Regulation of murine T cell proliferation by B cell stimulatory factor-1

The proliferation of mitogen-activated primary T cells, antigen-activated memory T cells from mixed leukocyte culture, and antigen-dependent alloreactive T cell clones in response to purified murine recombinant B cell stimulatory factor-1 (also known as interleukin 4) was examined. We found that B cell stimulatory factor-1 (BSF-1) stimulated optimal proliferation of these T cells only after their recent activation by antigen or mitogen. Analysis of cell surface BSF-1 receptor expression indicated that although T cell activation is accompanied by a small increase in BSF-1 receptor expression, the cells also express BSF-1 receptors prior to activation at a time when they do not proliferate in response to BSF-1. BSF-1 was as effective a stimulus as interleukin 2 for inducing proliferation of the Lyt-2+ subpopulation of concanavalin A-activated murine spleen cells and an alloreactive cytolytic T cell clone. However, the L3T4+ subpopulation of concanavalin A-activated spleen and an alloreactive helper T cell clone were less responsive to BSF-1 than to interleukin 2. Taken together, the data indicate an important role for BSF-1 in the regulation of normal T cell proliferation.     

Requirement for BSF-1 in the induction of antigen-specific B cell proliferation by a thymus-dependent antigen and carrier-reactive T cell line

We report here a role of B cell stimulatory factor 1 (BSF-1) in the induction of antigen-specific proliferation of affinity-purified small B lymphocytes by a thymus-dependent antigen and a carrier-reactive T cell line. By using an ovalbumin-reactive T cell line (designated Hen-1), which does not produce BSF-1 following activation, it was possible to demonstrate that the antigen-specific proliferative response of trinitrophenyl (TNP)-binding B cells to TNP-ovalbumin required exogenous BSF-1 in addition to direct interaction with irradiated Hen-1 T cells. The activation obtained under these conditions was highly efficient, being sensitive to antigen doses as low as 0.001 microgram/ml. The addition of saturating amounts of BSF-1 did not alter the antigen-specificity or the requirements for hapten-carrier linkage or major histocompatibility complex-restricted T-B interaction in this system. The involvement of BSF-1 was confirmed by the ability of 11B11 anti-BSF-1 antibody to specifically suppress the response of TNP-binding B cells to TNP-ovalbumin, BSF-1, and irradiated Hen-1 T cells. Finally, this response was augmented by addition of the monokine interleukin 1. These data indicate that the proliferative response of small B cells to the thymus-dependent antigen and carrier-reactive T cell line used in our experiments can be regulated by the same factors that govern B cell proliferation induced by thymus-independent type 2 antigens or anti-IgM antibodies.     

The role of the transferrin receptor in human B lymphocyte activation

Transferrin receptors are expressed on proliferating cells and are required for their growth. Transferrin receptors can be detected after, but not before, mitogenic stimulation of normal peripheral blood T and B cells. T cells demonstrate a functional requirement for transferrin receptors in the activation process. These receptors, in turn, are induced to appear by T cell growth factor (interleukin 2). In the experiments reported here, we examined the regulation of transferrin receptor expression on activated human B cells and whether these receptors are necessary for activation to occur. Activation was assessed by studying both proliferation and immunoglobulin secretion. We determined that transferrin receptor expression on B cells is regulated by a factor contained in supernatants of mitogen-stimulated T cells (probably B cell growth factor). This expression is required for proliferation to occur, because antibody to transferrin receptor (42/6) blocks B cell proliferation. Induction of immunoglobulin secretion, however, although dependent on phytohemagglutinin-treated T cell supernatant, is not dependent on transferrin receptor expression and can occur in mitogen-stimulated cells whose proliferation has been blocked by anti-transferrin receptor antibody. These findings support a model for B cell activation in which mitogen (or antigen) delivers two concurrent but distinct signals to B cells: one, dependent on B cell growth factor and transferrin receptor expression, for proliferation; and a second, dependent on T cell-derived factors and not requiring transferrin receptors, which leads to immunoglobulin secretion.     

Studies of in vitro activation and differentiation of human B lymphocytes. I. Phenotypic and functional characterization of the B cell population responding to anti-Ig antibody

Investigation of the activation of splenic B cells by anti-immunoglobulin (Ig) antibody has enabled us to characterize the anti-Ig-responsive B cell and to analyze the phenotypic changes which accompany proliferation and differentiation. The anti-Ig antibody-responsive B cell population was characterized by the expression of high levels of the B2 antigen and represented approximately 40% of splenic B cells. Brisk mitogenesis which peaked at 3 to 4 days was induced by anti-Ig antibody. The proliferative phase was characterized phenotypically by a dramatic decline in B2 antigen expression, with most cells showing no detectable B2 by 4 days post-activation. The other hallmark of this phase was de novo expression of a group of "activation antigens." These included the B cell-restricted antigens B-LAST 1, BB1, and B5, and the T cell-associated interleukin 2 receptor and T12 antigens. Concomitantly, B1, B4, and Ia expression increased, the increase being roughly proportional to the increase in cell size. After day 4, the mitogenic response progressively diminished, while Ig synthesis increased. During this differentiation phase, cell surface antigens again displayed a distinct sequence of changes. The five activation antigens and the B1, B4, and Ia antigens began to decrease. However, two markers, T10 and PCA-1, which are found on plasmacytomas, appeared and their level of expression steadily increased. These changes and the appearance of morphologically identifiable plasma cells required the presence of T cells in this system. T cell supernatants alone induced Ig secretion but did not induce expression of PCA-1 or the appearance of cells with plasma cell morphology. The culture system developed in this study has allowed us to analyze the antigenic changes following activation by anti-Ig antibody. This sequence of changes has not only permitted the identification of antigens which, by their appearance at distinct stages may have an important role in proliferation and differentiation of B cells, but also provides us with the means of studying the function of each antigen.     

Comparison of the expression of IL 2 receptors by human T and B cells: induction by the polyclonal mitogens, phorbol myristate acetate, and anti-mu antibody

It is well established that IL 2 plays an important role in the proliferative response of T cells. Activated B cells were also recently found to express IL 2 receptors. The present studies were designed to compare qualitative, quantitative, and functional aspects of IL 2 receptor expression by activated T and B cells. Phorbol myristate acetate (PMA)-activated human T and small resting B cells and enhanced the expression of HLA-DR, HLA-DC/DS, and transferrin receptors while reducing Leu-4 antigen expression by T cells and IgM and IgD expression on B cells. PMA induced both T and B cells to express functional IL 2 receptors before cellular proliferation. Immune interferon did not participate in this induction. The m.w. of the IL 2 receptors expressed by activated T and B cells was identical: 54,000 to 59,000. Several differences were noted in the expression of IL 2 receptors by activated T and B cells on stimulation with PMA; T cells expressed IL 2 receptors sooner than B cells and in higher density, and the enhanced proliferative response of T cells to IL 2 was more difficult to inhibit with antibody to IL 2 receptors. In addition, IL 2 enhanced the expression of transferrin receptors by activated T cells but did not have a similar effect on activated B cells. Small B cells from the blood could also be induced by a mitogenic monoclonal anti-IgM antibody to express functional IL 2 receptors. Relatively large B cells in fresh blood samples were found to express functional IL 2 receptors and were capable of a modest proliferative response to IL 2. The intensity of the IL 2 receptor expression and the proliferative response by large B cells were enhanced by PMA stimulation. The data suggest that IL 2 receptors may play an auxiliary role in the B cell proliferative response and that IL 2 may exert its effect at a late phase in the B cell activation process.     

Direct activation of human B lymphocytes by Candida albicans-derived mannan antigen

We have studied the activation of human resting B cells by a carbohydrate antigen, mannan, with a polymannose branched repetitive structure. Mannan has been extracted from the cell wall of the Candida albicans yeast. For this purpose, dense G0 B lymphocytes were purified from tonsils. Mannan antigen was shown to trigger B cell activation, since an increase of cell volume and RNA synthesis occurred. B cell proliferation was observed following addition of recombinant interleukin 2, but not following addition of recombinant interleukin 4 or low-molecular-weight BCGF. The B cell activation appears to be mannan-specific since B cells obtained from mannan-sensitized subjects but not from unsensitized subjects were responsive. The observation that mannan antigen can directly activate specific dense B lymphocytes can be related to the previous observation that the in vitro anti-mannan antibody production does not require a cognate T-B cell interaction.     

Induction of IgG secretion in a human B cell clone with recombinant IL 2

A human B cell clone (SGB3) responsive to IL 2 was established. Both recombinant IL 2 and B cell differentiation factor (BCDF) induced IgG secretion in SGB3 cells in a dose-dependent manner, but IL 2 did not affect the proliferation of SGB3 cells. FACS analysis showed that SGB3 cells expressed Tac antigen and anti-Tac antibody inhibited IL 2-induced IgG secretion without any inhibitory effect on BCDF-induced IgG secretion. These results showed that IL 2 could directly act on B cells and provide a differentiation signal through IL 2 receptors distinct from BCDF receptors. Physiologic relevance of IL 2 in the antibody response was discussed.     

Accessory cell function in the Con A response: role of Ia-positive and Ia-negative accessory cells

We have examined the role of Ia-positive and Ia-negative accessory cells (AC) and soluble factors in Con A-stimulated murine T cell activation. Supernatant fluids containing interleukin 1 (IL 1) derived from the P388D1 macrophage cell line and from a lipopolysaccharide (LPS)-stimulated macrophage hybridoma provided only partial reconstitution of the response of purified T cells (18 to 27%). The complete reconstitution obtained with gamma-irradiated spleen cells or LPS-activated B cells was inhibited by approximately 60 to 77% when anti-Ia antibody was included in the culture. Despite this apparent involvement of Ia+ spleen AC, Ia-negative L cell AC could also reconstitute the response of both Class I-restricted Lyt-2+ T cells and Class II-restricted L3T4+ T cells. When the Ia-negative AC were employed, the L3T4 antigen on L3T4+ T cells played a critical role because addition of anti-L3T4 antibody to the culture inhibited the response by 85 to 90%. In contrast, anti-L3T4 did not inhibit the response in the presence of spleen AC. These results suggest that the molecules involved in T cell-AC interactions may vary depending on the AC source. Moreover, at least one of the putative target ligands for L3T4 presumably is not Ia, because anti-L3T4 inhibited T cell stimulation when Ia-negative AC were used.     

Monoclonal antibodies to the human C3b/C4b receptor (CR1) enhance specific B cell differentiation

The addition of monoclonal antibodies against the human C3b/C4b receptor (CR1) to cultures of peripheral blood lymphocytes in the presence of suboptimal amounts of TNP bound to polyacrylamide beads enhanced by 150 to 400% the specific anti-TNP response, as measured by a plaque-forming cell assay on day 7. Anti-CR1 antibodies similarly enhanced the anti-fluorescein antibody response. Enhancement only occurred in cultures performed in the presence of the relevant antigen. No enhancing effect on the anti-TNP response was observed on addition to cultures of monoclonal antibodies directed against other surface antigens of B cells or an anti-T cell antibody of the same subclass as that of anti-CR1 antibodies. Anti-CR1 antibodies alone did not induce nonspecific B cell proliferation and did not provide B cells with a first signal for proliferation in the presence of a source of B cell growth factors. Anti-CR1 antibodies did not enhance the nonspecific proliferative response of B cells to growth factors derived from PHA-stimulated T cells, semi-purified BCGF 20 KD, BCGF 50 KD, or recombinant IL 2 in the presence of anti-mu. In this respect, the effect of anti-CR1 antibodies differs from that of anti-CR2 antibodies which interact with early stages of B cell activation. In contrast, anti-CR1 antibodies enhanced specific differentiation of antigen-activated B cells in the absence of T cells when soluble T cell factors were provided. Similar results were obtained by using either of two sources of differentiation factors, the MLA-144 supernatant or a 30 to 15 KD fraction from PHA-stimulated T cells. These results indicate that triggering of CR1 on B cells positively regulates the specific antibody response to low doses of antigen by enhancing B cell differentiation whether T cell help is provided by intact T cells or by T cell-derived differentiation factors.     

Two independent pathways of helper activity provided by a single T cell clone

Data presented in this paper demonstrate the existence of two separate pathways by which a single T cell clone can induce B cell differentiation. With the use of high doses of antigen, a T cell clone can induce a primary antibody response in unprimed B cells. With the use of low doses of antigen, the same T cell clone can induce an immunoglobulin (Ig)G response in primed B cells. The primary response is accompanied by T cell proliferation and lymphokine production (interleukin 2, B cell growth factor, B cell differentiation factor for immunoglobulin M, and B cell differentiation factor for immunoglobulin G). The secondary response does not require proliferation and occurs independently of detectable lymphokine production. Variants of the wild type T cell helper clone have been isolated. One variant can provide help to unprimed B cells when high doses of antigen are used. This variant cannot provide help to primed B cells when low doses of antigen are used, nor can it provide help to CBA/N "xid" B cells at any antigen concentration tested. Additional variants have been isolated that proliferate on antigen-pulsed-presenting cells, but fail to secrete detectable lymphokines and do not induce B cell differentiation. These results suggest that a single T cell helper clone has multiple functional activities that can be independently expressed.     

Interleukin 4 enhances the ability of antigen-specific B cells to form conjugates with T cells

T cell-B cell conjugates are formed when trinitrophenyl-specific B cells are exposed to trinitrophenyl-ovalbumin and ovalbumin-specific T hybridoma cells. The proportion of conjugates was increased two- to threefold when antigen-pulsed trinitrophenyl-specific B cells, but not T cells, were pre-exposed to interleukin 4. Antigen-specific B cells pretreated with antigen and interleukin 4 and cultured in the presence of specific T helper cells also produced a larger proportion of antibody-secreting cells as compared to cells pretreated with antigen alone. The interleukin 4-induced enhancement of T/B conjugate formation occurred over a wide range of antigen concentrations, was dependent on the concentration of interleukin 4, and was inhibited by the monoclonal anti-interleukin 4 antibody, 11B11. The importance of Ia antigens in the enhancement of conjugate formation and generation of antibody-secreting cells is suggested by a) the fact that the interleukin 4-mediated increase in the density of Ia antigens on the antigen-specific B cells correlated with their enhanced ability to form T/B conjugates, b) the kinetics of the interleukin 4-mediated increase in conjugate formation and surface Ia expression were similar, c) 10- to 20-fold higher concentrations of anti-I-A antibody were required to inhibit T/B conjugate formation by 50% with interleukin 4-treated antigen-specific B cells compared with untreated antigen-specific B cells, and d) interferon-gamma, which inhibits the interleukin 4-mediated increase in Ia antigens, inhibited the interleukin 4-induced enhancement of T/B conjugate formation. These results indicate that the interleukin 4-induced increase in the expression of Ia antigens on B cells plays an important role in the enhancement of T/B cell interactions and the subsequent differentiation of antigen-specific B cells into antibody-secreting cells.     

Different responses of CR(−) and CR(+) B cells to LPS stimulation

Proliferative response of B cells with or without CR [CR(+) or CR(?) B cells] was compared in their polyclonal response when they were stimulated with lipopolysaccharide (LPS). CR(+) B cells responded better in proliferation and more poorly in polyclonal antibody formation than did CR(?) B cells. The dissociation between proliferation and antibody formation in LPS response was not due to the shift of the time kinetics nor the exhaustion of the culture medium. T cells and macrophages did not take part in the dissociation, since macrophage depletion from nu/nu mouse spleen cells could not modify the dissociation. The polyclonal antibody response of CR(?) B cells was more resistant to irradiation than that of CR(+) B cells. These results suggest that among LPS-responsive B cells there are CR(?) B-cell subset(s) more mature than CR(+) B cells.     

The immunoregulatory role of bone marrow. I. Suppression of the induction of antibody responses to T-dependent and T-independent antigens by cells in the bone marrow.

Bone marrow cells (BMC) from normal mice suppressed the in vitro IgM, but not the IgG, antibody (Ab) response of spleen cells. BMC were inhibitory only when added during the first 24 hr of culture, and inhibition was not due to an induced shift in the kinetics of the response. Addition of specifically activated T cells or nonspecific T-cell-replacing factors to normal or T-depleted spleen cell cultures did not abrogate suppression while the response to the T-independent antigen DNP-polymerized flagellin or lipopolysaccharide was also suppressed. BMC did not inhibit background Ab synthesis by normal or primed cells in the absence of antigen and did not inhibit, but stimulated, DNA synthesis in normal spleen cell cultures. In addition, high-avidity Ab synthesis was preferentially suppressed. A possible role for the bone marrow suppressor cell in the induction of B cell tolerance is discussed.     

Modulation of human rheumatoid factor-specific lymphocyte responses with a cross-reactive anti-idiotype bearing the internal image of antigen

Rabbit anti-idiotypic antibodies to human rheumatoid factor (RF) autoantibodies were isolated by affinity chromatography on rabbit anti-human IgG Fc Sepharose 4B. The anti-idiotypic antibodies bore the "internal image" of the antigen, human IgG. They reacted specifically with multiple human monoclonal and polyclonal IgM-RF, independent of any particular light or heavy chain amino acid sequence. The anti-idiotypes did not react with IgM or IgG proteins lacking RF activity. The present experiments determined the potential of the "internal image" antibodies to modulate in vitro lymphocyte functions. The addition of anti-idiotypic antibody to peripheral blood mononuclear cell cultures from patients with rheumatoid arthritis elicited lymphocyte proliferation, but not RF synthesis. The antibody did not induce the proliferation of lymphocytes from a normal individual. Moreover, the anti-idiotype specifically suppressed IgM-RF secretory responses when preincubated with B cells before co-culture with autologous pokeweed mitogen-activated T cells. The data show that the anti-idiotypic antibodies with the "internal image" of antigen are capable of interacting with B cell receptors in an antigen-restricted manner, and possess specific immunomodulatory properties.     

Activation of antigen-enriched B cells. II. Role of linked recognition in B cell proliferation to thymus-dependent antigens

The responsiveness to T-dependent (TD) and T-independent (TI) TNP-antigens of murine splenic B cells previously enriched for antigen-binding cells (ABC) was examined. TNP-TI antigens induced B cell proliferation. TNP-TD antigens did not induce a proliferative response regardless of the physical form or nature of the TNP-TD antigen (e.g., soluble vs particulate, low or high haptenation of carrier, TNP on various insoluble matrices, etc.). TNP-TD antigens were effective in enhancing the response of the TNP-ABC to all concentrations of lipopolysaccharide (LPS) tested, indicating that binding of antigen to surface immunoglobulin alters the LPS responsiveness of the cell. Irradiated, keyhole limpet hemocyanin- (KLH) primed T cells induced a threefold to fourfold greater B cell proliferative response with TNP-KLH than with fluoresceinated KLH (FLU-KLH) or FLU-KLH together with TNP-human serum albumin (TNP-HSA). Therefore, linked recognition appears essential for optimal T cell-mediated B cell proliferation, whereas the induction of B cell proliferation via nonlinked, carrier-activated T cells is a minor component of the response.     

Immunosuppression of normal lymphoid cells by serum from mice undergoing chronic graft-vs-host disease.

Spleen cells from F1 mice undergoing chronic graft-vs-host (GVH) reaction, induced by injection of parental cells, were shown to be immunosuppressed since their in vitro responses to the mitogens concanavalin A (Con A) and bacterial lipopolysaccharide (LPS) were substantially lower than control animals. Serum, from mice undergoing GVH, when cultured in vitro with normal spleen cells was immunosuppressive. The proliferation response to Con A and allogeneic cells of normal syngeneic, allogeneic, and parental spleen cells was 90% suppressed when serum from mice undergoing chronic GVH was added in comparison to the addition of serum from untreated F1 mice. Similarly, the in vitro antibody response to a T-dependent antigen was impaired; however, the antibody response to a T-independent antigen was not impaired. These results indicate that T cell functions are more sensitive than are B cell functions to immunosuppressive factors in the serum of mice undergoing GVH.     

Disparate functional properties of two interleukin 1-responsive Ly-1+2- T cell clones: distinction of T cell growth factor and T cell-replacing factor activities

We describe the properties of two Ly-1+2- T cell clones (Ly-1.14 and Ly-1.21), which are maintained in long-term culture in the absence of other cell types. The clones require media containing a source of interleukin 1 as well as interleukin 2. They retain physiologic responses to interleukin 1, which is required for optimal production of T cell lymphokines by these clones in response to concanavalin A (Con A). The two Ly-1+2- T cell clones differ in their production of lymphokines after stimulation by Con A. The supernatant of clone Ly-1.21 promotes the proliferation of T cells maintained in long-term culture, induces antibody synthesis in cultures of B cells and antigen, and induces the differentiation of cytolytic cells in cultures of thymocytes and antigen; these assays define the properties of T cell growth factor (TCGF), T cell-replacing factor for B cells (TRF-B), and T cell-replacing factor for cytolytic cells (TRF-C), respectively. In contrast, the supernatant of clone Ly-1.14 contains only TCGF activity and does not promote antibody synthesis by B cells or differentiation of cytolytic cells from thymocytes. The results indicates that TCGF and TRF activities reside on independent, although perhaps related, molecules.     

Dextran-sulfate: a mitogen for human T lymphocytes

Dextran-sulfate (DxS) induced proliferation of human peripheral blood T lymphocytes but not of adult or neonatal B lymphocytes. The mitogenic activity on T cells by DxS required the presence of accessory cells because DxS was unable to trigger T cells to DNA synthesis in the absence of accessory cells. In addition, DxS stimulated OKT4+8- T cells to produce interleukin 2, a process that also occurred only in the presence of accessory cells. Cyclosporin-A strongly suppressed T cell proliferation induced by DxS by rendering T cells unresponsive to interleukin 2 and by inhibiting the synthesis of this T cell growth factor by OKT4+ T cells. These results indicate that DxS is a mitogen for human T lymphocytes but not for adult or neonatal B lymphocytes. The mechanism by which DxS triggers T cells is discussed.     

Mechanisms of idiotype suppression. V. Anti-idiotype antibody inhibits early B cell triggering induced by antigen

To investigate the relationship between antigen-mediated B cell commitment and induction of idiotype (id) suppression, anti-id antibody directed against the major id (TEPC-15 idiotype or T15id) of the anti-phosphorylcholine (PC) antibody was added at various time intervals to BALB/c spleen cell cultures stimulated with a T-independent PC antigen, R36a. The suppressive effect of anti-T15id antibody on the anti-PC response was rapidly decreased as addition of the antibody was delayed; when anti-T15id antibody was added 6 hr after the initiation of the cultures, only partial suppression was induced, whereas the addition of anti-id antibody after 24 hr did not result in significant suppression of the anti-PC response when compared with similar cultures treated with mock anti-id antibody. This acquisition of resistance to id suppression was completely inhibited by treatment with either sodium azide or colchicine, as well as at temperatures below 20 degrees C. The induction of resistance to id suppression during the preincubation period was dependent on the presence of an immunogenic level of specific antigen. This antigen-mediated B cell commitment did not appear to require macrophages because preincubation of macrophages with antigen did not affect the sensitivity of the B cells to anti-id antibody. These results support the possibility that anti-id antibody inhibits early B cell triggering, which involves an energy-dependent, epitope-mediated, lateral mobility of antigen receptors possibly followed by repolymerization of microtubules.     

Human B cell proliferation in response to IL-4 is associated with enhanced production of B cell-derived growth factors

To investigate the capacity of human IL-4 to function as a B cell growth factor (BCGF), we studied its ability to promote proliferation of a selected B cell line. We show that the cell line, designated A4, proliferated in response to IL-4 in a dose-dependent manner. The A4 cells also proliferated in response to their own B cell derived growth factor (B. BCGF), suggesting autocrine-mediated growth. The ability of IL-4 to induce proliferation of the A4 cell line was dependent on the level of autocrine growth. At low cell density, IL-4 induced marked dose-dependent proliferation. However, as A4 cell density increased, the ability of IL-4 to induce proliferation was diminished. The possibility that IL-4 may be mediating the autocrine growth of A4 cells was ruled out, because A4 cell-derived BCGF failed to induce CD23/low affinity receptors for the Fc region of IgE on activated tonsillar B cells and anti-IL-4 antibody did not block B. BCGF activity. We found that IL-4 stimulation of A4 cells and activated tonsillar B cells is associated with enhanced production of B. BCGF. These data indicate that human IL-4 has the capacity to promote proliferation of the B cell line A4, and that the ability of IL-4 to function as BCGF is associated with enhanced autocrine growth of activated B cells.