Current technologies to identify protein kinase substrates in high throughput

Since the discovery of protein phosphorylation as an important modulator of many cellular processes, the involvement of protein kinases in diseases, such as cancer, diabetes, cardiovascular diseases, and central nervous system pathologies, has been extensively documented. Our understanding of many disease pathologies at the molecular level, therefore, requires the comprehensive identification of substrates targeted by protein kinases. In this review, we focus on recent techniques for kinase substrate identification in high throughput, in particular on genetic and proteomic approaches. Each method with its inherent advantages and limitations is discussed.     

A phospho-proteomic screen identifies substrates of the checkpoint kinase Chk1

Background  

The cell-cycle checkpoint kinase Chk1 is essential in mammalian cells due to its roles in controlling processes such as DNA replication, mitosis and DNA-damage responses. Despite its paramount importance, how Chk1 controls these functions remains unclear, mainly because very few Chk1 substrates have hitherto been identified.     

A high throughput screen to identify substrates for the ubiquitin ligase Rsp5

Ubiquitin-protein ligases (E3s) are implicated in various human disorders and are attractive targets for therapeutic intervention. Although most cellular proteins are ubiquitinated, ubiquitination cannot be linked directly to a specific E3 for a large fraction of these proteins, and the substrates of most E3 enzymes are unknown. We have developed a luminescent assay to detect ubiquitination in vitro, which is more quantitative, effective, and sensitive than conventional ubiquitination assays. By taking advantage of the abundance of purified proteins made available by genomic efforts, we screened hundreds of purified yeast proteins for ubiquitination, and we identified previously reported and novel substrates of the yeast E3 ligase Rsp5. The relevance of these substrates was confirmed in vivo by showing that a number of them interact genetically with Rsp5, and some were ubiquitinated by Rsp5 in vivo. The combination of this sensitive assay and the availability of purified substrates will enable the identification of substrates for any purified E3 enzyme.     

Use of a novel method to find substrates of protein kinase C delta identifies M2 pyruvate kinase

Protein kinase C (PKC) family members have been implicated in numerous cellular processes. However, identifying the substrates of each PKC isozyme remains a challenge. Here, we describe a method using two-dimensional (2D) isoelectric focusing gel electrophoresis to identify substrates of delta PKC (deltaPKC) in MCF-7 breast carcinoma cells. We show that M2 pyruvate kinase is a substrate of deltaPKC, and further characterize the interaction between M2 pyruvate kinase and deltaPKC in MCF-7 cells by immunoprecipitation. deltaPKC activation in vitro or in cells did not appear to alter the enzyme activity or polymerization of M2 pyruvate kinase.     

A genetic screen identifies novel non-compatible loxP sites

The ability of the Cre/lox system to make precise genomic modifications is a tremendous accomplishment. However, recombination between cis-linked heterospecific lox sites limits the use of Cre- mediated exchange of DNA to systems where genetic selection can be applied. To circumvent this problem we carried out a genetic screen designed to identify novel mutant spacer-containing lox sites displaying enhanced incompatibility with the canonical loxP site. One of the mutant sites recovered appears to be completely stable in HEK293 cells constitutively expressing Cre recombinase and supports recombinase-mediated cassette exchange (RMCE) in bacteria and mammalian cell culture. By preventing undesirable recombination, these novel lox sites could improve the efficiency of in vivo gene transfer.     

A mutagenesis-based screen to rapidly identify phosphorylation sites in mitogen-activated protein kinase substrates

Electroporation is an important approach for genetic engineering experiments allowing for introduction of foreign DNA in a selected host. Here, we describe for the first time the use of glycine betaine as an osmoprotectant for electroporation of gram-positive bacteria Bacillus subtilis. High electroporation efficiency (up to 5×10(5) cfu/μg) was obtained using 7.5% glycine betaine. The new method improved the transformation efficiency of B. subtilis with linear integrative DNA nearly 700-fold compared with existing Bacillus transformation techniques.     

A high throughput screen identifies chemical modulators of the laminin-induced clustering of dystroglycan and aquaporin-4 in primary astrocytes

Background

Aquaporin-4 (AQP4) constitutes the principal water channel in the brain and is clusteredat the perivascular astrocyte endfeet. This specific distribution of AQP4 plays a major role in maintaining water homeostasis in the brain. A growing body of evidence points to a role ofthe dystroglycan complex and its interaction with perivascular laminin in the clusteringof AQP4 atperivascular astrocyte endfeet. Indeed, mice lacking components of this complex or in which laminin-dystroglycan interaction is disrupted show a delayed onset of brain edema due to a redistribution of AQP4 away from astrocyte endfeet. It is therefore important to identify inhibitory drugs of laminin-dependent AQP4 clustering which may prevent or reduce brain edema.

Methodolgy/Principal Findings

In the present study we used primary rat astrocyte cultures toscreen a library of >3,500 chemicals and identified 6 drugs that inhibit the laminin-induced clustering of dystroglycan and AQP4. Detailed analysis of the inhibitory drug, chloranil, revealed that its inhibition of the clustering is due to the metalloproteinase-2-mediated ß-dystroglycan shedding and subsequent loss of laminin interaction with dystroglycan. Furthermore, chemical variants of chloranil induced a similar effect on ß-dystroglycan and this was prevented by the antioxidant N-acetylcysteine.

Conclusion/Significance

These findings reveal the mechanism of action of chloranil in preventing the laminin-induced clustering of dystroglycan and AQP4 and validate the use of high-throughput screening as a tool to identify drugs that modulate AQP4 clustering and that could be tested in models of brain edema.     

Inhibitors of protein synthesis identified by a high throughput multiplexed translation screen

The use of small molecule inhibitors of cellular processes is a powerful approach to understanding gene function that complements the genetic approach. We have designed a high throughput screen to identify new inhibitors of eukaryotic protein synthesis. We used a bicistronic mRNA reporter to multiplex our assay and simultaneously screen for inhibitors of cap-dependent initiation, internal initiation and translation elongation/termination. Functional screening of >90 000 compounds in an in vitro translation reaction identified 36 inhibitors, 14 of which are known inhibitors of translation and 18 of which are nucleic acid-binding ligands. Our results indicate that intercalators constitute a large class of protein synthesis inhibitors. Four non-intercalating compounds were identified, three of which block elongation and one of which inhibits initiation. The novel inhibitor of initiation affects 5' end-mediated initiation, as well as translation initiated from picornaviral IRESs, but does not significantly affect internal initiation from the hepatitis C virus 5'-untranslated region. This compound should be useful for delineating differences in mechanism of initiation among IRESs.     

A bifunctional monolithic column for combined protein preconcentration and digestion for high throughput proteomics research

Enzymatic digestion of proteins is a key step in protein identification by mass spectrometry (MS). Traditional solution-based protein digestion methods require long incubation times and are limitations for high throughput proteomics research. Recently, solid phase digestion (e.g. trypsin immobilization on solid supports) has become a useful strategy to accelerate the speed of protein digestion and eliminate autodigestion by immobilizing and isolating the enzyme moieties on solid supports. Monolithic media is an attractive support for immobilization of enzymes due to its unique properties that include fast mass transfer, stability in most solvents, and versatility of functional groups on the surfaces of monoliths. We prepared immobilized trypsin monolithic capillaries for on-column protein digestion, analyzed the digested peptides through LC/FTICR tandem MS, and compared peptide mass fingerprinting by MALDI-TOF-MS. To further improve the digestion efficiency for low abundance proteins, we introduced C4 functional groups onto the monolith surfaces to combine on-column protein enrichment and digestion. Compared with immobilized trypsin monolithic capillaries without C4, the immobilized trypsin-C4 monolith showed improved digestion efficiency. A mechanism for increased efficiency from the combination of sample enrichment and on-column digestion is also proposed in this paper. Moreover, we investigated the effects of organic solvent on digestion and detection by comparing the observed digested peptide sequences. Our data demonstrated that all columns showed good tolerance to organic solvents and maintained reproducible enzymatic activity for at least 30 days.     

Antisense depletion of death-associated protein kinase promotes apoptosis

Death-associated protein kinases (DAPK) are serine/threonine protein kinases that have an important role in regulating cell death. In this study two antisense approaches were employed to down-regulate expression of the endogenous DAPK-alpha and DAPK-beta proteins. Transient expression of an antisense DAPK cDNA or antisense morpholino oligonucleotides in HeLa, 3T3, or primary human vascular smooth muscle cells demonstrate that decreased DAPK expression promotes a spontaneous, caspase-mediated apoptosis as evidenced by increased activities of caspases-3 and -9. Clonal HeLa cell lines with attenuated levels of DAPK expression, obtained following selection in the presence of antisense DAPK cDNA, are more sensitive to tumor necrosis factor-induced caspase-mediated apoptosis, and their sensitivity is inversely related to DAPK expression. In contrast, HeLa cells with reduced DAPK expression are moderately resistant to cell death induced by interferon-gamma. This finding is consistent with previous studies showing that DAPK has a role in promoting caspase-independent cell death. Together, these studies demonstrate that the cellular activities of DAPK are critical for antagonizing caspase-dependent apoptosis to promote cell survival under normal cell growth conditions.     

High throughput protein production for functional proteomics

A major impact of genome projects on human health will be their contribution to the understanding of protein function. Proteins are the engines of biological systems, nearly all pharmaceuticals act on proteins and increasingly proteins themselves are used therapeutically. As biology enters the post-genomic era, researchers have begun to embrace the exciting opportunity of investigating proteins in high throughput (HT) experiments. The study of proteins includes a vast array of techniques ranging from enzyme catalysis assays to interaction and structural studies. Many of these methods depend on purified proteins. The discovery of thousands of novel protein-coding sequences and the increased availability of large cDNA collections provide the opportunity to investigate protein function in a systematic manner and at an unprecedented scale. This opportunity highlights the need for development of HT methods for protein isolation. This article describes the challenges faced and the approaches taken to develop proteome-scale protein expression systems.     

A synthetic lethal screen identifies SLK1, a novel protein kinase homolog implicated in yeast cell morphogenesis and cell growth.

The Saccharomyces cerevisiae SPA2 protein localizes at sites involved in polarized cell growth in budding cells and mating cells. spa2 mutants have defects in projection formation during mating but are healthy during vegetative growth. A synthetic lethal screen was devised to identify mutants that require the SPA2 gene for vegetative growth. One mutant, called slk-1 (for synthetic lethal kinase), has been characterized extensively. The SLK1 gene has been cloned, and sequence analysis predicts that the SLK1 protein is 1,478 amino acid residues in length. Approximately 300 amino acids at the carboxy terminus exhibit sequence similarity with the catalytic domains of protein kinases. Disruption mutations have been constructed in the SLK1 gene. slk1 null mutants cannot grow at 37 degrees C, but many cells can grow at 30, 24, and 17 degrees C. Dead slk1 mutant cells usually have aberrant cell morphologies, and many cells are very small, approximately one-half the diameter of wild-type cells. Surviving slk1 cells also exhibit morphogenic defects; these cells are impaired in their ability to form projections upon exposure to mating pheromones. During vegetative growth, a higher fraction of slk1 cells are unbudded compared with wild-type cells, and under nutrient limiting conditions, slk1 cells exhibit defects in cell cycle arrest. The different slk1 mutant defects are partially rescued by an extra copy of the SSD1/SRK1 gene. SSD1/SRK1 has been independently isolated as a suppressor of mutations in genes involved in growth control, sit4, pde2, bcy1, and ins1 (A. Sutton, D. Immanuel, and K.T. Arnat, Mol. Cell. Biol. 11:2133-2148, 1991; R.B. Wilson, A.A. Brenner, T.B. White, M.J. Engler, J.P. Gaughran, and K. Tatchell, Mol. Cell. Biol. 11:3369-3373, 1991). These data suggest that SLK1 plays a role in both cell morphogenesis and the control of cell growth. We speculate that SLK1 may be a regulatory link for these two cellular processes.     

cGMP-dependent protein kinase I promotes cell apoptosis through hyperactivation of death-associated protein kinase 2

cGMP-dependent protein kinase-I (cGK-I) induces apoptosis in various cancer cell lines. However, the signaling mechanisms involved remain unknown. Using protein microarray technology, we identified a novel cGK substrate, death-associated protein kinase 2 (DAPK2), which is a Ca(2+)/calmodulin-regulated serine/threonine kinase. cGK-I phosphorylated DAPK2 at Ser(299), Ser(367) and Ser(368). Interestingly, a phospho-mimic mutant, DAPK2 S299D, significantly enhanced its kinase activity in the absence of Ca(2+)/calmodulin, while a S367D/S368D mutant did not. Overexpression of DAPK2 S299D also resulted in a twofold increase in apoptosis of human breast cancer MCF-7 cells as compared with wild-type DAPK2. These results suggest that DAPK2 is one of the targets of cGK-I in apoptosis induction.     

A high throughput screen for inhibitors of fungal cell wall synthesis

Fungal cell wall synthesis is essential for viability, requiring the activity of genes involved in environmental sensing, precursor synthesis, transport, secretion, and assembly. This multitude of potential targets, the availability of known agents targeting this pathway, and the unique nature of fungal cell wall synthesis make this pathway an appealing target for drug discovery. Here we describe the adaptation of an assay monitoring cell wall synthesis for high-throughput screening. The assay requires fungal cell growth, in the presence of the test compound, for 3 h before the cells are subjected to osmotic shock in the presence of a dye that stains DNA. Miniaturization of the assay to a 384-well plate format and removing a mechanical transfer led to subtle changes in the assay characteristics. Validation of the assay with a library of known pharmacologically active agents has identified a number of different classes of compounds that are active in this assay, causing aberrant cell wall morphology and in many cases the inhibition of fungal cell growth.     

Current trends in high throughput proteomics in cyanobacteria

Advancements in genome sequencing and high throughput proteomics of cyanobacterial strains led to 13 published reports, from a small number of laboratories. These successful studies focused on Synechocystis, Nostoc and Anabaena strains, prochlorococcus, and halotolerant Euhalothece. The implications of emerging quantitative aspects developed and applied in these large-scale studies are assessed in the wake of advanced cyanobacterial research. Furthermore, contributions from traditional and early high throughput analysis of cyanobacterial proteomics are compared and summarised. Finally, opinions are provided to link both the trends and the future challenges. This review aims to push the synergy between proteomics and cyanobacterial research to improve both the technical and biological significance.     

A phosphosite screen identifies autocrine TGF-beta-driven activation of protein kinase R as a survival-limiting factor for eosinophils

The differential usage of signaling pathways by chemokines and cytokines in eosinophils is largely unresolved. In this study, we investigate signaling similarities and differences between CCL11 (eotaxin) and IL-5 in a phosphosite screen of human eosinophils. We confirm many previously known pathways of cytokine and chemokine signaling and elucidate novel phosphoregulation in eosinophils. The signaling molecules that were stimulated by both agents were members of the ERK1/2 and p38 MAPK pathways and their downstream effectors such as RSK and MSK1/2. Both agents inhibited S6 kinase, protein kinase Cepsilon, and glycogen synthase kinase 3 alpha and beta. The molecules that were differentially regulated include STATs and protein kinase R (PKR). One of the chief findings in this investigation was that PKR and eukaryotic initiation factor 2alpha are phosphorylated under basal conditions in eosinophils and neutrophils. This basal phosphorylation was linked to autocrine secretion of TGF-beta in eosinophils. TGF-beta directly activates PKR in eosinophils. Basal phosphorylation of PKR was inhibited by incubation of eosinophils with a neutralizing anti-TGF-beta Ab suggesting its physiological importance. We show that inhibition of PKR activity prolongs eosinophil survival. The eosinophil survival factor IL-5 strongly suppresses phosphorylation of PKR. The biological relevance of IL-5 inhibition of phospho-PKR was established by the observation that ex vivo bone marrow-derived eosinophils from OVA-immunized mice had no PKR phosphorylation in contrast to the high level of phosphorylation in sham-immunized mice. Together, our findings suggest that survival of eosinophils is in part controlled by basal activation of PKR through autocrine TGF-beta and that this could be modulated by a Th2 microenvironment in vivo.     

Chemical genetic screen identifies Gapex-5/GAPVD1 and STBD1 as novel AMPK substrates

AMP-activated protein kinase (AMPK) is a key regulator of cellular energy homeostasis, acting as a sensor of energy and nutrient status. As such, AMPK is considered a promising drug target for treatment of medical conditions particularly associated with metabolic dysfunctions. To better understand the downstream effectors and physiological consequences of AMPK activation, we have employed a chemical genetic screen in mouse primary hepatocytes in an attempt to identify novel AMPK targets. Treatment of hepatocytes with a potent and specific AMPK activator 991 resulted in identification of 65 proteins phosphorylated upon AMPK activation, which are involved in a variety of cellular processes such as lipid/glycogen metabolism, vesicle trafficking, and cytoskeleton organisation. Further characterisation and validation using mass spectrometry followed by immunoblotting analysis with phosphorylation site-specific antibodies identified AMPK-dependent phosphorylation of Gapex-5 (also known as GTPase-activating protein and VPS9 domain-containing protein 1 (GAPVD1)) on Ser902 in hepatocytes and starch-binding domain 1 (STBD1) on Ser175 in multiple cells/tissues. As new promising roles of AMPK as a key metabolic regulator continue to emerge, the substrates we identified could provide new mechanistic and therapeutic insights into AMPK-activating drugs in the liver.