Mechanism of cell-mediated cytotoxicity at the single cell level. VI. Direct assessment of the cytotoxic potential of human peripheral blood non-lytic effector-target cell conjugates

Single cell cytotoxicity assays reveal that a large percentage of lymphocytes are unable to kill attached targets in a 4- to 18-hr assay. Additional signals (in the form of lectin or anti-target antibody) delivered to target-bound lymphocytes enable these previously non-lytic lymphocytes to kill attached target cells. This finding was obtained by using a modification of the single cell assay, in which lectin or target cell antibody is incorporated into agarose with preformed lymphocyte-target conjugates. Human peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) or Percoll density gradient-enriched large granular lymphocytes (LGL) were used as effector cells in natural killer (NK), antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity (LDCC) assay systems. The targets used were NK-sensitive K562 and Molt-4 and NK-insensitive Raji. Several findings were made in the modified single cell assay, namely a) the frequency of cytotoxic NK or ADCC effector cells was not augmented, suggesting that the initial trigger was sufficient for lytic expression in these instances. Furthermore, these results showed that the NK-sensitive targets used do not bind nonspecifically to the LDCC effector cells. K562 coated with Con A, however, serve as LDCC targets. b) The frequency of two target conjugate lysis by NK/K effectors was not augmented by Con A. These results suggest that Con A does not potentiate the killing of multiple targets bound to a single cytotoxic lymphocyte. c) Although conjugates formed between LGL or PBL and NK-insensitive Raji are non-lethal, significant lysis was observed when these conjugates were suspended in Con A or antibody agarose. These results demonstrate that Raji bind to cytotoxic NK, K, and LDCC effector cells, but are lysed only when the appropriate trigger is provided. d) The cytotoxic potential of non-lytic conjugates appears to lie within the low density Percoll fraction, although the high density lymphocytes are able to nonlethally bind to targets. Altogether the results demonstrate that target recognition and/or binding by the effector cells is a distinct event from the trigger or lytic process. The implications of these findings are discussed.     

Mechanism of target cell recognition by CD3- LGL. I. Development of a monoclonal antibody to a K562-associated target cell antigen.

In an attempt to identify the target recognition molecule(s) involved in the interaction between CD3- large granular lymphocyte (LGL) and a tumor cell target, monoclonal antibodies (mAb) to NK-susceptible K562 tumor cell membrane glycoproteins were developed. After screening by ELISA for reactivity to K562 membrane glycoproteins, two monoclonal antibodies were identified (mAb 35 and mAb 36). One of the monoclonal antibodies (mAb 36) was found to inhibit conjugation between LGL and K562 target cells and also to inhibit lysis of K562 by LGL. Upon further testing, mAb 36 also inhibited the binding between LGL and other NK-susceptible target cells, e.g., Daudi and Molt 4. In contrast, mAb 35, even though binding to K562, did not inhibit the binding of LGL to tumor targets and therefore was used as an isotype control. When mAb 36 was utilized as an affinity matrix, bound proteins specifically inhibited CD3- LGL-K562 conjugation. Experiments involving tunicamycin treatment of tumor target cells demonstrated that mAb 36 recognized a carbohydrate moiety rather than the protein core. Therefore, these data suggested that the target cell recognition molecule which is recognized by mAb 36 appears to be a membrane carbohydrate-associated molecule.     

Inhibition of natural killer cell lysis by natural killer-inhibitory substance: mechanism of suppression

The mechanism of suppression of NK-mediated lysis by a soluble product of peritoneal cells (NK-IS, natural killer-inhibitory substance) was investigated. Pretreatment of effector cells resulted in depressed NK lysis while pretreatment of targets had no effect, indicating suppression is due to alterations in effector cell function rather than changes in target cells. NK-IS had no effect on the formation of conjugates between effectors and NK-susceptible targets. When NK-IS was added to effector-target cell mixtures after the binding step had been successfully completed, ensuing lysis was significantly depressed, confirming that NK-IS inhibited a postbinding lytic event. The degree of suppression caused by NK-IS was directly related to the duration of exposure to the inhibitory molecule. In addition, a preliminary temperature-dependent step of binding to and/or intracellular entry of NK-IS into effectors is required before suppression can occur. NK-IS prevents the activation of NK cell lysis by interferon and Corynebacterium parvum and effectively inhibits lysis mediated by already activated effectors. The potent suppression of NK lysis and prevention of interferon and C. parvum-mediated activation of NK lysis by a soluble product of peritoneal cells may explain the extremely low level of NK effector cell function within the peritoneal cavity.     

Natural killer activity in the rat. III. Characterization of transplantable large granular lymphocyte (LGL) leukemias in the F344 rat

Six transplantable large granular lymphocyte (LGL) tumor lines in F344 rats were examined for natural killer (NK) and antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity. Tumor cells from all six lines were highly cytotoxic, even at low effector to target ratios, when tested against NK-susceptible targets, but were unreactive against an NK-resistant target (C58NT)D) and a macrophage-susceptible target (P815). Three lines showed significant levels of lysis against antibody-coated tumor cells. After in vivo transplantation, the levels of cytotoxicity steadily increased in three lines and decreased in one. The cytotoxic activity of one line (RNK-16) remained high through 12 transplant generations. Tumor cells injected i.p. spread via the lymphatics to regional lymph nodes, mediastinal nodes, blood, and eventually the bone marrow. Leukemia occurred concurrently with organ enlargement and increased levels of NK. Studies in (F344 X W/Fu)F1 rats clearly demonstrated that the cytotoxic cells from leukemic animals were the transplanted tumor cells themselves and not merely the activation of normal host LGL. These results demonstrate that naturally occurring, transplantable LGL leukemias are an easily obtainable and excellent source of materials for those studies requiring a large number of functionally active LGL.     

Effect of altered membrane fluidity on NK cell-mediated cytotoxicity. I. Selective inhibition of the recognition or post recognition events in the cytolytic pathway of NK cells

NK cell-mediated cytotoxicity results from membrane interactions between NK effector and target cells. The role of membrane fluidity in these events is not known. The present study was undertaken to investigate the effect of changes in membrane lipid fluidity of NK effector and NK-sensitive target cells on the lytic pathway of NK cell-mediated cytotoxicity. Fluidity was modulated by various lipids and measured by fluorescence polarization. NK effector cells treated with phosphatidylcholine complexed with polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP) and bovine serum albumin (BSA) showed increased membrane fluidity. This fluidization of the effector cell membrane resulted in a significant inhibition of cytotoxic activity in the 51Cr-release assay. Single cell analysis revealed that the inhibition was due to a decrease in the frequency of NK target conjugates and reduced killing of conjugated targets. Rigidification of the NK effector cell membranes by treatment with cholesteryl hemisuccinate complexed with PVP and BSA also resulted in inhibition of cytotoxicity. This inhibition was post binding, because binding was increased and lysis was abrogated. Fluidization of K562 target cell membranes caused a slight but insignificant increase in their lysis by NK cells without affecting the binding step. On the other hand, rigidification of K562 membranes decreased the sensitivity of these target cells to lysis. Single cell analysis revealed that this inhibition of NK lysis is post binding, because the frequency of killers was significantly decreased. It was also shown that membrane rigidification of target cells that were programmed for lysis during the lethal hit stage and subsequently separated from effector cells, rendered the programmed cells resistant to killing during the killer cell-independent lysis step. These results demonstrate that fluidization or rigidification of the plasma membrane of either effector or target cells affect different stages of the NK cell-mediated cytolytic events.     

K562 killing by K, IL 2-responsive NK, and T cells involves different effector cell post-binding trigger mechanisms

The monoclonal antibody 13.3 specifically blocks the trigger process of the NK-K562 cytolytic sequence at a post-binding effector cell level. This antibody was used to define differences in the lytic trigger processes of NK and other mechanisms of K562 lysis. Monoclonal antibody 13.3 inhibited lysis of K562 target cells by freshly isolated peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) and purified large granular lymphocytes (LGL), but had no inhibitory effect on antibody-dependent cell-mediated cytotoxicity to K562 by these effectors. Lectin-dependent cellular cytotoxicity (LDCC) to this target cell was also unresponsive to 13.3. The 13.3-induced inhibition of NK-K562 lytic activity persisted when PBL were activated in culture with interleukin 2 (IL 2) for periods up to 48 hr. After 48 hr of culture, the degree of inhibition diminished progressively in medium containing fetal calf serum but not in medium containing autologous serum. This 13.3-unresponsive lytic activity in cultured PBL could be attributed to more than one cell type and was present in both the LGL and Fc gamma receptor-depleted T cell fraction. Thus, K562 lysis by freshly isolated human lymphocytes via NK, K, and LDCC mechanisms is characterized by heterogeneity of the post-binding effector cell trigger mechanism. K562 lysis by lymphocytes cultured with IL 2 is similarly heterogeneous.     

Potentiation of NK cytotoxicity by antibody-C3b/iC3b heteroconjugates

The interaction of two Burkitt lymphoma lines, Raji and Rael, with human C and NK cells was analyzed. Raji cells activate the alternative C pathway (ACP) and then bind C3 fragments. Consequently, the cells become more sensitive to lysis by CR3-bearing NK cells but not to C lysis. In contrast, Rael cells are poor ACP activators, do not bind C3 fragments, and are therefore resistant to C-dependent NK lysis. As suggested earlier, the difference between Raji and Rael could be attributed to the presence or absence of CR2, respectively, on their surface. To potentiate C- and NK-dependent lysis of target cells, we generated heteroconjugates composed of a murine antitransferrin receptor mAb and of human C C3b or iC3b. Antibody-C3b conjugates induced C3 deposition on Rael cells and elevated C3 deposition on Raji cells in human serum. Both Raji and Rael cells coated with antibody-C3b conjugates were efficiently lyzed by the cytolytic ACP in human serum. This conjugate had a small enhancing effect on target cell lysis by NK cells which could be markedly increased by combined treatment of the target cell with antibody-C3b conjugate and C5-depleted human serum. On the other hand, antibody-iC3b conjugates efficiently potentiated lysis of target cells by NK cells in the absence of serum. The iC3b-directed cytotoxicity was mediated by CR3-bearing NK effector cells. Anti-C3 but not anti-mouse Ig antibodies abrogated the activity of the antibody-iC3b conjugate. These results further demonstrate that NK cytotoxicity may be potentiated by opsonizing the target cells with C3 fragments and suggest that antibody-C3b/iC3b conjugates could be potent tools for targeting and potentiation of the lytic action of both C and NK cells against tumor cells.     

Feline cytotoxic large granular lymphocytes induced by recombinant human IL-2

Large granular lymphocytes (LGL) have been characterized phenotypically and functionally as cytotoxic T lymphocytes, NK cells or lymphokine-activated killer cells. The most prominent morphologic feature of LGL is large cytoplasmic granules that are thought to contain the molecules responsible for cell lysis. In this study, we describe the morphologic and functional characteristics of IL-2-dependent cytotoxic lymphocytes derived from feline PBL. Stimulation of feline PBL with Con A followed by culturing in 50 U of gibbon monkey IL-2 human rIL-2 induced long term lymphocyte cultures. These lymphocytes are cytotoxic for the feline leukemia virus-induced T cell lymphoma (FL74), in a 4-h 51Cr release assay. All cell lines are either constitutively cytotoxic for FL74 cells, or cytotoxic in a lectin-dependent cell cytotoxic assay, the latter being a characteristic of low passage cultures. In contrast, no cell lines express self lysis or lysis for other lines. [3H]TdR uptake showed that 1 U of human rIL-2 produces a 50% maximal proliferative response by feline lymphocytes suggesting a high degree of homology between the ligand binding sites of feline and human IL-2R. Feline cytotoxic lymphocytes possess abundant cytoplasm containing large azurophilic granules characteristic of LGL. These granules are bound by a bilipid membrane and contain numerous smaller membrane-bound vesicles 50 to 60 nm in diameter. A model is proposed, whereby subsequent to binding of LGL to target cell the large granules fuse to the LGL plasma membrane and release the small vesicles into the binding pocket. The vesicles then transport the lytic molecules directly and selectively to the target cell membrane.     

Rapid kinetics of lysis in human natural cell-mediated cytotoxicity: Some implications

The entire lytic process of natural cell-mediated cytotoxicity against sensitive target cells can occur rapidly, within minutes. This was demonstrated by ⁵¹chromium release and in single-cell assays. At the cellular level, most of the target cell lysis occurred within 15–30 min after binding to effector cells. The enriched natural killer cell subpopulation of lymphocytes obtained by Percoll density gradient centrifugation (containing >70% large granular lymphocytes (LGL)) was the most rapidly lytic population by ⁵¹chromium release. However, in the single-cell assay, the rate of lysis of bound target cells was quite similar for the LGL-enriched effector subpopulation and the higher density subpopulation of effector cells recognized previously. Both the light and dense effector cells contained similar numbers of target binding cells. Therefore, that the light subpopulation effected lysis more rapidly and to a greater extent than the dense subpopulation suggested that the low-density effector cells probably recycled more rapidly than those of higher density. This was corroborated by the finding that when conjugates were formed at 29 °C for the single-cell assay, a significant number of dead unconjugated targets could be observed only on the slides made with the LGL-enriched effector cells but not on those made with dense effector cell. Lysis continued to increase in the chromium-release assay probably because of recycling, recruitment, and/or heterogeneity of the effector cells, and/or because of heterogeneity or delayed death of the target cells.     

Lymphokine-activated killer cells in rats. IV. Developmental relationships among large agranular lymphocytes, large granular lymphocytes, and lymphokine-activated killer cells

The developmental relationships among large agranular lymphocytes (LAL) large granular lymphocytes (LGL) and the activation of these cells into lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cells by rIL-2 was investigated. Highly enriched populations of LAL were isolated from Fischer 344 spleen cells by a combination of nylon-wool filtration (to remove B cells and macrophages), treatment with a pan T cell antibody plus complement (to remove T cells) and incubation in L-leucine methyl ester (to remove LGL). The resultant cells were highly enriched in morphologically identifiable LAL which expressed asialo GM1 and partially expressed the OX8 surface marker. The enriched LAL did not contain detectable NK cytotoxic activity, did not express pan T cell (OX19), Ia, Ig, or laminin surface markers and contained less than 0.2% LGL. Incubation of LAL in a low dose of rIL-2 (100 U/ml) induced the generation of LGL having NK activity within 24 h of culture. Longer culture periods (48 h) resulted in a continued increase in the percentage of LGL and higher levels of NK activity. However, with this low dose of rIL-2, little or no LAK activity (i.e., reactivity against NK-resistant target cells) was generated. With a high dose of rIL-2 (500 U/ml), LAL responded by first generating LGL with NK activity (within 24 h), with subsequent generation of LAK activity by 48 h. Evidence that the development of granular lymphocytes from LAL was responsible first for NK activity and then LAK activity was demonstrated by depletion of the generated granular NK or LAK effector cells by second treatments with L-leucine methyl ester. Concomitant with the induction of LGL with NK or LAK activity, rIL-2 also caused LGL to proliferate and expand four- to five-fold in 48 h. This occurred in the presence of high or low dose rIL-2. These results indicate that LAL are the precursors of LGL/NK cells, that LAL, LGL/NK cells and LAK cells appear to represent sequential developmental or activation stages and that LAL may comprise major source of LAK progenitors in lymphoid populations having few LGL or mature active NK cells.     

Mechanism of cell-mediated cytotoxicity at the single-cell level: VII. Trigger of the lethal hit event is distinct for NK/K and LDCC effector cells as measured in the two-target conjugate assay

Normal human peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) express several in vitro cytotoxic functions, among which are natural killer (NK), antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity (ADCC), and lectin-dependent cellular cytotoxicity (LDCC). The relationship of these various cytotoxic functions and the identity of cells involved has been a subject of controversy. Recently it was reported that NK and K for ADCC can be mediated by the same cell, suggesting that they constitute in large part a single subpopulation with multiple cytotoxic functions. The ability of this NK/K effector cell to mediate LDCC was examined here using the two target conjugate assay. The effector cells were Ficoll-Hypaque PBL or LGL-enriched fractions. The targets used were K562 or MOLT for NK, RAJI coated with antibody for ADCC, and RAJI coated with PHA or Con A or modified by NaIO₄ for LDCC. In the two-target conjugate assay, one of the targets is fluorescein labeled for identification. The results show that (a) LDCC copurifies with NK/K and is enriched in the LGL fraction, as measured in both the ⁵¹Cr-release assay and the single-cell assay for cytotoxicity; (b) single effector cells simultaneously bind to NK or ADCC and LDCC targets, revealing that single cells bear binding receptors for all targets; and (c) single lymphocytes were not able to kill both bound NK/K and LDCC targets. However, significant two-target killing was obtained when both targets were NK targets, ADCC targets, LDCC targets, or one NK and one ADCC target. These results demonstrate that the NK and LDCC effector cells are distinct subpopulations copurified in the LGL fraction. In addition, the results show that lectin is unable to trigger globally an NK effector cell to mediate cytotoxicity against a bound NK insensitive target. Thus, although both NK and LDCC effector cells are present in the LGL fraction and can bind to both types of targets, the trigger of the lethal hit event is the function of specialized effector cells.     

Analysis of rat natural killer cytotoxic factor (NKCF) produced by rat NK cell lines and the production of a murine monoclonal antibody that neutralizes NKCF

Natural killer cytotoxic factor (NKCF) is produced as a result of the interaction of murine, rat, or human natural killer (NK) cells with NK-susceptible targets. This factor has been linked to the target cell lysis mediated by the NK effector cell. In the present results, culture supernatants from rat large granular lymphocyte (LGL) tumors exhibited NKCF activity which lysed the susceptible targets, MBL-2 and YAC-1. NKCF production from these rat tumor lines was spontaneous and was not significantly increased by co-incubation of the LGL tumors with target cells, target cell membranes, or by preincubation of the LGL tumor cells with interferon or interleukin 2. In addition to NKCF activity, the supernatants lysed L929, indicating the presence of tumor necrosis factor (TNF) in these preparations. The presence of this latter cytokine was verified using specific antibodies to recombinant murine TNF which neutralized the L929 activity while not affecting the NKCF activity against MBL-2 or YAC-1. Mouse monoclonal antibodies (mAb) A0287, A0462, and A0316) which significantly inhibit the NKCF cytolytic activity of these LGL-derived supernatants were also produced. These antibodies were shown to cross-react with human NKCF in a manner similar to that seen in the rat. Interestingly these same mAb demonstrated no inhibition of L929 cytotoxicity from either LGL-derived supernatants or by recombinant murine or human TNF. To examine further the specificity of these antibodies, they were chemically linked to Sepharose 4B and found to remove a significant proportion of the NKCF cytolytic activity from LGL supernatants, while not affecting the TNF reactivities in these preparations. In addition, these antibodies demonstrated significant inhibition of cell-mediated cytotoxicity by rat LGL against YAC-1 target cells. Biochemical analysis of labeled NKCF-containing supernatants indicated the major protein recognized by these anti-NKCF mAb to be approximately 12,000 m.w. The use of these mAb against NKCF should be very useful in further purification and biochemical characterization of NKCF and in studying its role in a variety of cell-mediated cytotoxicity assays.     

Human cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) against Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) infected cells: EBV specificity and involvement of major histocompatibility complex determinants in the lysis exerted by anti-EBV CTL toward HLA-compatible and allogeneic target cells

Human peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL), from anti-Epstein-Barr virus (EBV)-seropositive donors, were stimulated by EBV and were shown to be cytotoxic toward autologous, HLA-compatible, and fully allogeneic EBV-transformed target cells. The lysis was not due to natural killer (NK) cells since the target cells used were resistant to lysis by fresh PBL and by virus-stimulated PBL-depleted of AET-SRBC-rosetting T cells (the latter being still fully cytotoxic on K562 NK-susceptible target cells). Conversely only E-rosette-purified (T) lymphocytes killed EBV-transformed HLA-compatible and allogeneic target cells. Moreover, anti-MHC antibodies inhibited the cytotoxicity exerted by EBV-induced cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) on both autologous and allogeneic target cells. Finally the lysis was EBV specific since PHA blasts were not killed and since only EBV-transformed cells could compete for lysis with the EBV-positive target cells. Efficient competition was achieved by EBV-transformed cells autologous or allogeneic to the targets, even when effector and target cells were fully allogeneic. All together, the data suggest that human anti-EBV CTL may recognize nonpolymorphic HLA determinants on the target cells in association with the virus-induced antigens.     

Generation of large granular T lymphocytes in vivo during viral infection

Cytolytic lymphocytes were isolated from the spleens of lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCMV)-infected mice and were characterized in regards to function, cell size, antigen phenotype, and cell morphology. Only 2% of the Lyt-2+ cells from uninfected mice were large granular lymphocytes (LGL), whereas 21% of the Lyt-2+ cells isolated 7 days postinfection were LGL. The day 7 Lyt-2+ populations contained all of the LCMV-specific, class I histocompatibility antigen-restricted cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) activity, but no natural killer (NK) cell activity. The NK cell activity was consistently recovered in Lyt-2- populations isolated from both control mice and mice on day 7 postinfection. The LGL isolated on day 7 postinfection were concluded to be predominantly T cells and not NK cells because 1) the proportions of LGL in fractionated cell populations 7 days postinfection correlated with levels of CTL-mediated lysis but not NK cell-mediated lysis, 2) they were recovered in the Lyt-2+ population, and 3) antibody to asialo GM1, known to eliminate NK cell-mediated lysis but not T cell-mediated lysis, dramatically reduced NK cell LGL numbers in vivo on day 3 postinfection but only marginally affected LGL numbers on day 7. Virus-induced inflammation elicited a 50-fold increase in LGL numbers in the peritoneum on day 7 postinfection. The peritoneal exudate LGL were also associated with CTL activity and were resistant to treatment with antibody to asialo GM1. These results indicate that in vivo-generated CTL have the morphology of LGL and that the appearance of cytoplasmic granules correlates with the ability of cells to mediate lysis. To focus on cells being stimulated during infections, activated blast cells were separated from small resting cells by centrifugal elutriation. Coincidental with the peak in overall spleen leukocyte cytotoxic activity, the peaks of blast NK cells and CTL were at days 3 and 7 postinfection respectively. More than 50% of the blast lymphocytes isolated on either day 3 or day 7 postinfection were LGL. The CTL activity in the blast populations on day 7 postinfection was mediated by Lyt-2+ cells, and 37 to 64% of these Lyt-2+ blast cells were LGL. Cytolytic NK cell and CTL LGL could not be distinguished by morphology or by cell densities, because they overlapped in low density Percoll gradient fractions. Since this technique has been used to enrich for LGL, these data indicate that heterogeneity in LGL populations may result from the presence of both CTL and NK cell LGL.     

Cytotoxic activity against trophoblast and choriocarcinoma cells of large granular lymphocytes from human early pregnancy decidua

Large granular lymphocytes (LGL) are the most abundant cell type in first trimester human pregnancy decidua. We have shown previously that CD56-positive decidual LGL have cytotoxic activity against the natural killer (NK) target K562, and that this cytotoxicity is augmented by pretreatment with interleukin-2 (IL-2). We now report that flow cytometrically purified populations of CD56-positive decidual LGL have no cytotoxic activity against either the BeWo choriocarcinoma cell line or freshly isolated term trophoblast. Incubation of unfractionated decidual cells with IL-2 induced cytotoxicity against BeWo, but term trophoblast remained resistant to lysis. Both BeWo and trophoblast showed much lower binding frequencies to decidual or peripheral blood cells than K56 targets, and excess trophoblast did not inhibit cytotoxic activity against K562. This suggests that the resistance of trophoblast to lysis by either decidual or peripheral blood LGL is due to the lack of accessible NK target structures on the surface of trophoblast.     

Effects of transforming growth factor beta on the functions of natural killer cells: depressed cytolytic activity and blunting of interferon responsiveness

Type beta transforming growth factor (TGF-beta) is a unique polypeptide that has been isolated from a number of different tissues and can induce the phenotypic transformation of non-neoplastic fibroblasts as measured by the stimulation of their growth in soft agar. Recently, TGF-beta has been demonstrated to exert profound inhibitory effects on T and B lymphocyte proliferation. In this study, the effects of TGF-beta on natural killer (NK) cell function were investigated. After 20 hr of culture in the presence of TGF-beta, the NK activity of peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) was significantly reduced compared with PBL cultured in medium alone. Similarly, TGF-beta produced a significant depression in the cytolytic activity of highly enriched large granular lymphocytes (LGL). This effect of TGF-beta appeared to be mediated directly on the effector cells, because cultivation of the K562 target cells in TGF-beta did not affect target cell susceptibility to lysis. Binding studies with 125I-TGF-beta indicated that LGL possess approximately 1400 high-affinity (Kd = 1PM) receptors/cell, which represents a considerably higher affinity receptor for TGF-beta than that found on fibroblasts. Culturing of PBL and LGL in TGF-beta resulted in a marked blunting of the boosting of NK cytolysis by interferon-alpha but not by interleukin 2, which suggested that TGF-beta may down-regulate interferon-alpha receptors on NK cells. These results, indicate that in addition to inhibitory effects on T and B cells, TGF-beta also inhibits NK cell function. Although the in vivo role of TGF-beta is presently undefined, it may be an important immunoregulatory protein that has a negative influence on lymphocyte activation.     

K562 cells induced to differentiate by phorbol ester tumor promotors resist NK lysis

The effect of various phorbols and phorbol diesters on the NK sensitivity of the human leukemic K562 cells was studied. A marked decrease in K562 cell susceptibility was achieved by culture in the presence of either 12-O-tetradecanoyl-phorbol-13-acetate (TPA) or beta-phorbol-dibutyrate. The maximum protection against NK lysis was achieved when K562 cells were cultured in the presence of 160 nM TPA for 48 hr (mean percentage inhibition: 61% of specific lysis). As for untreated targets, the residual killing of K562 cells after TPA treatment was mediated through large granular lymphocytes (LGL). The experimental procedures required to achieve maximal NK protection with TPA resulted simultaneously in marked phenotypical changes in K562 cells: erythroid and early myeloid markers decreased, whereas the expression of megakaryocytic markers was increased as shown by staining with antiplatelet monoclonal antibodies and assessment of platelet peroxidase activity. Chemical phorbol analogs which were unable to induce K562 cell differentiation did not affect K562 cell sensitivity to NK lysis. De novo protein synthesis is involved in the TPA-induced NK resistance, since this effect was abolished by pretreatment of K562 cells with actinomycin D or cycloheximide. TPA has been previously demonstrated to reduce NK effector activity. In our data however, the observed TPA effects were not due to release of TPA acting on effector cells during the NK assay since TPA-treated K562 cell supernatants were unable to inhibit NK activity in control assays. Thus, TPA appears to decrease NK killing of malignant cells, both by depressing NK effector cells functions and by reducing the susceptibility to NK lysis of the target cells. In single-cell agarose assays, TPA-treated K562 cells demonstrated reduced NK-binding capacity and reduced sensitivity to lysis after binding. These defects could not be reversed by activation of the NK effector cells with interferon. The results here reported extend the previously suggested relations between the expression of NK-target structures and the differentiation stage of malignant cells.     

Natural killer-sensitive targets stimulate production of TNF-alpha but not TNF-beta (lymphotoxin) by highly purified human peripheral blood large granular lymphocytes

Highly purified populations of large granular lymphocytes (LGL) have been shown to mediate natural killer (NK) cell activity. The mechanism of target cell killing by NK cells is as yet undefined; however, it has been postulated that such killing may involve soluble cytotoxic factors produced and secreted by NK cells. The data presented show that NK-sensitive, but not NK-resistant, tumor cell lines induce highly purified populations of human LGL to produce factors with cytotoxic and/or cytostatic activities. We have identified one of these factors as tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-alpha), and have shown that production of this factor is enhanced by recombinant human interferon-gamma (rHuIFN-gamma). We have also examined the role of TNF-alpha in the cytotoxic function of NK cells. The data show that although highly purified LGL populations produce low levels of TNF-alpha, the cytotoxic/cytostatic activity of this lymphokine on tumor target cells does not correlate with the cytotoxic activity of highly purified populations of LGL on tumor target cells. Furthermore, NK cell-mediated cytotoxicity is not reliably inhibited by antibodies directed against various epitopes of recombinant human TNF-alpha and/or recombinant TNF-beta (lymphotoxin) or rHuIFN-gamma. These data show that although TNF-alpha is produced by highly purified NK-containing LGL cell populations, this factor does not appear to be responsible for NK cell cytotoxicity against classical NK target cells such as Molt-4 or K562. We suggest that NK function can be attributed to a combination of factors rather than to a single factor alone, and that at least two major phenomena are involved in LGL function: the rapid cytotoxic events which lead to the cell lysis measured in classical in vitro NK assays such as against K562; and the release of factors such as TNF-alpha with cytotoxic/cytostatic activities which would inhibit the growth of invading tumor cells in vivo.     

Characterization of effector-target conjugates for cloned human natural killer and human lymphokine activated killer cells by flow cytometry.

The present studies demonstrate that the intracellular fluorochromes calcein and hydroethidine can be used for quantification of effector-target conjugates involving cloned human natural killer (NK) or interleukin-2 (IL-2) activated human lymphokine activated killer (LAK) cells by dual color flow cytometry without potential artifacts that might result from extensive modification of effector and/or target cell membranes. Cloned NK cells and LAK cells form conjugates with cultured cell lines regardless of susceptibility to lysis. The strength of the interactions in these conjugates was investigated using a variable speed vortexer. Even relatively gentle vortexing disrupted most conjugates involving fresh human peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) but only about one-fourth of conjugates between K-562 cells and human PBL that had been cultured with or without IL-2 by this treatment. The rate of conjugate formation for LAK cells was determined to be about 3 times faster than for cloned NK cells, and both rates are considerably faster than the reported rate of formation of cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) target conjugates. The differences in the rate of conjugate formation are apparently not related to target cell specificity, since LAK cells form conjugates with susceptible and resistant cell lines at comparable rates. When effector-target conjugates are incubated at 37 degrees C in the absence of calcium--thereby precluding lysis--the percentage of conjugated LAK or cloned NK cells decreases logarithmically with time. These results suggest that an initial equilibrium between free and conjugated lymphocytes gradually shifts in favor of unconjugated cells.     

Natural killing target antigens as inducers of interferon: studies with an immunoselected, natural killing-resistant human T lymphoblastoid cell line

The human T lymphoblastoid cell line CEM was subjected to immunoselection by co-culture with peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) for resistance to natural killer (NK) cell-mediated lysis. The NK susceptibility of the resulting subline, CEM.NKR, was 8.4 to 20.6% of that of CEM when PBMC or adherent cell-depleted PBMC were used as effector cells, and -7.1 to 12.1% of that of CEM when Percoll gradient-enriched large granular lymphocytes (LGL) were used. However, CEM and CEM.NKR exhibited comparable sensitivity to antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity. Unlabeled CEM was eight- to 32-fold more effective than unlabeled CEM.NKR in inhibiting the NK lysis of labeled CEM target cells, and CEM bound 1.9 to 3.9-fold more Percoll gradient-enriched LGL than CEM.NKR in single cell-binding assays, suggesting that the NK-resistant variant has lost the expression of NK target antigens. However, CEM.NKR was comparable to CEM in its ability to induce interferon (IFN)-alpha production by PBMC in vitro, and the NK-resistant variant maintained its susceptibility to the antiproliferative effects of IFN-alpha, indicating that these phenomena may be mediated by molecules other than NK target structures. Comparison of CEM and CEM.NKR by indirect immunofluorescence with monoclonal antibodies specific for leukocyte antigens and the transferrin receptor, and by microcytotoxicity typing for HLA-A and B specificities, revealed no major differences.