X-Ray Structure of the Nucleosome Core Particle

Abstract

Two monoclinic crystal forms (P2₁,C2) of chicken erythrocyte nucleosomes have been under study in this laboratory. The x-ray structure of the P2₁ crystal form has been solved to 15 Å resolution. The B-DNA superhelix has a relatively uniform curvature, with only several local distortions observed in the superhelix. The individual histone domains have been localized and specific contacts between each histone and the DNA can be observed. Histone contacts to the inner surface of the DNA superhelix occur predominantly at the minor groove sites. Most of the histone core is contained within the inner surface of the superhelical DNA, except for part of H2A which extends between the DNA gyres near the terminus of the DNA. No part of H2A blocks the DNA terminus or would prevent a smooth exit of the DNA into the linker region. A similar extension of a portion of histone H4 between the DNA gyres occurs close to the dyad axis. Both unique nucleosomes in the P2₁ asymmetric unit demonstrate good dyad symmetry and are similar to each other throughout the histone core and DNA regions.     

Structure of the nucleosome core particle at 8 A resolution

The x-ray crystallographic structure of the nucleosome core particle has been determined using 8 A resolution diffraction data. The particle has a mean diameter of 106 A and a maximum thickness of 65 A in the superhelical axis direction. The longest chord through the histone core measures 85 A and is in a non-axial direction. The 1.87 turn superhelix consists of B-DNA with about 78 base pairs or 7.6 helical repeats per superhelical turn. The mean DNA helical repeat contains 10.2 +/- 0.05 base pairs and spans 35 A, slightly more than standard B-DNA. The superhelix varies several Angstroms in radius and pitch, and has three distinct domains of curvature (with radii of curvature of 60, 45 and 51 A). These regions are separated by localized sharper bends +/- 10 and +/- 40 base pairs from the center of the particle, resulting in an overall radius of curvature about 43 A. Compression of superhelical DNA grooves on the inner surface and expansion on the outer surface can be seen throughout the DNA electron density. This density has been fit with a double helical ribbon model providing groove width estimates of 12 +/- 1 A inside vs. 19 +/- 1 A outside for the major groove, and 8 +/- 1 A inside vs. 13 +/- 1 A outside for the minor groove. The histone core is primarily contained within the bounds defined by the superhelical DNA, contacting the DNA where the phosphate backbone faces in toward the core. Possible extensions of density between the gyres have been located, but these are below the significance level of the electron density map. In cross-section, a tripartite organization of the histone octamer is apparent, with the tetramer occupying the central region and the dimers at the extremes. Several extensions of histone density are present which form contacts between nucleosomes in the crystal, perhaps representing flexible or "tail" histone regions. The radius of gyration of the histone portion of the electron density is calculated to be 30.4 A (in reasonable agreement with solution scattering values), and the histone core volume in the map is 93% of its theoretical volume.     

Nucleosomes in solution exist as a mixture of twist-defect states

The 2.0 A crystal structure of a nucleosome core particle in complex with a bivalent pyrrole-imidazole polyamide reveals that this "clamp" effectively crossbraces the two gyres of the DNA superhelix, thereby stabilizing the nucleosome against dissociation. Using X-ray crystallography and footprinting techniques, we show that the clamp preferentially binds nucleosomes over free DNA, and that nucleosomal DNA exists as a mixture of multiple twist-defect intermediates in solution. The nucleosomes exist in one of two different conformations in various crystal structures that trap twist-defect intermediates, even on a strong positioning sequence. Evidence has been obtained supporting the existence of twist-defect states in nucleosomal DNA in solution that are similar to those obtained in crystal structures. Our results also substantiate the idea that twist diffusion may represent an important means of altering the accessibility of nucleosomal DNA both in the presence and in the absence of ATP-dependent chromatin-remodelling enzymes.     

A Distinct Switch in Interactions of the Histone H4 Tail Domain upon Salt-dependent Folding of Nucleosome Arrays

The core histone tail domains mediate inter-nucleosomal interactions that direct folding and condensation of nucleosome arrays into higher-order chromatin structures. The histone H4 tail domain facilitates inter-array interactions by contacting both the H2A/H2B acidic patch and DNA of neighboring nucleosomes (1, 2). Likewise, H4 tail-H2A contacts stabilize array folding (3). However, whether the H4 tail domains stabilize array folding via inter-nucleosomal interactions with the DNA of neighboring nucleosomes remains unclear. We utilized defined oligonucleosome arrays containing a single specialized nucleosome with a photo-inducible cross-linker in the N terminus of the H4 tail to characterize these interactions. We observed that the H4 tail participates exclusively in intra-array interactions with DNA in unfolded arrays. These interactions are diminished during array folding, yet no inter-nucleosome, intra-array H4 tail-DNA contacts are observed in condensed chromatin. However, we document contacts between the N terminus of the H4 tail and H2A. Installation of acetylation mimics known to disrupt H4-H2A surface interactions did not increase observance of H4-DNA inter-nucleosomal interactions. These results suggest the multiple functions of the H4 tail require targeted distinct interactions within condensed chromatin.     

Interaction of maize chromatin-associated HMG proteins with mononucleosomes: role of core and linker histones

Two groups of plant chromatin-associated high mobility group (HMG) proteins, namely the HMGA family, typically containing four A/T-hook DNA-binding motifs, and the HMGB family, containing a single HMG-box DNA-binding domain, have been identified. We have examined the interaction of recombinant maize HMGA and five different HMGB proteins with mononucleosomes (containing approx. 165 bp of DNA) purified from micrococcal nuclease-digested maize chromatin. The HMGB proteins interacted with the nucleosomes independent of the presence of the linker histone H1, while the binding of HMGA in the presence of H1 differed from that observed in the absence of H1. HMGA and the HMGB proteins bound H1-containing nucleosome particles with similar affinity. The plant HMG proteins could also bind nucleosomes that were briefly treated with trypsin (removing the N-terminal domains of the core histones), suggesting that the histone N-termini are dispensable for HMG protein binding. In the presence of untreated nucleosomes and trypsinised nucleosomes, HMGB1 could be chemically crosslinked with a core histone, which indicates that the trypsin-resistant part of the histones within the nucleosome is the main interaction partner of HMGB1 rather than the histone N-termini. In conclusion, these results indicate that specific nucleosome binding of the plant HMGB proteins requires simultaneous DNA and histone contacts.     

Alteration of the nucleosomal DNA path in the crystal structure of a human nucleosome core particle

Gene expression in eukaryotes depends upon positioning, mobility and packaging of nucleosomes; thus, we need the detailed information of the human nucleosome core particle (NCP) structure, which could clarify chromatin properties. Here, we report the 2.5 Å crystal structure of a human NCP. The overall structure is similar to those of other NCPs reported previously. However, the DNA path of human NCP is remarkably different from that taken within other NCPs with an identical DNA sequence. A comparison of the structural parameters between human and Xenopus laevis DNA reveals that the DNA path of human NCP consecutively shifts by 1 bp in the regions of superhelix axis location −5.0 to −2.0 and 5.0 to 7.0. This alteration of the human DNA path is caused predominantly by tight DNA–DNA contacts within the crystal. It is also likely that the conformational change in the human H2B tail induces the local alteration of the DNA path. In human NCP, the region with the altered DNA path lacks Mn²⁺ ions and the B-factors of the DNA phosphate groups are substantially high. Therefore, in contrast to the histone octamer, the nucleosomal DNA is sufficiently flexible and mobile and can undergo drastic conformational changes, depending upon the environment.     

The N-terminal Tails of Histones H2A and H2B Adopt Two Distinct Conformations in the Nucleosome with Contact and Reduced Contact to DNA

The nucleosome comprises two histone dimers of H2A-H2B and one histone tetramer of (H3-H4)₂, wrapped around by ~145 bp of DNA. Detailed core structures of nucleosomes have been established by X-ray and cryo-EM, however, histone tails have not been visualized. Here, we have examined the dynamic structures of the H2A and H2B tails in 145-bp and 193-bp nucleosomes using NMR, and have compared them with those of the H2A and H2B tail peptides unbound and bound to DNA. Whereas the H2A C-tail adopts a single but different conformation in both nucleosomes, the N-tails of H2A and H2B adopt two distinct conformations in each nucleosome. To clarify these conformations, we conducted molecular dynamics (MD) simulations, which suggest that the H2A N-tail can locate stably in either the major or minor grooves of nucleosomal DNA. While the H2B N-tail, which sticks out between two DNA gyres in the nucleosome, was considered to adopt two different orientations, one toward the entry/exit side and one on the opposite side. Then, the H2A N-tail minor groove conformation was obtained in the H2B opposite side and the H2B N-tail interacts with DNA similarly in both sides, though more varied conformations are obtained in the entry/exit side. Collectively, the NMR findings and MD simulations suggest that the minor groove conformer of the H2A N-tail is likely to contact DNA more strongly than the major groove conformer, and the H2A N-tail reduces contact with DNA in the major groove when the H2B N-tail is located in the entry/exit side.     

Sin mutations alter inherent nucleosome mobility

Previous studies have identified sin mutations that alleviate the requirement for the yeast SWI/SNF chromatin remodelling complex, which include point changes in the yeast genes encoding core histones. Here we characterise the biochemical properties of nucleosomes bearing these mutations. We find that sin mutant nucleosomes have a high inherent thermal mobility. As the SWI/SNF complex can alter nucleosome positioning, the higher mobility of sin mutant nucleosomes provides a means by which sin mutations may substitute for SWI/SNF function. The location of sin mutations also provides a new opportunity for insights into the mechanism for nucleosome mobilisation. We find that both mutations altering histone DNA contacts at the nucleosome dyad and mutations in the dimer-tetramer interface influence nucleosome mobility. Furthermore, incorporation of H2A.Z into nucleosomes, which also alters dimer-tetramer interactions, affects nucleosome mobility. Thus, variation of histone sequence or subtype provides a means by which eukaryotes may regulate access to chromatin through alterations to nucleosome mobility.     

Distinct Features of the Histone Core Structure in Nucleosomes Containing the Histone H2A.B Variant

Nucleosomes containing a human histone variant, H2A.B, in an aqueous solution were analyzed by small-angle neutron scattering utilizing a contrast variation technique. Comparisons with the canonical H2A nucleosome structure revealed that the DNA termini of the H2A.B nucleosome are detached from the histone core surface, and flexibly expanded toward the solvent. In contrast, the histone tails are compacted in H2A.B nucleosomes compared to those in canonical H2A nucleosomes, suggesting that they bind to the surface of the histone core and/or DNA. Therefore, the histone tail dynamics may function to regulate the flexibility of the DNA termini in the nucleosomes.     

Distinct Features of the Histone Core Structure in Nucleosomes Containing the Histone H2A.B Variant

Nucleosomes containing a human histone variant, H2A.B, in an aqueous solution were analyzed by small-angle neutron scattering utilizing a contrast variation technique. Comparisons with the canonical H2A nucleosome structure revealed that the DNA termini of the H2A.B nucleosome are detached from the histone core surface, and flexibly expanded toward the solvent. In contrast, the histone tails are compacted in H2A.B nucleosomes compared to those in canonical H2A nucleosomes, suggesting that they bind to the surface of the histone core and/or DNA. Therefore, the histone tail dynamics may function to regulate the flexibility of the DNA termini in the nucleosomes.     

Primary organization of nucleosomes. Interaction of non-histone high mobility group proteins 14 and 17 with nucleosomes, as revealed by DNA-protein crosslinking and immunoaffinity isolation

The binding sites for histones and high mobility group proteins (HMG) 14 and 17 have been located on DNA in the nucleosomal cores and H1/H5-containing nucleosomes. The nucleosomes were specifically associated with two molecules of the non-histone proteins HMG 14 and/or HMG 17 when followed by DNA-protein crosslinking and immunoaffinity isolation of the crosslinked HMG-DNA complexes. HMGs 14 and 17 were shown to be crosslinked in a similar manner to each core DNA strand at four sites: to both 3' and 5' DNA ends and also at distances of about 25 and 125 nucleotides from the 5' termini of the DNA. These sites are designated as HMG(143), (0), (25) and (125). The site HMG(125) is located at the place where no significant histone-DNA crosslinking was observed. The HMG(125) and HMG(25) sites lie opposite one another on the complementary DNA strands across the minor DNA groove and are placed, similarly to histones, on the inner side of the DNA superhelix in the nucleosome. The crosslinking of HMG 17 to the 3' ends of the DNA is much weaker than that of HMG 14. These data indicate that each of two molecules of HMG 14 and/or HMG 17 is bound to the double-stranded core DNA at two discrete sites: to the 3' and 5' ends of the DNA and at a distance of 20 to 25 base-pairs from each DNA terminus inside the nucleosome on a histone-free DNA region. Binding of HMG 14 or 17 does not induce any detectable rearrangement of histones on DNA and both HMGs seem to choose the same sites for attachment in nucleosomal cores and H1/H5-containing nucleosomes.     

Nucleosomes from normal and regenerating rat liver

Micrococcal-nuclease digestion of rat liver nuclei selectively released mononucleosomes associated with ADP-ribosylated [Caplan, Ord & Stocken (1978) Biochem. J.174, 475-483] histone H1. Two classes of mononucleosome were detected, those that leaked out during digestion and those that were subsequently released by 5mm-sodium phosphate buffer (pH6.8)/0.2mm-NaEDTA. The former, from which histone H1 had been dissociated, contained 140-base-pair-length DNA and core histones;the latter contained core particles and mononucleosomes with histone H1 and 200-base-pair-length DNA. When normal liver nuclei were phosphorylated with [gamma-(32)P]ATP, dissociated histone H1, which could be separated from core particles with Sephadex G-200, showed (32)P uptake. (32)P uptake into histones H2A and poly(ADP-ribosyl)ated H3 was appreciable in core particles, but was less evident in nucleosomes still containing histone H1. When [(3)H]-thymidine was given to partially hepatectomized rats in S-phase, 5-10min pulses in animals of over 300g body wt. showed the presence of high-specific-radioactivity DNA in released core particles and mononucleosomes compared with DNA retained in the nuclear pellets. Mononucleosomes from rat livers in S-phase with new, [(3)H]lysine-containing histones, had higher (32)P incorporation in histones H1 and their core histones, than for di- or tri-nucleosomes. Thermal-denaturation properties of control and phosphorylated mononucleosomes and core particles were very similar; removal of histone H1 and non-histone chromosomal proteins in 0.5m-NaCl markedly increased the proportion of DNA ;melting' below 70 degrees C.     

Sequence-dependent nucleosome structural and dynamic polymorphism. Potential involvement of histone H2B N-terminal tail proximal domain

Relaxation of nucleosomes on an homologous series (pBR) of ca 350-370 bp DNA minicircles originating from plasmid pBR322 was recently used as a tool to study their structure and dynamics. These nucleosomes thermally fluctuated between three distinct DNA conformations within a histone N-terminal tail-modulated equilibrium: one conformation was canonical, with 1.75 turn wrapping and negatively crossed entering and exiting DNAs; another was also "closed", but with these DNAs positively crossed; and the third was "open", with a lower than 1.5 turn wrapping and uncrossed DNAs. In this work, a new minicircle series (5S) of similar size was used, which contained the 5S nucleosome positioning sequence. Results showed that DNA in pBR nucleosomes was untwisted by approximately 0.2 turn relative to 5S nucleosomes, which DNase I footprinting confirmed in revealing a approximately 1 bp untwisting at each of the two dyad-distal sites where H2B N-terminal tails pass between the two gyres. In contrast, both nucleosomes showed untwistings at the dyad-proximal sites, i.e. on the other gyre, which were also observed in the high-resolution crystal structure. 5S nucleosomes also differ with respect to their dynamics: they hardly accessed the positively crossed conformation, but had an easier access to the negatively crossed conformation. Simulation showed that such reverse effects on the conformational free energies could be simply achieved by slightly altering the trajectories of entering and exiting DNAs. We propose that this is accomplished by H2B tail untwisting at the distal sites through action at a distance ( approximately 20 bp) on H3-tail interactions with the small groove at the nucleosome entry-exit. These results may help to gain a first glimpse into the two perhaps most intriguing features of the high-resolution structure: the alignment of the grooves on the two gyres and the passage of H2B and H3 N-terminal tails between them.     

Structural dynamics of nucleosome core particle: comparison with nucleosomes containing histone variants

The present study provides insights on the dominant mechanisms of motions of the nucleosome core particle and the changes in its functional dynamics in response to histone variants. Comparative analysis of the global dynamics of nucleosomes with native and variant H2A histones, using normal mode analysis revealed that the dynamics of the nucleosome is highly symmetric, and its interaction with the nucleosomal DNA plays a vital role in its regulation. The collective dynamics of nucleosomes are predicted to be dominated by two types of large-scale motions: (1) a global stretching-compression of nucleosome along the dyad axis by which the nucleosome undergoes a breathing motion with a massive distortion of nucleosomal DNA, modulated by histone-DNA interactions; and (2) the flipping (or bending) of both the sides of the nucleosome in an out-of-plane fashion with respect to the dyad axis, originated by the highly dynamic N-termini of H3 and (H2A.Z-H2B) dimer in agreement with the experimentally observed perturbed dynamics of the particular N-terminus under physiological conditions. In general, the nucleosomes with variant histones exhibit higher mobilities and weaker correlations between internal motions compared to the nucleosome containing ordinary histones. The differences are more pronounced at the L1 and L2 loops of the respective monomers H2B and H2A, and at the N-termini of the monomers H3 and H4, all of which closely interact with the wrapping DNA.     

Different mechanism for in vitro formation of nucleosome core particles

The interaction of different histone oligomers with nucleosomes has been investigated by using nondenaturing gel electrophoresis. In the presence of 0.2 M NaCl, the addition of the pairs H2A,H2B or H3,H4 or the four core histones to nucleosome core particles produces a decrease in the intensity of the core particle band and the appearance of aggregated material at the top of the gel, indicating that all these histone oligomers are able to associate with nucleosomes. Equivalent results were obtained by using oligonucleosome core particles. Additional electrophoretic results, together with second-dimension analysis of histone composition and fluorescence and solubility studies, indicate that H2A,H2B, H3,H4, and the four core histones can migrate spontaneously from the aggregated nucleosomes containing excess histones to free core DNA. In all cases the estimated yield of histone transfer is very high. Furthermore, the results obtained from electron microscopy, solubility, and supercoiling assays demonstrate the transfer of excess histones from oligonucleosomes to free circular DNA. However, the extent of solubilization obtained in this case is lower than that observed with core DNA as histone acceptor. Our results demonstrate that nucleosome core particles can be formed in 0.2 M NaCl by the following mechanisms: (1) transfer of excess core histones from oligonucleosomes of free DNA, (2) transfer to excess H2A,H2B and H3,H4 associated separately with oligonucleosomes to free DNA, (3) transfer to excess H2A,H2B initially associated with oligonucleosomes to DNA, followed by the reaction of the resulting DNA-(H2A,H2B) complex with oligonucleosomes containing excess H3,H4, and (4) a two-step transfer reaction similar to that indicated in (3), in which excess histones H3,H4 are transferred to DNA before the reaction with oligonucleosomes containing excess H2A,H2B. The possible biological implications of these spontaneous reactions are discussed in the context of the present knowledge of the nucleosome function.     

Inner nuclear membrane protein LBR preferentially interacts with DNA secondary structures and nucleosomal linker

The lamin B receptor (LBR) is an integral protein of inner nuclear membrane whose nucleoplasmic amino-terminal domain contributes to the attachment of the membrane to chromatin. Here we analyzed the interactions of a recombinant GST protein containing the amino-terminal domain of the protein with in vitro reconstituted nucleosomes and short DNA fragments. Data show that the LBR amino-terminal domain (AT) binds linker DNA but does not interact with the nucleosome core. Titration and competition studies revealed that the interaction between LBR AT and DNA is saturable, of high affinity (K(D) approximately 4 nM), independent of DNA sequence, and enhanced by DNA curvature and supercoiling. In this respect, LBR amino-terminal domain binding to nucleosomes is similar to that of histone H1 and non histone proteins HMG1/2 which both bind preferentially to linker DNA and present a significant affinity for DNA secondary structures.     

The role of H2B histones from the sea urchin sperm in the formation of supranucleosome structures

The structural role of histone H2B from sea urchin sperm (H2Bsp) has been examined in experiments on reconstitution of chromatin from DNA and core histones taken in three variants: (1) four core histones from sea urchin sperm; (2) four core histones from calf thymus; (3) (H3, H4, H2A) from calf thymus and H2Bsp. It is shown that H2Bsp when present in reconstituted chromatin induces its aggregation. Fidelity of the reconstitution of nucleosomes has been tested using DNase I probe, one- and two-dimensional electrophoresis and electron microscopy. The reconstitutes that contain H2Bsp appear under electron microscope mainly as regular closely spaced large granules, about 450 A in diameter, which are very similar to the granules found in "native" sea urchin sperm chromatin. The reconstitutes formed by four core histones from calf thymus appear as randomly arranged particles, about 100 A in diameter. We conclude that histone H2Bsp participates in interactions between nucleosomes and is involved in the formation of the condensed supranucleosomal structure in sea urchin sperm chromatin.     

X-ray diffraction study of a new crystal form of the nucleosome core showing higher resolution

Crystals have been grown of intact (unproteolysed) nucleosome cores from a variety of sources. The unit cells are all very similar, with one core particle per asymmetric unit. The X-ray diffraction patterns extend to about 5 Å in the direction perpendicular to the plane of the flat particle, and to somewhat less than this in other directions. The arrangement of particles in the unit cell has been deduced from Patterson projection maps, which also indicate the presence of a particle dyad. The data are consistent with the earlier proposed model for the core particle in which the 146 base-pairs of DNA are wound in about $\text{1}\text{3}\text{4}$ turns of superhelix about a histone octamer core.High angle diffuse X-ray scattering from the crystals shows that the DNA of the core particle is in the B form. The anisotropy of the diffuse scattering shows that the DNA is not firmly fixed to the histone core all along the superhelix path, but only over limited regions whose location correlates well with those in which the DNA is differentially protected against nuclease digestion.