increase in SCE frequency, indicating that arginine depletion was not involved in causing the induction of SCEs in mycoplasma-infected lymphocytes. With regard to the genetic effectiveness of SCE, these results suggested that mycoplasmas are capable of inducing cytogenetic changes in infected host cells.     

Cytogenetic investigations on Werner's syndrome, Acrogeria and Keratosis Palmo-Plantaris

The frequencies of sister chromatid exchanges and of aspecific chromosome aberrations have been investigated in the lymphocytes from a Werner patient, from an Acrogeria patient and from three members of a family with Keratosis Palmo-Plantaris. These investigations point out that: 1) the SCE frequency is significatively enhanced in Werner as in KPP lymphocytes, 2) the frequency of aspecific chromosome aberrations is increased only in Werner lymphocytes, without evidence of variegated translocation mosaicism. The findings confirm that SCE and chromosome aberrations do not necessarily result from the same genetic damage and that SCE may represent the cytological evidence of unexcised non fatal DNA lesions, which occasionally may be responsible for carcinogenesis.     

Metabolite ratio of toluene-exposed rotogravure printing plant workers reflects individual mutagenic risk by sister chromatid exchanges

The study involved a group of 42 printing plant workers and a control group of 45 blood donors. At the working places, the ambient air-toluene concentration amounted from 141 to 328 mg/m(3). Sister chromatid exchanges (SCEs) were significantly elevated by three units in the exposed group. In this group, the concentration of urinary toluene metabolites was also considerably increased-hippuric acid was four times higher and the o-cresol and p-cresol fractions were twice as high. Results of toluene monitoring of ambient air- or blood-toluene concentrations did not show any relationships with individual SCE. While these SCE values revealed only a weak relationship with the corresponding hippuric acid data, a significant correlation with the cresols, which are known to be more genotoxic than hippuric acid, appeared in highly exposed workers. An attempt was made to consider the individual metabolic balance of toluene excretion products. For that reason individual cresol to hippuric acid ratios were calculated and related to corresponding SCE values. In all investigated subpopulations of the exposed group, this ratio correlated with SCE at a level of high significance. This strong interrelationship is a powerful argument for the genotoxic behavior of toluene. Furthermore, the individual metabolic balance, as a consequence of genetic polymorphism, should be considered in the discussion about genetic risk of toluene.     

石油作业习惯性流产女性细胞遗传毒性研究

目的：研究石油作业环境对女性习惯性流产的遗传毒性。方法：随机选择习惯性流产的石油作业女性38人和正常的育龄女性20人,检测其外周血淋巴细胞姐妹染色单体互换,记数SCE发生率。结果：观察组的外周血淋巴细胞SCE发生率为8．81＋0．35,明显高于对照组（P〈0．05）。结论：SCE的发生可作为石油作业习惯性流产女性染色体结构稳定性的检测指标。石油作业环境对女性生育具有遗传毒性。     

香烟烟雾水溶液中的活性氧及其对姊妹染色单体互换的影响

SCE频率分析是研究环境诱变剂和致癌剂引起人类遗传物质损伤的有效手段。以人类外周血林巴细胞姊妹染色单体交换（SCE）为指标,评价了香烟烟雾水溶液的遗传毒性。首先,定量测定了香烟烟雾水溶液中含有H2O2、O2-等活性氧,从而间接证明了其潜在的遗传毒性。然后,将一定量的香烟烟雾水溶液加入人外周血淋巴细胞培养液中,结果表明实验组SCE频率明显高于空白对照组,因此直接证明了香烟烟雾水溶液的遗传毒性。     

Monitoring of occupational exposure to epichlorohydrin by genetic effects and hemoglobin adducts

The present work is focused on the determination of in vivo doses and studies of genetic effects in workers exposed to epichlorohydrin (ECH). The studied endpoints were hemoglobin (Hb) adducts, frequencies of hprt mutants, micronuclei in cytochalasin B blocked binucleated lymphocytes, sister chromatid exchanges (SCE) and high frequency cells (HFC). Blood samples were collected from office clerks and ECH exposed factory workers at an industrial plant in Germany. The workers were exposed to 0.11–0.23 ppm ECH in the air 45 h per week and to 0.2–2.6 ppm for 3 h per week. Some Swedish non-exposed subjects were also used for Hb adduct measurements. The genetic data, HFC and SCE, showed a significant difference between exposed and unexposed donors. In contrast to earlier studies on SCE, no impact of smoking was observed. Effects on micronuclei were on the borderline of significance, whereas there was no effect for HPRT mutants. The average Hb adduct level was higher in exposed than in non-exposed donors, although the difference was only significant when the exposed group was compared to Swedish controls. Smoking gave significantly increased adduct levels. The absence of significant correlations between individual data for Hb adducts and genetic effects, may be explained by the different periods of time covered by the responses in these endpoints. Whereas Hb adducts reflect the exposure during up to 4 months (i.e. the life span of human erythrocytes), the SCE, and particularly the HFC, seem to accumulate for years in a long-lived fraction of T-lymphocytes without DNA repair. Thus, the adduct data does not reflect the exposure backwards in time unless it can be shown that exposure conditions have remained unchanged. The origin of the background adduct levels in non-smoking control persons is at present not known.     

The absence of the yeast chromatin assembly factor Asf1 increases genomic instability and sister chromatid exchange

Histone chaperone Asf1 participates in heterochromatin silencing, DNA repair and regulation of gene expression, and promotes the assembly of DNA into chromatin in vitro. To determine the influence of Asf1 on genetic stability, we have analysed the effect of asf1Delta on homologous recombination. In accordance with a defect in nucleosome assembly, asf1Delta leads to a loss of negative supercoiling in plasmids. Importantly, asf1Delta increases spontaneous recombination between inverted DNA sequences. This increase correlates with an accumulation of double-strand breaks (DSBs) as determined by immunodetection of phosphorylated histone H2A and fluorescent detection of Rad52-YFP foci during S and G2/M phases. In addition, asf1Delta shows high levels of sister chromatid exchange (SCE) and is proficient in DSB-induced SCE as determined by physical analysis. Our results suggest that defective chromatin assembly caused by asf1Delta leads to DSBs that can be repaired by SCE, affecting genetic stability.