Inhibition of erythroid cell growth by allogeneic murine lymphocytes. Evidence for a synergism between lymph node cells and thymocytes

Murine lymphoid cells from thymus and lymph nodes were tested for synergistic response in a graft-vs-host test. The test is based on the principle that allogeneic lymphocytes inhibit erythroid cell proliferation in the spleens of irradiated mice infused with syngeneic bone marrow cells.I was observed that mixtures of thymocytes and lymph node cells from the same parental strain yielded graft-vs-host responses in irradiated F₁-hybrids higher than expected by summing the responses of the two cell populations tested separately. A similar synergistic response was obtained using mixtures of thymocytes and lymph node cells obtained from the two parental strains of the hybrid, whereas such an effect was not detected using mixtures of lymph node cells or mixtures of thymocytes from the two parental strains. Nor could synergy be demonstrated between parental strain lymph node cells and thymocytes syngeneic with the bone marrow target cells. Thymocytes obtained from one parental strain which were injected into its irradiated F₁-hybrid transformed into a population of sensitized cells in the spleens of the recipients. This transformation was suppressed by the simultaneous injection of lymph node cells from the second parental strain. Since there is a synergistic immune response by such cell mixtures it is concluded that thymocytes may enhance the graft-vs-host response of lymph node cells. Parental strain thymocytes and lymph node cells, the latter being specifically immunologically tolerant to the bone marrow target cells, failed to give a synergistic response indicating that thymocytes do not transform unresponsive lymphocytes into responsive, but rather enhance the reactivity of existing, specifically responsive cells.The results thus show that thymocytes may enhance the response of lymph node cells in this specific graft-vs-host assay.     

Enhancement of the mixed lymphocyte response in the mouse by addition of thymocytes

Synthesis of DNA by mixtures of mouse lymph node and thymic cells was studied in vitro using mitomycin-treated allogeneic spleen cells as stimulator cells. The tests were performed to see whether there occurs a similar cell synergy during this reaction as has been reported during the in vivo graft-vs-host response.It was observed that mixtures of thymocytes and lymph node cells give higher incorporations of isotope-labelled thymidine than can be explained by a pure additive effect of the two cell populations tested separately. This enhancement of the reactivity was more pronounced using combinations of lymph node cells and medullary thymocytes obtained from cortisone-treated donors. Enhancement was also noted between lymph node cells and spleen cells. Blocking of the capacity of lymph node cells to synthesize DNA by treatment with mitomycin abolished this enhanced activity when mixed with thymic cells. On the contrary, mitomycin treatment of thymocytes did not abolish their capacity to increase the reactivity when mixed with normal lymph node cells. Thymocytes, which were unresponsive to the mitomycin-treated cells for genetic reasons, were also found to increase DNA synthesis when combined with lymph node cells. The mechanism by which thymocytes increase DNA synthesis of lymph node cells is not clear, but the results show that they have to be present during the reaction, since culture medium “conditioned” by thymocytes did not exhibit any enhanced capacity to promote a mixed lymphocyte reaction of lymph node cells.The results are thus in agreement with the findings obtained by others showing that mixtures of lymph node cells and thymic cells yield higher immunological reactivities in vivo against foreign transplantation, antigens than can be explained by a pure additive effect of the reactivities by the two cell populations tested separately. However, in contrast to these findings, the thymic cells do not have to be able to synthesize DNA or to react against the foreign cells in vitro to yield an enhanced response when mixed with lymph node cells.     

Stimulation of antibody production to the hapten, 2,4-dinitrobenzene by affinity-labeled murine lymphoid cells. II. Suppressive activity of an excess of thymocytes.

The suppressive effects of excess numbers of normal thymocytes on the transfer of immunity to 2,4-dinitrophenyl (DNP) into irradiated syngeneic recipients with metanitrobenzenediazonium fluoborate (m-NBDF)-labeled spleen cells and normal thymocytes (NT) was investigated. The significant immune response to DNP obtained with the optimal dose of 10 × 10⁷ NT was completely ablated when 20 × 10⁷ NT were used. The suppression was not the result of supro-optimal helper activity. T cell interference of m-NBDF-labeled spleen cell homing, or nonspecific suppression due to excessive numbers of cells. The suppressor activity was T cell dependent and was present in both the cortisone-resistant and cortisone-sensitive thymocyte populations. The suppression was obliterated by 1000 R of irradiation. Thus, the suppressor activity could be the result of either a radiosensitive property of normal thymocytes when they are in excess or a subpopulation of radiosensitive, suppressor thymocytes.     

Lymphoid cell subpopulations. I. Synergy between lymph node cells and thymocytes in response to alloantigens and mitogens.

Mixtures of isogenic thymocytes (TC) and lymph node cells (LNC) were shown to exhibit synergistic responsiveness to M and H-2 alloantigens in the mixed lymphocyte interaction (MLI). With respect to the kinetics and magnitude of proliferation and effector cell generation, the response occurring in synergizing cultures closely resembled that of optimal numbers of LNC or spleen cells (SC). In addition, the antigen specificity of effector cells generated by synergizing cultures was similar to that of effectors derived from cultures containing optimal numbers of responding SC. LNC-TC mixtures also exhibited synergy in response to the phytomitogens concanavalin A and pokeweed mitogen but not to phytohemagglutinin. Weakly positive synergy was observed in response to bacterial lipopolysaccharide. It is proposed that the phenomenon of synergy is not restricted to cultures containing mixtures of LNC and TC but also occurs in cultures containing optimal numbers of LNC or SC as a result of interactions between subpopulations of lymphocytes contained within these tissues.     

Interleukin 2 regulation of mitogen induction of immune interferon (IFN gamma) in spleen cells and thymocytes

Interleukin 2 (IL 2) or T-cell growth factor induced the production of immune interferon (IFN_γ) in C57B1/6 mouse spleen cell cultures, and enhanced mitogen-induced IFN_γ production in both spleen cells and thymocytes. Staphylococcal enterotoxin A, but not phytohemagglutinin P (PHA-P), induced IFN_γ production in thymocytes. IL 2 enhanced this production by almost 12-fold, while having no effect on the negative response to PHA-P. The IFN activity was shown to be IFN_γ by neutralization with specific antiserum. A strict correlation between IL 2 induction or enhancement of IFN_γ production and cell proliferation was not observed, probably indicating that non-IFN-producing cells also proliferated in the presence of IL 2. The data indicate that IL 2 can both induce IFN_γ and modulate mitogen induction of IFN_γ.     

The generation of cytolytic activity in mixed leukocyte cultures: cortisone-resistant thymocytes are deficient in helper T lymphocytes

Cortisone-resistant (CR) thymocytes did not generate cytolytic activity toward H-2 K or D alloantigen unless they were also stimulated by H-2 I or non-H-2 alloantigens, even though spleen cells generated brisk cytolytic activity toward H-2 K or D alone. Backstimulation by stimulating strain T lymphocytes accounted for neither the response of spleen cells toward H-2 K or D alloantigen nor the response of CR thymocytes to a full set of alloantigens. In addition, lack of non-T accessory cells did not account for the CR thymocyte pattern of reactivity. Rather, CR thymocytes appeared to be relatively deficient in helper T lymphocytes (HTL). CR thymocytes generated specific cytolytic activity toward H-2 D alloantigen when T cell growth factors (TCGF) or cloned alloreactive helper T lymphocytes were added to culture. CR thymocytes contained fewer HTL precursors detected at limit dilution than spleen cells did. Thus spleen cells generated cytolytic activity toward class I alloantigens alone, but under the same culture conditions CR thymocytes had to be stimulated by both class I and class II alloantigens. Class II alloantigens may be required to stimulate cytolytic activity only under culture conditions in which class I-reactive HTL are not sufficient to provide a minimal threshold of help.     

Absence of mitochondrial uncoupling protein 1 affects apoptosis in thymocytes,thymocyte/T-cell profile and peripheral T-cell number

Our laboratory has previously demonstrated the presence of constitutively expressed mitochondrial uncoupling protein 1 in mouse thymocytes. In our endeavours to understand the role of mitochondrial uncoupling protein 1 in thymocyte function, we compared cell profiles in thymus and spleen of wild-type with those of UCP 1 knock-out mice, which in turn led to comparative investigations of apoptotic potential in thymocytes from these mice. We demonstrate that spleen cell numbers were reduced ～ 3-fold in UCP 1 knock-out mice compared to wild-type mice. We record a halving of CD8 single positive cell numbers in thymus with a significant incremental increase in CD4/CD8 double positives cell numbers in the thymus of UCP 1 knock-out mice compared to wild-type mice. These data are mirrored by an approximate halving of CD8 single positive cell numbers and a doubling of CD4/CD8 double positive cell numbers in the spleen of UCP 1 knock-out mice compared to wild-type mice. These differences are most probably explained by our observations of decreased apoptotic potential and higher ATP levels in thymocytes of UCP 1 knock-out mice when compared to wild-type controls. We conclude that constitutively expressed UCP 1 is a factor in determining T-cell population selection in mice.     

Con A-stimulated thymocytes produce interleukin 2 after removal of Lyt-1 positive cells

Mouse lymphocytes produce several lymphokines, including interleukin 2 (IL-2) and colony-stimulating factors (CSFs) following stimulation with T-cell mitogens. However, very little IL-2 is produced by thymocytes upon concanavalin A (Con A) stimulation. Strong selective inhibition of IL-2 production was observed when fresh spleen cells were mixed with Con A-activated thymocytes. Sorting of populations on the basis of antigenic phenotype showed that the cell mediating the blockage in IL-2 secretion is a large T cell expressing markers for both Lyt-1 and Lyt-2. This specific inhibition of IL-2 accumulation was not mediated by a soluble product, or by absorption on expressed IL-2 receptors on the activated thymocytes. Removal of the Lyt-1 positive cells from a thymocyte population renders it capable to produce IL-2 upon Con A stimulation, indicating a functional role of these cells.     

Autoreactive antibody-forming cells directed against thymocytes and thymus-derived lymphocytes.

Antibody-forming cells with specificities against syngeneic and allogeneic thymocytes are detected in the spleens of normal mice after activation in vitro or in vivo with lipopolysaccharide (LPS). The activity of such cells was measured in a complement-dependent plaque assay employing trypan blue dye to assess zones of lysis. Plaques were rarely seen in the absence of LPS treatment. Anti-immunoglobulin added to the plaque assay abrogated the appearance of plaques, but the addition of LPS had no effect. Furthermore, plaque formation was 2-mercaptoethanol sensitive indicating that the antibody responsible was of the IgM class. Plaque forming cells (PFC) were also detected against syngeneic and allogeneic lymph node cells and to a much lesser extent against splenocytes. The numbers of PFC found against syngeneic, allogeneic, or a mixture of thymocytes was similar and ranged from 1000 to 3000 PFC/10(8) viable spleen cells tested. All murine strains tested, including congenitally athymic nude mice, exhibited anti-thymocyte PFC after LPS activation. C3H/HeJ mice, genetically unresponsive to LPS, did not respond mitogenically to LPS and no anti-thymocyte plaques were observed. These findings suggest that clones of autoreactive B cells are present in normal mice and can be activated by LPS.     

Suppression of natural killer (NK) cell activity of spleen cells by thymocytes

The in vitro influence of thymus cells on natural killer cell activity of spleen cells against prelabeled target cells (YAC-I and RL♂I) has been studied in syngeneic as well as in allogeneic murine models. In mixing experiments to demonstrate suppression, total thymocytes have been found to have no effect on NK activity of syngeneic or allogeneic spleen cells. Among several thymocyte fractions separated by velocity sedimentation, a relatively faster sedimenting fraction showed remarkable suppression of NK activity by spleen cells against two target cells. The suppressive effect of this particular fraction on NK activity was demonstrated to be proportional to the cell dose. The suppressive function was resistant to irradiation at 1000 or 2000 rad administered in vitro and was not restricted by the major histocompatibility complex. Moreover, the thymocyte fraction which induced suppression was not sensitive to NK-mediated cytolysi? by syngeneic spleen cells. The suppression of NK cytolysis in vitro by certain subpopulations of thymocytes as observed in the present studies may be consistent with a role for the thymus in regulating NK activity in vivo.     

Dysfunction of thymocytes of C3H/HeJ mice in blastogenic response to anti-thymocyte serum in vitro and its repair with lipopolysaccharide induced mediator.

In vitro mitogenic responses of thymocytes to rabbit anti-mouse thymocyte serum (ATS) have been compared in several mouse strains. The response of thymocytes of C3H/HeJ mice is about one-third of those of thymocytes of C3H/He, ATL or ATH strains. Phenol-extracted bacterial lipopolysaccharide (LPS) does not induce mitogenic response in cultured C3H/HeJ spleen cells, but the spleen cells of all other strains used are capable of responding to LPS. The low response of C3H/HeJ thymocytes to ATS is restored by adding “endotoxin soup” prepared from spleen cell cultures of LPS-responder mice in the presence of LPS. Neither soup prepared from C3H/HeJ spleen cell cultures without the addition of LPS nor soup prepared from cell cultures with LPS show such restoration of the response of C3H/HeJ thymocytes to ATS. The molecular size of the active factor in “endotoxin soup” was estimated on a Sepharose CL-4B column and determined to be about 20,000 daltons. The activity of “endotoxin soup” is destroyed by heating at 70 C for 30 min or 80 C for 10 min and diminished by digestion with trypsin. The mechanisms of restoration of low response of C3H/HeJ thymocytes to ATS by “endotoxin soup” are discussed.     

Formation of IgM-binding factors by murine thymocytes

Normal mouse thymocytes activated with concanavalin A (Con A) released soluble factors which selectively inhibited rosette formation between human peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) and ox erythrocytes (E_O) sensitized with rabbit IgM antibodies. The factors were removed by absorption with mouse IgM-coupled Sepharose, and were recovered from the beads by elution at acid pH. They neither bound to mouse IgG-Sepharose nor inhibited rosette formation of PBL with E_o sensitized with rabbit IgG antibodies. Mouse IgM enhanced the formation of IgM-binding factors by Con A-activated thymocytes. Unstimulated normal mouse thymocytes also released IgM-binding factors upon incubation with mouse IgM. The molecular weights of IgM-binding factors were approximately 90–110 and 35–50 kDa as estimated by gel filtration. Each species of IgM-binding factors markedly suppressed the IgM-plaque-forming cell (PFC) response of sheep red blood cell-primed spleen cells and slightly suppressed the IgG PFC response.     

Helper cell function of human fetal thymocytes

The role of human fetal thymocytes in the regulation of IgG and IgM production was examined. In pokeweed mitogen (PWM)-driven cocultures between thymocytes and normal adult peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMs) significantly enhanced secretion of both IgM (350% expected; P < 0.02) and IgG (450% expected; P < 0.001) was observed. In contrast, adult PBMs or adult T cells neither suppressed nor enhanced IgM or IgG production in coculture with allogeneic adult PBMs. Enhanced immunoglobulin secretion was not found when fetal thymocytes were cocultured with the T-cell-depleted fraction of adult PBMs. These results suggest that human fetal thymocytes (as early as 12 weeks gestational age) can provide helper cell function for both IgM and IgG secretion in PWM-driven cell cultures; however, a more mature T-cell effector is required for expression of this helper function.     

Proliferation and cytotoxicity of thymus lymphocytes in vitro]

Proliferative and cytollytical activity of lymphocytes was compared in lymphocyte alloimmunization of the spleen and intact thymus. The count of live cells and DNA-synthesizing cells in the thymocyte monoculture was 10--15-fold, and in mixed thymus cell culture--about 5-fold lower than the corresponding amounts of spleen cells. The index of immune thymocyte stimulation was several times greater than that of the immune cells of the spleen. The cytotoxicity peak was observed on the 4th--5th day of stimulation when the cytolytic activity of the immune thymocytes approached the action of the immune cells of the spleen. Low DNA synthesis and a marked cytotoxic activity of immune thymocytes signified that stimulation of the thymus cells in vitro permitted to obtain cell population with a high content of cytolytic T-lymphocytes.     

A spleen-derived maturational factor allows immature thymocytes, prepared as cells bearing low amounts of surface sialic acid, to become cytotoxic T cells

A population of immature mouse thymocytes bears low levels of surface sialic acid and can be separated from the more mature high sialic acid-bearing thymocytes by selective agglutination with the sialic acid-specific lectin, lobster agglutinin 1. These immature thymocytes do not proliferate in response to concanavalin A (Con A). They do not produce interleukin 2 (IL-2), do not provide T cell help to B cells for an in vitro antibody response, and as shown here, do not become cytotoxic T lymphocytes when polyclonally stimulated with Con A + IL-2. We describe here a spleen-derived maturational factor which stimulates these immature thymocytes, in the presence of Con A and IL-2, to become cytotoxic T lymphocytes. The maturational factor is a protein secreted by Con A-stimulated mouse or rat spleen cells; it is apparently neither interleukin 1, IL-2, interleukin 3, gamma-interferon, nor combinations of these cytokines, because these materials do not replace the maturational factor. The active material in Con A-stimulated mouse spleen cell supernatant was recovered from a G-75 column in the 33,000-48,000 m.w. range. These experiments suggest that within the lobster agglutinin 1-negative thymocyte population there are cells which can mature under the influence of a spleen-derived factor. It is possible that these cells represent the small subpopulation of immature cells destined to become immunocompetent peripheral T cells. On the other hand, the factor may be rescuing cells destined to die in the thymus.     

Differentiation of lymphoid cells: the preferential binding of the lipid A moiety of lipopolysaccharide to B lymphocyte populations.

Lipid A, prepared from lipopolysaccharide, was labeled with 125 I. Such iodinated lipid A possesses the full mitogenic activity of untreated lipid A. Comparison of the 125 I-lipid A-binding activity of splenocytes and thymocytes from the same rabbit revealed that the extent of labeling of splenocytes was 10 to 20 times greater than that observed with an equivalent number of thymocytes. A similar preferential binding was detected in comparing cells in mouse and rat. Spleen populations depleted of adherent cells were essentially unaltered with regard to binding when compared to the original population. In addition, spleen cell populations enriched for thymus-derived cells (T cells) exhibited a marked loss of specific binding activity. On the other hand, spleen cell populations enriched for bone marrow-derived cells (B cells) exhibited the expected binding. The difference in binding behavior of B and T cell-enriched populations was confirmed by using three independent techniques to separate B and T cells. These findings are consistent with the mitogenic specificity of lipid A toward B cells rather than T cells and suggest that the observed cellular specificity resides in an early event in mitogenesis, i.e., binding of the mitogen.     

Requirement for three distinct lymphokines for the induction of cytotoxic T lymphocytes from thymocytes

The induction of cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) from CTL precursors requires a combination of antigen and lymphokine signals. To investigate lymphokine requirements for CTL generation, we used an assay in which helper T cell and accessory cell-depleted spleen cells or whole thymocytes were cultured with lectin (Con A) and lymphokines. This culture was followed by assessment of lectin-dependent cytolysis. High concentrations of recombinant interleukin 2 (R-IL 2) (100 U/ml) alone were not sufficient for lectin-mediated CTL induction from thymocytes, whereas 20 to 100 U/ml of R-IL 2 alone could induce a significant lectin-mediated CTL response from accessory cell-depleted spleen cells. Using thymocytes as responders, we found purified or recombinant interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) did not cause cytolytic activity either in the absence of or in the presence of R-IL 2. However, supernatant from Con A-stimulated rat spleen cells (rat Con A SN) in combination with R-IL 2 could induce cytolytic activity, suggesting that several factors are required for CTL induction. Con A SN was fractionated by gel filtration and the fractions were tested for ability to induce CTL. In the presence of a low level of R-IL 2 (5 U/ml), fractions with a Mr of approximately 31,000 could induce CTL, and this activity was referred to as CTL differentiation factor (CDF). The peak fractions containing CDF activity did not have detectable IL 1, IL 2, IFN-gamma, or CSF activity. However, by add-back experiments and the use of blocking antibodies, a monoclonal antibody against the IL 2 receptor or antibodies against murine IFN-gamma, we demonstrated that CTL induction from mature thymocytes (L3T4-, Lyt-2+) requires CDF activity in addition to IL 2 and IFN-gamma.     

Distinct patterns of lymphokine requirement for the proliferation of various subpopulations of activated thymocytes in a single cell assay

The frequency and capacity for clonal expansion of several murine thymocyte subpopulations responsive to various IL (fetal day 15, and adult CD4-8-, CD4+8- and CD4-8+) were investigated using a single-cell limiting-dilution cell culture system without filler cells. This assay requires the presence of PMA and ionomycin. The main conclusions of these studies are the following: 1) IL-4 is a better growth factor than IL-2 for immature thymocytes (fetal day 15 or adult CD4-8-). 2) IL-2 is a better growth factor than IL-4 for mature phenotype thymocytes (CD4+8- and CD4-8+). 3) IL-4 is a relatively poor growth factor for adult CD4-CD8- thymocytes and CD4+CD8- thymocytes, while it induced strong responses in fetal day 15 and CD4-8+ thymocytes. 4) IL-6 enhanced the response of CD4+8- thymocytes to either IL-2 or IL-4. 5) Cortisone-resistant thymocytes grown initially with IL-4 and then switched to IL-2 showed a significant decrease in cloning efficiency. No inhibitory effect was observed when cells were cultured first with IL-2 and then switched to IL-4. 6) Finally, supernatant from Con-A stimulated rat spleen cells induced maximal growth of all adult thymocyte populations tested, suggesting that unidentified thymocyte growth factor(s) remain to be characterized. These results indicate that the maturational stage of thymocytes determines their requirements for activation and proliferation.     

Syngeneic responses by murine thymocytes: a role for non-MHC and non-MLS genes

A subpopulation of thymocytes from adult mice that is nonadherent to macrophage monolayers showed dramatically increased syngeneic mixed leukocyte responses (SMLR). Cloned cells were derived by limiting dilution from these SMLR-primed BALB/c thymocytes and were maintained and subcloned by repeated stimulation with syngeneic BALB/c spleen cells without the addition of exogenous interleukins. The cloned thymocytes were tested for their reactivities against H-2- and Mls-identical BALB/c and B10.D2 spleen cells (H-2d, Mlsb). We found that BALB/c and B10.D2 stimulator cells differed significantly in their capacity to restimulate the cloned BALB/c thymocytes. In addition, polyclonal syngeneic mixed leukocyte cultures (SMLC) of BALB/c thymocytes also showed differential restimulation by BALB/c and B10.D2 stimulators. Taken together, our data indicate a role for the product(s) specified by non-MHC and non-Mls gene(s) in the autorecognition by thymocytes.     

Degree of chromatin fragmentation and frequency of nuclear pyknosis in Percoll-fractionated thymocytes of irradiated rats

The relationship between nuclear chromatin degradation to polydeoxyribonucleotides (PDN) and other features of interphase death were studied using thymocytes of normal and X-irradiated rats. Fractionation of the thymic cells in Percoll gradients was performed in order to separate dead from intact cells. The degree of radiation-induced chromatin fragmentation, as assessed by electrophoresis, was similar for PDN from all Percoll bands. Following irradiation 87-98 per cent of 'heavy' thymocytes were pyknotic and almost devoid of receptors to autologous erythrocytes thus comprising a dead cell population. A direct relationship between PDN content and nuclear pyknosis was noted throughout the gradient. The loss of autologous rosette-forming ability was directly related to other indices of interphase death. The possibility of PDN originating from pyknosis-prone cells and the capacity of radiosensitive thymocytes to form autologous rosettes are discussed.