Defining requirements for collagenase cleavage in collagen type III using a bacterial collagen system

Degradation of fibrillar collagens is important in many physiological and pathological events. These collagens are resistant to most proteases due to the tightly packed triple-helical structure, but are readily cleaved at a specific site by collagenases, selected members of the matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs). To investigate the structural requirements for collagenolysis, varying numbers of GXY triplets from human type III collagen around the collagenase cleavage site were inserted between two triple helix domains of the Scl2 bacterial collagen protein. The original bacterial CL domain was not cleaved by MMP-1 (collagenase 1) or MMP-13 (collagenase 3). The minimum type III sequence necessary for cleavage by the two collagenases was 5 GXY triplets, including 4 residues before and 11 residues after the cleavage site (P4-P11'). Cleavage of these chimeric substrates was not achieved by the catalytic domain of MMP-1 or MMP-13, nor by full-length MMP-3. Kinetic analysis of the chimeras indicated that the rate of cleavage by MMP-1 of the chimera containing six triplets (P7-P11') of collagen III was similar to that of native collagen III. The collagenase-susceptible chimeras were cleaved very slowly by trypsin, a property also seen for native collagen III, supporting a local structural relaxation of the triple helix near the collagenase cleavage site. The recombinant bacterial-human collagen system characterized here is a good model to investigate the specificity and mechanism of action of collagenases.     

A targeted mutation at the known collagenase cleavage site in mouse type I collagen impairs tissue remodeling

Degradation of type I collagen, the most abundant collagen, is initiated by collagenase cleavage at a highly conserved site between Gly775 and Ile776 of the alpha 1 (I) chain. Mutations at or around this site render type I collagen resistant to collagenase digestion in vitro. We show here that mice carrying a collagenase-resistant mutant Col1a-1 transgene die late in embryo-genesis, ascribable to overexpression of the transgene, since the same mutation introduced into the endogenous Col1a-1 gene by gene targeting permitted normal development of mutant mice to young adulthood. With increasing age, animals carrying the targeted mutation developed marked fibrosis of the dermis similar to that in human scleroderma. Postpartum involution of the uterus in the mutant mice was also impaired, with persistence of collagenous nodules in the uterine wall. Although type I collagen from the homozygous mutant mice was resistant to cleavage by human or rat fibroblast collagenases at the helical site, only the rat collagenase cleaved collagen trimers at an additional, novel site in the nonhelical N-telopeptide domain. Our results suggest that cleavage by murine collagenase at the N-telopeptide site could account for resorption of type I collagen during embryonic and early adult life. During intense collagen resorption, however, such as in the immediate postpartum uterus and in the dermis later in life, cleavage at the helical site is essential for normal collagen turnover. Thus, type I collagen is degraded by at least two differentially controlled mechanisms involving collagenases with distinct, but overlapping, substrate specificities.     

Conformational selection and collagenolysis in Type III collagen

Matrix metalloproteases (MMPs) cleave native collagen at a single site despite the fact that collagen contains more than one scissile bond that can, in principle, be cleaved. For peptide bond hydrolysis to occur at one specific site, MMPs must (1) localize to a region near the unique scissile bond, (2) bind residues at the catalytic site that form the scissile bond, and (3) hydrolyze the corresponding peptide bond. Prior studies suggest that for some types of collagen, binding of noncatalytic MMP domains to amino acid sequences in the vicinity of the true cleavage site facilitates the localization of collagenases. In the present study, our goal was to determine whether binding to the catalytic site also plays a role in determining MMP specificity. To investigate this, we computed the conformational free energy landscape of Type III collagen at each potential cleavage site. The free energy profiles suggest that although all potential cleavage sites sample unfolded states at relatively low temperatures, the true cleavage site samples structures that are complementary to the catalytic site. By contrast, potential cleavage sites that are not cleaved sample states that are relatively incompatible with the MMP active site. Furthermore, our findings point to a specific role for arginine residues in modulating the structural stability of collagen near the collagenase cleavage site. These data imply that locally unfolded potential cleavage sites in Type III collagen sample distinct unfolded ensembles, and that the region about the true collagenase cleavage site samples states that are most complementary to the MMP active site. Proteins 2010. © 2009 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Limited proteolysis of type I collagen at hyperreactive sites by class I and II Clostridium histolyticum collagenases: complementary digestion patterns

The initial proteolytic events in the hydrolysis of rat tendon type I collagen by the class I and II collagenases from Clostridium histolyticum have been investigated at 15 degrees C. Sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis has been used to detect the initial cleavage fragments of both the alpha 1(I) and alpha 2 chains, which migrate at different rates in the buffer system employed. Experiments with the class I collagenases indicate that the first cleavage occurs across all three chains of the triple helix close to the C-terminus to produce fragments whose alpha chains have molecular weights of approximately 88,000. The second cleavage occurs near the N-terminus to reduce the molecular weight of the alpha chains to 80,000. Initial proteolysis by the class II collagenases occurs across all three chains at a site in the interior of the collagen triple helix to give N- and C-terminal fragments with alpha-chain molecular weights of 35,000 and 62,000, respectively. The C-terminal fragment is subsequently cleaved to give fragments with alpha-chain molecular weights of 59,000. These results indicate that type I collagen is degraded at several hyperreactive sites by these enzymes. Thus, initial proteolysis by these bacterial collagenases occurs at specific sites, much like the mammalian collagenases. These results with the individual clostridial collagenases provide an explanation for earlier data which indicated that collagen is degraded sequentially from the ends by a crude clostridial collagenase preparation.     

Do collagenases unwind triple‐helical collagen before peptide bond hydrolysis? Reinterpreting experimental observations with mathematical models

It has been postulated that triple-helical collagen is actively unwound by collagenases before peptide bond hydrolysis--a supposition that explains the small catalytic rate constant associated with collagenolysis. We propose an alternate model of collagen degradation that does not require active unwinding by collagenases, but instead suggests that the regions of collagen near the collagenase cleavage site can adopt either a native triple-helical or a partially unfolded conformation. In this model, collagenases preferentially bind to and stabilize partially unfolded conformers before cleaving the scissile bond. Existing experimental observations (which were previously taken to support active unwinding models) are reinterpreted using corroborative evidence from numerical simulations and found to be consistent with this framework. These data support the notion that collagen, like all other biological heteropolymers, undergoes thermal fluctuations that cause it to sample distinct structures in the neighborhood of the native state, and collagenolysis occurs when collagenases recognize the appropriate unwound conformers.     

A model for biased diffusion of collagenase along collagen fibrils

We present a model to describe the biased diffusion of a collagenase along collagen fibrils. Based on the structures of collagen fibril and collagenase, the interaction is described by a one-dimensional potential that is symmetric in the region of no cleavage and asymmetric in the cleavage region. We show that the mean velocity of the unidirectional diffusion of the collagenase depends on the three parameters: the asymmetric ratio of the local potential in the cleavage region, the chemical reaction rate of proteolysis and the jumping rate of collagenase between two neighboring tracks. We calculate the correlation function and the mean transport velocity for both wild-type and mutant collagenases along collagen fibrils, the results of which are consistent with the previous experiments.     

Specific cleavage of human type III collagen by human polymorphonuclear leukocyte elastase

Purified polymorphonuclear leukocyte elastase degraded native human liver type III collagen at 27 degrees C by making a cleavage through the triple helix. The enzyme had no effect on human type I collagen. The reaction was inhibited by phenylmethanesulfonyl fluoride (PhCH2SO2F) but not by EDTA. The collagen reaction products were identical with those generated by human rheumatoid synovial collagenase when analyzed by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and gel filtration. NH2-trminal sequence analysis indicated that the enzyme cleaved at an isoleucyl-threonyl bond located 4 residues on the carboxyl side of the established cleavage site for animal collagenases. Therefore, it is likely that in pathologic states, type III collagen can be selectively depleted from the matrix by this enzyme.     

Do mammalian collagenases and DNA restriction endonucleases share a similar mechanism for cleavage site recognition?

Despite the apparent uniformity of the collagen molecule, vertebrate and invertebrate collagenases cleave it in one region only. We suggest that the enzyme recognises the cleavage site by the arrangement of the imino acids proline and hydroxyproline on either side of a region where the helical conformation of the collagen molecule is less stable. This less stable region could fold out of the rigid collagen molecule allowing the two recognition sites to be simultaneously attached to identical subunits in the same collagenase molecule. Class II DNA restriction endonucleases are confronted by a similar recognition problem in cleaving the DNA molecule at a specific site and it is generally accepted that here recognition is achieved by a sequence of bases with two-fold symmetry. We postulate that collagenase may, like the DNA restriction enzyme, be active in the dimeric form and that it recognises its substrate site by a similar two-fold symmetric arrangement of imino acid residues.     

Sequence specificities of human fibroblast and neutrophil collagenases.

The sequence specificities of human fibroblast and neutrophil collagenases have been investigated by measuring the rate of hydrolysis of 60 synthetic oligopeptides covering the P4 through P'5 subsites of the substrate. The choice of peptides was patterned after both known cleavage sites in noncollagenous proteins and potential cleavage sites (those containing Gly-Ile-Ala, Gly-Leu-Ala, or Gly-Ile-Leu sequences) found in types I, II, III, and IV collagens. The initial rate of hydrolysis of the P1-P'1 bond of each peptide has been measured under first-order conditions ([SO] much less than KM), and kcat/KM values have been calculated from the initial rates. The amino acids in subsites P4 through P'4 all influence the hydrolysis rates for both collagenases. However, the effects of substitutions at each site are distinctive and are consistent with the view that human fibroblast and neutrophil collagenases are homologous but nonidentical enzymes. For peptides with unblocked NH2 and COOH termini, occupancy of subsites P3 through P'3 is necessary for rapid hydrolysis. Compared with the alpha 1(I) cleavage sequence, none of the substitutions investigated at subsites P3, P2, and P'4 produces markedly improved substrates. In contrast, many substitutions at subsites P1, P'1, and P'2 improve specificity. The preferences of both collagenases for alanine in subsite P1 and tryptophan or phenylalanine in subsite P'2, is noteworthy. Human neutrophil collagenase accommodates aromatic residues in subsite P'1 much better than human fibroblast collagenase. The subsite preferences observed for human fibroblast collagenase in these studies agree well with the residues found at cleavage sites in noncollagenous substrates. However, the sequence specificities of these collagenases cannot explain the failure of these enzymes to hydrolyze many potentially cleavable but apparently protected sites in intact collagens. This represents additional support for the notion that the local structure of collagen is important in determining the location of collagenase cleavage sites.     

A convenient fluorescent assay for vertebrate collagenases

A versatile, convenient assay for vertebrate collagenases has been developed using the fluorescent peptide substrate dansyl-Pro-Gln-Gly-Ile-Ala-Gly-D-Arg. This sequence resembles that of collagen at the site of cleavage but includes modifications designed to eliminate nonspecific hydrolysis by contaminating peptidases. Both human skin fibroblast and bovine corneal cell collagenases cleave the substrate specifically at the Gly-Ile bond. Plasmin, thrombin, trypsin, alpha-chymotrypsin, carboxypeptidase B, and bacterial collagenase do not cleave the substrate. Elastase and angiotensin converting enzyme display 20- and 400-fold less activity than the vertebrate collagenases, respectively, and cleave the peptide at different positions. The assay is performed by incubating a 5- to 25-microliters aliquot of trypsin-activated sample with an equal volume of 2 mM substrate overnight at 33 degrees C and pH 7.5. Thin-layer chromatography then separates the fluorescent product from the substrate in less than 20 min and allows the detection of subnanogram levels of collagenase. The assay is applicable to the screening of large numbers of samples under different conditions of pH and ionic strength and is readily adaptable for use in a variety of collagenase-dependent systems, such as assays for collagenase activating and/or inducing factors.     

Some newly characterized collagenases from procaryotes and lower eucaryotes

Summary Chemical and enzymatic properties of four collagenases newly isolated from anaerobic Clostridium histolyticum, aerobic Achromobacter iophagus, and from two lower eucaryotes, the fungus Entomophthora coronata and the insect Hypoderma lineatum are reviewed.The problems of their biosynthesis and precursors, namely the effect of induction of collagenase and neutral proteinase in Achromobacter by their macromolecular substrates are discussed.The two bacterial collagenases are Zn-metallo-enzymes; the highly purified Clostridium collagenase contains cyst(e)ine, serine phosphate and tryptophan additionally to amino acids reported previously. Achromobacter collagenase has the highest specific activity of all collagenases; it yields by autolysis enzymatically active degraded forms. The active dimer is composed of two identical subunits of molecular weight 35,000. Similarities between Achromobacter collagenase, thermolysin and Bacillus subtilis neutral proteinase in molecular weight, amino acid composition, and amino acids important for the active sites are discussed.The two collagenases from low eucaryotes are serine proteinases; Hypoderma collagenase is homologous to the trypsin family in the amino terminal sequence.The initial cleavage of native collagen by highly purified bacterial collagenases occurs in the central helical part of the a chains and not progressively from the amino terminal end. One of the two initial cleavages produced by Achromobacter collagenase is situated in the region cleaved specifically by vertebrate collagenases, but with different bond specificity. The same is true for the insect collagenase. Entomophthora collagenase is a proteinase of broad specificity which also cleaves collagen in its helical parts. All four collagenases also degrade other proteins according to their bond specificity.     

Activity of matrix metalloproteinase-9 against native collagen types I and III

Interstitial collagen types I, II and III are highly resistant to proteolytic attack, due to their triple helical structure, but can be cleaved by matrix metalloproteinase (MMP) collagenases at a specific site, approximately three-quarters of the length from the N-terminus of each chain. MMP-2 and -9 are closely related at the structural level, but MMP-2, and not MMP-9, has been previously described as a collagenase. This report investigates the ability of purified recombinant human MMP-9 produced in insect cells to degrade native collagen types I and III. Purified MMP-9 was able to cleave the soluble, monomeric forms of native collagen types I and III at 37 degrees C and 25 degrees C, respectively. Activity against collagens I and III was abolished by metalloproteinase inhibitors and was not present in the concentrated crude medium of mock-transfected cells, demonstrating that it was MMP-9-derived. Mutated, collagenase-resistant type I collagen was not digested by MMP-9, indicating that the three-quarters/one-quarter locus was the site of initial attack. Digestion of type III collagen generated a three-quarter fragment, as shown by comparison with MMP-1-mediated cleavage. These data demonstrate that MMP-9, like MMP-2, is able to cleave collagens I and III in their native form and in a manner that is characteristic of the unique collagenolytic activity of MMP collagenases.     

Molecular Mechanism of Type I Collagen Homotrimer Resistance to Mammalian Collagenases

Type I collagen cleavage is crucial for tissue remodeling, but its homotrimeric isoform is resistant to all collagenases. The homotrimers occur in fetal tissues, fibrosis, and cancer, where their collagenase resistance may play an important physiological role. To understand the mechanism of this resistance, we studied interactions of α1(I)₃ homotrimers and normal α1(I)₂α2(I) heterotrimers with fibroblast collagenase (MMP-1). Similar MMP-1 binding to the two isoforms and similar cleavage efficiency of unwound α1(I) and α2(I) chains suggested increased stability and less efficient unwinding of the homotrimer triple helix at the collagenase cleavage site. The unwinding, necessary for placing individual chains inside the catalytic cleft of the enzyme, was the rate-limiting cleavage step for both collagen isoforms. Comparative analysis of the homo- and heterotrimer cleavage kinetics revealed that MMP-1 binding promotes stochastic helix unwinding, resolving the controversy between different models of collagenase action.     

Covalent structure of collagen: amino acid sequence of alpha 1 (III)-CB5 from type III collagen of human liver

Type III collagen was prepared from human liver by limited pepsin digestion, differential salt precipitation, and carboxymethylcellulose chromatography. Ten distinct peptides were obtained by cyanogen bromide digestion. The peptide alpha 1 (III)-CB5 was further purified by carboxymethylcellulose chromatography, and its amino acid sequence was determined. Automatic Edman degradation of intact alpha 1 (III)-CB5, tryptic and thermolytic peptides, and hydroxylamine-derived fragments was used to establish the total sequence. The mammalian collagenase site contained in the alpha 1 (III)-CB5 sequence was ascertained by digestion of native type III collagen with purified rheumatoid synovial collagenase. Collagenase cleavage occurred at a single Gly--Ile bond, one triplet before the corresponding specific cleavage site of type I collagen. The present work brings the known sequence of human liver type III collagen to include alpha 1 (III)-CB3-7-6-1-8-10-2-4-5. These correspond to the homologous region of alpha 1 (I)-CB0-1-2-4-5-8-3-7 residues 11--804.     

Specificity of the collagenase from the insect Hypoderma lineatum

Specificity of the collagenase from the larvae Hypoderma lineatum, a serine protease related to trypsin, has been investigated by using native collagen and non-collagenous substrates. At 25 degrees C and neutral pH the degradation of collagen by the larval enzyme in solution results in a 52% loss of specific viscosity, without loss of helicity. Electron microscopy of segment-long-spacing crystallites of the digest shows the occurrence of one cleavage region between bands 41 and 44 whereas Edman degradation indicates several cleavage loci in this region. Hypoderma collagenase differs from proteinases I and II from the crab Uca pugilator, which catalyse cleavages in multiple regions of the collagen molecule, and also from vertebrate collagenases, which cleave collagen only between residues 775 and 776. Apart of specific action on collagen, Hypoderma collagenase degrades the oxidized chain B of insulin; the major cleavage occurs at the Leu15-Tyr16 bond followed by two minor cleavages at the Arg22-Gly23 and Lys29-Ala30 bonds. The larval enzyme has no action on synthetic peptide substrates of trypsin or chymotrypsin.     

SLRP interaction can protect collagen fibrils from cleavage by collagenases

Decorin, fibromodulin and lumican are small leucine-rich repeat proteoglycans (SLRPs) which interact with the surface of collagen fibrils. Together with other molecules they form a coat on the fibril surface which could impede the access to collagenolytic proteinases. To address this hypothesis, fibrils of type I or type II collagen were formed in vitro and treated with either collagenase-1 (MMP1) or collagenase-3 (MMP13). The fibrils were either treated directly or following incubation in the presence of the recombinant SLRPs. The susceptibility of the uncoated and SLRP-coated fibrils to collagenase cleavage was assessed by SDS/PAGE. Interaction with either recombinant decorin, fibromodulin or lumican results in decreased collagenase cleavage of both fibril types. Thus SLRP interaction can help protect collagen fibrils from cleavage by collagenases.     

Isolation and characterization of a peptide containing the site of cleavage of the chick skin collagen alpha 1[I] chain by animal collagenases.

A 36-residue peptide containing the bond cleaved by animal collagenases was isolated from a digest of chick skin collagen α1-CB7 by Staphylococcus V8 protease. This cleavage site peptide, in contrast to the 36-residue α1-CB2, showed no tendency to renature to the triple helical form, as monitored by molecular sieve chromatography and the determination of circular dichroism spectra. These results provide a direct demonstration that the conformation of the α1[I] chain immediately around the collagenase cleavage site in the native molecule must be of a lower degree of helicity than other portions of the chain. This is considered to be an important factor in the collagenase specificity, in providing access to the sensitive bonds, but enzyme binding sites, probably located in the adjacent region(s) of maximum helicity, are also considered necessary to produce the maximum reaction rate.     

Differential susceptibility of type X collagen to cleavage by two mammalian interstitial collagenases and 72-kDa type IV collagenase

We have studied the degradation of type X collagen by human skin fibroblast and rat uterus interstitial collagenases and human 72-kDa type IV collagenase. The interstitial collagenases attacked the native type X helix at two loci, cleaving residues Gly92-Leu93 and Gly420-Ile421, both scissions involving Gly-X bonds of Gly-X-Y-Z-A sequences. However, the human and rat interstitial enzymes displayed an opposite and substantial selectivity for each of these potential sites, with the uterine enzyme catalyzing the Gly420-Ile421 cleavage almost 20-fold faster than the Gly92-Leu93 locus. Values for enzyme-substrate affinity were approximately 1 microM indistinguishable from the corresponding Km values against type I collagen. Interestingly, in attacking type X collagen, both enzymes manifested kinetic properties intermediate between those characterizing the degradation of native and denatured collagen substrates. Thus, energy dependence of reaction velocity revealed a value of EA of 45 kcal, typical of native interstitial collagen substrates. However, the substitution of D2O for H2O in solvent buffer failed to slow type X collagenolysis significantly (kH/kD = 1.1), in contrast to the 50-70% slowing (kH/kD = 2-3) observed with native interstitial collagens. Since this lack of deuterium isotope effect is characteristic of interstitial collagenase cleavage of denatured collagens, we investigated the capacity of another metalloproteinase with substantial gelatinolytic activity, 72-kDa type IV collagenase, to degrade type X collagen. The 72-kDa type IV collagenase cleaved type X collagen at both 25 and 37 degrees C, and at loci in close proximity to those attacked by the interstitial enzymes. No further cleavages were observed at either temperature with type IV collagenase, and although values for kcat were not determined (due to associated tissue inhibitor of metalloproteinases-2), catalytic rates appeared to be substantial in comparison to the interstitial enzymes. In contrast, type X collagen was completely resistant to proteolysis by stromelysin. Type X collagen thus appears to be highly unusual in its susceptibility to degradation by both interstitial collagenase and another member of the metalloproteinase gene family.     

Purification of human collagenases with a hydroxamic acid affinity column

Human collagenase has been isolated from skin fibroblasts and rheumatoid synovium by using an affinity matrix, prepared by coupling Pro-Leu-Gly-NHOH to agarose. Following the methodology described herein, the skin enzyme was isolated in two steps in 76% yield and the synovial enzyme was purified in three steps in 71% yield. Importantly, each enzyme hydrolyzed collagen into 3/4-1/4 cleavage fragments, indicating that a true collagenase had been isolated. The column was specific for the human enzyme since the collagenase from Clostridium histolyticum did not bind. The affinity ligand was designed according to the formalism proposed by Holmquist and Vallee [Holmquist, B., & Vallee, B. L. (1979) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 76, 6216] that effective metalloenzyme inhibitors can be synthesized by coupling a suitable metal-coordinating group to a substrate analogue. In this case, the hydroxamic acid probably coordinates to the active-site metal and the Pro-Leu-Gly moiety is similar to the carboxyl side of the cleavage site of collagen, the enzyme's substrate. The IC50 for N-(benzyloxycarbonyl)-Pro-Leu-Gly-NHOH is 4 X 10(-5) M for both enzymes. The affinity chromatographic procedures described here should aid in future studies on vertebrate collagenases.     

Pivotal molecular determinants of peptidic and collagen triple helicase activities reside in the S3' subsite of matrix metalloproteinase 8 (MMP-8): the role of hydrogen bonding potential of ASN188 and TYR189 and the connecting cis bond

The mechanism of triple helical collagen unwinding and cleavage by collagenases in the matrix metalloproteinase (MMP) family is complex and remains enigmatic. Recent reports show that triple helicase activity is initiated by the hemopexin C domain of membrane type 1-MMP, whereas catalytically inactive full-length interstitial collagenase (MMP-1) exhibits full triple helicase functionality pointing to active site determinants that are needed to complete the triple helicase mechanism. In MMP-8, the neutrophil collagenase, a conserved Gly at the S(3)' substrate specificity subsite is replaced by Asn(188) that forms a highly unusual cis bond with Tyr(189), a conserved active site residue in the collagenases. Only in MMP-1 is the S(3)' Gly also replaced, and there too a cis configured Glu-Tyr occurs. Thus, this high energy peptide bond coupled to the canonical Tyr may be important in the collagenolytic process. In a systematic mutagenesis investigation of the MMP-8 S(3)' subsite we found that introducing an S(3)' Gly(188) into MMP-8 reduced collagenolytic efficiency by approximately 30% with a corresponding reduction in cleavage of a synthetic peptide fluorescence resonance energy transfer substrate analogue of the alpha2(I) collagen chain cleavage site. The substitution of Asn(188) to Leu, a hydrophobic residue of similar size to the highly polar Asn and designed to retain the cis bond, revealed the importance of hydrogen bonding to bound substrate with both collagenolytic and peptidic activities reduced approximately 3-fold. In contrast, the specificity for type I collagen of the mutant Y189F dropped 3-fold without any significant alteration in general peptidase activity. Therefore, S(3)' and in particular the hydrogen bonding potential of Tyr(189) is a specific molecular determinant for MMP-8 triple helicase activity. The cis bond connection to Asn(188) juxtaposes these two side chains for closely spaced hydrogen bonding with substrate that improves collagenolytic and general catalytic efficiency that could be exploited for new collagenase-specific inhibitor drugs.