More than words: the chemistry behind the interactions in the plant holobiont

Plants and microbes have evolved sophisticated ways to communicate and coexist. The simplest interactions that occur in plant-associated habitats, i.e., those involved in disease detection, depend on the production of microbial pathogenic and virulence factors and the host's evolved immunological response. In contrast, microbes can also be beneficial for their host plants in a number of ways, including fighting pathogens and promoting plant growth. In order to clarify the mechanisms directly involved in these various plant–microbe interactions, we must still deepen our understanding of how these interkingdom communication systems, which are constantly modulated by resident microbial activity, are established and, most importantly, how their effects can span physically separated plant compartments. Efforts in this direction have revealed a complex and interconnected network of molecules and associated metabolic pathways that modulate plant–microbe and microbe–microbe communication pathways to regulate diverse ecological responses. Once sufficiently understood, these pathways will be biotechnologically exploitable, for example, in the use of beneficial microbes in sustainable agriculture. The aim of this review is to present the latest findings on the dazzlingly diverse arsenal of molecules that efficiently mediate specific microbe–microbe and microbe–plant communication pathways during plant development and on different plant organs.     

Endocytosis in plant–microbe interactions

Plants encounter throughout their life all kinds of microorganisms, such as bacteria, fungi, or oomycetes, with either friendly or unfriendly intentions. During evolution, plants have developed a wide range of defense mechanisms against attackers. In return, adapted microbes have developed strategies to overcome the plant lines of defense, some of these microbes engaging in mutualistic or parasitic endosymbioses. By sensing microbe presence and activating signaling cascades, the plasma membrane through its dynamics plays a crucial role in the ongoing molecular dialogue between plants and microbes. This review describes the contribution of endocytosis to different aspects of plant–microbe interactions, microbe recognition and development of a basal immune response, and colonization of plant cells by endosymbionts. The putative endocytic routes for the entry of microbe molecules or microbes themselves are explored with a special emphasis on clathrin-mediated endocytosis. Finally, we evaluate recent findings that suggest a link between the compartmentalization of plant plasma membrane into microdomains and endocytosis.     

Plant hydrolytic enzymes (chitinases and β-1,3-glucanases) in root reactions to pathogenic and symbiotic microorganisms

Within the last decade, a great deal of attention has been devoted to the role of chitinases and -1,3-glucanases in plant/microbe interactions. While there is strong evidence that these hydrolases are antifungal proteins, there are also recent indications of roles in both plant morphogenesis and plant/microbe signal perception. This paper reviews recent findings pertinent to root/microbe interactions, and discusses the nature and significance of specific hydrolase isoforms in symbioses with arbuscular mycorrhizal (AM) fungi.     

Emerging roles of low-molecular-weight thiols at the host–microbe interface

Low-molecular-weight (LMW) thiols are an abundant class of cysteine-derived small molecules found in all forms of life that maintain reducing conditions within cells. While their contributions to cellular redox homeostasis are well established, LMW thiols can also mediate other aspects of cellular physiology, including intercellular interactions between microbial and host cells. Here we discuss emerging roles for these redox-active metabolites at the host–microbe interface. We begin by providing an overview of chemical and computational approaches to LMW-thiol discovery. Next, we highlight mechanisms of virulence regulation by LMW thiols in infected cells. Finally, we describe how microbial metabolism of these compounds may influence host physiology.     

Axenic and gnotobiotic insect technologies in research on host–microbiota interactions

Insects are one of the most important animal life forms on earth. Symbiotic microbes are closely related to the growth and development of the host insects and can affect pathogen transmission. For decades, various axenic insect-rearing systems have been developed, allowing further manipulation of symbiotic microbiota composition. Here we review the historical development of axenic rearing systems and the latest progress in using axenic and gnotobiotic approaches to study insect–microbe interactions. We also discuss the challenges of these emerging technologies, possible solutions to address these challenges, and future research directions that can contribute to a more comprehensive understanding of insect–microbe interactions.     

Plant–microbe interactions in the apoplast: Communication at the plant cell wall

The apoplast is a continuous plant compartment that connects cells between tissues and organs and is one of the first sites of interaction between plants and microbes. The plant cell wall occupies most of the apoplast and is composed of polysaccharides and associated proteins and ions. This dynamic part of the cell constitutes an essential physical barrier and a source of nutrients for the microbe. At the same time, the plant cell wall serves important functions in the interkingdom detection, recognition, and response to other organisms. Thus, both plant and microbe modify the plant cell wall and its environment in versatile ways to benefit from the interaction. We discuss here crucial processes occurring at the plant cell wall during the contact and communication between microbe and plant. Finally, we argue that these local and dynamic changes need to be considered to fully understand plant–microbe interactions.

Plants and microbes modify the host cell wall to benefit from the interaction by altering its properties, which are defined by the biochemistry of its polysaccharides, regulated by cell wall ions and proteins.     

A perspective on insect–microbe holobionts facing thermal fluctuations in a climate-change context

Temperature influences the ecology and evolution of insects and their symbionts by impacting each partner independently and their interactions, considering the holobiont as a primary unit of selection. There are sound data about the responses of these partnerships to constant temperatures and sporadic thermal stress (mostly heat shock). However, the current understanding of the thermal ecology of insect–microbe holobionts remains patchy because the complex thermal fluctuations (at different spatial and temporal scales) experienced by these organisms in nature have often been overlooked experimentally. This may drastically constrain our ability to predict the fate of mutualistic interactions under climate change, which will alter both mean temperatures and thermal variability. Here, we tackle down these issues by focusing on the effects of temperature fluctuations on the evolutionary ecology of insect–microbe holobionts. We propose potentially worth-investigating research avenues to (i) evaluate the relevance of theoretical concepts used to predict the biological impacts of temperature fluctuations when applied to holobionts; (ii) acknowledge the plastic (behavioural thermoregulation, physiological acclimation) and genetic responses (evolution) expressed by holobionts in fluctuating thermal environments; and (iii) explore the potential impacts of previously unconsidered patterns of temperature fluctuations on the outcomes and the dynamic of these insect–microbe associations.     

An interaction between host and microbe genotypes determines colonization success of a key bumble bee gut microbiota member

There has been a proliferation of studies demonstrating an organism's health is influenced by its microbiota. However, factors influencing beneficial microbe colonization and the evolution of these relationships remain understudied relative to host–pathogen interactions. Vertically transmitted beneficial microbes are predicted to show high levels of specificity in colonization, including genotype matching, which may transpire through coevolution. We investigate how host and bacterial genotypes influence colonization of a core coevolved microbiota member in bumble bees. The hindgut colonizing Snodgrassella alvi confers direct benefits, but, as an early colonizer, also facilitates the further development of a healthy microbiota. Due to predominantly vertical transmission promoting tight evolution between colonization factors of bacteria and host lineages, we predict that genotype‐by‐genotype interactions will determine successful colonization. Germ‐free adult bees from seven bumble bee colonies (host genotypic units) were inoculated with one of six genetically distinct strains of S. alvi. Subsequent colonization within host and microbe genotypes combinations ranged from 0 to 100%, and an interaction between host and microbe genotypes determined colonization success. This novel finding of a genotype‐by‐genotype interaction determining colonization in an animal host‐beneficial microbe system has implications for the ecological and evolutionary dynamics of host and microbe, including associated host‐fitness benefits.     

Real-Time Sensing of Enteropathogenic E. coli-Induced Effects on Epithelial Host Cell Height,Cell-Substrate Interactions,and Endocytic Processes by Infrared Surface Plasmon Spectroscopy

Enteropathogenic Escherichia coli (EPEC) is an important, generally non-invasive, bacterial pathogen that causes diarrhea in humans. The microbe infects mainly the enterocytes of the small intestine. Here we have applied our newly developed infrared surface plasmon resonance (IR-SPR) spectroscopy approach to study how EPEC infection affects epithelial host cells. The IR-SPR experiments showed that EPEC infection results in a robust reduction in the refractive index of the infected cells. Assisted by confocal and total internal reflection microscopy, we discovered that the microbe dilates the intercellular gaps and induces the appearance of fluid-phase-filled pinocytic vesicles in the lower basolateral regions of the host epithelial cells. Partial cell detachment from the underlying substratum was also observed. Finally, the waveguide mode observed by our IR-SPR analyses showed that EPEC infection decreases the host cell''s height to some extent. Together, these observations reveal novel impacts of the pathogen on the host cell architecture and endocytic functions. We suggest that these changes may induce the infiltration of a watery environment into the host cell, and potentially lead to failure of the epithelium barrier functions. Our findings also indicate the great potential of the label-free IR-SPR approach to study the dynamics of host-pathogen interactions with high spatiotemporal sensitivity.     

Involvement of auxin pathways in modulating root architecture during beneficial plant–microorganism interactions

A wide variety of microorganisms known to produce auxin and auxin precursors form beneficial relationships with plants and alter host root development. Moreover, other signals produced by microorganisms affect auxin pathways in host plants. However, the precise role of auxin and auxin‐signalling pathways in modulating plant–microbe interactions is unknown. Dissecting out the auxin synthesis, transport and signalling pathways resulting in the characteristic molecular, physiological and developmental response in plants will further illuminate upon how these intriguing inter‐species interactions of environmental, ecological and economic significance occur. The present review seeks to survey and summarize the scattered evidence in support of known host root modifications brought about by beneficial microorganisms and implicate the role of auxin synthesis, transport and signal transduction in modulating beneficial effects in plants. Finally, through a synthesis of the current body of work, we present outstanding challenges and potential future research directions on studies related to auxin signalling in plant–microbe interactions.     

Plant–microbe interactions at multiple scales across a high-elevation landscape

Here we review the numerous studies of plant–microbe interactions conducted at the Niwot Ridge LTER site in Colorado, USA. By synthesising work at scales ranging from the rhizosphere to the landscape, we offer a mechanistic view of how these interactions are essential to understanding the spatial and temporal structuring of plant and microbial communities across this diverse and changing landscape. These new insights are also important for making predictions about how both plant and microbial communities and populations will respond to future changes in this environment, especially with regard to the potential uphill movement of plants and microbes in response to climate change and nitrogen deposition. We predict that the uphill movement of plants and microbes will be especially apparent, and have the most impact, in areas of the alpine that are now mostly plant free. These areas are currently undergoing a shift from a microbe-dominated ecosystem to one where microbe–plant interactions will play a critical role in reducing nutrient losses to downstream ecosystems.     

Continuous production of extracellular antioxidants in suspension cells attenuates the oxidative burst detected in plant microbe interactions

Suspension cells of Solanacearum tuberosum and Nicotiana tabacum placed in fresh buffer rapidly produce and maintain significant pools of extracellular antioxidants. The extracellular antioxidant was detected by first adding a known amount of exogenous H₂O₂ to samples and then immediately measuring the remaining H₂O₂. The difference between the amount added and amount remaining was used to determine the antioxidant capacity of the sample. This extracellular antioxidant pool attenuates levels of hydrogen peroxide produced during plant–bacterial interactions. When tobacco cells were inoculated with an isolate Pseudomonas syringae pv. syringae that causes a hypersensitive response much of the antioxidant capacity had been expended neutralizing the oxidative burst characteristic of such plant–microbe interactions. After a brief delay, the levels of extracellular phenolics increased commensurate to antioxidative capacity in freshly transferred cells within 2–4 h. The strong UV absorbance of these extracellular phenolics within 250 and 350 nm was used to follow oxidation upon reaction with H₂O₂. This extracellular antioxidant pool is an important consideration in cell suspension studies of the plant–microbe oxidative burst. This study demonstrates that the true magnitude and timing of the oxidative burst in cell suspensions is masked by extracellular antioxidants.     

Agent-based model of diffusion of N-acyl homoserine lactones in a multicellular environment of Pseudomonas aeruginosa and Candida albicans

Experimental incapacity to track microbe–microbe interactions in structures like biofilms, and the complexity inherent to the mathematical modelling of those interactions, raises the need for feasible, alternative modelling approaches. This work proposes an agent-based representation of the diffusion of N-acyl homoserine lactones (AHL) in a multicellular environment formed by Pseudomonas aeruginosa and Candida albicans. Depending on the spatial location, C. albicans cells were variably exposed to AHLs, an observation that might help explain why phenotypic switching of individual cells in biofilms occurred at different time points. The simulation and algebraic results were similar for simpler scenarios, although some statistical differences could be observed (p?<?0.05). The model was also successfully applied to a more complex scenario representing a small multicellular environment containing C. albicans and P. aeruginosa cells encased in a 3-D matrix. Further development of this model may help create a predictive tool to depict biofilm heterogeneity at the single-cell level.     

The zebrafish as a model for gastrointestinal tract–microbe interactions

The zebrafish (Danio rerio) has become a widely used vertebrate model for bacterial, fungal, viral, and protozoan infections. Due to its genetic tractability, large clutch sizes, ease of manipulation, and optical transparency during early life stages, it is a particularly useful model to address questions about the cellular microbiology of host–microbe interactions. Although its use as a model for systemic infections, as well as infections localised to the hindbrain and swimbladder having been thoroughly reviewed, studies focusing on host–microbe interactions in the zebrafish gastrointestinal tract have been neglected. Here, we summarise recent findings regarding the developmental and immune biology of the gastrointestinal tract, drawing parallels to mammalian systems. We discuss the use of adult and larval zebrafish as models for gastrointestinal infections, and more generally, for studies of host–microbe interactions in the gut.     

Resilience of the rhizosphere to anthropogenic disturbance

The rhizosphere is a dominant site of microbial metabolism in soiland whereas it can be shown that anthropogenic disturbances can influence this metabolism,the impact of these disturbances on biodiversity is rather difficult to determineat the species level. This is in part because no more than 10% of the microbial species are culturable, and in part because there is very poor precision inplate counting, usually requiring a change of 300–500% to be significant. We have therefore used a functional approach. The `ecophysiological index' is based onr or K strategy of the organisms being counted. Also, enzyme families, microbial biomass,microbe/microbe and microbe/fauna interactions have been determined,along with nutrient uptake measurements. The techniques have been applied to determinethe effects of disturbances created by the introduction of GM plants and microorganismsto soil, these effects being small compared with those caused by time-honoured practices such as crop rotation and ploughing. Toxicity from industrial influences(e.g. cyanide) can be remediated by rhizosphere microorganisms.     

Genome‐wide association studies on the phyllosphere microbiome: Embracing complexity in host–microbe interactions

Environmental sequencing shows that plants harbor complex communities of microbes that vary across environments. However, many approaches for mapping plant genetic variation to microbe‐related traits were developed in the relatively simple context of binary host–microbe interactions under controlled conditions. Recent advances in sequencing and statistics make genome‐wide association studies (GWAS) an increasingly promising approach for identifying the plant genetic variation associated with microbes in a community context. This review discusses early efforts on GWAS of the plant phyllosphere microbiome and the outlook for future studies based on human microbiome GWAS. A workflow for GWAS of the phyllosphere microbiome is then presented, with particular attention to how perspectives on the mechanisms, evolution and environmental dependence of plant–microbe interactions will influence the choice of traits to be mapped.     

Transgenerational developmental effects of species‐specific,maternally transmitted microbiota in Onthophagus dung beetles

1. The significance of host–microbe interactions is increasingly appreciated across biological disciplines, yet to what extent these interactions influence developmental outcomes within and across generations remains poorly understood. 2. This study investigated the putative role of host–microbe interactions in the adaptive diversification of Onthophagus dung beetles, one of the most species‐rich and ecologically successful genera of insects. Onthophagus mothers vertically transmit growth‐ and fitness‐enhancing gut symbionts to their offspring through a faecal secretion known as the pedestal. 3. Pedestals were reciprocally exchanged between two ecologically similar congeneric Onthophagus species to assess the degree to which pedestal microbiota from one species can substitute for those of another. 4. It was found that the presence of a heterospecific pedestal delays development and increases mortality, and that the fitness costs of non‐host‐specific microbiota are maintained transgenerationally. 5. Collectively, these results support the hypothesis that Onthophagus beetles maintain, interact with, and are dependent upon host species‐specific microbial communities to support normal growth and development. The implications of these results are discussed in the context of host microbiota coevolution.     

Frenemies of the soil: Bacillus and Pseudomonas interspecies interactions

Bacillus and Pseudomonas ubiquitously occur in natural environments and are two of the most intensively studied bacterial genera in the soil. They are often coisolated from environmental samples, and as a result, several studies have experimentally cocultured bacilli and pseudomonads to obtain emergent properties. Even so, the general interaction between members of these genera is virtually unknown. In the past decade, data on interspecies interactions between natural isolates of Bacillus and Pseudomonas has become more detailed, and now, molecular studies permit mapping of the mechanisms behind their pairwise ecology. This review addresses the current knowledge about microbe–microbe interactions between strains of Bacillus and Pseudomonas and discusses how we can attempt to generalize the interaction on a taxonomic and molecular level.     

Conservation and divergence of signalling pathways between roots and soil microbes – the Rhizobium-legume symbiosis compared to the development of lateral roots, mycorrhizal interactions and nematode-induced galls

This review compares endophytic symbiotic and pathogenic root–microbe interactions and examines how the development of root structures elicited by various micro-organisms could have evolved by recruitment of existing plant developmental pathways. Plants are exposed to a multitude of soil micro-organisms which affect root development and performance. Their interactions can be of symbiotic and pathogenic nature, both of which can result in the formation of new root structures – how does the plant regulate the different outcomes of interactions with microbes? The idea that pathways activated in plant by micro-organisms could have been `hijacked' from plant developmental pathways is not new, it was essentially proposed by P. S. Nutman in 1948, but at that time, the molecular evidence to support that hypothesis was missing. Genetic evidence for overlaps between different plant–microbe interactions have previously been examined. This review compares the physiological and molecular plant responses to symbiotic rhizobia with those to arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi, pathogenic nematodes and the development of lateral roots and summarises evidence from both molecular and cellular studies for substantial overlaps in the signalling pathways underlying root–micro-organism interactions. A more difficult question has been why plant responses to micro-organisms are so similar, even though the outcomes are very different. Possible hypotheses for divergence of signalling pathways and future approaches to test these ideas are presented.     

Expression of fluorescent proteins in Lactobacillus rhamnosus to study host–microbe and microbe–microbe interactions

Probiotic Lactobacillus strains are widely used to benefit human and animal health, although the exact mechanisms behind their interactions with the host and the microbiota are largely unknown. Fluorescent tagging of live probiotic cells is an important tool to unravel their modes of action. In this study, the implementation of different heterologously expressed fluorescent proteins for the labelling of the model probiotic strains Lactobacillus rhamnosusGG (gastrointestinal) and Lactobacillus rhamnosusGR‐1 (vaginal) was explored. Heterologous expression of mTagBFP2 and mCherry resulted in long‐lasting fluorescence of L. rhamnosusGG and GR‐1 cells, using the nisin‐controlled expression (NICE) system. These novel fluorescent strains were then used to study in vitro aspects of their microbe–microbe and microbe–host interactions. Lactobacillus rhamnosusGG and L. rhamnosusGR‐1 expressing mTagBFP2 and mCherry could be visualized in mixed‐species biofilms, where they inhibited biofilm formation by Salmonella Typhimurium–gfpmut3 expressing the green fluorescent protein. Likewise, fluorescent L. rhamnosusGG and L. rhamnosusGR‐1 were implemented for the visualization of their adhesion patterns to intestinal epithelial cell cultures. The fluorescent L. rhamnosus strains developed in this study can therefore serve as novel tools for the study of probiotic interactions with their environment.