A comparison of several published methods for barley anther culture

A number of methods have been published for barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) anther culture and have gained acceptance in different laboratories. The breeder's requirement is for a compromise method that gives good, repeatable results for a wide range of genotypes. Yet the routine production of spontaneously doubled haploid green regenerants remains difficult. Despite attempts to formulate a widely-applicable anther culture method, the 4 main published methods, compared here with one modified procedure, are quite distinct for a number of important characteristics. The methods interacted strongly with the 3 genotypes, and response ranged from zero to 28 green regenerants per 100 anthers plated. The current methods still require often substantial modification to suit local situations in order that the technology may be exploited by barley breeders.Abbreviations BAP benzylaminopurine - DH doubled haploid - FV final volume - IAA indoleacetic acid - IBA indole-3-butyric acid - MS Murashige & Skoog - PABA para-aminobenzoic acid     

Barley anther culture using membrane rafts

When compared to agarose solidified media in small petri dishes, membrane rafts used in conjunction with liquid induction media significantly improved anther culture response in the Australian, malting-quality, spring barley cultivar Clipper. In contrast, the German cultivar Gimpel did not show an increased response on rafts.Abbreviations BA 6-benzylaminopurine - IAA indoleacetic acid - DH doubled haploid     

Somatic embryogenesis,plant regeneration and somaclonal variation in barley

In vitro culture of immature embryo and young leaf tissues was carried out with five cultivars of barley, Hordeum vulgare. Two cultivars (Albacete and Porthos) responded poorly from both types of explants, while the three others (Dissa, Golden Promise and Ingrid) produced a high frequency of embryogenic callus from these explants (25–60%). For Dissa and Ingrid, young leaf explants were slightly better than immature embryo explants for embryogenic callus induction, while immature embryo cultures of Golden Promise responded better than young leaf explants. Thus, there appears to be a significant genotype × explant interaction in the initiation of embryogenic callus in barley.Some phenotypic variants were detected among the regenerated plants of Golden Promise and Ingrid, most originating by epigenetic changes. Only in one case was the variant phenotype heritable, probably due to a mutation in the chloroplast DNA. Mitotic alteractions were not detected. Consequently, somaclonal variation did not appear to be a very frequent event in plants regenerated from 1- to 6- month-old cultures of barley.     

The influence of genotype and temperature pre-treatment on anther culture response in barley (Hordeum vulgare L.)

The influence of temperature stress pre-treatment on anther culture response has been examined in eight commercially desirable barley cultivars. Spikes were pre-treated in darkness at 4°C for periods of 0, 7, 14, 21 and 28 days. Overall, the optimum pre-treatment period was 21 days, although there were large genotype by pre-treatment interactions. The most responsive cultivar was Igri, with a mean of 38% anthers responding, and relatively little effect of pre-treatment. The greatest effect of pre-treatment was in cv. Heriot, which had 3% response with no pre-treatment and 52% response from 14 days pre-treatment.     

Improved plant regeneration from barley callus cultures by increased copper levels

Incorporation of cupric sulfate into callus induction, maintenance, and regeneration media significantly enhanced plant regeneration from callus cultures of barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) immature embryos. Embryos from the cultivars Hector and Excel were cultured on MS medium containing 0, 0.1 (MS level), 0.5, 1.0, 5.0, 10.0, 50.0, or 100.0 M cupric sulfate. Plants were regenerated beginning at 8 weeks and continuing through 36 weeks. For Hector, medium containing 50 M copper regenerated significantly more plants than any other medium, with an average of 17 plants per embryo. In comparison, medium with MS copper levels (0.1 M) regenerated only 5 plants per embryo. For Excel, medium containing 5.0 M copper was the best, regenerating 1.4 plants per embryo. No Excel regenerants were obtained on medium with MS copper levels. Increased copper levels also increased the percentage of embryos that regenerated at least one plant, in both cultivars. The results indicate that MS copper levels are not optimized for barley callus cultures, and that improved plant regeneration can be obtained at higher copper concentrations.Abbreviations MS Murashige & Skoog (1962) - 2,4-d 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid The US Government's right to retain a non-exclusive royalty-free license on and to any copyright is acknowledged     

The agronomic performance of anther culture derived plants of barley produced via pollen embryogenesis

Anther culture was used to generate microspore-derived doubled haploid (DH) plants from four spring barley crosses. The culture medium used contained maltose as the sole carbohydrate source and the mode of plantlet regeneration was mainly via pollen embryogenesis. Both haploid and spontaneously doubled regenerants were produced and the doubled haploids were compared to recom-binant inbred lines generated by several rounds of selfing (single seed descent). Parental, DH and single seed descent (SSD) lines were grown in randomised, replicated field trials and the samples were scored for a range of agronomic traits. The mean performance and phenotypic distribution of the DH and SSD samples were similar and there was little evidence to support the conclusion that anther culture derived lines exhibit a reduction in vigour. Where significant differences were detected between groups these were mainly confined to crosses which were segregating for the denso dwarfing gene. The differential transmission of particular regions of the barley genome may therefore influence and confound the expression of agronomic traits in DH populations. This is the first report of the agronomic performance of anther culture lines produced via pollen embryogenesis and the results are discussed in relation to the exploitation of anther culture technology in barley breeding.     

Rapid production of recombinant barley yellow mosaic virus resistant Hordeum vulgare lines by anther culture

Summary In a winter barley breeding program for barley yellow mosaic virus (BaYMV) resistance, the resistant six-rowed cv. Franka was crossed to 17 susceptible and two resistant cultivars, three of which were tworowed. A total of 233,445 anthers of the 19 hybrids and their parents were cultured and 831 green plants regenerated. Anther culture responsiveness varied greatly between genotypes, and the responsiveness of F₁hybrids was generally related to that of the more responsive (high) parent. On average, 3.6 green plants were recovered from 1,000 cultured anthers, almost twice as many as in comparable spring barley experiments. Androgenetic green plants were tested for their reaction to mechanical inoculation of BaYMV. In crosses of resistant parents, all the cross progeny proved to be resistant, which indicates that both parents carry identical gene(s). In the crosses of the resistant cv. Franka to susceptible parents, an average of 62% of the androgenetic progenies were resistant, which indicates that probably more than one gene is responsible for Franka's BaYMV-resistance. From the crosses of Franka to two-rowed cultivars, 282 androgenetic plants were produced. When 132 of these were tested for their reaction to BaYMV, 79 (59.8%) were resistant, and 30 of the latter were shown to be two-rowed recombinant lines. Doubled haploid lines are field-tested for other agronomic characters including grain yield and its components.     

Ethylene influences green plant regeneration from barley callus

The plant hormone ethylene is involved in numerous plant processes including in vitro growth and regeneration. Manipulating ethylene in vitro may be useful for increasing plant regeneration from cultured cells. As part of ongoing efforts to improve plant regeneration from barley (Hordeum vulgare L.), we investigated ethylene emanation using our improved system and investigated methods of manipulating ethylene to increase regeneration. In vitro assays of regeneration from six cultivars, involving 10 weeks of callus initiation and proliferation followed by 8 weeks of plant regeneration, showed a correlation between regeneration and ethylene production: ethylene production was highest from ‘Golden Promise’, the best regenerator, and lowest from ‘Morex’ and ‘DH-20’, the poorest regenerators. Increasing ethylene production by addition of 1-aminocyclopropane 1-carboxylic acid (ACC) during weeks 8–10 increased regeneration from Morex. In contrast, adding ACC to Golden Promise cultures during any of the tissue culture steps reduced regeneration, suggesting that Golden Promise may produce more ethylene than needed for maximum regeneration rates. Blocking ethylene action with silver nitrate during weeks 5–10 almost doubled the regeneration from Morex and increased the Golden Promise regeneration 1.5-fold. Silver nitrate treatment of Golden Promise cultures during weeks 8–14 more than doubled the green plant regeneration. These results indicate that differential ethylene production is related to regeneration in the improved barley tissue culture system. Specific manipulations of ethylene were identified that can be used to increase the green plant regeneration from barley cultivars. The timing of ethylene action appears to be critical for maximum regeneration.     

Effects of chromosome reconstruction of barley genome on tissue culture response using two different regeneration systems

Mature embryos and seedlings from mature embryos of one standard and five reconstructed karyotypes of barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) were cultured in vitro to study the influence of repositioning of particular chromosome segments of barley genome on the regeneration response. A comparative analysis of the regeneration response of a reconstructed karyotype having complete and well characterized rearrangement of the chromosome complement, and its four parental lines were used as experimental material. Depending on the source of explants two systems of in vitro culture were applied. The regeneration ability was found to be significantly influenced by both chromosome reconstruction and protocol applied. Possible reasons underlying the effects of chromosomal reconstruction on the regeneration response of karyotypes are briefly discussed.     

Cold pretreatment to enhance green plant regeneration from rye anther culture

Cold pretreatment of detached tillers of rye, Secale cereale, was tested under two light regimes. The ryes included two spring and two winter cultivars. Significant increases in green plant regeneration were recorded in each experiment when cold pretreatments of two to four weeks were applied. Dim light during the stress period improved green plant regeneration for two of the four cultivars tested. The highest regeneration rate, 30.6 green plants per 100 plated anthers, was reached following three weeks at +4 °C under dim light, for spring rye Jo02. Starvation stress applied to plated anthers in mannitol medium suppressed anther response. This revised version was published online in June 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

High frequency somatic embryogenesis and plant regeneration from papaya hypocotyl callus

High frequency somatic embryogenesis in papaya (Carica papaya L.) tissue cultures was achieved by culturing hypocotyl sections from ten-day-old seedlings on half-strength Murashige and Skoog salts (MS) medium containing modified MS vitamins, 2.3 to 112.5 M 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-d), 400 mg l^-1 glutamine, and 6% sucrose. Four hermaphroditic Hawaiian cultivars produced embryogenic calluses after ten to 14 weeks of culture at 27°C in the dark. Efficiency in embryogenic response of genotypes differed, Kapoho > Sunset > Sunrise > Waimanalo. The frequency of embryogenesis in induction medium containing 4.5 M 2,4-d was lowest with 3% sucrose and highest with 7% sucrose. Somatic embryos developed directly from embryogenic calluses on induction medium, or, more often, they differentiated from calluses subcultured on a medium devoid of growth regulators. Between 50 and 500 embryos were produced from each 2-mm hypocotyl section after at least two months on induction medium and two months on maturation medium. Embryos subsequently developed into normal-looking plants on MS medium. Shoot cuttings from germinated embryos and micropropagated plants were rooted with 5.0 M indole-3-butyric acid (IBA), grown in the greenhouse, and transferred to the field.Journal Series no. 3732 of the Hawaii Institute of Tropical Agriculture and Human Resourees     

Effect of anther orientation on microspore-callus production in barley (Hordeum vulgare L.)

Barley anthers from cold pretreated spikes produced no or few calluses when plated with both loculi in contact with the medium (flat). When anthers were plated with only one loculus in contact with the medium (up), a high proportion of the anthers produced calluses. The top loculus of the up anthers was most productive. Flat anthers, when compared with up anthers, were not only slower to produce multicellular pollen grains (MCPs) and microcalluses, but also produced fewer of them and ceased production earlier. The MCPs and microcalluses in flat anthers grew more slowly and few developed beyond the 30 cell stage. These results establish the importance of anther orientation for barley anther culture.     

Plant regeneration by pollen embryogenesis from cultured whole spikes of barley (Hordeum vulgare)

Summary Pollen embryogenesis and subsequent plant regeneration have been established from cultured whole barley spikes in agitated N6 liquid medium (Chu 1978) containing high levels of 2,4-D, Ficoll and potato extract. Microspore division within the anthers and subsequent embryogenic development were obtained in medium containing high amounts of reduced nitrogen with Zeatin, NAA and BAP (all at 0.5 mg/l levels, pH 6.2). Once embryoids were formed in the liquid medium, they produced secondary embryoids from the scutellum and subsequently plants on MS (Murashige and Skoog 1962) agar medium containing BAP and NAA. The ratio of green plants to albino was 18.7.     

Protein markers for anther culturability in barley

Two-dimensional electrophoresis of proteins from a recombinant population of anther culture-derived doubled haploid lines identified 4 loci or linkage groups showing a deviation from an expected 11 segregation. It was hypothesized that these markers are linked to genes involved in the process of haploid plant production and that the deviation was due to a selection for alleles conferring higher anther culture response. To check this hypothesis, the anther culturability of 50 of the doubled haploid lines and their two inbred parents was assessed. It was found that 2 of the loci which had a distortion of segregation showed a significant effect on anther culture response, the most efficient allele being the most frequent in both loci. In addition, 2 more markers associated with anther culturability were found. One of the first mentioned 2 loci and one of the latter 2 were found to be linked to genes involved in both embryoid production and subsequent green plant regeneration. The remaining two were linked to genes involved only in green plant regeneration. Of the 4 favorable alleles 3 were inherited from one parent.     

Optimizing somatic embryogenesis and particle bombardment of barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) immature embryos

Summary A highly regenerable target tissue and a high-frequency DNA delivery system are required for the routine production of transgenic barley. This project separately optimized tissue culture and particle bombardment parameters. Immature zygotic embryos (0.7 to 1.2 mm) were excised and culture on B5L solid medium. Klages and H930-36 cultivars regenerated significantly more green plants than Sabarlis and Bruce. The regeneration pathway shifted from organogenesis to somatic embryogenesis when maltose was used as the medium carbohydrate source instead of sucrose. More somatic embryos were induced on 5 mg/liter 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid than 2 mg/liter. Gene delivery was optimized using anthocyanin regulatory genes as a transient marker. A 3-mm rupture disc-to-macrocarrier gap distance, a 1-day prebombardment embryo culture period, and a maltose carbohydrate source were each significantly better than other treatments. Double bombardments per plate, a 6-mm macrocarrier fly distance, and 650-psi rupture discs each had the highest number of transiently expressing cells in individual experiments, although the results were not statistically significant compared to the other treatments. Using the optimized parameters, over 200 cells routinely expressed anthocyanin in a bombarded immature embryo. In tissue culture experiments, 350 to 400 green plants regenerated per 100 immature embryos. The improvement of green plant regeneration and gene delivery forms a strong basis to develop a practical barley transformation system.     

Production of gynogenic haploids of Hordeum vulgare L.

Haploid plants were regenerated from cultured unfertilized ovaries of Hordeum vulgare L. (barley). Optimal response was obtained by the addition of 0.6 M 4-chloro-2-methylphenoxyacetic acid (MCPA), 2.8 M indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) and 4.4 M 6-benzyladenine (BA) in the N₆ medium. Further increase in the rate of callus formation and the number of green plants produced was possible with the addition of 90 g/l sucrose and 100 g/l coconut water. The stage of development of the ovaries at the time of culture was critical; the largest number of plants being produced by ovaries from flowers at the trinucleate stage of pollen.Abbreviations (BA) 6-benzyladenine - (MCPA) 4-chloro-2-methylphenoxyaceticacid - (2,4-D) 2,4-dichlorophenoxyaceticacid - (GA₃) gibberellic acid - (IAA) indole-3-acetic acid     

Screening salt-tolerant barley genotypes via F1 anther culture in salt stress media

Summary Anthers of two six-row barley cultivars Diamond (a germination salt sensitive cultivar) and Men Yuan Liang Lan (a germination salt tolerant cultivar), and their F₁ reciprocal crosses were cultured in liquid media containing 0, 0.4, 0.6, and 0.8% Na₂SO₄. A total of 138 green pollen plants were obtained: 7 from Na₂SO₄ media, 128 from Na₂SO₄ free medium. Seeds of two successive generations of 61 pollen plants were germinated in a series of Na₂SO₄ solution (0 to 5.5%). It was found that among 37 progenies from F₁ pollen in Na₂SO₄ free medium, 11 were as sensitive as Diamond, 12 were intermediate to the two parents, 7 were equal to the salt tolerant parent and 7 were more tolerant to Na₂SO₄ than Men Yuan Liang Lan. Whereas, no progeny from F₁ pollen in high salt media was as susceptible as the susceptible parent; 2 were intermediate, 2 were equal to the salt tolerant parent and 2 were more tolerant than the salt tolerant parent. The results indicate that culturing anthers in Na₂SO₄ media effectively eliminated salt susceptible progenies. All 16 microspore-derived lines of Diamond were as susceptible as Diamond to Na₂SO₄. The 5 lines from Men Yuan Liang Lan microspores were as resistant to Na₂SO₄ as Men Yuan Liang Lan. All of the lines breed-true. The results indicate that the lines exhibiting elevated levels of tolerance to salt probably resulted from recombination of genes rather than from spontaneous mutation.     

Barley anther culture: assessment of carbohydrate effects on embryo yield, green plant production and differential plastid development in relation with albinism

Sugars and polyols were tested at different steps of anther culture in barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) to elucidate their influence on both the overall yield of androgenesis and the structure of plastids in relation to albinism. During the pretreatment period, the osmotic regulation in the medium was beneficial to microspore embryogenesis regardless of the type and concentration of the tested osmoticum. The use of mannitol (300 mOsm/kg), sorbitol (180 mOsm/kg), PEG (240 mOsm/kg) and sucrose (180 mOsm/kg) gave the best results in terms of green plant production, although the influence of each substance differed according to the studied parameter. Similarly, during anther culture the regulation of the osmotic pressure in the medium had various effects, according to the osmoticum used. The best results were obtained using mannitol (364 mOsm/kg), providing 139.7 green plants per 100 plated anthers. Plastids were examined by electron microscopy following both pretreatment and culture. In the presence of mannitol and PEG, plastids did not accumulate starch at any stage of the protocol but they started to differentiate into chloroplasts in the microspore-derived embryos. Using sorbitol and sucrose, plastids differentiated poorly but accumulated large amounts of starch, suggesting that these sugars are metabolized by micropores and microspore derived structures. However, the accumulation of starch was not correlated with the occurrence of albinism. These results indicated that, in barley, the osmotic regulation was favourable to switch the microspore gametophytic program toward a sporophytic program regardless of the nature of the osmoticum. In addition, during the pretreatment period, mannito was found to be the most suitable osmoticum for subsequent embryo development.     

Tests for the presence of gametoclonal variation in barley and wheat doubled haploids produced using the Hordeum bulbosum system

Summary To investigate whether the Hordeum bulbosum system of doubled haploid production generates gametoclonal variation, populations of second generation doubled haploid lines were developed from first generation doubled haploid lines of two barley varieties and three wheat genotypes. In barley, no variation between doubled haploids from doubled haploids was detected for a range of quantitative characters, suggesting the absence of any gametoclonal effects. However, the original selfed-seed stocks were shown to contain cryptic allelic variation for some of the characters investigated. In wheat, gametoclonal variation was detected for ear emergence time, plant height and yield, and its components for two out of the three genotypes investigated. The type and range of variation was similar to that reported from studies of somaclonal variation from immature embryos and gametoclonal variation from anther culture. Generally, the effects appeared to reduce the yield performance of individual lines. The difference in response between the two species and the consequences for the use of the doubled haploid system in breeding programmes are discussed.     

The effect of selenium on sulfur uptake by barley and rice

Because of their chemical and physical similarities, plant uptake of S and Se are closely related. Barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) and rice (Oryza sativa L.) were grown in greenhouse solution culture to examine the synergistic interactions between SO₄ and Se⁶⁺ in plant uptake. In the presence of low concentrations of solution SO₄, shoot and root yields were decreased with additions of Se⁶⁺. However, when SO₄ was present in elevated concentrations, no Se-induced yield reduction occurred. A synergistic interaction between SO₄ and Se⁶⁺ caused an increase in the shoot S concentrations with increasing concentrations of Se⁶⁺ at low SO₄ solution concentrations. At elevated SO₄ concentrations, no synergism was osberved. Selenium had a lesser effect on the S concentration in plant roots.