Further evidence for the participation of proteins S 3, S 14 and S 19 in tRNA binding to E. coli 30 S subunits

Previous studies have shown that iodination of 30 S subunits causes inactivation for both enzymatic fMet-tRNA and non-enzymatic phe-tRNA binding activities. This inactivation was shown to be due to the modification of three to five ribosomal proteins [1]. In this report the role of these proteins in tRNA binding activity has been further studied. Purified ribosomal proteins, isolated from modified subunits, are re-assembled into otherwise unmodified 30 S ribosomes and assayed for tRNA binding capacity. The presence of modified S 3, S 14 and S 19 (S 15) in the reconstituted particle results in substantial reduction of both fMet-tRNA and phe-tRNA binding activities. This reduction in tRNA binding activity does not appear to be due to an assembly defect.     

The ribosome modulation factor (RMF) binding site on the 100S ribosome of Escherichia coli

During the stationary growth phase, Escherichia coli 70S ribosomes are converted to 100S ribosomes, and translational activity is lost. This conversion is caused by the binding of the ribosome modulation factor (RMF) to 70S ribosomes. In order to elucidate the mechanisms by which 100S ribosomes form and translational inactivation occurs, the shape of the 100S ribosome and the RMF ribosomal binding site were investigated by electron microscopy and protein-protein cross-linking, respectively. We show that (i) the 100S ribosome is formed by the dimerization of two 70S ribosomes mediated by face-to-face contacts between their constituent 30S subunits, and (ii) RMF binds near the ribosomal proteins S13, L13, and L2. The positions of these proteins indicate that the RMF binding site is near the peptidyl transferase center or the P site (peptidyl-tRNA binding site). These observations are consistent with the translational inactivation of the ribosome by RMF binding. After the "Recycling" stage, ribosomes can readily proceed to the "Initiation" stage during exponential growth, but during stationary phase, the majority of 70S ribosomes are stored as 100S ribosomes and are translationally inactive. We suggest that this conversion of 70S to 100S ribosomes represents a newly identified stage of the ribosomal cycle in stationary phase cells, and we have termed it the "Hibernation" stage.     

On the role of protein S4 N-terminal residues 1 through 30 in 30S ribosome function.

30S ribosomal protein S4 contains a single cysteine residue at position 31. We have selectively cleaved the peptide bond adjacent to this residue using the reagent 2-nitro-5-thiocyanobenzoic acid. The two resultant fragments were purified. The smaller S4-fragment (1-30) was found to be incapable of interacting with 16S RNA directly. This fragment also is not incorporated into a particle reconstituted from 16S RNA and 20 purified proteins with S4 missing. In contrast, the large S4-fragment (31-203) appears to be fully functional in ribosome assembly. Replacement of S4 with this fragment in the reconstitution reaction leads to a complete 30S ribosome containing all 30S proteins. This particle has a full capacity to bind poly U but has lost all activity for poly U directed phe-tRNA binding. We therefore propose that the N-terminus of protein S4 is not critical for ribosome assembly but is essential for tRNA binding.     

The binding sites for tRNA on eukaryotic ribosomes.

We have studied the non-enzymic binding of phe-tRNA to ribosomes from rat liver using deacylated tRNA to inhibit binding to the P-site and puromycin (5 x 10-minus3M) to inhibit binding to the A-site. We conclude that at a low concentration of magnesium ions (10mM) phe-tRNA is bound only at the A-site of 80S irbosomes, whereas at a high concentration of magnesium ions (40mM) phe-tRNA is also bound at the P-site. Studies with edeine indicate that, during non-enzymic binding of phe-tRNA, eukaryotic ribosomes (in contrast to prokarotic ribosomes) have the A-site of the 60S subunit and the initiation site of the 40S subunit juxtaposed. This may account for the differences observed, in formation of diphenylalanyl-tRNA and phenylalanyl-puromycin, between phe-tRNA bound non-enzymically to the P-sites of eukaryotic and prokaryotic ribosomes.     

Chemical inactivation of Escherichia coli 30-S ribosomes by iodination. Identification of proteins involved in tRNA binding.

30-S ribosomal subunits are inactivated by iodination for both enzymic fMet-tRNA and non-enzymic Phe-tRNA binding activities. This inactivation is due to modification of the protein moiety of the ribosome. Reconstitutions were performed with 16-S RNA and mixtures of total protein isolated from modified subunits and purified proteins isolated from unmodified subunits. This allowed identification of the individual proteins which restore tRNA binding activity. S3, S14 and S19 were identified as proteins involved in fMet-tRNA binding. S1, S2, S3, S14 and S19 were identified as proteins involved in Phe-tRNA binding. Modified particles shown normal sedimentation constants and complete protein compositions both before and after reconstitution. This suggests that the loss of activity is due to modification of one or more of the actual binding sites located on the 30-S subunit and that restoration of activity is due to structural correction at this site rather than to correction of an assembly defect.     

Effects of aminoethylation of cysteine residues on the structural and functional activities of the Escherichia coli 30 S ribosomal proteins

The purified 30 S ribosomal proteins from Escherichia coli strain Q13 were chemically modified by reaction with ethyleneimine, specifically converting cysteine residues to S-2-aminoethylcysteine residues. Proteins S1, S2, S4, S8, S11, S12, S13, S14, S17, S18 and S21 were found to contain aminoethylcysteine residues after modification, whereas proteins S3, S5, S6, S7, S9, S10, S15, S16, S19 and S20 did not. Aminoethylated proteins S4, S13, S17 and S18 were active in the reconstitution of 30 S ribosomes and did not have altered functional activities in poly(U)-dependent polyphenylalanine synthesis, R17-dependent protein synthesis, fMet-tRNA binding and Phe-tRNA binding. Aminoethylated proteins S2, S11, S12, S14 and S21 were not active in the reconstitution of complete 30 S ribosomes, either because the aminoethylated protein did not bind stably to the ribosome (S2, S11, S12 and S21) or because the aminoethylated protein did not stabilize the binding of other ribosomal proteins (S14). The functional activities of 30 S ribosomes reconstituted from a mixture of proteins containing one sensitive aminoethylated protein (S2, S11, S12, S14 or S21) were similar to ribosomes reconstituted from mixtures lacking that protein. These results imply that the sulfhydryl groups of the proteins S4, S13, S17 and S18 are not necessary for the structural or functional activities of these proteins, and that aminoethylation of the sulfhydryl groups of S2, S11, S12, S14 and S21 forms either a kinetic or thermodynamic barrier to the assembly of active 30 S ribosomes in vitro.     

Characterization of different conformational forms of 30 S ribosomal subunits in isolated and associated states: possible correlations between structure and function.

The reaction pattern with N-[¹⁴C]ethylmaleimide served to follow conformational changes of 30 S ribosomal subunits that are induced by association with 50 S subunits and by the binding of aminoacyl-tRNA to 70 S ribosomes either enzymatically or non-enzymatically.The usefulness of the reaction with N-ethylmaleimide in discerning different conformational forms of the ribosome was previously demonstrated (Ginzburg et al., 1973) in an analysis of inactive and active 30 S subunits (as obtained at low Mg²⁺ and after heat reactivation, respectively). The reaction pattern of the 30 S moiety of 70 S ribosomes differs from the pattern of isolated active subunits (the only form capable of forming 70 S ribosomes) in both the nature of the labeled proteins and in being Mg²⁺-dependent. The reaction at 10 mm-Mg²⁺ reveals the following differences between isolated and reassociated 30 S subunits: (1) proteins S1, S18 and S21 that are not labeled in isolated active subunits, but are labeled in the inactive subunits, are highly reactive in 70 S ribosomes; (2) proteins S2, S4, S12 and S17 that uniquely react with N-ethylmaleimide in active subunits are all rendered inaccessible to modification after association; and (3) proteins S9, S13 and S19, that react in both active and inactive 30 S subunits, are labeled to a lesser extent in the 70 S ribosomes than in isolated subunits. This pattern is altered in two respects when the reaction with the maleimide is carried out at 20 mm-Mg²⁺; protein S18 is not modified while S17 becomes labeled.The differences in reaction pattern are considered as manifesting the existence of different conformational forms of the 30 S subunit in the dissociated and associated states as well as of different forms of 70 S ribosomes. The 30 S moiety of 70 S ribosomes at 10 mm-Mg²⁺ resembles the inactive subunit, while some of the features of the active subunit are preserved in the 70 S ribosome at 20 mmMg²⁺. The structural changes appear to be expressed in the functioning of the ribosome: non-enzymatic binding of aminoacyl-tRNA to active 30 S subunits is suppressed by 50 S subunits at 10 mm but not at 20 mm-Mg²⁺ (Kaufmann &; Zamir, 1972). The fact that elongation factor Tu-mediated binding is not suppressed by 50 S subunits raises the possibility that the function of the elongation factor might involve the facilitation of a conformational change of the ribosome. The analysis of different ribosomal binding complexes with N-ethylmaleimide showed that the binding of poly(U) alone results in a decrease in the labeling of S1 and S18. Binding of aminoacyl-tRNA, on the other hand, is closely correlated with the exposure of S17 for reaction with the maleimide. A model is outlined that accounts for this correlation as well as for the proposed role of elongation factor Tu.     

Identification of three 30S proteins contributing to the ribosomal A site

Summary When 30S ribosomal subunits from E. coli are incubated with unfractionated 30S protein, the protein synthetic activity of the ribosomes is enhanced. Part of this effect is due to the stimulation of mRNA binding by S1 (Van Duin and Kurland, 1970). In addition, three other proteins (S2, S3 and S14) increase the number of tRNA binding sites. The enhancing effect of S2, S3 and S14 on the tRNA binding capacity of the ribosomes is seen both in the presence and absence of T factor. S2, S3 and S14 do not seem to stimulate mRNA binding. The aminoacyl-tRNA bound in response to S2, S3 and S14 is associated with the 70S ribosome and it can donate amino acid residues for polypeptide synthesis. We conclude that S2, S3 and S14 are part of the 30S A site.     

Binding of erythromycin to the 50S ribosomal subunit is affected by alterations in the 30S ribosomal subunit

Summary Expression of resistance to erythromycin in Escherichia coli, caused by an altered L4 protein in the 50S ribosomal subunit, can be masked when two additional ribosomal mutations affecting the 30S proteins S5 and S12 are introduced into the strain (Saltzman, Brown, and Apirion, 1974). Ribosomes from such strains bind erythromycin to the same extent as ribosomes from erythromycin sensitive parental strains (Apirion and Saltzman, 1974).Among mutants isolated for the reappearance of erythromycin resistance, kasugamycin resistant mutants were found. One such mutant was analysed and found to be due to undermethylation of the rRNA. The ribosomes of this strain do not bind erythromycin, thus there is a complete correlation between phenotype of cells with respect to erythromycin resistance and binding of erythromycin to ribosomes.Furthermore, by separating the ribosomal subunits we showed that 50S ribosomes bind or do not bind erythromycin according to their L4 protein; 50S with normal L4 bind and 50S with altered L4 do not bind erythromycin. However, the 30s ribosomes with altered S5 and S12 can restore binding in resistant 50S ribosomes while the 30S ribosomes in which the rRNA also became undermethylated did not allow erythromycin binding to occur.Thus, evidence for an intimate functional relationship between 30S and 50S ribosomal elements in the function of the ribosome could be demonstrated. These functional interrelationships concerns four ribosomal components, two proteins from the 30S ribosomal subunit, S5, and S12, one protein from the 50S subunit L4, and 16S rRNA.     

Study of mammalian ribosomal protein reactivity in situ. I. - Effect of 2-methoxy-5-nitrotropone on 40S and 60S subunits.

Liver ribosomes and subunits were reacted with increasing concentrations of 2-methoxy-5-nitrotropone. At low reagent concentrations (0.3 mM), the molar uptake by 60S subunits was more efficient than the uptake by 40S subunits, and the amount of reagent bound to 80S ribosomes was less than that bound to both free subunits considered together. At higher reagent concentrations, the molar uptake of both subunits was equivalent. Subunits and ribosomes remained fully active when reacted with up to 0.3 mM and 1 mM of the reagent, respectively. With 2 mM of the reagent, both subunits were half inactivated, although their sedimentation characteristics were unaltered. The reactivity of each ribosomal protein was assessed by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis and quantitative measurement of the unmodified proteins. From these results, considered together with the uptake characteristics and the inactivation curves, a number of tentative conclusions about ribosome topography can be drawn. The over-all sensitivity of the 60S subunits to the reagent is higher than that of the 40S subunits. Both subunits undergo a conformational change when they combine to form 80S ribosomes. Proteins S18, S20, S28 and L5, L9, L11, L15, L16, L25, L29, L30, L31, L34, L37 have NH2 groups exposed in native subunits. These groups are not essential for subunit function.     

The plastid ribosomal proteins. Identification of all the proteins in the 50 S subunit of an organelle ribosome (chloroplast)

We have completed identification of all the ribosomal proteins (RPs) in spinach plastid (chloroplast) ribosomal 50 S subunit via a proteomic approach using two-dimensional electrophoresis, electroblotting/protein sequencing, high performance liquid chromatography purification, polymerase chain reaction-based screening of cDNA library/nucleotide sequencing, and mass spectrometry (reversed-phase HPLC coupled to electrospray ionization mass spectrometry and electrospray ionization mass spectrometry). Spinach plastid 50 S subunit comprises 33 proteins, of which 31 are orthologues of Escherichia coli RPs and two are plastid-specific RPs (PSRP-5 and PSRP-6) having no homologues in other types of ribosomes. Orthologues of E. coli L25 and L30 are absent in spinach plastid ribosome. 25 of the plastid 50 S RPs are encoded in the nuclear genome and synthesized on cytosolic ribosomes, whereas eight of the plastid RPs are encoded in the plastid organelle genome and synthesized on plastid ribosomes. Sites for transit peptide cleavages in the cytosolic RP precursors and formyl Met processing in the plastid-synthesized RPs were established. Post-translational modifications were observed in several mature plastid RPs, including multiple forms of L10, L18, L31, and PSRP-5 and N-terminal/internal modifications in L2, L11 and L16. Comparison of the RPs in gradient-purified 70 S ribosome with those in the 30 and 50 S subunits revealed an additional protein, in approximately stoichiometric amount, specific to the 70 S ribosome. It was identified to be plastid ribosome recycling factor. Combining with our recent study of the proteins in plastid 30 S subunit (Yamaguchi, K., von Knoblauch, K., and Subramanian, A. R. (2000) J. Biol. Chem. 275, 28455-28465), we show that spinach plastid ribosome comprises 59 proteins (33 in 50 S subunit and 25 in 30 S subunit and ribosome recycling factor in 70 S), of which 53 are E. coli orthologues and 6 are plastid-specific proteins (PSRP-1 to PSRP-6). We propose the hypothesis that PSRPs were evolved to perform functions unique to plastid translation and its regulation, including protein targeting/translocation to thylakoid membrane via plastid 50 S subunit.     

Inhibition of peptide chain termination by antibodies specific for ribosomal proteins

The effects of antibodies specific for the Escherichia coli 30 S and 50 S ribosomal proteins have been determined for in vitro peptide chain termination and two partial reactions, the codon-directed binding of E. coli release factor to the ribosome and peptidyl-tRNA hydrolysis with RF². Antibodies to ribosomal proteins L7 and L12 inhibit the initial binding of RF to the ribosome, and as a result, the subsequent peptidyl-tRNA hydrolysis. The kinetics of ribosomal inactivation for in vitro termination by anti-L7/L12 indicate that Fab fragments bind to three ribosome sites, and suggest that each of three copies of L7/L12 is involved in the binding of RF to the ribosome. When 70 S ribosome substrates are pretreated with anti-L11 and anti-L16 RF-dependent peptidyl-tRNA, hydrolysis is partially inhibited but the interaction of RF with the ribosome is not affected. The inactivation of in vitro termination by a mixture of anti-L11 and anti-L16 is not co-operative. Pretreatment of the 30 S ribosomal subunit (but not 70 S ribosomal substrate) with antibodies to the 30 S proteins, S9 and S11, results in strong inhibition of codon-directed hydrolysis of peptidyl-tRNA. While these antibodies inhibit ribosome subunit association, a requirement for peptide chain termination, and thereby may inhibit the in vitro termination reactions indirectly, the codon-directed binding of RF is markedly more affected than peptidyl-tRNA hydrolysis by anti-S9 and anti-S11. Antibody to S2 and anti-S3 exhibit a similar but less marked differential effect on the partial reactions of in vitro termination under the same conditions. When dissociated ribosomes are pretreated with anti-L11, in vitro termination is completely inhibited and both codon-directed binding of RF and peptidyl-tRNA hydrolysis are affected. L11 may, therefore, be at or near the interface between the ribosome subunits and like S9 and S11 not completely accessible to antibody in 70 S ribosomes. Pretreatment of dissociated ribosomes with antibodies to a number of other ribosomal proteins (L2, L4, L6, L14, L15, L17, L18, L20, L23, L26, L27) results in partial inhibition of all termination reactions although these antibodies have no effect on termination when incubated with 70 S ribosome substrates. The antibodies probably affect in vitro termination indirectly as a result of either preventing correct ribosome subunit association, or preventing correct positioning of the fMet-tRNA at the ribosome P site.     

Spatial proximity of the ribosomal mRNA binding center to the 50S subunit]

4-(N-2-chloroethyl-N-methylamino)benzylamide of 5'-heptaadenylic acid was used for affinity labelling of the ribosome in the vicinity of its mRNA-binding centre. This derivative, similar to the free oligonucleotide, stimulates the binding of [14C]-lysyl-tRNA to ribosomes of E. coli and alkylates ribosomes both the 30S and the 50S subunits. The alkylation of ribosomes is inhibited by pre-incubation of ribosomes with polyadenylic acid, which suggests that the chemical modification is a specific one and occurs in the vicinity of mRNA-binding site. The fact, that a short oligonucleotide having an active group on its 5'end attacks the 50S subunit of ribosome may indicate that the mRNA-binding centre is located in the contact region between ribosomal subunits.     

Ribosome reactivation by replacement of damaged proteins

Ribosomal functions are vital for all organisms. Bacterial ribosomes are stable 2.4 MDa particles composed of three RNAs and over 50 different proteins. Accumulating damage to ribosomal RNA or proteins can disturb ribosome functioning. Organisms could benefit from degrading or possibly repairing inactive or partially active ribosomes. Reactivation of chemically damaged ribosomes by a process of protein replacement was studied in vitro. Ribosomes were inactivated by chemical modification of Cys residues. Incubation of modified ribosomes with total ribosomal proteins led to reactivation of translational activity. Intriguingly, ribosomal proteins extracted by LiCl are equally active in the restoration of ribosome function. Incubation of 70S ribosomes with isotopically labelled r‐proteins followed by separation of ribosomes was used to identify exchangeable proteins. A similar set of proteins was found to be exchanged in vivo under stress conditions in the stationary phase. We propose that repair of damaged ribosomes might be an important mechanism for maintaining protein synthesis activity following chemical damage.     

Nonbridging phosphate oxygens in 16S rRNA important for 30S subunit assembly and association with the 50S ribosomal subunit

Ribosomes are composed of RNA and protein molecules that associate together to form a supramolecular machine responsible for protein biosynthesis. Detailed information about the structure of the ribosome has come from the recent X-ray crystal structures of the ribosome and the ribosomal subunits. However, the molecular interactions between the rRNAs and the r-proteins that occur during the intermediate steps of ribosome assembly are poorly understood. Here we describe a modification-interference approach to identify nonbridging phosphate oxygens within 16S rRNA that are important for the in vitro assembly of the Escherichia coli 30S small ribosomal subunit and for its association with the 50S large ribosomal subunit. The 30S small subunit was reconstituted from phosphorothioate-substituted 16S rRNA and small subunit proteins. Active 30S subunits were selected by their ability to bind to the 50S large subunit and form 70S ribosomes. Analysis of the selected population shows that phosphate oxygens at specific positions in the 16S rRNA are important for either subunit assembly or for binding to the 50S subunit. The X-ray crystallographic structures of the 30S subunit suggest that some of these phosphate oxygens participate in r-protein binding, coordination of metal ions, or for the formation of intersubunit bridges in the mature 30S subunit. Interestingly, however, several of the phosphate oxygens identified in this study do not participate in any interaction in the mature 30S subunit, suggesting that they play a role in the early steps of the 30S subunit assembly.     

Chain initiation factor 3 crosslinks to E. coli 30S and 50S ribosomal subunits and alters the UV absorbance spectrum of 70S ribosomes

We report a direct procedure to determine the proteins near the IF-3 binding site in purified 30S and 50S ribosomal subunits. This procedure introduces only limited numbers of cleavable crosslinks between IF-3 and its nearest neighbors. The cleavable crosslinking reagent, 2-iminothiolane, was used to crosslink IF-3 in place to both 30S and 50S subunits. Ribosomal proteins S9/S11, S12, L2, L5 and L17 were found, by this approach, to be in close proximity to the factor in purified IF-3-subunit complexes. In addition, IF-3 was shown to alter the ultraviolet absorbance spectrum of E. coli 70S ribosomes at 10 mM Mg2+. The magnitude of the observed difference spectrum at a constant IF-3/ribosome ratio of 1.0, is linearly dependent upon ribosome concentration over the range 5 nM - 55 nM. Titration experiments indicated that the observed effect is maximal at an IF-3/ribosome ratio of approximately 1.0. These results are taken to indicate a conformational change in the 70S ribosome induced by IF-3.     

The role of ethanol extractable proteins from the 80S rat liver ribosome

80S rat liver ribosomes have been extracted with fifty percent ethanol at varying salt concentrations. The resulting 80S core ribosomes have lost almost all of their protein synthesis activity. The protein synthesis activity could be partially regained when the ethanol extracted proteins were reconstituted with the core ribosomes; however, reconstitution of the ribosome dependent EF-II GTP hydrolysis activity could not be detected. The ethanol extracts were found to contain only a few proteins, one or more of which we believe is necessary for the binding of elongation factor-II.     

Assembly of the 30S ribosomal subunit

The assembly of ribosomes requires a significant fraction of the energy expenditure for rapidly growing bacteria. The ribosome is composed of three large RNA molecules and over 50 small proteins that must be rapidly and efficiently assembled into the molecular machine responsible for protein synthesis. For over 30 years, the 30S ribosome has been a key model system for understanding the process of ribosome biogenesis through in vitro assembly experiments. We have recently developed an isotope pulse-chase experiment using quantitative mass spectrometry that permits assembly kinetics to be measured in real time. Kinetic studies have revealed an assembly energy landscape that ensures efficient assembly by a flexible and robust pathway.     

Conformation of 4.5S RNA in the signal recognition particle and on the 30S ribosomal subunit

The signal recognition particle (SRP) from Escherichia coli consists of 4.5S RNA and protein Ffh. It is essential for targeting ribosomes that are translating integral membrane proteins to the translocation pore in the plasma membrane. Independently of Ffh, 4.5S RNA also interacts with elongation factor G (EF-G) and the 30S ribosomal subunit. Here we use a cross-linking approach to probe the conformation of 4.5S RNA in SRP and in the complex with the 30S ribosomal subunit and to map the binding site. The UV-activatable cross-linker p-azidophenacyl bromide (AzP) was attached to positions 1, 21, and 54 of wild-type or modified 4.5S RNA. In SRP, cross-links to Ffh were formed from AzP in all three positions in 4.5S RNA, indicating a strongly bent conformation in which the 5' end (position 1) and the tetraloop region (including position 54) of the molecule are close to one another and to Ffh. In ribosomal complexes of 4.5S RNA, AzP in both positions 1 and 54 formed cross-links to the 30S ribosomal subunit, independently of the presence of Ffh. The major cross-linking target on the ribosome was protein S7; minor cross-links were formed to S2, S18, and S21. There were no cross-links from 4.5S RNA to the 50S subunit, where the primary binding site of SRP is located close to the peptide exit. The functional role of 4.5S RNA binding to the 30S subunit is unclear, as the RNA had no effect on translation or tRNA translocation on the ribosome.     

Ribosomal activity of the 16 S.23 S RNA complex

It has been demonstrated in this laboratory that 16 S and 23 S RNAs form a binary complex like 30 S and 50 S ribosomes under certain specific conditions, and 5 S RNA can be incorporated into the complex in stoichiometric amounts in presence of three ribosomal proteins, L5, L18, and L15/25. These studies raised the basic question of whether such complex will have biological activity. Therefore, the following steps in protein synthesis were examined with the complex in place of the ribosomes: (i) poly-U-dependent binding of phenylalanyl tRNA; (ii) EF-G-dependent GTPase activity; (iii) initiation complex formation; (iv) peptidyl transferase activity; and (v) poly-U-dependent polyphenylalanine synthesis. All the steps could be unequivocally demonstrated by the addition of a limited number of proteins although the complex had comparatively much less activity than 70 S ribosomes. It appears that rRNAs are directly involved in various steps of protein synthesis. Furthermore, the 16 S.23 S RNA complex might have acted as a primitive ribosome, as suggested by Crick and Orgel.