Mitochondrial DNA genetic polymorphism in thirteen rice cytoplasmic male sterile lines

Key message

Thirteen rice CMS lines derived from different cytoplasms were classified into eight groups by PCR amplification on mtDNA. The orf79 gene, which causes Boro II CMS, possibly results in Dian1-CMS.

Abstract

Thirteen rice cytoplasmic male sterile (CMS) lines derived from different cytoplasms are widely used for hybrid rice breeding. Based on 27 loci on mitochondrial DNA, including single nucleotide polymorphisms and segmental sequence variations between typical indica and japonica as well as high-polymorphism segmental sequence variations and single nucleotide polymorphisms among rice CMS lines, the 13 rice CMS lines were classified into eight groups: (I) wild-abortive CMS, Indonesian Shuitiangu CMS, K-CMS, Gang CMS, D-CMS and dwarf abortive CMS; (II) Maxie-CMS; (III) Honglian CMS; (IV) Boro II CMS; (V) Dian1-CMS; (VI) Liao-CMS; (VII) Lead CMS; and (VIII) Chinese wild rice CMS. According to their pollen abortion phenotypes, groups I and II (including 7 CMS lines) were classified as sporophytic CMS lines, the cytoplasmic genetic relationships among which were very close. They could have originated from similar, or even the same, cytoplasm donors. Groups III–VIII (including 6 CMS lines) were categorized as gametophytic CMS lines, the cytoplasms of which differed from one another, with some having relatively far genetic relationships. Dian1-CMS was found to harbor the orf79 gene, which causes Boro II CMS, whereas Liao-CMS had an orf79 structure that does not result in Lead CMS. Therefore, we speculated that orf79 is associated with Dian1-CMS but not with Liao-CMS. The atp6–orf79 structure related to sterility was also found to experience multiple evolutionary turnovers. All sporophytic CMS lines were indica-like. Except the Honglian CMS line, which was indica-like, all gametophytic CMS lines were japonica-like.     

Analyses of mitochondrial DNA structure and expression in three cytoplasmic male-sterile chicories originating from somatic hybridisation between fertile chicory and CMS sunflower protoplasts

Cytoplasmic male-sterile (CMS) chicories have been previously obtained by somatic hybridisation between fertile industrial chicory protoplasts and CMS sunflower protoplasts. In this study, we compared three different CMS chicory cybrids that originated from three different fusion events. The cybrids were backcrossed with different witloof chicories in order to transfer the three male-sterile cytoplasms from an industrial chicory nuclear environment to a witloof chicory nuclear context. Southern hybridisation, using different mitochondrial genes as probes, revealed that the three cybrid mitochondrial genomes were different and that they were stable throughout backcrossing generations regardless of the pollinator. However, pollinators were found to influence floral morphologies – with one being able to restore fertility – showing that nuclear context can affect the sterility of the cybrids. PCR and RFLP analyses revealed that the orf522 sequence, responsiblefor CMS in PET1 sunflower, was present in two out of the three cytoplasms studied, namely 411 and 523, but was absent from the other cytoplasm, 524. We thus concluded that orf522 is not responsible for CMS in the 524 cybrid. Although the orf522 gene is present in the 411 and 523 cytoplasms, it is probably not responsible for the sterile phenotype of these cybrids. Received: 3 June 1998 / Accepted: 30 April 1999     

Emergence of gynodioecy in wild beet (Beta vulgaris ssp. maritima L.): a genealogical approach using chloroplastic nucleotide sequences

Gynodioecy is a breeding system where both hermaphroditic and female individuals coexist within plant populations. This dimorphism is the result of a genomic interaction between maternally inherited cytoplasmic male sterility (CMS) genes and bi-parentally inherited nuclear male fertility restorers. As opposed to other gynodioecious species, where every cytoplasm seems to be associated with male sterility, wild beet Beta vulgaris ssp. maritima exhibits a minority of sterilizing cytoplasms among numerous non-sterilizing ones. Many studies on population genetics have explored the molecular diversity of different CMS cytoplasms, but questions remain concerning their evolutionary dynamics. In this paper we report one of the first investigations on phylogenetic relationships between CMS and non-CMS lineages. We investigated the phylogenetic relationships between 35 individuals exhibiting different mitochondrial haplotypes. Relying on the high linkage disequilibrium between chloroplastic and mitochondrial genomes, we chose to analyse the nucleotide sequence diversity of three chloroplastic fragments (trnK intron, trnD-trnT and trnL-trnF intergenic spacers). Nucleotide diversity appeared to be low, suggesting a recent bottleneck during the evolutionary history of B. vulgaris ssp. maritima. Statistical parsimony analyses revealed a star-like genealogy and showed that sterilizing haplotypes all belong to different lineages derived from an ancestral non-sterilizing cytoplasm. These results suggest a rapid evolution of male sterility in this taxon. The emergence of gynodioecy in wild beet is confronted with theoretical expectations, describing either gynodioecy dynamics as the maintenance of CMS factors through balancing selection or as a constant turnover of new CMSs.     

The structure of sterile cytoplasm types within a maize genebank collection

Maize Research Institute (MRI) gene bank maintains a collection of 6000 maize accessions. Within this collection over 100 sources of cytoplasmic male sterility (CMS) were found in field trials, i.e. more than 2% of the total accession numbers. These sources are distributed among Yugoslav open-pollinated varieties (4.56% of them contain CMS), as well as introduced heterozygous genotypes and inbred lines. In order to identify cytoplasm types the gene-bank sources of CMS were screened using a PCR assay with specific primers for C, T and S cytoplasms. Predominant cytoplasmic male sterility type among the analyzed accessions was CMS-S. Results were inconclusive for three accessions, i.e. different results for the progenies of two ears per accession were obtained. For another two accessions a new PCR product profile was identified, consisting of one band characteristic for CMS-S and one unspecific for any of the three CMS types. The PCR approach enabled a simple, fast and reliable large scale screening of maize cytoplasm among MRI gene bank accessions, significantly reducing time for cytoplasm characterizations compared to classical method of testing with restorers for each known type of CMS.     

Isolation of mitochondrial DNA sequences that distinguish male-sterility-inducing cytoplasms in Sorghum bicolor (L.) Moench

We have demonstrated that sorghum DNA sequences of mitochondrial origin can be used to distinguish different male-sterility-inducing cytoplasms. Six DNA clones containing single-copy mitochondrial sequences were hybridized on Southern blots to restriction enzyme-digested DNA of 28 sorghum lines representing sources of different cytoplasmic male-sterility (CMS) groups. Four cytoplasmic types were defined on the basis of the pattern of DNA fragments detected. Similar analyses of 50 additional diverse sorghum accessions suggested that three of the four cytoplasmic types may be diagnostic for CMS. Also, three other cytoplasmic types were discovered. These and other mitochondrial DNA clones may be useful molecular tools for “fingerprinting” sterility-inducing cytoplasms in breeding programs, determining cytoplasmic diversity among germ plasm accessions, and identifying new sources of cytoplasm that induce male sterility.     

Genetic analyses supported by molecular methods provide evidence of a new genic (st1) and a new cytoplasmic (st2) male sterility in Allium schoenoprasum L.

Spontaneous mutations leading to male sterility have been described for many different crops and are of great importance to hybrid breeding, provided that their inheritance is resolved. This paper describes an efficient method to characterise male sterilities with respect to cytoplasmic factors that might be causally related to them. The differentiation of cytoplasmic (CMS) and genic (GMS) male sterility is achieved by a specific transfer of nuclear male sterility factors to different cytoplasm types which have previously been distinguished by means of RFLP analyses using mitochondrial gene probes. The nuclear sterility factors of Allium schoenoprasum used, st1 and st2, showed a monogenic recessive inheritance in their original cytoplasms. While st1 was expressed in four different cytoplasm types, st2 did not show itself in a cytoplasm type differing from the original. Therefore, the st1-sterility is a GMS, while a cytoplasmic factor is necessary for the occurrence of st2-sterility. This cytoplasmic factor was verified by a reciprocal cross, and the CMS system was completed by the selection of maintainer genotypes. Neither of these new sterilities were influenced by high temperatures or tetracycline. The benefits of a new CMS system to practical breeding and the advantages and disadvantages of the environmental influences on the expression of male sterility are discussed. Received: 24 November 1999 / Accepted: 3 December 1999     

Development of a CMS-specific marker based on chloroplast-derived mitochondrial sequence in pepper

Molecular markers developed from the flanking sequences of two cytoplasmic male sterility (CMS)-associated genes, orf456 and ψatp6-2, have been used for marker-assisted selection of CMS in pepper. However, in practice, the presence of orf456 and ψatp6-2 at substoichiometric levels even in maintainer lines hampers reliable selection of plants containing the CMS gene. In this study, we developed a novel CMS-specific molecular marker, accD-U, for reliable determination of CMS lines in pepper, and used the newly and previously developed markers to determine the cytoplasm types of pepper breeding lines and germplasms. This marker was developed from a deletion in a chloroplast-derived sequence in the mitochondrial genome of a CMS pepper line. CMS pepper lines could be unambiguously determined by presence or absence of the accD-U marker band. Application of orf456, ψatp6-2 and accD-U to various pepper breeding lines and germplasms revealed that accD-U is the most reliable CMS selection marker. A wide distribution of orf456, but not ψatp6-2, in germplasms suggests that the pepper cytoplasm containing both orf456 and ψatp6-2 has been selected as CMS cytoplasm from cytoplasm containing only orf456. Furthermore, factors other than orf456 may be required for the regulation of male sterility in pepper.     

Cytoplasmic male sterility (CMS) in Lolium perenne L.: 1. Development of a diagnostic probe for the male-sterile cytoplasm

Analysis of reciprocal crosses between nonrestoring fertile genotypes and restored male-sterile genotypes of Lolium perenne confirmed the cytoplasmic nature of the sterility trait. This prompted a search for a molecular probe that could be used to distinguish between fertile and cytoplasmic male-sterile (CMS) cytoplasms. We describe the identification and cloning of a 4.5-kb BamHI-HindIII restriction fragment from the mtDNA of the CMS line. The cloned fragment (pCMS45) failed to hybridise to sequences in the mtDNA of fertile lines and was thus capable of unambiguously distinguishing between fertile and CMS cytoplasms. The use of pCMS45 as a diagnostic probe provided a simple test for positive identification of young non-flowering plants carrying the CMS cytoplasm and also permitted confirmation at the molecular level of the maternal transmission of the CMS trait suggested by the genetic data.     

Complete mitochondrial genome sequence and identification of a candidate gene responsible for cytoplasmic male sterility in radish (Raphanus sativus L.) containing DCGMS cytoplasm

A novel cytoplasmic male sterility (CMS) conferred by Dongbu cytoplasmic and genic male-sterility (DCGMS) cytoplasm and its restorer-of-fertility gene (Rfd1) was previously reported in radish (Raphanus sativus L.). Its inheritance of fertility restoration and profiles of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA)-based molecular markers were reported to be different from those of Ogura CMS, the first reported CMS in radish. The complete mitochondrial genome sequence (239,186 bp; GenBank accession No. KC193578) of DCGMS mitotype is reported in this study. Thirty-four protein-coding genes and three ribosomal RNA genes were identified. Comparative analysis of a mitochondrial genome sequence of DCGMS and previously reported complete sequences of normal and Ogura CMS mitotypes revealed various recombined structures of seventeen syntenic sequence blocks. Short-repeat sequences were identified in almost all junctions between syntenic sequence blocks. Phylogenetic analysis of three radish mitotypes showed that DCGMS was more closely related to the normal mitotype than to the Ogura mitotype. A single 1,551-bp unique region was identified in DCGMS mtDNA sequences and a novel chimeric gene, designated orf463, consisting of 128-bp partial sequences of cox1 gene and 1,261-bp unidentified sequences were found in the unique region. No other genes with a chimeric structure, a major feature of most characterized CMS-associated genes in other plant species, were found in rearranged junctions of syntenic sequence blocks. Like other known CMS-associated mitochondrial genes, the predicted gene product of orf463 contained 12 transmembrane domains. Thus, this gene product might be integrated into the mitochondrial membrane. In total, the results indicate that orf463 is likely to be a casual factor for CMS induction in radish containing the DCGMS cytoplasm.     

Diversity among male-sterility-inducing and male-fertile cytoplasms of onion

Hybrid-onion (Allium cepa) seed is produced using systems of cytoplasmic-genic male sterility (CMS). Two different sources of CMS (S and T cytoplasms) have been genetically characterized. Testcrosses of N-cytoplasmic maintaining and restoring genotypes to S and T cytoplasmic lines demonstrated that different alleles, or loci, restore male fertility for these two male-sterile cytoplasms. Other sources of CMS have been used or reported in Europe, Japan and India, and their relationships to S and T cytoplasms are not clear. Restriction fragment length polymorphisms were identified in the organellar genomes among commercially used male-sterile cytoplasms from Holland, Japan and India, and were compared to S and T cytoplasms. Mitochondrial DNA diversity among 58 non-S-cytoplasmic open-pollinated onion populations was also assessed. All five putative CMS lines selected from the Indian population Nasik White Globe were identical to S cytoplasm for all polymorphisms in the chloroplast genome, and always possessed the same-sized mitochondrial fragments as S cytoplasm. T cytoplasm, the male-sterile cytoplasm used to produce the Dutch hybrid Hygro F₁, and two sources of CMS from Japan, were similar and showed numbers of mitochondrial polymorphisms similar to those observed among the 58 non-S-cytoplasmic open-pollinated populations. This research demonstrates that the same, or very similar, male-sterile cytoplasms have been independently isolated and exploited for hybrid-seed production in onion. Received: 27 October 1999 / Accepted: 12 February 2000     

Development of a SCAR marker for early identification of S-cytoplasm based on mitochondrial SRAP analysis in pepper (Capsicum annuum L.)

Molecular markers, coxII SCAR, atp6-2 SCAR and accD-U, have been used for marker-assisted selection of cytoplasmic male sterility (CMS) in pepper. However, the presence of these markers at the sub-stoichiometric level in maintainer lines affects the reliable selection of male sterile (S-) cytoplasm. This study aimed to develop a new CMS-specific molecular marker, SCAR₁₃₀, for reliable identification of S-cytoplasm in pepper, while the new and three previous molecular markers were used to determine the cytoplasm types of pepper lines. Based on mitochondrial genome sequence related amplified polymorphism (SRAP) analysis of the CMS lines and the maintainer lines, SCAR₁₃₀ was developed from a 10-bp deletion at the SRAP primer binding site in the CMS line (130 bp) compared with that in the maintainer line (140 bp). S-cytoplasm could be unambiguously selected from the pepper lines by the different length of the marker bands. Application of the four molecular markers to various pepper lines revealed that SCAR₁₃₀ is more reliable than the other three previous markers, orf507, ψatp6-2 and accD-U. Homology alignment with BLAST showed that the marker was located between trnE and trnS in the Nicotiana tabacum mitochondrial genome. Furthermore, expression of the marker-linked gene was significantly higher at the pollen abortive stage in the CMS line (HW203A) than in the maintainer line, which indicated that the marker was closely related to male sterility. Hence, factors other than orf507 and ψatp6-2 may exist for the regulation of male sterility in pepper.     

Cytoplasmic-nuclear male sterility in pearl millet: comparative RFLP and transcript analyses of isonuclear male-sterile lines

The identification of diagnostic cytoplasmic molecular markers is of prime interest to pearl millet breeders wishing to identify sources of cytoplasmic-nuclear male sterility (CMS) which can be used as an alternative to the single source currently used in the production of F₁ hybrid seed. Here, we report the classification of five pearl millet CMS sources based on RFLP analysis of isonuclear lines carried out using mitochondrial gene-specific DNA probes in combination with eight restriction endonucleases. On the basis of RFLP data, the five CMS cytoplasms can be distinguished from each other and from the isonuclear fertile cytoplasm. In addition, based on cox1, cox3, atp6 and atp9 polymorphisms, these lines can be classified into two major groups: one corresponds to A₅, A_egp, A_v and A₁ cytoplasms, and the other consists of the A₄ cytoplasm. Our results suggest that a rearrangement involving the cox1 gene might be related to CMS in the first group (A₅, A_egp, A_v and A₁), whereas a rearrangement within the atp6/cox3 cluster region might be related to CMS in the second group (A₄).