Phase separation in bilayer lipid membranes: effects on the inner leaf due to coupling to the outer leaf

The combined effects of the tendency of cholesterol to order lipids in the liquid phase and the coupling between lipids in the two leaves of a bilayer are investigated theoretically utilizing a Landau free energy. We show that as a consequence of these combined effects, lateral phase separation in the outer leaf between cholesterol-rich and -poor liquids causes a similar, but weaker, phase separation in the inner leaf. Just as the areal density of lipids in the outer leaf increases in the cholesterol-rich regions, so the areal density of lipids also increases in the inner leaf. Thus, the areal density in the inner leaf varies spatially, reflecting spatial variations of the areal density in the outer leaf. This provides a mechanism for proteins attached to the inner leaf via a hydrocarbon tether to respond to variations in the composition of the outer leaf. We also note that the effect of coupling between the leaves should be observable in artificial bilayers.     

Model of a Raft in Both Leaves of an Asymmetric Lipid Bilayer

We present a theory of inhomogeneities in the plasma membrane, or rafts, that can exist in both leaves of the plasma membrane. We note that although neither of the major phospholipid components of the outer leaf, sphingomyelin (SM) nor phosphatidylcholine (PC), evinces a tendency to form phases characterized by nonzero curvature, one of the major components of the inner leaf, phosphatidylethanolamine (PE), displays a strong tendency to do so whereas the other, phosphatidylserine (PS), does not. Therefore, we posit that the concentration difference of PS and PE couples to height fluctuations of the plasma membrane bilayer. This brings about a microemulsion in the inner leaf. Coupling of the concentration difference between PS and PE in the inner leaf and SM and PC in the outer leaf propagates the microemulsion to that leaf as well. The characteristic size of the inhomogeneities is equal to the square-root of the ratio of the bending modulus of the bilayer to its surface tension, a size which is ∼100 nm for the plasma membrane. If the coupling between leaves were to be provided by the interchange of cholesterol, then our model raft would consist of SM and cholesterol in the outer leaf and PS and cholesterol in the inner leaf floating in a sea of PC and PE in both leaves.     

Model of a Raft in Both Leaves of an Asymmetric Lipid Bilayer

We present a theory of inhomogeneities in the plasma membrane, or rafts, that can exist in both leaves of the plasma membrane. We note that although neither of the major phospholipid components of the outer leaf, sphingomyelin (SM) nor phosphatidylcholine (PC), evinces a tendency to form phases characterized by nonzero curvature, one of the major components of the inner leaf, phosphatidylethanolamine (PE), displays a strong tendency to do so whereas the other, phosphatidylserine (PS), does not. Therefore, we posit that the concentration difference of PS and PE couples to height fluctuations of the plasma membrane bilayer. This brings about a microemulsion in the inner leaf. Coupling of the concentration difference between PS and PE in the inner leaf and SM and PC in the outer leaf propagates the microemulsion to that leaf as well. The characteristic size of the inhomogeneities is equal to the square-root of the ratio of the bending modulus of the bilayer to its surface tension, a size which is ∼100 nm for the plasma membrane. If the coupling between leaves were to be provided by the interchange of cholesterol, then our model raft would consist of SM and cholesterol in the outer leaf and PS and cholesterol in the inner leaf floating in a sea of PC and PE in both leaves.     

Pore Formation in a Binary Giant Vesicle Induced by Cone-Shaped Lipids

We have investigated shape deformations of binary giant unilamellar vesicles (GUVs) composed of cone- and cylinder-shaped lipids. By coupling the spontaneous curvature of lipids with the phase separation, we demonstrated pore opening and closing in GUVs. When the temperature was set below the chain melting transition temperature of the cylinder-shaped lipid, the GUVs burst and then formed a single large pore, where the cone shape lipids form a cap at the edge of the bilayer to stabilize the pore. The pore closed when we increased the temperature above the transition temperature. The pore showed three types of shapes depending on the cone-shaped lipid concentration: simple circular, rolled-rim, and wrinkled-rim pores. These pore shape changes indicate that the distribution of the cone- and cylinder-shaped lipids is asymmetric between the inner and outer leaflets in the bilayer. We have proposed a theoretical model for a two-component membrane with an edge of bilayer where lipids can transfer between two leaflets. Using this model, we have reproduced numerically the observed shape deformations at the rim of pore.     

How Cholesterol Could Be Drawn to the Cytoplasmic Leaf of the Plasma Membrane by Phosphatidylethanolamine

In the mammalian plasma membrane, cholesterol can translocate rapidly between the exoplasmic and cytoplasmic leaves, so that its distribution between them should be given by the equality of its chemical potential in the leaves. Due to its favorable interaction with sphingomyelin, which is almost entirely in the outer leaf, one expects the great majority of cholesterol to be there also. Experimental results do not support this, implying that there is some mechanism attracting cholesterol to the inner leaf. We hypothesize that it is drawn there to reduce the bending free energy of the membrane caused by the presence of PE (phosphatidylethanolamine). It does this in two ways: first by simply diluting the amount of PE in the inner leaf, and second by ordering the tails of the PE to reduce its spontaneous curvature. Incorporating this mechanism into a model free energy for the bilayer, we find that between 50 and 60% of the total cholesterol should be in the inner leaf of human erythrocytes.     

Acyl Chain Length and Saturation Modulate Interleaflet Coupling in Asymmetric Bilayers: Effects on Dynamics and Structural Order

A long-standing question about membrane structure and function is the degree to which the physical properties of the inner and outer leaflets of a bilayer are coupled to one another. Using our recently developed methods to prepare asymmetric vesicles, coupling was investigated for vesicles containing phosphatidylcholine (PC) in the inner leaflet and sphingomyelin (SM) in the outer leaflet. The coupling of both lateral diffusion and membrane order was monitored as a function of PC and SM acyl chain structure. The presence in the outer leaflet of brain SM, which decreased outer-leaflet lateral diffusion, had little effect upon lateral diffusion in inner leaflets composed of dioleoyl PC (i.e., diffusion was only weakly coupled in the two leaflets) but did greatly reduce lateral diffusion in inner leaflets composed of PC with one saturated and one oleoyl acyl chain (i.e., diffusion was strongly coupled in these cases). In addition, reduced outer-leaflet diffusion upon introduction of outer-leaflet milk SM or a synthetic C24:0 SM, both of which have long interdigitating acyl chains, also greatly reduce diffusion of inner leaflets composed of dioleoyl PC, indicative of strong coupling. Strikingly, several assays showed that the ordering of the outer leaflet induced by the presence of SM was not reflected in increased lipid order in the inner leaflet, i.e., there was no detectable coupling between inner and outer leaflet membrane order. We propose a model for how lateral diffusion can be coupled in opposite leaflets and discuss how this might impact membrane function.     

Cholesterol-Dependent Bending Energy Is Important in Cholesterol Distribution of the Plasma Membrane

We consider the plasma membrane that contains a cholesterol molar fraction of 0.4 and ask how that cholesterol is distributed between the two leaves. Because of the rapid flip-flop of cholesterol between leaves, we assume that its distribution is determined by the equality of its chemical potentials in the two leaves. When we consider only the contributions of entropy and interactions to the cholesterol chemical potential in our model system, we find, not surprisingly, that the cholesterol is mostly in the outer leaf because of the strong attraction between cholesterol and sphingomyelin (SM), which is predominantly in that leaf. We find 72% there. We then include the contribution from the bending energy in each leaf that must be overcome to join the leaves in a flat bilayer. The product of bending modulus and spontaneous curvature is obtained from simulation. We find that the addition of cholesterol to the outer leaf reduces the spontaneous curvature, which is initially positive, until it passes through zero when the molar fraction of cholesterol in the outer leaf is 0.28. Additional cholesterol is driven toward the inner leaf by the sphingomyelin phosphatidylcholine mixture. This is resisted by the bending energy contribution to the inner leaf. We find, again by simulation, that the addition of cholesterol monotonically increases the magnitude of the spontaneous curvature of the inner leaf, which is negative. This increases its bending energy. We conclude that, as a result of these competing effects, the percentage of cholesterol in the outer leaf is reduced to ∼63 ± 6%.     

Phase fluctuations on the micron-submicron scale in GUVs composed of a binary lipid mixture

We used a combination of imaging and fluctuation techniques to investigate the temporal evolution of gel phase domains at the onset of phase separation, as well as the correlation between domain topology and local lipid ordering in GUVs composed of a binary mixture of DPPC/DLPC 1:1. The data acquired at temperatures immediately above the transition temperature of the two lipids suggest fluctuations in the lipid organization with a lifetime <0.1 s and a characteristic length of 1.2 μm. As the temperature is decreased below the transition temperature of one of the lipids, coupling between the two leaflets of the bilayer is observed to begin within the first five minutes after the onset of phase separation. However, domains confined to only one leaflet can be found during the first 45-50 min after the onset of phase separation. Our analysis using a two-state model (liquid and gel) indicates that for the first 45-50 min from the onset of phase separation the two lipid phases do not strongly influence the phase behavior of each other on the micron-length scale. At longer times, behavior that deviates from the two-state model is observed and appears to be correlated to domain morphology.     

Model Plasma Membrane Exhibits a Microemulsion in Both Leaves Providing a Foundation for “Rafts”

We consider a model lipid plasma membrane, one that describes the outer leaf as consisting of sphingomyelin, phosphatidylcholine, and cholesterol and the inner leaf of phosphatidylethanolamine, phosphatidylserine, phosphatidylcholine, and cholesterol. Their relative compositions are taken from experiment; the cholesterol freely interchanges between leaves. Fluctuations in local composition are coupled to fluctuations in the local membrane curvature, as in the Leibler-Andelman mechanism. Structure factors of components in both leaves display a peak at nonzero wavevector. This indicates that the disordered fluid membrane is characterized by structure of the corresponding wavelength. The scale is given by membrane properties: its bending modulus and its surface tension, which arises from the membrane’s connections to the cytoskeleton. From measurements on the plasma membrane, this scale is on the order of 100 nm. We find that the membrane can be divided into two different kinds of domains that differ not only in their composition but also in their curvature. The first domain in the outer, exoplasmic leaf is rich in cholesterol and sphingomyelin, whereas the inner, cytoplasmic leaf is rich in phosphatidylserine and phosphatidylcholine. The second kind of domain is rich in phosphatidylcholine in the outer leaf and in cholesterol and phosphatidylethanolamine in the inner leaf. The theory provides a tenable basis for the origin of structure in the plasma membrane and an illuminating picture of the organization of lipids therein.     

Polymer-induced membrane contraction, phase separation, and fusion via Marangoni flow.

Experiments have shown that the depletion of polymer in the region between two apposed (contacting or nearly contacting) bilayer membranes leads to fusion. In this paper we show theoretically that the addition of nonadsorbing polymer in solution can promote lateral contraction and phase separation of the lipids in the outer monolayers of the membranes exposed to the polymer solution, i.e., outside the contact zone. This initial phase coexistence of higher- and lower-density lipid domains in the outer monolayer results in surface tension gradients in the outer monolayer. Initially, the inner layer lipids are not exposed to the polymer solution and remain in their original "unstressed" state. The differential stresses on the bilayers give rise to a Marangoni flow of lipid from the outer monolayers in the "contact zone" (where there is little polymer and hence a uniform phase) to the outer monolayers in the "reservoir" (where initially the surface tension gradients are large due to the polymer-induced phase separation). As a result, the low-density domains of the outer monolayers in the contact zone expose their hydrophobic chains, and those of the inner monolayers, to the solvent and to each other across the narrow water gap, allowing fusion to occur via a hydrophobic interaction. More generally, this type of mechanism suggests that fusion and other intermembrane interactions may be triggered by Marangoni flows induced by surface tension gradients that provide "action at a distance" far from the fusion or interaction zone.     

Bilayer balance and regulation of red cell shape changes

Discocytic human red cells undergo discocyte-echinocyte and discocytestomatocyte transformations under the action of a wide variety of lipid-soluble anionic and cationic agents respectively. These shape transformations are explained by the bilayer couple hypothesis of Sheetz and Singer to be the result of preferential distribution of the anionic agents in the outer half of the bilayer and the cationic agents in the inner half of the bilayer. We demonstrate that echinocytogenic effects indeed occur when the naturally occurring phospholipid lysophosphatidylcholine (LPC) is localized in the outer half of the bilayer, and stomatocytogenic effects occur when LPC is in the inner half. However, in contrast to the bilayer couple hypothesis, our results show that simple equivalent membrane surface area expansion on each layer is insufficient to maintain the discocytic shape and there exists a differential concentration effect of LPC on the two halves of the bilayer.     

Histochemistry, ultrastructure and possible significance of dead parenchyma cells with specialized walls in the leaf and rhizome of Sansevieria

Abstract. The internal parenchyma of the leaf and rhizome in 36 species of Sansevieria is made of dead cells and living cells arranged in a regular pattern. Intercellular spaces are lacking. The walls of dead cells consist of an inner amorphous layer positive to the fluorescence test for callose, a middle suberin-like layer and an outer fibrillar layer. In about half of the species examined, the inner layer forms distinctive thickenings. Detached leaves of Sansevieria lose water very slowly, and are able to recover it quickly. The pattern of leaf dehydration appears to be related to leaf morphology, whereas no relation is evident between the pattern of leaf rehydration and leaf morphology. Neither leaf dehydration nor leaf rehydration pattern is affected by the presence of wall thickenings in the dead parenchyma cells. The fresh weight per unit volume of both turgid and droughted leaves is nearly 1, denoting that the dead cells are filled with water and do not undergo substantial cavitation during drought. The data indicate that the dead parenchyma cells of Sansevieria are a specialized water-storing system.     

Coupling of cholesterol-rich lipid phases in asymmetric bilayers

We showed previously that cholesterol-rich liquid-ordered domains with lipid compositions typically found in the outer leaflet of plasma membranes induce liquid-ordered domains in adjacent regions of asymmetric lipid bilayers with apposed leaflets composed of typical inner leaflet lipid mixtures [Kiessling, V., Crane, J. M., and Tamm, L. K. (2006) Biophys. J. 91, 3313-26]. To further examine the nature of transbilayer couplings in asymmetric cholesterol-rich lipid bilayers, the effects on the lipid phase behavior in asymmetric bilayers of different lipid compositions were investigated. We established systems containing several combinations of natural extracted and synthetic lipids that exhibited coexisting liquid-ordered (lo) and liquid-disordered (ld) domains in a supported bilayer format. We find that lo phase domains are induced in all quaternary inner leaflet combinations composed of PCs, PEs, PSs, and cholesterol. Ternary mixtures of PCs/PEs/Chol, PCs/PSs/Chol also exhibit lo phases adjacent to outer leaflet lo phases. However, with the exception of brain PC extracts, binary PC/Chol mixtures are not induced to form lo phases by adjacent outer leaflet lo phases. Higher melting lipid ad-mixtures of PEs and PSs are needed for lo phase induction in the inner leaflet. It appears that the phase behavior of the inner leaflet mixtures is dominated by the intrinsic chain melting temperatures of the lipid components, rather than by their specific headgroup classes. In addition, similar studies with synthetic, completely saturated lipids and cholesterol show that lipid oxidation is not a factor in the observed phase behavior.     

Transbilayer effects of raft-like lipid domains in asymmetric planar bilayers measured by single molecule tracking

Cell membranes have complex lipid compositions, including an asymmetric distribution of phospholipids between the opposing leaflets of the bilayer. Although it has been demonstrated that the lipid composition of the outer leaflet of the plasma membrane is sufficient for the formation of raft-like liquid-ordered (l(o)) phase domains, the influence that such domains may have on the lipids and proteins of the inner leaflet remains unknown. We used tethered polymer supports and a combined Langmuir-Blodgett/vesicle fusion (LB/VF) technique to build asymmetric planar bilayers that mimic plasma membrane asymmetry in many ways. We show that directly supported LB monolayers containing cholesterol-rich l(o) phases are inherently unstable when exposed to water or vesicle suspensions. However, tethering the LB monolayer to the solid support with the lipid-anchored polymer 1,2-dimyristoyl phophatidylethanolamine-N-[poly(ethylene glycol)-triethoxysilane] significantly improves stability and allows for the formation of complex planar-supported bilayers that retain >90% asymmetry for 1-2 h. We developed a single molecule tracking (SPT) system for the study of lipid diffusion in asymmetric bilayers with coexisting liquid phases. SPT allowed us to study in detail the diffusion of individual lipids inside, outside, or directly opposed to l(o) phase domains. We show here that l(o) phase domains in one monolayer of an asymmetric bilayer do not induce the formation of domains in the opposite leaflet when this leaflet is composed of palmitoyl-oleoyl phosphatidylcholine and cholesterol but do induce domains when this leaflet is composed of porcine brain phosphatidylcholine, phosphatidylethanolamine, phosphatidylserine, and cholesterol. The diffusion of lipids is similar in l(o) and liquid-disordered phase domains and is not affected by transbilayer coupling, indicating that lateral and transverse lipid interactions that give rise to the domain structure are weak in the biological lipid mixtures that were employed in this work.     

Ionic control of the metastable inner leaflet of the plasma membrane: Fusions natural and artefactual

The phospholipids of the inner and outer leaflets of the plasma membrane face chemically very different environments, and are specialized to serve different needs. While lipids of the outer leaflet are inherently stable in a lamellar (bilayer) phase, the main lipid of the inner layer, phosphatidylethanolamine (PE), does not form a lamellar phase unless evenly mixed with phosphatidylserine (PS⁻). This mixture can be readily perturbed by factors that include an influx of Ca²⁺ that chelates the negatively charged PS⁻, thereby destabilizing PE. The implications of this metastability of the inner leaflet for vesicular trafficking, and experimentally for the isolation of detergent-resistant membrane domains (DRMs) at physiological temperature, are considered.     

Improving our picture of the plasma membrane: Rafts induce ordered domains in a simplified model cytoplasmic leaflet

By study of asymmetric membranes, models of the cell plasma membrane (PM) have improved, with more realistic properties of the asymmetric lipid composition of the membrane being explored. We used hemifusion of symmetric giant unilamellar vesicles (GUVs) with a supported lipid bilayer (SLB) to engineer bilayer leaflets of different composition. During hemifusion, only the outer leaflets of GUV and SLB are connected, exchanging lipids by simple diffusion. aGUVs were detached from the SLB for study. In general these aGUVs are formed with one leaflet that phase-separates into Ld (liquid disordered) + Lo (liquid ordered) phases, and another leaflet with lipid composition that would form a single fluid phase in a symmetric bilayer. We observed that ordered phases of either Lo or Lβ (gel phase) induce an ordered domain in the apposed fluid leaflet that lacks high melting lipids. Results suggest both an inter-leaflet and an intra-leaflet redistribution of cholesterol. We used C-Laurdan spectral images to investigate the lipid packing/order of aGUVs, finding that cholesterol partitions into the induced ordered domains. We suggest this behavior to be commonplace, that when Ld + Lo phase separation occurs in a cell PM exoplasmic leaflet, an induced order domain forms in the cytoplasmic leaflet.     

Transmembrane asymmetry and lateral domains in biological membranes

It is generally assumed that rafts exist in both the external and internal leaflets of the membrane, and that they overlap so that they are coupled functionally and structurally. However, the two monolayers of the plasma membrane of eukaryotic cells have different chemical compositions. This out-of-equilibrium situation is maintained by the activity of lipid translocases, which compensate for the slow spontaneous transverse diffusion of lipids. Thus rafts in the outer leaflet, corresponding to domains enriched in sphingomyelin and cholesterol, cannot be mirrored in the inner cytoplasmic leaflet. The extent to which lipids contribute to raft properties can be conveniently studied in giant unilamellar vesicles. In these, cholesterol can be seen to condense with saturated sphingolipids or phosphatidylcholine to form μm scale domains. However, such rafts fail to model biological rafts because they are symmetric, and because their membranes lack the mechanism that establishes this asymmetry, namely proteins. Biological rafts are in general of nm scale, and almost certainly differ in size and stability in inner and outer monolayers. Any coupling between rafts in the two leaflets, should it occur, is probably transient and dependent not upon the properties of lipids, but on transmembrane proteins within the rafts.     

Lipid lateral diffusion and membrane heterogeneity

The pulsed field gradient (pfg)-NMR method for measurements of translational diffusion of molecules in macroscopically aligned lipid bilayers is described. This technique is proposed to have an appreciable potential for investigations in the field of lipid and membrane biology. Transport of molecules in the plane of the bilayer can be successfully studied, as well as lateral phase separation of lipids and their dynamics within the bilayer organizations. Lateral diffusion coefficients depend on lipid packing and acyl chain ordering and investigations of order parameters of perdeuterated acyl chains, using (2)H NMR quadrupole splittings, are useful complements. In this review we summarize some of our recent achievements obtained on lipid membranes. In particular, bilayers exhibiting two-phase coexistence of liquid disordered (l(d)) and liquid ordered (l(o)) phases are considered in detail. Methods for obtaining good oriented lipid bilayers, necessary for the pfg-NMR method to be efficiently used, are also briefly described. Among our major results, besides determinations of l(d) and l(o) phases, belongs the finding that the lateral diffusion is the same for all components, independent of the molecular structure (including cholesterol (CHOL)), if they reside in the same domain or phase in the membrane. Furthermore, quite unexpectedly CHOL seems to partition into the l(d)and l(o) phases to roughly the same extent, indicating that CHOL has no strong preference for any of these phases, i.e. CHOL seems to have similar interactions with all of the lipids. We propose that the lateral phase separation in bilayers containing one high-T(m) and one low-T(m) lipid together with CHOL is driven by the increasing difficulty of incorporating an unsaturated or prenyl lipid into the highly ordered bilayer formed by a saturated lipid and CHOL, i.e. the phase transition is entropy driven to keep the disorder of the hydrocarbon chains of the unsaturated lipid.     

Domain coupling in asymmetric lipid bilayers

Biological membranes are heterogeneous assemblies of lipids, proteins, and cholesterol that are organized as asymmetric bimolecular leaflets of lipids with embedded proteins. Modulated by the concentration of cholesterol lipids and proteins may segregate into two or more liquid phases with different physical properties that can coexist in the same membrane. In this review, we summarize recent advances on how this situation can be recreated in a supported bilayer format and how this system has been used to demonstrate the induction of ordered lipid domains in lipid compositions that are typical for the inner leaflet by lipid compositions that are typical for the outer leaflet of mammalian plasma membranes. Proteins are shown to differentially target such induced inner leaflet domains.