EXPERIMENTALLY INDUCED CHROMOSOME ABERRATIONS IN PLANTS : II. THE EFFECT OF CYANIDE AND OTHER HEAVY METAL COMPLEXING AGENTS ON THE PRODUCTION OF CHROMOSOME ABERRATIONS BY X-RAYS

The discovery of Lilly and Thoday, that the presence of potassium cyanide (KCN) increases the production of chromosome aberrations by x-rays in anoxia, but has no effect on the production of chromosome aberrations by x-rays in air, was confirmed. In the presence of cyanide, the effect of a given dose of x-rays in nitrogen was found to be even greater than the effect of the same dose of x-rays in air. The cyanide effect on x-ray breakage in nitrogen was obtained at cyanide concentrations as low as 2 x 10^–5 M. The breakage obtained after the combined x-ray-cyanide treatments was of the x-ray type, as evidenced by the distribution of breaks within and between the chromosomes. A number of other heavy metal complexing agents as well as some other compounds were tested for their ability to increase x-ray breakage in nitrogen and air. Of these compounds only cupferron proved to be effective. The results are discussed and it is concluded that the increased x-ray breakage in the presence of cyanide or cupferron cannot be due to an accumulation of peroxides. Instead it is suggested that the cyanide effect may be due to a complex formation between the active agents and heavy metals, presumably iron, within the chromosomes. The consequences of this hypothesis on the concept of the "oxygen effect," are discussed.     

Experimentally induced chromosome aberrations in plants. I. The production of chromosome aberrations by cyanide and other heavy metal complexing agents

The finding of Lilly and Thoday that potassium cyanide produces structural chromosome changes in root tips of Vicia faba was confirmed. Like mustards, diepoxides, and maleic hydrazide, potassium cyanide seems to act on cells at early interphase. A tendency of cyanide breaks to be concentrated in heterochromatic segments of the chromosomes was evident. The production of chromosome aberrations by cyanide proved to be practically unaffected by the temperature during treatment. In agreement with Lilly and Thoday, the effect of potassium cyanide was found to be dependent on oxygen tension during treatment. The effect of potassium cyanide increases with increasing oxygen concentration up to 100 per cent oxygen. In the absence of oxygen, potassium cyanide was not completely inactive, but produced a low, though significant frequency of aberrations. Pretreatments with 2.4-dinitrophenol did not influence the effect of potassium cyanide. When bean roots were treated with potassium cyanide before a treatment with 8-ethoxycaffeine, or at the same time as they were treated with 8-ethoxycaffeine, the effect of 8-ethoxycaffeine was almost completely suppressed. The effects of a number of other heavy metal complexing agents were also tested. Sodium fluoride, potassium thiocyanate, carbon monoxide, o-phenanthroline, 2.2-bipyridine, and sodium azide were without radiomimetic effect under the conditions employed, and so was a mixture of sodium azide and sodium fluoride. A low, but quite significant, radiomimetic effect was obtained after treatments with sodium diethyldithiocarbamate, cupferron, and 8-hydroxyquinoline. Under anaerobic conditions, the effects of cyanide and cupferron were both quantitatively and qualitatively indistinguishable. Unlike the effect of cyanide, the effect of cupferron was not enhanced by the presence of oxygen. The effects of the same heavy metal complexing agents were tested on the activities of the enzymes catalase and peroxidase. The activities of both of these enzymes were found to be totally inhibited only by potassium cyanide. In the other cases, little correlation was found between ability to inhibit the activities of these enzymes and ability to produce chromosome aberrations. In a number of experiments, hydrogen peroxide was found to be without radiomimetic effect, whether alone or in combination with potassium cyanide. t-Butyl hydroperoxide proved to be active. The effect of t-butyl hydroperoxide was substantially increased by pretreatments with 2.4.-dinitrophenol. The results are discussed, and it is concluded that the observations made do not support the hypothesis that hydrogen peroxide is involved in the production of chromosome aberrations by potassium cyanide. The possibility that organic peroxides are involved cannot be excluded on the bases of the experimental results. As an alternative hypothesis, it is suggested that iron or other heavy metals are present in the chromosomes and that cyanide and other heavy metal complexing agents produce chromosome aberrations by reacting with these metals.     

EXPERIMENTALLY INDUCED CHROMOSOME ABERRATIONS IN PLANTS : I. THE PRODUCTION OF CHROMOSOME ABERRATIONS BY CYANIDE AND OTHER HEAVY METAL COMPLEXING AGENTS

The finding of Lilly and Thoday that potassium cyanide produces structural chromosome changes in root tips of Vicia faba was confirmed. Like mustards, diepoxides, and maleic hydrazide, potassium cyanide seems to act on cells at early interphase. A tendency of cyanide breaks to be concentrated in heterochromatic segments of the chromosomes was evident. The production of chromosome aberrations by cyanide proved to be practically unaffected by the temperature during treatment. In agreement with Lilly and Thoday, the effect of potassium cyanide was found to be dependent on oxygen tension during treatment. The effect of potassium cyanide increases with increasing oxygen concentration up to 100 per cent oxygen. In the absence of oxygen, potassium cyanide was not completely inactive, but produced a low, though significant frequency of aberrations. Pretreatments with 2.4-dinitrophenol did not influence the effect of potassium cyanide. When bean roots were treated with potassium cyanide before a treatment with 8-ethoxycaffeine, or at the same time as they were treated with 8-ethoxycaffeine, the effect of 8-ethoxycaffeine was almost completely suppressed. The effects of a number of other heavy metal complexing agents were also tested. Sodium fluoride, potassium thiocyanate, carbon monoxide, o-phenanthroline, 2.2-bipyridine, and sodium azide were without radiomimetic effect under the conditions employed, and so was a mixture of sodium azide and sodium fluoride. A low, but quite significant, radiomimetic effect was obtained after treatments with sodium diethyldithiocarbamate, cupferron, and 8-hydroxyquinoline. Under anaerobic conditions, the effects of cyanide and cupferron were both quantitatively and qualitatively indistinguishable. Unlike the effect of cyanide, the effect of cupferron was not enhanced by the presence of oxygen. The effects of the same heavy metal complexing agents were tested on the activities of the enzymes catalase and peroxidase. The activities of both of these enzymes were found to be totally inhibited only by potassium cyanide. In the other cases, little correlation was found between ability to inhibit the activities of these enzymes and ability to produce chromosome aberrations. In a number of experiments, hydrogen peroxide was found to be without radiomimetic effect, whether alone or in combination with potassium cyanide. t-Butyl hydroperoxide proved to be active. The effect of t-butyl hydroperoxide was substantially increased by pretreatments with 2.4.-dinitrophenol. The results are discussed, and it is concluded that the observations made do not support the hypothesis that hydrogen peroxide is involved in the production of chromosome aberrations by potassium cyanide. The possibility that organic peroxides are involved cannot be excluded on the bases of the experimental results. As an alternative hypothesis, it is suggested that iron or other heavy metals are present in the chromosomes and that cyanide and other heavy metal complexing agents produce chromosome aberrations by reacting with these metals.     

The Effect of Respiratory Inhibitors and Chelating Agents on the Frequencies of Chromosomal Aberrations Produced by X-Rays in Vicia

Nitrosophenylhydroxylamine-ammonium (cupferron), potassium cyanide, sodium azide, ethylenediaminetetraacetate (EDTA), α,α'-dipyridyl, and o-phenanthroline were tested (1) for their ability to enhance the frequencies of chromosomal aberrations produced by x-rays in the root tip cells of the broad bean, Vicia faba, and (2) for their ability to inhibit oxygen consumption of excised roots of the same plant. In all cases a close correlation was found between the inhibitory effect on respiration and the enhancement of the sensitivity to x-rays at low oxygen pressures. EDTA, dipyridyl, and o-phenanthroline did not affect respiration to any greater extent, and they were without influence on the radiosensitivity. Cyanide, azide, and cupferron, which strongly inhibited respiration, also increased the frequencies of chromosome aberrations produced by x-rays at low oxygen pressures. The relation between oxygen concentration and radiosensitivity was determined both in the presence and the absence of the respiratory inhibitor cupferron. When cupferron was present, the radiosensitivity was influenced by oxygen concentrations 30 times lower than those effective in the absence of the inhibitor. In an atmosphere of pure oxygen, an increase of radiosensitivity of about 20 per cent was obtained with cupferron, EDTA, and potassium cyanide.     

Factors limiting the number of radiation-induced chromosome exchanges. I. Distance: evidence from non-interaction of x-ray- and neutron-induced breaks

Soaked seeds of Vicia faba were exposed to fractionated doses of x-rays or x-rays and fast neutrons. When the two-hit (exchange) chromosome aberrations were scored at the first mitosis of the root tip, it was observed that with short fractionation times the radiation-induced breaks from the two x-ray doses could rejoin with one another to form exchanges in proportion to the square of the total dose. If, however, one dose was x-rays and the second neutrons, then no quantitatively determinable interaction occurred between the breaks induced by each of the doses, and the aberration yield was simply the sum of that induced by each fraction. The phenomenon of non-interaction as observed by these dose fractionation studies and also by the linear dose response curve for two-break aberrations induced by neutrons has led to calculations of the distance over which two breaks can rejoin. The distance is evidently much smaller than the previously accepted value of 1 micro.     

The effect of ethylnitrosourea on chromosome aberrations in vitro and in vivo.

The effect of ENU on (A) human chromosomes from blood lymphocyte cultures in vitro, and on (B) rat and mouse bone marrow chromosomes in vivo, was investigated. Doses of 25, 50, 100 and 200 mug/ml were tested in vitro and cells with chromosome breakage were found to be dose dependent. Chromosome damage was also dependent on time; maximum damage was seen when cells were treated 2--6 hrs before harvest. Two doses of 100 and 200 mg/kg were studied in rat and mouse in vivo and a dose effect could be shown in both species. The highest number of abnormal cells was found 6 hrs after treatment; there was a sharp decrease at 18 hrs and thereafer. Types of aberrations were also analyzed, in both in vitro and in vivo studies.     

Possible mechanisms of the occurrence of chromosome restructurings. IV. Chromosome restructurings in spontaneous mutagenesis

An attempt was undertaken to modify the spontaneous mutation process by varying its conditions in somatic cells of different species and tissues. The rate of chromosome aberrations and their types were studied in anaphase and metaphase. Under normal conditions, chromosome breaks were only found to occur. Breakage of chromosomes occurs during interphase, and as a result, acentric fragments are located outside the equatorial plate during metaphase. This process of chromosome breakage leads to elimination of some genetic material, without concomitant exchanges, and therefore, it has been named "elimination" process. Spontaneous chromosome mutagenesis manifesting itself at cytogenetic level was concluded to be an elimination process directed to elimination of a portion of chromatin from chromosomes. When the conditions of spontaneous mutagenesis are altered, in particular, by cardiovascular diseases in man, by partial inhibition of DNA repair in mice and pea cells, by transformation of Chinese hamster cells, upon ageing of pea seeds-qualitative changes in the chromosomal aberrations are registered, connected with the appearance of chromosome exchanges and acentric fragments situated within the equatorial plate during metaphase. These two types of chromosome aberrations are proposed to be considered as new criteria of pathology. A system of processes was suggested to exist, preventing the appearance of aberrations during mitosis, and it is supposed to be one of the most significant homeostatic systems.     

Extensive chromosome aberrations caused by [3H]thymidine incorporation in a diploid monkey cell line DBS-FRhL-2.

Extensive chromosome aberrations were induced in a diploid monkey cell line designated as DBS-FRhL-2 after exposure to [3H]thymidine ([3H]Tdr) for either 30 or 60 min at a dose of 1 muCi per ml of medium. Cultures exposed to [3H]Tdr for a longer period had significantly larger numbers of aberrations than those exposed for a shorter period. The most common type of aberrations were chromatid breaks. The majority of aberrations were observed in cells which were in contact with [3H]Tdr during S phase, especially the middle S. Cells from cultures of early and late passages exposed to [3H]Tdr were affected to a similar extent when chromosomes were examined. No clear relationship between sites of breakage and intensity of labeling could be established.     

Premature chromosome condensation. I. Visualization of x-ray-induced chromosome damage in interphase cells

A new method is described to visualize chromosome damage in interphase cells immediately after exposure to mutagenic agents. This method involves the fusion of treated interphase cells with untreated mitotic cells which results in the induction of premature chromosome condensation (PCC). Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells were treated with X-rays and chromosome aberrations were scored in G2-PCC and the mitotic chromosomes. The incidence of aberrations was significantly higher in PCC than that observed in the mitotic chromosomes of the treated cells. Post-irradiation incubation for I h before fusion allowed the repair of some of the chromosome damage. Data are also presented which indicate that the extent of radiation damage visualized in PCC is inversely proportional to the degree of chromosome condensation. These results indicate that the PCC method has a greater senstivity in the detection of induced chromosome damage than the standard method of scoring metaphase chromosomes.     

Factors Limiting the Number of Radiation-Induced Chromosome Exchanges : I. Distance: Evidence from Non-Interaction of x-Ray— and Neutron-Induced Breaks

Soaked seeds of Vicia faba were exposed to fractionated doses of x-rays or x-rays and fast neutrons. When the two-hit (exchange) chromosome aberrations were scored at the first mitosis of the root tip, it was observed that with short fractionation times the radiation-induced breaks from the two x-ray doses could rejoin with one another to form exchanges in proportion to the square of the total dose. If, however, one dose was x-rays and the second neutrons, then no quantitatively determinable interaction occurred between the breaks induced by each of the doses, and the aberration yield was simply the sum of that induced by each fraction. The phenomenon of non-interaction as observed by these dose fractionation studies and also by the linear dose response curve for two-break aberrations induced by neutrons has led to calculations of the distance over which two breaks can rejoin. The distance is evidently much smaller than the previously accepted value of 1 µ.     

Congenital chromosome breakage clusters within Giemsa-light bands and identifies sites of chromatin instability

Analysis of the distribution of published chromosome breaks in cells with constitutional chromosome aberrations showed a nonrandom distribution of breaks among chromosomes and chromosome regions. A significant amount of breakage occurred at Giemsa-negative bands. In addition, chromosome sites associated with a number of fragile sites and cellular oncogene sites were affected nonrandomly. The data are consistent with the hypothesis that chromosome breakage occurs in somatic or germ cells as a result of recombinational errors involving actively transcribing chromatin regions or regions of unstable DNA sequence structure placed in proximity during interphase.     

Effects of caffeine on chromosome aberrations and sister-chromatid exchanges induced by mitomycin C in BrdU-labeled human chromosomes.

The BrdU-Hoechst staining technique has been used in analyzing the effect of caffeine (CAF) on chromosome aberrations and sister-chromatid exchanges (SCEs) induced by mitomycin C (MC). CAF increased the frequency of SCE in MC-treated chromosomes in all specimens. The combination of MC and CAF caused a remarkable increase in all types of chromosome aberrations, but the most startling effect was the appearance of many cells with multiple aberrations (shattered chromosomes). The BrdU-Hoechst technique showed that the shattered chromosomes did not appear in cells that had replicated only once, but did occur in cells which replicated twice in the presence of MC and CAF. The large majority of chromatid breaks observed did not involve areas common to SCE; and the SCE frequency significantly increased in spite of the existence of multiple breaks. This indicates that very few of the breaks are incomplete exchanges and that the mechanism for formation of SCE might be different from that of chromosome breaks. In another experiment, monofunctional-MC (M-MC) had a small effect on SCE rates, though it induced shattered chromosomes with CAF post-treatment. Possible differences in the mechanisms leading to SCE and chromosome breaks are discussed.     

Analysis of chromosome aberrations in human peripheral lymphocytes induced by 5.4 keV x-rays

Irradiation of human lymphocytes by x-rays has been seen, in past studies, to produce increasing frequencies of chromosome aberrations at lower x-ray energies. However, in one earlier irradiation experiment with chromium x-rays, the relative biological effectiveness (RBE) did not appear to be larger than that of hard x-rays, especially at higher doses. A possible reason for this unexpected result may have been the irradiation and culture conditions. We have, therefore, in the present study used a technique that has been developed in our laboratory to ensure uniformity of irradiation within lymphocytes and to avoid artefacts due to the cell cycle kinetics. Monolayers of 3-h-stimulated lymphocytes were exposed to 5.4 keV x-rays. A linear-quadratic dose-response was found for dicentrics. The comparison to an earlier finding with 220 kV x-rays shows the expected result of the RBE of the 5.4 keV x-rays to be above that of 220 kV x-rays. The intercellular distribution of dicentrics did not differ significantly from a Poisson distribution. Received: 17 January 1997 / Accepted in revised form: 17 July 1997     

Linear dose-response of acentric chromosome fragments down to 1 R of x-rays in grasshopper neuroblasts, a potential mutagen-test system

Grasshopper-embryo neuroblasts have no spontaneous chromosome breakage; therefore they permit easy detection of agents that break chromosomes. An X-ray exposure of 1 R induces in them a detectable number of chromosome fragments. The dose-response of acentric fragment frequency fits a linear model between 0 and 128 R. Thus another cell type is added to those previously demonstrated to have no threshold dose for the induction of chromosome or gene mutations.     

Analysis of bleomycin- and cytosine arabinoside-induced chromosome aberrations involving chromosomes 1 and 4 by painting FISH

The genomic frequency of chromosomal aberrations obtained by chromosome painting is usually extrapolated from the observed frequency of aberrations by correcting for the DNA content of the labelled chromosomes. This extrapolation is based upon the assumption of random distribution of breakpoints from which aberrations are generated. However, the validity of this assumption has been widely questioned. While extensive investigations have been performed with ionizing radiation as chromosome breaking agent, little efforts have been done with chemical clastogens. In order to investigate interchromosomal differences in chemically-induced chromosome damage, we have used multicolour chromosome painting to analyse bleomycin-induced aberrations involving chromosomes 1 and 4, two chromosomes that differ in gene density. In addition, we have measured the effect of cytosine arabinoside upon the repair of bleomycin-induced DNA damage in chromosomes 1 and 4. Our results show that these chromosomes are equally sensitive to the clastogenic effect of bleomycin with a similar linear dose-effect relationship. However, the high gene density chromosome 1 appeared to be more sensitive to repair inhibition by Ara-C than chromosome 4. This enhanced sensitivity to repair inhibition in chromosome 1 could be mediated by preferential repair of open chromatin and actively transcribed regions.     

The effect of ethylnitrosourea on chromosome aberrations in vitro and in vivo

Summary The effect of ENU on (A) human chromosomes from blood lymphocyte cultures in vitro, and on (B) rat and mouse bone marrow chromosomes in vivo, was investigated. Doses of 25, 50, 100 and 200 g/ml were tested in vitro and cells with chromosome breakage were found to be dose dependent. Chromosome damage was also dependent on time; maximum damage was seen when cells were treated 2–6 hrs before harvest.Two doses of 100 and 200 mg/kg were studied in rat and mouse in vivo and a dose effect could be shown in both species. The highest number of abnormal cells was found 6 hrs after treatment; there was a sharp decrease at 18 hrs and thereafter. Types of aberrations were also analyzed, in both in vitro and in vivo studies.     

Premature chromosome condensation. II. The nature of chromosome gaps produced by alkylating agents and ultraviolet light

Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells were treated with ultraviolet radiation or the alkylating agents, nitrogen mustard or trenimon, and chromosome damage to G2 phase cells were scored by the premature chromosome condensation (PCC) method or the metotic chromosome method. Treatment with these agents produced gaps but not chromatid breaks or exchanges. After UV treatment, the gap frequency observed in G2-PCC was higher than in the mitotic chromosomes, while the reverse trend was observed after treatment with nitrogen mustard or trenimon. These results suggest that two types of chromosome gaps exist, both of which are observable in mitotic chromosomes while only one type is observable in PCC due to differences in the stages of condensation between PCC and mitotic chromosomes.     

A search for radioresistance in experimental populations of Drosophila with radiation histories

Human lymphocytes in the G₀ stage were irradiated with UV light and X-rays. A 2-fold increase in the yield of dicentrics was observed in comparison with the yield for X-rays alone. This synergistic effect was constant irrespective of the variation in the UV dose between 50 and 100 erg/mm².The individual chromosomes participated in interchange aberrations as expected from a random distribution per mitotic chromosome length unit. This observation is in contrast with the recent finding that X-ray-induced chromosome-type breakage is preferentially located on chromosomes with relatively large amounts of R-bands. Thus, the present data indicate that the additional breakage points, due to the synergism, had a different distribution between chromosomes from those induced by X-irradiation alone. Mechanisms that could account for the synergistic reaction are discussed.     

Specificity of daunomycin in causing chromosome aberrations in human leukocytes

When the chromosome aberrations induced in human leukocytes in culture with daunomycin (Dm) (0.015 g/ml, with or without added arginine) are analyzed with respect to sites of breakage and reunion, non-randomness is observed, both between and within chromosomes. These results suggest either a site-specificity of action of the drug or site-specific sensitivity or both. Superficially, the data give an indication of the phenomenon of somatic crossing-over having occurred. However, if chromosome breakage and reunions of broken ends are considered as two events, independent of each other, the frequency of exchanges between homologues and apparent homologues is lower than the expected frequency in cases of groups involving chromosomes 6–12/X and 13/15 and almost equal to the expected frequency in cases of chromosomes 1, 2 and 3.     

Lack of specificity of chromosome breaks resulting from radiation-induced genomic instability in Chinese hamster cells

In V79 Chinese hamster cells, radiation-induced genomic instability results in a persistently increased frequency of micronuclei, dicentric chromosomes and apoptosis and in decreased colony-forming ability. These manifestations of radiation-induced genomic instability may be attributed to an increased rate of chromosome breakage events many generations after irradiation. This chromosomal instability does not seem to be a property which has been inflicted on individual chromosomes at the time of irradiation. Rather, it appears to be secondary to an increased level of non-specific clastogenic factors in the progeny of most if not all irradiated cells. This conclusion is drawn from the observations presented here, that all the chromosomes in surviving V79 cells are involved in the formation of dicentric chromosome aberrations 1 or 2 weeks after irradiation with about equal probability if corrections are made for chromosome length. Received: 5 March 1998 / Accepted in revised form: 1 July 1998