Limited use of the Cre/loxP recombination system in efficient production of loxP-containing minicircles in vivo

The Cre/loxP recombination system of bacteriophage P1 is one of the most powerful tools in genome engineering. We report, however, that the activity of the Cre/loxP system interferes with the stability of the multicopy loxP-bearing plasmids in Escherichia coli recA bacteria. Due to the predominantly unidirectional Cre-mediated high-order multimer formation of these plasmids, the number of their copies (overall yield) gradually decreases. Intermolecular recombination reduces the copy number of plasmids and eventually increases their segregational instability. We have found that in the presence of even the slightest amount of Cre activity, loxP-bearing plasmids continuously undergo multimerization, which very rapidly leads to loxP-plasmid free cells. Our results are compatible with the hypothesis of the multimer catastrophe [Cell, 1984 (36), 1097].     

Investigation of the instability of plasmids directing the expression of Met-prochymosin in Escherichia coli

The causes of the instability of a multicopy plasmid, pCT70, which directs the expression of calf prochymosin in Escherichia coli, were investigated. Plasmid pAT153 and its derivative, pCT54, were stable for more than 90 generations in continuous culture with glucose limitation. The multicopy plasmid pCT66, which expressed very low levels of prochymosin due to poor translational efficiency, and low copy number plasmids which efficiently expressed the prochymosin gene, were also stable. These results indicated that high level translation of the recombinant gene was the cause of the instability of pCT70. The maximum specific growth rate of E. coli(pCT70) was reduced by 30% compared with E. coli(pCT66). To fulfil the requirements of a production system, a dual origin plasmid with controllable copy number was developed. Both this plasmid (pMG165) and a derivative which contained the prochymosin gene (pMG168) were stable when maintained at low copy number. When the copy number of plasmid pMG168 was increased by putting replication under the control of the lambda PR promoter and the cI857 temperature sensitive repressor, expression of prochymosin was achieved. This strategy enables large-scale production of prochymosin without the need for antibiotic selection or other methods of preventing plasmid loss.     

Origin pairing ('handcuffing') as a mode of negative control of P1 plasmid copy number.

In one family of bacterial plasmids, multiple initiator binding sites, called iterons, are used for initiation of plasmid replication as well as for the control of plasmid copy number. Iterons can also pair in vitro via the bound initiators. This pairing, called handcuffing, has been suggested to cause steric hindrance to initiation and thereby control the copy number. To test this hypothesis, we have compared copy numbers of isogenic miniP1 plasmid monomer and dimer. The dimer copy number was only one-quarter that of the monomer, suggesting that the higher local concentration of origins in the dimer facilitated their pairing. Physical evidence consistent with iteron-mediated pairing of origins preferentially in the dimer was obtained in vivo. Thus, origin handcuffing can be a mechanism to control P1 plasmid replication.     

Indole inhibition of ColE1 replication contributes to stable plasmid maintenance

In the absence of active partitioning, strict control of plasmid copy number is required to minimise the possibility of plasmid loss at bacterial cell division. An important cause of multicopy plasmid instability is the formation of plasmid dimers by recombination and their subsequent proliferation by over-replication in a process known as the dimer catastrophe. This leads to the formation of dimer-only cells in which plasmid copy number is substantially lower than in cells containing only monomers, and which have a greatly increased probability of plasmid loss at division. The accumulation of dimers triggers the synthesis of the regulatory small RNA, Rcd, which stimulates tryptophanase and increases the production of indole. This, in turn, inhibits Escherichia coli cell division. The Rcd checkpoint hypothesis proposes that delaying cell division allows time for the relatively slow conversion of plasmid dimers to monomers by Xer-cer site-specific recombination. In the present work we have re-evaluated this hypothesis and concluded that a cell division block is insufficient to prevent the dimer catastrophe. Plasmid replication must also be inhibited. In vivo experiments have shown that indole, when added exogenously to a broth culture of E. coli does indeed stop plasmid replication as well as cell division. We have also shown that indole inhibits the activity of DNA gyrase in vitro and propose that this is the mechanism by which plasmid replication is blocked. The simultaneous effects of upon growth, cell division and DNA replication in E. coli suggest that indole acts as a true cell cycle regulator.     

Structural-functional organization of the par region of the ColN plasmid

In the 679 b.p. SalI-KpnI-fragment of the small colicinogenic plasmid Co1N, the par-region has been localized, functioning at the expense of resolution of plasmid DNA multimer forms. It has been shown that the replication process of the monomeric form of the recombinant plasmid containing the Co1N par-region do not result in formation of a considerable number of multimers. Gene xer A product is necessary for the functioning of the multimer resolution mechanism of Co1N as well as Co1E1. Nucleotide sequence analysis of the Co1N par-region revealed the presence of essential homology with the par-locus of plasmid Co1E1. Results obtained in this work and data from literature indicate that par-regions of the Co1E1-type plasmids possess considerable homology, function according to a similar mechanism and represent the universal stability module of multicopy colicinogenic plasmids.     

Kinetic analysis of the effects of plasmid multimerization on segregational instability of CoIE1 type plasmids in Escherichia coli B/r

The effect of plasmid multimerization on segregational instability was investigated using a structured, segregated model of genetically modified Escherichia coli cells. By including the multimerization of plasmids, the model can predict the proportion of each multimer in the total plasmid population. Simulation results suggest that the plasmid copy number is controlled by the total plasmid content (i.e., total number of plasmid origins) in the host cell and that multimerization reduces the total number of independent, monomeric segregation units. However, multimerization is found to have a minor effect on decreasing plasmid segregational stability for multicopy plasmids with average copy number per cell greater than about 25. Also model predictions were used to test whether or not a nonrandom plasmid distribution at cell fission could cause segregational instability. Even in the case of severely biased partitioning, plasmids whose copy number is above 45 per cell do not show significant segregational instability. The results suggest that when the ColE1-type plasmid does not encode and express any large or disruptive foreign proteins, the copy number of 45 per cell may be the threshold at which only growth rate-dependent instability is responsible for overall plasmid instability.     

A mathematical model for lambda dv plasmid replication: analysis of copy number mutants

A mathematical model based on the molecular control mechanisms for lambda dv plasmid replication in a single Escherichia coli cell has been applied to simulate replication of mutant lambda dv plasmids. Model simulations of changes in repressor level and copy number resulting from mutations in the promoter-operator PROR region are consistent with experimental data. Calculated effects on lambda dv plasmid copy number of oligomer formation and of alternations in termination efficiency at tR1 also agree with experiment. The model has been employed to simulate the influence of cro mutants and of cro and tR1 double mutants on copy number and stable maintenance of lambda dv plasmid copy number. The genetic structure included in formulation of the replicon model provides a framework for relating changes in specific genetic loci on the plasmid with resulting alterations in host-plasmid system function.     

Synthesis of linear multimers of OriC and pBR322 derivatives in Escherichia coli K-12: role of recombination and replication functions.

Inactivation of RecBCD nuclease (exonuclease V) and SbcB nuclease (exonuclease I) in Escherichia coli K-12 diverts most of plasmid replication activity from circular monomer production to the synthesis of linear multimers. Linear multimer synthesis has been demonstrated in plasmids of diverse origins and copy numbers, including E. coli minichromosomes. The effect of dnaA, dnaB, recF, and recJ mutations on the rate of linear multimer synthesis in sbcB cells after gam inactivation of RecBCD nuclease was investigated. Results are consistent with the hypothesis that homologous recombination, but not activities at the plasmid origin of replication, is involved in initiation of linear multimer synthesis.     

Par site of the ColN plasmid: Structural and functional organization

Summary A par site involved in the resolution of multimeric plasmid DNA forms was localized in a 679 by SalI-KpnI fragment of the small colicinogenic plasmid CoIN. It was shown that replication of the monomeric pUC19 recombinant plasmid carrying the par region of ColN does not result in the formation of significant numbers of multimers. In order to function properly, the Co1N multimer resolution mechanism requires the product of the xerA gene, just as in the case of ColEI. Nucleotide sequence analysis of the par region of CoIN revealed substantial homology with the par locus of the ColE1 plasmid. The results of this study and data from the literature indicate that the par sites of ColEl-type plasmids have substantial homology and the same mechanism of action, and in fact represent a universal stability module for small multicopy colicinogenic plasmids.     

ArgR and PepA, accessory proteins for XerCD-mediated resolution of ColE1 dimers, are also required for stable maintenance of the P1 prophage

Dimers of low copy number plasmids must be resolved to monomers to prevent interference with active partition. For the P1 prophage this is achieved by the Cre site-specific recombinase acting at lox. Multimerisation of multicopy plasmids threatens stability via copy number depression, and multimers of ColE1 are resolved by XerCD-mediated recombination at cer. Xer-cer is constrained to multimer resolution by accessory proteins ArgR and PepA. Recently, it has been shown that ArgR and PepA influence Cre-mediated recombination at a cer-lox hybrid site in vitro, defining the structure of the synaptic complex. We show here that both ArgR and PepA are required for stable maintenance of the P1 prophage. It is extremely difficult to establish P1 in a strain lacking PepA and the prophage was lost rapidly once selection was removed. ArgR plays a less crucial role although its absence significantly increased prophage loss. The effect of the accessory proteins is seen only at physiological concentrations of Cre; when the recombinase is expressed from a multicopy plasmid, the prophage is unstable even in the presence of ArgR and PepA. We propose that ArgR and PepA are involved in Cre-lox recombination in vivo, probably by constraining the system to resolution of prophage dimers.     

Partitioning of the F plasmid: Overproduction of an essential protein for partition inhibits plasmid maintenance

Summary Multicopy plasmids carrying the sopB gene of the F plasmid inhibit stable inheritance of a coexisting mini-F plasmid. This incompatibility, termed IncG, is found to be caused by excess amounts of the SopB protein, which is essential for accuratepartitioning of plasmid DNA molecules into daughter cells. A sopB-carrying multicopy plasmid that shows the IncG⁺ phenotype was mutagenized in vitro and IncG negative mutant plasmids were isolated. Among these amber and missense mutants of sopB, mutants with a low plasmid copy number and a mutant in the Shine-Dalgarno sequence for translation of the SopB protein were obtained. These results demonstrate that the IncG phenotype is caused by the SopB protein, and that the incompatibility is expressed only when the protein is overproduced. This suggests that the protein must be kept at appropriate concentrations to ensure stable maintenance of the plasmid.     

Replication and segregational stability of Bacillus plasmid pBAA1.

A cryptic plasmid, pBAA1, was identified in an industrial Bacillus strain. The plasmid is 6.8 kilobases in size and is present in cells at a copy number of approximately 5 per chromosome equivalent. The plasmid has been maintained under industrial fermentation conditions without apparent selective pressure and so is assumed to be partition proficient. The minimal replicon was localized to a 1.4-kilobase fragment which also contains the functions required for copy number control. The very low level of segregational instability of the minimal replicon suggests that it also contains functions involved in plasmid maintenance. Comparison with other plasmids indicates that pBAA1 belongs to the group of small gram-positive plasmids which replicate by a rolling cycle-type mechanism. A sequence was identified which is required for the efficient conversion of the single plus strand to the double-stranded form during plasmid replication. Deletion of this sequence resulted in a low level of segregational plasmid instability.     

Spread and survival of promiscuous IncP-1 plasmids

Plasmids classified to the IncP-1 incompatibility group belong to the most stably maintained mobile elements among low copy number plasmids known to date. The remarkable persistence is achieved by various tightly controlled stability mechanisms like active partitioning, efficient conjugative transfer system, killing of plasmid-free segregants and multimer resolution. The unique feature of IncP-1 plasmids is the central control operon coding for global regulators which control the expression of genes involved in vegetative replication, stable maintenance and conjugative transfer. The multivalent regulatory network provides means for coordinated expression of all plasmid functions. The current state of knowledge about two fully sequenced plasmids RK2 and R751, representatives of the IncP-1alpha and IncP-1beta subgroups, is presented.     

P1 plasmid replication. Role of initiator titration in copy number control

The copy number control locus incA of unit copy plasmid P1 maps in a region containing nine 19 base-pair repeats. Previous results from studies in vivo and in vitro indicated that incA interacts with the plasmid-encoded RepA protein, which is essential for replication. It has been proposed that the repeat sequences negatively control copy number by sequestering the RepA protein, which is rate-limiting for replication. Our results lend further support to this hypothesis. Here we show that the repeats can be deleted completely from P1 miniplasmids and the deletion results in an approximately eightfold increase in plasmid copy number. So, incA sequences are totally dispensable for replication and have only a regulatory role. The copy number of incA-deleted plasmids can be reduced if incA sequences are present in trans or are reincorporated at two different positions in the plasmid. This reduction in copy number is not due to lowered expression of the repA gene in the presence of incA. We show that one repeat sequence is sufficient to bind RepA and can reduce the copy number of incA-deleted plasmids. When part of the repeat was deleted, it lost its ability to bind as well as influence copy number. These results show a strong correlation between the capacity of incA repeats to bind RepA protein both in vivo and in vitro, and the function of incA in the control of copy number.     

Evidence for positive regulation of plasmid prophage P1 replication: integrative suppression by copy mutants.

Like low-copy-number plasmids including P1 wild type, multicopy P1 mutants (P1 cop, maintained at five to eight copies per chromosome) can suppress the thermosensitive phenotype of an Escherichia coli dnaA host by forming a cointegrate. At 40 degrees C in a dnaA host suppressed by P1 cop, the only copy of P1 is the one in the host chromosome. Trivial explanations of the lack of extrachromosomal copies of P1 cop have been eliminated: (i) during integrative suppression, the P1 cop plasmid does not revert to cop+; (ii) the dnaA+ function of the host is not required to maintain P1 cop at a high copy number; and (iii) integrative recombination does not occur within the region of the plasmid involved in regulation of copy number. Since there are no more copies of the chromosomal origin (now located within the integrated P1 plasmid) than in a P1 cop+-suppressed strain, the extra initiation potential of the P1 cop is not used to provide multiple initiations of the chromosome. When a P1 cop-suppressed dnaA strain was grown at 30 degrees C so that replication could initiate from the chromosomal origin as well as from the P1 origin, multicopy supercoiled P1 DNA was found in the cells. This plasmid DNA was lost again when the temperature was shifted back to 40 degrees C.     

Low-copy-number plasmid-cloning vectors amplifiable by derepression of an inserted foreign promoter

By insertion of a DNA fragment, containing the phage lambda pR promoter and the pM-promoted cI857 allele of the lambda repressor gene, in plasmid R1 upstream of the replication control genes, cloning vectors have been constructed which are present in one copy per chromosome at temperatures below 37 degrees C, and which display uncontrolled replication at 42 degrees C. Derivatives have been made which carry the R1 par region, stabilizing the plasmid at low temperature when grown in the absence of selection pressure. Cells harbouring these plasmids stop growing after 1-2 h incubation at 42 degrees C, and at this time 50% of the total DNA in the cells is plasmid DNA corresponding to more than 1000 plasmid molecules per cell. Concomitant with plasmid amplification at the high temperature, synthesis of plasmid-coded gene products is amplified, and these vectors can therefore be utilized for obtaining greatly enhanced yields of gene products that may be detrimental to the host cell when present in large amounts.     

Isolation and characterization of lambda phages carrying the basic replicon of the resistance plasmid R1

Summary Specialized transducing lambda phages, oriR1, harboring DNA from the resistance plasmid R1drd-19 and its copy mutant pKN103 were isolated. From measurements of CCC-DNA content it is concluded that upon infection the phages can establish themselves as self-replicating plasmids in recA hosts lysogenic for lambda. It is thought that this bypassing of lambda immunity is due to the presence of the R1 origin of replication. The plasmids are sensitive to the incompatibility expressed by plasmid R1. This has been shown mainly by transduction of oriR1 into recipients containing R1 plasmids or plasmid pBR322 carrying the basic replicon. We were able to demonstrate that a copy mutant of plasmid R1 was insensitive to copA ⁺, but sensitive to the conserted action of Pst1 fragments F₁ and F₂. This mutant was previously assumed to be of the dominant type. Physical mapping of the oriR1 derivatives verified that they carry the basic replicon of plasmid R1. The plasmids are not stably maintained, but are lost in a frequency of 1%–2% per cell generation, which is consistent with their lack of the R1par region.