Quantitative approaches to monitor protein-nucleic acid interactions using fluorescent probes

Sequence-specific recognition of nucleic acids by proteins is required for nearly every aspect of gene expression. Quantitative binding experiments are a useful tool to measure the ability of a protein to distinguish between multiple sequences. Here, we describe the use of fluorophore-labeled oligonucleotide probes to quantitatively monitor protein/nucleic acid interactions. We review two complementary experimental methods, fluorescence polarization and fluorescence electrophoretic mobility shift assays, that enable the quantitative measurement of binding affinity. We also present two strategies for post-synthetic end-labeling of DNA or RNA oligonucleotides with fluorescent dyes. The approaches discussed here are efficient and sensitive, providing a safe and accessible alternative to the more commonly used radio-isotopic methods.     

Recognition schemes for protein-nucleic acid interactions

The molecular forces involved in protein-nucleic acid interaction are electrostatic, stacking and hydrogen-bonding. These interactions have a certain amount of specificity due to the directional nature of such interactions and the spatial contributions of the steric effects of different substituent groups. Quantum chemical calculations on these interactions have been reported which clearly bring out such features. While the binding energies for electrostatic interactions are an order of magnitude higher, the differences in interaction energies for structures stabilised by hydrogen-bonding and stacking are relatively small. Thus, the molecular interactions alone cannot explain the highly specific nature of binding observed in certain segments of proteins and nucleic acids. It is therefore logical to assume that the sequence dependent three dimensional structures of these molecules help to place the functional groups in the correct geometry for a favourable interaction between the two molecules. We have carried out 2D-FT nuclear magnetic resonance studies on the oligonucleotide d-GGATCCGGATCC. This oligonucleotide sequence has two binding sites for the restriction enzyme Bam H1. Our studies indicate that the conformation of this DNA fragment is predominantly B-type except near the binding sites where the ribose ring prefers a³E conformation. This interesting finding raises the general question about the presence of specificity in the inherent backbone structures of proteins and nucleic acids as opposed to specific intermolecular interactions which may induce conformational changes to facilitate such binding.     

Roles of intrinsic disorder in protein-nucleic acid interactions

Interactions between proteins and nucleic acids typify the role of disordered segments, linkers, tails and other entities in the function of complexes that must form with high affinity and specificity but which must be capable of dissociating when no longer needed. While much of the emphasis in the literature has been on the interactions of disordered proteins with other proteins, disorder is also frequently observed in nucleic acids (particularly RNA) and in the proteins that interact with them. The interactions of disordered proteins with DNA most often manifest as molding of the protein onto the B-form DNA structure, although some well-known instances involve remodeling of the DNA structure that seems to require that the interacting proteins be disordered to various extents in the free state. By contrast, induced fit in RNA-protein interactions has been recognized for many years-the existence and prevalence of this phenomenon provides the clearest possible evidence that RNA and its interactions with proteins must be considered as highly dynamic, and the dynamic nature of RNA and its multiplicity of folded and unfolded states is an integral part of its nature and function.     

A new electron microscopic method for studying protein-nucleic acid interactions.

A new method for preparation of nucleic acid specimens for electron microscopy has been adapted to study the interaction of proteins with DNA. Both a detergent and a basic protein are added to the DNA-protein solution before spreading on a hypophase containing 0.2 m ammonium acetate. This method has been tested using T7 DNA and Escherichia coli RNA polymerase. Specifically bound enzyme molecules were clearly visible on the well extended DNA molecules; the binding sites were located at 0.59, 1.24, 1.57, and 1.86% of the total length of T7 DNA. Under carefully controlled conditions, 40–85% of the DNA molecules specifically bound at least one enzyme molecule.     

Thermodynamic databases for proteins and protein-nucleic acid interactions

Thermodynamic data regarding proteins and their interactions are important for understanding the mechanisms of protein folding, protein stability, and molecular recognition. Although there are several structural databases available for proteins and their complexes with other molecules, databases for experimental thermodynamic data on protein stability and interactions are rather scarce. Thus, we have developed two electronically accessible thermodynamic databases. ProTherm, Thermodynamic Database for Proteins and Mutants, contains numerical data of several thermodynamic parameters of protein stability, experimental methods and conditions, along with structural, functional, and literature information. ProNIT, Thermodynamic Database for Protein-Nucleic Acid Interactions, contains thermodynamic data for protein-nucleic acid binding, experimental conditions, structural information of proteins, nucleic acids and the complex, and literature information. These data have been incorporated into 3DinSight, an integrated database for structure, function, and properties of biomolecules. A WWW interface allows users to search for data based on various conditions, with different display and sorting options, and to visualize molecular structures and their interactions. These thermodynamic databases, together with structural databases, help researchers gain insight into the relationship among structure, function, and thermodynamics of proteins and their interactions, and will become useful resources for studying proteins in the postgenomic era.     

Characterization of bacteriophage T4 regA protein-nucleic acid interactions

The bacteriophage T4 regA protein is a translational repressor of a group of T4 early mRNAs. We have characterized the binding of regA protein to polynucleotides and to specific RNAs. Binding to nucleic acids was monitored by the quenching of the intrinsic tryptophan fluorescence of regA protein. regA protein exhibited differential affinities for the polynucleotides examined, with the order of affinity being poly(rU) greater than poly(dT) greater than poly(dU) = poly(rG) greater than poly(rC) = poly(rA). The binding site size calculated for regA protein binding to poly(rU) was n = 9 +/- 1 nucleotides. Cooperativity was observed in binding to multiple-site oligonucleotides, with a cooperativity parameter (omega) value of 10-22. To study the specific interaction between regA protein and T4 gene 44 mRNA, the affinity of regA protein for synthetic gene 44 RNA fragments was measured. The association constant (Ka) for regA protein binding to gene 44 RNA fragments was 100-fold higher than for binding to nontarget RNA. Study of variant gene 44 RNA fragments indicated that the nucleotides required for specific binding are contained within a 12-nucleotide sequence spanning -12 to -1, relative to the AUG codon. The bases of five nucleotides (indicated in upper case type) are critical for specific regA protein interaction with the gene 44 recognition element, 5'-aaUGAGgAaauu-3'. These studies further showed that formation of a regA protein-RNA complex involves a maximum of 2-3 ionic interactions and is primarily an enthalpy-driven process.     

Thermodynamic database for protein-nucleic acid interactions (ProNIT).

MOTIVATION: Protein-nucleic acid interactions are fundamental to the regulation of gene expression. In order to elucidate the molecular mechanism of protein-nucleic acid recognition and analyze the gene regulation network, not only structural data but also quantitative binding data are necessary. Although there are structural databases for proteins and nucleic acids, there exists no database for their experimental binding data. Thus, we have developed a Thermodynamic Database for Protein-Nucleic Acid Interactions (ProNIT). RESULTS: We have collected experimentally observed binding data from the literature. ProNIT contains several important thermodynamic data for protein-nucleic acid binding, such as dissociation constant (K(d)), association constant (K(a)), Gibbs free energy change (DeltaG), enthalpy change (DeltaH), heat capacity change (DeltaC(p)), experimental conditions, structural information of proteins, nucleic acids and the complex, and literature information. These data are integrated into a relational database system together with structural and functional information to provide flexible searching facilities by using combinations of various terms and parameters. A www interface allows users to search for data based on various conditions, with different display and sorting options, and to visualize molecular structures and their interactions. AVAILABILITY: ProNIT is freely accessible at the URL http://www.rtc.riken.go.jp/jouhou/pronit/pronit.html.     

NUCPLOT: a program to generate schematic diagrams of protein-nucleic acid interactions.

Proteins that bind to DNA are found in all areas of genetic activity within the cell. To help understand how these proteins perform their various functions, it is useful to analyse which residues are involved in binding to the DNA and how they interact with the bases and sugar-phosphate backbone of nucleic acids. Here we describe a program called NUCPLOT which can automatically identify these interactions from the 3D atomic coordinates of the complex from a PDB file and generate a plot that shows all the interactions in a schematic manner. The program produces a PostScript output file representing hydrogen, van der Waals and covalent bonds between the protein and the DNA. The resulting diagram is both clear and simple and allows immediate identification of important interactions within the structure. It also facilitates comparison of binding found in different structures. NUCPLOT is a completely automatic program, which can be used for any protein-DNA complex and will also work for certain protein-RNA structures.     

Antibody-nucleic acid interactions. Antibodies to psoralen-modified RNA as probes of RNA structure.

Antisera elicited by immunization of rabbits with 4'-aminomethyl-trioxsalen (AMT)-modified poly(A,U) complexed with methylated bovine serum albumin was characterized in competition radioimmunoassays (RIA) and enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays (ELISA). AMT-poly(A,U) was over 10,000-fold more reactive than unmodified poly(A,U) or AMT alone. The antiserum cross-reacted to varying extents with AMT-modified-RNA's and -DNA's. The presence of AMT-uridine usually assured strong reactivity. The amino group of AMT contributed to antibody binding to a small degree. Binding was not significantly affected by high ionic strength, suggesting that binding does not involve ion pair formation. Murine encephalomyocarditis virus replicative intermediates, as well as cellular RNA and DNA were modified by psoralen in intact cells, suggesting that EMCV RNA and cellular RNA's in intact cells possess detectable stretches of base pairs. The antibodies described here will be useful in studying the secondary and tertiary structure of RNA's in vitro and in intact cells.     

FRET-based analysis of protein-nucleic acid interactions by genetically incorporating a fluorescent amino acid

Protein–nucleic acid interaction is an important process in many biological phenomena. In this study, a fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET)-based protein–DNA binding assay has been developed, in which a fluorescent amino acid is genetically incorporated into a DNA-binding protein. A coumarin-containing amino acid was incorporated into a DNA-binding protein, and the mutant protein specifically produced a FRET signal upon binding to its cognate DNA labeled with a fluorophore. The protein–DNA binding affinity was then measured under equilibrium conditions. This method is advantageous for studying protein-nucleic acid interactions, because it is performed under equilibrium conditions, technically easy, and applicable to any nucleic acid-binding protein.     

Theoretical studies on protein-nucleic acid interactions. I. Interaction of positively charged amino acids with nucleic acid fragments

Coulombic interactions between the side chains of charged amino acids (Arg⁺, Lys⁺, and His⁺) and negatively charged phosphate groups of nucleic acid fragments have been studied theoretically. Diribose monophosphate and dideoxyribose monophosphate are chosen as model systems for single-stranded RNA and DNA, respectively. The interaction energies have been calculated by second-order perturbation theory using simplified formulas for individual terms. The interaction energy in this formalism is a sum of electrostatic, polarization, dispersion, and repulsive energies. Our results show that about 90% of the total interaction energy is contributed by the electrostatic term alone. Contribution from the repulsive term exceeds that from the dispersion term. Calculated interaction energies suggest that Lys⁺ and His⁺ form more stable complexes with RNA than with single-stranded DNA. On the other hand, Arg⁺ has a higher affinity for DNA than for RNA. The affinity of nucleic acids for the three amino acids is in the order Lys⁺ > His⁺ > Arg⁺. Further, the basic amino acid residues form more stable complexes with A-DNA than with B-DNA. The role of the Coulombic interactions in the specific recognition of nucleic acids by proteins is discussed.     

Use of difference boundary sedimentation velocity to investigate nonspecific protein-nucleic acid interactions

The difference boundary sedimentation velocity technique of Schachman and co-workers is demonstrated to be applicalbe to the measurement of binding constants (Kobsd) in the range 10(2)-10(5) M(-1) for the nonspecific interactions of proteins with DNA. The difference technique can reproducibly detect a 2% change in the sedimentation coefficient of the DNA upon binding ligands, corresponding to average extents of association as low as 10 molecules of protein (in the cases of Escherichia coli lac repressor and E. coli RNA polymerase) per molecule of bacteriophage T7 DNA. At these low binding densities, it is plausible to assume that the primary effect of ligand binding is on the buoyant mass of the complex and not on the frictional coefficient of the flexible DNA coil. Binding constants calculated by using this assumption agree well with literature values for the nonspecific interactions of RNase and lac repressor proteins with double-stranded DNA. Advantages of the method are that it is relatively rapid, requires the optical detection of the DNA only, and can be performed on small amounts of sample. The method appears useful for surveying (to an accuracy of +/-50% in Kobsd or +/-10% in log Kobsd) the effects of solution variables on Kobsd of protein-DNA interactions. Applications of the method to the nonspecific interactions of RNA polymerase core and holoenzymes with T7 DNA are discussed.     

Electrophoretic mobility shift assay (EMSA) for detecting protein-nucleic acid interactions

The gel electrophoresis mobility shift assay (EMSA) is used to detect protein complexes with nucleic acids. It is the core technology underlying a wide range of qualitative and quantitative analyses for the characterization of interacting systems. In the classical assay, solutions of protein and nucleic acid are combined and the resulting mixtures are subjected to electrophoresis under native conditions through polyacrylamide or agarose gel. After electrophoresis, the distribution of species containing nucleic acid is determined, usually by autoradiography of 32P-labeled nucleic acid. In general, protein-nucleic acid complexes migrate more slowly than the corresponding free nucleic acid. In this protocol, we identify the most important factors that determine the stabilities and electrophoretic mobilities of complexes under assay conditions. A representative protocol is provided and commonly used variants are discussed. Expected outcomes are briefly described. References to extensions of the method and a troubleshooting guide are provided.     

Dissecting the role of protein-protein and protein-nucleic acid interactions in MS2 bacteriophage stability

To investigate the role of protein-protein and protein-nucleic acid interactions in virus assembly, we compared the stabilities of native bacteriophage MS2, virus-like particles (VLPs) containing nonviral RNAs, and an assembly-defective coat protein mutant (dlFG) and its single-chain variant (sc-dlFG). Physical (high pressure) and chemical (urea and guanidine hydrochloride) agents were used to promote virus disassembly and protein denaturation, and the changes in virus and protein structure were monitored by measuring tryptophan intrinsic fluorescence, bis-ANS probe fluorescence, and light scattering. We found that VLPs dissociate into capsid proteins that remain folded and more stable than the proteins dissociated from authentic particles. The proposed model is that the capsid disassembles but the protein remains bound to the heterologous RNA encased by VLPs. The dlFG dimerizes correctly, but fails to assemble into capsids, because it lacks the 15-amino acid FG loop involved in inter-dimer interactions at the viral fivefold and quasi-sixfold axes. This protein was very unstable and, when compared with the dissociation/denaturation of the VLPs and the wild-type virus, it was much more susceptible to chemical and physical perturbation. Genetic fusion of the two subunits of the dimer in the single-chain dimer sc-dlFG stabilized the protein, as did the presence of 34-bp poly(GC) DNA. These studies reveal mechanisms by which interactions in the capsid lattice can be sufficiently stable and specific to ensure assembly, and they shed light on the processes that lead to the formation of infectious viral particles.