INTERACTING EFFECTS OF LIGHT AND NUTRIENT LIMITATION ON THE GROWTH RATE OF SYNECHOCOCCUS LINEARIS (CYANOPHYCEAE)1

The blue-green alga Synechococcus linearis (Naeg.) Kom. was grown in P- and N-limited chemostats over a range of potentially limiting irradiances in order to determine the combined effects of light and nutrient limitation on some aspects of the composition and metabolism of this alga. Over a narrow range of low irradiances, simultaneous limitation of growth rate by light and either N or P was shown. This simultaneous limitation of growth rate by a nutrient and a physical factor can be explained by the ability of an increased supply of one to compensate in part for a decreased supply of the other. At all irradiances, the internal concentration of the limiting nutrient increased with increasing dilution rate, and the results could be fitted to the Droop relationship. With decreasing irradiance, the internal concentration of the limiting nutrient increased. There appeared to be little or no effect of light on the minimum internal concentration of P but that of N increased with decreasing light. Both chlorophyll a and biliprotein per unit particulate C increased with increasing dilution rate and decreasing irradiance. The critical N/P ratio increased with decreasing light as the N requirement of N-limited cells increased faster than did the P requirement of P-limited cells. The composition of exponentially growing cells in complete medium varied much less with light. Neither dilution rate nor irradiance during growth had a great effect on saturated rates of P or N uptake or alkaline phosphatase activity. Calculated assimilation ratios increased with light and dilution rate. The role of the flexibility of nutrient composition in adaptation to adverse conditions and the implications of the results for the use of physiological indicators of nutrient status are discussed.     

INTERACTION OF NITROGEN FIXATION AND PHOSPHORUS LIMITATION IN APHANIZOMENON FLOS-AQUAE (CYANOPHYCEAE)1

The effect of simultaneous nitrogen fixation and phosphorus limitation on the physiological adaptation and growth performance of Aphanizomenon flos-aquae (L.) Ralfs PCC 7905 was studied in continuous culture. In the absence of ammonia, N₂ fixation occurred and the maximum growth rate (as determined in diluted batch cultures) was lower. However, no distinction could be made between the steady-state N uptake rates (based on cellular N contents) of N₂-fixing cells and cells grown with ammonia. At the higher dilution rates, the residual P concentration increased with increasing dilution rate, more so under N₂-fixing conditions, compared to the cultures grown in the presence of ammonia. More generally, the yield of biomass per consumed P, as the biomass concentration itself, decreased with increasing dilution rate, and both were lower under N₂-fixing conditions. The restricted biomass production under N₂-fixing conditions suggests that reduction of N loading may benefit lake restoration projects. The influence of N₂-fixation on the severity of P limitation is discussed in terms of metabolic control analysis. From the increase of the residual P concentration on switching from ammonium to N₂-fixing conditions, it is deduced that under N₂-fixing and P-limited conditions, control of growth is shared by N and P metabolism.     

Diel variation of the cellular carbon to nitrogen ratio of Chlorella autotrophica (Chlorophyta) growing in phosphorus‐ and nitrogen‐limited continuous cultures

We investigated the relationship between daily growth rates and diel variation of carbon (C) metabolism and C to nitrogen (N) ratio under P‐ and N‐limitation in the green algae Chlorella autotrophica. To do this, continuous cultures of C. autotrophica were maintained in a cyclostat culture system under 14:10 light:dark cycle over a series of P‐ and N‐limited growth rates. Cell abundance, together with cell size, as reflected by side scatter signal from flow cytometric analysis demonstrated a synchronized diel pattern with cell division occurring at night. Under either type of nutrient limitation, the cellular C:N ratio increased through the light period and decreased through the dark period over all growth rates, indicating a higher diel variation of C metabolism than that of N. Daily average cellular C:N ratios were higher at lower dilution rates under both types of nutrient limitation but cell enlargement was only observed at lower dilution rates under P‐limitation. Carbon specific growth rates during the dark period positively correlated with cellular daily growth rates (dilution rates), with net loss of C during night at the lowest growth rates under N‐limitation. Under P‐limitation, dark C specific growth rates were close to zero at low dilution rates but also exhibited an increasing trend at high dilution rates. In general, diel variations of cellular C:N were low when dark C specific growth rates were high. This result indicated that the fast growing cells performed dark C assimilation at high rates, hence diminished the uncoupling of C and N metabolism at night.     

Cell yields and fermentation responses of a <Emphasis Type="Italic">Salmonella</Emphasis> Typhimurium poultry isolate at different dilution rates in an anaerobic steady state continuous culture

The objectives of these studies were to determine cell yield and fermentation responses of a Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium poultry isolate using various dilution rates in steady state continuous culture incubations. S. enterica Typhimurium cells were propagated in continuous cultures with a total volume of 0.50 l of Luria Bertani medium containing 0.1% glucose. Dilution rates from 0.0125 to 1.44/h were used. Cell protein concentration generally increased linearly with increased dilution rate up to a rate of 0.54/h and declined at the higher dilution rates. Glucose consumption gave a similar pattern to cell protein concentration by declining at the three highest dilution rates. Short chain fatty acid production was inconsistently influenced by dilution rate. Acetate, the most predominant fatty acid produced, declined at the higher dilution rates, as did propionate. Ammonia production remained stable at the lowest dilution rates, but increased significantly at a dilution rates above 0.27/h.     

Effect of dilution rate on β-glucosidase secretion and cell wall metabolism in Trichoderma aureoviride cultivated in a continuous air lift fermenter

Summary Trichoderma aureoviride was grown in continuous culture under glucose limitation in an airlift fermenter at dilution rates (D) varying between 0.06–0.21 h^–1. Autoradiography showed a high incorporation of ³H-GlcNAc into hyphal tips under these conditions, indicating that the hyphae were not suffering from physical stress.Under these conditions -glucosidase activity increased with decreasing growth rate and also the ratio of extracellular to cell wall bound -glucosidase activity increased indicating that the release of -glucosidase from the cell walls in increased at lower dilution rates.The composition of the cell wall varied with the dilution rate; glucans and chitin were lower at low dilution rates, whereas the cell wall protein, galactosamine, galactose and mannose content was increased, indicating changes in the rigidity of the cell wall. No changes seemed to occur in the pore sizes of wall, as measured by the molecular weight of the proteins released into the culture fluid.Cell walls contained bound -1.3-glucanase, -glucanase, -mannase, N-acetyl-glucosaminidase and N-acetyl-galactosaminidase activities, all of which increased with decreasing dilution rate. In vitro autolysis could be demonstrated to be higher with cell walls from low dilution rates.The results show several pronounced changes in cell wall metabolism which accompany increased release of -glucosidase from the cell walls, among which the increased activities of cell wall lytic enzymes are most likely responsible for increased -glucosidase release.     

黄土丘陵区刺槐人工林林龄增加土壤微环境变化对凋落物分解的影响

凋落物所处的土壤微环境是影响其分解的关键因素之一,然而在黄土高原广泛栽植的刺槐人工林中,土壤微环境随林龄增加如何改变、其对凋落物分解过程的影响趋势尚不清楚。为明确上述问题,以油松凋落物(典型的难分解凋落物)和白三叶凋落物(易分解)为对象,分别在林龄为10、20、33 a和43 a的刺槐林地土壤表面进行为期592 d的模拟分解试验,检测凋落物分解特征以及地表土壤理化生物学性质随林龄增加的变化趋势,并分析凋落物分解速率与土壤微环境指标间的关系。结果表明:(1)随林龄增加,油松凋落物的分解速率呈先小幅降低后提高的趋势,白三叶凋落物的分解速率持续提高(P<0.05);(2)总体而言,随林龄增加林地表层土壤温度呈先降后增趋势,土壤湿度、有效磷含量和pH持续降低,而速效氮含量持续提高(P<0.05);(3)林龄增加显著改变了林地土壤微生物群落结构,特别是在各分解时间点时均导致真菌属的明显演替现象。土壤中9种凋落物分解酶的总酶活性和木质纤维素酶活性均在分解第108天时随林龄增加呈先降后增趋势,而在分解第389天和第592天时持续提高(P<0.05)。(4)油松凋落物分解速率仅与土壤总酶活性、真菌群落结构和铵态氮含量呈显著正相关,白三叶凋落物分解速率则与总酶和木质纤维素酶活性、细菌和真菌群落结构、温度和铵态氮含量显著正相关,而与土壤湿度和pH显著负相关(P<0.05)。综上所述,刺槐林龄增加引起的土壤理、化和生物微环境变化总体倾向于加速凋落物的分解过程。     

Compositional profiles of Rhodosporidium toruloides cells under nutrient limitation

Lipid production by the red yeast Rhodosporidium toruloides was explored under nutrient limitation. To determine the compositional profiles of R. toruloides cells, samples were prepared using a continuous cultivation process under nutrient limitation and analyzed via several methods, including Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy and elemental analysis. Under nitrogen limitation, as the dilution rate increased, the cellular lipid content decreased but the carbohydrate and protein contents increased. Under carbon limitation, the cellular lipid, protein, and carbohydrate contents remained relatively constant at the different dilution rates. Moreover, the cellular elemental composition was essentially identical under nitrogen and carbon limitation at a high dilution rate of 0.20 h⁻¹. We also analyzed the consumed carbon to nitrogen (C/N) under different nutrition conditions. The results indicated that the consumed C/N had a major influence on cell metabolism and product formation, which contributed to our understanding of the physiological characteristics of R. toruloides.

     

Lipid formation by Cryptococcus albidus in nitrogen-limited and in carbon-limited chemostat cultures

Summary Cryptococcus albidus var. Albidus CBS 4517 was grown in nitrogen-limited and in carbon-limited chemostat cultures. The effect of growth rate and limiting nutrient on lipid accumulation and fatty acid composition was investigated.The maximum lipid content in the biomass was, in both cultivation systems, observed at the lowest dilution rate (growth rate) tested. At this dilution rate, D=0.31 h^-1, cells from the nitrogen-limited culture contained 41% (w/w) lipid and cells from the carbon-limited culture 37%. These results indicate the ability of C. albidus, unlike other oleaginous yeasts, to accumulate lipid also in carbon-limited chemostats.The yield of lipid from carbon source was about the same at D=0.031 h^-1 in nitrogen-limited (Y _L/S=0.16 g/g) as in carbon-limited (Y _L/S=0.17 g/g) cultures and decreased with increasing growth rates. In the nitrogen-limited culture, the lipid productivity was about constant at low growth rates (0.031–0.056 h^-1) and a slight decrease was observed at D=0.08 h^-1, while the specific lipid productivity, q _L, increased to 27.5 mg/g per hour. In the carbon-limited culture, however, lipid productivity increased with increasing growth rates and reached its maximum value near _max, whereas q _L was about constant at 20 mg/g per hour.The fatty acid composition was influenced by the specific growth rate in nitrogen-limited as well as in carbon-limited cultures, although the changes were more pronounced during carbonlimitation. A decrease in the degree of unsaturation (/mole) was also observed with increasing lipid content in the cells.     

Effects of medium composition and nutrient limitation on loss of the recombinant plasmid pLG669-z and β -galactosidase expression by Saccharomyces cerevisiae

The effects of medium composition, nutrient limitation and dilution rate on the loss of the recombinant plasmid pLG669-z and plasmid-borne β -galactosidase expression were studied in batch and chemostat cultures of Saccharomyces cerevisiae strain CGpLG. The difference in growth rates between plasmid-free and plasmid-containing cells (Δμ) and the rate of segregation (R) were determined and some common factors resulting from the effect of medium composition on plasmid loss were identified. Glucose-limited chemostat cultures of CGpLG grown on defined medium were more stable at higher dilution rates and exhibited Δμ -dominated plasmid loss kinetics. Similar cultures grown on complex medium were more stable at lower dilution rates and exhibited R-dominated plasmid loss kinetics. Overall plasmid stability was greatest in phosphate-limited chemostat cultures grown on defined medium and was least stable in magnesium-limited cultures grown on defined medium. Δμ decreased and R increased with increased dilution rate, irrespective of medium composition. Increased plasmid loss rates at high or low dilution rates would appear to be characteristic of loss kinetics dominated by R or Δμ, respectively. Growth of glucose-limited chemostat cultures on complex medium decreased Δμ values but increased R values, in comparison to those cultures grown on defined medium. Any increased stability that a complex medium-induced reduction of Δμ may have conferred was counteracted by an increased R value. Increased β-galactosidase productivity was correlated with increased plasmid stability only in glucose-limited chemostat cultures grown on defined medium and not in those grown on complex medium. Previous studies have yielded contrasting responses with regard to the effect of dilution rate on recombinant plasmid loss from S. cerevisiae. Our findings can account for these differences and may be generally valid for the stability of similar yeast plasmid constructs. This information would facilitate the design of bioprocesses, where recombinant plasmid instability results in reduced culture productivity. Received 08 July 1996/ Accepted in revised form 14 January 1997     

The biochemical composition and calorific content of a rotifer and its algal food: comparison of a two stage chemostat and batch culture

It is often assumed that the use of a two-stage chemostat yields algal food with a well-defined nutritional composition that can maintain herbivores in a steady state of growth. In this study I investigated two bacteriafree culture techniques, continuous flow chemostats and batch cultures, to determine whether the biochemical composition of the rotifer Encentrum linnhei differed in the two cultures. Changes in the biochemical composition and calorific content of the algal food were also examined. In the rotifer reaction vessel only the lipid content of the algal food increased significantly with dilution rates, while significant decreases in protein and carbohydrates were detected at increasing algal densities. A different pattern was observed in the response of the unused algal cells to variables such as dilution, algal input and algal densities in the sump of the rotifer chemostat. In the chemostat the biochemical composition of the rotifers varied as expected with dilution rates, algal input and food availability but significant differences were found in the biochemical composition of the animals growing in the reaction vessel and those collected from the sump. In contrast, the biochemical content of batch-grown E. linnhei varied with time in a way that depended upon food availability and also on the biochemical state of the algal food. However, at the end of the exponential phase of growth, when maximum densities had been achieved, batch-grown rotifers were more biochemically nutritious than chemostat-grown animals in their steady-state phase.     

Exopolysaccharide and extracellular metabolite production by Lactobacillus delbrueckii subsp. bulgaricus, grown on lactose in continuous culture

Lactobacillus delbrueckii subsp. bulgaricus NCFB 2483, when grown on lactose in continuous culture, showed increasing specific yields and volumetric productivities of exopolysaccharide (EPS) with increasing dilution rate. Specific and volumetric productivities of lactate and galactose, as extracellular metabolites, increased in response to the incremental changes in the dilution rate up to 0.4 h^–1. Elevated Y_p/s values determined for EPS (0.025 g EPSg lactose^–1) at the dilution rates of 0.3 h^–1–0.4 h^–1, relative to those determined at lower dilution rates, suggest a diversion of carbon flux towards EPS being associated with the higher rates of growth.     

The DNA,RNA and protein composition of the cyanobacterium Anacystis nidulans grown in light- and carbon dioxide-limited chemostats

The DNA, RNA and protein content of the cyanobacterium Anacystis nidulans was determined in light-limited and carbon dioxide-limited chemostat cultures over the dilution rate range, D=0.02 h^-1 to 0.19 h^-1. The macromolecular contents as a percentage of the dry weight and on a per cell basis varied significantly as a function of organism growth rate and the nature of the growth conditions. For both limitations the RNA content per cell increased [20–55 fg RNA (cell)^-1] with increasing dilution rate and also showed an increase as a percentage of the dry weight. The DNA content as a percentage of the dry weight showed a 2-fold decrease with increasing dilution rate over the range examined. On a per cell basis DNA reached a peak at D=0.1 h^-1 [4.5 fg DNA (cell)^-1] for light-limited organisms and at D=0.08 h^-1 [8.0 fg DNA (cell)^-1] for carbon dioxide-limited organisms. The q _RNA increased with increasing dilution rates over the complete growth rate range examined whilst q _DNA reached a maximum at D=0.09 to 0.10 h^-1. The protein content as a percentage of the dry weight was greater in CO₂-limited organisms than light-limited organisms but in both cultures declined as the dilution rate was increased above D=0.10 h^-1.     

CHARACTERISTICS OF PHOSPHORUS LIMITATION IN CHLAMYDOMONAS REINHARDTH (CHLOROPHYCEAE) AND ITS PALMELLOIDS1

Chlamydomonas reinhardtii Dang, was grown in a chemostat culture under phosphate limitation. The steady state concentration of phosphate was below the detection limit (< 1 μg P/L) in all runs. The cellular content of phosphorus (Q_p), polyphosphate (Q_pp) and chlorophyll a increased with increasing dilution rate, and the growth rate of the alga was described by Q_p as well as Q_pp in the Droop model. The ratio Q_pp/Q_p and the activity of alkaline phosphatase were maximal at high and low growth rates, respectively. Palmelloids of Chlamydomonas were found at high dilution rates (D > 0.12 h^?1) and became attached to the wall of the culture vessel. They differed from the vegetative stage in both chemical composition and growth rate. Their contents of phosphorus and chlorophyll a were low, as in the vegetative cells, which grew at a low growth rate, whereas the ration Q_pp/Q_p and the activity of alkaline phosphatase were comparable with those of fast growing vegetative cells. The growth rate of the palmelloids was 0.03 h^?1 whereas maximum growth rate (μ_m) for the vegetative cells was 0.21 h^?1.     

Metabolomic markers and physiological adaptations for high phosphate utilization efficiency in rice

Utilizing phosphate more efficiently is crucial for sustainable crop production. Highly efficient rice (Oryza sativa) cultivars have been identified and this study aims to identify metabolic markers associated with P utilization efficiency (PUE). P deficiency generally reduced leaf P concentrations and CO₂ assimilation rates but efficient cultivars were reducing leaf P concentrations further than inefficient ones while maintaining similar CO₂ assimilation rates. Adaptive changes in carbon metabolism were detected but equally in efficient and inefficient cultivar groups. Groups furthermore did not differ with respect to partial substitutions of phospholipids by sulfo- and galactolipids. Metabolites significantly more abundant in the efficient group, such as sinapate, benzoate and glucoronate, were related to antioxidant defence and may help alleviating oxidative stress caused by P deficiency. Sugar alcohols ribitol and threitol were another marker metabolite for higher phosphate efficiency as were several amino acids, especially threonine. Since these metabolites are not known to be associated with P deficiency, they may provide novel clues for the selection of more P efficient genotypes. In conclusion, metabolite signatures detected here were not related to phosphate metabolism but rather helped P efficient lines to keep vital processes functional under the adverse conditions of P starvation.     

Growth Rate of the Microalga Tetraselmis suecica Changes the Biochemical Composition of Artemia Species

The impact of different microalgal semicontinuous cultures on growth and biochemical composition in the next link of the food chain was tested using the filter feeder Artemia species as a model. The marine microalga Tetraselmis suecica was cultured semicontinuously with renewal rates between 10% and 50% and used to feed Artemia. Microalgal cultures maintained with a low renewal rate that had biochemical composition similar to that of the stationary-phase cultures commonly used in aquaculture produced poor growth and survival and low food-conversion efficiency compared to cultures maintained with a high renewal rate. Changes in the renewal rate in microalgal cultures also resulted in important changes in the gross biochemical composition of the filter feeder. The gross biochemical composition of the Artemia resembled that of the microalgae used as food except for total lipid content. The percentage of protein in the organic fraction of Artemia increased from 45% to 65% of the organic weight with increasing renewal rates in the microalgal cultures, while the carbohydrate percentage decreased under the same conditions. Higher renewal rates resulted in higher lipid percentages in the microalga, but in Artemia the percentage of lipids decreased from 19% of the organic weight with a renewal rate of 10%, to 13% with a renewal rate of 50%. The percentage of all polyunsaturated fatty acids in Artemia, including 20:5n-3, increased slightly with increasing renewal rates in the microalgal cultures. Results emphasize the importance of controlling microalgal nutritional value for the success of aquaculture food chains in which filter feeders are involved. Received October 15, 2000; accepted December 29, 2000.     

Kinetic studies of constitutive human granulocyte-macrophage colony stimulating factor (hGM-CSF) expression in continuous culture of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Pichia pastoris</Emphasis>

Extracellular human granulocyte-macrophage colony stimulating factor (hGM-CSF) expression was studied under the control of the GAP promoter in recombinant Pichia pastoris in a series of continuous culture runs (dilution rates from 0.025 to 0.2 h⁻¹). The inlet feed concentration was also varied and the steady state biomass concentration increased proportionally demonstrating efficient substrate utilization and constancy of the biomass yield coefficient (Y_x/s) for a given dilution rate. The specific product formation rate (q_P) showed a strong correlation with dilution rates demonstrating growth associated product formation of hGM-CSF. The volumetric product concentration achieved at the highest feed concentration (4×) and a dilution rate of 0.2 h⁻¹ was 82 mg l⁻¹ which was 5-fold higher compared to the continuous culture run with 1× feed concentration at the lowest dilution rate thus translating to a 40 fold increase in the volumetric productivity. The specific product yield (Y_P/X) increased slightly from 2 to 2.5 mg g⁻¹, with increasing dilution rates, while it remained fairly invariant, for all feed concentrations demonstrating negligible product degradation or feed back inhibition. The robust nature of this expression system would make it easily amenable to scale up for industrial production.     

Metabolic and kinetic studies of hybridomas in exponentially fed-batch cultures using T-flasks

Exponentially fed-batch cultures (EFBC) of a murine hybridoma in T-flasks were explored as a simple alternative experimental tool to chemostats for the study of metabolism, growth and monoclonal antibody (MAb) production kinetics. EFBC were operated in the variable volume mode using an exponentially increasing and predetermined stepwise feeding profile of fresh complete medium. The dynamic and steady-state behaviors of the EFBC coincided with those reported for chemostats at dilution rates below the maximum growth rate. In particular, steady-state for growth rate and concentration of viable cells, glucose, and lactate was attained at different dilution rates between 0.005 and 0.05 h^–1. For such a range, the glucose and lactate metabolic quotients and the steady-state glucose concentration increased, whereas total MAb, volumetric, and specific MAb production rates decreased 65-, 6-, and 3-fold, respectively, with increasing dilution rates. The lactate from glucose yield remained relatively constant for dilution rates up to 0.03 h^–1, where it started to decrease. In contrast, viability remained above 80% at high dilution rates but rapidly decreased at dilution rates below 0.02 h^–1. No true washout occurred during operation above the maximum growth, as concluded from the constant viable cell number. However, growth rate decreased to as low as 0.01 h^–1, suggesting the requirement of a minimum cell density, and concomitant autocrine growth factors, for growth. Chemostat operation drawbacks were avoided by EFBC in T-flasks. Namely, simple and stable operation was obtained at dilution rates ranging from very low to above the maximum growth rate. Furthermore, simultaneous operation of multiple experiments in reduced size was possible, minimizing start-up time, media and equipment costs.Abbreviations EFBC exponentially-fed batch culture - CSC continuous suspended culture - MAb monoclonal antibody - D dilution rate - q _i metabolic quotient or specific rate of consumption or production of i     

Continuous cultivation of Trichoderma viride on cellulose

Using ball milled cellulose as the only carbon source Trichoderma viride was grown in a continuous flow culture at pH = 5.0 and T = 30°C. Steady-state values for cell protein, cellulose, and cellulase for different substrate concentrations (4–11 g/liter) and dilution rates (0.033–0.080 hr^?1) were obtained. Under steady-state conditions, 50–75% of the cellulose was consumed indicating a critical dilution rate on 0.17 hr^?1. Cellulase activity (U/ml) in the fermentation broth increased slightly with increasing substrate concentration and decreased with increasing dilution rate, while the specific cellulase productivity (U/mg cell protein·hr) was fairly independent of the dilution rate, with a maximum around D = 0.05 hr^?1. Following step changes in substrate concentration and dilution rate, new steady-state values were reached after three to five residence times (cell protein and cellulose) and four to six residence times (celullase activity).     

Growth and survival ofAzospirillum brasilense andArthrobacter giacomelloi in binary continuous culture

Summary Azospirillum brasilense andArthrobacter giacomelloi were grown in single and mixed succinate-limited continuous cultures at a partial oxygen pressure of 0.01atm. Growth, viability and survival during nutrient starvation were examined at various dilution rates. At D=0.05 h^–1, K_s values for succinate consumed were calculated.Arthrobacter giacomelloi viability was inversely related to dilution rate whereasAzo. brasilense was directly related. Slightly lower values of viability were obtained in mixed culture, but the ratio between the microorganisms was constant. The survival ofArth. giacomelloi in single culture decreased with increasing growth rate while survival ofAzo. brasilense was directly related to dilution rate. Acetylene reduction activity was generally very low in both single and mixed cultures. Respiration rate was also determined and the mixed culture showed an oxygen uptake rate higher than that of single cultures.Research work supported by CNR, Italy. Special grant I.P.R.A. Sub-project 1. Paper N. 317.