Tree seedling growth in natural deep shade: functional traits related to interspecific variation in response to elevated CO2

The mechanisms for species-specific growth responses to changes in atmospheric CO₂ concentration within narrow ecological groups of species, such as shade-tolerant, late-successional trees, have rarely been addressed and are not well understood. In this study the underlying functional traits for interspecific variation in the biomass response to elevated CO₂ were explored for seedlings of five late-successional temperate forest tree species (Fagus sylvatica, Acer pseudoplatanus, Quercus robur, Taxus baccata, Abies alba). The seedlings were grown in the natural forest understorey in very low and low light microsites (an average of 1.3% and 3.4% full sun in this experiment), and were exposed to either current ambient CO₂ concentrations, 500, or 660 µl CO₂ l^-1 in 36 open-top chambers (OTC) over two growing seasons. Even across the narrow range of successional status and shade tolerance, the study species varied greatly in photosynthesis, light compensation point, leaf dark respiration (R_d), leaf nitrogen concentration, specific leaf area (SLA), leaf area ratio (LAR), and biomass allocation among different plant parts, and showed distinct responses to CO₂ in these traits. No single species combined all characteristics traditionally considered as adaptive to low light conditions. At very low light, the CO₂ stimulation of seedling biomass was related to increased LAR and decreased R_d, responses that were observed only in Fagus and Taxus. At slightly higher light levels, interspecific differences in the biomass response to elevated CO₂ were reversed and correlated best with leaf photosynthesis. The data provided here contribute to a mechanistic process-based understanding of distinct response patterns in co-occurring tree species to elevated CO₂ in natural deep shade. I conclude that the high variation in physiological and morphological traits among late-successional species, and the consequences for their responses to slight changes in resource availability, have previously been underestimated. The commonly used broad definitions of functional groups of species may not be sufficient for the understanding of recruitment success and dynamic changes in species composition of old-growth forests in response to rising concentrations of atmospheric CO₂.     

Differential impacts of long-term (CO<Subscript>2</Subscript>) and O<Subscript>3</Subscript> exposure on growth of northern conifer and deciduous tree species

The long-term effects of elevated CO₂ and CO₂+O₃ concentrations on the growth allocation in northern provenances of Norway spruce [Picea abies (L.) Karst.], Scots pine [Pinus sylvestris (L.)] and pubescent birch clones (Betula pubescens Ehrh.) were examined in open-top chambers after a 4-year-long experiment. The total biomass responses of the tree seedlings to increased CO₂ and CO₂+O₃ concentrations were not statistically significant and varied between the provenances and species. The seedlings of northern origin were the least sensitive in their response to treatments. The total biomass of the Norway spruce seedlings slightly decreased in response to CO₂ in three provenances. Scots pine from the local provenance had a slight biomass increase after elevated CO₂+O₃ treatment. The slower-growing birch clone seemed to benefit from elevated CO₂, whereas in the faster-growing clone, reductions in biomass accumulation were seen. The combined CO₂+O₃ treatment reduced the positive effects of elevated CO₂, especially in the slower-growing birches. Observations of significant effects were limited to a few parameters. Carbon dioxide treatment decreased needle dry weight of Norway spruce in one northern provenance. The needle and wood dry weight increased (CO₂ + O₃) in local Scots pine. Significant birch response was limited to increased fine root density (O₃ + CO₂) in the inland clone. The diverse effects of elevated CO₂ and CO₂ +O₃ on seedling growth and biomass provide evidence that exposure of northern trees to the enhanced variable CO₂ and O₃ concentrations of the future will have varied effects on the growth of these species. The direction and magnitude of those effects will differ depending on species and origins.     

Genotypic variation in response of quaking aspen (Populus tremuloides) to atmospheric CO2 enrichment

Enriched atmospheric CO₂ alters the quantity and quality of plant production, but how such effects vary among plant genotypes is poorly known. We evaluated the independent and interactive effects of CO₂ and nutrient availability on growth, allocation and phytochemistry of six aspen (Populus tremuloides Michx.) genotypes. One-year-old trees, propagated from root cuttings, were grown in CO₂-controlled glasshouses for 64 days, then harvested. Foliage was analyzed for levels of water, nitrogen, starch, phenolic glycosides and condensed tannins. Of seven plant growth/allocation variables measured, four (biomass production, stem growth, relative growth rate and root:shoot ratio) exhibited marginally to highly significant CO₂ 2 genotype interactions. CO₂ enrichment stimulated growth of some genotypes more than others, and this interaction was itself influenced by soil nutrient availability. In addition, enriched CO₂ increased the magnitude of the among-genotype variance for four of the growth/allocation variables. Of six foliar chemical constituents analyzed, CO₂-mediated responses of two (the phenolic glycoside tremulacin and condensed tannins) varied among genotypes. Moreover, enriched CO₂ increased the magnitude of among-genotype variance for four of the chemical variables. Given the importance of these growth and chemical characteristics to the biological fitness of aspen, this research suggests that projected atmospheric CO₂ increases are likely to alter the genetic structures and evolutionary trajectories of aspen populations.     

The effects of elevated CO2 on seed production and seedling recruitment in a sheep-grazed pasture

Seed production and seedling recruitment were measured over 2 years under ambient (360 ppm) and elevated (475 ppm) atmospheric CO₂ in a free air carbon dioxide enrichment (FACE) experiment, carried out in a sheep-grazed pasture on dry, sandy soil in New Zealand. In both years elevated CO₂ led to more dispersed seeds of the grasses Anthoxanthum odoratum, Lolium perenne and Poa pratensis, the legumes Trifolium repens and T. subterraneum and the herbs Hypochaeris radicata and Leontodon saxatilis. The increased seed dispersal in A. odoratum, H. radicata, Leontodon saxatilis and T. repens reflected both more inflorescences per unit area and more seeds per inflorescence under elevated CO₂. The increased seed dispersal in Lolium perenne, P. pratensis and T. subterraneum was due solely to more inflorescences per unit area. The number of seedlings that emerged and survived to at least 7 months of age was increased by elevated CO₂ for H. radicata, Leontodon saxatilis, T. repens and T. subterraneum in both years and for A. odoratum and Lolium perenne in the first year. For species where increased seedling recruitment was noted, there was a significant positive correlation between seed production in summer and seedling emergence in the following autumn and winter, and sowing 200 extra seeds per species m^-2 resulted in more seedlings compared to unsown controls. Elevated CO₂ did not affect seedling survival in any species. There was no measurable effect of elevated CO₂ on canopy and soil surface conditions or soil moisture at the time of seedling emergence. The results suggest the dominant effect of elevated CO₂ on seedling recruitment in this pasture was an indirect one, reflecting effects on the number of seeds produced. The biomass of H. radicata, Leontodon saxatilis, T. repens and T. subterraneum in the above-ground vegetation was greater under elevated than ambient CO₂. However, the size of individual seedlings and mature plants of these four species was unaffected by elevated CO₂. The results indicate an important way elevated CO₂ influenced plant species composition in this pasture was through changes in the pattern of seedling recruitment.     

Four-year growth dynamics of beech-spruce model ecosystems under CO2 enrichment on two different forest soils

To elucidate how atmospheric CO₂ enrichment, enhanced nutrient supply and soil quality interact to affect regrowth of temperate forests, young Fagus sylvatica and Picea abies trees were grown together in large model ecosystems. Identical communities were established on a nutrient-poor acidic and on a more fertile calcareous soil and tree growth, leaf area index, fine root density and soil respiration monitored over four complete growing seasons. Biomass responses to CO₂ enrichment and enhanced N supply at the end of the experiment reflected compound interest effects of growth stimulation during the first two to three seasons rather than persistent stimulation over the whole duration of the experiment. Whereas biomass of Picea was enhanced in elevated CO₂ on both soils, Fagus responded negatively to CO₂ on acidic but positively on calcareous soil. Biomass of both species profited from enhanced N supply on the poor acidic soil only. Leaf area index on both soils was greater in high N supply as a consequence of a stimulation early in the experiment, but was unaffected by CO₂ enrichment. Fine root density on acidic soil was increased in high N supply, but this did not stimulate soil respiration rate. In contrast, elevated CO₂ stimulated both fine root density and soil CO₂ efflux on calcareous soil, especially towards the end of the experiment. Our experiment suggests that future species dominance in beech-spruce forests is likely to change in response to CO₂ enrichment, but this response is subject to complex interactions with environmental factors other than CO₂, particularly soil type.     

Elevated CO2 influences nutrient availability in young beech-spruce communities on two soil types

The objectives of this study were to investigate how different soil types and elevated N deposition (0.7 vs 7 g N m^-2a^-1) influence the effects of elevated CO₂ (370 vs 570 µmol CO₂ mol^-1) on soil nutrients and net accumulation of N, P, K, S, Ca, Mg, Fe, Mn, and Zn in spruce (Picea abies) and beech (Fagus sylvatica). Model ecosystems were established in large open-top chambers on two different forest soils: a nutrient-poor acidic loam and a nutrient-rich calcareous sand. The response of net nutrient accumulation to elevated atmospheric CO₂ depended upon soil type (interaction soil 2 CO₂, P<0.05 for N, P, K, S, Ca, Mg, Zn) and differed between spruce and beech. On the acidic loam, CO₂ enrichment suppressed net accumulation of all nutrients in beech (P<0.05 for P, S, Zn), but stimulated it for spruce (P<0.05 for Fe, Zn) On the nutrient-rich calcareous sand, increased atmospheric CO₂ enhanced nutrient accumulation in both species significantly. Increasing the N deposition did not influence the CO₂ effects on net nutrient accumulation with either soil. Under elevated atmospheric CO₂, the accumulation of N declined relative to other nutrients, as indicated by decreasing ratios of N to other nutrients in tree biomass (all ratios: P<0.001, except the N to S ratio). In both the soil and soil solution, elevated CO₂ did not influence concentrations of base cations and available P. Under CO₂ enrichment, concentrations of exchangeable NH₄⁺ decreased by 22% in the acidic loam and increased by 50% in the calcareous sand (soil 2 CO₂, P<0.001). NO₃^- concentrations decreased by 10-70% at elevated CO₂ in both soils (P<0.01).     

Photosynthesis in an invasive grass and native forb at elevated CO2 during an El Niño year in the Mojave Desert

Annual and short-lived perennial plant performance during wet years is important for long-term persistence in the Mojave Desert. Additionally, the effects of elevated CO₂ on desert plants may be relatively greater during years of high resource availability compared to dry years. Therefore, during an El Niño year at the Nevada Desert FACE Facility (a whole-ecosystem CO₂ manipulation), we characterized photosynthetic investment (by assimilation rate-internal CO₂ concentration relationships) and evaluated the seasonal pattern of net photosynthesis (A_net) and stomatal conductance (g_s) for an invasive annual grass, Bromus madritensis ssp. rubens and a native herbaceous perennial, Eriogonum inflatum. Prior to and following flowering, Bromus showed consistent increases in both the maximum rate of carboxylation by Rubisco (V_Cmax) and the light-saturated rate of electron flow (J_max) at elevated CO₂. This resulted in greater A_net at elevated CO₂ throughout most of the life cycle and a decrease in the seasonal decline of maximum midday A_net upon flowering as compared to ambient CO₂. Eriogonum showed significant photosynthetic down-regulation to elevated CO₂ late in the season, but the overall pattern of maximum midday A_net was not altered with respect to phenology. For Eriogonum, this resulted in similar levels of A_net on a leaf area basis as the season progressed between CO₂ treatments, but greater photosynthetic activity over a typical diurnal period. While g_s did not consistently vary with CO₂ in Bromus, it did decrease in Eriogonum at elevated CO₂ throughout much of the season. Since the biomass of both plants increased significantly at elevated CO₂, these patterns of gas exchange highlight the differential mechanisms for increased plant growth. The species-specific interaction between CO₂ and phenology in different growth forms suggests that important plant strategies may be altered by elevated CO₂ in natural settings. These results indicate the importance of evaluating the effects of elevated CO₂ at all life cycle stages to better understand the effects of elevated CO₂ on whole-plant performance in natural ecosystems.     

The effect of elevated carbon dioxide and ozone on leaf- and branch-level photosynthesis and potential plant-level carbon gain in aspen

Two aspen (Populus tremuloides Michx.) clones, differing in O₃ tolerance, were grown in a free-air CO₂ enrichment (FACE) facility near Rhinelander, Wisconsin, and exposed to ambient air, elevated CO₂, elevated O₃ and elevated CO₂+O₃. Leaf instantaneous light-saturated photosynthesis (P_S) and leaf areas (A) were measured for all leaves of the current terminal, upper (current year) and the current-year increment of lower (1-year-old) lateral branches. An average, representative branch was chosen from each branch class. In addition, the average photosynthetic rate was estimated for the short-shoot leaves. A summing approach was used to estimate potential whole-plant C gain. The results of this method indicated that treatment differences were more pronounced at the plant- than at the leaf- or branch-level, because minor effects within modules accrued in scaling to plant level. The whole-plant response in C gain was determined by the counteracting changes in P_S and A. For example, in the O₃-sensitive clone (259), inhibition of P_S in elevated O₃ (at both ambient and elevated CO₂) was partially ameliorated by an increase in total A. For the O₃-tolerant clone (216), on the other hand, stimulation of photosynthetic rates in elevated CO₂ was nullified by decreased total A.     

Effects of elevated CO<Subscript>2</Subscript> on foliar chemistry of saplings of nine species of tropical tree

This study examined the effects of elevated CO₂ on secondary metabolites for saplings of tropical trees. In the first experiment, nine species of trees were grown in the ground in open-top chambers in central Panama at ambient and elevated CO₂ (about twice ambient). On average, leaf phenolic contents were 48% higher under elevated CO₂. Biomass accumulation was not affected by CO₂, but starch, total non-structural carbohydrates and C/N ratios all increased. In a second experiment with Ficus, an early successional species, and Virola, a late successional species, treatments were enriched for both CO₂ and nutrients. For both species, nutrient fertilization increased plant growth and decreased leaf carbohydrates, C/N ratios and phenolic contents, as predicted by the carbon/nutrient balance hypothesis. Changes in leaf C/N levels were correlated with changes in phenolic contents for Virola (r=0.95, P<0.05), but not for Ficus. Thus, elevated CO₂, particularly under conditions of low soil fertility, significantly increased phenolic content as well as the C/N ratio of leaves. The magnitude of the changes is sufficient to negatively affect herbivore growth, survival and fecundity, which should have impacts on plant/herbivore interactions.     

Feeding rates of the woodlouse Armadillidium vulgare on herb litters produced at two levels of atmospheric CO2

The consumption and assimilation rates of the woodlouse Armadillidium vulgare were measured on leaf litters from five herb species grown and naturally senesced at 350 and 700 µl l^-1 CO₂. Each type of litter was tested separately after 12, 30 and 45 days of decomposition at 18°C. The effects of elevated CO₂ differed depending on the plant species. In Medicago minima (Fabaceae), the CO₂ treatment had no significant effect on consumption and assimilation. In Tyrimnus leucographus (Asteraceae), the CO₂ treatment had no significant effect on consumption, but the elevated CO₂ litter was assimilated at a lower rate than the ambient CO₂ litter after 30 days of decomposition. In the three other species, Galactites tomentosa (Asteraceae), Trifolium angustifolium (Fabaceae) and Lolium rigidum (Poaceae), the elevated CO₂ litter was consumed and/or assimilated at a higher rate than the ambient CO₂ litter. Examination of the nitrogen contents in these three species of litter did not support the hypothesis of compensatory feeding, i.e. an increase in woodlouse consumption to compensate for low nitrogen content of the food. Rather, the results suggest that in herbs that were unpalatable at the start of the experiment (Galactites, Trifolium and Lolium), more of the the litter produced at 700 µl l^-1 CO₂ was consumed than of that produced at 350 µl l^-1 because inhibitory factors were eliminated faster during decomposition.     

Modeling dynamic understory photosynthesis of contrasting species in ambient and elevated carbon dioxide

Dynamic responses of understory plants to sunflecks have been extensively studied, but how much differences in dynamic light responses affect daily photosynthesis (A_day) is still the subject of active research. Recent models of dynamic photosynthesis have provided a quantitative tool that allows the critical assessment of the importance of these sunfleck responses on A_day. Here we used a dynamic photosynthesis model to assess differences in four species that were growing in ambient and elevated CO₂. We hypothesized that Liriodendron tulipifera, a species with rapid photosynthetic induction gain and slow induction loss, would have the least limitations to sunfleck photosynthesis relative to the other three species (Acer rubrum, Cornus florida, Liquidambar styraciflua). As a consequence, L. tulipifera should have the highest A_day in an understory environment, despite being the least shade tolerant of the species tested. We further hypothesized that daily photosynthetic enhancement by elevated CO₂ would differ from enhancement levels observed during light-saturated, steady-state measurements. Both hypotheses were supported by the model results under conditions of low daily photosynthetic photon flux density (PFD; <3% of the above-canopy PFD). However, under moderate PFD (10-20% of the above-canopy PFD), differences in dynamic sunfleck responses had no direct impact on A_day for any of the species, since stomatal and photosynthetic induction limitations to sunfleck photosynthesis were small. Thus, the relative species ranking in A_day under moderate PFD closely matched their rankings in steady-state measurements of light-saturated photosynthesis. Similarly, under elevated CO₂, enhancement of modeled A_day over A_day at ambient CO₂ matched the enhancement measured under light saturation. Thus, the effects of species-specific differences in dynamic sunfleck responses, and differences in elevated CO₂ responses of daily photosynthesis, are most important in marginal light environments.     

Effects of CO2 enrichment and intraspecific competition on biomass partitioning, nitrogen content and microbial biomass carbon in soil of perennial ryegrass and white clover

Seedlings of perennial ryegrass (Lolium perenne L. cv. Parcour)and white clover (Trifolium repens L. cv. Karina) grown at fivedifferent plant densities were exposed to ambient (390 ppm)and elevated (690 ppm) CO₂ concentrations. After 43 d the effectsof CO₂ enrichment and plant density on growth of shoot and root,nitrogen concentration of tissue, and microbial biomass carbon(C_mic) in soil were determined. CO₂ enrichment of Lolium perenneincreased shoot growth on average by 17% independent of plantdensity, while effects on root biomass ranged between -4% and+ 107% due to an interaction with plant density. Since tilernumber per plant was unaffected by elevated CO₂, the small responseof shoot growth to CO₂ enrichment was atributed to low sinkstrength. A significant correlation between nitrogen concentrationof total plant biomass and root fraction of total plant drymatter, which was not changed by CO₂ enrichment, indicates thatnitrogen status of the plant controls biomass partitioning andthe effect of CO₂ enrichment on root growth. Effects of elevatedCO₂ and plant density on shoot and root growth of Trifoliumrepens were not significantly interacting and mean CO₂-relatedincrease amounted to 29% and 66%, respectively. However, growthenhancement due to elevated CO₂ was strongest when leaf areaindex was lowest. Total amounts of nitrogen in shoots and rootswere bigger at 690 ppm than at 390 ppm CO₂. There was a significantincrease in C_mic in experiments with both species whereas plantdensity had no substantial effect. Key words: CO₂ enrichment, intraspecific competition, biomass partitioning, Lolium perenne, Trifolium repens, grassland     

Biomass allocation, needle structural characteristics and nutrient composition in Scots pine seedlings exposed to elevated CO2 and O3 concentrations

Three-year-old Scots pine (Pinus sylvestris L.) seedlings were exposed to ambient or elevated ozone (O₃) (1.52ambient) and carbon dioxide (CO₂) (590 µmol mol^-1) concentrations during two growing seasons in open-top field chambers (OTCs). Five different treatments were applied in the chambers: filtered air, ambient air, elevated O₃, elevated CO₂, and elevated O₃ and CO₂ combined. Ambient plots outside the OTCs were also included, but the chamber ambient was used as a control in O₃ and CO₂ treatments due to a significant chamber effect. Increases in yellowing and chlorotic mottling of previous-year (C+1) needles and in the amount of cytoplasmic ribosomes and electron density of the chloroplast stroma in current-year (C) and C+1 needle mesophyll cells were observed in elevated O₃ at both CO₂ concentrations. Elevated O₃ alone caused a non-significant 10.9% decrease in plant total dry mass and a significant decrease in manganese (Mn) content of C needles. CO₂ enrichment caused a significant increase in needle cross-sectional width after the first year of exposure, and an accumulation of starch and slight curling and swelling of the chloroplast thylakoids in the mesophyll tissue of C needles after the second year of exposure. Calcium and Mn contents were increased and copper and nitrogen contents were decreased, significantly, in CO₂-exposed needles. A non-significant 19.1% increase in plant total dry mass was measured in elevated CO₂ alone, whereas a 14.8% reduction in total dry mass, together with a significant reduction in current-year main shoot length, was found in the combined treatment. Overall, in spite of decreases in O₃-induced visible injuries by CO₂, elevated CO₂ levels were not able to counteract the impact of O₃ in this experiment.     

Forest carbon balance under elevated CO2

Free-air CO₂ enrichment (FACE) technology was used to expose a loblolly pine (Pinus taeda L.) forest to elevated atmospheric CO₂ (ambient + 200 µl l^-1). After 4 years, basal area of pine trees was 9.2% larger in elevated than in ambient CO₂ plots. During the first 3 years the growth rate of pine was stimulated by ~26%. In the fourth year this stimulation declined to 23%. The average net ecosystem production (NEP) in the ambient plots was 428 gC m^-2 year^-1, indicating that the forest was a net sink for atmospheric CO₂. Elevated atmospheric CO₂ stimulated NEP by 41%. This increase was primarily an increase in plant biomass increment (57%), and secondarily increased accumulation of carbon in the forest floor (35%) and fine root increment (8%). Net primary production (NPP) was stimulated by 27%, driven primarily by increases in the growth rate of the pines. Total heterotrophic respiration (R_h) increased by 165%, but total autotrophic respiration (R_a) was unaffected. Gross primary production was increased by 18%. The largest uncertainties in the carbon budget remain in separating belowground heterotrophic (soil microbes) and autotrophic (root) respiration. If applied to temperate forests globally, the increase in NEP that we measured would fix less than 10% of the anthropogenic CO₂ projected to be released into the atmosphere in the year 2050. This may represent an upper limit because rising global temperatures, land disturbance, and heterotrophic decomposition of woody tissues will ultimately cause an increased flux of carbon back to the atmosphere.     

Mechanical properties of spruce and beech wood grown in elevated CO2

Biomechanical responses of stems of 6- to 7-year-old spruce [Picea abies (L.) Karst.] and beech (Fagus sylvatica L) trees were studied after 4 years of growth in elevated atmospheric CO₂ in combination with a nitrogen treatment and on two different soil types. At the end of the treatment, stems were harvested and tested in fresh and air-dried status. Bending characteristics of juvenile wood (modulus of elasticity, termed rigidity) were determined by bending tests. Fracture characteristics (termed toughness) were determined by stroke-pendulum tests. From the base disk of each stem densitometric data were obtained. In spruce, wood produced under elevated CO₂ was tougher on both soil types; enhanced N deposition made wood less rigid only on acidic soils. In contrast, beech wood samples showed no significant reaction to CO₂ but were significantly tougher under high nitrogen depositions on acidic soil. Effects on wood density of both CO₂ and N treatments were not significant, but wood density was higher on acidic soil and so were rigidity and toughness (soil effect). Different genotypes of spruce and beech reacted significantly differently to the treatments. Some genotypes reacted strongly to CO₂ or N, whereas others did not react or showed interactions between CO₂ and N. This underlines the importance of genetic diversity in tree communities.     

The growth response of plants to elevated CO2 under non-optimal environmental conditions

Under benign environmental conditions, plant growth is generally stimulated by elevated atmospheric CO₂ concentrations. When environmental conditions become sub- or supra-optimal for growth, changes in the biomass enhancement ratio (BER; total plant biomass at elevated CO₂ divided by plant biomass at the current CO₂ level) may occur. We analysed literature sources that studied CO₂2environment interactions on the growth of herbaceous species and tree seedlings during the vegetative phase. For each experiment we calculated the difference in BER for plants that were grown under 'optimal' and 'non-optimal' conditions. Assuming that interactions would be most apparent if the environmental stress strongly diminished growth, we scaled the difference in the BER values by the growth reduction due to the stress factor. In our compilation we found a large variability in CO₂2environment interactions between experiments. To test the impact of experimental design, we simulated a range of analyses with a plant-to-plant variation in size common in experimental plant populations, in combination with a number of replicates generally used in CO₂2environment studies. A similar variation in results was found as in the compilation of real experiments, showing the strong impact of stochasticity. We therefore caution against strong inferences derived from single experiments and suggest rather a reliance on average interactions across a range of experiments. Averaged over the literature data available, low soil nutrient supply or sub-optimal temperatures were found to reduce the proportional growth stimulation of elevated CO₂. In contrast, BER increased when plants were grown at low water supply, albeit relatively modestly. Reduced irradiance or high salinity caused BER to increase in some cases and decrease in others, resulting in an average interaction with elevated CO₂ that was not significant. Under high ozone concentrations, the relative growth enhancement by elevated CO₂ was strongly increased, to the extent that high CO₂ even compensated in an absolute way for the harmful effect of ozone on growth. No systematic difference in response was found between herbaceous and woody species for any of the environmental variables considered.     

Effects of Elevated Carbon Dioxide on Plant Biomass Production and Competition in a Simulated Neutral Grassland Community

Using open-top chambers, four prominent species (Lolium perenne,Cynosurus cristatus, Holcus lanatusandAgrostis capillaris) ofIrish neutral grasslands were grown at ambient and elevated(700 µmol mol^-1) atmospheric CO₂for a period of 8 months.The effects of interspecific competition on plant responsesto CO₂enrichment were investigated by growing the species ina four-species mixture. The results indicate that the speciesdiffer in their ability to respond to elevated CO₂. CO₂-enrichmenthad the largest effect on the biomass production ofH. lanatus,but substantial stimulations in biomass production were alsofound for the other three species. The CO₂-stimulation of biomassproduction forH. lanatuswas accompanied by increased tillering.In addition, reductions in specific leaf area were found forall species. Exposure to elevated CO₂increased the communitybiomass of the four-species mixture. This increase can be mainlyattributed to a significant increase in the biomass ofH. lanatusatelevated CO₂. No statistically-significant changes in speciescomposition of community biomass were found. However,H. lanatusdidincrease its share of community biomass at each of the harvests,with the other three species, mainlyL. perenne, suffering lossesin their shares at elevated CO₂. The results show that: (1)the species varied in their response to elevated CO₂; and (2)species composition in natural plant communities is likely tochange at elevated CO₂, but these changes may occur rather slowly.Much longer periods of exposure to elevated atmospheric CO₂maybe required to permit detection of significant changes in speciescomposition.Copyright 1998 Annals of Botany Company Carbon dioxide (CO₂) enrichment, competition, Lolium perenne,Cynosurus cristatus, Holcus lanatus, Agrostis capillaris, biomass, specific leaf area, tillering.     

The effect of elevated CO2 and temperature on the secondary chemistry of Betula pendula seedlings

The effect of elevated atmospheric CO₂ and temperature on resource allocation and secondary chemistry of white birch (Betula pendula Roth) under a non-limiting nutrient and water supply was investigated. Birch seedlings were grown in closed-top chambers exposed to ambient CO₂ and temperature, elevated atmospheric CO₂ (700 ppm), elevated temperature (2°C above ambient) and a combination of elevated CO₂ and temperature for one growing season. Elevated CO₂ significantly increased the total biomass of the seedlings. The combined effect of the elevated CO₂ and temperature treatments further increased the total biomass, but not significantly. The content of nitrogen and water decreased, while some secondary compounds (such as condensed tannins and flavonol glycosides) increased in leaves subjected to CO₂ enrichment. Elevated temperature increased the concentration of total flavone aglycones and decreased that of total HPLC-phenolics in the leaves, due to the decrease in individual flavonol glycosides, cinnamoylquinic acids and (+)-catechin. There were no significant interactive effects between CO₂ and temperature in the phenolic concentrations of the leaves and in the stems, while the number of resin droplets in the top part of the stems showed significant interaction. This clearly implies that carbon allocation into secondary metabolites in the leaves and stems differ under enhanced CO₂ and temperature, and the combined effect of CO₂ and temperature on the herbivore resistance of birches, is lower than that of CO₂ and temperature alone.     

Microbial community composition and function beneath temperate trees exposed to elevated atmospheric carbon dioxide and ozone

We hypothesized that changes in plant growth resulting from atmospheric CO₂ and O₃ enrichment would alter the flow of C through soil food webs and that this effect would vary with tree species. To test this idea, we traced the course of C through the soil microbial community using soils from the free-air CO₂ and O₃ enrichment site in Rhinelander, Wisconsin. We added either ¹³C-labeled cellobiose or ¹³C-labeled N-acetylglucosamine to soils collected beneath ecologically distinct temperate trees exposed for 3 years to factorial CO₂ (ambient and 200 µl l^-1 above ambient) and O₃ (ambient and 20 µl l^-1 above ambient) treatments. For both labeled substrates, recovery of ¹³C in microbial respiration increased beneath plants grown under elevated CO₂ by 29% compared to ambient; elevated O₃ eliminated this effect. Production of ¹³C-CO₂ from soils beneath aspen (Populus tremuloides Michx.) and aspen-birch (Betula papyrifera Marsh.) was greater than that beneath aspen-maple (Acer saccharum Marsh.). Phospholipid fatty acid analyses (¹³C-PLFAs) indicated that the microbial community beneath plants exposed to elevated CO₂ metabolized more ¹³C-cellobiose, compared to the microbial community beneath plants exposed to the ambient condition. Recovery of ¹³C in PLFAs was an order of magnitude greater for N-acetylglucosamine-amended soil compared to cellobiose-amended soil, indicating that substrate type influenced microbial metabolism and soil C cycling. We found that elevated CO₂ increased fungal activity and microbial metabolism of cellobiose, and that microbial processes under early-successional aspen and birch species were more strongly affected by CO₂ and O₃ enrichment than those under late-successional maple.     

Root system adjustments: regulation of plant nutrient uptake and growth responses to elevated CO2

Nutrients such as nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) often limit plant growth rate and production in natural and agricultural ecosystems. Limited availability of these nutrients is also a major factor influencing long-term plant and ecosystem responses to rising atmospheric CO₂ levels, i.e., the commonly observed short-term increase in plant biomass may not be sustained over the long-term. Therefore, it is critical to obtain a mechanistic understanding of whether elevated CO₂ can elicit compensatory adjustments such that acquisition capacity for minerals increases in concert with carbon (C) uptake. Compensatory adjustments such as increases in (a) root mycorrhizal infection, (b) root-to-shoot ratio and changes in root morphology and architecture, (c) root nutrient absorption capacity, and (d) nutrient-use efficiency can enable plants to meet an increased nutrient demand under high CO₂. Here we examine the literature to assess the extent to which these mechanisms have been shown to respond to high CO₂. The literature survey reveals no consistent pattern either in direction or magnitude of responses of these mechanisms to high CO₂. This apparent lack of a pattern may represent variations in experimental protocol and/or interspecific differences. We found that in addressing nutrient uptake responses to high CO₂ most investigators have examined these mechanisms in isolation. Because such mechanisms can potentially counterbalance one another, a more reliable prediction of elevated CO₂ responses requires experimental designs that integrate all mechanisms simultaneously. Finally, we present a functional balance (FB) model as an example of how root system adjustments and nitrogen-use efficiency can be integrated to assess growth responses to high CO₂. The FB model suggests that the mechanisms of increased N uptake highlighted here have different weights in determining overall plant responses to high CO₂. For example, while changes in root-to-shoot biomass allocation, r, have a small effect on growth, adjustments in uptake rate per unit root mass, [`(n)]\bar \nu , and photosynthetic N use efficiency, p*, have a significantly greater leverage on growth responses to elevated CO₂ except when relative growth rate (RGR) reaches its developmental limit, maximum RGR (RGR_max).