Dissecting autophagosome formation: The missing pieces

The formation of autophagosomes is the central part of the macroautophagy pathway. Little is known, however, about how the participants in this process affect the membrane dynamics at the phagophore assembly site (PAS). Recently, we demonstrated that Atg8, a lipid-conjugated ubiquitin-like protein, controls the expansion of the phagophore. In addition, we showed that the autophagosome formation process can be traced and dissected by time-lapse fluorescence microscopy observation of GFP-Atg8. These findings constitute one step further in our understanding of autophagosome formation. Key questions remain open, however, on how the actions of other proteins at the PAS are coordinated with that of Atg8 and on the precise role of Atg8.

Addendum to: Xie Z, Nair U, Klionsky DJ. Atg8 controls phagophore expansion during autophagosome formation. Mol Biol Cell 2008; 19:3290-8.     

Dissecting autophagosome formation: the missing pieces

The formation of autophagosomes is the central part of the macroautophagy pathway. Little is known, however, about how the participants in this process affect the membrane dynamics at the phagophore assembly site (PAS). Recently, we demonstrated that Atg8, a lipid-conjugated ubiquitin-like protein, controls the expansion of the phagophore. In addition, we showed that the autophagosome formation process can be traced and dissected by time-lapse fluorescence microscopy observation of GFP-Atg8. These findings constitute one step further in our understanding of autophagosome formation. Key questions remain open, however, on how the actions of other proteins at the PAS are coordinated with that of Atg8 and on the precise role of Atg8.     

Atg8, a ubiquitin-like protein required for autophagosome formation, mediates membrane tethering and hemifusion

Autophagy involves de novo formation of double membrane-bound structures called autophagosomes, which engulf material to be degraded in lytic compartments. Atg8 is a ubiquitin-like protein required for this process in Saccharomyces cerevisiae that can be conjugated to the lipid phosphatidylethanolamine by a ubiquitin-like system. Here, we show using an in vitro system that Atg8 mediates the tethering and hemifusion of membranes, which are evoked by the lipidation of the protein and reversibly modulated by the deconjugation enzyme Atg4. Mutational analyses suggest that membrane tethering and hemifusion observed in vitro represent an authentic function of Atg8 in autophagosome formation in vivo. In addition, electron microscopic analyses indicate that these functions of Atg8 are involved in the expansion of autophagosomal membranes. Our results provide further insights into the mechanisms underlying the unique membrane dynamics of autophagy and also indicate the functional versatility of ubiquitin-like proteins.     

Dual roles of Atg8−PE deconjugation by Atg4 in autophagy

Modification of target molecules by ubiquitin or ubiquitin-like (Ubl) proteins is generally reversible. Little is known, however, about the physiological function of the reverse reaction, deconjugation. Atg8 is a unique Ubl protein whose conjugation target is the lipid phosphatidylethanolamine (PE). Atg8 functions in the formation of double-membrane autophagosomes, a central step in the well-conserved intracellular degradation pathway of macroautophagy (hereafter autophagy). Here we show that the deconjugation of Atg8?PE by the cysteine protease Atg4 plays dual roles in the formation of autophagosomes. During the early stage of autophagosome formation, deconjugation releases Atg8 from non-autophagosomal membranes to maintain a proper supply of Atg8. At a later stage, the release of Atg8 from intermediate autophagosomal membranes facilitates the maturation of these structures into fusion-capable autophagosomes. These results provide new insights into the functions of Atg8?PE and its deconjugation.     

Dual roles of Atg8-PE deconjugation by Atg4 in autophagy

Modification of target molecules by ubiquitin or ubiquitin-like (Ubl) proteins is generally reversible. Little is known, however, about the physiological function of the reverse reaction, deconjugation. Atg8 is a unique Ubl protein whose conjugation target is the lipid phosphatidylethanolamine (PE). Atg8 functions in the formation of double-membrane autophagosomes, a central step in the well-conserved intracellular degradation pathway of macroautophagy (hereafter autophagy). Here we show that the deconjugation of Atg8-PE by the cysteine protease Atg4 plays dual roles in the formation of autophagosomes. During the early stage of autophagosome formation, deconjugation releases Atg8 from non-autophagosomal membranes to maintain a proper supply of Atg8. At a later stage, the release of Atg8 from intermediate autophagosomal membranes facilitates the maturation of these structures into fusion-capable autophagosomes. These results provide new insights into the functions of Atg8-PE and its deconjugation.     

Mechanism and functions of membrane binding by the Atg5–Atg12/Atg16 complex during autophagosome formation

Autophagy is a conserved process for the bulk degradation of cytoplasmic material. Triggering of autophagy results in the formation of double membrane‐bound vesicles termed autophagosomes. The conserved Atg5–Atg12/Atg16 complex is essential for autophagosome formation. Here, we show that the yeast Atg5–Atg12/Atg16 complex directly binds membranes. Membrane binding is mediated by Atg5, inhibited by Atg12 and activated by Atg16. In a fully reconstituted system using giant unilamellar vesicles and recombinant proteins, we reveal that all components of the complex are required for efficient promotion of Atg8 conjugation to phosphatidylethanolamine and are able to assign precise functions to all of its components during this process. In addition, we report that in vitro the Atg5–Atg12/Atg16 complex is able to tether membranes independently of Atg8. Furthermore, we show that membrane binding by Atg5 is downstream of its recruitment to the pre‐autophagosomal structure but is essential for autophagy and cytoplasm‐to‐vacuole transport at a stage preceding Atg8 conjugation and vesicle closure. Our findings provide important insights into the mechanism of action of the Atg5–Atg12/Atg16 complex during autophagosome formation.     

Small but mighty: Atg8s and Rabs in membrane dynamics during autophagy

Autophagy is a degradative pathway during which autophagosomes are formed that enwrap cytosolic material destined for turnover within the lytic compartment. Autophagosome biogenesis requires controlled lipid and membrane rearrangements to allow the formation of an autophagosomal seed and its subsequent elongation into a fully closed and fusion-competent double membrane vesicle. Different membrane remodeling events are required, which are orchestrated by the distinct autophagy machinery. An important player among these autophagy proteins is the small lipid-modifier Atg8. Atg8 proteins facilitate various aspects of autophagosome formation and serve as a binding platform for autophagy factors. Also Rab GTPases have been implicated in autophagosome biogenesis. As Atg8 proteins interact with several Rab GTPase regulators, they provide a possible link between autophagy progression and Rab GTPase activity. Here, we review central aspects in membrane dynamics during autophagosome biogenesis with a focus on Atg8 proteins and selected Rab GTPases.     

Mammalian Atg8s: One is simply not enough

Yeast Atg8, a key factor in the autophagic process, is a ubiquitin-like protein that undergoes a unique conjugation to phosphatidylethanolamine (PE). Atg8 plays a dual role in early stages of autophagosome formation: It was implicated in recruitment of cargo proteins such as Atg19 and Atg32 for Cvt and mitophagy, respectively, and in autophagosome biogenesis, serving as an elongation factor by mediating membrane hemi-fusion. Similarly, the mammalian Atg8 proteins, LC3s and GABARAPs, recruit cargo into autophagosomes by binding to adaptor proteins such as p62, NBR1 and Nix. These functions, however, are not essential for bulk autophagic flux. Other studies in which the activity of the mammalian Atg8s was blocked either by knockout of the E2-like enzyme Atg3 or by using a dominant negative mutant of the promiscuous protease Atg4B revealed, in agreement with the yeast Atg8 data, that the mammalian factors are crucial for the formation of normal and mature autophagosomes. While it seems that the single yeast Atg8 and the mammalian Atg8s share similar roles, it is still unclear why the mammalian system employs several homologs. Recent publications demonstrated that the mammalian Atg8s differ in their cargo specificity, as Nix, for example, binds exclusively to GABARAP-L1. This may suggest that these proteins exhibit distinct activity also in autophagosome biogenesis. In our study we divided the mammalian Atg8s into two subfamilies of homologs based on amino acid similarity, the LC3 and GABARAP/GATE-16 subfamilies, and tested their essentiality and role in autophagy. In agreement with previous studies we found that the mammalian Atg8s are essential for autophagy but, more importantly, that each of these subfamilies has a distinct role in the process of autophagosome biogenesis.     

Atg9 vesicles are an important membrane source during early steps of autophagosome formation

During the process of autophagy, cytoplasmic materials are sequestered by double-membrane structures, the autophagosomes, and then transported to a lytic compartment to be degraded. One of the most fundamental questions about autophagy involves the origin of the autophagosomal membranes. In this study, we focus on the intracellular dynamics of Atg9, a multispanning membrane protein essential for autophagosome formation in yeast. We found that the vast majority of Atg9 existed on cytoplasmic mobile vesicles (designated Atg9 vesicles) that were derived from the Golgi apparatus in a process involving Atg23 and Atg27. We also found that only a few Atg9 vesicles were required for a single round of autophagosome formation. During starvation, several Atg9 vesicles assembled individually into the preautophagosomal structure, and eventually, they are incorporated into the autophagosomal outer membrane. Our findings provide conclusive linkage between the cytoplasmic Atg9 vesicles and autophagosomal membranes and offer new insight into the requirement for Atg9 vesicles at the early step of autophagosome formation.     

The Atg8 conjugation system is indispensable for proper development of autophagic isolation membranes in mice

Autophagy is an evolutionarily conserved bulk-protein degradation pathway in which isolation membranes engulf the cytoplasmic constituents, and the resulting autophagosomes transport them to lysosomes. Two ubiquitin-like conjugation systems, termed Atg12 and Atg8 systems, are essential for autophagosomal formation. In addition to the pathophysiological roles of autophagy in mammals, recent mouse genetic studies have shown that the Atg8 system is predominantly under the control of the Atg12 system. To clarify the roles of the Atg8 system in mammalian autophagosome formation, we generated mice deficient in Atg3 gene encoding specific E2 enzyme for Atg8. Atg3-deficient mice were born but died within 1 d after birth. Conjugate formation of mammalian Atg8 homologues was completely defective in the mutant mice. Intriguingly, Atg12–Atg5 conjugation was markedly decreased in Atg3-deficient mice, and its dissociation from isolation membranes was significantly delayed. Furthermore, loss of Atg3 was associated with defective process of autophagosome formation, including the elongation and complete closure of the isolation membranes, resulting in malformation of the autophagosomes. The results indicate the essential role of the Atg8 system in the proper development of autophagic isolation membranes in mice.     

A role for Atg8–PE deconjugation in autophagosome biogenesis

Formation of the autophagosome is likely the most complex step of macroautophagy, and indeed it is the morphological and functional hallmark of this process; accordingly, it is critical to understand the corresponding molecular mechanism. Atg8 is the only known autophagy-related (Atg) protein required for autophagosome formation that remains associated with the completed sequestering vesicle. Approximately one-fourth of all of the characterized Atg proteins that participate in autophagosome biogenesis affect Atg8, regulating its conjugation to phosphatidylethanolamine (PE), localization to the phagophore assembly site and/or subsequent deconjugation. An unanswered question in the field regards the physiological role of the deconjugation of Atg8–PE. Using an Atg8 mutant that bypasses the initial Atg4-dependent processing, we demonstrate that Atg8 deconjugation is an important step required to facilitate multiple events during macroautophagy. The inability to deconjugate Atg8–PE results in the mislocalization of this protein to the vacuolar membrane. We also show that the deconjugation of Atg8–PE is required for efficient autophagosome biogenesis, the assembly of Atg9-containing tubulovesicular clusters into phagophores/autophagosomes, and for the disassembly of PAS-associated Atg components.     

A role for Atg8-PE deconjugation in autophagosome biogenesis

Formation of the autophagosome is likely the most complex step of macroautophagy, and indeed it is the morphological and functional hallmark of this process; accordingly, it is critical to understand the corresponding molecular mechanism. Atg8 is the only known autophagy-related (Atg) protein required for autophagosome formation that remains associated with the completed sequestering vesicle. Approximately one-fourth of all of the characterized Atg proteins that participate in autophagosome biogenesis affect Atg8, regulating its conjugation to phosphatidylethanolamine (PE), localization to the phagophore assembly site and/or subsequent deconjugation. An unanswered question in the field regards the physiological role of the deconjugation of Atg8-PE. Using an Atg8 mutant that bypasses the initial Atg4-dependent processing, we demonstrate that Atg8 deconjugation is an important step required to facilitate multiple events during macroautophagy. The inability to deconjugate Atg8-PE results in the mislocalization of this protein to the vacuolar membrane. We also show that the deconjugation of Atg8-PE is required for efficient autophagosome biogenesis, the assembly of Atg9-containing tubulovesicular clusters into phagophores/autophagosomes, and for the disassembly of PAS-associated Atg components.     

Unraveling the role of myosin in forming autophagosomes

Macroautophagy (hereafter autophagy) is a membrane-mediated catabolic process that occurs in response to a variety of intra- and extra-cellular stresses. It is characterized by the formation of specialized double-membrane vesicles, autophagosomes, which engulf organelles and long-lived proteins, and in turn fuse with lysosomes for degradation and recycling. How autophagosomes emerge is still unclear. The Atg1 kinase plays a crucial role in the induction of autophagosome formation. While several Atg (autophagy-related) proteins have been associated with, and have been found to regulate, Atg1 kinase activity, the downstream targets of Atg1 that trigger autophagy remain unknown. Our recent studies have identified a myosin light chain kinase (MLCK)-like kinase as the Atg1 kinase effector that induces the activation of myosin II, and have found it to be required for autophagosome formation during nutrient deprivation. We further demonstrated that Atg1-mediated myosin II activation is crucial for the movement of the Atg9 transmembrane protein between the Golgi and the forming autophagosome, which provides a membrane source for the formation of autophagosomes during starvation.     

Unraveling the role of myosin in forming autophagosomes

Macroautophagy (hereafter autophagy) is a membrane-mediated catabolic process that occurs in response to a variety of intra- and extra-cellular stresses. It is characterized by the formation of specialized double-membrane vesicles, autophagosomes, which engulf organelles and long-lived proteins, and in turn fuse with lysosomes for degradation and recycling. How autophagosomes emerge is still unclear. The Atg1 kinase plays a crucial role in the induction of autophagosome formation. While several Atg (autophagy-related) proteins have been associated with, and have been found to regulate, Atg1 kinase activity, the downstream targets of Atg1 that trigger autophagy remain unknown. Our recent studies have identified a myosin light chain kinase (MLCK)-like kinase as the Atg1 kinase effector that induces the activation of myosin II, and have found it to be required for autophagosome formation during nutrient deprivation. We further demonstrated that Atg1-mediated myosin II activation is crucial for the movement of the Atg9 transmembrane protein between the Golgi and the forming autophagosome, which provides a membrane source for the formation of autophagosomes during starvation.     

The yeast autophagy protease Atg4 is regulated by thioredoxin

Autophagy is a membrane-trafficking process whereby double-membrane vesicles called autophagosomes engulf and deliver intracellular material to the vacuole for degradation. Atg4 is a cysteine protease with an essential function in autophagosome formation. Mounting evidence suggests that reactive oxygen species may play a role in the control of autophagy and could regulate Atg4 activity but the precise mechanisms remain unclear. In this study, we showed that reactive oxygen species activate autophagy in the model yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae and unraveled the molecular mechanism by which redox balance controls Atg4 activity. A combination of biochemical assays, redox titrations, and site-directed mutagenesis revealed that Atg4 is regulated by oxidoreduction of a single disulfide bond between Cys338 and Cys394. This disulfide has a low redox potential and is very efficiently reduced by thioredoxin, suggesting that this oxidoreductase plays an important role in Atg4 regulation. Accordingly, we found that autophagy activation by rapamycin was more pronounced in a thioredoxin mutant compared with wild-type cells. Moreover, in vivo studies indicated that Cys338 and Cys394 are required for the proper regulation of autophagosome biogenesis, since mutation of these cysteines resulted in increased recruitment of Atg8 to the phagophore assembly site. Thus, we propose that the fine-tuning of Atg4 activity depending on the intracellular redox state may regulate autophagosome formation.     

The yeast autophagy protease Atg4 is regulated by thioredoxin

Autophagy is a membrane-trafficking process whereby double-membrane vesicles called autophagosomes engulf and deliver intracellular material to the vacuole for degradation. Atg4 is a cysteine protease with an essential function in autophagosome formation. Mounting evidence suggests that reactive oxygen species may play a role in the control of autophagy and could regulate Atg4 activity but the precise mechanisms remain unclear. In this study, we showed that reactive oxygen species activate autophagy in the model yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae and unraveled the molecular mechanism by which redox balance controls Atg4 activity. A combination of biochemical assays, redox titrations, and site-directed mutagenesis revealed that Atg4 is regulated by oxidoreduction of a single disulfide bond between Cys338 and Cys394. This disulfide has a low redox potential and is very efficiently reduced by thioredoxin, suggesting that this oxidoreductase plays an important role in Atg4 regulation. Accordingly, we found that autophagy activation by rapamycin was more pronounced in a thioredoxin mutant compared with wild-type cells. Moreover, in vivo studies indicated that Cys338 and Cys394 are required for the proper regulation of autophagosome biogenesis, since mutation of these cysteines resulted in increased recruitment of Atg8 to the phagophore assembly site. Thus, we propose that the fine-tuning of Atg4 activity depending on the intracellular redox state may regulate autophagosome formation.     

SNARE proteins are required for macroautophagy

Macroautophagy mediates the degradation of long-lived proteins and organelles via the de novo formation of double-membrane autophagosomes that sequester cytoplasm and deliver it to the vacuole/lysosome; however, relatively little is known about autophagosome biogenesis. Atg8, a phosphatidylethanolamine-conjugated protein, was previously proposed to function in autophagosome membrane expansion, based on the observation that it mediates liposome tethering and hemifusion in vitro. We show here that with physiological concentrations of phosphatidylethanolamine, Atg8 does not act as a fusogen. Rather, we provide evidence for the involvement of exocytic Q/t-SNAREs in autophagosome formation, acting in the recruitment of key autophagy components to the site of autophagosome formation, and in regulating the organization of Atg9 into tubulovesicular clusters. Additionally, we found that the endosomal Q/t-SNARE Tlg2 and the R/v-SNAREs Sec22 and Ykt6 interact with Sso1-Sec9, and are required for normal Atg9 transport. Thus, multiple SNARE-mediated fusion events are likely to be involved in autophagosome biogenesis.     

Autophagosome formation and cargo sequestration in the absence of LC3/GABARAPs

It has been widely assumed that Atg8 family LC3/GABARAP proteins are essential for the formation of autophagosomes during macroautophagy/autophagy, and the sequestration of cargo during selective autophagy. However, there is little direct evidence on the functional contribution of these proteins to autophagosome biogenesis in mammalian cells. To dissect the functions of LC3/GABARAPs during starvation-induced autophagy and PINK1-PARK2/Parkin-dependent mitophagy, we used CRISPR/Cas9 gene editing to generate knockouts of the LC3 and GABARAP subfamilies, and all 6 Atg8 family proteins in HeLa cells. Unexpectedly, the absence of all LC3/GABARAPs did not prevent the formation of sealed autophagosomes, or selective engulfment of mitochondria during PINK1-PARK2-dependent mitophagy. Despite not being essential for autophagosome formation, the loss of LC3/GABARAPs affected both autophagosome size, and the efficiency at which they are formed. However, the critical autophagy defect in cells lacking LC3/GABARAPs was failure to drive autophagosome-lysosome fusion. Relative to the LC3 subfamily, GABARAPs were found to play a prominent role in autophagosome-lysosome fusion and recruitment of the adaptor protein PLEKHM1. Our work clarifies the essential contribution of Atg8 family proteins to autophagy in promoting autolysosome formation, and reveals the GABARAP subfamily as a key driver of starvation-induced autophagy and PINK1-PARK2-dependent mitophagy. Since LC3/GABARAPs are not essential for mitochondrial cargo sequestration, we propose an additional mechanism of selective autophagy. The model highlights the importance of ubiquitin signals and autophagy receptors for PINK-PARK2-mediated selectivity rather than Atg8 family-LIR-mediated interactions.     

Starvation-induced Hyperacetylation of Tubulin Is Required for the Stimulation of Autophagy by Nutrient Deprivation

The molecular mechanisms underlying microtubule participation in autophagy are not known. In this study, we show that starvation-induced autophagosome formation requires the most dynamic microtubule subset. Upon nutrient deprivation, labile microtubules specifically recruit markers of autophagosome formation like class III-phosphatidylinositol kinase, WIPI-1, the Atg12-Atg5 conjugate, and LC3-I, whereas mature autophagosomes may bind to stable microtubules. We further found that upon nutrient deprivation, tubulin acetylation increases both in labile and stable microtubules and is required to allow autophagy stimulation. Tubulin hyperacetylation on lysine 40 enhances kinesin-1 and JIP-1 recruitment on microtubules and allows JNK phosphorylation and activation. JNK, in turn, triggers the release of Beclin 1 from Bcl-2-Beclin 1 complexes and its recruitment on microtubules where it may initiate autophagosome formation. Finally, although kinesin-1 functions to carry autophagosomes in basal conditions, it is not involved in motoring autophagosomes after nutrient deprivation. Our results show that the dynamics of microtubules and tubulin post-translational modifications play a major role in the regulation of starvation-induced autophagy.     

Cheating on ubiquitin with Atg8

Macroautophagy sequesters superflous cytosol and organelles into double-membraned autophagosomes. Over 30 autophagy-related (ATG) genes have been identified without elucidating the molecular details of autophagosome biogenesis. All proposed models for autophagosome formation require membrane fusion events (Fig. 1). Previous studies assumed that the autophagic machinery mediates these membrane fusions in a SNARE-independent manner and identified the ubiquitin-like protein Atg8 as a key component especially for elongation of the forming autophagosome. However, if and how Atg8 mediates membrane fusion and why a ubiquitin-like protein is needed for autophagosome biogenesis remained open questions. Since nuclear envelope growth and fusion of Golgi fragments are topologically similar to autophagosome formation and depend on the AAA (+) ATPase p97/VCP and p47 we analyzed the involvement of their yeast homologues Cdc48 and Shp1 in macroautophagy.