Field testing of a vaccine against eel diseases caused by Vibrio vulnificus

The field results of a vaccination programme against Vibrio vulnificus serovar E (biotype 2) in a Spanish eel farm are reported. A total of 9.5 million glass eels were vaccinated from January 1998 to March 2000 by prolonged immersion followed by 2 subsequent reimmunisations after 12 to 14 and 24 to 28 d, respectively. The acquired protection and the immune response against serovar E were estimated over a period of 6 mo after vaccination. A similar vaccination schedule was conducted with elvers in a Danish eel farm. In this case, the acquired protection and the immune response against serovar E and the new eel-pathogenic serovars, recently described in Denmark, were evaluated over a short term. The overall results show that the vaccine against V. vulnificus serovar E induces a satisfactory protective immunity during the main growth period of eels (around 6 mo) with a relative percentage survival of 62 to 86% and protects them against the new eel-pathogenic serovars. Vaccination of eels by immersion seems to be the best strategy to prevent diseases caused by V. vulnificus.     

Effectiveness of different vaccine formulations against vibriosis caused by Vibrio vulnificus serovar E (biotype 2) in European eels Anguilla anguilla

Vibriosis due to Vibrio vulnificus serovar E (biotype 2) is one of the main causes of mortality in European eels cultured in Europe. The main objective of this study was to develop a vaccine and a vaccination procedure against this pathogen. With this aim, we tested several vaccine formulations (inactivated whole-cells with and without toxoids--inactivated extracellular products--from capsulated and uncapsulated strains, attenuated live vaccines and purified lipopolysaccharide [LPS]) on eels maintained under controlled laboratory conditions using different delivery routes (injection and immersion). To study the immune response we estimated antibody titers and bactericidal/bacteriostatic activity in mucus and serum. To evaluate protection, we calculated the relative percent survival (RPS) after intraperitoneal (i.p.) injection and bath challenge of the pathogen. The overall results indicate that: (1) capsular antigens seem to be essential for protective immunization; (2) vaccines confer the highest protection when administered by i.p. injection; (3) booster is needed to achieve good protection by immersion; (4) enriching the vaccine with toxoids enhances protection to optimal levels (RPS values around 70 to 100%, depending on the delivery route); and (5) the protective effect in serum and mucus depends on the route of administration and seems to be related to the production of specific antibodies.     

The kinetics of antibody production in mucus and serum of European eel (Anguilla anguilla L.) after vaccination against Vibrio vulnificus: development of a new method for antibody quantification in skin mucus

Vibrio vulnificus serovar E, a bacterial pathogen for eels cultured in intensive systems, is transmitted through water and enters into new hosts mainly via gills. The main objective of this work was to study the kinetics of antibody production to V. vulnificus in serum and mucus and their relationship with protection after vaccination. To quantify local mucus antibodies, a new "in situ" dot blot immunoassay using image analysis has been developed. This assay was applied to measure antibody production in the skin zone next to the gills. We found that (i) the immune response in mucus was faster (peak at days 3-4) and shorter in duration (titres significantly elevated up to day 5 and 11 for skin zone next to the gills and for general cutaneous mucus, respectively) than in serum (peak at day 7; titres significantly elevated for more than 25 days); (ii) the exposure of vaccinated eels with basal levels of local antibodies to sub-lethal dose of the pathogen stimulated a more lasting secreted antibody production (for more than 14 days); (iii) protection and antibody levels in serum were clearly correlated, and (iv) immunised eels with basal levels of serum antibodies and maximal levels of local antibodies were partially protected.     

Antigens recognized by the human immune response to vaccination with a bivalent hardjo/pomona leptospiral vaccine

Serum from volunteer subjects vaccinated with a bivalent whole cell vaccine of Leptospira interrogans serovar hardjo/serovar pomona grown in protein-free medium, was tested by the microscopic agglutination test (MAT), enzyme-immunoassay (EIA) and immunoblotting. Specific IgM antibodies to either serovars hardjo or pomona were detected in some subjects as early as 6 days after vaccination with peak antibody levels occurring 13-68 days after vaccination. Whereas all subjects produced specific IgM to both serovars, not all produced specific IgG to both serovars. Immunoblotting with hardjo sonicate revealed that all subjects produced IgM antibodies reacting with the 15, 23 and 28 kDa components of hardjo lipopolysaccharide (LPS), and most produced IgM antibodies that reacted with the 34.5 kDa flagellar doublet. In contrast, not all sera immunoblotted against pomona sonicate reacted with the 29 and 35 kDa components of pomona LPS. However all subjects produced antibodies reacting with a diffuse 14.4-27 kDa band. These antibodies appeared early in the immune response. Serum from the one vaccinated subject tested protected hamsters from acute lethal infection with serovar pomona.     

Identification of DNA sequences specific for Vibrio vulnificus biotype 2 strains by suppression subtractive hybridization

Vibrio vulnificus can be divided into three biotypes, and only biotype 2, which is further divided into serovars, contains eel-virulent strains. We compared the genomic DNA of a biotype 2 serovar E isolate (tester) with the genomic DNAs of three biotype 1 strains by suppression subtractive hybridization and then tested the distribution of the tester-specific DNA sequences in a wide collection of bacterial strains. In this way we identified three plasmid-borne DNA sequences that were specific for biotype 2 strains irrespective of the serovar and three chromosomal DNA sequences that were specific for serovar E biotype 2 strains. These sequences have potential for use in the diagnosis of eel vibriosis caused by V. vulnificus and in the detection of biotype 2 serovar E strains.     

Protocol for specific isolation of virulent strains of Vibrio vulnificus serovar E (biotype 2) from environmental samples

The eel pathogen Vibrio vulnificus biotype 2 comprises at least three serovars, with serovar E being the only one involved in both epizootics of eel vibriosis and sporadic cases of human infections. The virulent strains of this serovar (VSE) have only been recovered from clinical (mainly eel tissue) sources. The main objective of this work was to design and validate a new protocol for VSE-specific isolation from environmental samples. The key element of the new protocol is the broth used for the first step (saline eel serum broth [SEB]), which contains eel serum as a nutritive and selective component. This approach takes advantage of the ability of VSE cells to grow in eel serum and thus to separate themselves from the pool of competitors. The growth yield in SEB after 8 h of incubation was 1,000 times higher for VSE strains than for their putative competitors (including biotype 1 strains of the species). The selective and differential agar Vibrio vulnificus medium (VVM) was selected from five selective media for the second step because it gave the highest plating efficiency not only for the VSE group but also for other V. vulnificus groups, including biotype 3. The entire protocol was validated by field studies, with alkaline peptone water plus VVM as a control. V. vulnificus was isolated by both protocols, but serovar E was only recovered by the new method described here. All selected serovar E isolates were identified as VSE since they were virulent for both eels and iron-overloaded mice and resisted the bactericidal action of eel and iron-overloaded human sera. In conclusion, this new protocol is a suitable method for the isolation of VSE strains from environmental samples and is recommended for epidemiological studies of the pathogenic serovar E.     

Antigens recognized by the human immune response to vaccination with a bivalent hardjo/pomona leptospiral vaccine

Abstract Serum from volunteer subjects vaccinated with a bivalent whole cell vaccine of Leptospira interrogans serovar hardjo /serovar pomona grown in protein-free medium, was tested by the microcospic agglutination test (MAT), enzyme-immunoassay and immunoblotting. Specific IgM antiboidies to either serevars hardjo or pomona were detected in some subjects as early as 6 days after vaccinated with peak antibody levels occurring 13–68 after vaccination. Whereas all subjects produced specific IgM to both serovars, not all produced specific IgG to both serovars, Immunoblotting with hardjo sonicate revealed that all subjects produced IgM antibodies reacting with the 15, 23 and 28 kDa components of hardjo lipopolysaccharide (LPS), and most produced IgM antibodies that reacted with the 34.5 kDa flagellar doublet. In contrast, not all sera immunoblotted against pomona sonicate reacted with the 29 and 35 kDa components of pomona LPS. However all subjects produced antibodies reacting with a diffuse 14.4–27 kDa band. These antibodies appeared early in the immune response. Serum from the one vaccinated subject tested protected hamsters from acute lethal infection with serovar pomona .     

Role of the metalloprotease Vvp and the virulence plasmid pR99 of Vibrio vulnificus serovar E in surface colonization and fish virulence

The virulence for eels of Vibrio vulnificus biotype 2 serovar E (VSE) is conferred by a plasmid that codifies ability to survive in eel serum and cause septicaemia. To find out whether the plasmid and the selected chromosomal gene vvp plays a role in the initial steps of infection, the VSE strain CECT4999, the cured strain CT218 and the Vvp-deficient mutant CT201 (obtained in this work by allelic exchange) were used in colonization and virulence experiments. The eel avirulent biotype 1 (BT1) strain YJ016, whose genome has been sequenced, was used for comparative purposes. The global results demonstrate that the plasmid does not play a significant role in surface colonization because (i) CECT4999 and CT218 were equally chemoattracted towards and adherent to eel mucus and gills, and (ii) CT218 persisted in gills from bath-infected eels 2 weeks post infection. In contrast, mutation in vvp gene reduced significantly chemoattraction and attachment to eel mucus and gills, as well as virulence degree by immersion challenge. Co-infection experiments by bath with CECT4999 and CT201 confirmed that Vvp was involved in eel colonization and persistence in gills, because CECT4999 was recovered at higher numbers compared with CT201 from both internal organs of moribund fish (ratio 4:1) and gills from survivors (ratio 50:1). Interestingly, YJ016 also showed chemoattraction and attachment to mucus, and complementation of CT201 with BT1- vvp gene restored both activities together with virulence degree by immersion challenge. Additional experiments with algae mucus and purified mucin gave similar results. In conclusion, the protease Vvp of V. vulnificus seems to play an essential role in colonization of mucosal surfaces present in aquatic environments. Among the V. vulnificus strains colonizing fish mucus, only those harbouring the plasmid could survive in blood and cause septicaemia.     

Immunological importance of the second gut segment of carp. III. Systemic and/or mucosal immune responses after immunization with soluble or particulate antigen

Mucosal and systemic (serum) immune responses were studied after oral, anal or intramuscular (i.m.) immunization with particulate ( Vibrio anguillarum ) or soluble (ferritin) antigen. Antigen specific antibodies were found by ELISA in skin mucus after repeated oral or anal administration of bacteria, but not after immunization with ferritin. Daily feeding with bacteria did not give detectable antibodies in serum, while regular oral administration of ferritin resulted in an increase of specific antibodies during the first 3 weeks. From that time immunosuppression was observed, as the antibody titre decreased despite the continued ferritin feeding. Immunosuppression was also found after a second anal intubation or i.m. injection with ferritin, independent of the route of priming (i.m. or anal). On the contrary, a second anal intubation of bacteria resulted in a secondary serum response. These results combined with those reported in Parts I and II of the study indicate an important immunological role for the second gut segment. Because mucosal as well as serum responses can be obtained by anal immunization with bacteria, the significance for oral vaccination is discussed.     

Mucosal response in African catfish after administration of Vibrio anguillarum O2 antigens via different routes

The aim of this study was to investigate the possibility of mucosal vaccination in African catfish (Clarias gariepinus) with Vibrio anguillarum O2 bacterins. The antigen was administered via different routes: anal intubation, oral administration, intraperitoneal injection and immersion. To monitor the antigen uptake, a competitive ELISA was used. The antibody response was measured using an indirect ELISA. Increased antibody levels were found in bile and mucus upon anal intubation, which was not the case after intraperitoneal injection. The data indicate that oral vaccination of fish may be possible when antigens can reach the second gut segment in sufficient quantities and in the right form as confirmed by the recorded substantial induction of systemic and mucosal immunity. The results obtained are a strong indication for mucosal immune response and the two compartmental models for immune response in fish.     

An indirect immunofluorescent antibody technique for detection and enumeration of Vibrio vulnificus serovar E (biotype 2): development and applications

The applications of an indirect fluorescent antibody technique (IFAT), developed to detect and enumerate the pathogenic bacterium Vibrio vulnificus serovar E from water and clinical samples, are described. This technique proved accurate for detecting V. vulnificus, even under starvation conditions and in the non-culturable state, and could differentiate this species from other bacteria which share the same habitats. The IFAT was successfully used to diagnose vibriosis from naturally- and artificially-infected eels. The overall data suggest that applying this technique properly in environmental and epidemiological/epizootiological studies could significantly increase our knowledge of this bacterium.     

Characterization of Vibrio anguillarum Strains Isolated from Diseased Fish in Finland

Characterization of V anguillarum strains (n=109) isolated from diseased salmonids was performed. Eight O serovars were found among the strains. Serovar Ol was predominant (90 %), while serovars O2, O3, O5, O8, O9, and a new serovar Va NT2, were represented by 1 or 2 strains. Two strains remained non-typeable. One of these was cross-reactive with several antisera, but had a LPS profile identical to that of serovar O8. All serovars showed specific LPS profiles. All but 1 of the Ol strains had a plasmid comparable in size to the pJMl virulence plasmid, while plasmids of different sizes were found in O2, Va NT2 and the non-typeable strains. Apart from a single strain resistant to tetracycline, all the strains were sensitive to oxolinic acid, tetracycline, and trimethoprim-sulfonamides. By their biochemical and antigenic properties strains causing vibriosis among salmonids in Finland closely resemble Scandinavian strains. Predominance of the serovars Ol and O2 suggests that commercial vaccines containing these serovars should afford sufficient protection against vibriosis in Finland.     

Role of the virulence plasmid pR99 and the metalloprotease Vvp in resistance of Vibrio vulnificus serovar E to eel innate immunity

Vibrio vulnificus biotype 2 serovar E (VSE) is a bacterial pathogen that produces a haemorrhagic septicaemia called vibriosis in eels. Its ability to grow in blood is conferred by a recently described virulence plasmid [Lee CT, Amaro C, Wu KM, Valiente E, Chang YF, Tsai SF, et al. A common virulence plasmid in biotype 2 Vibrio vulnificus and its dissemination aided by a conjugal plasmid. Journal of Bacteriology, submitted for publication.]. In this study, we analyzed the role of this plasmid together with the role played by the metalloprotease (Vvp) in the interaction between bacteria and eel innate immunity. To this end, we compared and statistically analyzed the differences in resistance to serum and mucus factors (complement, selected antimicrobial peptides, transferrin and lysozyme) and also to phagocytosis/opsonophagocytosis between one VSE strain and its derivatives: a plasmid-cured strain and a vvp-deficient mutant. The wild-type and the metalloprotease-deficient strains were resistant to both the bactericidal action of fresh serum and the phagocytosis and opsonophagocytosis by eel phagocytes, confirming that Vvp is not involved in resistance to eel innate immunity. In contrast, the cured strain was sensitive to both the bactericidal action of eel serum activated by the alternative pathway and phagocytosis/opsonophagocytosis. Since no plasmid-encoded ORF, with homology to known genes, is related to the resistance to innate immunity [Lee CT, Amaro C, Wu KM, Valiente E, Chang YF, Tsai SF, et al. A common virulence plasmid in biotype 2 Vibrio vulnificus and its dissemination aided by a conjugal plasmid. Journal of Bacteriology, submitted for publication.], this function could be codified by one or more new genes. Further studies are underway to characterize the plasmid-encoded system responsible for V. vulnificus resistance to the innate immune system of eels.     

First description of nonmotile Vibrio vulnificus strains virulent for eels

Nonmotile Vibrio vulnificus strains were isolated as pure cultures from body ulcers and internal organs of wild diseased European eels caught in a Mediterranean freshwater coastal lagoon. All 54 V. vulnificus isolates were nonmotile, indole-, ornithine decarboxilase-, mannitol- and cellobiose-positive, developed the opaque variant in culture, belonged to the O-antigenic serovar A and were highly virulent for eels by both intraperitoneal injection and immersion challenges. The nonmotile phenotype found in our V. vulnificus isolates was stable: nonmotile cells were always recovered from experimentally infected eels; no variation in the immobility of the V. vulnificus cells was observed for repeated subculture by daily passages on solid media, at different temperatures or incubation times and with or without magnesium sulfate. Many of the fla genes of Vibrio were present in the genome of the nonmotile strains (flaCDE and flaFBA for flagellins and flaH for the distal capping protein), although we observed by transmission electron microscopy that these V. vulnificus strains always lacked the polar flagellum. This is the first report on the existence of nonmotile wild-type V. vulnificus strains.     

Immunogenic antigens of the eel pathogen Vibrio vulnificus serovar E

The immunogenic antigens of Vibrio vulnificus serovar E were investigated in the eel. Fish were vaccinated by immersion with Vulnivaccine (V), revaccinated 2 years later by intraperitoneal injection (RV) and bath infected 15 days post-revaccination (RVI). The specific immune response in serum was followed in all groups, and selected sera were used for immunostaining of surface (SA) and extracellular antigens (ECA). Bacteria were grown in iron-rich (TSB and MSWYE) and iron-poor media (TSB and MSWYE plus human transferrin (TSB-T and MSWYE-T)) as well as eel serum (ES), and their SA and ECA were extracted and electrophoretically analysed. Cells grown in MSWYE-T and ES presented the same antigenic profiles, which suggests that iron-restriction is the main growth-limiting factor in vivo. The electrophoretic pattern of SA, but not that of ECA, varied with iron-availability in the growth medium. Further, SA extracted from bacteria grown in iron restriction were strongly immunogenic for eels, especially after vaccination and infection. Among the immunogenic antigens over expressed in iron-restriction, three outer membrane proteins of around 70-80 kDa, including the putative receptor for vulnibactin, together with the rapid and slow migrating forms of the lipopolysaccharide (LPS), were identified. The response was not so evident in the case of capsule, which was not clearly stained with any of the eel sera. With respect to ECA, two proteins, identified as the V. vulnificus protease (Vvp) and the major outer membrane protein (OMP), probably liberated to the medium after cell death, were recognised by RV and, more strongly, by RVI sera. The specific antibodies against the mentioned OMPs, LPS bands and the Vvp may contribute to the protection of vaccinated eels against infection, giving a reasonable explanation for the high effectiveness of Vulnivaccine.     

Protection, immune responses and side effects in Atlantic salmon (Salmo salarL.) vaccinated against furunculosis by different procedures

In an experimental trial lasting approximately 6 months, 10 different vaccination regimes against furunculosis were studied in Atlantic salmon pre-smolts. Single and repeated administration of vaccine by the intraperitoneal (i.p.), immersion or oral route, and revaccination by combinations of these methods, were tested. In challenge assays initiated 8 and 16 weeks after vaccination, fish injected once with a trivalent vaccine, and fish injected twice with a monovalent vaccine, both containing aluminium phosphate as adjuvant, were moderately protected. Non-injection vaccination protocols consistently failed to protect the fish. Compared with unvaccinated fish, protected groups showed elevated antibody responses toAeromonas salmonicidaantigens throughout the study. Increasedin vitroproliferation of head kidney leucocytes from i.p. vaccinated fish was found 16 weeks after vaccination. The use of a polyvalent vaccine preparation, and revaccination by injection or the oral route improved both immune responses and survival, compared to a single inoculation of monovalent vaccine. In all groups subjected to i.p. administration of vaccine, minor to moderate intraperitoneal lesions were found. In conclusion, i.p. administration of adjuvanted vaccine, preferably in a polyvalent formulation, is the optimal method of inducing anti-furunculosis immunity in Atlantic salmon, and is apparently necessary for an effective immunoprophylaxis of salmonid fish against furunculosis.     

Indole-positive Vibrio vulnificus isolated from disease outbreaks on a Danish eel farm

Vibrio vulnificus was isolated in 1996 from 2 disease outbreaks on a Danish eel farm which used brackish water. A characteristic clinical sign was extensive, deep muscle necrosis in the head region. V. vulnificus was isolated from kidney, mucus, spleen, gill and intestine of diseased eels. Thirty-two isolates were examined phenotypically and serologically for pathogenicity to eels and for correlation to ribotype and plasmid profile. Biochemically, the isolates showed properties similar to those described previously for eel-pathogenic strains of V. vulnificus, with the exception of indole production. Virulence was evaluated by LD50 (the 50% lethal dose), which ranged from < 9.4 x 10(3) to 2.3 x 10(5) CFU (colony-forming units) per fish. The isolates which were lethal for eels showed identical ribotypes and serotypes. A relationship between certain plasmids and virulence was not found. A serotyping system based on lipopolysaccharide (LPS)-associated O antigen type and on carbohydrate capsule antigens showed that the eel-virulent isolates shared a common LPS-based homogeneous O serogroup and a capsule antigen. V. vulnificus serovar O4 and capsule type 9 was identical serologically to the Japanese isolate ATCC 33149 and was the agent responsible for the disease outbreaks that occurred on the Danish eel farm. Despite absence of antibiotic resistance, treatment had little effect and disease reoccurred.     

Correlation of immune assays with protection in rainbow trout, Salmo gairdneri, immersed in Vibrio bacterins

One hundred kg of Rainbow trout, Salmo gairdneri, weighing 80–100g each were immersed in a formalized, bivalent vaccine of Vibrio anguiliárum (VA) and Vibrio ordalii (VO), at a1/10 dilution for 30s at 10°C. The protection levels achieved at 8 and 10 weeks post vaccination were assessed by intraperitoneal challenge with 10⁵ live V. anguillarnm or V. ordalii. No decline in protection due to antigen depletion was found between batches throughout the procedure. The protection conferred by one component of the vaccine was slightly better than the other (80% against VO and 42 % against VA). A number of measures of immunity were monitored before and after challenge. These included serum and mucus antibody litres, bactericidal effects of serum and mucus and phagocytosis by peritoneal exudate cells. Serum antibody was present (peak litre of-log₂ 3.25 for VO, and 4.4 for VA) but had declined to background levels by the time of challenge, whereas bactericidal effects and phagocytosis rate of 40% were not increased by vaccination. The most likely immune mechanism responsible for the observed protection was discussed and suggested to be a cellular mechanism where serum antibody acts as an opsonin to increase phagocytosis.     

Isolation of Vibrio vulnificus serovar E from aquatic habitats in Taiwan

The existence of strains of Vibrio vulnificus serovar E that are avirulent for eels is reported in this work. These isolates were recovered from water and oysters and differed from eel virulent strains in (i) fermentation and utilization of mannitol, (ii) ribotyping after HindIII digestion, and (iii) susceptibility to eel serum. Lipopolysaccharide of these strains lacked the highest molecular weight immunoreactive bands, which are probably involved in serum resistance.