Spectrum of in vitro differentiation of quail trunk neural crest cells isolated by cell sorting using the HNK-1 antibody and analysis of the adrenergic development of HNK-1+ sorted subpopulations.

Previous work has demonstrated that catecholamine-containing cells differentiate preferentially from populations of quail trunk neural crest cells isolated by cell sorting using the HNK-1 antibody (Maxwell, Forbes, and Christie, 1988). In the present work, we examine several additional features of the differentiation of these sorted cell populations. As one part of this study, the development of subpopulations of the HNK-(1+)-sorted neural crest cells has been investigated. Twice as many catecholamine-positive and total cells developed from the brightest third of the HNK-1+ cells compared to the remaining HNK-1+ cells, but the proportion of catecholamine-containing cells was similar in both populations. When either of these HNK-1+ subpopulations were grown together with HNK-1- cells, no reduction in the number of adrenergic cells was observed. These results indicate that subpopulations of HNK-1+ cells are qualitatively similar and that their adrenergic development is not affected by HNK-1- cells. In the second part of this study, we investigate the specificity of differentiation of HNK-(1+)- and HNK-(1-)-sorted cells by examining several additional phenotypic markers of development. We found that tyrosine hydroxylase and somatostatin immunoreactive cells developed from the HNK-(1+)-sorted population, while few, if any, cells bearing these phenotypic markers appeared in the HNK-(1-)-sorted population. In marked contrast, substantial numbers of cells immunoreactive for A2B5, E/C8, and NF-160 differentiated from both the HNK-(1+)- and the HNK-(1-)-sorted cell populations. The A2B5, E/C8, and NF-160 immunoreactive cells exhibited a variety of morphologies ranging from nonneuronal to neuronal in both sorted populations. Taken together, these results indicate that the presence of the HNK-1 antigen(s) on the trunk neural crest cell surface at 2 days in vitro is rather tightly correlated with the differentiation of adrenergic and some peptidergic cells, but much less so with other classes of neural cells including A2B5, E/C8, and NF-160 immunoreactive cells. Thus, these findings support the view that cell surface differences are correlated with and may contribute to the generation of the phenotypic diversity of neural crest cell derivatives.     

Exogenous basement-membrane-like matrix stimulates adrenergic development in avian neural crest cultures

The development of quail trunk neural crest cultures was dramatically altered when the cultures were overlaid with a gel of reconstituted basement membrane (RBM) components derived from the Engelbreth-Holm-Swarm sarcoma. In the presence of the RBM gel overlay, the number of catecholamine-positive (CA+) cells that developed was increased 50-fold, while the final number of melanocytes and total cells was only half that seen in the control cultures. The presence of the RBM gel overlay did not alter the time of onset of differentiation of the CA+ cells or melanocytes. The stimulation of CA+ cell number was not observed with type IV collagen substrates, laminin substrates or type I collagen gel overlays with or without added laminin. The stimulation of CA+ cell development was dependent on initial plating density. The number of CA+ cells that developed in the presence of the RBM gel was proportional to the initial plating density at 80-320 cells mm-2, whereas no CA+ cells were observed below 20 cells mm-2 and only a few CA+ cells were detected at 40 cells mm-2. There was, however, extensive cell division and differentiation of melanocytes and unpigmented cells at the lower initial plating densities. When the RBM gel was used as a substrate, rather than as an overlay, a striking rearrangement of cells into interconnected strands was observed. After several days in culture, melanocytes, CA+ cells and unpigmented cells were present in these strands. These results indicate that molecules associated with a reconstituted basement-membrane-like matrix are a potent stimulatory influence on adrenergic development and also act to inhibit the production of other cell types in neural crest cultures.     

Spectrum of in vitro differentiation of quail trunk neural crest cells isolated by cell sorting using the HNK-1 antibody and analysis of the adrenergic development of HNK-1+ sorted subpopulations

Previous work has demonstrated that catecholamine-containing cells differentiate preferentially from populations of quail trunk neural crest cells isolated by cell sorting using the HNK-1 antibody (Maxwell, Forbes, and Christie, 1988). In the present work, we examine several additional features of the differentiation of these sorted cell populations. As one part of this study, the development of subpopulations of the HNK-1⁺-sorted neural crest cells has been investigated. Twice as many catecholamine-positive and total cells developed from the brightest third of the HNK-1⁺ cells compared to the remaining HNK-1⁺ cells, but the proportion of catecholamine-containing cells was similar in both populations. When either of these HNK-1⁺ subpopulations were grown together with HNK-1^? cells, no reduction in the number of adrenergic cells was observed. These results indicate that subpopulations of HNK-1⁺ cells are qualitatively similar and that their adrenergic development is not affected by HNK-1^? cells. In the second part of this study, we investigate the specificity of differentiation of HNK-1⁺- and HNK-1^?-sorted cells by examining several additional phenotypic markers of development. We found that tyrosine hydroxylase and somatostatin immunoreactive cells developed from the HNK-1⁺-sorted population, while few, if any, cells bearing these phenotypic markers appeared in the HNK-1^?-sorted population. In marked contrast, substantial numbers of cells immunoreactive for A2B5, E/C8, and NF-160 differentiated from both the HNK-1⁺- and the HNK-1^?-sorted cell populations. The A2B5, E/C8, and NF-160 immunoreactive cells exhibited a variety of morphologies ranging from nonneuronal to neuronal in both sorted populations. Taken together, these results indicate that the presence of the HNK-1 antigen(s) on the trunk neural crest cell surface at 2 days in vitro is rather tightly correlated with the differentiation of adrenergic and some peptidergic cells, but much less so with other classes of neural cells including A2B5, E/C8, and NF-160 immunoreactive cells. Thus, these findings support the view that cell surface differences are correlated with and may contribute to the generation of the phenotypic diversity of neural crest cell derivatives.     

Perturbation of cranial neural crest migration by the HNK-1 antibody

The HNK-1 antibody recognizes a carbohydrate moiety that is shared by a family of cell adhesion molecules and is also present on the surface of migrating neural crest cells. Here, the effects of the HNK-1 antibody on neural crest cells were examined in vitro and in vivo. When the HNK-1 antibody was added to neural tube explants in tissue culture, neural crest cells detached from laminin substrates but were unaffected on fibronectin substrates. In order to examine the effects of the HNK-1 antibody in vivo, antibody was injected lateral to the mesencephalic neural tube at the onset of cranial neural crest migration. The injected antibody persisted for approximately 16 hr on the injected side of the embryo and appeared to be most prevalent on the surface of neural crest cells. Embryos fixed within the first 24 hr after injection of HNK-1 antibodies (either whole IgMs or small IgM fragments) showed one or more of the following abnormalities: (1) ectopic neural crest cells external to the neural tube, (2) an accumulation of neural crest cell volume on the lumen of the neural tube, (3) some neural tube anomalies, or (4) a reduction in the neural crest cell volume on the injected side. The ectopic cells and neural tube anomalies persisted in embryos fixed 2 days postinjection. Only embryos having 10 or less somites at the time of injection were affected, suggesting a limited period of sensitivity to the HNK-1 antibody. Control embryos injected with a nonspecific antibody or with a nonblocking antibody against the neural cell adhesion molecule (N-CAM) were unaffected. Previous experiments from this laboratory have demonstrated than an antibody against integrin, a fibronectin and laminin receptor caused defects qualitatively similar to those resulting from HNK-1 antibody injection (M. Bronner-Fraser, J. Cell Biol., 101, 610, 1985). Coinjection of the HNK-1 and integrin antibodies resulted in a greater percentage of affected embryos than with either antibody alone. The additive nature of the effects of the two antibodies suggests that they act at different sites. These results demonstrate that the HNK-1 antibody causes abnormalities in cranial neural crest migration, perhaps by perturbing interactions between neural crest cells and laminin substrates.     

Clonal analysis of quail neural crest cells: They are pluripotent and differentiate in vitro in the absence of noncrest cells

To determine if neural crest cells are pluripotent and establish whether differentiation occurs in the absence of noncrest cells, a cell culture method was devised in which differentiation could be examined in clones derived from single, isolated neural crest cells. Single neural crest cells, which were isolated before the onset of in vivo migration, gave rise to three types of clones: pigmented, unpigmented, and mixed. Pigmented clones consisted of melanocytes only, whereas some unpigmented cells in mixed and unpigmented clones contained catecholamines, identifying them as adrenergic cells. Extracellular matrix derived from quail somite or chick skin fibroblast cultures stimulated adrenergic differentiation and axon formation. These results demonstrate for the first time the existence of pluripotent quail neural crest cells that give rise to at least two progeny, melanocytes and neuronal cells. They also suggest that continuous direct interactions with noncrest cells are not required for the differentiation of these two cell types. However, components of the extracellular matrix derived from noncrest cells may play an important role in expression of the adrenergic phenotype.     

Xenopus neural crest cell migration in an applied electrical field

Xenopus neural crest cells migrated toward the cathode in an applied electrical field of 10 mV/mm or greater. This behavior was observed in relatively isolated cells, as well as in groups of neural crest cells; however, the velocity of directed migration usually declined when a cell made close contact with other cells. Melanocytes with a full complement of evenly distributed melanosomes did not migrate of their own accord, but could be distorted and pulled by unpigmented neural crest cells. Incompletely differentiated melanocytes and melanocytes with aggregated melanosomes displayed the same behavior as undifferentiated neural crest cells, that is, migration toward the cathode. An electrical field of 10 mV/mm corresponded to a voltage drop of less than 1 mV across the diameter of each cell; the outer epithelium of Xenopus embryos drives an endogenous transembryonic current that may produce voltage gradients of nearly this magnitude within high-resistance regions of the embryo. We, therefore, propose that electrical current produced by the skin battery present in these embryos may act as a vector to guide neural crest migration.     

Cellular fibronectin promotes adrenergic differentiation of quail neural crest cells in vitro

We have investigated the interaction of cellular fibronectin (CFN) with cultured quail neural crest cells and its possible role in crest cell migration and differentiation. In vitro, quail neural crest cells from the trunk region differentiate into at least two morphologically recognizable cell types, melanocytes and adrenergic nerve cells. The latter often aggregate spontaneously into ganglia-like structures. We found that neither melanocytes nor adrenergic nerve cells synthesize CFN. However, both cell types readily interacted with exogenous CFN: Melanocytes removed CFN from the substratum and accumulated it in an aggegated form on their upper cell surface, whereas unpigmented cells migrated on the CFN substratum, often rearranging it into a fibrillar network. The adsorption of CFN by melanocytes was apparently without further consequences. However, catecholamine-positive cells were substantially increased after treatment with exogeneous fibronectin. The stimulation of adrenergic differentiation of neural crest cells is the first evidence for a positive regulatory role of fibronectin in differentiation.     

Expression of the HNK-1/NC-1 epitope in early vertebrate neurogenesis

Summary A family of glycoconjugates has recently been shown to share a common carbohydrate epitope recognized by the mouse monoclonal antibody HNK-1. The specificity of HNK-1 was found to be similar to that of another monoclonal antibody, NC-1. These two IgM monoclonal antibodies were raised after immunization of mice with a human T-cell line and avian neural crest-derived ganglia, respectively. The antigens recognized by these antibodies include the myelin-associated glycoprotein, MAG, a glycolipid of defined structure, and a set of molecules involved in cell adhesion. The timing and pattern of appearance of these antigens are distinct. Moreover, the epitope may be absent on an antigen at a given stage or in a given tissue. Therefore, although the molecules able to carry the NC-1/ HNK-1 epitope are numerous and expressed in various tissues, the use of the monoclonal antibodies on tissue sections has proven adequate for following the migration of avian neural crest cells, the major cell lineage recognized by NC-1 and HNK-1 during early embryogenesis. Analogies in several other species have been found on the basis of HNK-1 reactivity. In this study we show that NC-1 and HNK-1 can be used successfully to label migrating neural crest cells in dog, pig and human. On the other hand, the NC-l/HNK-1 epitope was not present on migrating crest cells in amphibians or mice and was found only transiently on the neural crest of rats.     

Analysis of developmentally homogeneous neural crest cell populations in vitro: I. Formation,morphology and differentiative behavior

When early embryonic quail neural tubes are dissected free from surrounding tissues and placed in culture, small stellate neural crest cells usually migrate from the explant onto the substratum. This outgrowth has been reported to consist of a mixture of cells, some of which undergo melanogenesis, while the rest remain unpigmented. We have, in contrast to earlier observations, obtained a spatial separation of the two phenotypes. In these cultures the primary outgrowth of migrating cells remained almost free of pigment-forming cells, whereas small spherical clusters containing several hundred pigment-forming cells appeared on the explanted neural tubes. Whether the clusters remained with the tube explants or were subcultured, all cluster cells differentiated into melanocytes. Prior to melanogenesis, the appearance of the cultured cells from a cluster was indistinguishable from the cells in the outgrowth. The clusters provide a source of neural crest cells, that (1) can be easily obtained in comparatively large numbers, (2) is not contaminated with any other cell type, (3) can be isolated before the onset of differentiation, and (4) is developmentally homogeneous. Thus, the cluster population is well suited for many types of experiments, such as the identification of specific environmental factors that might control neural crest cell differentiation.     

Lectin binding to neural crest cells. Changes of the cell surface during differentiation in vitro

To examine possible changes in cell surface carbohydrates, fluorescent lectins were applied at various times during differentiation of neural crest cells in vitro. The pattern and intensity of binding of several lectins changed as the crest cells developed into melanocytes and adrenergic cells. Considerable amounts of concanavalin A (Con A) and wheat germ agglutinin (WGA) bound to all unpigmented cells throughout the culture period. Melanocytes, however, bound much less of these lectins. Soy bean agglutinin (SBA), unlike Con A and WGA, only bound later in development to unpigmented cells at about the time when catecholamines were detected histochemically. Binding of SBA could be induced in younger cultures by pretreating the cells with neuraminidase. Melanocytes, however, did not bind detectable amounts of SBA even if treated with neuraminidase. The SBA-binding sites were often concentrated on cytoplasmic extensions and on contact points between neighboring cells, even when receptor mobility was restricted by prefixation of the cells or adsorption of lectin at 0 degrees C. All three lectins bound to cell processes resembling nerve fibers in particularly high amounts.     

Characterization of HNK-1 antigens during the formation of the avian enteric nervous system.

During vertebrate embryogenesis, interaction between neural crest cells and the enteric mesenchyme gives rise to the development of the enteric nervous system. In birds, monoclonal antibody HNK-1 is a marker for neural crest cells from the entire rostrocaudal axis. In this study, we aimed to characterize the HNK-1 carrying cells and antigen(s) during the formation of the enteric nervous system in the hindgut. Immunohistological findings showed that HNK-1-positive mesenchymal cells are present in the gut prior to neural crest cell colonization. After neural crest cell colonization this cell type cannot be visualized anymore with the HNK-1 antibody. We characterized the HNK-1 antigens that are present before and after neural crest cell colonization of the hindgut. Immunoblot analysis of plasma membranes from embryonic hindgut revealed a wide array of HNK-1-carrying glycoproteins. We found that two HNK-1 antigens are present in E4 hindgut prior to neural crest cell colonization and that the expression of these antigens disappears after neural crest colonization. These two membrane glycoproteins, G-42 and G-44, have relative molecular masses of 42,000 and 44,000, respectively, and they both have isoelectric points of 5.5 under reducing conditions. We suggest that these HNK-1 antigens and the HNK-1-positive mesenchymal cells have some role in the formation of the enteric nervous system.     

Temporal Expression of HNK-1-Reactive Sulfoglucuronyl Glycolipid in Cultured Quail Trunk Neural Crest Cells: Comparison with Other Developmentally Regulated Glycolipids

Monoclonal antibody HNK-1 is an important marker for embryonic neural crest cells and some of their differentiated derivatives. We have identified 3-sulfoglucuronylneolactotetraosylceramide (SGGL-1) as one of the HNK-1 antigens present in cultures of trunk neural crest cells. This lipid was present at 2 days in vitro and increased in amount with time in culture. Other major HNK-1-reactive antigens present in the culture were glycoproteins of apparent molecular masses of 120, 180, and 200 kDa. The 180- and 200-kDa bands were present at 2, 7, and 17 days in vitro, whereas the 120-kDa band was present only at 17 days in vitro. Gangliosides GD3, LD1, and LM1 were also found in the cultures and exhibited distinct temporal patterns of expression. Ganglioside GD3 was present at all stages examined and its expression peaked at 7 days in vitro. In contrast, LD1 was present only at 2 days in vitro and was not detectable at later times. Ganglioside LM1 increased in amount with time in culture in a pattern similar to that seen for SGGL-1. Taken together, these results indicate that several HNK-1-reactive molecules are expressed in neural crest cultures in a temporally regulated manner along with several glycolipids that do not bear this epitope.     

Tumor-Promoting Phorbol Esters Promote Melanogenesis and Prevent Expression of the Adrenergic Phenotype in Quail Neural Crest Cells

Tumor-promoting phorbol esters were used to manipulate the in vitro development of neural crest cells. When plated at clonal density in secondary culture, quail neural crest cells from the trunk region gave rise to three types of colonies, pigmented, unpigmented, and mixed. Pigmented colonies consisted exclusively of melanocytes; up to 50% of the unpigmented and mixed colonies contained adrenergic nerve cells which could be identified by a catecholamine-specific histofluorescence method. Addition of potent tumor promoters to the culture medium shortened the doubling time of neural crest cells and altered their morphologic appearance. It also delayed the onset of pigmentation, prevented the expression of the adrenergic phenotype, reduced the number of unpigmented and mixed colonies, and increased the number of pigmented colonies, most likely by directing progenitor cells preferentially to the melanogenic pathway. There was a clear correlation between the ability of phorbol esters to promote skin tumors in mice and their ability to interfere with the in vitro development of quail neural crest cells. The potent promoters 12–0–tetradecanoyl phorbol 13–acetate (TPA) and phorbol 12,13–didecanoate (PDD) were most effective, phorbol 12,13–diacetate (PDA) was considerably less effective, the nonpromoting analogues 4–0–methyl 12–0–tetradecanoyl phorbol 13–acetate (4–0–Me-TPA) and 4α-phorbol 12,13–didecanoate (4α-PDD) and the parent alcohol phorbol (PHR) had little or no effect.     

In vitro clonal analysis of quail cardiac neural crest development

The developmental potentials of cardiac neural crest cells were investigated by in vitro clonal analysis. Five morphologically distinct types of clones were observed: (1) "pigmented" clones contained melanocytes only; (2) "mixed" clones consisted of pigmented and unpigmented cells; (3) "unpigmented dense" clones consisted of flattened, closely aligned unpigmented cells; (4) "unpigmented loose" clones consisted of a few loosely arranged, flattened cells; and (5) "unpigmented large" clones included a large number of small, stellate cells that were highly proliferative. The binding patterns of antibodies against lineage-specific markers showed that cells in the different clones expressed characteristic phenotypes. The following phenotypes were expressed in addition to pigment cells: smooth muscle cells, connective tissue cells, chondrocytes, and cells in the sensory neuron lineage. Mixed clones expressed all five phenotypes. Unpigmented dense clones contained smooth muscle cells, connective tissue cells, chondrocytes, and sensory neurons. Unpigmented loose clones exclusively consisted of smooth muscle cells, whereas unpigmented large clones contained chondrocytes and sensory neuron precursors. Based on these results, the following conclusions can be drawn: (1) Pigmented and unpigmented loose clones are most likely formed by precursors that are committed to the melanogenic and myogenic cell lineages, respectively. (2) Mixed and unpigmented dense clones are derived from pluripotent cells with the capacity to give rise to four or five phenotypes. (3) Unpigmented large clones originate from progenitor cells that appear to have a partially restricted developmental potential, that is, these cells are capable of generating two phenotypes in clonal cultures. Thus, the data indicate that the early migratory cardiac neural crest is a heterogeneous population of cells, consisting of pluripotent cells, cells with a partially restricted developmental potential, and cells committed to a particular cell lineage.     

Avian neural crest cell attachment to laminin: involvement of divalent cation dependent and independent integrins.

The mechanisms of neural crest cell interaction with laminin were explored using a quantitative cell attachment assay. With increasing substratum concentrations, an increasing percentage of neural crest cells adhere to laminin. Cell adhesion at all substratum concentrations was inhibited by the CSAT antibody, which recognizes the chick beta 1 subunit of integrin, suggesting that beta 1-integrins mediate neural crest cell interactions with laminin. The HNK-1 antibody, which recognizes a carbohydrate epitope, inhibited neural crest cell attachment to laminin at low coating concentrations (greater than 1 microgram ml-1; Low-LM), but not at high coating concentration of laminin (10 micrograms ml-1; High-LM). Attachment to Low-LM occurred in the absence of divalent cations, whereas attachment to High-LM required greater than 0.1 mM Ca2+ or Mn2+. Neural crest cell adherence to the E8 fragment of laminin, derived from its long arm, was similar to that on intact laminin at high and low coating concentrations, suggesting that this fragment contains the neural crest cell binding site(s). The HNK-1 antibody recognizes a protein of 165,000 Mr which is also found in immunoprecipitates using antibodies against the beta 1 subunit of integrin and is likely to be an integrin alpha subunit or an integrin-associated protein. Our results suggest that the HNK-1 epitope on neural crest cells is present on or associated with a novel or differentially glycosylated form of beta 1-integrin, which recognizes laminin in the apparent absence of divalent cations. We conclude that neural crest cells have at least two functionally independent means of attachment to laminin which are revealed at different substratum concentrations and/or conformations of laminin.     

SSEA-1 is a specific marker for the spinal sensory neuron lineage in the quail embryo and in neural crest cell cultures

Investigation of the early phases of the development of primary sensory neurons has been limited to cells obtained from sensory ganglia. Due to the lack of an early, lineage-specific marker for sensory neuroblasts, it has not been possible to use the neural crest, which gives rise to all spinal and some cranial primary sensory neurons, as a source of precursor cells. In the present study, we show that in neural crest derivatives of the quail embryo, the stage-specific embryonic antigen-1 (SSEA-1) is expressed specifically by developing sensory neuroblasts. The monoclonal antibodies anti-SSEA-1 and AC4 were used to characterize sensory neuron development in vivo and in neural crest cell cultures. In the rat and mouse, both antibodies recognize the same carbohydrate sequence [galactose beta 1-4(fucose alpha 1-3)N-acetylglucosamine] which characterizes SSEA-1. In the quail embryo, this epitope is a marker with several attractive characteristics. Among neural crest derivatives, it is specific for the sensory lineage and is expressed by all detectable sensory neuroblasts at all spinal axial levels. In addition, the carbohydrate sequence appears early and persists throughout development. Expression of SSEA-1 was also studied in neural crest cell cultures, in which two populations of sensory neuroblasts were observed. One population differentiated before or shortly after explanation into culture; these cells did not emigrate from the neural tube. A second population appeared in older cultures. Forming the leading edge of the emigrating neural crest cells, they became SSEA-1+ 3 days after the nonmigrating SSEA-1+ cells. Double staining experiments revealed no obvious differences between the two populations with regard to morphology, neurofilament expression, and neurotransmitter content.     

Cranial and trunk neural crest cells use different mechanisms for attachment to extracellular matrices.

We have used a quantitative cell attachment assay to compare the interactions of cranial and trunk neural crest cells with the extracellular matrix (ECM) molecules fibronectin, laminin and collagen types I and IV. Antibodies to the beta 1 subunit of integrin inhibited attachment under all conditions tested, suggesting that integrins mediate neural crest cell interactions with these ECM molecules. The HNK-1 antibody against a surface carbohydrate epitope under certain conditions inhibited both cranial and trunk neural crest cell attachment to laminin, but not to fibronectin. An antiserum to alpha 1 intergrin inhibited attachment of trunk, but not cranial, neural crest cells to laminin and collagen type I, though interactions with fibronectin or collagen type IV were unaffected. The surface properties of trunk and cranial neural crest cells differed in several ways. First, trunk neural crest cells attached to collagen types I and IV, but cranial neural crest cells did not. Second, their divalent cation requirements for attachment to ECM molecules differed. For fibronectin substrata, trunk neural crest cells required divalent cations for attachment, whereas cranial neural crest cells bound in the absence of divalent cations. However, cranial neural crest cells lost this cation-independent attachment after a few days of culture. For laminin substrata, trunk cells used two integrins, one divalent cation-dependent and the other divalent cation-independent (Lallier, T. E. and Bronner-Fraser, M. (1991) Development 113, 1069-1081). In contrast, cranial neural crest cells attached to laminin using a single, divalent cation-dependent receptor system. Immunoprecipitations and immunoblots of surface labelled neural crest cells with HNK-1, alpha 1 integrin and beta 1 integrin antibodies suggest that cranial and trunk neural crest cells possess biochemically distinct integrins. Our results demonstrate that cranial and trunk cells differ in their mechanisms of adhesion to selected ECM components, suggesting that they are non-overlapping populations of cells with regard to their adhesive properties.     

Requirement of a neural tube signal for the differentiation of neural crest cells into dorsal root ganglia

The influence of the neural tube on early development of neural crest cells into sensory ganglia was studied in the chick embryo. Silastic membranes were implanted between the neural tube and the somites in 30-somite-stage embryos at the level of somites 21-24, thus separating the early migrated population of neural crest cells from the neural tube. Neural crest cells and peripheral ganglia were visualized by immunofluorescence using the HNK-1 monoclonal antibody and several histochemical techniques. Separation of crest cells from the neural tube caused the selective death of the neural crest cells from which dorsal root ganglia (DRG) would have developed. Complete disappearance of HNK-1 positive cells was evident already 10 hr after silastic implantation, before early differentiation sensory neurons could have reached their peripheral targets. In older embryos, DRG were absent at the level of implantation. In contrast, the development of ventral roots, sympathetic ganglia and adrenal gland was normal, and so was somitic differentiation into cartilage and muscle, while morphogenesis of the vertebrae was perturbed. To overcome the experimentally induced crest cell death, the silastic membranes were impregnated with a 3-day-old embryonic chick neural tube extract. Under these conditions, crest cells which were separated from the tube survived for a period of 30 hr after operation, compared to less than 10 hr in respective controls. The extract of another tissue, the liver, did not protract survival of DRG progenitor cells. Among the cells which survived with neural tube extract, some even succeeded in extending neurites; nevertheless, in absence of normal connections with the central nervous system (CNS) they finally died. Treatment of silastic implanted embryos with nerve growth factor (NGF) did not prevent the experimentally induced crest cell death. These results demonstrate that DRG develop from a population of neural crest cells which depends for its survival and probably for its differentiation upon a signal arising from the CNS, needed as early as the first hours after initiation of migration. Recovery experiments suggest that the subpopulation of crest cells which will develop along the sensory pathway probably depends for its survival and/or differentiation upon a factor contained in the neural tube, which is different from NGF.     

A paraxial exclusion zone creates patterned cranial neural crest cell outgrowth adjacent to rhombomeres 3 and 5.

Cranial neural crest cell migration is patterned, with neural crest cell-free zones adjacent to rhombomere (R) 3 and R5. These zones have been suggested to result from death of premigratory neural crest cells via upregulation of BMP-4 and Msx-2 in R3 and R5, consequent to R2-, R4-, and R6-derived signals. We reinvestigated this model and found that cell death detected by acridine orange staining in avian embryos varied widely numerically and in pattern, but with a tendency for an elevated zone centered at the R2/3 boundary. In situ hybridization of BMP-4 mRNA resolved to centers at R3 and R5 but Msx-2 resolved to the R2/3 border with only a faint smear from R5 to R6. Outgrowth of neural crest cells was less in isolated R3 cultures than in R1+2, R2, and R4 cultures, but R3 showed neither a decrease in outgrowth of neural crest cells nor an increase in cell death when cocultured with R1+2, R2, or R4. In addition, in serum-free culture, exogenous BMP-4 strikingly reduced neural crest cell outgrowth from R1+2 and R4 as well as R3. Thus we cannot confirm the role of intraneural cell death in patterning rhombomeric neural crest outgrowth. However, grafting quail R2 or R4 adjacent to the chick hindbrain demonstrated a neural crest cell exclusion zone next to R3 and R5. We suggest that one important pattern determinant for rhombomeric neural crest cell migration involves the microenvironment next to the neural tube.