Plastid differentiation during androgenesis in albino and non-albino producing cultivars of barley (Hordeum vulgare L.)

In order to better understand androgenic albinism in barley, we compared plastid differentiation during anther culture in two cultivars, an albino (spring cultivar Cork) and a non-albino (winter cultivar Igri) producing cultivar. The ultrastructure of plastids and the relative amount of DNA containing plastids were followed in both cultivars during the androgenic process and correlated with the proportion of regenerated chlorophyllous plantlets. For androgenesis, anthers were collected at the uninucleate stage, during mid- or late-microspore vacuolation. At this stage DNA was detected in 15.3 ± 2. 7% of microspore plastid sections in the winter cultivar Igri, compared to 1.7 ± 0.5% in the spring cultivar Cork. In the winter cultivar Igri, starch was broken down after anther pretreatment but plastids divided rapidly during anther culture and thylakoids developed in the stroma. Prior to regeneration, plastids contained 2.0 ± 0.2 thylakoids per plastid and starch represented 26.1 ± 3.3% of the plastid volume. In the spring cultivar Cork, plastids followed a different developmental pathway. After anther pretreatment, microspore plastids differentiated exclusively into amyloplasts, accumulating starch and losing their thylakoids as well as their capacity to divide. This developmental pattern became progressively more marked, so that by the end of anther culture plastids contained 0.5 ± 0.4 thylakoids per plastid and starch represented up to 90.3 ± 4.3% of plastid volume. Following androgenesis, the response was similar in both cultivars except that the winter cultivar Igri provided 87.8% of chlorophyllous plantlets compared to 99.7% albino plantlets in the cultivar Cork. The results presented here suggest that the exclusive regeneration of albino plantlets in the spring cultivar Cork may be due to degradation of microspore plastid DNA during early pollen development, preventing the plastids from differentiating into chloroplasts under culture conditions. Received: 13 March 2000 / Revision accepted: 6 June 2000     

Barley anther culture: assessment of carbohydrate effects on embryo yield, green plant production and differential plastid development in relation with albinism

Sugars and polyols were tested at different steps of anther culture in barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) to elucidate their influence on both the overall yield of androgenesis and the structure of plastids in relation to albinism. During the pretreatment period, the osmotic regulation in the medium was beneficial to microspore embryogenesis regardless of the type and concentration of the tested osmoticum. The use of mannitol (300 mOsm/kg), sorbitol (180 mOsm/kg), PEG (240 mOsm/kg) and sucrose (180 mOsm/kg) gave the best results in terms of green plant production, although the influence of each substance differed according to the studied parameter. Similarly, during anther culture the regulation of the osmotic pressure in the medium had various effects, according to the osmoticum used. The best results were obtained using mannitol (364 mOsm/kg), providing 139.7 green plants per 100 plated anthers. Plastids were examined by electron microscopy following both pretreatment and culture. In the presence of mannitol and PEG, plastids did not accumulate starch at any stage of the protocol but they started to differentiate into chloroplasts in the microspore-derived embryos. Using sorbitol and sucrose, plastids differentiated poorly but accumulated large amounts of starch, suggesting that these sugars are metabolized by micropores and microspore derived structures. However, the accumulation of starch was not correlated with the occurrence of albinism. These results indicated that, in barley, the osmotic regulation was favourable to switch the microspore gametophytic program toward a sporophytic program regardless of the nature of the osmoticum. In addition, during the pretreatment period, mannito was found to be the most suitable osmoticum for subsequent embryo development.     

Induction of in vitro androgenesis in anther and isolated microspore culture of different spelt wheat (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Triticum spelta</Emphasis> L.) genotypes

This is the first report on isolated microspore culture—derived spelt wheat. The efficiency of anther- and isolated microspore was compared using four genotypes (‘Franckenkorn’, ‘GK Fehér’, ‘Mv Martongold’, ‘Oberkulmer Rotkorn’). In anther culture, genotype dependency was observed, and cold pre-treatment enhanced the efficiency of the method. In isolated microspore culture, the ovary co-culture supported the development of embryo-like structures. The presence of growth regulators (0.5 mg/l 2,4-D and 0.5 mg/l kinetin) were not essential for the induction of androgenesis, but these increased the production of embryo-like structures, green and albino plantlets. The low plant regeneration rate and high number of albinos hinder the practical application of isolated microspore culture while anther culture was efficient for in vitro green plantlets production in spelt wheat. The mean of green plantlets production was 41.45/100 anthers (from 20.93 to 83.07 depending on genotype). The phenomenon of albinism was mitigated in anther culture (3.48 albinos/100 anthers). Altogether, 1720 anther culture—derived green plantlets were produced from the four genotypes.     

Microspore embryogenesis in barley: anther pre-treatment stimulates plant defence gene expression

Microspore embryogenesis (ME) is a process in which the gametophytic pollen programme of the microspore is reorientated towards a new embryo sporophytic programme. This process requires a stress treatment, usually performed in the anther or isolated microspores for several days. Despite the universal use of stress to induce ME, very few studies have addressed the physiological processes that occur in the anther during this step. To further understand the processes triggered by stress treatment, we followed the response of anthers by measuring the expression of stress-related genes in two barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) cultivars differing in their ME response. Genes encoding enzymes involved in oxidative stress (glutathione-S-transferase, GST; oxalate oxidase, OxO), in the synthesis of jasmonic acid (13-lipoxygenase, Lox; allene oxide cyclase, AOC; allene oxide synthase, AOS) and in the phenylpropanoid pathway (phenylalanine ammonia lyase, PAL), as well as those encoding PR proteins (Barwin, chitinase 2b, Chit 2b; glucanase, Gluc; basic pathogenesis-related protein 1, PR1; pathogenesis-related protein 10, PR10) were up-regulated in whole anthers upon stress treatment, indicating that anther perceives stress and reacts by triggering general plant defence mechanisms. In particular, both OxO and Chit 2b genes are good markers of anther reactivity owing to their high level of induction during the stress treatment. The effect of copper sulphate appeared to limit the expression of defence-related genes, which may be correlated with its positive effect on the yield of microspore embryos.     

Effects of n-butanol on barley microspore embryogenesis

Doubled haploid (DH) production is an efficient tool in barley breeding, but efficiency of DH methods is not consistent. Hence, the aim of this study was to study the effect of n-butanol application on DH barley plant production efficiency. Five elite cultivars of barley and thirteen breeding crosses with different microspore embryogenesis capacities were selected for n-butanol application in anther and isolated microspore cultures. Application of 0.1 % n-butanol after a mannitol stress treatment in anther culture significantly increased the number of embryos (up to almost twice) and green plants (from 1.7 to 3 times) in three low-responding cultivars: Albacete, Astoria and Majestic. No significant differences on microspore embryogenesis efficiency were observed in medium and high responding cultivars. The application of n-butanol treatment to isolated microspores from cold treated spikes in thirteen spring breeding crosses with a low or very low androgenetic response did not have a significant effect on the overall number of green plants. Nevertheless, an increase in the number of green plants was observed when 0.2 % n-butanol was applied in four out of seven low-responding crosses. Therefore, application of n-butanol could be routinely applied to anther cultures using mannitol treatment, in low-responding material. However, further studies are needed to determine optimal conditions in protocols using cold treatment and isolated microspore cultures.     

Improved plant regeneration from wheat anther and barley microspore culture using phenylacetic acid (PAA)

Summary The effect of the auxin phenylacetic acid (PAA) on wheat anther and on barley anther/microspore culture was investigated. With PAA the induction response was not usually significantly different from controls but a significantly higher number of green plants were produced in wheat anther and barley microspore culture. For wheat anther culture 100 mg/L PAA was beneficial. For barley microspore culture the optimum levels were from 1 to 100 mg/L, depending on genotype. In barley anther culture there were no improvements using PAA. In wheat anther culture, 145 green plants/100 anthers were obtained with cultivar VeeryS, while the average response from twelve F₁ hybrids in the breeding program was 332 green plants/100 anthers. At least 1000 green plants were obtained using isolated microspores from 100 anthers in barley cv. Igri. With cv. Bruce, regeneration occurred only when 100 mg/L PAA was used. The influence of PAA appears at the embryogenic phase of the culture system. The possible mechanisms by which PAA may improve regeneration are discussed.     

Characterization of anther differentiation in cytoplasmic male sterile maize using a specific isozyme system (esterase)

Summary During anther development, characterized in maize plants with N cytoplasm, certain esterase isozymes in non-microspore cells decrease in amount with anther age and new isozymes appear in the developing microspores. In anthers from male sterile plants with cms T or cms C cytoplasm, neither of these changes in esterase patterns occurred. In anthers from plants with cms S cytoplasm, the decrease in the esterases of non-microsporogenous cells was observed but not the appearance of microspore esterases. In lines carrying cms S cytoplasm and nuclear restorer genes, esterase changes during anther development were as in normal fertile anthers. These results are discussed with respect to the phenomenon of cytoplasmic male sterility in the different maize genotypes.     

Modification of cell development in vitro: The effect of colchicine on anther and isolated microspore culture in Brassica napus

In an attempt to discover the biological basis of microspore derived embryogenesis, the effect of the antimicrotubule agent colchicine on anther and free microspore embryogenesis was investigated. The microtubule inhibitor colchicine promoted embryogenesis from cultured anthers, both with regard to the number of anthers responding and the number of embryos being produced per anther. A similar promotional response was also observed with cultured microspores. Although the parameters for cultured anthers and free microspores differed, administration of the drug for a short period immediately prior to pollen mitosis I seems to exert the maximum promotional effect. Of the five cultivars of Brassica napus studied, all responded to colchicine treatment. However, the drug did release more embryogenic potential in poor-responding varieties (i.e. Lirawell and Optima) than in the highest responding variety (Topas). Colchicine also resulted in increased embryogenic response in microspores cultured at lower temperatures.These results are considered in terms of models proposed to explain the switch in microspore development from a gametophytic to a sporophytic pathway. The use ofcolchicine as agent to promote embryogenesis in previously recalcitrant species other than Brassica is also discussed.     

Programmed cell death promotes male sterility in the functional dioecious Opuntia stenopetala (Cactaceae)

Background and Aims

The sexual separation in dioecious species has interested biologists for decades; however, the cellular mechanism leading to unisexuality has been poorly understood. In this study, the cellular changes that lead to male sterility in the functionally dioecious cactus, Opuntia stenopetala, are described.

Methods

The spatial and temporal patterns of programmed cell death (PCD) were determined in the anthers of male and female flowers using scanning electron microscopy analysis and histological observations, focusing attention on the transition from bisexual to unisexual development. In addition, terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase-mediated dUTP nick-end labelling assays were used as an indicator of DNA fragmentation to corroborate PCD.

Key results

PCD was detected in anthers of both female and male flowers, but their patterns differed in time and space. Functionally male individuals developed viable pollen, and normal development involved PCD on each layer of the anther wall, which occurred progressively from the inner (tapetum) to the outer layer (epidermis). Conversely, functional female individuals aborted anthers by premature and displaced PCD. In anthers of female flowers, the first signs of PCD, such as a nucleus with irregular shape, fragmented and condensed chromatin, high vacuolization and condensed cytoplasm, occurred at the microspore mother cell stage. Later these features were observed simultaneously in all anther wall layers, connective tissue and filament. Neither pollen formation nor anther dehiscence was detected in female flowers of O. stenopetala due to total anther disruption.

Conclusions

Temporal and spatial changes in the patterns of PCD are responsible for male sterility of female flowers in O. stenopetala. Male fertility requires the co-ordination of different events, which, when altered, can lead to male sterility and to functionally unisexual individuals. PCD could be a widespread mechanism in the determination of functionally dioecious species.     

Anther plastids in angiosperms

In the anther of angiosperms, all types of plastids are found in the course of pollen development. They are located in the different cell layers of the microsporangium and have various functions that contribute to the formation of the functional male gametophyte. This includes photosynthesis, stomata opening, sugar storage and/or mobilization, lipid synthesis and secretion for pollenkitt formation, as well as serving as a physiological buffer under stress conditions. They are also involved in plastid inheritance, but to different extents, according to the species. The plastid is a semi-autonomous organelle. Plastid division in the anther is synchronous with cell division, except in the vegetative cell during pollen maturation. Furthermore, recent data seem to show that plastids are affected by programmed cell death and DNA degradation, which occur in the whole anther throughout pollen development. However, the timing of plastid disappearance fluctuates in the different cell layers and also depending on species. In vitro, following androgenesis, plastids that originate in the microspore are responsible for the occurrence of albino plantlets in Poaceae. This trait reflects the relative independence of the plastid genome when compared with that of the nucleus. In this family, microspore plastids may become so involved in programmed cell death that they are unable to follow the alternative sporopohytic program. The different pathways of plastid differentiation in neighboring anther cell layers require an accurate regulation of cell development that remains widely unknown in the anther.     

Effects of incubation temperature on microspore callus production and plant regeneration in wheat anther cultures

Anthers of wheat cultivars Orofen and Pitic 62 were incubated for 8 days at 15, 20, 25, 30, 35 and 40°C before transfer to 25°C. Compared with anthers cultured at 25°C constantly, anthers treated at 30°C produced 40% more microspore callus and green plants in both cultivars whereas those treated at 35°C produced 2–3 fold more green plants. Treatment at 40°C was deleterious. Possible modes of action of high temperature on callus production and albinism were discussed.     

Differences on the microsporogenesis and tapetal development of male fertile and cytoplasmic male sterile pepper (Capsicum annuum L.)

To clarify the time and cause of pollen abortion, differences on the microsporogenesis and tapetum development in the anthers of male fertile maintainer line and cytoplasmic male sterile (CMS) line pepper were studied using transmission electron microscopy. The results showed that CMS line anthers appeared to have much greater variability in developmental pattern than male fertile maintainer line ones. The earliest deviation from normal anther development occurred in CMS line anthers at prophase I was cytomixis in some microspore mother cells (MMCs), and vacuolisation in tapetal cells. Then, MMCs in CMS line anthers developed asynchronously and a small part of ones at the different stage degenerated in advance appearing to have typical morphological features of programmed cell death (PCD). Most MMCs could complete the meiosis, but formed non-tetrahedral tetrad microspores with irregular shape and different size and uncertain number of nuclei, and some degenerated ahead of time as well. Tapetal cells in CMS line anther degenerated during meiosis, and were crushed at the tetrad stage, which paralleled the collapse of pollens. Pollen abortion in CMS line anthers happened by PCD themselves, and the premature PCD of tapetal cells were closely associated with male sterility.     

Isolated microspore culture techniques and recent progress for haploid and doubled haploid plant production

An isolated microspore culture provides an excellent system for the study of microspore induction and embryogenesis, provides a platform for an ever-increasing array of molecular studies, and can produce doubled haploid (DH) plants, which are used to accelerate plant-breeding programs. Moreover, isolated microspore cultures have several advantages over anther culture, wherein presence of the anther walls can lead to the development of diploid, somatic calli and plants. Although protocols for isolated microspore culture vary from laboratory to laboratory, the basic steps of growing donor plants, harvesting floral organs, isolating microspores, culturing and inducing microspores, regenerating embryos, and doubling the chromosomes, remain the same. Over the past few years, a large proportion of the research reports on isolated microspore culture have focused on cereal and Brassica species. For some of these species, isolated microspore culture protocols are well established and routinely used in laboratories around the world for developing new varieties, as well as for basic research in areas such as genomics, gene expression, and genetic mapping. Although these species are considered highly responsive to microspore culture, improvements in efficiency are still being made. However, with many species, isolated microspore culture is simply not yet efficient enough at producing DH plants to be cost-effective for breeding programs. There has been a recent resurgence of haploidy research with response being reported in some species once considered recalcitrant. Future research programs aimed at elucidating pathways involved in microspore induction and embryogenesis will be of benefit, as will novel approaches to improve the efficiency of microspore culture for DH production. With many species, anther culture has proven to be more effective than isolated microspore culture, necessitating more research to clarify the contribution of the anther wall to embryogenesis. The development of molecular markers for use in determining the gametic origin of regenerated plants, irrespective of their ploidy, would also be beneficial. In this review, we aim to provide an overview of the basic isolated microspore culture protocol with an emphasis on recent progress in several crop species.     

Zinc sulphate improved microspore embryogenesis in barley

The effect of ZnSO₄ concentration on barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) microspore embryogenesis was investigated using cultivars of different androgenetic response. Concentrations from 0 (control) to 600 μM in the stress pre-treatment medium alone or in combination with 30 (control) to 600 μM in the embryo induction medium were assayed in anther culture. Incorporation of Zn²⁺ in the pre-treatment medium itself did not affect microspore embryogenesis. The optimum concentration in the stress pre-treatment and induction media was 180 μM for cultivars (cvs.) Igri and Reinette, and 90 μM for cv. Hop. A significant increase of 30 and 300% in cv. Igri and Reinette, respectively, were produced with 180 μM ZnSO₄ in both the number of embryos and green plants. In order to confirm the effect of Zn²⁺ on microspore embryogenesis this micronutrient was incorporated in the induction medium of isolated microspore cultures of cv. Igri. Concentrations of 90–300 μM ZnSO₄ resulted in an increase of 40–53% in the number of embryos and green plants. All these results indicate that the beneficial effect of Zn²⁺ is exerted mainly during the culture phase, increasing the number of embryos, leading to an increased number of green plants, but it had no effect on percentage of regeneration or green plants.     

Effect of the 1BL.1RS wheat-rye translocation on the androgenic response in spring bread wheat

The study was conducted to investigate the effect of the 1BL.1RS wheat-rye-translocation on the androgenic response in spring bread wheat. Therefore, four bread wheat cultivars carrying the translocation, four Greek and three Canadian bread wheat cultivars without the translocation were used. An equal number of anthers from each cultivar, containing microspores in the mid (MU) to late uninucleate (LU) microspore developmental stage, were cultured after cold pre-treatment for seven days at 4°C. W14, 190-2 and the basic MS were used as induction, regeneration, and rooting media respectively. The best androgenic response was recorded in two cultivars carrying the translocation. Only two cultivars lacking the translocation responded to anther culture. It is concluded that the positive effect of the 1BL.1RS translocation on anther culture response of bread wheat cultivars cannot be attributed entirely to its presence because the genetic background of the cultivars carrying the translocation could be also important.     

Improving the efficiency of isolated microspore culture in six-row spring barley: I-optimization of key physical factors

Key message

An improved isolated microspore culture protocol alleviating the recalcitrance typically observed in six-row spring barley was developed by optimizing four key physical factors to increase embryogenesis and reduce albinism.

Abstract

Doubled haploid (DH) plants are completely homozygous individuals that can be generated in just a few months via androgenesis in vitro. DHs are useful tools in genetic research and in plant breeding. Isolated microspore culture (IMC) is the most efficient way to produce DHs, but a strong genotype dependency imposes limitations to its wide application. Six-row, spring barley genotypes are considered as particularly recalcitrant due to a low frequency of embryogenesis and a high rate of albinism. Seeking to develop an efficient IMC protocol for this type of barley, we explored four important factors: (1) the harvest stage of immature spikes, (2) the type of pretreatment applied, (3) the osmotic potential in the induction medium, and (4) the plating density of microspores. This work was first performed using four barley genotypes: two typical six-row spring cultivars (ACCA and Léger), a two-row spring (Gobernadora) and a two-row winter (Igri) cultivar. First, by optimizing the harvest stage for each genotype we obtained a twofold to fourfold increase in the yield of embryogenic microspores. Second, two pretreatments (0.3 M mannitol for 2 days, or a combination of cold and heat over 15 days) both performed significantly better than the commonly used cold pretreatment (28 days at 4 °C). Third, an induction medium-containing mannitol (32 g/l) doubled green plant regeneration. Fourth, a plating density of 10⁶ microspores/ml yielded the highest number of green regenerated plants. Our most important findings were then confirmed using sets of F1s from a six-row, spring-type breeding program.     

Improving the efficiency of isolated microspore culture in six-row spring barley: II-exploring novel growth regulators to maximize embryogenesis and reduce albinism

Key message

Two alternative cytokinins, thidiazuron and meta-topoline, were tested in isolated microspore culture on recalcitrant barley genotypes (six-row, spring), and green plant regeneration was improved substantially.

Abstract

Doubled-haploid (DH) plants are coveted in plant breeding and in genetic studies, since they are rapidly obtained and perfectly homozygous. In barley, DHs are produced mainly via androgenesis, and isolated microspore culture (IMC) constitutes the method offering the greatest potential efficiency. However, IMC can often be challenging in some genotypes because of low yield of microspores, low regeneration and high incidence of albinism. Six-row spring-type barleys, the predominant type grown in Eastern Canada, are considered recalcitrant in this regard. Our general objective was to optimize an IMC protocol for DH production in six-row spring barley. In particular, we explored the use of alternative hormones in the induction medium (thidiazuron and dicamba), and in the regeneration medium (meta-topoline). This optimization was performed on two typical six-row spring (ACCA and Léger), a two-row spring (Gobernadora) and a two-row winter (Igri) barley cultivar. When 6-benzyl-aminopurine (BAP) was replaced by a combination of thidiazuron and dicamba in the induction medium, a 5.1-fold increase (P < 0.01) in the production of green plants resulted. This increase was mainly achieved by a reduction of albinism. Moreover, a 2.9-fold increase (P < 0.01) in embryo differentiation into green plants was obtained using meta-topoline instead of BAP in the regeneration medium. Together, these innovations allowed us to achieve a substantial improvement in the efficiency of IMC in this recalcitrant type of barley. These results were later successfully validated using sets of F1s from a six-row spring barley breeding program.     

Prospects of androgenetic induction in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Lupinus</Emphasis> spp.

Anthers cultures of six Polish cultivars of pasture lupin (Lupinus L.) were examined for their androgenic response. Anthers with microspores at the uninucleate stage were isolated from flower buds and cultured in liquid media. Better viability of androgenetic structures was obtained when donor plants had grown under field as opposed to greenhouse conditions. A density of five anthers per 0.5 ml medium was more conducive to androgenetic induction than 25 anthers per 0.5 ml medium. Addition of 5% maltose to the induction medium and culture at 25°C without pre-treatment of flowers, buds or anthers promoted microspore release and division. The greatest frequency of androgenic callus, ~70% was developed from cvs. Katon, Wat (white lupin), in contrast to cvs. Legat, Juno (yellow lupin), Polonez and Sonet (narrow-leafed lupin) with callus induction ~30–40%. Despite various combinations of media tested, plant regeneration was not obtained from anther derived callus.     

The influence of genotype and temperature pre-treatment on anther culture response in barley (Hordeum vulgare L.)

The influence of temperature stress pre-treatment on anther culture response has been examined in eight commercially desirable barley cultivars. Spikes were pre-treated in darkness at 4°C for periods of 0, 7, 14, 21 and 28 days. Overall, the optimum pre-treatment period was 21 days, although there were large genotype by pre-treatment interactions. The most responsive cultivar was Igri, with a mean of 38% anthers responding, and relatively little effect of pre-treatment. The greatest effect of pre-treatment was in cv. Heriot, which had 3% response with no pre-treatment and 52% response from 14 days pre-treatment.     

Improvements in the production of doubled haploids in durum wheat (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Triticum turgidum</Emphasis> L<Emphasis Type="Italic">.</Emphasis>) through isolated microspore culture

The objective of this study was to produce durum wheat doubled haploid (DH) plants through the induction of microspore embryogenesis. The microspore culture technique was improved to maximize production of green plants per spike using three commercial cultivars. Studies on factors such as induction media composition, induction media support and the stage and growth of donor plants were carried out in order to develop an efficient protocol to regenerate green and fertile DH plants. Microspores were plated on a C₁₇ induction culture medium with ovary co-culture and a supplement of glutathione plus glutamine; 300 g/l Ficoll Type-400 was incorporated to the induction medium support. Donor plants were fertilized with a combination of macro and microelements. With the cultivars ‘Ciccio’ and ‘Claudio’ an average of 36.5 and 148.5 fertile plants were produced, respectively, from 1,000 anthers inoculated. This technique was then used to produce fertile DH plants of potential agronomic interest from a collection of ten F₁ crosses involving cultivars of high breeding value. From these crosses 849 green plants were obtained and seed was harvested from 702 plants indicating that 83% of green plants were fertile and therefore were spontaneously DHs. No aneuploid plant was obtained. The 702 plants yielded enough seeds to be field tested. One of the DH lines obtained by microspore embryogenesis, named ‘Lanuza’, has been sent to the Spanish Plant Variety Office for Registration by the Batlle Seed Company. This protocol can be used instead of the labor-intensive inter-generic crossing with maize as an economically feasible method to obtain DHs for most crosses involving the durum wheat cultivars grown in Spain.