Pulsatile signaling in intercellular communication. Periodic stimuli are more efficient than random or chaotic signals in a model based on receptor desensitization.

The efficiency of various patterns of pulsatile stimulation is determined in a model in which a receptor becomes desensitized in the presence of its stimulatory ligand. The effect of stochastic or chaotic changes in the duration and/or interval between successive pulses in a series of square-wave stimuli is investigated. Before addressing the effect of random variations in the pulsatile signal, we first extend the results of a previous analysis (Li, Y.X., and A. Goldbeter. 1989. Biophys. J. 55:125-145) by demonstrating the existence of an optimal periodic signal that maximizes target cell responsiveness whatever the magnitude of stimulation. As to the effect of stochastic or chaotic variations in the pulsatile stimulus, three kinds of random distributions are used, namely, a Gaussian and a white-noise distribution, and a chaotic time series generated by the logistic map. All these random distributions are symmetrically centered around the reference value of the duration or interval that characterizes the optimal periodic stimulus yielding maximal responsiveness in target cells. Stochastically or chaotically varying pulses are less effective than the periodic signal that corresponds to the optimal pattern of pulsatile stimulation. The response of the receptor system is most sensitive to changes in the time interval that separates successive stimuli. Similar conclusions hold when stochastic or chaotic signals are compared to a reference periodic stimulus differing from the optimal one, although the effect of random variations is then reduced. The decreased efficiency of stochastic pulses accounts for the observed superiority of periodic versus stochastic pulses of cyclic AMP (cAMP) in Dictyostelium amoebae. The results are also discussed with respect to the efficiency of periodic versus stochastic or chaotic patterns of hormone secretion.     

Frequency encoding of pulsatile signals of cAMP based on receptor desensitization in Dictyostelium cells

Dictyostelium discoideum amoebae represent a prototype for the study of periodic signaling in intercellular communication. These cells synthesize cAMP in response to cAMP pulses. Cell responsiveness in Dictyostelium can be characterized by the capability to generate a large number of significant responses to cAMP signals in a given amount of time. The existence of a frequency of pulsatile cAMP signals yielding maximum responsiveness is demonstrated by analysis of a realistic model for cAMP synthesis, based on receptor desensitization. The optimal frequency of stimulation closely depends on the kinetics of receptor desensitization and resensitization in target cells. Synthesis of cAMP is determined both in conditions where cells are not excitable and in conditions where they relay suprathreshold pulses of cAMP. Moreover, the effect of the stimulus waveform is investigated, and several measures of cell responsiveness are compared. The results provide an explanation for the effectiveness of cAMP pulses delivered at 5 min intervals, and for the failure of pulses delivered at 2 min intervals, in inducing slime mold development. Besides applying to intercellular communication in Dictyostelium, the present analysis bears on patterns of pulsatile signaling observed for hormones and growth factors. In all these cases, it appears that pulsatile signals can be encoded in terms of their frequency on the basis of desensitization in target cells.     

A Model Based on Receptor Desensitization for Cyclic AMP Signaling in Dictyostelium Cells

We analyze a model based on receptor modification for the cAMP signaling system that controls aggregation of the slime mold Dictyostelium discoideum after starvation. The model takes into account both the desensitization of the cAMP receptor by reversible phosphorylation and the activation of adenylate cyclase that follows binding of extracellular cAMP to the unmodified receptor. The dynamics of the signaling system is studied in terms of three variables, namely, intracellular and extracellular cAMP, and the fraction of receptor in active state. Using parameter values collected from experimental studies on cAMP signaling and receptor phosphorylation, we show that the model accounts qualitatively and, in a large measure, quantitatively for the various modes of dynamic behavior observed in the experiments: (a) autonomous oscillations of cAMP, (b) relay of suprathreshold cAMP pulses, i.e., excitability, characterized by both an absolute and a relative refractory period, and (c) adaptation to constant cAMP stimuli. A two-variable version of the model is used to demonstrate the link between excitability and oscillations by phase plane analysis. The response of the model to repetitive stimulation allows comprehension, in terms of receptor desensitization, of the role of periodic signaling in Dictyostelium and, more generally, the function of pulsatile patterns of hormone secretion.     

Periodic stimuli are more successful than randomly spaced ones for inducing development inDictyostelium discoideum

Aggregation in the cellular slime moldDictyostelium discoideum is due to chemotaxis. The chemoattractant, cyclic AMP, is synthesised and released periodically by the cells. Externally applied periodic pulses of cyclic AMP can also induce differentiation in this organism. The present work examines the role of periodicityper se in cyclic AMP-mediated stimulation of cell differentiation. For this purpose we use Agip53, aDictyostelium mutant which does not develop beyond the vegetative state but can be made to aggregate and differentiate by reiterated applications of cyclic AMP. Importantly, Agip53 cells do not make or release any cyclic AMP themselves even in response to an increase in extracellular cyclic AMP. A comparison of the relative efficiencies of periodic and aperiodic stimulation shows that whereas the two patterns of stimulation are equally effective in inducing the formation of EDTA-stable cell contacts, periodic stimuli are significantly superior for inducing terminal differentiation. This suggests that there must be molecular pathways which can only function when stimulation occurs at regular intervals.     

Cyclic GMP and cyclic AMP changes in response to folic acid pulses during cell development of Dictyostelium discoideum.

Folic acid pulses induced developmental processes in agip 71, a morphogenetic mutant of Dictyostelium discoideum, strain Ax-2. Cells that had received folic acid pulses were able to form EDTA-stable cell aggregates and to complete full differentiation to fruiting bodies. In these cells no autonomous periodic activities were observed by light scattering. Folic acid pulses elicited increases in the concentrations of cyclic GMP and cyclic AMP. In undifferentiated cells, folic acid caused a rapid increase in the level of cyclic GMP without a significant change in the level of cyclic AMP. In an advanced developmental state folic acid caused an increase in cyclic AMP in addition to two successsive peaks of cyclic GMP. Experiments performed with the parent strain, Ax-2, also showed that during the development towards aggregation competence, cells acquired the ability to produce a cyclic AMP peak in response to folic acid.     

Homologous Desensitization of the D1 Dopamine Receptor

Preincubation of D384 cells, derived from the human astrocytoma cell line G-CCM, with dopamine resulted in a time-dependent attenuation of cyclic AMP responsiveness to subsequent dopamine stimulation. This effect was agonist specific because the prostaglandin E1 (PGE1) stimulation of cyclic AMP of similarly treated cells remained unchanged. The attenuation by dopamine was concentration dependent with a maximum observed at 100 microM. A comparison of dopamine concentration-response curves of control and dopamine-preincubated cells revealed no change in the Ka apparent value, but a marked attenuation of the maximal response. Preincubation of cells with dopamine in the presence of D1 but not D2 selective antagonists partially prevented the observed attenuation. Attenuations in dopamine responsiveness were also obtained when D384 cells were preincubated with D1 but not D2 receptor agonists. The level of attenuation attained related to agonist efficiency in stimulating cyclic AMP: SKF38393 less than 3,4-dihydroxynomifensine less than fenoldopam less than 2-amino-6,7-dihydroxy-1,2,3,4-tetrahydronaphthalene = dopamine. However, increasing the efficiency of 3,4-dihydroxynomifensine stimulation of cyclic AMP, using the synergistic effect of adding a low concentration of forskolin, produced no further change in the attenuation of the subsequent response to dopamine. Thus, the D1 dopamine receptors expressed by D384 cells undergo homologous desensitization. Uncoupling of the D1 dopamine receptor appears to be independent of cyclic AMP formation, analogous to a mechanism proposed for the beta-adrenergic receptor.     

A plausible role for a membrane-bound cyclic AMP phosphodiesterase in cellular slime mold chemotaxis.

1. Kinetics of membrane-bound cyclic AMP phosphodiesterase of the cellular slime mold, Dictyostelium discoideum, were studied under two conditions: in the 27 000 times g sediment of cell homogenates (particle-bound phosphodiesterase) and in cell suspensions using external cyclic AMP as a substrate (cell-bound phosphodiesterase). Both methods revealed non-Michaelian kinetics with interaction coefficients less than 1. 2. The membrane-bound phosphodiesterase has a specificity different from that of the cyclic AMP receptor, also present at the cell surface. 3. The membrane-bound enzyme was solubilized by lithium 3, 5-diiodosalicylate and partially purified. In this state the non-linear kinetics were still retained; however, the enzyme was not inhibited by the D. discoideum inhibitor, unlike the cell-bound phosphodiesterase in vivo. This indicates that both enzymes share an inhibitor binding site and that this site is cryptic in the cell-bound state. 4. Production of periodic cyclic AMP pulses by centers, and their relay by other cells, is believed to occur during aggregation. It is suggested that the cell-bound enzyme determines a "time window" significantly smaller than the period of pulsing, and optimizes stimulation of the cyclic AMP receptors in chemotaxis and signal relaying.     

Cyclic AMP waves during aggregation of Dictyostelium amoebae

During the aggregation phase of their life cycle, Dictyostelium discoideum amoebae communicate with each other by traveling waves of cyclic AMP. These waves are generated by an interplay between random diffusion of cyclic AMP in the extracellular milieu and the signal-reception/signal/relaying capabilities of individual amoebae. Kinetic properties of the enzymes, transport proteins and cell-surface receptor proteins involved in the cyclic AMP signaling system have been painstakingly worked out over the past fifteen years in many laboratories. Recently Martiel & Goldbeter (1987) incorporated this biochemical information into a unified mathematical model of communication among Dictyostelium amoebae. Numerical simulations of the mathematical model, carried out by Tyson et al. (1989), agree in quantitative detail with experimental observations of cyclic AMP traveling waves in Dictyostelium cultures. Such mathematical modeling and numerical experimentation provide a necessary link between detailed studies of the molecular control mechanism and experimental observations of the intact developmental system.     

Suppression of cyclic AMP-induced cell excitation in Dictyostelium discoideum by inhibitors of eicosanoid oxidation

Abstract Receptor-mediated stimulation of Dictyostelium cells by the aggregative chemoattractant cyclic AMP leads to a complex excitatory response resulting in chemotaxis and the synthesis and release of cyclic AMP as the relayed chemotactic signal. However, the mechanism of this stimulus-response coupling is not well understood. In this study, we show that a number of compounds, best known as inhibitors of cyclooxygenase activity in mammalian cells, prevent cyclic AMP receptor-mediated cell excitation and cyclic AMP accumulation in aggregation-competent Dictyostelium cells. These observations suggest that some eicosanoid-like compound(s) may be involved in stimulus-response coupling in this organism, as is the case in higher eukaryotic cells.     

Oscillations and waves of cyclic AMP in Dictyostelium: A prototype for spatio-temporal organization and pulsatile intercellular communication

The amoebae Dictyostelium discoideum aggregate after starvation in a wavelike manner in response to periodic pulses of cyclic AMP (cAMP) secreted by cells which behave as aggregation centers. In addition to autonomous oscillations, the cAMP signaling system that controls aggregation is also capable of excitable behavior, which consists in the transient amplification of suprathreshold pulses of extracellular cAMP. Since the first theoretical model for slime mold aggregation proposed by Keller and Segel in 1970, many theoretical studies have addressed various aspects of the mechanism and function of cAMP signaling in Dictyostelium. This paper presents a brief overview of these developments as well as some reminiscences of the author's collaboration with Lee Segel in modeling the dynamics of cAMP relay and oscillations. Considered in turn are models for cAMP signaling in Dictyostelium, the developmental path followed by the cAMP signaling system after starvation, the frequency encoding of cAMP signals, and the origin of concentric or spiral waves of cAMP.     

Galpha-mediated inhibition of developmental signal response

BACKGROUND: Seven-transmembrane receptor (7-TMR)-G protein networks are molecular sensors of extracellular signals in all eukarya. These pathways cycle through activated (sensitized) and inhibited (desensitized) states, and, while many of the molecular components for signal activation have been described, inhibitory mechanisms are not well characterized. In Dictyostelium, 7-TM cAMP receptors direct chemotaxis and development but also regulate the periodic synthesis of their own ligand, the chemoattractant/morphogen cAMP. We now demonstrate through loss-of-function/gain-of-function studies that the novel heterotrimeric Galpha9 protein subunit regulates an inhibitory pathway during early Dictyostelium development for the cAMP signal response.RESULTS: galpha9 null cells form more cAMP signaling centers, are more resistant to compounds that inhibit cAMP signaling, and complete aggregation sooner and at lower cell densities than wild-type cells. These phentoypes are consistent with the loss of an inhibitory signaling pathway during development of galpha9 null cells. Cells expressing constitutively activated Galpha9 are defective in cAMP signaling center formation and development at low cell density and display an increased sensitivity to cAMP signal inhibition that is characteristic of enhanced suppression of the cAMP signal response. Finally, we demonstrate that galpha9 null cells, which have been codeveloped with a majority of wild-type cells, primarily establish cAMP signaling centers and are able to non-autonomously direct wild-type cells to adopt a galpha9 null-like phenotype.CONCLUSIONS: We suggest that Galpha9 functions in an inhibitory-feedback pathway that regulates cAMP signaling center formation and propagation. Galpha9 may be part of the mechanism that regulates lateral signal inhibition or that modulates receptor desensitization.     

Evidence that the rate of association of adenosine 3'',5''-monophosphate to its chemotactic receptor induces phosphodiesterase activity in Dictyostelium discoideum

Adenosine 3',5'-monophosphate (cyclic AMP) mediates cell aggregation in Dictyostelium discoideum. Cell aggregation is enhanced by pulses of cyclic AMP. Application of pulses of cyclic AMP to cells that were starved only for 1 h (postvegetative cells) induces enzyme activity. One of the enzymes induced by cyclic AMP pulses is phosphodiesterase. We pulsed postvegetative cells with a set of cyclic AMP derivatives that were selected according to certain conformational and physical-chemical properties, and we measured their effect on the induction of phosphodiesterase activity. The cyclic nucleotide specificity for chemotaxis in the aggregative phase was similar to the specificity for phosphodiesterase induction in the postvegetative phase. The shape of the dose-response curves shows a paradox: the activity of a derivative, when applied at receptor-saturating concentrations, is inversely related to its affinity. These results can be explained by the assumption that the response of the chemoreceptor to different cyclic AMP derivatives is proportional to the frequency of associations (rate receptor) and not to the proportion of occupied receptors (occupation receptor). The characteristics of rate receptors and occupation receptors during chemosensory transduction will be discussed.     

Homologous beta-adrenergic desensitization in isolated rat hepatocytes.

Hepatocytes from hypothyroid rats have a marked beta-adrenergic responsiveness. Preincubation of these hepatocytes with isoprenaline induced a time-dependent and concentration-dependent desensitization of the beta-adrenergic responsiveness without altering that to glucagon (homologous desensitization). The desensitization was evidenced both in the cyclic AMP accumulation and in the stimulation of ureagenesis induced by the beta-adrenergic agonists. Under the same conditions, preincubation with glucagon induced no desensitization. Propranolol was also unable to induce desensitization, but blocked that induced by isoprenaline. Pertussis-toxin treatment did not alter the homologous beta-adrenergic desensitization induced by isoprenaline.     

Characterization of the homologous and heterologous desensitization of rat Leydig-tumour-cell adenylate cyclase.

The homologous and heterologous desensitization of rat Leydig-tumour-cell adenylate cyclase induced by lutropin (LH) was characterized with the aid of forskolin and cholera toxin. Forskolin stimulated cyclic AMP production in a dose-dependent manner, with linear kinetics up to 2h. Forskolin also potentiated the action of LH on cyclic AMP production, but was only additive with cholera toxin. Preincubation of rat Leydig tumour cells with LH (1.0 micrograms/ml) for 1 h produced a desensitization of the subsequent LH (1.0 micrograms/ml)-stimulated cyclic AMP production, whereas the responses to cholera toxin (5.0 micrograms/ml), forskolin (100 microM), LH plus forskolin or cholera toxin plus forskolin were unaltered. In contrast, preincubation with LH for 20h produced a desensitization to all the stimuli tested. When rat Leydig tumour cells were preincubated for 1h with forskolin or dibutyryl cyclic AMP, the only subsequent response that was significantly altered was that to LH plus forskolin after preincubation with forskolin. However, preincubation for 20h with forskolin or dibutyryl cyclic AMP induced a desensitization to all stimuli subsequently tested. LH produced a rapid (0-1h) homologous desensitization, which was followed by a slower (2-8h)-onset heterologous desensitization. Forskolin and dibutyryl cyclic AMP were only able to induce heterologous desensitization. The rate of desensitization induced by either forskolin or dibutyryl cyclic AMP was similar to the rate of heterologous desensitization induced by LH. These results demonstrate that in purified rat Leydig tumour cells LH produces an initial homologous desensitization of adenylate cyclase that involves a cyclic AMP-independent lesion at or proximal to the guanine nucleotide regulatory protein (G-protein). This is followed by heterologous desensitization, which can also be induced by forskolin or dibutyryl cyclic AMP, thus indicating that LH-induced heterologous desensitization of rat Leydig-tumour-cell adenylate cyclase involves a cyclic AMP-dependent lesion that is after the G-protein.     

Desensitization of the epidermal adenylate cyclase system: agonists and phorbol esters desensitize by independent mechanisms.

Exposure of pig epidermis to adenylate cyclase stimulators results in receptor-specific desensitization. We investigated the nature of the agonist-induced desensitization, which was compared with the phorbol ester-induced, receptor-nonspecific desensitization. Both phorbol ester-induced desensitization and the agonist-induced desensitization were accompanied by an increase in forskolin- and cholera toxin-induced cyclic AMP accumulations. The magnitude of the increase in the agonist-induced desensitization was parallel to the degree of the initial cyclic AMP accumulation; histamine and adenosine, which increase more cyclic AMP than epinephrine, resulted in a more marked increase in forskolin- and cholera toxin-induced cyclic AMP accumulations. Similarly, epidermis desensitized to multiple receptors revealed more marked forskolin- and cholera toxin-induced cyclic AMP accumulations than epidermis desensitized to a single receptor. In contrast to the phorbol ester-induced desensitization, agonist-induced desensitization was not affected by the protein kinase C inhibitors H-7 and staurosporin. Further, agonist-induced desensitization was still inducible in phorbol ester-desensitized epidermis and vice versa. In contrast to the agonist-induced desensitization, which is accompanied by the preceding adenylate cyclase stimulation, no evidence for the stimulation of the adenylate cyclase during phorbol ester treatment was obtained. Neither agonist-induced desensitization nor phorbol ester-induced desensitization affected the content of inhibitory guanine nucleotide binding protein of the epidermis, which was monitored by the pertussis toxin (IAP)-catalyzed ADP ribosylation reaction. Our results indicate that agonist-induced desensitization and the phorbol ester-induced desensitization are independent of each other. Although both processes are characterized by increased forskolin- and toxin-induced cyclic AMP accumulations, the former is accompanied by initial cyclic AMP accumulation; the latter is not.     

Time-patterned drug administration: insights from a modeling approach

The physiological effects of a drug depend not only on its molecular structure but also on the time-pattern of its administration. One of the main reasons for the importance of temporal patterns in drug action is biological rhythms—particularly those of circadian period. These rhythms affect most physiological functions as well as drug metabolism, clearance, and dynamic processes that may alter drug availability and target cell responsiveness with reference to biological time. We present an overview of the importance of time-patterned signals in physiology focused on the insights provided by a modeling approach. We first discuss examples of pulsatile intercellular communication by hormones such as gonadotropin-releasing hormone, and by cyclic adenosine monophosphate (cAMP) signals in Dictyostelium amoebae. Models based on reversible receptor desensitization account in both cases for the existence of optimal patterns of pulsatile signaling. Turning to circadian rhythms, we examine how models can be used to account for the response of 24h patterns to external stimuli such as light pulses or gene expression, and to predict how to restore the physiological characteristics of altered rhythms. Time-patterned treatments of cancer involve two distinct lines of research. The first, currently evaluated in clinical trials, relies on circadian chronomodulation of anticancer drugs, while the second, mostly based on theoretical studies, involves a resonance phenomenon with the cell-cycle length. We discuss the implications of modeling studies to improve the temporal patterning of drug administration.     

Agonist-induced desensitization of an octopamine receptor

The octopamine-sensitive adenylate cyclase associated with haemocytes of the American cockroach, Periplaneta americana, has been used as a model system with which to study desensitization of the octopamine receptor. Preincubation of the haemocytes with octopamine results in a large decrease in subsequent maximal stimulation of cyclic AMP production by octopamine with little change in affinity of the receptor for the agonist. This effect of preincubation is dependent upon the concentration of octopamine in the preincubation media and on the duration of exposure. The attenuation appears to be a receptor-mediated event rather than an artifact of the preincubation. Octopamine receptor agonists (octopamine, synephrine, N-demethylchlordimeform) induce desensitization while biogenic amines with poor octopamine receptor affinity (dopamine, serotonin, norepinephrine) are without affect. In contrast, the octopamine receptor antagonist, phentolamine, appears to enhance subsequent stimulation by octopamine. The attenuation of octopamine stimulation of adenylate cyclase is conserved in broken-cell preparations with no alteration of responses to NaF or forskolin. Incubation of the cells with dibutyryl cyclic AMP or forskolin does not induce desensitization. The data indicate that the OA receptors coupled to AC in cockroach haemocytes undergo an homologous desensitization in response to exposure to agonists.     

cAMP-induced desensitization of surface cAMP receptors in Dictyostelium: different second messengers mediate receptor phosphorylation, loss of ligand binding, degradation of receptor, and reduction of receptor mRNA levels.

Surface cAMP receptors on Dictyostelium cells are linked to several second messenger systems and mediate multiple physiological responses, including chemotaxis and differentiation. Activation of the receptor also triggers events which desensitize signal transduction. These events include the following: 1) loss of ligand binding without loss of receptor protein; 2) phosphorylation of the receptor protein, which may lead to impaired signal transduction; 3) redistribution and degradation of the receptor protein; and 4) decrease of cyclic AMP (cAMP) receptor mRNA levels. These mechanisms of desensitization were investigated with the use of mutant synag7, with no activation of adenylyl cyclase; fgdC, with no activation of phospholipase C; and fgdA, with defects in both pathways. cAMP-induced receptor phosphorylation and loss of ligand binding activity was normal in all mutants. In contrast, cAMP-induced degradation of the receptor was absent in all mutants. The cAMP-induced decrease of cAMP-receptor mRNA levels was normal in mutant synag7, but absent in mutant fgdC. Finally, the cAMP analogue (Rp)-cAMPS induced loss of ligand binding without inducing second messenger responses or phosphorylation, redistribution, and degradation of the receptor. We conclude that 1) loss of ligand binding can occur in the absence of receptor phosphorylation; 2) loss of ligand binding and receptor phosphorylation do not require the activation of second messenger systems; 3) cAMP-induced degradation of the receptor may require the phosphorylation of the receptor as well as the activation of at least the synag7 and fgdC gene products; and 4) cAMP-induced decrease of receptor mRNA levels requires the activation of the fgdC gene product and not the synag7 gene product. These results imply that desensitization is composed of multiple components that are regulated by different but partly overlapping sensory transduction pathways.     

Rapid in vitro desensitization of the testosterone response in rat Leydig cells by sub-active concentrations of porcine luteinizing hormone

We have studied in rat Leydig cells, the effect of sub-active concentrations of porcine LH on the subsequent stimulation of the cAMP and testosterone production by a sub-maximal concentration of pLH or hCG. We found that extremely low concentrations of pLH (0.01-2.0 ng/ml) were able to induce rapidly a partial but highly significative desensitization of the testosterone response without affecting the cyclic AMP response. These data indicate that desensitization of the steroidogenic response might be due to some lesion beyond cAMP formation or at the level of one discrete compartment of cyclic AMP, directly involved in the control of steroidogenesis. Moreover, our data strongly suggest that the basal circulating concentrations of LH can exert an inhibitory control on the testosterone response to LH pulses in vivo.     

Local and spatially coordinated movements in Dictyostelium discoideum amoebae during chemotaxis

We have studied chemotaxis by individual Dictyostelium discoideum amoebae using strong, local gradients of the chemoattractant cyclic AMP. Gradients were provided by diffusion of cyclic AMP from a microneedle, which could be positioned at various points around the cell. Responses to changes in the gradient indicate how the cell is structurally organized for chemotactic movement. There is a polarity in the responsiveness of the surface to stimulation by cyclic AMP along the length of the amoeba. Furthermore, two aspects of chemotactic movement can be distinguished. The first response to cyclic AMP is a locally generated extension of a hyaline pseudopod from the region of the surface nearest the stimulus. The second response, the flow of cytoplasm in the direction of the stimulus, is coordinated and separate from the first response. The coordination appears to depend on the nucleus or on the microtubule-organizing center.