Frequency of the fragile X syndrome in institutionalized mentally retarded females in Japan

Summary The fragile X [fra(X)] syndrome was screened on 190 Japanese institutionalized females with moderate to severe mental retardation. Two inmates with severe mental retardation (IQ 20) had the fra(X) chromosome in 26% and 15% of the cells examined, indicating that the prevalence of the fra(X) syndrome was about 1% in all female inmates and was about 3.27% in severely mentally retarded females with known causes. However, no female with fra(X) syndrome was found in 35 moderately retarded females. Both had brothers with the fra(X) syndrome and the prevalence was 10% in females with a family history of mental retardation. In addition, the replication study of the fra(X) chromosome in the patients supported the proposal that an excess of the early replicated fra(X) chromosome is related to the mental capacity in heterozygous females. Therefore, the fra(X) syndrome should not be ignored even in severely mentally retarded females with a family history, though the heterozygotes are commonly normal to subnormal in their mental development. in addition, the replication study of the fra(X) chromosome may help to estimate mental development in the carrier children.     

Neuroanatomy in fragile X females: the posterior fossa.

The relative homogeneity of the neuropsychiatric phenotype in individuals with fragile (fra) X syndrome suggests that there are consistent central nervous system (CNS) abnormalities underlying the observed cognitive and behavioral abnormalities. In this study, the neuroanatomy of the posterior fossa and other selected CNS regions in 12 young fra X females were compared with those of a group of 12 age-, sex-, and IQ-matched females without evidence of the fra X syndrome. Fra X females were shown to have decreased size of the posterior cerebellar vermis and increased size of the fourth ventricle, findings that are identical to those previously reported for fra X males. When compared with fra X male and nonfra X control groups, the distribution of the posterior-vermis and fourth-ventricle variables for the fra X female group was intermediate. These results support the hypothesis that the fra X genetic abnormality leads to hypoplasia of the posterior cerebellar vermis, a neuroanatomical variation of potential importance to both developmental and neuropsychiatric syndromes.     

A fragile X female with Down syndrome

Summary Clinical and cytogenetic aspects of a female infant with trisomy 21 and the fragile X [fra (X)] chromosome are reported. Most of the facial characteristics of the patient are those observed in Down syndrome, but some features such as long face with prominent forehead and lower jaw, and large ears are related to the fra (X) syndrome. The origin of an additional chromosome 21 may be ascribed to maternal first meiotic nondisjunction in our case. It has been suspected that female carriers of the fra (X) chromosome may be predisposed to meiotic nondisjunctional events. However, there is probably no relationship between the two chromosomal abnormalities in our case because of the maternal age at the delivery.     

Fragile X expression and X inactivation

Summary The major concept of fragile X pathogenesis postulates that the fragile site at band Xq27.3 [fra(X)] represents the primary defect. The expression of fra(X) is predicted to be an intrinsic property of the mutated chromosome and, hence, should not be suppressed by X inactivation in females or induced by X-linked trans-acting factors. We made fibroblast clones of a fra(X)-positive female. Monoclonality was demonstrated using the DNA methylation assay at DXS255. The mutated X chromosomes and their states of genetic activity in the different clones were also defined by molecular methods. Five clones were selected to induce expression of fra(X) by 10^-7 M FUdR; two carried an active mutated X chromosome, in the other three the mutated X chromosome was inactivated. Fra(X) was found expressed in both types of clones. The percentages of positive cells were as high as 7–10%, regardless of the genetic activity of the mutated X chromosomes. DNA replicating patterns, obtained by BUdR labelling, demonstrated that expression occurred only on the mutated X chromosomes previously identified by molecular methods. The concept that the fragile site represents the primary mutation is now strongly supported by experimental evidence. The expression of fra (X) in females is independent of X inactivation and other trans-acting factors.     

Further evidence for genetic heterogeneity in the fragile X syndrome

Summary The X-linked fragile X[fra(X)] syndrome, associated with a fragile site at Xq27.3, is the most common Mendeban inherited form of mental deficiency. Approximately 1 in 1060 males and 1 in 677 females carry the fra (X) chromosome. However, diagnosis of carrier status can be difficult since about 20% of males and 44% of females are nonpenetrant for mental impairment and/or expression of fra (X). We analyzed DNA from 327 individuals in 23 families segregating fra (X) for linkage to three flanking polymorphic probes: 52A, F9, and ST14. This allowed probable nonpenetrant, transmitting males and carrier females to be identified. A combined linkage analysis was conducted using these families and published probe information on F9 in 27 other families, 52A in six families, and ST14 in five families. The two-point recombination fraction for 52A-F9 was 0.13 (90% confidence interval, 0.10–0.16), for F9-fra(X) was 0.21 (0.17–0.24), and for fra(X)-ST14 was 0.12 (0.07–0.17). Tight linkage between F9 and fra(X) was observed in some families; in others loose linkage was seen suggesting genetic linkage heterogeneity. Risk analysis of carrier status using flanking DNA probes showed that probable nonpenetrant transmitting males were included in families showing both tight and loose linkage. Thus, in contrast to our previous conclusions, it appears that the presence or absence of nonpenetrant, transmitting males in a family is not an indicator of heterogeneity. To determine if heterogeneity was present, we employed the admixture test. Evidence for linkage heterogeneity between F9 and fra(X) was found, significant at P<0.0005. Nonsignificant heterogeneity was seen for 52A-F9 linkage. No heterogeneity was found for fra(X)-ST14. The frequency of fra(X) expression was significantly lower in families with tight F9-fra(X) linkage than in families with loose linkage. Cognition appeared to relate to linkage type: affected males in tight linkage families had higher IQs than those in loose linkage families. These findings of genetic heterogeneity can account in part for the high prevalence and apparent high new mutation rate of fra(X). They will affect genetic counseling using RFLPs. An understanding of the basis for genetic heterogeneity in fra(X) will help to clarify the nature of the unusual pattern of inheritance seen in this syndrome.     

Chromosomal characteristics of X-linked recessive mental retardation. I. The X chromosome

The X-chromosome was studied in blood lymphocytes of 68 males with aspecific mental retardation (MR), their 57 relatives and 15 intellectually normal males. The incidence of a fragile X-chromosome (fra(X)) was found to be 4.7% in an unselected group of 42 patients, 50% among 10 probands in which pedigree data were suggestive of X-linked MR diagnosis, and 75% in the group of 15 patients selected for phenotype characteristic of the fragile X syndrome. The fra(X) was present in 1-43% of metaphases in different individuals, no such marker being observed in cells of 15 normal individuals. No significant difference was found when the incidence of the fra(X) was compared in cells cultured in the medium 199 with low folic acid content and the Eagle's medium supplemented with 5-fluorodeoxyuridine (10.62 +/- 2.94 SEM and 13.53 +/- 2.85 SEM, respectively). The possibility of false-positive diagnosis of the fragile X syndrome was quantitatively appreciated. A half of the patients showing a fra(C) in conventionally stained chromosomes were found to have fragile 6 autosome as the only marker in these cells, and in patients with the evident fragile (X) syndrome the fra(6) constituted about one-third of the fra(X) frequency. Both culture media employed were similar in the fra(6) induction.     

Selective advantage of fra (X) heterozygotes

Summary The high incidence of the fra (X) syndrome (about 12000 male newborns) requires an explanation in view of the low fitness of mentally retarded hemizygous males and heterozygous females. In the past, it has been proposed that the mutation rate may be unusually high, and that mutations occur exclusively in male germ cells. According to an alternative hypothesis, a moderately high mutation rate might combine with a selective advantage of clinically unaffected heterozygotes. In earlier studies, such a combined hypothesis was shown to lead to plausible implications regarding mutation rate and fitness. Moreover, a mutation rate in male germ cells of the magnitude required by the exclusive mutation hypothesis was excluded by studies on comprehensive pedigree data. In this third study in the series, an increased fitness of heterozygous females is demonstrated directly by a comparison of the reproductive performance of heterozygotes with that of adequate controls (mothers and grandparents of Down's syndrome patients). Since average numbers of children have decreased during recent decades in populations of industrialized countries, heterozygotes (mothers of affected probands and their female relatives in their own generation) were subdivided into those born before and after 1940. Moreover, sibship sizes of probands' mothers and fathers were analyzed separately for family branches in which the fra (X) trait segregated (mostly the maternal branch), or did not segregate (in most instances the paternal branch). In all four categories reproductive performance in heterozygotes was found to be higher than in the controls. This difference was significant statistically for two of the four groups: it was small and nonsignificant only for the parental family branch in which the fra (X) mutant did not segregate and for mothers born after 1940. Fitness estimates ranged between 1.11 and 1.36. A higher incidence of dizygotic twinning suggests a biological component for this increased fertility. On the other hand, fra (X) families have a significantly lower social status than the controls. This suggests a socio-psychological component of their higher fertility. Apparently, both components contribute to their fertility: at present, their relative importance cannot be assessed.     

Folate-sensitive fragile sites on the X-chromosome heterochromatin of the Indian mole rat, Nesokia indica

Folate-sensitive fragile sites have been demonstrated on the X chromosome of the Indian mole rat, Nesokia indica (subfamily Murinae), utilizing peripheral blood lymphocyte cultures. All normal female individuals expressed fragile sites on the constitutive heterochromatic long arm of one of their two X chromosomes (heterozygous expression); in contrast, no fragile sites were found on the single X chromosome of normal males. Preferential transmission of the maternal fragile X to the daughters is therefore suggested. Four sites have been detected so far: fra Xq1, fra Xq2, fra Xq3, and fra Xc (centromeric). It is significant that their location corresponds to the regions where constitutive heterochromatic deletions occur that result in a variety of polymorphic X chromosomes in natural populations of Nesokia. Thus there is a correlation between fragile sites, deletion sites, and karyotypic changes. In individuals that did not reproduce in the laboratory, there were more fragile sites on both X chromosomes of the females (homozygous/double heterozygous expression) and also on the X of the males (hemizygous expression). This difference in fragile site expression from the normal situation could be attributed to one or more new mutations. However, the mechanism by which fragile sites influence reproductive performance is unclear.     

Fragile (X) X-linked mental retardation. II. Frequency and replication pattern of fragile (X)(q28) in heterozygotes

The frequency of cytologic expression and the replication pattern of the fragile (X) [fra(X)] were investigated in 28 fra(X) heterozygotes, of which 25 agreed to psychological assessment. One-third of the heterozygotes in this study are mentally retarded. The intellectually impaired carriers had a higher frequency of fra(X) and a higher proportion of early-replicating fra(X) than the normally intelligent carriers. The early-replicating fra(X) accounted for 39% of the variability in IQ and the late-replicating fra(X) for 12%. Age had a minimal inverse effect on fra(X) expression and replication pattern. Thus, it appears that mental retardation in females heterozygous for the fra(X) may largely be a function of the proportion of cells with an early-replicating, active X chromosome possessing the fragile site.     

Coincidence of familial systemic lupus erythematosus and the fragile X syndrome

The coincidence of fragile X syndrome (fra(X] and systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) in the same family is reported here for the first time. A 16-year-old boy with typical fra(X) had a severe SLE with multiple organ involvement. His 12-year-old sister of normal intelligence had circulating antinuclear antibodies and proliferative glomerulonephritis. The fra(X) was not found in her karyotype. Except for abnormalities due to immunosuppressive treatment during pregnancy, the association of SLE and chromosome abnormalities has been only reported in Klinefelter's syndrome. The possible pathogenic role of sex hormonal abnormalities due to an extra X chromosome has been suggested in the occurrence of SLE.     

The effect of caffeine on fragile X expression

Summary Caffeine has been reported to enhance the expression of the fragile X [fra(X)] and common fragile sites in peripheral blood lymphocyte cultures (PBLC) treated with 5-fluorodeoxyuridine (FUdR). One of the effects of caffeine on replicating cells is inhibition of DNA repair suggesting that fragile sites may be regions of DNA with a high rate of misreplication under the conditions of thymidylate stress induced by FUdR. We have studied the effect of caffeine on the expression of the fra(X) and common folate-dependent fragile sites in PBLC from two fra(X) expressing individuals and in five lymphoblastoid cell lines (LCL) established from individuals in families in which the fra(X) is segregating. Caffeine did not enhance the expression of the fra(X) in the PBLC or in the three LCL from fra(X) expressing individuals nor did it elicit fra(X) expression in LCL from a non-expressing obligate-carrier female and a transmitting male. However, in all cultures there was a marked increase of common fragile site expression due to caffeine treatment. These data suggest that the mechanism of expression of the common fragile sites and the fra(X) may be quite different.     

Auditory brain-stem responses in the fragile X syndrome.

Auditory brain-stem responses (ABRs) were recorded from a group of 12 mentally retarded males with the fragile X (fra[X]). The responses were analyzed in terms of ABR thresholds, absolute latencies, and interpeak latencies. One patient had increased ABR thresholds, indicating hearing impairment. Five fra(X) subjects had prolonged I-V interpeak latencies. Comparisons between the fra(X) group (excluding one possible hard-of-hearing subject) and a control group of age-matched males with normal intelligence showed that the fra(X) group's interpeak latencies were significantly prolonged for the III-V and I-V but not for the I-III. This pattern of prolongation of interpeak latencies suggests that central, as opposed to peripheral, nervous-system dysfunction predominates in many patients having this syndrome. In addition, frequently observed prolongation of the transmission time may indicate that brain-stem white-matter functioning is also apt to be involved in this syndrome.     

Low frequencies of apparently fragile X chromosomes in normal control cultures: a possible explanation

Low frequencies of apparently fragile X [fra(X)] chromosomes have been reported in normal control, short-term, whole blood cultures, and they have been noted in both amniocyte and fetal blood cultures. However, there is currently no universal agreement on the lowest frequency for fra(X)(q27) that is diagnostic for the fragile X syndrome. Here, we present our observations on low levels of apparently fra(X) chromosomes in normal samples. We observed frequencies of 0.5% in short-term whole blood cultures and 0.9% in amniotic fluid cell cultures. In 1982, Steinbach et al. described nonspecific telomeric structural changes (TSC) and suggested that such low frequencies of apparently fra(X) chromosomes in normal material may be occurring by the same mechanism that is responsible for TSC formation. To determine if TSC formation can explain the significant baseline frequencies of fra(X) in normal controls, 10,457 cells were screened from 178 individuals referred for fra(X) analysis. Our findings indicated that TSC are not randomly distributed across chromosomes but tend to occur at specific sites. Based on our observations, we offer the hypothesis that the low frequency of apparent fra(X) in normal individuals may be due to nonrandom TSC distribution.     

Multilocus analysis of the fragile X syndrome

Summary A multilocus analysis of the fragile X (fra(X)) syndrome was conducted with 147 families. Two proximal loci, DXS51 and F9, and two distal loci, DXS52 and DXS15, were studied. Overall, the best multipoint distances were found to be DXS51-F9, 6.9%, F9-fra(X), 22.4%; fra(X)-DXS52, 12.7%; DXS52-DXS15, 2.2%. These distances can be used for multipoint mapping of new probes, carrier testing and counseling of fra(X) families. Consistent with several previous studies, the families as a whole showed genetic heterogeneity for linkage between F9 and fra(X).     

Variability in the expression of the fragile site of the (fra)X chromosome in 2 consecutive cell cycles

The number and morphology of X chromosomes were analysed in tetraploid cells induced with colcemid in cultured blood lymphocytes obtained from a patient with fra(X) syndrome of mental retardation. In contrast to diploid cells containing fra(X) chromosome in 22.7% of cells, the marker X was found in 51.6% of tetraploids, each cell containing only one fragile X out of the two expected ones. The data obtained indicate an extreme lability of the expression of fragile site (X) (q 27) in consecutive lymphocyte generation.     

Frequency of the fragile X syndrome in Japanese mentally retarded males

Summary Among 243 institutionalized mentally retarded males in Japan, 13 patients (5.3%) with the fre(X)(q27) from nine families were detected. These 13 patients accounted for 8.6% of 152 male inmates with unknown causes of mental retardation in the population. One out of nine pedigrees had an apparently unaffected male transmitter of this disorder. Our data agree with the frequencies of the fra(X) syndrome in various retarded populations, most of which were Caucasians, suggesting that the prevalence of the fra(X) syndrome in Japanese is not significantly different from those in Causasians.     

A cytogenetic study of mentally retarded school children in taiwan with special reference to the fragile X chromosome

Summary A cytogenetic study was made on 341 mentally retarded children in the Provincial Nantou Rehabilitation Center for the Mentally Retarded and the St. Raphael Opportunity Center in Tainan. Of the 89 mentally retarded children with chromosomal abnormalities, 63 had Down syndrome, 13 had the fragile X [fra(X)] syndrome, and the remaining had other aneuploid constitutions. Family studies were possible for 2 of the 13 fra(X) probands. The results of this study illustrate the contribution of chromosomal abnormalities to the pathogenesis of mental retardation in children.     

Fragile×expression and×inactivation

Summary The inactive fragile×chromosomes of a 47,fra(X),fra(X),Y male with a typical fragile×phenotype were successfully separated from the active homologues by means of somatic cell hybridization. It was shown by FUdR-induction and caffein-posttreatment that the separated inactive×chromosomes expressed their fragile sites and that the presence of an active mutated \sxchromosome was not a prerequisite for fragile X expression. The fragility seems to be an intrinsic property of the individual fragile site. This result is in favour of the classical concept that the fragile site at Xq27.3 has a primary pathogenetic function in this syndrome, although the fragility itself could represent a secondary phenomenon related to an unknown alteration of the DNA in this chromosome region. It is also concluded that inactivation of the fragile\sxchromosome in females is not responsible for either false negative fragile\sxfindings or the observation of fragile\sxnegative colonies isolated from fragile\sxpositive fibroblasts in heterozygotes.     

Further segregation analysis of the fragile X syndrome with special reference to transmitting males

Summary A new series of 96 pedigrees with the fra(X) syndrome was analysed using complex segregation analysis with pointers, defining affection as any degree of mental impairment. These families were found to exhibit the same segregation pattern as the first series of 110 pedigrees (Sherman et al. 1984). The best estimate for penetrance of mental impairment in males was 79% and in females was 35% for the combined data. Again, there was little evidence for sporadic cases among affected males.Many more intellectually normal transmitting males have been observed since the existence of such males and the concomitant need to investigate the paternal side of pedigrees was recognized. On further investigation of all 206 pedigrees from the old and new data sets, the sibships of nonexpressing males appeared to be different from those of expressing males. Our analysis, using mental impairment as the phenotype, suggested that obligate carrier mothers and daughters of intellectually normal transmitting males are rarely, if ever, mentally impaired and that the sibs of transmitting males are much less likely to be retarded than the sibs of mentally impaired males. Though mothers and daughters of transmitting males are similar in phenotype, the expression of the gene in their offspring appears to be different: the penetrance of mental impairment is higher in offspring of intellectually normal daughters of transmitting males than in offspring of intellectually normal mothers of transmitting males. The implications of these observations for genetic counseling and for genetic models of the fra(X) syndrome are discussed.