The structure of cyanine 5 terminally attached to double-stranded DNA: implications for FRET studies

Fluorescence resonance energy transfer, FRET, can be used to obtain long-range distance information for macromolecules and is particularly powerful when used in single-molecule studies. The determination of accurate distances requires knowledge of the fluorophore position with respect to the macromolecule. In this study we have used NMR to determine the structure of the commonly used fluorophore indocarbocyanine-5 (Cy5) covalently attached to the 5'-terminus of double-helical DNA. We find that Cy5 is predominantly stacked onto the end of the duplex, in a manner similar to an additional base pair. This is very similar to the behavior of Cy3 terminally attached to DNA and suggests that the efficiency of energy transfer between Cy3 and Cy5, that are attached to nucleic acids in this way, will exhibit significant dependence on fluorophore orientation.     

The structure of sulfoindocarbocyanine 3 terminally attached to dsDNA via a long, flexible tether

Fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) is an important source of long-range distance information in macromolecules. However, extracting maximum information requires knowledge of fluorophore, donor and acceptor, positions on the macromolecule. We previously determined the structure of the indocarbocyanine fluorophores Cy3 and Cy5 attached to DNA via three-carbon atom tethers, showing that they stacked onto the end of the helix in a manner similar to an additional basepair. Our recent FRET study has suggested that when they are attached via a longer 13-atom tether, these fluorophores are repositioned relative to the terminal basepair by a rotation of ～30°, while remaining stacked. In this study, we have used NMR to extend our structural understanding to the commonly used fluorophore sulfoindocarbocyanine-3 (sCy3) attached to the 5'-terminus of the double-helical DNA via a 13-atom flexible tether (L13). We find that L13-sCy3 remains predominantly stacked onto the end of the duplex, but adopts a significantly different conformation, from that of either Cy3 or Cy5 attached by 3-atom tethers, with the long axes of the fluorophore and the terminal basepair approximately parallel. This result is in close agreement with our FRET data, supporting the contention that FRET data can be used to provide orientational information.     

Long range molecular wire behaviour in a metal complex of DNA

M-DNA is a complex of metal ions such as Zn(2+) with duplex DNA. Previous results showed that the fluorescence of a donor fluorophore was quenched when an acceptor fluorophore was placed at the opposite end of a short M-DNA duplex. In order to investigate further the molecular wire behaviour of M-DNA, 30-mer duplexes were constructed with fluorescein as donor and rhodamine, pyrene and the cyanine dyes, Cy5 and Cy5.5 as acceptors. Good quenching was observed in all cases even though the efficiency of resonance energy transfer was calculated to be < 5%. The distance dependence of quenching was investigated by preparing doubly-labelled duplexes ranging in length from 20 to 1,000 base pairs. Upon formation of M-DNA significant quenching of the fluorescence of the donor fluorophore was observed in duplexes up to 500 base pairs in length. The amount of quenching decreased with increasing length of the duplexes with a shallow distance dependence. The results are consistent with an electron transfer mechanism in which the electron hops between metal centers. This process can occur efficiently over long distances.     

The estimation of distances between specific backbone-labeled sites in DNA using fluorescence resonance energy transfer.

A series DNA helices of twenty-four base pairs has been prepared for the study of fluorescence resonance energy transfer. Each of the DNA helices contains two phosphorothioate diesters (one in each strand) at pre-selected sites for introduction of the desired donor and acceptor fluorophores. The phosphorothioate-containing oligodeoxynucleotides have been prepared as pure Rp or Sp derivatives or as deastereomeric mixtures. Fluorescein and eosin are employed as the respective donor and acceptor fluorophores. A series of donor-acceptor pairs was generated by labeling of the appropriate phosphorothioate diester with the desired fluorophore and annealing the two complementary DNA strands (one containing the acceptor and one containing the donor fluorophore) to form the double-stranded helix. The 24-mer helices containing two covalently attached fluorophores exhibited some thermal destabilization and the extent of this destabilization was dependent upon the stereochemical orientation of the fluorophore. The Sp derivatives direct the fluorophore out, away from the the DNA helix, while the Rp derivatives direct the fluorophore toward the major groove. As expected, the Sp labeled duplexes were more stable than the corresponding Rp labeled sequences. However, all of the duplex structures formed were stable under the conditions used to measure energy transfer. Energy transfer could be observed with these complexes from the quenching of the donor fluorescence in the presence of the acceptor fluorophore. Using F?rster's theories, distances separating the fluorophores could be calculated that were generally in reasonable agreement with the distances expected in an idealized B-form DNA helix. However anomalous results were obtained for one donor/acceptor pair where the expected distance was less than 20 A. Fluorescence anisotropy values determined in solutions of varying viscosity were quite high suggesting that the fluorophores did not experience complete freedom of movement when attached to the DNA helix.     

The Effect of Dye-Dye Interactions on the Spatial Resolution of Single-Molecule FRET Measurements in Nucleic Acids

We study the effect of dye-dye interactions in labeled double-stranded DNA molecules on the Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) efficiency at the single-molecule level. An extensive analysis of internally labeled double-stranded DNA molecules in bulk and at the single-molecule level reveals that donor-acceptor absolute distances can be reliably extracted down to ∼3-nm separation, provided that dye-dye quenching is accounted for. At these short separations, we find significant long-lived fluorescence fluctuations among discrete levels originating from the simultaneous and synchronous quenching of both dyes. By comparing four different donor-acceptor dye pairs (TMR-ATTO647N, Cy3-ATTO647N, TMR-Cy5, and Cy3-Cy5), we find that this phenomenon depends on the nature of the dye pair used, with the cyanine pair Cy3-Cy5 showing the least amount of fluctuations. The significance of these results is twofold: First, they illustrate that when dye-dye quenching is accounted for, single-molecule FRET can be used to accurately measure inter-dye distances, even at short separations. Second, these results are useful when deciding which dye pairs to use for nucleic acids analyses using FRET.     

Fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) and competing processes in donor-acceptor substituted DNA strands: a comparative study of ensemble and single-molecule data

We studied the fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) efficiency of different donor-acceptor labeled model DNA systems in aqueous solution from ensemble measurements and at the single molecule level. The donor dyes: tetramethylrhodamine (TMR); rhodamine 6G (R6G); and a carbocyanine dye (Cy3) were covalently attached to the 5'-end of a 40-mer model oligonucleotide. The acceptor dyes, a carbocyanine dye (Cy5), and a rhodamine derivative (JA133) were attached at modified thymidine bases in the complementary DNA strand with donor-acceptor distances of 5, 15, 25 and 35 DNA-bases, respectively. Anisotropy measurements demonstrate that none of the dyes can be observed as a free rotor; especially in the 5-bp constructs the dyes exhibit relatively high anisotropy values. Nevertheless, the dyes change their conformation with respect to the oligonucleotide on a slower time scale in the millisecond range. This results in a dynamic inhomogeneous distribution of donor/acceptor (D/A) distances and orientations. FRET efficiencies have been calculated from donor and acceptor fluorescence intensity as well as from time-resolved fluorescence measurements of the donor fluorescence decay. Dependent on the D/A pair and distance, additional strong fluorescence quenching of the donor is observed, which simulates lower FRET efficiencies at short distances and higher efficiencies at longer distances. On the other hand, spFRET measurements revealed subpopulations that exhibit the expected FRET efficiency, even at short D/A distances. In addition, the measured acceptor fluorescence intensities and lifetimes also partly show fluorescence quenching effects independent of the excitation wavelength, i.e. either directly excited or via FRET. These effects strongly depend on the D/A distance and the dyes used, respectively. The obtained data demonstrate that besides dimerization at short D/A distances, an electron transfer process between the acceptor Cy5 and rhodamine donors has to be taken into account. To explain deviations from FRET theory even at larger D/A distances, we suggest that the pi-stack of the DNA double helix mediates electron transfer from the donor to the acceptor, even over distances as long as 35 base pairs. Our data show that FRET experiments at the single molecule level are rather suited to resolve fluorescent subpopulations in heterogeneous mixture, information about strongly quenched subpopulations gets lost.     

DFT study of the interaction between the conjugated fluorescein and dabcyl system, using fluorescene quenching method

Molecular beacon is a DNA probe containing a sequence complementary to the target that is flanked by self-complementary termini, and carries a fluorophore and a quencher at the ends. We used the fluorescein and dabcyl as fluorophore and quencher respectively, and studied with DFT calculations at the GGA/DNP level, and taking into account DFT dispersion corrections by the Grimme and Tkatchenko-Scheffler (TS) schemes, the distance, where the most favorable energetic interaction between the fluorophore and quencher in conjugated form occurs. This distance occurs at a separation distance of 29.451?? between the centers of Dabcyl and fluorescein employing the TS DFT dispersion correction scheme, indicating FRET efficiency around 94.28?%. The calculated emission spectra of the conjugated pair in water indicated that the emission and absorption spectrum overlap completely and thus no fluorescence can be observed due to the fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) effect. The DFT results confirmed the experimentally observing fluorescence quenching of the fluorescein-dabcyl conjugated system by FRET.     

Development of a novel FRET immunosensor technique

We report on a novel technique to develop an optical immunosensor based on fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET). IgG antibodies were labeled with acceptor fluorophores while one of three carrier molecules (protein A, protein G, or F(ab')2 fragment) was labeled with donor fluorophores. The carrier molecule was incubated with the antibody to allow specific binding to the Fc portion. The labeled antibody-protein complex was then exposed to specific and nonspecific antigens, and experiments were designed to determine the 'in solution' response. The paper reports the results of three different donor-acceptor FRET pairs, fluorescein isothiocyanate/tetramethylrhodamine isothiocyanate, Texas Red/Cy5, and Alexa Fluor 546/Alexa Fluor 594. The effects of the fluorophore to protein conjugation ratio (F/P ratio) and acceptor to donor fluorophore ratios between the antibody and protein (A/D ratio) were examined. In the presence of specific antigens, the antibodies underwent a conformational change, resulting in an energy transfer from the donor to the acceptor fluorophore as measured by a change in fluorescence. The non-specific antigens elicited little or no changes. The Alexa Fluor FRET pair demonstrated the largest change in fluorescence, resulting in a 35% change. The F/P and A/D ratio will affect the efficiency of energy transfer, but there exists a suitable range of A/D and F/P ratios for the FRET pairs. The feasibility of the FRET immunosensor technique was established; however, it will be necessary to immobilize the complexes onto optical substrates so that consistent trends can be obtained that would allow calibration plots.     

Imaging protein-protein interactions using fluorescence resonance energy transfer microscopy

Fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) detects the proximity of fluorescently labeled molecules over distances >100 A. When performed in a fluorescence microscope, FRET can be used to map protein-protein interactions in vivo. We here describe a FRET microscopy method that can be used to determine whether proteins that are colocalized at the level of light microscopy interact with one another. This method can be implemented using digital microscopy systems such as a confocal microscope or a wide-field fluorescence microscope coupled to a charge-coupled device (CCD) camera. It is readily applied to samples prepared with standard immunofluorescence techniques using antibodies labeled with fluorescent dyes that act as a donor and acceptor pair for FRET. Energy transfer efficiencies are quantified based on the release of quenching of donor fluorescence due to FRET, measured by comparing the intensity of donor fluorescence before and after complete photobleaching of the acceptor. As described, this method uses Cy3 and Cy5 as the donor and acceptor fluorophores, but can be adapted for other FRET pairs including cyan fluorescent protein and yellow fluorescent protein.     

Fluorescence stopped-flow studies of single turnover kinetics of E.coli RecBCD helicase-catalyzed DNA unwinding

We have developed and optimized a stopped-flow fluorescence assay for use in studying DNA unwinding catalyzed by Escherichia coli RecBCD helicase. This assay monitors changes in fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) between a pair of fluorescent probes (Cy3 donor and Cy5 acceptor) placed on opposite sides of a nick in duplex DNA. As such, this is an "all-or-none" DNA unwinding assay. Single turnover DNA unwinding experiments were performed using a series of eight fluorescent DNA substrates containing duplex DNA regions ranging from 24 bp to 60 bp. The time-courses obtained by monitoring Cy3 fluorescence display a distinct lag phase that increases with increasing duplex DNA length, reflecting the transient formation of partially unwound DNA intermediates. These Cy3 FRET time-courses are identical with those obtained using a chemical quenched-flow kinetic assay developed previously. The signal from the Cy5 fluorescence probe shows additional effects that appear to specifically monitor the RecD helicase subunit. The continuous nature of this fluorescence assay enabled us to acquire more precise time-courses for many more duplex DNA lengths in a significantly reduced amount of time, compared to quenched-flow methods. Global analysis of the Cy3 and Cy5 FRET time-courses, using an n-step sequential DNA unwinding model, indicates that RecBCD unwinds duplex DNA with an average unwinding rate constant of kU = 200(+/-40) steps s(-1) (mkU = 680(+/-12)bp s(-1)) and an average kinetic step size, m = 3.4 (+/-0.6) bp step(-1) (5 mM ATP, 10 mM MgCl(2), 30 mM NaCl, pH 7.0, 5% (v/v) glycerol, 25.0 degrees C), in excellent agreement with the kinetic parameters determined using quenched-flow techniques. Under these same conditions, the RecBC enzyme unwinds DNA with a very similar rate. These methods will facilitate detailed studies of the mechanisms of DNA unwinding and translocation of the RecBCD and RecBC helicases.     

Probing complexes with single fluorophores: factors contributing to dispersion of FRET in DNA/RNA duplexes

Single molecule fluorescent microscopy is a method for the analysis of the dynamics of biological macromolecules by detecting the fluorescence signal produced by fluorophores associated with the macromolecule. Two fluorophores located in a close proximity may result in Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET), which can be detected at the single molecule level and the efficiency of energy transfer calculated. In most cases, the experimentally observed distribution of FRET efficiency exhibits a significant width corresponding to 0.07–0.2 (on a scale of 0–1). Here, we present a general approach describing the analysis of experimental data for a DNA/RNA duplex. We have found that for a 15 bp duplex with Cy3 and Cy5 fluorophores attached to the opposite ends of the helix, the width of the energy transfer distribution is mainly determined by the photon shot noise and the orientation factor, whereas the variation of inter-dye distances plays a minor role.     

Orientation of cyanine fluorophores terminally attached to DNA via long, flexible tethers

Cyanine fluorophores are commonly used in single-molecule FRET experiments with nucleic acids. We have previously shown that indocarbocyanine fluorophores attached to the 5′-termini of DNA and RNA via three-carbon atom linkers stack on the ends of the helix, orienting their transition moments. We now investigate the orientation of sulfoindocarbocyanine fluorophores tethered to the 5′-termini of DNA via 13-atom linkers. Fluorescence lifetime measurements of sulfoindocarbocyanine 3 attached to double-stranded DNA indicate that the fluorophore is extensively stacked onto the terminal basepair at 15°C, with properties that depend on the terminal sequence. In single molecules of duplex DNA, FRET efficiency between sulfoindocarbocyanine 3 and 5 attached in this manner is modulated with helix length, indicative of fluorophore orientation and consistent with stacked fluorophores that can undergo lateral motion. We conclude that terminal stacking is an intrinsic property of the cyanine fluorophores irrespective of the length of the tether and the presence or absence of sulfonyl groups. However, compared to short-tether indocarbocyanine, the mean rotational relationship between the two fluorophores is changed by ∼60° for the long-tether sulfoindocarbocyanine fluorophores. This is consistent with the transition moments becoming approximately aligned with the long axis of the terminal basepair for the long-linker species.     

Structural study of DNA duplexes containing the (6–4) photoproduct by fluorescence resonance energy transfer

Fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) experiments have been performed to elucidate the structural features of oligonucleotide duplexes containing the pyrimidine(6–4)pyrimidone photoproduct, which is one of the major DNA lesions formed at dipyrimidine sites by UV light. Synthetic 32mer duplexes with and without the (6–4) photoproduct were prepared and fluorescein and tetramethylrhodamine were attached, as a donor and an acceptor, respectively, to the aminohexyl linker at the C5 position of thymine in each strand. Steady-state and time-resolved analyses revealed that both the FRET efficiency and the fluorescence lifetime of the duplex containing the (6–4) photoproduct were almost identical to those of the undamaged duplex, while marked differences were observed for a cisplatin-modified duplex, as a model of kinked DNA. Lifetime measurements of a series of duplexes containing the (6–4) photoproduct, in which the fluorescein position was changed systematically, revealed a small unwinding at the damage site, but did not suggest a kinked structure. These results indicate that formation of the (6–4) photoproduct induces only a small change in the DNA structure, in contrast to the large kink at the (6–4) photoproduct site reported in an NMR study.     

Evaluation of fluorescent compound interference in 4 fluorescence polarization assays: 2 kinases, 1 protease,and 1 phosphatase

With the increasing use of fluorescence-based assays in high-throughput screening (HTS), the possibility of interference by fluorescent compounds needs to be considered. To investigate compound interference, a well-defined sample set of biologically active compounds, LOPAC, was evaluated using 4 fluorescein-based fluorescence polarization (FP) assays. Two kinase assays, a protease assay, and a phosphatase assay were studied. Fluorescent compound interference and light scattering were observed in both mixture- and single-compound testing under certain circumstances. In the kinase assays, which used low levels (1-3 nM) of fluorophore, an increase in total fluorescence, an abnormal decrease in mP readings, and negative inhibition values were attributed to compound fluorescence. Light scattering was observed by an increase in total fluorescence and minimal reduction in mP, leading to false positives. The protease and phosphatase assays, which used a higher concentration of fluorophore (20-1200 nM) than the kinase assays, showed minimal interference from fluorescent compounds, demonstrating that an increase in the concentration of the fluorophore minimized potential fluorescent compound interference. The data also suggests that mixtures containing fluorescent compounds can result in either false negatives that can mask a potential "hit" or false positives, depending on the assay format. Cy dyes (e.g., Cy3B and Cy5 ) excite and emit further into the red region than fluorescein and, when used in place of fluorescein in kinase 1, eliminate fluorescence interference and light scattering by LOPAC compounds. This work demonstrates that fluorescent compound and light scattering interferences can be overcome by increasing the fluorophore concentration in an assay or by using longer wavelength dyes.     

High throughput measurement of duplex, triplex and quadruplex melting curves using molecular beacons and a LightCycler

We have used oligonucleotides containing molecular beacons to determine melting profiles for intramolecular DNA duplexes, triplexes and quadruplexes (tetraplexes). The synthetic oligonucleotides used in these studies contain a fluorophore (fluorescein) and quencher (methyl red) attached either to deoxyribose or to the 5 position of dU. In the folded DNA structures the fluorophore and quencher are in close proximity and the fluorescence is quenched. When the structures melt, the fluorophore and quencher are separated and there is a large increase in fluorescence. These experiments were performed in a Roche LightCycler; this requires small amounts of material (typically 4 pmol oligonucleotide) and can perform 32 melting profiles in parallel. We have used this technique to compare the stability of triplexes containing different base analogues and to confirm the selectivity of a triplex-binding ligand for triplex, rather than duplex, DNA. We have also compared the melting of inter- and intramolecular quadruplexes.     

Global and local dynamics of the U1A polyadenylation inhibition element (PIE) RNA and PIE RNA-U1A complexes

The structure and dynamics of the polyadenylation inhibition element (PIE) RNA, free and bound to the U1A protein, have been examined using time-resolved FRET and 2-aminopurine (2AP) fluorescence. This regulatory RNA, located at the 3' end of the U1A pre-mRNA, adopts a U-shaped structure, with binding sites for a single U1A protein at each bend (box 1 and box 2). The distance between the termini of the arms of the RNA is sensitive to its three-dimensional structure. Using Cy3/Cy5 FRET efficiency to monitor binding of Mg(2+), we show that the PIE RNA binds two Mg(2+) ions, which results in a restriction of its distance distribution of conformations. Local RNA structure probing using 2AP fluorescence shows that the structure of box 2 changes in response to Mg(2+) binding, thus tentatively locating the ion binding sites. Steady-state FRET data show that the distance R between the termini of the PIE RNA stems decreases from 66 A in the free RNA, to 58 A when N-terminal RNA binding domains (RBD1) of U1A are bound, and to 53 A when U1A proteins bind. However, anisotropy measurements indicate that both Cy3 and Cy5 stack on the ends of the RNA. To examine the consequences of the restricted motion of the fluorophores, FRET data are analyzed using two different models of motion and then compared to analogous data from the Cy3/fluorescein FRET pair. We conclude that the error introduced into distance calculations by stacking of the dyes is within the error of our measurements. Distance distributions of the RNA structures show that the intramolecular distance between the arms of the PIE RNA varies on the time scale of the fluorescence measurements; the mean distance is dependent on protein binding, but the breadth of the distributions indicates that the RNA retains structural heterogeneity.     

Factors Affecting the Tailing of Blunt End DNA with Fluorescent Pyrimidine dNTPs

The transferase activity of non-proofreading DNA polymerases is a well-known phenomenon that has been utilized in cloning and sequencing applications. The non-templated addition of modified nucleotides at DNA blunt ends is a potentially useful feature of DNA polymerases that can be used for selective transformation of DNA 3′ ends. In this paper, we characterized the tailing reaction at perfectly matched and mismatched duplex ends with Cy3- and Cy5-modified pyrimidine nucleotides. It was shown that the best DNA tailing substrate does not have a perfect Watson–Crick base pair at the end. Mismatched duplexes with a 3′ dC were the most efficient in the Taq DNA polymerase-catalysed tailing reaction with a Cy5-modified dUTP. We further demonstrated that the arrangement of the dye residue relative to the nucleobase notably affects the outcome of the tailing reaction. A comparative study of labelled deoxycytidine and deoxyuridine nucleotides showed higher efficiency for dUTP derivatives. The non-templated addition of modified nucleotides by Taq polymerase at a duplex blunt end was generally complicated by the pyrophosphorolysis and 5′ exonuclease activity of the enzyme.     

Trajectory of nucleosomal linker DNA studied by fluorescence resonance energy transfer

While the structure of the nucleosome core is known in atomic detail, the precise geometry of the DNA beyond the core particle is still unknown. We have used fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) for determining the end-to-end distance of DNA fragments assembled with histones into nucleosomes. The DNA of a length of 150-220 bp was labeled with rhodamine-X on one end and fluorescein or Alexa 488 on the other. Assembling nucleosomes on these DNA fragments leads to a measurable energy transfer. The end-to-end distance computed from the FRET increases from 60 +/- 5 A at 150 bp to 75 +/- 5 A at 170 bp without measurable change above it. These distances are compatible with different geometries of the linker DNA, all having in common that no crossing can be observed up to 220 bp. Addition of H1 histone leads to an increase in energy transfer, indicating a compaction of the linker DNA toward the nucleosome.     

Errors in RNA NOESY distance measurements in chimeric and hybrid duplexes: differences in RNA and DNA proton relaxation.

Nuclear magnetic resonance experiments reveal that the base H8/H6 protons of oligoribonucleotides (RNA) have T1 relaxation times that are distinctly longer than those of oligodeoxyribonucleotides (DNA). Similarly, the T1 values for the RNA H1' protons are approximately twice those of the corresponding DNA H1' protons. These relaxation differences persist in single duplexes containing covalently linked RNA and DNA segments and cause serious overestimation of distances involving RNA protons in typical NOESY spectra collected with a duty cycle of 2-3 s. NMR and circular dichroism experiments indicate that the segments of RNA maintain their A-form geometry even in the interior of DNA-RNA-DNA chimeric duplexes, suggesting that the relaxation times are correlated with the type of helix topology. The difference in local proton density is the major cause of the longer nonselective T1s of RNA compared to DNA, although small differences in internal motion cannot be completely ruled out. Fortunately, any internal motion differences that might exist are shown to be too small to affect cross-relaxation rates, and therefore reliable distance data can be obtained from time-dependent NOESY data sets provided an adequately long relaxation delay is used. In hybrid or chimeric RNA-DNA duplexes, if the longer RNA relaxation times are not taken into account in the recycle delay of NOESY pulse sequences, serious errors in measuring RNA proton distances are introduced.