Telecytologic diagnosis of breast fine needle aspiration biopsies. Intraobserver concordance

OBJECTIVE: To determine the intraobserver concordance between telecytologic and glass slide diagnosis of breast fine needle aspirates. STUDY DESIGN: Twenty-five cases, originally received in consultation, were each examined by three cytopathologists. An average of seven compressed digital images per case were presented, together with a brief clinical history, using the http protocol and an internet browser. RESULTS: Agreement between the telecytologic and glass slide diagnosis ranged from 80% to 96%. Nevertheless, two cases that had been unequivocally diagnosed as malignant based upon video images were considered to be benign by the same pathologist when reviewing the glass slides. Both diagnostic confidence and self-concordance were higher for one pathologist having significant previous video microscopy experience. CONCLUSION: Although intraobserver concordance between telecytologic and glass slide diagnoses of breast fine needle aspirates is high, refinement of existing criteria for diagnosis of malignancy, taking account of the particular limitations associated with telecytologic diagnosis, may be prudent prior to widespread use of telecytology for fine needle aspiration evaluation.     

Statistical approach to fine needle aspiration diagnosis of breast masses

A statistical algorithm was used for recursively partitioning a consecutive series of 37 benign and 69 malignant fine needle aspirates to produce a decision tree for diagnosing breast masses. Optimal separation between benign and malignant cytology was accomplished by evaluating clump characteristics when clumps were present and evaluating cell integrity when clumps were absent. The 1.5% false-negative and 9.7% false-positive rates obtained through this scheme are better than those reported for most series.     

Electron microscopy of fine needle aspiration biopsies of mediastinal and paramediastinal lesions

The ultrastructural cytologic study of fine needle aspiration (FNA) biopsies from eight cases with mediastinal and paramediastinal lesions is reported. In these cases, electron microscopy (EM) was essential in cytologically determining the correct type of the cancer cells. The results in these cases suggest that portions of FNA biopsies from deep sites, where aspiration is difficult or requires computed tomographic scanning, should be routinely processed for plastic embedding, so that EM examination can be performed if the cells are undifferentiated, scanty or poorly preserved by light microscopic examination. The proper cytologic identification of the cell might, in fact, have a major bearing on the therapeutic choices and on the prognosis.     

Flow cytometric DNA analysis on fine needle aspiration biopsies of liver lesions

Flow cytometric DNA analysis on fine needle aspiration biopsies of liver lesions The DNA cell content of 39 fine needle aspiration biopsies (FNAs) from five benign liver lesions, nine hepatocellular carcinomas (HCCs), and 25 metastatic tumours was analysed in a prospective fashion by flow cytometry (FCM). All benign lesions were diploid. Aneuploidy was found in five (55.6%) HCCs and in nine (36%) metastatic tumours. DNA index (DI) differences were not significant. The S-phase fraction (SPF) was higher in the malignant tumours, both combined (P < 0.02) and separated primary and metastatic (P < 0.05). We could not demonstrate an association between diploidy and percentage of benign hepatocytes in the smears of malignant tumours. The serum alpha-fetoprotein (AFP) level did not correlate with ploidy, DI, or SPF in the HCCs. In conclusion, ploidy and DI do not discriminate between benign and malignant liver lesions, but the SPF is higher in malignant tumours. DNA analysis does not help to distinguish primary from metastatic liver tumours. The presence of benign hepatocytes in samples from malignant tumours does not seem to influence the analysis of ploidy by FCM.     

Value of fine needle aspiration in the diagnosis of breast lesions.

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the accuracy values of 276 fine needle aspriations (FNA) of breast lesions with a subsequent excisional biopsy diagnosis and to make a comparison between 25 studies of the literature using the same criteria to calculate those values. STUDY DESIGN: Cytologic findings were compared with the histologic diagnosis of each mass. The correlation of results was analyzed by a decision-analysis approach, and the following values concerning diagnostic accuracy were calculated in the present study and in 25 other reports: sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, negative predictive value, false positive fraction and false negative fraction. To calculate those values, we eliminated unsatisfactory results and assumed that suspicious and positive cytologic findings represented carcinoma of the breast. RESULTS: Comparing our results with the means in the literature (numbers in parenthesis), FNA detected cancer with a sensitivity of 92.1% (87.7%), specificity of 98.6% (94.7%), positive predictive value of 99.4% (92.8%), negative predictive value of 82.1% (90.7%), false positive fraction of 0.6% (7.1%) and false negative fraction of 17.9% (13.4%); in 6.2% of cases the material was unsatisfactory (13.4%). CONCLUSION: All the rates varied enormously between the studies and during the past 13 years. It seems that false positive and false negative fractions tended to diminish and stabilize in more recent years, and specificity and sensitivity underwent a slight increase. The differences between the rates of those studies suggest that FNA of the breast has some unavoidable limitations.     

Fine needle aspiration of palpable breast lesions. Results obtained with cytocentrifuge preparation of aspirates

The use of cytocentrifugation in the preparation of fine needle aspiration (FNA) specimens from the breast was evaluated. A total of 174 fine needle aspirates of breast masses were flushed into cytospin Collection Fluid, from which Papanicolaou-stained Cytospin preparations were made in the laboratory. Comparison of these preparations to conventional smears of aspirates showed no significant differences in the number or morphology of the cells. In 148 cases, the FNA cytologic study was followed up by excisional biopsy, Tru-Cut biopsy and/or a combination of mammography and clinical follow-up of two to nine months. Of 36 verified carcinomas, 31 (86%) were correctly diagnosed, with a zero false-positive rate. Among the 74 cytologically benign aspirates, 2 carcinomas were found on open biopsy, giving a false-negative rate of 3%. Lipomas were not diagnosable with this technique. This technique should be considered in institutions with a high turnover of junior staff members, which frequently results in a higher number of poorly smeared specimens or in poorly fixed/air-dried specimens that give suboptimal results with the Papanicolaou stain. With this method, there is less risk of creation of potentially hazardous aerosols and further preparations for additional studies may be made if required.     

Quantitative image analysis of estrogen receptors in breast fine needle aspiration biopsies

OBJECTIVE: To establish whether the results of quantitative evaluation of estrogen receptors (ERs) in cytologic fine needle aspiration (FNA) biopsies of the breast are comparable to the results obtained on excised breast tumors and therefore suitable for making a clinical decision on tamoxifen treatment in women who are not candidates for surgery. STUDY DESIGN: We performed a retrospective review of 118 breast FNA specimens that were positive for adenocarcinoma cells, had adequate cell block cellularity and provided subsequent surgical resection tissue. Quantification of ERs was performed on cell block material and follow-up tissue sections by the Chromavision Automated Imaging System, San Juan Capistrano, California, U.S.A. RESULTS: Quantitative image analysis provided consistently reliable, comparable results when evaluating for the presence or absence of ERs (at a 5% staining cutoff level), with 98.3% agreement between FNA cytology and histology specimens. Quantitative measurements of FNA samples showed the best agreement with the values derived from the subsequent surgical specimens at high-end (> 85% staining) and low-end (< 10% staining) values. However, a direct linear correlation of values was not observed. In the great majority of parallel measures, ERs were either strongly positive (> 75% staining) or had a zero value, particularly in the surgical specimens, with more "in-between" values identified in FNA specimens. CONCLUSION: Quantitative image analysis of FNA of ER results are comparable to those of surgical excision specimens and can be used for therapeutic decision making. The utility and advantages of quantitative ERs by image analysis include providing the patient and physician with important early prognostic and diagnostic information before planning a surgical approach. Additionally, FNA ERs are useful in determining therapy alternatives in patients who are not surgical candidates and in evaluating the preoperative hormone status of patients receiving chemotherapy prior to surgery.     

Diagnostic value of fine needle aspiration biopsy of palpable colonic masses.

OBJECTIVE: To assess the role of fine needle aspiration biopsy (FNAB) in patients with palpable colonic masses. STUDY DESIGN: FNAB was performed on 32 patients with palpable colonic masses before subjecting them to colonoscopic examination. Smears prepared from the material obtained by aspiration biopsy were examined. The results of aspiration biopsy were confirmed by histopathologic examination of the tissue obtained on colonoscopy or surgery or by a salutory response to antituberculous therapy in patients with tuberculosis of the colon. RESULTS: Twenty-nine patients had carcinoma of the colon, and three had ileocecal tuberculosis. Aspiration biopsy could correctly diagnose all the cases with malignancy and two of the three cases with colonic tuberculosis. Colonoscopy could not be performed on two patients with cancer of the colon. However, a barium enema examination revealed evidence of cecal malignancy in both patients. In the two patients diagnosed as having colonic tuberculosis by FNAB, colonoscopic biopsies revealed only nonspecific changes. There were no false positive results or complications of the procedure. CONCLUSION: FNAB is a simple, rapid and accurate method of diagnosing palpable colonic masses.     

The triage role of fine needle aspiration biopsy of palpable breast masses. Diagnostic accuracy and cost-effectiveness

A total of 219 fine needle aspiration (FNA) biopsies of the breast were performed during the period 1983 to 1985 at a tertiary medical center. The series consisted of 215 women (98.2%) and 4 men (1.8%), with an are range of 14 to 90 years (mean of 46.5 years). Histologic confirmation (93 cases) or clinical follow-up for up to two years was obtained. The sensitivity of the FNA procedure was 82.2%, its specificity was 98.8%, and the overall efficiency of the test was 95.4%. The false-negative rate was 4.4%, with no false-positive diagnoses for the primary diagnosis of breast carcinoma. We have found that one of the major advantages of FNA biopsy is that it lowers costs by allowing the surgeon to triage which patients should have an outpatient excisional biopsy under local anesthesia and which patients should have a one-stage inpatient procedure with frozen section confirmation. For this triage role, suspicious diagnoses (3.2%) were included in the positive group and atypical (1.8%) and insufficient diagnoses (6.8%) in the negative group. Taking into account the FNA biopsy cost of $75, the procedure resulted in a savings per case of $262 over the cost that would have occurred if all cases had had routine inpatient biopsy and $154 per case over the cost that would have occurred with routine outpatient biopsy of all cases. Our results indicate that FNA breast biopsy is a diagnostically accurate and economical triage procedure, even when followed by an excisional or frozen-section biopsy for confirmation. The use of FNA biopsy could be expanded to a greater number of medical centers and decrease the potential for false-positive diagnoses by combining FNA biopsy with frozen-section confirmation.     

Positive predictive value of fine needle aspiration cytology of breast lesions

The predictive value of fine needle aspiration (FNA) was assessed in 1,181 consecutive cases of breast lesions in which cytologic abnormalities were reported. The positive predictive value (PPV) of an FNA cytologic report of atypia, suspicious or positive was 0.49, 0.95 or 0.996, respectively. In the presence of a suspicious/positive report by both physical examination and mammography, the PPV of a cytologic report of suspicious was 0.99. The PPV was directly correlated with age, partly due to the incidence of fibroadenomas among younger patients; fibroadenomas were present in 53 of 146 cases with a false FNA report of atypia, in 10 of 19 cases with a false FNA report of suspicious and in 2 of 2 cases with a false FNA report of positive. Overall, 93 cases reported as benign by physical examination and mammography were biopsied on the basis of the FNA cytologic report; cancers were diagnosed in 33 of these 93 cases (6 cancers among 42 women less than 40 years old and 27 cancers among 51 women greater than 39 years old). The widespread use of FNA cytology to study breast lesions is thus recommended, without regard to patient age and even in the presence of clinically benign findings, since the increase in the rate of cancer detection is worth the excess of unnecessary biopsies. The predictive value of a positive report of FNA cytology, or even of a suspicious report in the presence of clinical suspicion, is so high that an intraoperative frozen section biopsy might be spared in such cases.     

Nucleolar morphometry in fine needle aspiration biopsies of the prostate.

OBJECTIVE: To find efficient morphometric nucleolar features for distinguishing different prostatic atypia groups in fine needle aspiration biopsies. STUDY DESIGN: A computerized interactive morphometry program was used to outline nucleoli of prostate cells. The samples were divided into three groups: group 1 (definitely benign [n = 10] and atypical but benign [n = 13]), group 2 (moderately atypical [n = 11] or highly suspicious [n = 13]) and group 3 (definitely malignant [n = 17]). RESULTS: The analysis revealed a difference in the number of nucleoli between definitely benign samples and other atypia groups but not between the latter. Nucleolar size features were best in distinguishing between atypia groups. The sample-associated mean size features were more powerful than cell group-associated size features. CONCLUSION: The sample-associated mean area, defined from cells selected by an experienced cytologist, if larger than 2 micron 2, was strongly associated with definitely malignant samples. The same was true for the largest nucleolar area if larger than 5.0 micron 2. Morphometric nucleolar size features appeared efficient in distinguishing between definitely malignant and other samples.     

Application of the probabilistic approach to reporting breast fine needle aspiration in males

OBJECTIVE: To apply the probabilistic approach to a series offine needle aspiration (FNA) samples of male breast lesions and determine the accuracy and reproducibility of this method of reporting in men. STUDY DESIGN: All male breast surgical specimens with a preoperative breast FNA at our institution from 1994 to 2005 were identified. The FNAs were blindly reviewed by 2 groups of observers and classified in 1 of 5 categories using published reporting guidelines: positive, suspicious, atypical, proliferative without atypia and unremarkable. The histologic and cytologic diagnoses were correlated. The interobserver variation was determined. RESULTS: A total of 138 FNAs were performed for 123 male patients. Histologic correlation was available for 23 satisfactory FNAs. A total of 11 of 11 carcinomas (100%) were classified as positive, suspicious or atypical. Of 12 benign masses, 11 (91.6%) were classified as proliferative without atypia or unremarkable. One case of gynecomastia was classified as atypical by 1 observer but deemed not atypical with consensus review. The kappa statistic for benign and atypical/suspicious/malignant categories was 0.90. CONCLUSION: Based on this series, the probabilistic approach can be applied to the reporting of FNAs of male breast lesions. Gynecomastia may result in an atypical cytologic diagnosis.     

Choriocarcinoma metastatic to the breast diagnosed by fine needle aspiration.

Fine needle aspiration (FNA) was used to study nodules in the left breast of a patient with a previous history of uterine choriocarcinoma. The FNA smears contained numerous malignant mononucleated cells and multinucleated giant cells. The cytologic diagnosis was metastatic choriocarcinoma, which was confirmed by histologic study of excised tissue. That diagnosis would have been difficult to make cytologically if the previous history had not been known; the differential diagnosis of multinucleated giant cells in an aspirate from a breast mass is discussed.     

Morphologic spectrum of hepatocellular carcinoma in fine needle aspiration biopsies

The light microscopic features of fine needle aspiration smears from 52 primary hepatocellular carcinomas were reviewed. Cytologic grading of these tumors, which indicated three grade I, 29 grade II and 20 grade III carcinomas, was compatible with grading done by histologic examination. In addition to the general cellular characteristics, other cytologic features observed in the smears included bile (48% of the cases), large cytoplasmic vacuoles (23%), small cytoplasmic vacuoles (46%), eosinophilic cytoplasmic inclusions (8%), basophilic cytoplasmic inclusions (48%) and intranuclear cytoplasmic inclusions (71%). The significance of these features is briefly discussed.     

Routine audit of breast fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology specimens and aspirator inadequate rates

Routine audit of breast fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology specimens and aspirator inadequate rates In an attempt to improve the quality of the breast FNA specimens we instigated a continuing audit of this procedure in this hospital. All FNAs since 1990 have had the following recorded: mode of aspiration, e.g. freehand or image guided, patient presentation (screening or symptomatic), patient diagnostic category, cytological diagnosis and final histological diagnosis. Aspirator performance was assessed by means of the inadequate aspiration rate (IR) of FNAs performed on patients with a final diagnosis of cancer (FDC) and diagnostic category A patients (clinically or radiologically malignant lesions). An ongoing annual review of the performance of all the aspirators was undertaken, all of whom received individual feedback. Counselling and further training were offered where indicated by poor performance. Over the period 1990–1995 a total of 13 537 FNAs were performed by 27 aspirators. The IR on category A and FDC cases over this period was 16.0% and 18.1%. The best performance achieved by an aspirator in a calendar year was an IR of 3.6% with no inadequate specimens in either FDC or category A lesions, and the best performance over the entire period was an average IR of 11.75% and 14.25% for FDC and category A groups, respectively. The overall IR on category A patients ranged from 15.9% to 23.8% and on FDC cases from 12.2% to 21.7%. There was a significant improvement in individual junior aspirator performance when their first year was compared with their last year on the unit. In some cases a deterioration in intra-aspirator performance was observed, from an IR of 6% to 33%. The overall IR rate of the unit remained stable for FDC patients, 15.5% in 1990 compared with 15.1% in 1995. This appeared to be largely due to a high proportion of the aspirations being performed by experienced personnel with consistent IRs. However, concealed within the overall rate there were some poor performers who benefited from counselling and/or further training. These results indicate an important role for audit in identifying poor aspirators who benefit from targeted training and advice, thereby improving the quality of FNA specimens, and ultimately patient care.     

Genotypic analysis of DNA isolated from fine needle aspiration biopsies

DNA was isolated from 20 fine needle aspiration (FNA) biopsies from lymphomas, hyperplastic lymph nodes and nonlymphoid malignant tumors. Small aliquots (0.2 microgram to 2.0 micrograms) of DNA from each sample were digested to completion with restriction endonuclease Eco RI and/or Bam HI and electrophoresed in 0.8% agarose minigels. DNA was transferred to a nylon filter after brief treatment in HCl and subsequent denaturation and neutralization. Filters were hybridized to radiolabeled JH, C kappa, TCR beta or bcl-2 probes to determine if these genes were in germline or rearranged configurations in each of the samples. It was possible to demonstrate rearrangement of at least one immunoglobulin gene in each of the samples diagnosed as lymphoma, while all samples derived from hyperplastic lymph nodes and nonlymphoid malignant tumors exhibited a germline pattern for each probe tested. Thus, FNA biopsies can provide suitable and sufficient DNA for genotypic analysis using molecular probes that detect gene rearrangement.     

Stereotaxic fine needle aspiration cytology of clinically occult malignant and premalignant breast lesions

Stereotaxic fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology was used to study clinically occult (nonpalpable) breast lesions in 114 consecutive patients with mammographically suspicious findings prior to excisional biopsy. The aspirate contained insufficient material for cytologic evaluation in 15 cases (13.2%), which were histologically diagnosed as benign (7 cases), atypical hyperplasia (7 cases) or carcinoma in situ (1 case). The cytologic findings indicated a benign lesion in 77 cases (67.5%), which were histologically diagnosed as benign (71 cases) or atypical ductal hyperplasia (6 cases). The cytologic sample showed atypia in eight cases (7.0%), which were histologically diagnosed as severe atypical ductal hyperplasia (three cases), carcinoma in situ (one case) or proliferative fibrocystic disease (four cases). In the eight cases (7.0%) cytologically interpreted as probably malignant, histology confirmed six invasive carcinomas, one carcinoma in situ and one fibrocystic disease. Of six cases (4.4%) cytologically reported as malignant, five were histologically diagnosed as invasive carcinoma and one as carcinoma in situ. Overall, stereotaxic FNA cytology reported as malignant or probably malignant 14 of the 15 cases with a histologic confirmation of malignancy, for a sensitivity of 93.3%. Cytology correctly identified 78 of the 83 histologically negative cases, for a specificity of 94.0%. The 16 cases histologically diagnosed as ductal hyperplasia, which carries a high risk for subsequent malignancy, were studied in detail in an effort to define histologic and cytologic criteria for this entity. Using selected histologic criteria, 11 of these cases were graded as showing mild-to-moderate atypical hyperplasia and 5 as showing severe atypical hyperplasia. Three of the latter cases were similarly identified by an analogous cytologic grading; the other two cases had insufficient cytologic samples. The total results in this series of 114 cases support the use of stereotaxic FNA cytology in the diagnosis of these nonpalpable breast lesions, examples of which are illustrated. In particular, it may help to raise the low specificity yielded by mammography alone, which would represent a significant advance for the patient in terms of the accuracy, expediency and reduced cost of diagnosing these lesions.     

Paratesticular adenomatoid tumors. The cytologic presentation in fine needle aspiration biopsies

Adenomatoid tumors are the most common tumors of male paratesticular tissues (epididymis, tunica or spermatic cord) and have also been described in females (uterus, fallopian tube, ovary and paraovarian tissues); fine needle aspiration (FNA) of masses in these locations is increasingly utilized as an alternative to surgical exploration in order to establish a tissue diagnosis. This paper describes the FNA cytodiagnosis of seven cases of paratesticular adenomatoid tumors. The main cytologic criteria included epithelioid sheets and multilayered clusters of monotonous cells with round or ovoid, eccentric nuclei containing small, central nucleoli. Paranuclear clearing with a pink coloration (Giemsa stain) or a clear vacuolelike area (Papanicolaou stain) and abundant cellularity with a background of naked nuclei and stromal fragments were noted. The clinical presentation and clinicohistologic follow-up of these seven cases is also described in detail. A discussion of the differential diagnosis and the expected FNA findings is provided.     

Cytomorphometry as quality control for fine needle aspiration. A study in 321 breast lesions

Material collected by fine needle aspiration (FNA) in 321 histologically examined primary breast lesions of previously untreated patients was analyzed by morphometry. The mean nuclear area (MNA) and its standard deviation (SD) were calculated for 50 cells in each case. Four subclasses were defined on the basis of the MNA and SD: benign (less than 10% probability of malignancy), doubtful benign (10% to 49%), doubtful malignant (50% to 90%) and malignant (greater than 90% probability of malignancy). FNA samples showing signs of acute inflammation or only apocrine metaplastic cells were not suitable for analysis by this morphometric method and were excluded. In 274 (85.4%) of the cases, the measurements allowed a definite morphometric conclusion, with predictive values of 99.5% and 100% for the histologically malignant and benign aspirates, respectively. The probability of malignancy in the doubtful malignant group was almost 86%. The morphometric method described is quick, easy to perform and well suited for use in routine daily practice; furthermore, it does not require expensive equipment. The ease of the technique and its high predictive value make this method appropriate for use as a quality control procedure in FNA cytology.