GATC motifs may alter the conformation of DNA depending on sequence context and N6-adenine methylation status: possible implications for DNA-protein recognition

As part of our analysis of the role of a uniquely clustered set of dam methylation sites (the motif GATC) within the origin of DNA replication in Escherichia coli, we have studied the effect of GATCs in various methylation states on the intrinsic curvature of DNA. We have designed a set of DNA linkers and used commercially available linkers containing GATC motifs. The linkers were ligated and the electrophoretic mobility of the resulting multimers in different states of methylation was tested relative to reference fragments. We report that properly phased GATCs in certain sequence environments modulate DNA curvature and that these effects may be enhanced by N⁶-adenine methylation of the GATCs. These structural alterations may in turn affect DNA-protein interactions, especially those involving proteins that rely on both primary sequence and structure for recognition. We present an example, where introduction of a GATC within an integration host factor (IHF) binding site, which does not alter the consensus sequence, reduces the binding affinity of the protein for the modified site.     

GATC motifs may alter the conformation of DNA depending on sequence context and N6-adenine methylation status: possible implications for DNA-protein recognition

As part of our analysis of the role of a uniquely clustered set of dam methylation sites (the motif GATC) within the origin of DNA replication in Escherichia coli, we have studied the effect of GATCs in various methylation states on the intrinsic curvature of DNA. We have designed a set of DNA linkers and used commercially available linkers containing GATC motifs. The linkers were ligated and the electrophoretic mobility of the resulting multimers in different states of methylation was tested relative to reference fragments. We report that properly phased GATCs in certain sequence environments modulate DNA curvature and that these effects may be enhanced by N⁶-adenine methylation of the GATCs. These structural alterations may in turn affect DNA-protein interactions, especially those involving proteins that rely on both primary sequence and structure for recognition. We present an example, where introduction of a GATC within an integration host factor (IHF) binding site, which does not alter the consensus sequence, reduces the binding affinity of the protein for the modified site. Received: 16 December 1997 / Accepted: 24 February 1998     

The requirement of IHF protein for extrachromosomal replication of the Escherichia coli oriC in a mutant deficient in DNA polymerase I activity

It is shown here that plasmids containing the replication origin of Escherichia coli (oriC) cannot replicate in an extrachromosomal state in E. coli cells with the polA1hip3 double mutation. This E. coli mutant is deficient in the polymerizing function of DNA polymerase I (Pol I) and is unable to produce functional IHF protein. The inability of the oriC minichromosomes to replicate in the absence of IHF is dependent on the absence of Pol I; cells with the polA+himA- or polA+hip- mutation, which are deficient in the alpha and beta subunits of the IHF heterodimer, respectively, can support replication of the oriC replicons. We propose that IHF-deficient cells utilize an alternative pathway of the DNA replication in which Pol I is required. In vitro DNA binding assays revealed that the IHF binding site resides between the oriC coordinates 110 and 122 and is adjacent to the DnaA "box" 1. Within the area protected by IHF we found at least 1 out of 11 GATC methylation sites present in oriC. The consequences of lack of IHF protein binding to the oriC and the indirect effects of the IHF deficiency on the oriC replication are discussed.     

Escherichia coli prereplication complex assembly is regulated by dynamic interplay among Fis, IHF and DnaA

Initiator DnaA and DNA bending proteins, Fis and IHF, comprise prereplication complexes (pre-RC) that unwind the Escherichia coli chromosome's origin of replication, oriC. Loss of either Fis or IHF perturbs synchronous initiation from oriC copies in rapidly growing E. coli. Based on dimethylsulphate (DMS) footprinting of purified proteins, we observed a dynamic interplay among Fis, IHF and DnaA on supercoiled oriC templates. Low levels of Fis inhibited oriC unwinding by blocking both IHF and DnaA binding to low affinity sites. As the concentration of DnaA was increased, Fis repression was relieved and IHF rapidly redistributed DnaA to all unfilled binding sites on oriC. This behaviour in vitro is analogous to observed assembly of pre-RC in synchronized E. coli. We propose that as new DnaA is synthesized in E. coli, opposing activities of Fis and IHF ensure an abrupt transition from a repressed complex with unfilled weak affinity DnaA binding sites to a completely loaded unwound complex, increasing both the precision of DNA replication timing and initiation synchrony.     

The Escherichia coli Fis protein prevents initiation of DNA replication from oriC in vitro.

Fis protein participates in the normal control of chromosomal replication in Escherichia coli. However, the mechanism by which it executes its effect is largely unknown. We demonstrate an inhibitory influence of purified Fis protein on replication from oriC in vitro. Fis inhibits DNA synthesis equally well in replication systems either dependent upon or independent of RNA polymerase, even when the latter is stimulated by the presence of HU or IHF. The extent of inhibition by Fis is modulated by the concentrations of DnaA protein and RNA polymerase; the more limiting the amounts of these, the more severe the inhibition by Fis. Thus, the level of inhibition seems to depend on the ease with which the open complex can be formed. Fis-mediated inhibition of DNA replication does not depend on a functional primary Fis binding site between DnaA boxes R2 and R3 in oriC, as mutations that cause reduced binding of Fis to this site do not affect the degree of inhibition. The data presented suggest that Fis prevents formation of an initiation-proficient structure at oriC by forming an alternative, initiation-preventive complex. This indicates a negative role for Fis in the regulation of replication initiation.     

Drunken-cell footprints: nuclease treatment of ethanol-permeabilized bacteria reveals an initiation-like nucleoprotein complex in stationary phase replication origins.

The nucleoprotein complex formed on oriC, the Escherichia coli replication origin, is dynamic. During the cell cycle, high levels of the initiator DnaA and a bending protein, IHF, bind to oriC at the time of initiation of DNA replication, while binding of Fis, another bending protein, is reduced. In order to probe the structure of nucleoprotein complexes at oriC in more detail, we have developed an in situ footprinting method, termed drunken-cell footprinting, that allows enzymatic DNA modifying reagents access to intracellular nucleoprotein complexes in E.coli, after a brief exposure to ethanol. With this method, we observed in situ binding of Fis to oriC in exponentially growing cells, and binding of IHF to oriC in stationary cells, using DNase I and Bst NI endonuclease, respectively. Increased binding of DnaA to oriC in stationary phase was also noted. Because binding of DnaA and IHF results in unwinding of oriC in vitro, P1 endonuclease was used to probe for intracellular unwinding of oriC. P1 cleavage sites, localized within the 13mer unwinding region of oriC ', were dramatically enhanced in stationary phase on wild-type origins, but not on mutant versions of oriC unable to unwind. These observations suggest that most oriC copies become unwound during stationary phase, forming an initiation-like nucleoprotein complex.     

Escherichia coli cells lacking methylation-blocking factor (leucine-responsive regulatory protein) have precise timing of initiation of DNA replication in the cell cycle.

A protein that is required for specific methylation inhibition of two GATC sites in the papBA pilin promoter region, known as methylation-blocking factor (Mbf) and recently shown to be identical to the leucine-responsive regulatory protein (Lrp), is not responsible for the delayed methylation at oriC implicated in an eclipse period following initiation of DNA replication. Cells containing a transposon mutation within the mbf (lrp) gene initiate DNA replication at the correct time during the cell cycle, whereas cells with increased amounts of the Dam methyltransferase initiate DNA replication randomly throughout the cell cycle.     

IHF redistributes bound initiator protein, DnaA, on supercoiled oriC of Escherichia coli

In Escherichia coli, initiation of chromosome replication requires that DnaA binds to R boxes (9-mer repeats) in oriC, the unique chromosomal replication origin. At the time of initiation, integration host factor (IHF) also binds to a specific site in oriC. IHF stimulates open complex formation by DnaA on supercoiled oriC in cell-free replication systems, but it is unclear whether this stimulation involves specific changes in the oriC nucleoprotein complex. Using dimethylsulphate (DMS) footprinting on supercoiled oriC plasmids, we observed that IHF redistributed prebound DnaA, stimulating binding to sites R2, R3 and R5(M), as well as to three previously unidentified non-R sites with consensus sequence (A/T)G(G/C) (A/T)N(G/C)G(A/T)(A/T)(T/C)A. Redistribution was dependent on IHF binding to its cognate site and also required a functional R4 box. By reducing the DnaA level required to separate DNA strands and trigger initiation of DNA replication at each origin, IHF eliminates competition between strong and weak sites for free DnaA and enhances the precision of initiation synchrony during the cell cycle.     

A protein that binds to the P1 origin core and the oriC 13mer region in a methylation-specific fashion is the product of the host seqA gene.

The P1 plasmid replication origin P1oriR is controlled by methylation of four GATC adenine methylation sites within heptamer repeats. A comparable (13mer) region is present in the host origin, oriC. The two origins show comparable responses to methylation; negative control by recognition of hemimethylated DNA (sequestration) and a positive requirement for methylation for efficient function. We have isolated a host protein that recognizes the P1 origin region only when it is isolated from a strain proficient for adenine methylation. The substantially purified 22 kDa protein also binds to the 13mer region of oriC in a methylation-specific fashion. It proved to be the product of the seqA gene that acts in the negative control of oriC by sequestration. We conclude that the role of the SeqA protein in sequestration is to recognize the methylation state of P1oriR and oriC by direct DNA binding. Using synthetic substrates we show that SeqA binds exclusively to the hemimethylated forms of these origins forms that are the immediate products of replication in a methylation-proficient strain. We also show that the protein can recognize sequences with multiple GATC sites, irrespective of the surrounding sequence. The basis for origin specificity is primarily the persistence of hemimethylated forms that are over-represented in the natural. DNA preparations relative to controls.     

The oriC unwinding by dam methylation in Escherichia coli.

It has been shown that dam methylation is important in the regulation of initiation of DNA replication in E.coli. The question then arises as to whether dam methylation in the oriC region mediates any structural changes in DNA involved in the regulation of initiation of DNA replication. We demonstrate that the thermal melting temperature of the oriC region is lowered by adenine methylation at GATC sites. The regulation of initiation of DNA replication by dam methylation may be attributed to the ease of unwinding at GATC sites in oriC.     

Parental strand recognition of the DNA replication origin by the outer membrane in Escherichia coli.

The outer membrane of Escherichia coli binds the origin of DNA replication (oriC) only when it is hemimethylated. We report here the results of a footprinting analysis with the outer membrane which demonstrate that its interaction with oriC occurs mainly at the left moiety of the minimal oriC, where 10 out of 11 Dam methylation sites are concentrated. Two regions, flanking the Integration Host Factor (IHF) sites, are preferentially recognized at the minimum membrane concentration at which oriC plasmid replication is inhibited in vitro. We have identified the putative proteins involved in hemimethylated oriC binding and cloned one of the corresponding genes (hobH). The purified LacZ-HobH fusion protein specifically binds oriC DNA at the same preferential sites as the membrane. A mutant of the hobH gene reveals partial asynchronous initiation of DNA replication.     

Binding of SeqA protein to DNA requires interaction between two or more complexes bound to separate hemimethylated GATC sequences

The SeqA protein binds to the post-replicative forms of the origins of replication of the Escherichia coli chromosome (oriC) and the P1 plasmid (P1oriR) at hemimethylated GATC adenine methylation sites. It appears to regulate replication by preventing premature reinitiation. However, SeqA binding is not exclusive to replication origins: different fragments with hemimethylated GATC sites can bind SeqA in vitro when certain rules apply. Most notably, more than one such site must be present on a bound fragment. The protein appears to recognize individual hemimethylated sites, but must undergo an obligate cooperative interaction with a nearby bound protein for stable binding. SeqA contacts both DNA strands in a discrete patch at each hemimethylated GATC sequence. All four GATC bases are contacted and are essential for binding. Although the recognized sequence is symmetrical, the footprint on the methylated strand is always broader, suggesting that the bound protein is positioned asymmetrically with its orientation dictated by the position of the unique methyl group. Studies of alternative spacings and relative orientations of adjacent sites suggest that each site may be recognized by a symmetrical dimer with an induced asymmetry in one of the subunits similar to that seen with certain type II restriction endonucleases.     

HU, the major histone-like protein of E. coli, modulates the binding of IHF to oriC.

HU is one of the most abundant DNA binding proteins of bacteria. Unlike IHF, integration host factor of Escherichia coli, with which HU shares many properties, including a strong sequence homology and similar predicted structure, HU seems to bind non-specifically to DNA whereas IHF binds to specific sites. In this work we compare the binding characteristics of HU and IHF to a DNA fragment containing the minimal origin of replication of E. coli (oriC) and we analyse the effect of HU on the binding capacity of IHF to this oriC fragment. We show that HU interacts randomly and non-specifically with oriC as opposed to the specific binding of IHF to this same DNA sequence. In addition, we show that HU can modulate the binding of IHF to its specific oriC site. Depending on the relative concentrations of HU and IHF, HU is able either to activate or to inhibit the binding of IHF to oriC.     

Modulation of Escherichia coli DNA methyltransferase activity by biologically derived GATC-flanking sequences

Escherichia coli DNA adenine methyltransferase (EcoDam) methylates the N-6 position of the adenine in the sequence 5'-GATC-3' and plays vital roles in gene regulation, mismatch repair, and DNA replication. It remains unclear how the small number of critical GATC sites involved in the regulation of replication and gene expression are differentially methylated, whereas the approximately 20,000 GATCs important for mismatch repair and dispersed throughout the genome are extensively methylated. Our prior work, limited to the pap regulon, showed that methylation efficiency is controlled by sequences immediately flanking the GATC sites. We extend these studies to include GATC sites involved in diverse gene regulatory and DNA replication pathways as well as sites previously shown to undergo differential in vivo methylation but whose function remains to be assigned. EcoDam shows no change in affinity with variations in flanking sequences derived from these sources, but methylation kinetics varied 12-fold. A-tracts immediately adjacent to the GATC site contribute significantly to these differences in methylation kinetics. Interestingly, only when the poly(A) is located 5' of the GATC are the changes in methylation kinetics revealed. Preferential methylation is obscured when two GATC sites are positioned on the same DNA molecule, unless both sites are surrounded by large amounts of nonspecific DNA. Thus, facilitated diffusion and sequences immediately flanking target sites contribute to higher order specificity for EcoDam; we suggest that the diverse biological roles of the enzyme are in part regulated by these two factors, which may be important for other enzymes that sequence-specifically modify DNA.     

Role of DNA methylation at GATC sites in the dnaA promoter, dnaAp2

DnaA protein is required for the initiation of DNA replication at the bacterial chromosomal origin, oriC, and at the origins of many plasmids. The concentration of DnaA protein is an important factor in determining when initiation occurs during the cell cycle. Methylation of GATC sites in the dnaAp2 promoter, two of which are in the -35 and -10 sequences, has been predicted to play an important role in regulating dnaA gene expression during the cell cycle because the promoter is sequestered from methylation immediately following replication. Mutations that eliminate these two GATC sites but do not substantially change the activity of the promoter were introduced into a reporter gene fusion and into the chromosome. The chromosomal mutants are able to initiate DNA replication synchronously at both moderately slow and fast growth rates, demonstrating that GATC methylation at these two sites is not directly involved in providing the necessary amount of DnaA for precise timing of initiation during the cell cycle. Either sequestration does not involve these GATC sites, or cell cycle control of DnaA expression is not required to supply the concentration necessary for correct timing of initiation.     

IHF and HU stimulate assembly of pre-replication complexes at Escherichia coli oriC by two different mechanisms

Pre-replication complexes (pre-RC) assemble on replication origins and unwind DNA in the presence of chromatin proteins. As components of Escherichia coli pre-RC, two histone-like proteins HU and IHF (integration host factor), stimulate initiator DnaA-catalysed unwinding of the chromosomal replication origin, oriC. Using in vivo footprint analysis just before DNA synthesis initiates, we detect IHF binding coincident with a shift of DnaA to weaker central oriC sites. Integration host factor redistributed pre-bound DnaA to identical sites in vitro. HU did not redistribute DnaA, but suppressed binding specifically at I3. These results suggest that different pathways mediated by bacterial chromatin proteins exist to regulate pre-RC assembly and unwind oriC.     

Cell cycle-specific changes in nucleoprotein complexes at a chromosomal replication origin.

Initiation of DNA synthesis is triggered by the binding of proteins to replication origins. However, little is known about the order in which specific proteins associate with origin sites during the cell cycle. We show that in cycling cells there are at least two different nucleoprotein complexes at oriC. A factor for inversion stimulation (FIS)-bound nucleoprotein complex, present throughout the majority of the cell cycle, switches to an integration host factor (IHF)-bound form as cells initiate DNA replication. Coincident with binding of IHF, initiator DnaA binds to its previously unoccupied R3 site. In stationary phase, a third nucleoprotein complex forms. FIS is absent and inactive oriC forms a nucleoprotein structure containing IHF that is not observed in cycling cells. We propose that interplay between FIS and IHF aids assembly of initiation nucleoprotein complexes during the cell cycle and blocks initiation at inappropriate times. This exchange of components at replication origins is reminiscent of switching between pre- and post-replicative chromatin states at yeast ARS1.