Estuarine and Tidal Wetland Restoration in the United Kingdom: Policy Versus Practice

Restoration of reclaimed marshes in the United Kingdom, referred to as managed realignment, is both a scientific and a political issue. A cross‐party House of Commons report to Government stressed that provision of long‐term sustainable coastal defenses must start with the premise that “coasts need space” and that government must work to increase public awareness, scientific knowledge, and political will to facilitate such a retreat from the almost sacrosanct existing shoreline. Government, in turn, has agreed with the basis of the report but is aware of conflicting interests, not least the European legislation, which has designated large areas of reclaimed marshes as Special Areas of Conservation that cannot legally be restored to their former tidal processes. Against this background, it is essential that scientific research provides convincing arguments for the necessity for managed realignment, the location, extent, and type of marshlands that need to be restored to provide sustainable flood defenses, maintain and enhance conservation status, and ensure a healthy functioning estuarine system. We examine the political and scientific issues involved, discuss model predictions and field experiments into realignment techniques, and outline the preliminary results of such experiments showing the evolution of restored intertidal wetlands in the United Kingdom.     

The challenge of restoring vegetation on tidal,hypersaline substrates

Hypersaline tidal wetland restoration sites are challenging to vegetate, and the specific factors responsible for transplant mortality are difficult to pinpoint. Two southern California sites (Tidal Linkage and Friendship Marsh), planted as large field experiments, had differential transplant survival (93% for a 1997 planting at the first site, and 10% for a 2000 planting in the second site). Multiple stresses (high salinity, sediment deposition, algal smothering and animal activity) are implicated as the cause of mortality in the experimental plantings. Greater hypersalinity and sedimentation appeared to be a function of site context, with greater sediment inflows and salt concentration over the larger (8-ha) marsh plain at the Friendship Marsh. Species differed in establishment rates among sites and years; the regional dominant, Salicornia virginica, performed best as a transplant and in volunteer seedling recruitment in the Tidal Linkage; hence, it was not planted at the larger site, where it has recruited without assistance. Frankenia salina had high survival in the 2000–2001 plantings; this species is also widespread in the region. Our attempts to restore salt marsh plain vegetation in Southern California led to greater appreciation of the importance of environmental stress and stochastic events and their potential for interaction. Hypersalinity and other factors are extremely difficult to ameliorate, especially in large restoration sites.     

盐沼湿地大规模恢复的概念生态模型——以盐城为例

大规模湿地生态恢复是一项耗资巨大、复杂的系统工程,需要以整个区域湿地结构和功能恢复作为基本目标,将时间和空间上分散的研究成果进行系统梳理,形成对区域湿地生态变化及其驱动因素的规律性认识。本研究以盐城盐沼湿地为案例,以1987年作为未干扰或干扰较少的状态,从结构-过程-功能耦合作用角度,确定区域湿地恢复的关键生态特征,包括:健康与动态潮间带湿地系统、碱蓬生态系统生产力与弹性、复杂景观镶嵌与相互作用、潮间带底栖动物丰富与鸟类觅食基地,以及濒危与关键水鸟种群保护。在此基础上,将围垦与土地利用、水管理、全球变化与海平面上升作为驱动区域湿地生态变化的三大外部因素;海岸侵蚀与沉积、区域水格局变化、地形地貌变化、湿地空间变化与连通性丧失,以及互花米草入侵等是影响湿地生态系统变化的内在压力因子;基于这些压力因子与湿地生态系统变化之间复杂作用关系分析,形成了外部驱动力-内在压力源-生态影响-生态特征之间联合作用下的区域湿地恢复概念生态模型。此模型以复杂因果关系研究为基础,直观展示了湿地恢复需要去除或减缓各种压力因子的一般路径,有利于指导大规模盐沼湿地恢复规划与实践。     

重建沿海韧性——旧金山湾盐沼修复及其启示

潮洪灾害、海平面上升已促使沿海城市由“抵御”向“适应”转变。通过修复盐沼提高海岸防护的韧性,已被认可是一种有效的适应对策。选取旧金山湾为案例,基于文献和实地调研,探究城市盐沼修复的实践路径和设计方法。研究表明,适应性管理是旧金山湾三代修复实践得以不断优化、发展的关键,帮助制定、调整目标和方法,弹性应对不确定性;旧金山湾通过发展修复设计导则,加速盐沼修复,促进形成更自然的盐沼;并修复过渡区,提供盐沼向内陆迁移的空间,缓解海岸挤迫。最后,提出中国河口海岸城市实施盐沼修复的可借鉴之处,推进海岸防护措施向基于自然的途径转变。     

滨海盐沼湿地有机碳的沉积与埋藏研究进展

滨海盐沼湿地有着较高的碳沉积速率和固碳能力,在缓解全球变暖方面发挥着重要作用,而盐渍土壤是滨海盐沼湿地碳收支研究中最大的有机碳库,研究其碳沉积与埋藏对于理解滨海湿地碳收支有着重要的意义.本文从滨海盐沼湿地土壤有机碳的来源、土壤有机碳库与沉积速率、盐沼湿地有机碳的埋藏机制、全球变化与滨海盐沼湿地碳封存等几方面对滨海盐沼湿地有机碳沉积与埋藏的相关研究进行综述.今后研究应侧重:1)加强对控制滨海盐沼湿地碳储存变异的基本因素的迸一步研究;2)对测量滨海盐沼湿地沉积物碳储量和沉积碳埋藏速率的方法进行标准化;3)对潮汐影响下滨海盐沼湿地碳与邻近生态系统之间的横向交换通量进行量化;4)探明全球变暖的影响和生产力的提高是否可以抵消因呼吸增强而造成的有机碳降解速率的升高.确定固碳速率变化驱动因子,理解气候变化和人类活动对碳埋藏的影响机制,有助于提升我国滨海盐沼湿地的固碳能力.     

The Effect of Zostera noltii, Spartina maritima and Scirpus maritimus on Sediment Pore-water Profiles in a Temperate Intertidal Estuary

The objective of the present work was to study the effect of plants common in temperate latitudes (Zostera noltii, Spartina maritima and Scirpus maritimus) on sediment nutrient profiles, and to compare it to sand- and mud-flats without vegetation. The study focused on the organic matter contents, the concentration of dissolved inorganic nutrients (PO₄–P, NH₃–N, NO₃–N), an on the estimation of the total amount of these nutrients during day and night conditions and their potential net-fluxes. It was also hypothesised that in an estuarine system, different plants may have specific effects, and consequently different contributions to the system nutrient dynamics as a whole. Sediment profiles of loss on ignition (LOI) showed an increase of the organic matter contents from sand-flat, to Zostera, Spartina, mud-flat and Scirpus. Statistically, there were significant differences between sediment profiles of phosphate, ammonia and nitrate (Mann-Whitney test, p<0.05), during day and night periods. These results suggest that there is an intense mobility of nutrients in the sediment, showing a day-night variation of nutrient concentrations in the pore-water. In the plants’ rhizosphere, the day-night variation of nutrients seemed dependent on plant biomass and penetration of the roots. Additionally, coupling between plant and sediment seems to be a species-specific process. In spring, Scirpus salt marsh reaches the maximum density and biomass, and despite the higher organic matter contents in the plant covered sediment, Scirpus acts as a sink of nutrients. In contrast, the top 10 cm of the sediment in the Spartina salt marsh and in the Zostera beds may contribute to the efflux of nutrients during the night period, especially phosphate.     

Coastal vegetation on the Western, Southern, and Eastern coasts of South Korea

We used the Braun-Blanquet method to study the vegetation of coastal wetlands in South Korea. Three habitat types were found, i.e., salt marshes, salt swamps, and sand dunes. These plant communities were classified as: 1) two groups (five associations each) in the salt marshes that comprised either annual herbaceous halophytes (ClassThero-Salicornietea), or biennial/perennial herbaceous species (ClassAsteretea tripolii); 2) one group in the salt swamps consisting of five hydrophilous halo-tolerant associations (ClassPhragmitetea); and 3) three groups in the sand dunes, including one association of annual herbaceous halophytes (ClassSalsoletea komarovii), seven associations of herbaceous perennial halophytes (ClassGlehnietea littoralis), and one association of shrub perennial halophytes (ClassVrticetea rotundifoliae). These three habitat types accounted for the majority of the six main classifications of coastal vegetation distributed in South Korea.     

Restoration principles emerging from one of the world's largest tidal marsh restoration projects

One of the world's largest tidal wetland restorationprojects was conceived to offset the loss of nekton toonce-through cooling at a power plant on Delaware Bay,USA. An aggregated food chain model was employed toestimate the area of tidal salt marsh required toreplace these losses. The 5040 ha was comprised of twodegraded marsh types – Phragmites- dominatedmarshes and diked salt hay farms – at elevenlocations in oligo-mesohaline and polyhaline reachesof the estuary. At a series of summits convened withnoted experts in the field, it was decided to apply anecological engineering approach (i.e., self design,and minimal intrusion) in a landscape ecologyframework to the restoration designs while at the sametime monitoring long-term success of the project inthe context of a bound of expectation. The latterencompassed a range of reference marsh planforms andacceptable end-points established interactively withtwo advisory committees, numerous resource agencies,the permitting agency and multiple-stakeholder groups.In addition to the technical recommendations providedby the project's advisors, public health and safety,property protection and public access to the restoredsites were a constant part of the dialogue between theutility, its consulting scientists and theresource/permitting agencies. Adaptive management wasused to maintain the restoration trajectories, ensurethat success criteria were met in a timely fashion,and to protect the public against potential effects ofsalt intrusion into wells and septic systems, andagainst upland flooding. Herbicide spray, followed byprescribed burns and altered microtopography were usedat Phragmites-dominated sites, and excavation ofhigher order channels and dike breaching were themethods used to initiate the restorations at the dikedsalt hay farms. Monitoring consisted of evaluating therate of re-vegetation and redevelopment of naturaldrainage networks, nekton response to therestorations, and focused research on nutrient flux,nekton movements, condition factors, trophic linkages,and other specific topics. Because of its size anduniqueness, the Estuary Enhancement Program as thisproject is known, has become an important case studyfor scientists engaged in restoration ecology and theapplication of ecological engineering principles. Thehistory of this project, and ultimately theRestoration Principles that emerged from it, are thesubjects of this paper. By documenting the pathways tosuccess, it is hoped that other restoration ecologistsand practitioners will benefit from the experiences wehave gained.     

Below-ground biomass in healthy and impaired salt marshes

Twelve salt marshes in south Louisiana (USA) were classified as either impaired or healthy before a summer sample collection of above- and below-ground biomass and determination of sediment accretion rates. The above-ground biomass of plant tissues was the same at both impaired and healthy salt marshes and was not a good predictor of marsh health. However, below-ground root biomass in the upper 30cm was much lower in the impaired marshes compared to the healthy marshes. Compromises to root production apparently occur before there is an obvious consequence to the above-ground biomass, which may quickly collapse before remedial action can be taken. The subsequent change in vertical position of the marsh surface may be equivalent to many years of accretion, and be irreversible within decades without considerable effort. These results are consistent with the hypothesis that it is the plants below-ground accumulation of organic matter, not inorganic matter that governs the maintenance of salt marsh ecosystem in the vertical plane. Reversing the precursor conditions leading to marsh stress before the collapse of the above-ground biomass occurs is therefore a prudent management objective and could be easier than restoration.     

基于比较优势分析法的冬小麦产量差异

在农户调查基础上,采用比较优势分析法对曲周县2003—2004年度冬小麦产量差异进行分析.调查数据表明,地块间小麦产量差异较大,产量范围为在4.2～7.9 t·hm-²,变异系数为0.14.通过逐步回归建立的由土壤盐碱度、土壤肥力、是否咸水灌溉、品种选择、返青期追施氮肥类型、播种时间、病虫害防治和返青期是否水分胁迫8个因子构成的产量差模型可以解释63%的产量差异.其中土壤盐碱度、土壤肥力和是否咸水灌溉是冬小麦的主要产量限制因子,其引起的产量差为727 kg·hm^-2,占总模拟产量差的52%.小麦品种引起的产量差为202.1 kg·hm^-2,占总模拟产量差的14%.播种时间、返青期追施氮肥类型、病虫害防治和返青期是否水分胁迫4个因子引起的产量差分别占总模拟产量差的7%、14%、10%和3%.因此,除土壤和气候状况外,管理措施也是造成产量差异的重要因素,通过优化管理措施可以大大减小产量差异.     

滨海盐沼湿地有机碳的沉积与埋藏研究进展

滨海盐沼湿地有着较高的碳沉积速率和固碳能力,在缓解全球变暖方面发挥着重要作用,而盐渍土壤是滨海盐沼湿地碳收支研究中最大的有机碳库,研究其碳沉积与埋藏对于理解滨海湿地碳收支有着重要的意义.本文从滨海盐沼湿地土壤有机碳的来源、土壤有机碳库与沉积速率、盐沼湿地有机碳的埋藏机制、全球变化与滨海盐沼湿地碳封存等几方面对滨海盐沼湿地有机碳沉积与埋藏的相关研究进行综述.今后研究应侧重:1)加强对控制滨海盐沼湿地碳储存变异的基本因素的进一步研究;2)对测量滨海盐沼湿地沉积物碳储量和沉积碳埋藏速率的方法进行标准化;3)对潮汐影响下滨海盐沼湿地碳与邻近生态系统之间的横向交换通量进行量化;4)探明全球变暖的影响和生产力的提高是否可以抵消因呼吸增强而造成的有机碳降解速率的升高.确定固碳速率变化驱动因子,理解气候变化和人类活动对碳埋藏的影响机制,有助于提升我国滨海盐沼湿地的固碳能力.